{ "Contributors": [ "Pegah Alipoormolabashi" ], "Source": [ "perspectrum" ], "URL": [ "https://github.com/CogComp/perspectrum/" ], "Categories": [ "Textual Entailment" ], "Reasoning": [ "Textual Entailment" ], "Definition": [ "In this task you will be given a claim and a perspective. You should determine whether that perspective supports or undermines the claim. If the perspective could possibly convince someone with different view, it is supporting, otherwise it is undermining." ], "Input_language": [ "English" ], "Output_language": [ "English" ], "Instruction_language": [ "English" ], "Domains": [ "Debatepedia" ], "Positive Examples": [ { "input": "claim: Music containing lyrics that glorify violent and criminal lifestyles should be banned.\n perspective: hip hop artists have a right to free speech", "output": "undermine", "explanation": "Musicians having a right to free speech clearly undermines the claim for putting constraints on their lyrics." }, { "input": "claim: Abolish the US Electoral College.\n perspective: The electoral college weakens incentives for voting and party building.", "output": "support", "explanation": "The perspective is clearly in support of the claim as it is giving an example of problems of the Electoral College." } ], "Negative Examples": [ { "input": "claim: Abolish the monarchy.\n perspective: monarchy in britain led to lots of chaos in the past", "output": "undermine", "explanation": "The given perspective is supporting the claim, so this is not a correct answer." }, { "input": "claim: Gambling must be banned.\n perspective: Casinos support local communities financially.", "output": "weaken", "explanation": "The perspective is weakening the claim, but your answer should only be one of \"support\" or \"undermine\"." } ], "Instances": [ { "id": "task738-c9c33d62d9a44563a6cafd4e6d9ec67b", "input": "claim: Children should not be allowed to inherit vast wealth as this damages them and society.\n perspective: Inherited wealth demotivates the recipients so that they put less effort into training, education and social skills.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-7bde66d008f6449f90b430dac8a78257", "input": "claim: Domestic intelligence agencies have a legitimate role to play in democracy.\n perspective: The government does not have the right to spy on its citizens", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-9c72c59698de42b28e2eb660e71704d9", "input": "claim: Should Turkey Be Accepted In The EU.\n perspective: As a matter of precedent, Turkey should be allowed into the EU.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-64c076c130a84ce7974ba89ee7b042e8", "input": "claim: Arming the police is a good idea.\n perspective: arming police will not help violence", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a13b5d667ada4ad9b3c2c4f3098903e6", "input": "claim: Same sex relationships should have the same legal status as heterosexual relationships under EU law.\n perspective: There are economic advantages for states to approve gay marriages. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-4ef765ba5e2c4d68b037f6b3d4696e75", "input": "claim: Same sex relationships should have the same legal status as heterosexual relationships under EU law.\n perspective: Legalizing gay marriage is a stepping stone toward disgusting and harmful marriage practices such as incestuous, bestial and child marriages. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-dc7eab43a64d4c079729b7609c50fe53", "input": "claim: The use of child performers should be banned.\n perspective: Being a performer can make the child physically vulnerable", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-554a6f1d9fa3484fa004a2dcd610930f", "input": "claim: UK should have a second Brexit referendum before leaving the EU.\n perspective: The referendum is inconsistent with the UK's tradition of representative democracy EU membersh", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-dd5fd91596ed44b38181b13d4ad5b1c3", "input": "claim: Everyone Should Automatically Be Opted into an Organ Donation Scheme.\n perspective: Some just don’t bother to register as a donor, even if they support the cause.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-df72a31689eb42219dccc3174763efc3", "input": "claim: Marriage is an outdated institution.\n perspective: Those who are observant religiously think that marriage is important.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-7cfd93569c6a425782e0d6ab69d51e97", "input": "claim: Basic income tax should be abolished.\n perspective: Income tax is not the best way to redistribute wealth or pay for public goods.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-4c4ceb9d79f24e95914a5c069da81a46", "input": "claim: Junk Food Should Be Banned.\n perspective: The sale of \"junk food\" items provide vital financial assistance to schools.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-610711bb5669485e9cf916439b3bcb01", "input": "claim: All nations have a right to nuclear weapons.\n perspective: No country has an inherent right to invade or use aggression against another.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-80e4c0292b65466da5549342f73bc20d", "input": "claim: Global Warming is not an issue.\n perspective: Because people are losing lives and our climate is changing", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-f19ffef4b3bf436986d3ed3ca6af9269", "input": "claim: We must ban negative advertising in political campaigns.\n perspective: Negative campaigns reduce diversity", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d1cdd6aa9f8d4936b12ccc9eb16f9fb0", "input": "claim: Voting should be compulsory in the UK.\n perspective: People forced to vote are unlikely to vote intelligently.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-bdb32a02e39441acb7642d399f79e3f1", "input": "claim: We should expand NATO.\n perspective: NATO development was important for international stability ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-9fa6c37885064aa8a0aa5242365cd140", "input": "claim: Forced marriage should be banned.\n perspective: The state should not be allowed to intrude in such personal matters", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c65f1555232d49bd9772e501d0068972", "input": "claim: The American Jobs Act should pass.\n perspective: The American Jobs Act Will Help the Long Term Unemployed", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-bf920893ba3b4d0fbd6226951697a40e", "input": "claim: Golf is a Sport.\n perspective: If you can compete in golf with a handicap, then it is not a sport.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-49099fa9b2f84e2fa17fddaca4a9a1e3", "input": "claim: Everyone should go vegetarian.\n perspective: Studies show that vegetarians are up to 40% less likely to develop cancer than meat eaters. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-9973794d3d034a9daaf82b163af3cb07", "input": "claim: Speed limits should be reduced.\n perspective: Government have illegitimate reasons behind lowering the speed limit ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-f7820de660d7440ebe760224c2c8cbd6", "input": "claim: Same sex relationships should have the same legal status as heterosexual relationships under EU law.\n perspective: Legalizing gay marriage will not harm the institution of marriage, and same-sex marriages may even be more stable than heterosexual marriages. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-7345e5224ed749cba292946c8c645b2f", "input": "claim: Positive Discrimination Towards Women in Society Is Justified.\n perspective: It does not address the underlying issues", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c311369b659640fd848640a4ff4cc22f", "input": "claim: All drugs should be decriminalised.\n perspective: Why is it legitimate for the government to ban drugs", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-33873d41b1b0464ca4f999248aa9d363", "input": "claim: Teachers Should Have The Right To Punish Pupils Physically If The Parents Consent.\n perspective: Allowing children to be hit sends the message that it is OK to treat children in this way.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-12625021551e49d9ae5195be8b6124f9", "input": "claim: The world should go vegan.\n perspective: The risk of heart disease is reduced in people who adhere to a vegetarian diet.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-93a5139742fd4d2789e78a90284c2083", "input": "claim: The US should immediately close Guantanamo Bay.\n perspective: Release is not the Solution", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-91202058cd8c47bfb117ef2dc8ac0305", "input": "claim: Prostitution Should Be Legal.\n perspective: Legalization has benefits for society", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c4038473c1ea4d46ac3d468ce0d927bb", "input": "claim: Eliminate All Nuclear Weapons.\n perspective: countries have to right to self defense with nuclear weapons, even when they lack capacity in conventional weapon", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-1fc16332fca24f209ef77c3bf4e62177", "input": "claim: 16 year olds should be able to vote at presidental elections.\n perspective: 16 year olds are informed enough to cast a vote.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-586ab9c6acf94199b747b6eb4cee79ac", "input": "claim: Wind power should be a primary focus of future energy supply.\n perspective: Animal habitats are threatened by the turbines used in wind power.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-9dc7bf57897e4d5b8c6ac05fa26761df", "input": "claim: We have to teach creationism in schools.\n perspective: Freedom of speech should apply to teachers as much as anyone else", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-8b6967f37cee425d9c4aca8a059f691e", "input": "claim: All Americans should have the right (be entitled) to health care.\n perspective: Health care for all might cost more in taxes.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-8458867be1e74f268e092de458d9a6b8", "input": "claim: Raise The School Leaving Age To 18.\n perspective: Society should make it easier for all young people to receive an education.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-3c56b3af2c3d426ebbfc65808c12785e", "input": "claim: It is time to stop buying bottled water.\n perspective: Bottled water is important for travelers to avoid illnesss.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-20eaebedb5654f71aa910ddc7a0803e8", "input": "claim: Religion In Itself Is A Purely Positive Force In The World.\n perspective: Religion's Net Impact On The World Is A Positive One", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-bef8becebe1143c3baa5a0f351768b96", "input": "claim: Performing tests on animals must be banned.\n perspective: Testing is needed for really new drugs", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-d77f2f2a96654f798be20d3350971adf", "input": "claim: Fast Food Advertising Should Be Banned.\n perspective: Marketing aimed at children should be subject to strict regulations.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-affaf75d1262445cba93972723746cb2", "input": "claim: Religious freedom abroad should be one of the primary foreign policy concerns for any country.\n perspective: Religion does not motivate foreign policy", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-320ed56728344d58b3f599f3f0bbd2fd", "input": "claim: The U.S. Should Ban The Use of Cluster Bombs.\n perspective: This House Believes That the U.S. Should Ban The Use of Cluster Bombs", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-cd0b2b13c73349fdb64b517ed86a8bb8", "input": "claim: Fast Food Advertising Should Be Banned.\n perspective: There are alternative methods of distributing the toys.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-138ca2d835994c6693d0011aa4ed0e37", "input": "claim: All nations should ban bullfighting.\n perspective: Bullfighting should be treated like other forms of animal torture", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f186796e9e2942ea8a3a71c520c98fc5", "input": "claim: Deny Organs to Non-Donors.\n perspective: People may have valid religious reasons not to donate organs", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-defbbb3239944dd3a851e36533befbde", "input": "claim: The UN should be reformed or replaced.\n perspective: The UN has performed a valuable service in preventing wars and in peacekeeping. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-2f885841fcfa43d0ba0abff7ee8de695", "input": "claim: Tablets should replace textbooks in K-12 schools.\n perspective: Tablets increase the number of excuses available for students not doing their schoolwork.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c3b3d12e905c4b9aa0dee27e246b0f53", "input": "claim: Gay couples should be allowed to marry.\n perspective: Same-sex marriage may have a lower divorce rate than heterosexual marriage proving once and for all that gay marriage is good for the institution of marriage. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-65070959bd7b4a2c8a3a3fc4e770b222", "input": "claim: Drones Should Be Used to Take Out Enemy Combatants.\n perspective: Drone strikes are often not targeting high value targets.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-8e6a0689088145778de1a021671d1112", "input": "claim: Widen the East African Community.\n perspective: Conflicts and insecurity in the region will be resolved.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-610044dedbea4185b1474d3b920f6271", "input": "claim: Ghana’s ban on smoking in public places is a model for Africa.\n perspective: It isn't necessary to ban smoking.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-512d68c894d14aa9908553bf00c1a5db", "input": "claim: People should have a right to private education.\n perspective: Private schools are financially good for the state", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-bd9cca55cd7443279fe833d39af80615", "input": "claim: permit the use of performance enhancing drugs in professional sports.\n perspective: Sports will become even more dangerous for athletes if they are allowed to take performance enhancing drugs. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-167ee0b08f2e4425bf340371370e839a", "input": "claim: We should build new nuclear power plants.\n perspective: Nuclear energy will not change carbon emissions in the atmosphere ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-93b97a2473ae4f9a9582d5df6d2ded18", "input": "claim: Violent video games cause violent crime.\n perspective: Restricting violent video games will have no correlation to a reduction in societal crime.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-fc3f0d2bfedf4f689329cba0cd31b71c", "input": "claim: We should allow death penalty for the worst of the worst criminals.\n perspective: The penalty of death is a crime deterrent.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d8f87852811642d481e01d7aaed7ec42", "input": "claim: You have nothing to worry about surveillance if you have done nothing wrong.\n perspective: Power trips can be had by agencies.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-39bcc9d6059f4f7a8982e87a4d8dcfe0", "input": "claim: The US and its allies were justified in taking military action against Iraq following Iraq’s invasion of Kuwait.\n perspective: The Coalition had a high probability of success", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d5db9920fd364287a5958241c2ce00b3", "input": "claim: The United States should use the electoral college in presidential elections.\n perspective: With the electoral college in place, it weakens people's incentives for voting.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-06e6e098ae844c36ae9fd2190a7ae30b", "input": "claim: College education is worth it.\n perspective: Attending college is a great way to network. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-b0738990de004d2d88cd4c5487749247", "input": "claim: social networking sites should be banned at the workplaces.\n perspective: The public has a reliable source of essential public health and safety information through their social media accounts.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a66a3cbb55f2489a842f916f4e119def", "input": "claim: Democracy Is the Best Form of Government.\n perspective: Promoting democracy promotes peace.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-89ad1c0e78c2440cb0c6033d630d998b", "input": "claim: Same sex relationships should have the same legal status as heterosexual relationships under EU law.\n perspective: A proper marriage is between two heterosexual people of different genders.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-8cc31542ab944a3994fe0ce7d17b637c", "input": "claim: Africans are worse off due to natural resources.\n perspective: Conflict is centered around resources. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-7025a09304d44f71a97131bc4c09cb82", "input": "claim: Same sex relationships should have the same legal status as heterosexual relationships under EU law.\n perspective: Gay marriage is contrary to the word of God and is incompatible with the beliefs, sacred texts, and traditions of many religious groups. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-21ce4e9f80ec404cadef5df04c0a5f6a", "input": "claim: We must ban negative advertising in political campaigns.\n perspective: Negative campaigning creates voter apathy and prevents accurate reporting of candidates’ policies and ideologies.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-21d3e6a68cdd40ada21d9e5ea50ac592", "input": "claim: The United States should maintain its embargo against Cuba.\n perspective: The embargo prevents the people of Cuba from joining the digital age by cutting them off from technology, and restricts the electronic flow of information to the island. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a4b42f69b2d34fb79f518ac2e0956a12", "input": "claim: The use of animals as objects of sport and entertainment should be banned.\n perspective: Using animals in sport demeans humans. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e563887e1c6f4ba4a482bea229bc8b97", "input": "claim: Tennessee is correct to protect teachers who wish to explore the merits of creationism.\n perspective: Teachers shouldn't teach whatever they want.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-56055cc093144503b2e60eaffdeb07ec", "input": "claim: The niqab and other face coverings in schools must be banned.\n perspective: It causes division within society", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-db022e2e115a4ecebf642f55707d8981", "input": "claim: Sikh school pupils should be allowed to carry ceremonial daggers.\n perspective: It is a potential weapon.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-02499eac013747419f1bb07b156b1fc1", "input": "claim: Increased taxes are good for America.\n perspective: Changing the wealth around to help income disparity ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-7fd1e579419e4177bc04c42de4a20267", "input": "claim: Strict parenting works best.\n perspective: Kids deserve some freedom. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-9a0258ff3c5e4957b4d0d3effb847f7f", "input": "claim: School Uniforms Should Be Mandatory.\n perspective: Making school uniforms mandatory creates a sense of equality since everyone will be wearing the same clothes.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-167c82ff7dc743a7945dc7ebb992af3c", "input": "claim: Reality TV shows are an important part of popular culture today.\n perspective: Reality TV is disgusting.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-10d23a7952af4c7fa1d2fe0029f935c7", "input": "claim: Gay couples should be allowed to marry.\n perspective: The concept of \"traditional marriage\" has changed over time, and the definition of marriage as always being between one man and one woman is historically inaccurate. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-784cdd0532b3482e94ce8112fef2242a", "input": "claim: Disclose previous convictions in court.\n perspective: Allowing this motion would lead to a miscarriage of justice.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-8327d6a5a2634f8cb9f56596252d962f", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: Social media facilitates political change.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-739a60f4bb834150a9583b144b13e46a", "input": "claim: We must negotiate with terrorists.\n perspective: Negotiations cannot take place while innocents are being threatened", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-620ee84c8f394eb49d695bcc72385c9d", "input": "claim: We should be investing in public transport.\n perspective: it is the only way to stop our lazy nation from driving", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-da431bde321d499bb30d56603da75bf4", "input": "claim: Basic income tax should be abolished.\n perspective: Balancing governmental problems for society", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-cc96b45839494270b61fdeaccea6751f", "input": "claim: More gun control laws should be enacted.\n perspective: More gun control laws are needed in protecting women from domestic abusers and stalkers.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c93897ec59544a82b50a860355220fc9", "input": "claim: It is sometimes right for the government to restrict freedom of speech.\n perspective: Freedoms are not earned or deserved they are given to all people equally and no one should determine which agendas are too extreme to receive this protection.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-3b6fef95407a4932b075b73b66065c0c", "input": "claim: Compensation should be paid for those who have had their culture appropriated.\n perspective: Compensation rights a wrong", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-9faba77bb7284636b22b57d5341de194", "input": "claim: Drones Should Be Used to Take Out Enemy Combatants.\n perspective: Not enough legal oversight prevents the accountability resulting from secret drone strikes.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-bc3936552f8d489baf6b2f18ceb6ab5c", "input": "claim: Homework is a waste of time.\n perspective: Too much homework can be harmful", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e83bc9af41254d1daf2c78a9b4ff086f", "input": "claim: The age of consent laws should be lowered.\n perspective: Lowering the age of consent will open the door to more criminal problems", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-40d7fb2e47804a8e9259b9633ab8b11f", "input": "claim: School vouchers should be encouraged.\n perspective: School vouchers improve education in general by making public schools compete with private schools for students in a free market", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-edc361fe22054ee5bcbcfc7f74cac7ba", "input": "claim: The US and its allies were justified in taking military action against Iraq following Iraq’s invasion of Kuwait.\n perspective: The US' intentions were wrong.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-1bb7ed2e71004de2a6833474231f8bc1", "input": "claim: Wikileaks is not and has never been a non-profit organization.\n perspective: Wikileaks is not accountable ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-8ef4e6637c45402b801d359b84d00010", "input": "claim: Developing nations should place restrictions on rural-urban migration.\n perspective: It is practically impossible to control people's movement", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-f368a544b70247448392779901f55b01", "input": "claim: Wire-tapped and ‘intercepted’ evidence must be allowed as admissible in court.\n perspective: Intercepted evidence is a strong tool against widespread criminal networks.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-79647babaff448b981c48541ef97997e", "input": "claim: Voting should become compulsory.\n perspective: What's the point of voting as politicians don't listen to the public anyways", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-7d8a122c587e45d195eed1e6ac88bc7f", "input": "claim: Ban junk food from schools.\n perspective: Unhealthy foods lead to a higher risk of diabetes.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-18d8930c48584a49807e7e698e7f654b", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: Social media has been found to be used for criminal activity.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-467ee4d383754746a868362ef37721e4", "input": "claim: Europe should be federal.\n perspective: Member states will reap the benefits of a federal Europe.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-37f8c978742e48abb7f8b4e92a6eff5b", "input": "claim: Violent video games cause violent crime.\n perspective: Violent video games have been shown to have positive effect on kindness and cooperative behavior.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c2d3521d4941414a99831c41c11a60a7", "input": "claim: Global Warming is not an issue.\n perspective: There are other things that cause the global warming situation.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-1065a762399042698dbe5a037f8d99b2", "input": "claim: The EU should significantly reduce the amount it spends on agricultural production subsidies.\n perspective: The market needs stability", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-8f3c7c6841c34fe18d5b10110e8bd8ce", "input": "claim: Voting should be compulsory in the UK.\n perspective: There is precedent to compulsory voting working.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-22db4694ffa04244acac91bb710d309a", "input": "claim: Scotland should cede from the union.\n perspective: Scotland's economy cannot survive if it doesn't have England to lean on.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-148db6f44b334a80b7a09d4000453d99", "input": "claim: Vaccination must be made compulsory.\n perspective: It is the state’s duty to protect its community ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-0c60d7b4147540e196bdb21a341a4f5c", "input": "claim: Vaccination must be made compulsory.\n perspective: The state must keep it's community safe.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-6cba51e9941e4fe091ed785c52b509eb", "input": "claim: Vaccination must be made compulsory.\n perspective: The safety of the community is the state's priority.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-7a2e13c825f640ffbf5c26495184f618", "input": "claim: Vaccination must be made compulsory.\n perspective: Compulsory vaccination violates the individuals’ right to bodily integrity", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ccbcdd37106a4d239b2b152c747cc76f", "input": "claim: Vaccination must be made compulsory.\n perspective: Individuals have the right to refuse vaccinations.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-6ea72388cc904fae99fb75902920b867", "input": "claim: Vaccination must be made compulsory.\n perspective: People's bodies are there own, and they have the right to refuse to be vaccinated.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-d26a7b51b40b4d3c903220e79efe132c", "input": "claim: Vaccination must be made compulsory.\n perspective: Compulsory vaccines are a financial relief on the health system ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a224d5408e8e4d339c3914c066370b40", "input": "claim: Vaccination must be made compulsory.\n perspective: The impacts of unvaccinated populations stain the financial resources of the healthcare system.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-9a7da81700e942e2bf892b3f2612bb19", "input": "claim: Vaccination must be made compulsory.\n perspective: A fully vaccinated population lesses the financial stress of the health system.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c11c183d6e714eefbf4fa709ce0e559e", "input": "claim: Vaccination must be made compulsory.\n perspective: Duty to protect the child", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-6939d70c05e84f48a5fe733ba7f35b76", "input": "claim: Vaccination must be made compulsory.\n perspective: Children must be protected.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c9747d520e2248ce9c494bec5cabcfd5", "input": "claim: Vaccination must be made compulsory.\n perspective: It is the duty of the state to protect children.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d89570a2736a48429bdba61a3f711597", "input": "claim: Vaccination must be made compulsory.\n perspective: It is a parental right to decide about vaccinations for a child", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-abe3009e595e4fb48208f4d3d2031990", "input": "claim: Vaccination must be made compulsory.\n perspective: Parents have the right to make the decision about vaccinations for their children.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-0a0e8a07728c4b38b01d5990c3514a64", "input": "claim: Vaccination must be made compulsory.\n perspective: By making vaccinations mandatory, it takes away the rights of the parent.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-6413ee8d2955457095593fa3327246df", "input": "claim: Vaccination must be made compulsory.\n perspective: Vaccines have severe side effects ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-5d3ec35b0a3e4c69b1db401b3d69f08b", "input": "claim: Male infant circumcision is tantamount to child abuse.\n perspective: Parents have the right to use their best judgment, in the light of medical advice, as to what is in the best interest of their child ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-5d79b046037241a6ad423d6ad0ef1858", "input": "claim: Male infant circumcision is tantamount to child abuse.\n perspective: Parents know what best for thier child ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-d0f4d1131bec4356ab349b45c7cd5e66", "input": "claim: Male infant circumcision is tantamount to child abuse.\n perspective: Parents have the right to make the decisions for their child", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-decae5ad62e142568f505f951b1dcdaf", "input": "claim: School Day Should Be Extended.\n perspective: Lessons would feel less broken.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-59ab92b1abbb49d1827f7433c7e644e2", "input": "claim: School Day Should Be Extended.\n perspective: Not enough fundng...", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-7d8ac754385f4231a7aa002c02a27ef0", "input": "claim: School Day Should Be Extended.\n perspective: So much easier for parents!", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-668f8cab39c94103bd148b74ceff6d0a", "input": "claim: School Day Should Be Extended.\n perspective: Less need for homework.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-12e8511e83594db48ffe38622700b850", "input": "claim: School Day Should Be Extended.\n perspective: Time to finish activities", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-46beb172e2ad4022bdc98baefe79cfad", "input": "claim: punishment should fit the criminal.\n perspective: It will cause less re-offenders.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-fc1514387f6048769552d0dbcaf19d2a", "input": "claim: punishment should fit the criminal.\n perspective: Adequate punishment reduces future offenses.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-90dd7192b2d1431e8587b6794a7400dd", "input": "claim: punishment should fit the criminal.\n perspective: Just punishment will lead to less criminals re-offending. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-8bf6a56380624334ba56625db03b5161", "input": "claim: punishment should fit the criminal.\n perspective: The onus should not be on punishing the criminal.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-7fc0c772578e43a48292889e77870543", "input": "claim: punishment should fit the criminal.\n perspective: Punishment should not be the primary focus.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-42d7370350bd470098faf7441ddb1c98", "input": "claim: punishment should fit the criminal.\n perspective: Our main goal should not be punishing the criminal. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-f316ed7fc8ed4af9bfb69bdc65c9338d", "input": "claim: A government has the obligation to lessen the economic gap between its rich and poor citizens.\n perspective: True individual freedom cannot exist without economic security and independence", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d8bc88ea4ad54abaafd0b9c88c9958f3", "input": "claim: A government has the obligation to lessen the economic gap between its rich and poor citizens.\n perspective: The wealth gap does not allow for equality between the rich and the poor and so it should be reduced.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-fe296bc34bce46b8be8da342c7700015", "input": "claim: A government has the obligation to lessen the economic gap between its rich and poor citizens.\n perspective: Society gives an unfair advantage to certain groups of people and reducing the wealth gap will help achieve more equality.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-50bf78a060d742538bfe18e25bcde969", "input": "claim: A government has the obligation to lessen the economic gap between its rich and poor citizens.\n perspective: Wealth gap undermines equality of opportunity; reducing it makes society fairer.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-1dfff32f6e404e4581be2a566c246c0f", "input": "claim: A government has the obligation to lessen the economic gap between its rich and poor citizens.\n perspective: The Rich Poor Gap Silences the Political Voice of the Poor", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d9d05a5930174ba2ae3daeae4992ab4e", "input": "claim: We Should Question Authorities.\n perspective: Why is the authority figure there?", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ef82e61e5ff64b37b4b4399f5ef1b052", "input": "claim: China should be allowed more control over its own seas.\n perspective: Sovereignty of the Seas", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-4408269dbce54a42b77de4bf22c2ea82", "input": "claim: China should be allowed more control over its own seas.\n perspective: China should have freedom of the seas.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c3743769403d4c788254445cde8d5b40", "input": "claim: Islamic State/Daesh is the most significant threat to the west.\n perspective: Daesh and the Syrian civil war is nurture terrorism for export ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-2328729327e2444a92807abc0465b70a", "input": "claim: Islamic State/Daesh is the most significant threat to the west.\n perspective: There are other larger threats.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-f3430c3773cb49ffbd5016ce3028b0b2", "input": "claim: Islamic State/Daesh is the most significant threat to the west.\n perspective: More significant threats than the Islamic State exist for the west.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e28a9831901d40c2ba0a5e7a2027930d", "input": "claim: Islamic State/Daesh is the most significant threat to the west.\n perspective: The Islamic State is not the biggest concern for the western world.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-469796ef0e5d497294ce8bdb302b875c", "input": "claim: Islamic State/Daesh is the most significant threat to the west.\n perspective: There are more important threats to focus on", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-d4dde6e563a5477eb2272a8c97aa5c9d", "input": "claim: Islamic State/Daesh is the most significant threat to the west.\n perspective: The west is insulated by distance from Daesh", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-285b908c090a435f921fad33b9edaed0", "input": "claim: All patents should be removed on anti-retroviral drugs to fight AIDS.\n perspective: Patents on ARVs prevent drug companies from collaborating in the search for a cure for AIDS", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-2d91610ee8af4f11b7d9a42dcaf2b8a9", "input": "claim: Raise The School Leaving Age To 18.\n perspective: With more education comes more opportunities", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f3965241163847ebbba4835dfb77dbc5", "input": "claim: Raise The School Leaving Age To 18.\n perspective: More Education Brings More Opportunities", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-7b26467cd34e42fab56ece122f9fc11f", "input": "claim: Raise The School Leaving Age To 18.\n perspective: The more education you have the more opportunities", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-827a6aefb7404176903e40fb9dfac04d", "input": "claim: Raise The School Leaving Age To 18.\n perspective: More education brings more opportunities", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e32c343add894e5f8761ae94290b9880", "input": "claim: Raise The School Leaving Age To 18.\n perspective: Opportunities are influenced by education", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-741e1875ee384a15a12116fbdc1390dc", "input": "claim: Raise The School Leaving Age To 18.\n perspective: The longer they are educated, the more opportunities they get", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-2e051245fd2e45ef917192c2193c1de6", "input": "claim: Raise The School Leaving Age To 18.\n perspective: Raising the school learning age promotes equal opportunities", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-99075c2d24f74af09705e3bf82ccd1f9", "input": "claim: Raise The School Leaving Age To 18.\n perspective: Raising the school leaving age promotes equal opportunities", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ab90508e6e064d49a2eb7c89c6f64e51", "input": "claim: Raise The School Leaving Age To 18.\n perspective: There are cases where leaving school early is necessary", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c920aef225d541889e6b4123fe76c354", "input": "claim: Raise The School Leaving Age To 18.\n perspective: Forced education achieves little", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-5109a87074a34bcba29b83b6913b58a9", "input": "claim: Raise The School Leaving Age To 18.\n perspective: Little is accomplished when education is forced.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-6b74958a7faf49a490671c39899254ff", "input": "claim: Raise The School Leaving Age To 18.\n perspective: Education that is forced does little.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-38459c3eeade478fba87aa1038fd43fb", "input": "claim: Raise The School Leaving Age To 18.\n perspective: Forced Education Achieves Little", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-953283d5009e4ffd883754bee963d8a6", "input": "claim: Raise The School Leaving Age To 18.\n perspective: Not all skills are best learnt in a classroom environment.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-479129e88ec3468ba27119878154b45f", "input": "claim: Raise The School Leaving Age To 18.\n perspective: Some skills are better learned outside the classroom.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-0d21235755a140fd90dd8d37aa8c60c8", "input": "claim: Raise The School Leaving Age To 18.\n perspective: The classroom environment is not ideal for all lessons.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-feaaabcfec2041c7b9c884cc2d190365", "input": "claim: Raise The School Leaving Age To 18.\n perspective: Raising the school-leaving age is a crucial investment in society's future", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-2f661545a61246ad922229b854bc4011", "input": "claim: Raise The School Leaving Age To 18.\n perspective: A good investment in society would be to raise the school leaving age.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-4d5e7055387b4bae82ea790d4e2728bd", "input": "claim: Raise The School Leaving Age To 18.\n perspective: Society's future depends on raising the school-leaving age.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-4260609ad6c347c297cc70c67fce7cab", "input": "claim: Raise The School Leaving Age To 18.\n perspective: Raising the school-leaving age is a crucial investment in society’s future", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-de2097eb7ea0435585a80e7b3898e96a", "input": "claim: Raise The School Leaving Age To 18.\n perspective: The economy of the future requires more education", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-25d414a9cc6648348c03bb12ce2596de", "input": "claim: Raise The School Leaving Age To 18.\n perspective: In the future, the economy will rely on those with more education.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-90f029296835400e8e331396c9fd0dc9", "input": "claim: Raise The School Leaving Age To 18.\n perspective: The economy needs educated people in order to do well in the future.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ec96f0f1208743b8bce3ee2673d35323", "input": "claim: Raise The School Leaving Age To 18.\n perspective: Society has a moral responsibility to educate all its young people", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c3c384481f914f95b3fe96fc6e50b0f7", "input": "claim: Raise The School Leaving Age To 18.\n perspective: Benefit from the increase in skills through their standard of living", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a33922231c92482bb181c4c82da310cf", "input": "claim: Raise The School Leaving Age To 18.\n perspective: The aging population and increasing retirement age requires higher skills", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d78da3a55bb44a14bb474f75bff3422a", "input": "claim: Raise The School Leaving Age To 18.\n perspective: Young people should have the choice to decide for themselves", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-d0acfe5ad7804ccba164f412231ae4fe", "input": "claim: Raise The School Leaving Age To 18.\n perspective: Young people should have the freedom to make their own choices.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-d3fd534e2dc945479b65f91dd3dc49ee", "input": "claim: Raise The School Leaving Age To 18.\n perspective: Young people should be able to think for themselves and make their own decisions.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-96c6ff1f80844bdbac58b44f14517cc4", "input": "claim: Raise The School Leaving Age To 18.\n perspective: Unrealistically costly", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b854558110104ff5b7cf048cb641a925", "input": "claim: Raise The School Leaving Age To 18.\n perspective: Not everyone is good at studying", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-8a8c07beab224a619649a353a32ee943", "input": "claim: Raise The School Leaving Age To 18.\n perspective: Some people are unable to handle the rigor of university-level coursework.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-941efa622372440686eb014a4c21582a", "input": "claim: Raise The School Leaving Age To 18.\n perspective: We shouldn't force people to study if they aren't good at it and choose not to.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-bd2a05f821214029975a16953113fb53", "input": "claim: Raise The School Leaving Age To 18.\n perspective: not everyone is good academically", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-96bb4e1d685846eebe971ac0abcbad43", "input": "claim: Raise The School Leaving Age To 18.\n perspective: some people are not good at studying", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-efb49f495f824086ab4bd995a8c9df37", "input": "claim: Raise The School Leaving Age To 18.\n perspective: Compulsory studying would be taking young people out of the workforce", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-2af7975632da4743992558b236f0de50", "input": "claim: Raise The School Leaving Age To 18.\n perspective: Making university education compulsory would take young people out of the workforce.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b26e9f5a92e74861b791eac394252751", "input": "claim: Raise The School Leaving Age To 18.\n perspective: some young people would be taken out of workforce by compulsory studying", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-88ab54aa883042e9baa497df78244605", "input": "claim: Raise The School Leaving Age To 18.\n perspective: compulsory studying may remove young people from the workforce", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-25d6144e8b7a4b26bf40b82e52866018", "input": "claim: All countries should have the right to pursue a nuclear defence.\n perspective: Small countries would be able to pursue their independence without having to rely on larger countries.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-2d226ac29d73420bbd33e4bb93bfa8eb", "input": "claim: All countries should have the right to pursue a nuclear defence.\n perspective: Disarmament would actually cause increased insecurity among nations, it is near impossible to guarantee that a nation has disarmed.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-7a48c2babc1247098275dd81201cd267", "input": "claim: All countries should have the right to pursue a nuclear defence.\n perspective: Small countries would no longer need the protection of larger ones, so could become more politically independent.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-550648f5c4644b84bf27d713939fbb74", "input": "claim: All countries should have the right to pursue a nuclear defence.\n perspective: Disarmament would actually cause increased insecurity among nations, you can never really know for sure whether they have disarmed.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e121e41157934c70bfdda706959e59f8", "input": "claim: All countries should have the right to pursue a nuclear defence.\n perspective: Disarmament would actually cause increased insecurity among nations, as there can never be any guarantee that a nation has disarmed", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-3a64a2d0f6f84609ac258c6397c0d9cf", "input": "claim: All countries should have the right to pursue a nuclear defence.\n perspective: Thus the super power model will be broken and small countries will be finally given the chance to have political independence without the need of protection from a ‘big brother’.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a3b31edfaa9c45db86a34a0e8bf0ad65", "input": "claim: All countries should have the right to pursue a nuclear defence.\n perspective: All the people worldwide have the same rights and are equal to one another. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-0609aeaa13fd4edca7cf7df0f6751dd2", "input": "claim: All countries should have the right to pursue a nuclear defence.\n perspective: The pursuit of nuclear defence (respectively the possession of nuclear weapons) by more countries is a guarantee for peace. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-dd136c8f3ba049a1ba6b1999cf9a848e", "input": "claim: All countries should have the right to pursue a nuclear defence.\n perspective: Humanitarian intervention becomes impossible in states that possess nuclear weapons", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a56aa0d255c245b9824bfd42a683c43c", "input": "claim: All countries should have the right to pursue a nuclear defence.\n perspective: Humanitarian missions would not be possible in states that have nuclear weapons.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-fba69685f536408ea6b84953d56d65e9", "input": "claim: All countries should have the right to pursue a nuclear defence.\n perspective: It is very difficult to intercede in humanitarian crises in states wherein nuclear weapons are present.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-0cd32edd9aec4bb9abb2671e393578bc", "input": "claim: All countries should have the right to pursue a nuclear defence.\n perspective: The threat of a state developing nuclear weapons could instigate pre-emptive strikes from its neighbours and rivals to prevent the acquisition of such weapons", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-9379fa558db94eeb93dab0e06d3b7b11", "input": "claim: All countries should have the right to pursue a nuclear defence.\n perspective: Other countries could strike against those developing nuclear weapons to protect themselves.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-2df0c20a843b47cdbd5dc083e8e7ec81", "input": "claim: All countries should have the right to pursue a nuclear defence.\n perspective: To keep other countries from obtaining a nuclear arsenal, other nations may pre-emptively strike.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4c6d573816a244019d4f467a14f575fe", "input": "claim: All countries should have the right to pursue a nuclear defence.\n perspective: The intention of a state to develop nuclear weapons may incite military attacks by enemies and by other supporting countries.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-9c86e6995e60411baa1e51c40c65815b", "input": "claim: All countries should have the right to pursue a nuclear defence.\n perspective: Public acknowledgement of the right to nuclear deterrence will benefit the public regulation of nuclear weapons generally", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d27f4a92e5584845b63ee21dc6601ee3", "input": "claim: All countries should have the right to pursue a nuclear defence.\n perspective: Nuclear weapons give states valuable agenda-setting power on the international stage", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-09bde4c351ff44038ad267b3e8fded86", "input": "claim: All countries should have the right to pursue a nuclear defence.\n perspective: Countries with nuclear weapons have the ability to set their own agenda.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ac61fa27667d418c9c40e7e62539a496", "input": "claim: All countries should have the right to pursue a nuclear defence.\n perspective: States with nuclear weapons are afforded more authority to set agendas at international levels.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-2018c193ad9248b887bcc960590ee15e", "input": "claim: All countries should have the right to pursue a nuclear defence.\n perspective: All countries have a right to defend themselves with nuclear weapons, even when they lack the capacity in conventional weapons", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-dc084d507f8b4d008232ffd9b059b002", "input": "claim: All countries should have the right to pursue a nuclear defence.\n perspective: All states have a right to nuclear self-defense.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-68e4f8482ccd438187e267fb26b55454", "input": "claim: All countries should have the right to pursue a nuclear defence.\n perspective: To use nuclear weapons in defense of the nation is lawful for all countries.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c7c1d78c326b4d0e9ae173c53fd658ae", "input": "claim: All countries should have the right to pursue a nuclear defence.\n perspective: countries have to right to self defense with nuclear weapons, even when they lack capacity in conventional weapon", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-8437124d895647b9a77abfff5fa28b2d", "input": "claim: All countries should have the right to pursue a nuclear defence.\n perspective: all countries are entitled to self defense with nuclear weapons, even when they do not have the capacity to carry conventional weapons", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-0bd4da9c0281472baefbad3741a3de9a", "input": "claim: All countries should have the right to pursue a nuclear defence.\n perspective: Possessing nuclear weapons will be counter to the peaceful interests of states", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-dac30d9d0c954243aef9a95e3bcad41e", "input": "claim: All countries should have the right to pursue a nuclear defence.\n perspective: Nuclear weapons can fall into the wrong hands.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b505d036c8284f87bd4ff8aaedf2c4d2", "input": "claim: All countries should have the right to pursue a nuclear defence.\n perspective: It's conceivable that the wrong people will have the weapons.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-24827a67aa524d668edf5dbb5b3ab848", "input": "claim: All countries should have the right to pursue a nuclear defence.\n perspective: The nukes can end up being used against us.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-dfb1dcf514874b28b43c31084f108468", "input": "claim: All countries should have the right to pursue a nuclear defence.\n perspective: Terrorists will steal nuclear weapons from poorly guarded arsenals", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-627aba51127b480eb71788df4c504392", "input": "claim: All countries should have the right to pursue a nuclear defence.\n perspective: [Iran specific] Iran has threatened to destroy Israel", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4779d99ddc2444948768c57e4e13054e", "input": "claim: All countries should have the right to pursue a nuclear defence.\n perspective: Iran has Israel targeted.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-2f81802bcf784955b4d85e1ffbb85121", "input": "claim: All countries should have the right to pursue a nuclear defence.\n perspective: No country has an inherent right to invade or use aggression against another.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-5d561098f8854210abc9ab54906f9f73", "input": "claim: All countries should have the right to pursue a nuclear defence.\n perspective: The United States has an obligation to protect international stability due to its unique military strength.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-be2a5073ccd44721be7dfdb996629607", "input": "claim: All countries should have the right to pursue a nuclear defence.\n perspective: The US must protect the international community.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b2b58fec8446477a84d700e4b2045c8c", "input": "claim: All countries should have the right to pursue a nuclear defence.\n perspective: The US military is needed to ensure peace.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-9959c776a034484fa497faef9a453956", "input": "claim: All countries should have the right to pursue a nuclear defence.\n perspective: [Iran specific] Others, particularly Israel, would act if the United States did not", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4b57eb6036bd4373a2745c14eaa91d6b", "input": "claim: All countries should have the right to pursue a nuclear defence.\n perspective: If the US does not act on Iran, Israel will", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-d15afc79b31c4dca89214bbe93d9fcd0", "input": "claim: All countries should have the right to pursue a nuclear defence.\n perspective: Nuclear waste disposal is rarely safe/efficient; it is too much to expect a sqeaky clean disposal/disarmament of nuclear weapons ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-891339b1cef84d4c844f76fc27040939", "input": "claim: All countries should have the right to pursue a nuclear defence.\n perspective: Disarmament is impossible, rendering efforts to disarm pointless and simply wasteful", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-3d4b931182af494ab3d53d154bba8b83", "input": "claim: All countries should have the right to pursue a nuclear defence.\n perspective: The abolition of nuclear weapons would actually incentivize the development and use of even more dangerous weapons, such as chemical and biological weapons", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-bb2829a98667465989380b4d28a0a0d7", "input": "claim: All countries should have the right to pursue a nuclear defence.\n perspective: Proliferation of nuclear weapons increases the chances of nuclear accidents", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-7933c26a9f364962b7576ee0533dc146", "input": "claim: All countries should have the right to pursue a nuclear defence.\n perspective: States will give terrorists nuclear weapons", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e47b430ce8114934a522287fa4171ed2", "input": "claim: All countries should have the right to pursue a nuclear defence.\n perspective: Irrational leaders make the possession of nuclear weapons dangerous", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b12efbe7ab844147b60532ff258b3fd5", "input": "claim: All countries should have the right to pursue a nuclear defence.\n perspective: It is immoral to use the threat of nuclear annihilation in order to achieve foreign policy aims", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a049a6c4aa684b7d88f74472d7b27e90", "input": "claim: We should allow death penalty for the worst of the worst criminals.\n perspective: Too many innocents killed", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-9a45e481171742d89ab5790ba227f40f", "input": "claim: We should allow death penalty for the worst of the worst criminals.\n perspective: Many innocents have been killed because of the death penalty.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-d64d36dd27274eeca80deeda6cb669ab", "input": "claim: We should allow death penalty for the worst of the worst criminals.\n perspective: The death penalty has led to innocent people dying.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-49c860d26e704f67991c5ecf707e612e", "input": "claim: We should allow death penalty for the worst of the worst criminals.\n perspective: Can be reserved for the worst of the worst", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-4f62c584075247cbaf5ecc28d74961f8", "input": "claim: We should allow death penalty for the worst of the worst criminals.\n perspective: The death penalty should be used for the worst cases.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-452decf8b85b4ff8a65f93d8c13fcfa8", "input": "claim: We should allow death penalty for the worst of the worst criminals.\n perspective: The death penalty is saved for the most horrible criminals.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-9f58c6631e07444090121952c54737ce", "input": "claim: We should allow death penalty for the worst of the worst criminals.\n perspective: Necessary for punitive justice", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-09b49d4e2c0444ad827142c5393002a4", "input": "claim: We should allow death penalty for the worst of the worst criminals.\n perspective: The death penalty should be used if someone commits first-degree murder. They would receive the same treatment that they gave.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-86b196048e3e4fb3b898a6d58f7984ec", "input": "claim: We should allow death penalty for the worst of the worst criminals.\n perspective: The death penalty should apply as punishment for first-degree murder; an eye for an eye.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-db9b68001db042e3932395a2bec86a5f", "input": "claim: We should allow death penalty for the worst of the worst criminals.\n perspective: Killers must die to satisfy society", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-2fac1598790742b997ae84d97cc7897d", "input": "claim: We should allow death penalty for the worst of the worst criminals.\n perspective: There are more efficient policies than death penalty", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-deb2f20b38af498ab9219f1d44af47b9", "input": "claim: We should allow death penalty for the worst of the worst criminals.\n perspective: Other policies are more efficient than using the death penalty.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-381b849a661f48ad87b502805699eef0", "input": "claim: We should allow death penalty for the worst of the worst criminals.\n perspective: The death penalty is not an efficient policy.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-81c72ed8068145569d75bbe074682953", "input": "claim: We should allow death penalty for the worst of the worst criminals.\n perspective: we are increasing the hate inside terrorist organizations and the dead person will be seen as a hero that animates their fight. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-209fa6fa833d4bb09acbe85bf0fa0dc3", "input": "claim: We should allow death penalty for the worst of the worst criminals.\n perspective: It is dangerous to impose the death penalty because the dead person would be seen as a hero to their terrorist organization.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-44bf576d9e354a158117f0207cdee7a2", "input": "claim: We should allow death penalty for the worst of the worst criminals.\n perspective: The death penalty for terrorists causes their organizations to hate more and to idolize their dead.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-405cd7dc39be4d8d8c136748eb6feea1", "input": "claim: We should allow death penalty for the worst of the worst criminals.\n perspective: Execution helps alleviate the overcrowding of prisons.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-63a5fa6e6e864520a98c6c030d0a1e67", "input": "claim: We should allow death penalty for the worst of the worst criminals.\n perspective: We could make more room in the prison with execution punishment.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-bcddc925f0f341cb8af57f7fb9a37bb9", "input": "claim: We should allow death penalty for the worst of the worst criminals.\n perspective: The solution to the overcrowding in prisons is execution.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-3fe10d336df540f8b6c01c2964f0c99d", "input": "claim: We should allow death penalty for the worst of the worst criminals.\n perspective: The death penalty can produce irreversible miscarriages of justice.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4a9e59e550874c17b1dacb0b56380384", "input": "claim: We should allow death penalty for the worst of the worst criminals.\n perspective: The death penalty is too absolute and too irreversible.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-024fecaa1bc0443db7abea0a3883a751", "input": "claim: We should allow death penalty for the worst of the worst criminals.\n perspective: The death penalty is not justice.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-419b9aa5b99a47ccb9b292c67a9317b1", "input": "claim: We should allow death penalty for the worst of the worst criminals.\n perspective: The death penalty is a financial burden on the state.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-f840a75ccbae44febf2cfad1307abb3f", "input": "claim: We should allow death penalty for the worst of the worst criminals.\n perspective: The expense of the death penalty financial hardship on the state.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b90a7629389d440ab02fc3900b4f1c50", "input": "claim: We should allow death penalty for the worst of the worst criminals.\n perspective: It's a financial loss to the state enforcing the death penalty.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-66dfacb132a942169f68bee8fb22df32", "input": "claim: We should allow death penalty for the worst of the worst criminals.\n perspective: Crime can be prevented by threatening the death penalty.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-138bbdedc30643929e68a2a386fa9849", "input": "claim: We should allow death penalty for the worst of the worst criminals.\n perspective: The death penalty acts as a deterrent to crime", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-6c22070979ed458f9edd35976043a2a2", "input": "claim: We should allow death penalty for the worst of the worst criminals.\n perspective: With the death penalty in place, crime is deterred", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-28ccae0ea3df46f98bcb2c8d230d52c7", "input": "claim: We should allow death penalty for the worst of the worst criminals.\n perspective: The death penalty deters crime.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-61951f65a765418f8bc02dd62a3cf4f7", "input": "claim: We should allow death penalty for the worst of the worst criminals.\n perspective: Execution prevents the accused from committing further crimes.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-9ee52bdf3f234ad59c621b52ac98b73e", "input": "claim: We should allow death penalty for the worst of the worst criminals.\n perspective: State-sanctioned killing is wrong.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-71b44f5a93844585a2ace40b4479c798", "input": "claim: We should allow death penalty for the worst of the worst criminals.\n perspective: It's wrong to have the state enforce killing.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4f3c8b9d3c13444bba784d71836d045f", "input": "claim: We should allow death penalty for the worst of the worst criminals.\n perspective: The sanctioning of the State to kill is just immoral.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-6b7463180f634b99bec0663ecbc5ca12", "input": "claim: Sunbeds should be banned.\n perspective: Unmanned salons are legal, yet deadly", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-8ec2e56f6de245a1889498e6c2a5b103", "input": "claim: Sunbeds should be banned.\n perspective: Unmanned salons are deadly", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-2df2d15f2e974508be789756d3efd3d7", "input": "claim: Sunbeds should be banned.\n perspective: Unmanned salons are very deadly", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-7e2a1a74d092402f89e3d07fbfbc7132", "input": "claim: Sunbeds should be banned.\n perspective: Unmanned salons, while legal, are also deadly", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-9f3cfac32c1f46949e731dcb8bf3a907", "input": "claim: Sunbeds should be banned.\n perspective: Unmanned salons may be legal, but they also may be deadly", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-81c0bf09eda0493f82fb219cb5707173", "input": "claim: The prevalence of ‘African mercenaries’ is decreasing.\n perspective: Decreased Conflict and the end of the mercenary age", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-4bc638a87de14087a0e76212bdd133a3", "input": "claim: The prevalence of ‘African mercenaries’ is decreasing.\n perspective: The end of the mercenary age is related to decreased conflict.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d3497528bf16461aa5b35187d7a7a095", "input": "claim: The prevalence of ‘African mercenaries’ is decreasing.\n perspective: Mercenaries are still hired by NGOs ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ec5e26bfe91e410986086de08d664014", "input": "claim: The prevalence of ‘African mercenaries’ is decreasing.\n perspective: NGOs still hire mercenaries.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-bbdd55dbf4e14fa2a72b00e93cb59195", "input": "claim: The prevalence of ‘African mercenaries’ is decreasing.\n perspective: There is still a place for mercenaries working for NGOs.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-6bd0368f1d844c46acc04e6fe3317307", "input": "claim: The prevalence of ‘African mercenaries’ is decreasing.\n perspective: Mercenaries still have a presence in coups", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4a4853a6d7e94cf0abef5c1302b820b4", "input": "claim: The prevalence of ‘African mercenaries’ is decreasing.\n perspective: Mercenaries are still often involved in political coups.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-1b487318ec5d4b268e3de6665c31ccee", "input": "claim: The prevalence of ‘African mercenaries’ is decreasing.\n perspective: Mercenaries can still be found in coups.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-dd589f9543164bb58d01dedb85686cca", "input": "claim: The prevalence of ‘African mercenaries’ is decreasing.\n perspective: Legislation against mercenaries ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-dcb749b3093049c7b4b908c5cceee193", "input": "claim: The prevalence of ‘African mercenaries’ is decreasing.\n perspective: Laws are being passed against mercenaries.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-be4ab718f29444e7af986ab572eda030", "input": "claim: We must use Unmanned Aerial Vehicles to strike terrorist targets.\n perspective: Using drones blurs the distinction between war and peace.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-09b87f6092c641ee8b824fb905bc395e", "input": "claim: Make all museums free of charge.\n perspective: Museums preserve and display our heritage and therefore should be accessible to all of the public free of charge", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-3b151731711748ed87cf88b6dce58d15", "input": "claim: Make all museums free of charge.\n perspective: Since museums essentially maintain our collective histories, there should be free access to all citizens.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a713f574f6034363a9eab65911573803", "input": "claim: Make all museums free of charge.\n perspective: Museums exist as an archive of our shared experiences and history, and as such, should grant access to all without charge. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-2951d96db1b449cb9f29a3480d357101", "input": "claim: Make all museums free of charge.\n perspective: State funding should be used elsewhere", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-6b2f4238a21c4a4fa107d19434d8ded0", "input": "claim: Make all museums free of charge.\n perspective: Funding for museums is wasteful", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-55eca20a7a6f496688e18059d3e3f9f0", "input": "claim: Make all museums free of charge.\n perspective: We should not expect the state to fund museums", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-1af2c1b5f0444e968e82ecd4c5fec6a9", "input": "claim: Make all museums free of charge.\n perspective: Museums are a crucial source of inspiration and education", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-548131cc81b5498ab6af5b60968357a8", "input": "claim: Make all museums free of charge.\n perspective: Museums are a necessary part of a society's understanding of culture and edification.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-867d1bb8a2774b709c1e43c1e96706c5", "input": "claim: Make all museums free of charge.\n perspective: Museums are critical to the motivations as well as the education of a society as a whole. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-0111de65d42c4f7880c184806502a905", "input": "claim: Make all museums free of charge.\n perspective: Museum charges can be offset by government funding", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-3ade366f18b7439d916c5ac116524776", "input": "claim: Make all museums free of charge.\n perspective: Free museums encourage attendance", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-cbcd0ce60a35450b922ff0f34aa2c03b", "input": "claim: Make all museums free of charge.\n perspective: People are more likely to attend museums if they are free. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ffab092361d54e8d844abd25bcdf731f", "input": "claim: Make all museums free of charge.\n perspective: If state-funded, there is little incentive to increase numbers of visitors", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-2e6a7c7f7ac74f2c9439d45a5e066ce4", "input": "claim: Mind Sports Such as Chess, Quizzing and Debating Should Be Olympic Sports.\n perspective: Chess lacks the necessary physical activity", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-8fc3a692f9d844f8b1315a40114281e7", "input": "claim: Mind Sports Such as Chess, Quizzing and Debating Should Be Olympic Sports.\n perspective: Olympic sports are suppose to be physical", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-1198963d7143473e91106c155435c904", "input": "claim: Mind Sports Such as Chess, Quizzing and Debating Should Be Olympic Sports.\n perspective: Mind sports are some of the world's oldest and most contested competitive sports.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-02521cf256f944bea70376454da4ff91", "input": "claim: Mind Sports Such as Chess, Quizzing and Debating Should Be Olympic Sports.\n perspective: Mind sports have been around for centuries and are competitive.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-b5f9ca981bd04b8896a269f8fbe3bfd5", "input": "claim: Mind Sports Such as Chess, Quizzing and Debating Should Be Olympic Sports.\n perspective: Mind sports is the oldest and most highly competitive sports.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-9635d12f9f4f4a56bcd7fe634cc74181", "input": "claim: Mind Sports Such as Chess, Quizzing and Debating Should Be Olympic Sports.\n perspective: Chess ought to qualify as an Olympic sport", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-b7223ae05f784fdd8f4e07bef94dee3c", "input": "claim: Mind Sports Such as Chess, Quizzing and Debating Should Be Olympic Sports.\n perspective: It would be appropriate for Chess to become an Olympic sport.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-2b9bb2b2db224118ac057331bd495808", "input": "claim: Mind Sports Such as Chess, Quizzing and Debating Should Be Olympic Sports.\n perspective: Chess is currently not an Olympic sport, but it should be.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-4668b67fe2c14d4489a1ecc4744cd004", "input": "claim: Mind Sports Such as Chess, Quizzing and Debating Should Be Olympic Sports.\n perspective: chess should be included in the list of Olympic sport", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-21ae6f712ee44dc9a373c317db8f4687", "input": "claim: Mind Sports Such as Chess, Quizzing and Debating Should Be Olympic Sports.\n perspective: Opening up the Olympics for borderline sports is bad in itself", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e5722bc748d34a1590471f1f76ac6659", "input": "claim: Mind Sports Such as Chess, Quizzing and Debating Should Be Olympic Sports.\n perspective: Chess is highly popular and should be represented", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-940bcd565bb04bf39f4aec4e0a40abef", "input": "claim: Mind Sports Such as Chess, Quizzing and Debating Should Be Olympic Sports.\n perspective: Chess is popular worldwide and should be an Olympic sport.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-46d84218a3c24d918d4338b6c3029fb0", "input": "claim: Mind Sports Such as Chess, Quizzing and Debating Should Be Olympic Sports.\n perspective: The popularity of Chess worldwide sets it up as an appropriate Olympic sport.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-5171ceb1534d4c05a3c9850e900a4692", "input": "claim: Mind Sports Such as Chess, Quizzing and Debating Should Be Olympic Sports.\n perspective: Chess is one of the popular sport that should be represented at the Olympic.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c4fef502968e4f16bcb8a877605baf5c", "input": "claim: Mind Sports Such as Chess, Quizzing and Debating Should Be Olympic Sports.\n perspective: Introducing chess would preserve the spirit of the ancient Olympic Games", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-0e9ff970ff354d79b704acec0af364d7", "input": "claim: Mind Sports Such as Chess, Quizzing and Debating Should Be Olympic Sports.\n perspective: Chess cannot ensure fair play", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ba0bc8d9fb494a4e8811b3f862a5365d", "input": "claim: The right to anonymous posting on the internet should be protected by law.\n perspective: Internet anonymity allows people to speak the truth without fearing harm to their careers", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c20ecaccd6dc4e618ac4489f456cfe73", "input": "claim: The right to anonymous posting on the internet should be protected by law.\n perspective: Internet anonymity encourages honesty.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-82b18c5c1dc94866a6b55dbc593270fe", "input": "claim: The right to anonymous posting on the internet should be protected by law.\n perspective: Internet anonymity enables citizens to exercise their right to free speech", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f9a8494692024ec4a34d39b215d8bf86", "input": "claim: The right to anonymous posting on the internet should be protected by law.\n perspective: Anonymity online allows for free speech.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a2d0f49d06d44b8db04acf01ab83857e", "input": "claim: The right to anonymous posting on the internet should be protected by law.\n perspective: Internet anonymity leads to spam", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-eabc6af7d5bb4101bcf6f3a9d2da1f65", "input": "claim: The right to anonymous posting on the internet should be protected by law.\n perspective: Span proliferates with anonymity on the internet.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-061f88f01e5645799dce80587179801d", "input": "claim: The right to anonymous posting on the internet should be protected by law.\n perspective: Internet anonymity increases cyberbullying and trolling", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-7271eba0de35475f90cee1750ffbd684", "input": "claim: The right to anonymous posting on the internet should be protected by law.\n perspective: Individuals are more likely to bully and troll when they are anonymous.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-5ce09d92087344b5b1576797cc3968ee", "input": "claim: The right to anonymous posting on the internet should be protected by law.\n perspective: Cyberbullying and trolling are more common when people's internet activity is anonymous.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ae5341cb0c3841fa89663416b4290611", "input": "claim: The right to anonymous posting on the internet should be protected by law.\n perspective: Internet anonymity allows people to experiment and construct with new social identities", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-57f3d70c78d74d15931ced08da93a2b9", "input": "claim: The right to anonymous posting on the internet should be protected by law.\n perspective: People are able to create new social identities when the internet is anonymous.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c7e6b4d0d111451d9667db4d7e84f3ac", "input": "claim: The right to anonymous posting on the internet should be protected by law.\n perspective: The anonymity of the internet allows people to create new social identities for themselves.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-96ff936528ea4fac8a407e5d825157ae", "input": "claim: The right to anonymous posting on the internet should be protected by law.\n perspective: Internet anonymity allows internet users to engage in illegal activities ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-686d8cf96c4148c791f6c09e3d03e458", "input": "claim: The right to anonymous posting on the internet should be protected by law.\n perspective: When internet users are anonymous, they are more easily able to engage in illegal activities.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-5081c028ad524557a343632daa767730", "input": "claim: The right to anonymous posting on the internet should be protected by law.\n perspective: There is less deterrance to illegal activities on the internet when people are able to remain anonymous.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-dc59215b3a314e88aaf81d857e4aba10", "input": "claim: Sports initiations should be banned.\n perspective: Encourages binge drinking and bullying", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-b1526ff4e8fc481aaf9c63211ebbdb2f", "input": "claim: Chess must be at the Olympics.\n perspective: Chess ought to qualify as an Olympic sport", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-9b2e0392b55b404f944259bc36a14a78", "input": "claim: Chess must be at the Olympics.\n perspective: It would be appropriate for Chess to become an Olympic sport.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c32c63156e2f4bc6809a60850044f361", "input": "claim: Chess must be at the Olympics.\n perspective: Chess is currently not an Olympic sport, but it should be.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-25e7d114f1f44732a20d611fea8185d8", "input": "claim: Chess must be at the Olympics.\n perspective: chess should be included in the list of Olympic sport", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ebed811786dc43828bd9ef833af38bc7", "input": "claim: Chess must be at the Olympics.\n perspective: Opening up the Olympics for borderline sports is bad in itself", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-3bb6cd6a575a48a2b92a4470064a0b08", "input": "claim: Chess must be at the Olympics.\n perspective: Chess lacks the necessary physical activity", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-64a44cff44774de787340bcd7e2147b9", "input": "claim: Chess must be at the Olympics.\n perspective: Olympic sports are suppose to be physical", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-5617a7569ee04b1e965b4e824272a4e6", "input": "claim: Chess must be at the Olympics.\n perspective: Chess is highly popular and should be represented", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-63671536019a4605ae119cad93a71004", "input": "claim: Chess must be at the Olympics.\n perspective: Chess is popular worldwide and should be an Olympic sport.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-edb0fc7efaab496eb7db552ffd907ffb", "input": "claim: Chess must be at the Olympics.\n perspective: The popularity of Chess worldwide sets it up as an appropriate Olympic sport.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-42aef834bfa44db2b13cd3451d39e763", "input": "claim: Chess must be at the Olympics.\n perspective: Chess is one of the popular sport that should be represented at the Olympic.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-32da3589186d4d62b6144274fa4f591c", "input": "claim: Chess must be at the Olympics.\n perspective: Introducing chess would preserve the spirit of the ancient Olympic Games", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-1e244eaa1fc846bdaa4bbf030dbdecda", "input": "claim: Chess must be at the Olympics.\n perspective: Chess cannot ensure fair play", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-51bab3e289c94735b30feec7893133c3", "input": "claim: Chess must be at the Olympics.\n perspective: Mind sports are some of the world's oldest and most contested competitive sports.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e1c23a46418f433890e99c5a39a9bb1b", "input": "claim: Chess must be at the Olympics.\n perspective: Mind sports have been around for centuries and are competitive.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-58285006ca89465e90eb888bff4acda1", "input": "claim: Chess must be at the Olympics.\n perspective: Mind sports is the oldest and most highly competitive sports.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-15652849ed7c49aba2c39e60c5e9a455", "input": "claim: There should be no permanent members of the UN Security Council.\n perspective: It would make the UNSC more effective and efficient", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-eff6b92d905445b1b57c2c5ee9ee63f1", "input": "claim: There should be no permanent members of the UN Security Council.\n perspective: Argument 2: UNSC sanctions become powerless without PM", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ecc7024e2c434bce86d1307f733d8bdd", "input": "claim: There should be no permanent members of the UN Security Council.\n perspective: Any decisions imposed by the previous Security Council risk being annulled when the new members rotate in.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-9df3f2d1f9e0420e94cd12f9cf574d0e", "input": "claim: There should be no permanent members of the UN Security Council.\n perspective: UN sanctions would lose power, as they could be revoked by the new Security Council.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e11254b779054d96aa14125d13f87fce", "input": "claim: There should be no permanent members of the UN Security Council.\n perspective: It will lead to fair regional representation, as well as make it more legitimate and flexible", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-21e1b53268aa4f10b6fededb740b2ba1", "input": "claim: There should be no permanent members of the UN Security Council.\n perspective: With rotation in its membership, the UN Security Council would be a more fair and flexible in its representation.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c1eb873a30e5465f8e559acf76743f73", "input": "claim: There should be no permanent members of the UN Security Council.\n perspective: By removing permanent membership, the Security Council would be viewed as more legitimate, as it can better represent all regions of the world.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a584fb0b8c6d407e8f0a9f1ff42ce753", "input": "claim: There should be no permanent members of the UN Security Council.\n perspective: Argument 1: PM serves interests of developing countries", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c56dc6c5a0f94619b5984441af7efd01", "input": "claim: Persistent Bullies Should be Expelled.\n perspective: Bullies will not understand only if you talk to them, you need actions!", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-806e1db93c564a6caef2bd5e80467c17", "input": "claim: Persistent Bullies Should be Expelled.\n perspective: Harmful to others around them", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d3b826145ab74658819fd3735e8dbeca", "input": "claim: Persistent Bullies Should be Expelled.\n perspective: Bullies create a harmful environment.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ad11cafe1d394e2abb4d009725f9d929", "input": "claim: Persistent Bullies Should be Expelled.\n perspective: Individuals do not feel safe in the hostile environments created by bullies.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-16f72d3a39ae4e7292d97920ae9fd783", "input": "claim: Persistent Bullies Should be Expelled.\n perspective: There are different levels/degrees of bullying", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-5e6d0d3ae1e844c7b5e6e127c3571065", "input": "claim: Persistent Bullies Should be Expelled.\n perspective: One needs to look at the specific bullying behavior.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-2830214e68ca44b08709ea4ca5721e7f", "input": "claim: Persistent Bullies Should be Expelled.\n perspective: Bullying behavior varies greatly and individual instances need to be taken into account.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-0c52ac1cc37b4ddeab8a1eff504c103f", "input": "claim: Persistent Bullies Should be Expelled.\n perspective: Expelling a child will make them worse.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-f4e02dcf6b1848c69c572b480333df59", "input": "claim: Everyone should go vegetarian.\n perspective: Vegetarianism is healthier ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-32910e25af41468f9311b33bf1588cdf", "input": "claim: Everyone should go vegetarian.\n perspective: Being vegetarian reduces risks of food poisoning", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-3df8e3ed95c342288042e6d5c17b76a2", "input": "claim: Everyone should go vegetarian.\n perspective: It is cruel and unethical to kill animals for food when vegetarian options are available. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f259417b18f3439c9f02e09b107d6dcc", "input": "claim: Everyone should go vegetarian.\n perspective: If there are meat-free options available, it is brutal and immoral to kill animals for food", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-5c2b17bf0ae54092b6ec8898ec434d3b", "input": "claim: Everyone should go vegetarian.\n perspective: It is deplorable and unconscionable to take the life of an animal for food when one has a choice to eat vegetarian meals", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f3087e19a60c420191140837bb246dfb", "input": "claim: Everyone should go vegetarian.\n perspective: It is immoral to kill animals ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-7e9a051907ca446788f107ad8f4035d2", "input": "claim: Everyone should go vegetarian.\n perspective: The right to eat what we want, including meat, is a fundamental liberty that we must defend. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a844af1c430d4d578977e5bff5c7cdc2", "input": "claim: Everyone should go vegetarian.\n perspective: Humans can choose their own nutrition plan ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-98a10fa5a2e54a22a50192ac1484b91f", "input": "claim: Everyone should go vegetarian.\n perspective: Individuals have a right to eat meat if they want to.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4e0f4005c01b46579c8bce5a74627fe8", "input": "claim: Everyone should go vegetarian.\n perspective: People have a right to eat meat or anything else that they want to.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-411da9a4ff5a4ff5b5b62acfe3e23403", "input": "claim: Everyone should go vegetarian.\n perspective: We may accept that we have the right to eat meat", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-0e5c9271c5d24adf8f1415b8466a057e", "input": "claim: Everyone should go vegetarian.\n perspective: Being vegetarian helps the environment ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-b7873a7040894bb596fc0cf822df3271", "input": "claim: Everyone should go vegetarian.\n perspective: There are problems with being vegetarian", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ee77f09ed1ce4cc7a1a3b438e37c4b90", "input": "claim: Everyone should go vegetarian.\n perspective: A vegetarian diet reduces overuse of antibiotics. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-91c6caff9bff47b7b39d709234390ecf", "input": "claim: Everyone should go vegetarian.\n perspective: Anitbiotics aren't used in vegetarian foods.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-461f0d8f9d4641aca3e8459a531c5ddb", "input": "claim: Everyone should go vegetarian.\n perspective: Vegetarian diets result in a reduction of antibiotic usage.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-b3a14b79915c46edaeef17b46147c52b", "input": "claim: Everyone should go vegetarian.\n perspective: Vegetarian diets are not necessarily better for the environment. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e2ac2ca6e8ce48c593b6465a0605f59a", "input": "claim: Everyone should go vegetarian.\n perspective: There is no evidence that vegetarian diets help the environment. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-489ad0163ed447909efacc8b6336e0d2", "input": "claim: Everyone should go vegetarian.\n perspective: People who eat meat are not harming the environment. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e6cd5cd6eb91496d88a7b08de7534181", "input": "claim: Everyone should go vegetarian.\n perspective: Vegetarian diets aren't always more environmentally friendly", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-9b785056fe9b4814af65d549792c71eb", "input": "claim: Everyone should go vegetarian.\n perspective: Vegetarianism doesn't always help the environment", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-3b029c6dbfd643b7b934bc997c43ade4", "input": "claim: Everyone should go vegetarian.\n perspective: Human anatomy has evolved to support a primarily vegetarian diet. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-29fbbea87e7643b982b029e718a3c1b7", "input": "claim: Everyone should go vegetarian.\n perspective: The human body has changed over time to be able to handle a largely vegetarian diet", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-aa9bb595fdf94485b28b96aad257b4a8", "input": "claim: Everyone should go vegetarian.\n perspective: The internal organs of humans have changed over time to support a diet that is free of meat", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-497ea8ba7a8d4fefb15f6c77a7567ba7", "input": "claim: Everyone should go vegetarian.\n perspective: A vegetarian diet reduces the chances of developing kidney stones and gallstones. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-9d00ba5bedbb4c79bd280e9b768745ef", "input": "claim: Everyone should go vegetarian.\n perspective: Risk of kidney stones and gallstones can be reduced with a vegetarian diet.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-089536692e80444abc49d0d79d490fb0", "input": "claim: Everyone should go vegetarian.\n perspective: Vegetarians do not live longer. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-0d4a2007ce0c4f07bc49dd956432807d", "input": "claim: Everyone should go vegetarian.\n perspective: People who eat meat live just as long as vegetarians.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ccc948bfa435468098ef31a8c0965cf2", "input": "claim: Everyone should go vegetarian.\n perspective: Vegetarians die at the same rate as meat eaters.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-26139300439347ed834a2e2687e72bea", "input": "claim: Everyone should go vegetarian.\n perspective: Vegetarians have average lifespans", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-dbf319b439e14e30bad8e5534d8de4b7", "input": "claim: Everyone should go vegetarian.\n perspective: Vegetarianism makes no difference in longevity", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4e1631d56d394d6cb9548bc7006cb2e6", "input": "claim: Everyone should go vegetarian.\n perspective: vegetarians are 40 % less likely to have cancer", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-38d36465a83942a8ab61af16c6338cb8", "input": "claim: Everyone should go vegetarian.\n perspective: Eating meat has been an essential part of human evolution for 2.3 million years. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4d1fcfc2cfd6441c889bb5700395bbe5", "input": "claim: Everyone should go vegetarian.\n perspective: Our bodies were not designed for a vegan diet", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-5c903c68bbf7445a800b642cfc1f8043", "input": "claim: Everyone should go vegetarian.\n perspective: The evolution of humanity has progressed due to meat eating for 2.3 million years.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-456eaea907494da68c02ed4482805618", "input": "claim: Everyone should go vegetarian.\n perspective: It has been vital for humans to eat meat for over 2 million years.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-2614f8c75f55438ab8a779a3ee140d7a", "input": "claim: Everyone should go vegetarian.\n perspective: A vegetarian diet lowers the risk of heart disease. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-44609c0608884cb2bf31e2752c5be2c1", "input": "claim: Everyone should go vegetarian.\n perspective: A diet devoid of meat lowers the risk of heart disease.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ef565622119f454ca8ce81c0200f7b17", "input": "claim: Everyone should go vegetarian.\n perspective: The risk of heart disease is reduced in people who adhere to a vegetarian diet.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-bbc49854530d4131807ed2ba06750f99", "input": "claim: Everyone should go vegetarian.\n perspective: A vegetarian diet provides a more healthful form of iron than a meat-based diet. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ac10a9c6013546d5aca8783030a928ca", "input": "claim: Everyone should go vegetarian.\n perspective: Iron from a vegetarian diet is healthier than from a meat-based diet.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-51a82f6590904510a8f22d036e327b2b", "input": "claim: Everyone should go vegetarian.\n perspective: A vegetarian diet is a healthier way to get iron than from a meat-based diet.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-432ca95973fd44038801eb1288039697", "input": "claim: Everyone should go vegetarian.\n perspective: A vegetarian diet can help alleviate world hunger. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e15c6cdeaa334fc2873ed8737f30d204", "input": "claim: Everyone should go vegetarian.\n perspective: World hunger can be reduced with a vegetarian diet.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-bc87188744e84233a6bb64b6794954f9", "input": "claim: Everyone should go vegetarian.\n perspective: Eating a vegetarian diet can lead to less hunger around the world.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e8633e0f3bae403bab918af97641747a", "input": "claim: Everyone should go vegetarian.\n perspective: Eating meat provides healthy saturated fats, which enhance the function of the immune and nervous systems. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-8dbf7d4869fa4699b1343f1a499a34ea", "input": "claim: Everyone should go vegetarian.\n perspective: Saturated fats in meat help the immune and nervous system.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-5e375829a7cc401b82380e7a4d4cef1f", "input": "claim: Everyone should go vegetarian.\n perspective: Lean red meat, eaten in moderation, can be a healthful part of a balanced diet. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-12caef40b9e64b18ab0c0de5628ffc87", "input": "claim: Everyone should go vegetarian.\n perspective: Red meat can be unhealthy if eaten in large quantities and too often but is healthy in moderation. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-20ca8ba30c524ee2aa0706fc64470628", "input": "claim: Everyone should go vegetarian.\n perspective: A balanced and healthy diet consists of vegetables and lean red meat. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-cd84c58359c44fff954a85aa84a74705", "input": "claim: Everyone should go vegetarian.\n perspective: Lean red meat can be healthy", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ef9df5af41f04dfbabde8b4c6713568a", "input": "claim: Everyone should go vegetarian.\n perspective: Lean red meat is not necessarily unhealthy", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-52365a43509a4bbc80f2c36468c13227", "input": "claim: Everyone should go vegetarian.\n perspective: Vegetarian diets can cause the death of animals too. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-63681549141a416cb8b08c7eeec58eea", "input": "claim: Everyone should go vegetarian.\n perspective: Animals can also die as a result of vegetarian diets.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-2dc08fed6323440db744977354ab8faf", "input": "claim: Everyone should go vegetarian.\n perspective: Animals will still die even if everyone were to follow a vegetarian diet.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-7bd3f131831d49b7bbf4f611ce6e8eba", "input": "claim: Everyone should go vegetarian.\n perspective: Vegetarian diets can cause the death of animals too", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4e5864a937854e74b95e48f182b9d709", "input": "claim: Everyone should go vegetarian.\n perspective: Eating meat increases the risk of getting type 2 diabetes. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e06b58d0a07c4101a6aafc4781af3b84", "input": "claim: Everyone should go vegetarian.\n perspective: Eating More Meat is Linked to Higher Risk of Type 2", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-1fc8ff01f12e43b1b7cf424cda361f54", "input": "claim: Everyone should go vegetarian.\n perspective: Processed vegetarian protein options such as tofu can cause more greenhouse gas pollution than farming meat. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-69fad9dd57b54e869347846f4c61cd13", "input": "claim: Everyone should go vegetarian.\n perspective: Farming meat can produce less pollution than companies that process vegetarian proteins like tofu.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-81cf6125ff2f4509a014f5a92d5f3740", "input": "claim: Everyone should go vegetarian.\n perspective: Some vegetarian options cause more greenhouse gas emissions than meat production", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-229d646965b84a69885130f6a883496f", "input": "claim: Everyone should go vegetarian.\n perspective: Processed vegetarian protein is less environmentally friendly than eating meat", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ec69f594e5074349a8d7490cab1e0264", "input": "claim: Everyone should go vegetarian.\n perspective: It is not necessary to become vegetarian to lower our environmental footprint. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-0f79a8d45ae248d79a2a8ec5ce251e0c", "input": "claim: Everyone should go vegetarian.\n perspective: There are ways other than giving up meat to help the environment.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-d7e45fe8dad849cea91a93f042af542f", "input": "claim: Everyone should go vegetarian.\n perspective: People do not have to stop eating meat to improve environmental conditions.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-2fd3d334dfa24994b44b6a43a84c1ed9", "input": "claim: Everyone should go vegetarian.\n perspective: A vegetarian diet conserves water. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-457c95f219e741638de9650ead0ebe64", "input": "claim: Everyone should go vegetarian.\n perspective: People can conserve water by becoming a vegetarian.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c14d84e08b5e4e84a614bbfc8edf62ea", "input": "claim: Everyone should go vegetarian.\n perspective: Becoming a vegetarian is healthy for the environment because people conserve more water.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-af5b0872a74a45ea8d34889f375a92e9", "input": "claim: Everyone should go vegetarian.\n perspective: Becoming vegetarian will not help alleviate world hunger. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-963354549757479999cdf65d07246f9b", "input": "claim: Everyone should go vegetarian.\n perspective: World hunger can not be fixed by vegetarianism. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-bb204eb8a494460b9cfbf6ad3dc2ce40", "input": "claim: Everyone should go vegetarian.\n perspective: There must be access to meats in order to alleviate world hunger. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e976788b46d442c7b7d22022d3b92498", "input": "claim: Everyone should go vegetarian.\n perspective: Vegetarian diets won't help world hunger", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-366df0b28ef64ac0ae7f4568b355df00", "input": "claim: Everyone should go vegetarian.\n perspective: Vegetarianism doesn't reduce world hunger", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-168369f5e8474f9d85e31569439c66a0", "input": "claim: Everyone should go vegetarian.\n perspective: Raising animals for food contributes to air and water pollution. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c1c4531ed14f41159f45ca8f7826c204", "input": "claim: Everyone should go vegetarian.\n perspective: Vegetarians live longer. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-7164c478648d488a9d98ba5a90f30679", "input": "claim: Everyone should go vegetarian.\n perspective: It has been proven that Vegetarians Live Longer", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-7367b0e254ff4b35931ffdac601a4d87", "input": "claim: Everyone should go vegetarian.\n perspective: Eating meat provides a better source of iron than a vegetarian diet. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-410da1fc9d734b1084497341d5da1e1d", "input": "claim: Everyone should go vegetarian.\n perspective: Iron from meat is often cited as better than vegetables.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4b9121e595824c70aa242143b55029b3", "input": "claim: Everyone should go vegetarian.\n perspective: I think iron from meat eating is healthier than the vegetarian way.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-7e586af3187048f3b716982b96421657", "input": "claim: Everyone should go vegetarian.\n perspective: Producing one hamburger destroys 55 square feet of rainforest. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-37c0161eec034e73a6463768775648c9", "input": "claim: Everyone should go vegetarian.\n perspective: Rainforests are destroyed to support animals used for food.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-3e401905267647b2a1d4353f54959d97", "input": "claim: Everyone should go vegetarian.\n perspective: There is nothing inherently cruel about raising animals for food. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-8ed9554c8f7b4c4e80115d1bef9add7b", "input": "claim: Everyone should go vegetarian.\n perspective: Eating meat is part of the cycle of life.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-cb792ea048b445909473243cab1f447d", "input": "claim: Everyone should go vegetarian.\n perspective: Raising animals for food is not cruel.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-7a09a61e983346ca89865f88a7679b1c", "input": "claim: Everyone should go vegetarian.\n perspective: It is not cruel or wrong to raise animals to be eaten.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-04a536f7933c41b0b8a5fe3820974818", "input": "claim: Everyone should go vegetarian.\n perspective: There is nothing inherently cruel about raising animals for food", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-371ff569cc734d5bac7c5659be8f2090", "input": "claim: Everyone should go vegetarian.\n perspective: Eating meat is not cruel or unethical; it is a natural part of the cycle of life. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b82f5983c75b434f8400b834f224ffaf", "input": "claim: Everyone should go vegetarian.\n perspective: Meat is the best source of vitamin B12, a vitamin necessary to nervous and digestive system health. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c3aee3de3dde4bd793ed3bb10ca24418", "input": "claim: Everyone should go vegetarian.\n perspective: It was proven the b12 from meat is helps the nervous and digestive system.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4c0510017cf54be7a3c9da417e8cd39e", "input": "claim: Everyone should go vegetarian.\n perspective: For optimum nervous and digestive health, b12 from meat is ideal.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a7538d49c2e249fd9f01438030a3e652", "input": "claim: Everyone should go vegetarian.\n perspective: A vegetarian diet leads to lower greenhouse gas emissions. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-32d76607c9a34489a4a58545da7e197d", "input": "claim: Everyone should go vegetarian.\n perspective: If people became vegetarian, greenhouse gases would reduce. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-55b426c76a59406680b377c31a0069f0", "input": "claim: Everyone should go vegetarian.\n perspective: A vegetarian diet is better for the planet because it reduces greenhouse gases.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-991d9baeb31740e1887b51dca023f4c1", "input": "claim: Everyone should go vegetarian.\n perspective: A vegetarian diet delivers complete nutrition and can provide health benefits. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-1248ccbc07784f49a21e92c97772972f", "input": "claim: Everyone should go vegetarian.\n perspective: In addition to health benefits, a vegetarian diet also gives you everything your body needs.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-9cc1f17126da4ce6b377510324731f5b", "input": "claim: Everyone should go vegetarian.\n perspective: Complete nutrition and health benefits can be had with a vegetarian diet.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-beb8ae7789aa4735b71242445f35e57b", "input": "claim: Everyone should go vegetarian.\n perspective: A vegetarian diet promotes a healthy weight. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-3678c8f2ae0543dfa60e966da8f73827", "input": "claim: Everyone should go vegetarian.\n perspective: Healthy weight can be achieved with a vegetarian diet", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-b2adfacd84fa441281acb3ed346c4c10", "input": "claim: Everyone should go vegetarian.\n perspective: A vegetarian diet contributes to a healthy weight", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-0d843ad1baab4dc3b8dc5451d82fbe94", "input": "claim: Everyone should go vegetarian.\n perspective: A vegetarian diet helps build healthy bones because vegetarians absorb more calcium than meat eaters. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-410de92f4849482ea25c8e67c86235fe", "input": "claim: Everyone should go vegetarian.\n perspective: Vegetarian diets allow more calcium to be absorbed than from meat and leads to healthy bones.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-2545d475f05b45f182e744886cc1f1ce", "input": "claim: Everyone should go vegetarian.\n perspective: Meat is the most convenient protein source available. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-d8e9cc553b244a5aac1b3f175d561691", "input": "claim: Everyone should go vegetarian.\n perspective: Meat is the most readily available protein.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-12f4d3c94d9f484ab5e1f11c20603053", "input": "claim: Everyone should go vegetarian.\n perspective: Most find that meat is a very convenient source of protein.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-fed9012a46f14a1ca5bc8d7edf270b26", "input": "claim: Everyone should go vegetarian.\n perspective: It will facilitate world food distribution", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-120bb26039914db7a607ce62e85c8740", "input": "claim: Everyone should go vegetarian.\n perspective: Meat consumption should be reduced, but does NOT need to be eradicated", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d8aa933060b14575916e9706c5d6ba09", "input": "claim: Everyone should go vegetarian.\n perspective: A Vegan diet would not be practical in most parts of the world", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-dd130c49a58d4929b4debbf57f16795b", "input": "claim: A ‘wall’ on the shared USA and Mexico border would be ineffective.\n perspective: At the very least it slows people down", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a4bd219b3a5a439c871daac726592bbe", "input": "claim: Britain should scrap the monarchy.\n perspective: The Monarchy is backward and prejudiced", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-22ac81656dda4c83b0674b46961b3113", "input": "claim: Britain should scrap the monarchy.\n perspective: The Monarchy system is biased and inefficient.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-af781aa464f84eafa3a0551ddac71f84", "input": "claim: Britain should scrap the monarchy.\n perspective: Regressive and biased is how the Monarchy system is.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-336de0aec1b94fb68aa83e52c352ed48", "input": "claim: Britain should scrap the monarchy.\n perspective: The Monarchy contrasts the meaning of Democracy", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-3dd5eaf398724c2d9c943a84592bff3c", "input": "claim: Britain should scrap the monarchy.\n perspective: It is costing the tax payers money which could be better spent", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c3f01f64832a4bcb8985a00442ef5208", "input": "claim: Britain should scrap the monarchy.\n perspective: Tax payers money could be spent more appropriately.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-9df256b0773245f68ab36b89aed7454d", "input": "claim: Britain should scrap the monarchy.\n perspective: The tax payers are the ones losing out on money that could be spent properly.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-de29686bd50c49e3b137b3eb75ad1acf", "input": "claim: Britain should scrap the monarchy.\n perspective: tax payers money is valuable", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c89e0689b833400bbbf978a55895bcb5", "input": "claim: Britain should scrap the monarchy.\n perspective: tax payers money should be useful only to the public", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e1db3b99b32c420699372c00d743beaa", "input": "claim: Britain should scrap the monarchy.\n perspective: Monarchy is a child's creation", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-7841081080fb48c689b651464663f399", "input": "claim: Britain should scrap the monarchy.\n perspective: Monarchy is just childish.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-069a8d5e48014228a737bf377a92090f", "input": "claim: Britain should scrap the monarchy.\n perspective: Monarchy is an infantile idea.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-6f82a27765c94c10abeb7f67fd3e7685", "input": "claim: Britain should scrap the monarchy.\n perspective: it is high time to scrap monarchy", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-3bd891199e8643f1b211ce89131f8e76", "input": "claim: Britain should scrap the monarchy.\n perspective: monarchy in britain led to lots of chaos in the past", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-36adf31893cc47beb350dd01f3f7ccf9", "input": "claim: Britain should scrap the monarchy.\n perspective: Most other countries in Europe have abandoned the monarch", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-063fe6c7a4804798951ef62ac59d0a82", "input": "claim: Britain should scrap the monarchy.\n perspective: The head of state should be a position that is separate and distinct from politics", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-7e7c3d0144e040abac0ef32e8d54fe0b", "input": "claim: Britain should scrap the monarchy.\n perspective: Politics should not include the head of the state as in a monarchy.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-f70ff5d28f9d42728d88247771f250a3", "input": "claim: Britain should scrap the monarchy.\n perspective: There should be a separation from the head of state and politics.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-1be370f68e7347a2b99ed657b6e9cb80", "input": "claim: Britain should scrap the monarchy.\n perspective: There is no divine right to leadership or privilege", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e3049350dbef4f84abebc20d18a49e28", "input": "claim: Britain should scrap the monarchy.\n perspective: Leadership and privilege are not divine rights.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-026c437ce45b4944ac3c7b038e881a7e", "input": "claim: Housewives should be paid for their work.\n perspective: Paying housewives for their work is an important form of economic empowerment.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c68d8a842f3445f19606dc3d2701f020", "input": "claim: Housewives should be paid for their work.\n perspective: Being paid as a housewife is economically empowering", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a263866025504dadae21c58cf416af48", "input": "claim: Housewives should be paid for their work.\n perspective: Paid housewives have a better economic power", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d87bc7f427564ce9863eb903b3adb32c", "input": "claim: Housewives should be paid for their work.\n perspective: Payment and obligation works differently in public and in private.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-d27e235154274517b8156c91f19b6377", "input": "claim: Housewives should be paid for their work.\n perspective: Payments would be more difficult to quantify in private transactions", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-42c71d94f70a4b629d023d2b224f1b04", "input": "claim: Housewives should be paid for their work.\n perspective: It would be too inconvenient to make payments to housewives", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-0722699a7e6c461d9821d40a0c2c4497", "input": "claim: Housewives should be paid for their work.\n perspective: Paying housewives is financially impractical.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-3edc8d48d7f246fd80ec6b4219c418d4", "input": "claim: Housewives should be paid for their work.\n perspective: Paying housewives would be inconvenient", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b49ad6ffee71422489cc08e35464a82c", "input": "claim: Housewives should be paid for their work.\n perspective: Paying housewives would be difficult to achieve in the real world", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-7cf95279b01840daba772486648f97e4", "input": "claim: Housewives should be paid for their work.\n perspective: Housewives are entitled to pay", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-2a792db29852467c8106ffcf7415815f", "input": "claim: Housewives should be paid for their work.\n perspective: Women who are housewives should be paid", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-8f0ea1506447445787064fff7a1d6c33", "input": "claim: Housewives should be paid for their work.\n perspective: Paying housewives reduces social mobility", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-d9d02f8fb9c94b84bbf6eff2521147dc", "input": "claim: Housewives should be paid for their work.\n perspective: Housewives would lack incentives to find better paying, more fulfilling work", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-0031a65ac2bb4f5e83497be4d70a15b1", "input": "claim: Housewives should be paid for their work.\n perspective: Paying housewives would give them less incentives to find better conditions", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-1162637f934a4a1aa0ffc4ef0f435a27", "input": "claim: Housewives should be paid for their work.\n perspective: Paying housewives promotes more positive images of women and family life", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-5f3d0c701a7845648cf67e8da39acf86", "input": "claim: Housewives should be paid for their work.\n perspective: When a housewife is paid, they have a better stand in society", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-43636f7e2b664f7a828afff60ad9d6e8", "input": "claim: Housewives should be paid for their work.\n perspective: Being paid as a housewife promotes more positive images", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c8fc58cd5e524a3facd59ff918dfb54b", "input": "claim: Individuals should be able to legally bypass copyright protection technologies for fair use reasons.\n perspective: Fair use can be misused", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b9285029f9c54de5ac5e869ee2004ed0", "input": "claim: Individuals should be able to legally bypass copyright protection technologies for fair use reasons.\n perspective: Fair use is prone to abuse.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-40fc7dfc9aa446b4b7eea7e8d0915f6e", "input": "claim: Individuals should be able to legally bypass copyright protection technologies for fair use reasons.\n perspective: Fair use isn't failsafe and can be used in direct contention against the original intent of the law.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-23865044fe024247a06d3b30154863d1", "input": "claim: Individuals should be able to legally bypass copyright protection technologies for fair use reasons.\n perspective: Establishes a Clear Brightline in Favor of Data Freedom", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-44824f97cc0c4134ac25f16029ceeccf", "input": "claim: Individuals should be able to legally bypass copyright protection technologies for fair use reasons.\n perspective: Creates an easy to understand outline in support of Data Freedom.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-7d1ea3e83f6846aea391d6f10986598c", "input": "claim: Individuals should be able to legally bypass copyright protection technologies for fair use reasons.\n perspective: Provides the foundation which supports a rational set of ideas which foster an ideal in favor of Data Freedom.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-413b8a1ef11d408c8108a2eac1cd556e", "input": "claim: Remove Bush tax cuts for the wealthy.\n perspective: Expiring Tax Cuts Would Cause a Double Dip Recession", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a4d6dc77aafe49428dcf62cbec035fc7", "input": "claim: Remove Bush tax cuts for the wealthy.\n perspective: double dip recessions are caused by expiring tax cuts", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-3762d15f44554a3f84bcfb1d643e995c", "input": "claim: Remove Bush tax cuts for the wealthy.\n perspective: to avoid a double dip recession do not let tax cuts expire", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-66c3dd9980564310980a0464258b1574", "input": "claim: Remove Bush tax cuts for the wealthy.\n perspective: Removing Tax Cuts Would Reduce the Deficit", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-3b13e0af3a4d4dda96420a32bb4c09ea", "input": "claim: Remove Bush tax cuts for the wealthy.\n perspective: you can reduce the deficit by removing tax cuts", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-dc60fb6019814dff9b3f87d186a5437d", "input": "claim: ‘The Spear’ should have remained on public display.\n perspective: Public Decency", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b97071f2f56f422faa7ee6d083b68558", "input": "claim: Neil Armstrong did actually walk on the Moon.\n perspective: the USA had every incentive to lie", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-42b6a5a1aeb840b4bbe8baa75a657b79", "input": "claim: Neil Armstrong did actually walk on the Moon.\n perspective: There are problems with the pictures", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-6b8e421c8b1d4343939fa49be9d729f1", "input": "claim: Neil Armstrong did actually walk on the Moon.\n perspective: there are issues with the pictures", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-6a4eb83ffdd04655aae16da5904e2ba6", "input": "claim: Neil Armstrong did actually walk on the Moon.\n perspective: The pictures have issues", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-bc7441f8e5fd44cb98da79fd2c594979", "input": "claim: Federal States are better than unitary nations.\n perspective: Federal states are better able to protect their citizens.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-8c8e12a4b29746dc974b1c8bf88c37a1", "input": "claim: Federal States are better than unitary nations.\n perspective: Citizens are better protected in federal states.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-21c22c6789584d93aa9a8d9756ae26d9", "input": "claim: Federal States are better than unitary nations.\n perspective: Federal States often have persistent losers.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-32fbffd5521a4853a755abfc6ffc8d38", "input": "claim: Federal States are better than unitary nations.\n perspective: Losers abound in federal states.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a686121af2fb439f9de06f40ba77b000", "input": "claim: Federal States are better than unitary nations.\n perspective: Being a federal state helps large states deal with divergent economic performance", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-2b01c98af172438e96510dd53e1dfbf9", "input": "claim: Federal States are better than unitary nations.\n perspective: Federal United States are better off economically.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-4303ad3c164f446188bf9ad42a396b08", "input": "claim: Federal States are better than unitary nations.\n perspective: Federal governments often extend their powers and usurp local authority, especially if one or more federal units are disproportionately powerful.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-bdde0c7b132e42b3b5090ecd58811224", "input": "claim: Federal States are better than unitary nations.\n perspective: Federal states are economically stronger", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-b9bad2f058eb4e42b617e7b79f57a3fa", "input": "claim: Cannabis should be legalised.\n perspective: Cannabis is a gateway drug", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-fffcee47df12418cbeed2c7c3ca9cbbb", "input": "claim: Cannabis should be legalised.\n perspective: using cannabis leads to other drugs", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-3846ce57ac174c8b96ed8309c257a543", "input": "claim: Cannabis should be legalised.\n perspective: being involved with people who use cannabis exposes you to other drug use", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a4baf04b2e3d4b579ff32df85cb40f1f", "input": "claim: Cannabis should be legalised.\n perspective: Uncertainty over the effects of cannabis means it is best to be prudent", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c3da909d38ff4604ad1016956a1a08cc", "input": "claim: Cannabis should be legalised.\n perspective: before there is enough known about cannabis use it is wise to be careful", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e0b6206c9a624f788d719570ee62fa83", "input": "claim: Cannabis should be legalised.\n perspective: People should be allowed to do whatever they want to their own bodies", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-32fa9f3a1a43454cbb8d346d3a653042", "input": "claim: Cannabis should be legalised.\n perspective: Cannabis is harmful", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-83b3c51afd6f4a24bea7fa8814197f34", "input": "claim: Cannabis should be legalised.\n perspective: cannabis makes you lazy", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-154537d8a4e94e59a32a79351f0f461d", "input": "claim: Cannabis should be legalised.\n perspective: smoking cannabis keeps you from focusing", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-1351ab4161b342a3bc6f4e5b0c1630b2", "input": "claim: Cannabis should be legalised.\n perspective: Cannabis opens the mind in a positive and beneficial manner", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-7608d04caf2443c9b09eeddfde314a83", "input": "claim: Cannabis should be legalised.\n perspective: using cannabis has more benefits than not using", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d9d87a0ae4ed4b36957fc8c8e3d60f42", "input": "claim: Cannabis should be legalised.\n perspective: there are no negative side effects to the use of cannabis", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a54c090273b640b9abfe691e79840ca8", "input": "claim: Cannabis should be legalised.\n perspective: If cannabis was legalized, it could be regulated", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-31af98b358ab43c489934cebeea5b47b", "input": "claim: Cannabis should be legalised.\n perspective: If legalized it can be monitored and taxed.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-18298b17664e4c7daf08980e7f3dadba", "input": "claim: Cannabis should be legalised.\n perspective: Legal weed is subject to laws and is safer.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-4ab8c1145a69408d8c1c612e536e3116", "input": "claim: Cannabis should be legalised.\n perspective: Alcohol and tobacco are more harmful drugs, yet remain legal.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-4fe5642d66174b86a27f38bc68e65aa9", "input": "claim: Cannabis should be legalised.\n perspective: Other addictive substances are legal.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-cc3db9ff1686483dad7710a48e39b8ae", "input": "claim: Cannabis should be legalised.\n perspective: Banning weed will lead to other bans.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-24808196ea67422884cbae478c4f3017", "input": "claim: High taxes are necessary for an effective state.\n perspective: Higher taxes encourage tax avoidance", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4ba6bedefae04a569f6e59638ba285c0", "input": "claim: High taxes are necessary for an effective state.\n perspective: One problematic outcome is that higher taxes trigger tax avoidance.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a7bbcdf55f7a449db51a79399fdd8ad1", "input": "claim: High taxes are necessary for an effective state.\n perspective: The higher the taxes, the more often people will strive to dodge them. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4b944522e2bf487aada78a596d43c62e", "input": "claim: High taxes are necessary for an effective state.\n perspective: 2. No - it discourages incentive, increases dependence upon the government, and, if carried too far, impoverishes and oppresses people. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e79efd8d05254f5ca9ff9cc7ad8ac531", "input": "claim: High taxes are necessary for an effective state.\n perspective: Pays for common programs", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ed569cd5ecb344d588422a5a71847095", "input": "claim: High taxes are necessary for an effective state.\n perspective: With an increased standard of living for all the reason for crime would almost disappear.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-866e20e0e1af451ea3a0b6211e884d51", "input": "claim: High taxes are necessary for an effective state.\n perspective: People who enjoy a standard of living that allows them to be healthy and productive will decrease drug abuse.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-545ca75bb91a4ba480dc19a323a2e330", "input": "claim: High taxes are necessary for an effective state.\n perspective: Balancing governmental problems for society", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-fc7d9fc3f9064b298e418474053eef95", "input": "claim: High taxes are necessary for an effective state.\n perspective: balancing common deficits of the government for society ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-3895ba0e291a4441a549ff1e0c535c45", "input": "claim: High taxes are necessary for an effective state.\n perspective: Balancing governmental deficits for common good of society", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-0b15368ceedd400db146d65e3e716701", "input": "claim: High taxes are necessary for an effective state.\n perspective: Redistributing wealth to balance the inequality of income disparity", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-cd1971a725074d1fb0cf8dd7781172a9", "input": "claim: High taxes are necessary for an effective state.\n perspective: It is immoral that some have nothing and a few others are enormously wealthy.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d05107e0f633417c84baa52efd1d31c2", "input": "claim: High taxes are necessary for an effective state.\n perspective: Everyone should have the resources to live a healthy, productive life.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c960ce2cf1da48838688285c5aa243d0", "input": "claim: High taxes are necessary for an effective state.\n perspective: Changing the wealth around to help income disparity ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f98af5de7c294ed88f8e51db851f79cd", "input": "claim: The Catholic Church needs reform.\n perspective: It currently promotes loyalty to the institution not the laity", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-2e5645cff8b64552be1c3293006a91d3", "input": "claim: The Catholic Church needs reform.\n perspective: Currently the Catholic Chuch focuses on loyalty to the church itself, not those they serve.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-784cb73af0154023b37df1f9bc799fdf", "input": "claim: The Catholic Church needs reform.\n perspective: The Catholic Church wants loyalty to institution, not to the common man.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a774cc80135a4828a0d98649dd8cd676", "input": "claim: The Catholic Church needs reform.\n perspective: Catholicism has become too corporate", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-338613aca7ea4d08a04afcd1dfa8aff0", "input": "claim: The Catholic Church needs reform.\n perspective: Clerical rape of children is, in part, due to the celibacy of priests and must change", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-04f4e9ed1f6941dabd474d612d1cfef8", "input": "claim: The Catholic Church needs reform.\n perspective: If priests were not forced to be celibate, the issue of child rate would not be as widespread.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-0c8c7ee46f2c4e90be46f15e01b3c93b", "input": "claim: The Catholic Church needs reform.\n perspective: One of the reasons clerical child rape has happened is due to priests being forced to remain celibate.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e2cf364adda74e08a67280fbeab83c8e", "input": "claim: The Catholic Church needs reform.\n perspective: Too much responsibility on the Pope", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f328fb977d7946d0bf6aa629ff47cb3b", "input": "claim: We should build new nuclear power plants.\n perspective: Energy demands are increasing", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-88f64f6b3293453ca6b32c347530b376", "input": "claim: We should build new nuclear power plants.\n perspective: More nuclear plants are needed to deal with energy deficit concerns ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-8d014fd2572c4eb2a0b89386a128ac4b", "input": "claim: We should build new nuclear power plants.\n perspective: Nuclear energy use makes very little difference to CO2 emissions", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-865687e43e0f4351babc5ef809a7a2b2", "input": "claim: We should build new nuclear power plants.\n perspective: Nuclear energy has no impact on carbon emissions ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-98f1d543b5e64b69a14f89a5a3ee87e0", "input": "claim: Israel should recognise the Palestinian right of return.\n perspective: The Palestinian refugee crisis was created and is perpetuated by the Arab states and the Palestinians themselves", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-5eb256cc99a549ba9bd051ec84f3c15a", "input": "claim: Israel should recognise the Palestinian right of return.\n perspective: Palestinians have a right to return under international law", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e794eb886e7441f9a3672b4852644f3f", "input": "claim: Israel should recognise the Palestinian right of return.\n perspective: The right to return is granted to Palestinians under international law.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-566e79e77d6e42b099fabe17406a03f8", "input": "claim: Israel should recognise the Palestinian right of return.\n perspective: International law enables Palestinians to have the right to return.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-3d071b4a025a444b8b4228f2698e4c17", "input": "claim: Israel should recognise the Palestinian right of return.\n perspective: No real 'right of return' exists in international law", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e2b9fcb1dfdf49179b3eba6e03d31f9e", "input": "claim: Israel should recognise the Palestinian right of return.\n perspective: There really is no international law allowing for the right of return .", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-5a01aa5827924138932c77b76459fc90", "input": "claim: Israel should recognise the Palestinian right of return.\n perspective: The international law of right of return is not a true law.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4baea478984a4fea8c9f3d06e220a5d2", "input": "claim: Israel should recognise the Palestinian right of return.\n perspective: A Palestinian right of return would destroy the 'Jewish State' in Israel", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-17b20c9dc6784de5860e174a9b9b6024", "input": "claim: Israel should recognise the Palestinian right of return.\n perspective: The \"Jewish State\" in Israel would be destroyed if Palestinians were granted the right of return.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-23b0f9be879d407e8c54d0d52a4f7bcd", "input": "claim: Israel should recognise the Palestinian right of return.\n perspective: In Israel, the \"Jewish State\" would be destroyed if there is a Palestinian right of return.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-798679e1daa84a8f98b675387d6d4056", "input": "claim: Britain should give up its EU rebate.\n perspective: The rebate should go in exchange for CAP reform", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-3e01eed4091745179b13ea0efc64e6a7", "input": "claim: Britain should give up its EU rebate.\n perspective: CAP revision should be a priority trade-off for Britain's EU rebate", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-fcd9696c99154e47b90f9312463f4749", "input": "claim: Britain should give up its EU rebate.\n perspective: The Rebate makes membership acceptable to the British people", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-9cff9acac86f4f61a84e80b4bd16d7cd", "input": "claim: Britain should give up its EU rebate.\n perspective: The Rebate is essential to preserve domestic support in Great Britain.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ee91c1e5f9724b88919015841c6991f1", "input": "claim: The integration of Africa through the African Union can succeed.\n perspective: The AU can bring peace to the continent", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-8be362d08c6c4429bd41866211790269", "input": "claim: The integration of Africa through the African Union can succeed.\n perspective: African Union is promoting peace in the African continent. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-4c83458bcad6433292c98e1cc3a54f4f", "input": "claim: The integration of Africa through the African Union can succeed.\n perspective: Through the AU, there can be peace brought to the continent", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-7baf51f965e04bf6bde74701d4534447", "input": "claim: The integration of Africa through the African Union can succeed.\n perspective: One way to bring together the continent of Africa is though the AU", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e5625e3da17d4053a3a42482002d283c", "input": "claim: The integration of Africa through the African Union can succeed.\n perspective: African international organisations do not have a history of effectiveness", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ae7cba1161044014b506cf5425205404", "input": "claim: The integration of Africa through the African Union can succeed.\n perspective: Integration will fix the problem of borders", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-444685a8ddc44543a7635c2cb346e84b", "input": "claim: The integration of Africa through the African Union can succeed.\n perspective: Integration will mitigate the tension on border issues. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-94590fb94ada4b1e8db0525f2e4442a9", "input": "claim: The integration of Africa through the African Union can succeed.\n perspective: Integration of Africa solves the border issues. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d976aac1b5814765ac14c62421f9935e", "input": "claim: The integration of Africa through the African Union can succeed.\n perspective: Having integration would solve to border problem", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d9666a8ea4084f97837b1d324ab80d40", "input": "claim: The integration of Africa through the African Union can succeed.\n perspective: There would be no more border issues if there was integration", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d2eb3909ac5146fe917f08e628e3afbd", "input": "claim: The integration of Africa through the African Union can succeed.\n perspective: The role of leaders will prevent success", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b9bd1abec5664edea441923a33195570", "input": "claim: Positive Discrimination Towards Women in Society Is Justified.\n perspective: Positive discrimination towards women should not be allowed", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-119e5edbf3154f0f90fa5a21d9b27241", "input": "claim: Positive Discrimination Towards Women in Society Is Justified.\n perspective: It is Men, Not Women, who are Disadvantaged in our Society", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-680b80b2165746a2bf678c5bd30362f2", "input": "claim: Positive Discrimination Towards Women in Society Is Justified.\n perspective: Will Cause Resentment Between Men and Women", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-04811aea8fdc4cbd87cbcfee331c9872", "input": "claim: Positive Discrimination Towards Women in Society Is Justified.\n perspective: Positive discrimination towards women should be allowed", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-7ccea2a960a84c5cb3f81931f343de9d", "input": "claim: Positive Discrimination Towards Women in Society Is Justified.\n perspective: It is right to treated women differently than men in some cases. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-8b8bf4fb18304ca78240b9ecad04cb20", "input": "claim: Positive Discrimination Towards Women in Society Is Justified.\n perspective: Due to physical difference between men and women, it's ok to have some positive discrimination towards women. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d388327837874beeb1ab76d0a66024da", "input": "claim: Positive Discrimination Towards Women in Society Is Justified.\n perspective: Parliament must be representative of our society and that requires a substantial increase in the number of women which only positive discrimination can achieve", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ddf946f2f55341c3bd9f1f6535aafa64", "input": "claim: Positive Discrimination Towards Women in Society Is Justified.\n perspective: If we want Parliament to be truly representative of our society, we must use positive discrimination to increase the number of female members", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-036d91ba6a5548159a6fc280d9b82a91", "input": "claim: Positive Discrimination Towards Women in Society Is Justified.\n perspective: Female role models are needed urgently to raise aspirations among young women and change parliamentary practices", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-1b8ee3ac040948b3948a433d8481fc7b", "input": "claim: Positive Discrimination Towards Women in Society Is Justified.\n perspective: Female role models need to give hope to the desires of young women and change parliamentary practices.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-bcc7c5d26a584bd19f5792894de46590", "input": "claim: Positive Discrimination Towards Women in Society Is Justified.\n perspective: Female role models need to help young women achieve higher aspiration to change parliamentary practices.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-67ef706e516d4db087fc7f903959d339", "input": "claim: Positive Discrimination Towards Women in Society Is Justified.\n perspective: In order to change parliamentary practices it is urgent to have female role models to raise aspirations among young women.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-7ddb181c7447400bbf7546d7d3356ddf", "input": "claim: Positive Discrimination Towards Women in Society Is Justified.\n perspective: Positive discrimination for women is discrimination", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-38a999286c384f33bf91ce8976a7b3f1", "input": "claim: Positive Discrimination Towards Women in Society Is Justified.\n perspective: All-women shortlists or quotas restrict a constituent's freedom of choice", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-d7257855b2db4193965f7adcb1313fa5", "input": "claim: Positive Discrimination Towards Women in Society Is Justified.\n perspective: Positive discrimination takes away voters' freedom of choice by limiting their choices to women", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-49c8e16738344227917c07abda4a9021", "input": "claim: Positive Discrimination Towards Women in Society Is Justified.\n perspective: Women are vastly underrepresented in democratic legislatures across the world. Until 20 years ago women had never been more than 5% of MPs in UK Parliament. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-55dcf5ded1b346dcbc1c2af0b773a15a", "input": "claim: Positive Discrimination Towards Women in Society Is Justified.\n perspective: Until as recently as 20 years ago, no more than 5% of MPs in UK Parliament were female. Positive discrimination would increase that statistic", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-9c10fca3cfb74ef795ee174e507787ee", "input": "claim: Positive Discrimination Towards Women in Society Is Justified.\n perspective: You have to treat people differently in order to reach equality", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-efd4bc8434a64181bbf26251a01a8203", "input": "claim: College education is worth it.\n perspective: College graduates are more productive as members of society.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-df8b1b4e38d14c07a497c6a8baf3058b", "input": "claim: College education is worth it.\n perspective: An increase of graduates from college is beneficial to those in society who never attend college.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-95333edeaa044637adf98e1d817aef8f", "input": "claim: College education is worth it.\n perspective: Many people succeed without college degrees.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-fb815298ae7445758826a32f809e28e1", "input": "claim: College education is worth it.\n perspective: Some argue that a college education may not be necessary, since there are many people who have succeeded despite not having college degrees. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-01015e17de3d47928f8f60e2479de63c", "input": "claim: College education is worth it.\n perspective: The question of whether or not a college education is necessary for success is one that is debated, as many successful people are not college educated.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a59655ba576d4f47a055330bb9d3a655", "input": "claim: College education is worth it.\n perspective: Many college graduates are employed in jobs that do not require college degrees.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4c8fdf4ae2e34ad09dac86d2e05b18b7", "input": "claim: College education is worth it.\n perspective: Many people with college degrees find themselves working in positions in which their degrees are not a requirement. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-2afed15a52e941c197eebc1902f08b31", "input": "claim: College education is worth it.\n perspective: More and more college educated people are accepting jobs for which they do not need a college education. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-56fcbfcd59e54283aff447647b3a41ef", "input": "claim: College education is worth it.\n perspective: College exposes students to diverse people and ideas.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-53ab35ba97a846b0895d054104b01694", "input": "claim: College education is worth it.\n perspective: One of the benefits of a college education is the exposure it provides to a multitude of people and ideas.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e15d631e3acf4b3db152b7c05b1fdedd", "input": "claim: College education is worth it.\n perspective: College exposes students to a wide range of experiences and world perspectives.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a5fa8d25a19c40fdb7f0a58ab9ce862f", "input": "claim: College education is worth it.\n perspective: College graduates are more likely to have health insurance and retirement plans.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-cd2173c5027847b7baa44f98d9dbdb89", "input": "claim: College education is worth it.\n perspective: Those who graduate from college are more likely to have retirement plans and health insurance.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-4fdb80ec48304a0281d6ee6bd48101e3", "input": "claim: College education is worth it.\n perspective: Graduating from college increases the likelihood of having health insurance and a retirement plan.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-4629700af42f4bb082f87f21a16c7e42", "input": "claim: College education is worth it.\n perspective: Colleges may be indoctrinating students instead of educating them.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-6b9a53da645a432293872303855c8eef", "input": "claim: College education is worth it.\n perspective: Colleges may be brainwashing their students rather than helping them further their education.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-dababd7a3c964030b2198a8b9959ccb9", "input": "claim: College education is worth it.\n perspective: There are more students that are having their views and values shifted during college than in the past.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4a12e0a14ae34143b8627c2bd4c1153b", "input": "claim: College education is worth it.\n perspective: The children of college graduates are healthier and more prepared for school.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ed03f98efa444606bb5a66b87acec8db", "input": "claim: College education is worth it.\n perspective: College graduates tend to have healthier, better educated offspring.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-dda08d5aa5804ab78072abdc3780976b", "input": "claim: College education is worth it.\n perspective: Children are typically healthier and more studious when their parents have graduated college.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d3cdbe843fe148e0aa2cc37d17a52f57", "input": "claim: College education is worth it.\n perspective: More and more jobs require college degrees.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e57678a25f4940f985918b7a8efa2784", "input": "claim: College education is worth it.\n perspective: A college degree is required for an increasing number of jobs.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-13e2e926398d4ffcbb97ad2daa2a1288", "input": "claim: College education is worth it.\n perspective: More jobs only hire those with college degrees.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-037a7eb3a572494d8e624baab3df2a9d", "input": "claim: College education is worth it.\n perspective: Too many students earning degrees has diluted the value of a bachelor's degree.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e408fbbbef764880b4c6807087cd3f62", "input": "claim: College education is worth it.\n perspective: The value of a bachelor's degree has lessened.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-34a79e8836344bb88be17046dd9afd57", "input": "claim: College education is worth it.\n perspective: A bachelor's degree is considered standard now.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e1115e3136d74a5a951d6f1f6dd61485", "input": "claim: College education is worth it.\n perspective: College graduates have more and better employment opportunities.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-3d45e5af56094477a824e57b992c6176", "input": "claim: College education is worth it.\n perspective: Graduating from college increases employment opportunities.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-b0068c54f3cc4ecc93a357dc20f219f7", "input": "claim: College education is worth it.\n perspective: The variety and quality of employment opportunities increases for college graduates.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-661b3b9ce2f949fcbd08151397d22b8a", "input": "claim: College education is worth it.\n perspective: Earning a college degree is a major life achievement.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e72ffe53490c4646bcc1586bc6c97998", "input": "claim: College education is worth it.\n perspective: A college education is a significant accomplishment.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-45e17ad2d9bd4c5b9ca70d4425e1ca9c", "input": "claim: College education is worth it.\n perspective: One of the most important things that one can achieve in their lifetime is a college education. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f325ff4ad799484ea4bdf9b9300dc7b9", "input": "claim: College education is worth it.\n perspective: Young adults learn interpersonal skills in college.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-905892c3be2e458a9c53579cb7a09164", "input": "claim: College education is worth it.\n perspective: College imparts interpersonal skills to students.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f9264075858b4729b9f00740be34c32b", "input": "claim: College education is worth it.\n perspective: Graduating from college can keep poverty at bay.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-66883e10ed304a40af7c0d11f49bb82a", "input": "claim: College education is worth it.\n perspective: College graduates make more money.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-952a0bae2f6e4ea6b0898c116efecc9c", "input": "claim: College education is worth it.\n perspective: College graduates have lower poverty rates.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-8f00acfcc78e48d8aed0a1f2ae36c662", "input": "claim: College education is worth it.\n perspective: College graduates do better financially.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d0354aedcbfe48fbbc4a156b063f805a", "input": "claim: College education is worth it.\n perspective: People who graduate from college have more earning power.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c5fa45a4efcd4a9bb19b2edde72c7bd8", "input": "claim: College education is worth it.\n perspective: College education has a high return as an investment.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-6e687307f65c4d3c8c272bfee6396a50", "input": "claim: College education is worth it.\n perspective: Gaining a college education is money well spent. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-7e4b7fa3eb494c46a72ef0c959956e43", "input": "claim: College education is worth it.\n perspective: Earning college education is always a worthwhile investment. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-3389982d36e14c2c96528479b984df16", "input": "claim: College education is worth it.\n perspective: Learning is always worthwhile.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-9240b1d2b0f94c809bd10d03b37d8d93", "input": "claim: College education is worth it.\n perspective: Learning will always pay off. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-7c284f2be408420a8816de5f373dcaf5", "input": "claim: College education is worth it.\n perspective: Learning and education is always a good investment. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-6b7af5b97cf447c9b01f3b2eb157ecab", "input": "claim: College education is worth it.\n perspective: Many recent college graduates are un- or underemployed.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e2200bb1b62948b3a9fd84e526782dd0", "input": "claim: College education is worth it.\n perspective: In recent times, there are significant numbers of unemployed and underemployed college graduates. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-cfe735f4a5b146a2a16a07e986c437cd", "input": "claim: College education is worth it.\n perspective: Among those who are unemployed and underemployed, there are many college graduates. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-895fe52a6b1040c6a8a012f349454017", "input": "claim: College education is worth it.\n perspective: Colleges provide networking value.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-252f4b8d71b6451eb13585cf65f14a9f", "input": "claim: College education is worth it.\n perspective: Going to college provides many opportunities to network. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-31371ed938934b979896eb3dc1823b75", "input": "claim: College education is worth it.\n perspective: A college degree is no guarantee of workplace benefits.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-2a09d8c8200a44239207c0ca08395a0a", "input": "claim: College education is worth it.\n perspective: There is no guarantee there will be benefits.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ee2c8592232042efb49aa9e3ff87fbba", "input": "claim: College education is worth it.\n perspective: Learning a trade profession is a better option than college for many young adults.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-92ff2ee39f6f4569a7c0b40751a4d56a", "input": "claim: College education is worth it.\n perspective: Young adults should consider learning a trade instead of going to college.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-1debbce96d544eb4a788cb35ceb3c2c3", "input": "claim: College education is worth it.\n perspective: Trade professions are in need of more individuals and it may be more profitable than going to college.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a936c5b7db2645c4bde759f4387977d8", "input": "claim: College education is worth it.\n perspective: College graduates are healthier and live longer.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-4fdf8401725c40739bb20985959d6fe1", "input": "claim: College education is worth it.\n perspective: Health and longevity are associated with graduating from a college.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-79c79cfb75b448ba9053b8c16c4e9cde", "input": "claim: College education is worth it.\n perspective: College is an investment in health and longevity.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-3ad8bdc3fa574f2c909d307b98ea14fa", "input": "claim: College education is worth it.\n perspective: College graduates attract higher-paying employers to their communities.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-4b22c81901074d8d8c445904dc80f37e", "input": "claim: College education is worth it.\n perspective: Employers are attracted to locales with college graduates. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c8c26a7acd974a5ca3818a43a790e701", "input": "claim: College education is worth it.\n perspective: The more college graduates in one geographical area, the more higher-paying employers will be found", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-977875bd205d432aa55b9e7baaaeb065", "input": "claim: College education is worth it.\n perspective: College allows students to explore career options.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-65fd684d031e4b3e8f47b60dabe22e10", "input": "claim: College education is worth it.\n perspective: Attending college affords great chances to check out career options. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-942cbbda68a041768b5b3638ffd5407f", "input": "claim: College education is worth it.\n perspective: The total cost of going to college also includes the cost of missing opportunities to make money at a job.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e85c7c0946d74e9b9cd2ccae497c8080", "input": "claim: College education is worth it.\n perspective: College stress can lead to health problems and other negative consequences.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-df7b885fb6f247d4a7c8f4fd56111a38", "input": "claim: College education is worth it.\n perspective: College degrees do not guarantee learning or job preparation.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e04d7f80ad964335affbf83bc9eeec2a", "input": "claim: College education is worth it.\n perspective: Acquiring a degree does not guarantee you a job.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-9056db64ff7e40e9816a80c58657c7f8", "input": "claim: College education is worth it.\n perspective: We must retain a respect for academia", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-742c1a2056f74460a45624c321255c27", "input": "claim: College education is worth it.\n perspective: University education gives people something to aim for", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-cb70b52f6a6f4371913f896026fe57e6", "input": "claim: College education is worth it.\n perspective: Universities don’t have unlimited places available", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e06c933f3db045e9b0830e2eab0765b3", "input": "claim: Accessing your spouse’s email account hacking.\n perspective: Getting married is supposed to involve sharing your life with somebody", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a5123b8df9384ac1af34d8ce9e545797", "input": "claim: Accessing your spouse’s email account hacking.\n perspective: Marriage means an a voluntary equal sharing of your life with your partner.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-bdf4b0f8e9d34fe388fbb2c686160652", "input": "claim: Accessing your spouse’s email account hacking.\n perspective: In marriage, both members of the couple should be willing to share their lives.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-209e5faab95c46d4a786cf7cf8515d81", "input": "claim: Taxes on smoothies and fruit juices should be reduced.\n perspective: Removing VAT would increase sales of healthy drinks", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-116dc76846f848229c51f110d9b43277", "input": "claim: Socialism is Dead.\n perspective: Socialism was a twentieth century ideology which ran its course and ran out of steam when it became clear that Capitalism worked better", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-1dc67ea2c6574fd3b01cf02cb5715097", "input": "claim: Socialism is Dead.\n perspective: Capitalism replaced Socialism because it's the better system.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-7fe11ba2fa4b465cbd2d7069436eece7", "input": "claim: Socialism is Dead.\n perspective: Socialism died out, making way for Capitalism.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-aa0e6ebd08994a75b5aa168d79206b3f", "input": "claim: Socialism is Dead.\n perspective: Socialism has changed historically to meet the challenges of the moment and is addressing those of the 21st century in new ways", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c0508aeb4ef942faa54cd09223059bde", "input": "claim: Socialism is Dead.\n perspective: Socialism can be molded to fit the needs of the moment. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-d4feef3a773543c191d7da6decff2750", "input": "claim: Socialism is Dead.\n perspective: Socialism is a an ever changing set of principles that can be applied in new ways to meet the challenges of a changing world.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-0fdd3938a2ab47078a160b21d2b0dfe2", "input": "claim: Socialism is Dead.\n perspective: socialism have changed and adapted to meet the upcoming challenges of the 21st century", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ab3f59cc2ca143e9bd796c54ecc68a74", "input": "claim: Socialism is Dead.\n perspective: Even the leaders of the Left have given up on Socialism as a creed and have now accepted the vast majority of modern Capitalist principles", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-2492653c3cd24315be14d2354faae90d", "input": "claim: Socialism is Dead.\n perspective: Socialism is no longer seen as a viable option and even the Left has accepted that Capitalism is a better system.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-4f179d3d3bc9491f8303a4a8430b18ed", "input": "claim: Socialism is Dead.\n perspective: Capitalist principles are now being seen as a better option than Socialism even by the leaders of the Left. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c33fd93c0dd942eda9b8e201d6e8a9c6", "input": "claim: Socialism is Dead.\n perspective: even left side leaders have accepted capitalism pirnciples and have given up on socialism as a creed", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a0aa720c34944ad19a0b46dc975282fa", "input": "claim: Socialism is Dead.\n perspective: Even the left fielders are now accepting capitalist principles over socialism in term of real way of life", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ed957824e34d46e59f0fa1a94bf02713", "input": "claim: Socialism is Dead.\n perspective: Globalisation has made socialism impractical to implement", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-0ddd69bb3fc84361a32c9c1d7972c98a", "input": "claim: Socialism is Dead.\n perspective: Incentive in form of profit benefits society as a whole", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-0f9561df712d40bd965e39e12f6ab107", "input": "claim: Socialism is Dead.\n perspective: Socialism is a more secure system than the free market in Capitalism", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-322caf1dc3a345f6b4e3d7c329055e8d", "input": "claim: Socialism is Dead.\n perspective: Socialism outranks capitalism in security.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c32cb6e117e14c5eb7274b761cdea1b7", "input": "claim: Socialism is Dead.\n perspective: Capitalism is less secure than socialist systems. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c63479af4408423c99e54e33eff29443", "input": "claim: It is crucial to explore the universe.\n perspective: It is a moral imperative to constantly seek to expand the boundaries of knowledge", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-4776237d78c44b73b23835fd4b410cc6", "input": "claim: It is crucial to explore the universe.\n perspective: State-sponsored space programs can utilize the infrastructure built up in the last half-century, and therefore be substantially cheaper", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f6d67ef2018a4b3693eb537f2b3f7705", "input": "claim: It is crucial to explore the universe.\n perspective: Space exploration leads to technological advancement", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-6ad02e44aa3f41b1bb5a131158c31974", "input": "claim: It is crucial to explore the universe.\n perspective: Space exploration takes resources away from more worthy causes", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b8a476c972704a2cb59f98ba34ed3456", "input": "claim: It is crucial to explore the universe.\n perspective: there are other issues to worry about", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-7aaab99f31ef4d0ab43765cb29e77faa", "input": "claim: It is crucial to explore the universe.\n perspective: The cost of space exploration exceeds the positive benefits", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-8c65894f6ada48199bbd93b20eb43979", "input": "claim: It is crucial to explore the universe.\n perspective: Space exploration is too expensive to have many positive benefits.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4ce94bf701b24a2fbbe62391e969a233", "input": "claim: It is crucial to explore the universe.\n perspective: While there are some benefits, space exploration has too high a cost", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-af48c3325704481a8cb472eb0f453aa7", "input": "claim: It is crucial to explore the universe.\n perspective: The 'space race' fuels nationalistic sentiment and antagonism", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c32c950b148c4ae0bc2cd8126308893b", "input": "claim: It is crucial to explore the universe.\n perspective: Nationalistic sentiment and antagonism are fueled by the 'space race.'", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-6f067eb28fc64d09bd28a32d4519cb79", "input": "claim: It is crucial to explore the universe.\n perspective: Nationalistic sentiment (and antagonism) is powered by the space race.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-8e2e36d3be5b4efb930a7e73406d6b0b", "input": "claim: It is crucial to explore the universe.\n perspective: Space exploration has improved communications on Earth", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e23be0ef702348a7994a6ab2148b08b6", "input": "claim: The International Criminal Court is a force for good.\n perspective: The ICC does not have enough checks on prosecutorial powers, inviting prosecutorial abuse.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4ec8ff7e8c5e4b52821fb1085c88b179", "input": "claim: The International Criminal Court is a force for good.\n perspective: The prosecutorial abuse potential is high, due to its lack of checks on its power.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-35486dd027784f7cbfa3c3d206150d27", "input": "claim: The International Criminal Court is a force for good.\n perspective: The ICC needs more checks on its prosecutorial authority in order preclude abuse of power.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b90e7527f3244e819f44385544ea575c", "input": "claim: The International Criminal Court is a force for good.\n perspective: The ICC is not democratic in nature and is likely to be used as a political tool by powerful nations.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-00a7cac132ca4fb7981fbd9a9d5199e4", "input": "claim: The International Criminal Court is a force for good.\n perspective: The EU has a high potential to be used as a political ploy as it is not known for its democracy.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-705166c3e89c4592a76cff0ba9d23412", "input": "claim: The International Criminal Court is a force for good.\n perspective: The ICC is mainly not a democratic institution, thereby allowing for political malfeasance.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-33636c076ccd498a83fa0b2ca6bb002f", "input": "claim: The International Criminal Court is a force for good.\n perspective: The ICC interferes with national operations (both military and humanitarian) because of how loosely the Rome Statue can be interpreted.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-155e4fcd7f73474daab8c46f0a137646", "input": "claim: The International Criminal Court is a force for good.\n perspective: The ICC impedes a nation's core operations as as Rome Statue is not rigid in its interpretation", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-52e917d9d270490b8f75bb1d579b92e4", "input": "claim: The International Criminal Court is a force for good.\n perspective: The Rome Statute of the ICC hinders national operations due to its wide flexibility.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-5d732a914b644553808ab26c16ace9f5", "input": "claim: The International Criminal Court is a force for good.\n perspective: The ICC infringes upon national sovereignty by inherently implying that there is a higher court nations must answer to.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-fb154d6c735b4e27bd85f4c9fdca1bbe", "input": "claim: The International Criminal Court is a force for good.\n perspective: The ICC's criminal court marginalizes individual national courts.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c1f03fb26ecf40219bf0b92c168bd0ed", "input": "claim: The International Criminal Court is a force for good.\n perspective: The ICC messes up national independence by marginalizing individual member courts.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-1cf2144c07cc497aa7ec8c34188edfd4", "input": "claim: Governments Should Pay Compensation For Terrorist Atrocities Carried Out By Their Citizens.\n perspective: Set up an international fund to pay compensation ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-af1f6bb5376c4ca591d20789536ef50e", "input": "claim: Governments Should Pay Compensation For Terrorist Atrocities Carried Out By Their Citizens.\n perspective: Governments in countries where terrorism is prevalent should allocate tax dollars to a pool to compensate nations that have been victims.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-863d52f57b75461bad785a42113c1623", "input": "claim: Governments Should Pay Compensation For Terrorist Atrocities Carried Out By Their Citizens.\n perspective: The UN should allocate a fund to compensate nations that have been victims of terrorism.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-011aeaab77d8416e81f2eaf68abd594e", "input": "claim: Voting should become compulsory.\n perspective: Policing and financing the system is unmanageable", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-1f38ba28f25a42349fd27c8bbb972968", "input": "claim: Voting should become compulsory.\n perspective: It would be extremely difficult to police and finance mandatory voting.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-6808401611074353a0a31a50e2c42f8c", "input": "claim: Voting should become compulsory.\n perspective: It is unreasonable to expect that compulsory voting could be financed and verified.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e7594ee060f64f648aa4fa123b76b35c", "input": "claim: Voting should become compulsory.\n perspective: Voting is a civic duty", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-8f7cc8641d5a43cdba54ebf635a5b9eb", "input": "claim: Voting should become compulsory.\n perspective: A true democratic mandate for the government", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-22e9b6ad3069416e99badf107461c134", "input": "claim: Voting should become compulsory.\n perspective: Voting is the duty of every individual in a democratic society.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-26bcbfd35c044600b56ee69487b61ee9", "input": "claim: Voting should become compulsory.\n perspective: It is the duty of every citizen to vote.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-61039e0324644f869745d3a93410d59d", "input": "claim: Voting should become compulsory.\n perspective: There are alternatives that tackle the real causes of voter disengagement", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-00945696c6624d6fb5d0493192c4e743", "input": "claim: Voting should become compulsory.\n perspective: Compulsory voting broadens representation of disadvantaged groups", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-b793244f33454bbb9ff513a5c7dd3bf5", "input": "claim: Voting should become compulsory.\n perspective: Disadvantage groups are better represented when voting in mandatory.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-6c4dde53ee854f5ea1f02641d6668ece", "input": "claim: Voting should become compulsory.\n perspective: By making voting mandatory, disadvantaged groups improve their representation.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d4e2bd28a3ad4644a5f4f26e8119bc16", "input": "claim: Voting should become compulsory.\n perspective: It will cause more people to become interested in politics", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-0f9058aac8094b758026e2e456f2d3f6", "input": "claim: Voting should become compulsory.\n perspective: Cause more people to become interested in politics", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-06d1e12d480b4cebb22a27ce34e42a74", "input": "claim: Voting should become compulsory.\n perspective: Compulsory voting has been implemented successfully.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-31f081a981184da48a12d88904570716", "input": "claim: Voting should become compulsory.\n perspective: There is precedent to compulsory voting working.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-27c94b2d5a6f43ceb69a640235b4a99e", "input": "claim: Voting should become compulsory.\n perspective: Other places have successfully introduced compulsory voting.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-8145965e027641e8a6e99fee5c837f8f", "input": "claim: Voting should become compulsory.\n perspective: It will reduce the power of special interest groups", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-523e6718259f4e3ca7ca8b1ac70b333d", "input": "claim: Voting should become compulsory.\n perspective: Convincing is more effective than forcing.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-abb82a732150487aade417917c002ba2", "input": "claim: Voting should become compulsory.\n perspective: You can persuade to vote but you can't force someone to do it.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e693ef379e324f7299dde5d227e4f065", "input": "claim: Voting should become compulsory.\n perspective: People rebel from rules and do what they want anyway", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-648d3b8435c04c00afbf381d1ba19532", "input": "claim: Voting should become compulsory.\n perspective: People forced to vote are unlikely to vote intelligently.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-22bc65e607cd4b69ba2038ce4faec8ed", "input": "claim: Voting should become compulsory.\n perspective: If people are forced to vote, they will not have the information needed to vote intelligently.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-1d1c45fb17a943f98961a886036da091", "input": "claim: Voting should become compulsory.\n perspective: A vote cast by someone who does not want to vote is unlikely to be based on careful consideration.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-dab1a597543f45458675a7cd2c09d027", "input": "claim: Voting should become compulsory.\n perspective: It's a model that works", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-8fcb04beeeee4abdac6a97bc3a7cbcc9", "input": "claim: Voting should become compulsory.\n perspective: The right not to vote", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-5ca50a0baf24477b8abefaa0752f5803", "input": "claim: Voting should become compulsory.\n perspective: Compulsory Voting Does not enhance democracy", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-f9e82765fd194c1e98ec9cc3dc889d57", "input": "claim: Voting should become compulsory.\n perspective: Democracy is based on the freedom to vote or not.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a79d223a27804f06a3114ede57a2ccae", "input": "claim: Voting should become compulsory.\n perspective: People can only make free choices if they want to, not because the state makes them", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-16cde9f129f84b2ba81b06978c0eb764", "input": "claim: Voting should become compulsory.\n perspective: Why should anyone bother to vote when politicians do whatever they want?", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ff066b1a65f74f2cbfb7526f758e3020", "input": "claim: Voting should become compulsory.\n perspective: Once elected, politicians do what they want, so why vote?", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-257b1802ce694f79824afaa2e833ba22", "input": "claim: Voting should become compulsory.\n perspective: Voting does not make sense as a rewardable/punishable action.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-eedc0eb4bad14cc59f8594b5fc8dcd75", "input": "claim: Voting should become compulsory.\n perspective: Rewarding or punishing someone for voting is nonsensical.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-80bd86ecc6f54e7aad2986095b9e4957", "input": "claim: Voting should become compulsory.\n perspective: Voting should be neither rewarded or punished.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a9b2cf8754bd43f0a999938293e7a5fe", "input": "claim: Voting should become compulsory.\n perspective: Weekend voting would be a more sensible solution", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-6902356ef61048f08be3bd911cd0aa38", "input": "claim: Speed limits should be reduced.\n perspective: Reducing speed reduces deaths", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-10224bd164294aa68671772776bda2c9", "input": "claim: Speed limits should be reduced.\n perspective: slower speeds prevent death", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-da5afc2be598420895974dbde3992100", "input": "claim: Speed limits should be reduced.\n perspective: the slower the speed, the less death", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-37fd60900855499db8e0741159df3cb6", "input": "claim: Speed limits should be reduced.\n perspective: By reducing speeds, you can also reduce deaths", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-1af9d75191db470e9584c60cf015829f", "input": "claim: Speed limits should be reduced.\n perspective: With reduced speed comes reduced deaths", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-251f1a91b7e24006a33568230c71a18e", "input": "claim: Speed limits should be reduced.\n perspective: Negative impact on the environment ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-085a4de8527b48fc8429726ff0356fb3", "input": "claim: Speed limits should be reduced.\n perspective: High tax on cars is not value for money if you have to drive at a snail's pace", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-8e135144854d4ae0882d24821b26ced8", "input": "claim: Ban junk food from schools.\n perspective: Schools should educate about healthy choices, not make them on the students’ behalf.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-cc969d59cce14669bcb83bc23d0edf20", "input": "claim: Ban junk food from schools.\n perspective: Students should be educated to make healthy dietary choices.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-6650067cef504e6a81583f4a1a4f579e", "input": "claim: Ban junk food from schools.\n perspective: schools should educate on health", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-0166c6fe05264242a1d2e44037469e3d", "input": "claim: Ban junk food from schools.\n perspective: Students should not be forbidden from eating certain foods, they should be educated about them.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c938e28337014266be2243b6ea18af3d", "input": "claim: Ban junk food from schools.\n perspective: schools should educate the masses on healthy choices", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-59e153b6404b476daf8a86079cc220b4", "input": "claim: Ban junk food from schools.\n perspective: Better nutrition leads to better students.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-8374265b68a94061bf27e50106f0fd86", "input": "claim: Ban junk food from schools.\n perspective: Good food is better for students", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-456bc4562a904526b1745d46ce55855d", "input": "claim: Ban junk food from schools.\n perspective: Good food helps create better students", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-111e1d4877f34a5db85aced82c5ea958", "input": "claim: Ban junk food from schools.\n perspective: Better nutrition leads to more productive students.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c475884a32e24a94b655425a67823a99", "input": "claim: Ban junk food from schools.\n perspective: Better nutrition leads to a better student body. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-5dcdcfb6a0374d20ba073982355995f9", "input": "claim: Ban junk food from schools.\n perspective: A healthy diet starts from home and starts early. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-94d2ec2e18254a1e91df097f111b185c", "input": "claim: Ban junk food from schools.\n perspective: Schools are the best place to create lasting lifestyle changes.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a90a6f125e6d4aa6b1eb5dbd09f26149", "input": "claim: Ban junk food from schools.\n perspective: Schools are the best at changing lifestyles", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d1bb2c2b90174d029e96beb412a53cec", "input": "claim: Ban junk food from schools.\n perspective: Schools set the foundation for life", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-7e0cf4abfdb24d848603d91d882ede64", "input": "claim: Ban junk food from schools.\n perspective: Schools are the best place to create lasting positive habits. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-43f927a5adfb46ffa08a329786cc3ae2", "input": "claim: Ban junk food from schools.\n perspective: Schools are the best place to implement long lasting lifestyle changes. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c5787e6303b44f3a9118bac3d8dfc32a", "input": "claim: Ban junk food from schools.\n perspective: Habits Are Often Formed During Childhood And It's Important To Ensure That Kids Eat A Healthy Diet In School", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-14011f2ac8d54d9c8dc573ad8a8848e9", "input": "claim: Ban junk food from schools.\n perspective: Bans On Junk Food Have Been Successful", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d00a92f789ca498ab2a914618444684f", "input": "claim: Ban junk food from schools.\n perspective: Start your children early on the habit of good healthy food and it will stay with them throughout their lives. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f9149948e1ee489fa370e17f1f6b293d", "input": "claim: Ban junk food from schools.\n perspective: Pupils will bring unhealthy food with them to schools. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ae036ff23b694ccc99d78889d44277e5", "input": "claim: Ban junk food from schools.\n perspective: If \"junk food\" is banned, students will simply bring their own food to school.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-9dca88e0fe174b5eb8e4e2330c28bce7", "input": "claim: Ban junk food from schools.\n perspective: Banning \"junk food\" is not the answer because then students will simply bring their own \"junk food\" from home.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e5b028f88b7546e9b22c2597de19120c", "input": "claim: Ban junk food from schools.\n perspective: “Junk food” sales are an important source of funding for schools. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-aa6766aaa8d54508a65ec746064bc35d", "input": "claim: Ban junk food from schools.\n perspective: The sale of \"junk food\" items provide vital financial assistance to schools.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-3d6782a8a1844bda9fc1f0542f49773b", "input": "claim: Ban junk food from schools.\n perspective: \"Junk food\" revenues provide schools with much needed financial assistance.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-0dbf4452265c42ff9368c6e169a83cc8", "input": "claim: Ban junk food from schools.\n perspective: Junk Food Can Increase The Risk Of Diabetes", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-576a3016e57440f2b860b5db0eac3d08", "input": "claim: Ban junk food from schools.\n perspective: Eating junk food can make it more likely to receive a diagnosis of diabetes.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ab81e9306039465a9d34c8b5efed2e2a", "input": "claim: Ban junk food from schools.\n perspective: Junk Food Can Cause Obesity", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e0d47e103f02432fb9552033304ab596", "input": "claim: Ban junk food from schools.\n perspective: Eating junk food leads to obesity.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-52bd1ee4ec4d4b9c979918cfc5c71323", "input": "claim: Ban junk food from schools.\n perspective: Obesity is caused by junk food.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-6be37f8d793b4492b38f3b969ed1be2f", "input": "claim: Ban junk food from schools.\n perspective: Unhealthy Food May Be Bad For Brain Function", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a83ffcc450944fcf915b6931d9df4838", "input": "claim: Ban junk food from schools.\n perspective: Junk food can hinder the brain's performance.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-9cbd2e6621c042be9f033d88c848452b", "input": "claim: Ban junk food from schools.\n perspective: Brain function is inhibited by unhealthy foods.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-12272a7dae714ee99113b789b874d276", "input": "claim: Ban junk food from schools.\n perspective: Banning Junk Food In Schools Could Decrease The Frequency Of Heart Disease", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-5c4cf4902408435a8c6d8664ba130a6b", "input": "claim: Ban junk food from schools.\n perspective: Heart disease can be caused by junk food.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-822e1756d6914d9f98544bb14b1c92ff", "input": "claim: Ban junk food from schools.\n perspective: The frequency of heart disease in schools could be lowered by banning junk food.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ce444d1ebe2d4d829618be61f0c886da", "input": "claim: Ban junk food from schools.\n perspective: Junk Food Can Have Negative Affects On Bone Health", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e6f26840ab0544c3a901287872f8e9b4", "input": "claim: Ban junk food from schools.\n perspective: Eating junk food can be detrimental to bone health. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-25d9ca44db0e4d70849418c6b14280f0", "input": "claim: Ban junk food from schools.\n perspective: Junk food has been associated with poor bone health. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-38c13d60c1b14bac8126d37712fb8ad7", "input": "claim: Throw Russia out of the G8.\n perspective: The biggest action the west can take without sanctions", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-36ee5d4d5af1415fad2ed6fa8a3e27b5", "input": "claim: Throw Russia out of the G8.\n perspective: Simply narrows the G8 making it irrelevant", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4c2aac0696b745218e351d4cd53ebf47", "input": "claim: Arming the police is a good idea.\n perspective: It is hypocritical and will not benefit civilians", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-2480cd0ef76d4e108b92ee809332eac8", "input": "claim: Arming the police is a good idea.\n perspective: Innocent people are always going to be a factor in arming a police force.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a5dea68d85204bbe934d95dc08188ee0", "input": "claim: Arming the police is a good idea.\n perspective: When the police are armed, mistakes will lead to innocent people getting shot", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-9dfe4e9dd60444779b1b40d34566b1fe", "input": "claim: Arming the police is a good idea.\n perspective: Arming the police will cause an escalation in criminal violence", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-aa78b5fdd3864150a1b38d034e3c058d", "input": "claim: Arming the police is a good idea.\n perspective: Policing is a dangerous job. Police officers should be allowed to arm themselves", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ac169bd2a3174861afafca67bca06601", "input": "claim: Arming the police is a good idea.\n perspective: If the police are not armed, only the bad guys will have guns.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-71965f3e40da4f81bf64a137ecae092c", "input": "claim: Arming the police is a good idea.\n perspective: An armed police force will deter criminal behaviour", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-9a2ca7e16f5c4c74bae6b17b7060ed62", "input": "claim: Arming the police is a good idea.\n perspective: Arming the police makes communities feel safer", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-038d9b65803b422089a81bb67fe76713", "input": "claim: Arming the police is a good idea.\n perspective: Everyone saw the extent of damage caused several years ago when the Hollywood, CA police department was completely outgunned. The police had to break into a gun store to get better fire power. Many lives could have been saved if they had the proper fire power in the first place.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d71c13f87dd84613b96aa3e85885624f", "input": "claim: Arming the police is a good idea.\n perspective: Arming the police is a necessary step", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-98403954d7be4a01b4bcfbfe19e61efb", "input": "claim: Arming the police is a good idea.\n perspective: It is never a good idea when the police force is out gunned by the criminals.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-dc511633cf5f4d41939586a44444ba80", "input": "claim: Arming the police is a good idea.\n perspective: One of the first principals of defense is to have superior resources. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-909a5258e45547fea51498f1e46ef34e", "input": "claim: Arming the police is a good idea.\n perspective: The police should be equipped to react to contemporary social problems", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-01ca57b4987c4d989035478d52b6b6dc", "input": "claim: Arming the police is a good idea.\n perspective: Arming the police does not deal with the causes underlying violence", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-8fa05b0a2b6649b8b44eb980a9fe0138", "input": "claim: Arming the police is a good idea.\n perspective: Just because police have weapons, it doesn't mean the main issues of violence are being dealt with.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4ac39d9252aa44e08b2e1a4231b0ac1f", "input": "claim: Arming the police is a good idea.\n perspective: arming police will not help", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e012de7bbb9042b780105231eccb26ba", "input": "claim: Arming the police is a good idea.\n perspective: Arming the police will do more harm than good", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-1abc6119ecf644b49c4f6a4672dfbd96", "input": "claim: Science can determine human values.\n perspective: Science can't produce faith.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c1637811fa394c7fa5910aeccb229cf3", "input": "claim: Science can determine human values.\n perspective: Science can produce practical solutions and propose new policies to improve overall happiness.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-45f58f90a5da4f50b7095fa322ed9b70", "input": "claim: Science can determine human values.\n perspective: Science can measure and analyse the effect of certain moral behaviour on others.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-0a002046d93340fab5c5a022ea4c2973", "input": "claim: Science can determine human values.\n perspective: Science shouldn't be prescribing what we do.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ed5b017119a94d3baa00f66a550d97d0", "input": "claim: Science can determine human values.\n perspective: Science can't have a spiritual aspect.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-207b346049f341bcbc45ec4f11d5d60e", "input": "claim: Science can determine human values.\n perspective: Spirituality has no place in science.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4b985b1f96b24454a8728f7c56b24db9", "input": "claim: Science can determine human values.\n perspective: Science and spirituality do not go hand in hand. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-9d58e2ee7ca74c6b9bb1bab4880110ac", "input": "claim: Arranged marriages in EU countries should be banned.\n perspective: It’s impossible to police such a law.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b460ed09c37b426ea231f6906e743862", "input": "claim: Arranged marriages in EU countries should be banned.\n perspective: The police cannot enforce the law.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-132d3911d60d46a1bcc9875b95024b33", "input": "claim: Arranged marriages in EU countries should be banned.\n perspective: Regulating arranges marriages in EU countries would be impossible.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-f789eb54d3ea4dc79ef2fb9d2b8e79e5", "input": "claim: Arranged marriages in EU countries should be banned.\n perspective: It would be impossible to enforce a ban on arranged marriages in EU countries.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-9725819898c4423e8365e32f2703f89d", "input": "claim: Arranged marriages in EU countries should be banned.\n perspective: The state should not be allowed to intrude in such personal matters", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-33586252ee154c7d86d71687c0728479", "input": "claim: Arranged marriages in EU countries should be banned.\n perspective: The state should not regulate such personal matters. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-823fe6e0cdd14d39ae579d413f8898f5", "input": "claim: Arranged marriages in EU countries should be banned.\n perspective: Personal matters should not be regulated by the state", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-bde941cb60ad4b75aead7268fb526b60", "input": "claim: Arranged marriages in EU countries should be banned.\n perspective: Arranged marriages remains a personal choices and as such shouldn't be banned by the state.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-7f629a848a4e466ab768d685b5e6c74c", "input": "claim: Arranged marriages in EU countries should be banned.\n perspective: It will cause resentment and make certain communities feel targeted. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-0b4e510a3e72424ab10f16da8883cc84", "input": "claim: Arranged marriages in EU countries should be banned.\n perspective: To ban arranged marriages in EU countries would initiate resentment from certain communities.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-0b7cea52144a4ae08e4bd29dcd4097ea", "input": "claim: Arranged marriages in EU countries should be banned.\n perspective: Several communities in EU countries would feel targeted and begin to resent authorities should arranged marriages be banned.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ca3ee0b27c014c5a8a9fa9112c64372b", "input": "claim: Arranged marriages in EU countries should be banned.\n perspective: Integration and the acceptance of Western values are important", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-13678fbee15043058a9671857d74f162", "input": "claim: Arranged marriages in EU countries should be banned.\n perspective: The ban will give powers to police to crack down on the murky underworld of forced marriages", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-1e03a27a8e99458d87b4b4c88ad74777", "input": "claim: Arranged marriages in EU countries should be banned.\n perspective: Forced marriage is a barrier to integration", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-7efdcd6e3309485bbe490717d68bba24", "input": "claim: There is life after death.\n perspective: Life after death is strongly stated in the bible.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-839e41bd4c334bb1b4dd60e7b86ad758", "input": "claim: There is life after death.\n perspective: The bible states that there is life after death.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f23f053c4f514c99a9562714999e9426", "input": "claim: There is life after death.\n perspective: There is with certainty a Heaven and Hell.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-315af184a48d4533beaaecc30eab4f3b", "input": "claim: There is life after death.\n perspective: There is a Heaven and there is a Hell.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-9331fcb3e9b24e58b762c22dbb766d6c", "input": "claim: There is life after death.\n perspective: yes there is a heaven and a hell", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-fc62ecc75b4048b29340548bebaff82d", "input": "claim: There is life after death.\n perspective: My strong belief is that Heaven and Hell exist.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-0609903fd5ef480db1c94d9f2cfef0dd", "input": "claim: There is life after death.\n perspective: There definitely exists a Heaven and Hell.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-23c776fd10de4602baa63b4fbc2ee026", "input": "claim: The drinking age should be lowered from 21 to a younger age.\n perspective: The right to drink should have a higher age of initiation because of the dangers posed by drinking.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-3fa34fe23323448e991dc35a22f0ba47", "input": "claim: The drinking age should be lowered from 21 to a younger age.\n perspective: The American public overwhelmingly supports MLDA 21.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-9a9ba649be4f42b09fe7c718e8ce841e", "input": "claim: The drinking age should be lowered from 21 to a younger age.\n perspective: Lowering the drinking age will invite more use of illicit drugs among 18-21 year olds.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ed9b5b39dcec46ae8cce952c49b73af7", "input": "claim: The drinking age should be lowered from 21 to a younger age.\n perspective: State governments should have the right to establish a lower legal drinking age that reflects their unique demographics, legal context, and history.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-6edd860f309c4bd997190285ecc73031", "input": "claim: The drinking age should be lowered from 21 to a younger age.\n perspective: Lowering MLDA 21 to 18 will irresponsibly allow a greater segment of the population to drink alcohol in bars and nightclubs, which are not safe environments.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-d0d9135f6cdf4e4d83a93992021c7f8c", "input": "claim: The drinking age should be lowered from 21 to a younger age.\n perspective: Lowering the drinking age would allow younger people to go to more unsafe places.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4ef9b3e048a849dd83d8e53f164d2841", "input": "claim: The drinking age should be lowered from 21 to a younger age.\n perspective: MLDA 21 helps prevent underage binge drinking.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4825696167184c70a5a8c5590e1ee5ba", "input": "claim: The drinking age should be lowered from 21 to a younger age.\n perspective: they drink anyway why not let them do it legaly", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a92604316d8b4003b7ce8cdda2b3b01d", "input": "claim: The drinking age should be lowered from 21 to a younger age.\n perspective: MLDA 21 is largely ineffective because teens consume regardless.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-4952735c0229429599aa2ed2c6f9d927", "input": "claim: The drinking age should be lowered from 21 to a younger age.\n perspective: Kids will drink when they want, making it legal will reduce petty crimes.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-4b6c8507809f4554a6c0feb1ce22f512", "input": "claim: The drinking age should be lowered from 21 to a younger age.\n perspective: Kids aren't waiting until 21 now, they already don't care about the law.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-efac23229e9e47e1893b4b48e7ef0dd2", "input": "claim: The drinking age should be lowered from 21 to a younger age.\n perspective: Allowing 18- to 20-year-olds to drink alcohol in regulated environments with supervision would decrease unsafe drinking activity.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-7c11b4a135894a0cb4947f36fcf69803", "input": "claim: The drinking age should be lowered from 21 to a younger age.\n perspective: The MLDA should stay at 21 because people tend to be more mature and responsible at 21 than 18.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-64c976a9122c47fc9fe66ed1cbcb0928", "input": "claim: The drinking age should be lowered from 21 to a younger age.\n perspective: Lowering MLDA 21 would be medically irresponsible.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-115f1cc71bcc4570b8bf75caef7ad439", "input": "claim: The drinking age should be lowered from 21 to a younger age.\n perspective: Lowering the drinking age is a bad idea.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-27edcbe0f60040589126c0d9b8e29bb5", "input": "claim: The drinking age should be lowered from 21 to a younger age.\n perspective: MLDA 21 exerts valuable social pressure on potential underage drinkers and those who may serve them.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-669788ace4b846858318039366136b7a", "input": "claim: The drinking age should be lowered from 21 to a younger age.\n perspective: Lowering MLDA 21 would give high schoolers and even middle schoolers easier access to alcohol.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-dde74f6bcad84117abb0ecac098bf1ac", "input": "claim: The drinking age should be lowered from 21 to a younger age.\n perspective: Lowering MLDA 21 would be good for the economy.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-216beb78ab3c4daeaf1b21c0985ea4cf", "input": "claim: The drinking age should be lowered from 21 to a younger age.\n perspective: MLDA 18 is not a right. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-948d48feae0e49b581bc50db374f9aa7", "input": "claim: The drinking age should be lowered from 21 to a younger age.\n perspective: It is not a right to drink when you are 18 years old.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-195ad78de2ed44a68805dfba68459244", "input": "claim: The drinking age should be lowered from 21 to a younger age.\n perspective: There are fewer drunk driving traffic accidents and fatalities in many countries with MLDA of 18.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-fa3b25ed6cbb49fcb9b3734ef6a6a832", "input": "claim: The drinking age should be lowered from 21 to a younger age.\n perspective: Young adults drinking could cause more problems in the future", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-555555bc16b44501823bd0c8687572ee", "input": "claim: The drinking age should be lowered from 21 to a younger age.\n perspective: If you can fight for your country in Iraq, why can't you have a beer?", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-6667ad6a2ffa4cd9a754d43557da4f5f", "input": "claim: The drinking age should be lowered from 21 to a younger age.\n perspective: If you can die for your country, you should be trusted to drink. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e14f8d6a2ede4decb3930e6f47b9020c", "input": "claim: The drinking age should be lowered from 21 to a younger age.\n perspective: The drinking age should be 21 years of age.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b9f08c8273f547bb9fc232013e3dc975", "input": "claim: The drinking age should be lowered from 21 to a younger age.\n perspective: 21 years old should be the drinking age.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-5cce8e1cd0564e19ad4a41d6c75e8a15", "input": "claim: The drinking age should be lowered from 21 to a younger age.\n perspective: People can not be allowed to drink until they are 21.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-cf5d16153a0a45a8865eb8a486912935", "input": "claim: The drinking age should be lowered from 21 to a younger age.\n perspective: Young adults in college won't get in trouble with the law", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-dce107ea9de741c0af8fc7df2084db07", "input": "claim: The drinking age should be lowered from 21 to a younger age.\n perspective: Lowering the age will cut down on young adults drinking", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-6e1e635cb7f244c7a0defe8aff202780", "input": "claim: The drinking age should be lowered from 21 to a younger age.\n perspective: Lowering the age to drink will make it less interesting since everyone can do it.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-aa272c0553fe47698c9d578f3edcbe4f", "input": "claim: The drinking age should be lowered from 21 to a younger age.\n perspective: Use reverse psychology on kids to remove the appeal of drinking. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-b5e5285faf0d44cfbce872f83919691e", "input": "claim: The drinking age should be lowered from 21 to a younger age.\n perspective: If you can drive a lethal weapon (moterized vehicle) why cant you drink?", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a02a8c837709456c948789bead8ff18d", "input": "claim: The drinking age should be lowered from 21 to a younger age.\n perspective: you can vote at 18 why cant you drink?", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-dc3ff6d23495422da05ed508f0d24596", "input": "claim: The drinking age should be lowered from 21 to a younger age.\n perspective: Being an adult at 18 should be all encompassing across society, including drinking.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-12be3f2a58cf48dda8109c51dcf8d345", "input": "claim: College football should replace the bowl championship series (BCS).\n perspective: The proposed playoff system alternatives are actually less fair than the BCS system in place.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-cdf1354554db4fa7a827dd047e280c15", "input": "claim: College football should replace the bowl championship series (BCS).\n perspective: The BCS rankings are designed to favor consistency over the course of the entire season.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-6a84556f91d0427d94e353e89daf7467", "input": "claim: College football should replace the bowl championship series (BCS).\n perspective: A playoff system would not mean the end of the BCS rankings, which could still be used to determine the top 4, 8, 12, or 16 teams, depending on how many playoff games are feasible.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-4c687f263a0e4ceb8e682035beedd47b", "input": "claim: All drugs should be decriminalised.\n perspective: In addition to our first argument: There is no legal bar on the purchase of alcoholic drink and cigarettes, though both are often addictive ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-27b06a4b165141d18ea9b831b9dc2d09", "input": "claim: All drugs should be decriminalised.\n perspective: In addition to our fourth argument: Decriminilisation of drugs will diminish organised crime ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d28b706dd5074f65afcc8c7a388ce7fc", "input": "claim: All drugs should be decriminalised.\n perspective: Decriminilisation of drugs will diminish organised crime ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-b4684df8f41540869b135ca208a104aa", "input": "claim: All drugs should be decriminalised.\n perspective: In addition to our third argument: Individuals should be free to do whatever they like with themselves as long as this harms no one else", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-fff3be5020d74f849bf746a32b8db4da", "input": "claim: All drugs should be decriminalised.\n perspective: Individuals should be free to do whatever they like with themselves as long as this harms no one else", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ab3aa600c4e04744806413bf0f5f5c95", "input": "claim: Pensions should be privatised.\n perspective: Government pension schemes are not a viable or sustainable option.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-17cc6ee30b2441df8246e7dc7de5f6b3", "input": "claim: Pensions should be privatised.\n perspective: senior citizens should not and cannot be exposed to such naked risk on moral grounds", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-f58c09465ccb4dd29e3fe48d52c58140", "input": "claim: Pensions should be privatised.\n perspective: Private Enterprise is more suited to long-term planning and sustainability", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-1a03fb85291c4a4c9a5c6f942399acc7", "input": "claim: Pensions should be privatised.\n perspective: Private Enterprise demonstrates a greater capacity for dealing with long term planning and viable continuity over time.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-812714c4021b449583c0108a3b844cf1", "input": "claim: Pensions should be privatised.\n perspective: Private Business is more inclined towards future planning and sustainability.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-9c495aa231cb4430824a4bfb239dfd1e", "input": "claim: Pensions should be privatised.\n perspective: State involvement in pensions is deleterious to both pensioners and the state.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-780cfa91483c44c6a0dadbb7e7323bd8", "input": "claim: Pensions should be privatised.\n perspective: Government is fundamentally unsuited to running pension schemes.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-bb11aa9c8e434f698d56e39ef67238f0", "input": "claim: Pensions should be privatised.\n perspective: Historical evidence has shown that privatisation has been unsuccessful", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-9e1cac07bfed43b3b8e9e2531d84e7a7", "input": "claim: Parents have to be allowed to monitor their children's online and mobile communications.\n perspective: Monitoring raises digital awareness among parents.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-344a69d2379048cd8ac7bcf996e14429", "input": "claim: Parents have to be allowed to monitor their children's online and mobile communications.\n perspective: Monitoring children's use of electronics raises digital awareness.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-26b074cb13f448bc82d63abf1b639b6d", "input": "claim: Parents have to be allowed to monitor their children's online and mobile communications.\n perspective: Children's internet use should be monitored.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-30dbad17fb5249708f132cd76eea89c5", "input": "claim: Parents have to be allowed to monitor their children's online and mobile communications.\n perspective: Monitoring decreases children’s involvement with pornography. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-38889d264a304665b3cdcb734a3bd972", "input": "claim: Parents have to be allowed to monitor their children's online and mobile communications.\n perspective: Parents can determine which websites children visit.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-173be0ca513a467dad17f58480b2c6e0", "input": "claim: Parents have to be allowed to monitor their children's online and mobile communications.\n perspective: It should be acceptable for parents to prevent children from visiting pornographic websites. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-196d0726d049412c85e409b3c0150c5c", "input": "claim: Parents have to be allowed to monitor their children's online and mobile communications.\n perspective: Monitoring prevents cyberbullying.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-5a80010d48254d4485c08a339baa602c", "input": "claim: Parents have to be allowed to monitor their children's online and mobile communications.\n perspective: Cyberbullying may be reduced by parents' monitoring children's online communications. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c71a5e7716e64f94952d05ae0d2c266d", "input": "claim: Parents have to be allowed to monitor their children's online and mobile communications.\n perspective: Monitoring allows parents to correct children who are wasting their time. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-75e72fddeb3e412caeabfb8cc0ae7c30", "input": "claim: Parents have to be allowed to monitor their children's online and mobile communications.\n perspective: Parents can monitor whether children are use time online effectively.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-638b3b53f1cc42c3b9b4064e83be7b3a", "input": "claim: Parents have to be allowed to monitor their children's online and mobile communications.\n perspective: Parents can make sure children aren't wasting their time online. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-9017882c92814e979f1a0ab0f70773d4", "input": "claim: The national curriculum should be scrapped.\n perspective: The National Curriculum sets standards for the Teaching Learning Programme", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-83cd6cd7fbcf4007902f1d717940ba60", "input": "claim: The national curriculum should be scrapped.\n perspective: The National Curriculum does not provide personalised learning since it is an instrument of mass instruction.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a25caa376d214ff7ad22e27b8b2a63e6", "input": "claim: The national curriculum should be scrapped.\n perspective: The National Curriculum is the product of a factory system designed for a world that no longer exists.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-9050e5c3ebb84065b16827026fed08de", "input": "claim: The national curriculum should be scrapped.\n perspective: The national curriculum is capable of substantial improvement", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-f8674aa6d7d541b4bb2e3a0eeebc89b7", "input": "claim: The national curriculum should be scrapped.\n perspective: The National Curriculum has stifled creativity (the generation of ideas) and innovation (the addition of value).", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-0af92db302e24ef08be163c7183e2399", "input": "claim: The national curriculum should be scrapped.\n perspective: The National Curriculum provides reference points of achievement for parents and government.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-9497b9d00eb641659a740852d815c60f", "input": "claim: You have nothing to worry about surveillance if you have done nothing wrong.\n perspective: No one will ever actually look at the information", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-b6e0e77fb8b843adbc1920dc70872a8a", "input": "claim: You have nothing to worry about surveillance if you have done nothing wrong.\n perspective: Lack of trust", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-14f5f45b86d44a71939789a2ee08298b", "input": "claim: You have nothing to worry about surveillance if you have done nothing wrong.\n perspective: There is no trust", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a2623d7bc0ab4736aab7eae5601b7b94", "input": "claim: You have nothing to worry about surveillance if you have done nothing wrong.\n perspective: Trust is missing.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-fc76cc82baf94a4d91db43620dea7933", "input": "claim: You have nothing to worry about surveillance if you have done nothing wrong.\n perspective: There are safeguards to prevent misuse", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-0c7044db4b164eafb83a133a1dad5453", "input": "claim: You have nothing to worry about surveillance if you have done nothing wrong.\n perspective: The use of meta data causes unintentional harm", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-dfc66c15d1a14df1aebb98a944e0505e", "input": "claim: You have nothing to worry about surveillance if you have done nothing wrong.\n perspective: Abuse of information and power by intelligence agencies", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-2e904fe91c094bb3897b59d3c5f088a9", "input": "claim: You have nothing to worry about surveillance if you have done nothing wrong.\n perspective: Agencies use surveillance to abuse their power.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a51d98107464451c846621084269595f", "input": "claim: You have nothing to worry about surveillance if you have done nothing wrong.\n perspective: Loss of Privacy", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a09617065a19402987416d0d88d6b7fe", "input": "claim: You have nothing to worry about surveillance if you have done nothing wrong.\n perspective: People will lose their privacy.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-2b8964a05907480e93aa0fd4d561cdc8", "input": "claim: You have nothing to worry about surveillance if you have done nothing wrong.\n perspective: Privacy will go away.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-972ae70f078348708d738de401f4a799", "input": "claim: You have nothing to worry about surveillance if you have done nothing wrong.\n perspective: information gathered used to fight terrorism", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-12827d04dbf5419d84d36d2773e614e8", "input": "claim: You have nothing to worry about surveillance if you have done nothing wrong.\n perspective: information gathered can be used to fight terrorism .", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-32fd1b00aecb45098793c7bc7722aea0", "input": "claim: You have nothing to worry about surveillance if you have done nothing wrong.\n perspective: information gathered can be used to fight against radical terrorists. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-09e70434b8ce4d2ea6b30d4fdbddc1e0", "input": "claim: Institute a mandatory retirement age.\n perspective: Western workers are remaining healthier for longer", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-1a592d0d155e4d9bb6fe49eb3649454e", "input": "claim: Police body cameras should be allowed.\n perspective: Police body cameras invade the privacy of citizens, expose victims and witnesses of crimes, and damage police-public relationships.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e03f9e33d6174e10bb316bc3678d30fc", "input": "claim: Police body cameras should be allowed.\n perspective: What risks are there to individuals if police wear body cameras.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4db339c4cf3840cfbafadfc3b79f861e", "input": "claim: Police body cameras should be allowed.\n perspective: Explanation of police body camera effects.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-7c6cef24cdac4578a5bc1184e3de0bd9", "input": "claim: Police body cameras should be allowed.\n perspective: Police body cameras improve police accountability and protect officers from false accusations of misconduct", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ef5c705a71e34662a235cf4716d48a1f", "input": "claim: Police body cameras should be allowed.\n perspective: Police Body Cameras allow true facts to come out in alleged cases of Police misconduct", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-63d9b3209f2d4f94b52b18b9aaf41031", "input": "claim: Police body cameras should be allowed.\n perspective: Police officers are more accountable when wearing body cameras", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-63a4f22ef5374c4facc18267cf807535", "input": "claim: Police body cameras should be allowed.\n perspective: Police body cameras are too expensive and are unreliable.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-fa9c56b9a0f44c3bb53aa5e67004d486", "input": "claim: Police body cameras should be allowed.\n perspective: Police body cameras increase the safety of the public and the police", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-14ff3935dd6e47beac5a1d992ad300c4", "input": "claim: Police body cameras should be allowed.\n perspective: Police Body Cameras ensure safer interactions between the Police and the public", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-408c41e4209a44a29e1a453c3f9ce5ac", "input": "claim: Police body cameras should be allowed.\n perspective: Police body cameras decrease the safety of police officers and negatively affect their physical and mental health.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-f7f2beade14d4a63af5edb117971ebb4", "input": "claim: Police body cameras should be allowed.\n perspective: What are the negative effects of police body cameras.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-295e6ea4b4ad49aab1f9604a41bf215e", "input": "claim: Police body cameras should be allowed.\n perspective: Police body cameras are a good tool for learning and have strong support from members of the public.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-14d14a20fa5a4afc8b1a384eb8adcd11", "input": "claim: Police body cameras should be allowed.\n perspective: Will police body cameras teach police anything.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-3d14ce8e06d74c02a0f5b70933d8cc48", "input": "claim: We should restrict violent video games.\n perspective: Violent video games desensitise users", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-16c4920c93e9463dbf7c04c723caaa2e", "input": "claim: We should restrict violent video games.\n perspective: Violent games normalizes forms of violence.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-2cfeed2cc1d34564a8a80a49020abc25", "input": "claim: We should restrict violent video games.\n perspective: Restrictions would be ineffective", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-fd0e8c1d73ba4192a620db0c01dc4210", "input": "claim: We should restrict violent video games.\n perspective: Restricting video games only makes people more interested in them. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-7223bb6a505e476ab4e8b93440e63c61", "input": "claim: We should restrict violent video games.\n perspective: Restricting violent video games will have no correlation to a reduction in societal crime.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-cfbb100214184684a813ea6c28fff870", "input": "claim: We should restrict violent video games.\n perspective: Playing violent video games leads to violent behaviors.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-8a97c5957a3a452580a706bf059f83c5", "input": "claim: We should restrict violent video games.\n perspective: people immitate video games.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c7308f9cd3144ae0b1059635dd13cd25", "input": "claim: We should restrict violent video games.\n perspective: violent games make people agressive.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-704c63e11af2451bac4ab9e29e2d6e08", "input": "claim: We should restrict violent video games.\n perspective: Research has shown violent video games encourage criminal and anti-social behaviour", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e0bae08f85a3407f98a5be8beaeaf136", "input": "claim: We should restrict violent video games.\n perspective: Violent Video Games cause Violent Behaviour", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f8e345a01cc341b792b3c8af86ad1bfd", "input": "claim: We should restrict violent video games.\n perspective: The government has a right to restrict the sale of violent video games, in order to protect law and order.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-4f3e828c01fc49b1ad3f26090e56ac18", "input": "claim: We should restrict violent video games.\n perspective: In order to maintan a well funcitoning society, the government has a right to restrict violent games which could hurt people.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-5ddd2368009f452da30f169df5dee9f1", "input": "claim: We should restrict violent video games.\n perspective: Video games are content that has a right to be censored for the mass majority's public safety.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-bc7de22ac1934d83b82e77ae7942f0da", "input": "claim: We should restrict violent video games.\n perspective: The Responsibility Lies With Parents", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-de14ba2e208440cc896845b9f09af16c", "input": "claim: We should restrict violent video games.\n perspective: Violent Video Games Cause Social Interaction Problems", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-94f00c6bac7e47ea8662c18a48c6af8b", "input": "claim: We should restrict violent video games.\n perspective: Violent video games lead to inappropriate social interactions.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d374500f6e4742b5b75f8b84158bbf25", "input": "claim: We should restrict violent video games.\n perspective: Violent video games are detrimental to social interaction.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a0ce5eed80884229921584b4f1d00af9", "input": "claim: We should restrict violent video games.\n perspective: Gun violence is less prevalent in countries with high video game use.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ca1afedff2b945efad3b6583bb8a64bc", "input": "claim: We should restrict violent video games.\n perspective: Countries with high video game use see less gun violence", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c1f0e6cb92984aba884a8f34e22ae204", "input": "claim: We should restrict violent video games.\n perspective: Studies have shown that violent video games can have a positive effect on kindness, civic engagement, and \"prosocial” behaviors.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-8077312993ee4016a0df658d138d590d", "input": "claim: We should restrict violent video games.\n perspective: Violent video games have been shown to have positive effect on kindness and cooperative behavior.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-1219f1f1150a4046a0ab262f3958add4", "input": "claim: We should restrict violent video games.\n perspective: Violent video game players know the difference between virtual violence in the context of a game and appropriate behavior in the real world.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-20e4dbe59d68427cb4aeba27532e2e63", "input": "claim: We should restrict violent video games.\n perspective: There are many flaws to the theory that violent video games cause real life violence.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c586f3a356e641509d065f226b982bd7", "input": "claim: We should restrict violent video games.\n perspective: Studies claiming a causal link between video game violence and real life violence are flawed.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-266dac62ad6a45bfb983cc0ff17e0a12", "input": "claim: We should restrict violent video games.\n perspective: Playing violent video games does not cause kids to commit mass shootings.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-bd88d9c94d794332b7eabd16100065da", "input": "claim: The use of animals as objects of sport and entertainment should be banned.\n perspective: Fighting bulls have a better quality of life than meat-producing bulls", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-47c4f4659aa44a3993efd618152b0343", "input": "claim: The use of animals as objects of sport and entertainment should be banned.\n perspective: Blood sports cannot be justified by reference to their role in pest control or conservation", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-b9252eaeb5264fbb948a45ce7c628339", "input": "claim: The use of animals as objects of sport and entertainment should be banned.\n perspective: Blood sports are not justified by their role in pest control or conservation.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-0c4ab72c72c941af94f828505c570e1a", "input": "claim: The use of animals as objects of sport and entertainment should be banned.\n perspective: The need for pest control or conservation does not justify blood sports. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-b0092a795af64c1fa0dfab2dfc110ee0", "input": "claim: The use of animals as objects of sport and entertainment should be banned.\n perspective: Pest control or conservation arguments does not rationalize our use of animals as objects in blood sports.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-02ac0a4c70c94f3789d5e051eec0ead4", "input": "claim: The use of animals as objects of sport and entertainment should be banned.\n perspective: The use of animals as objects in blood sports cannot be justified by the week argument that it provides benefit through pest control or conservation.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c82f1ddb25f741fb9d6e8e910e3ec7c6", "input": "claim: The use of animals as objects of sport and entertainment should be banned.\n perspective: Treating animals as property prevents them from being perceived as part of the moral community", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-528981b57d71490e92e4f6367261469a", "input": "claim: The use of animals as objects of sport and entertainment should be banned.\n perspective: When animals are treated as property it prevents them from being perceieved as part of the moral community. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-7a1a9df934594cf49a92b3b6832ec32b", "input": "claim: The use of animals as objects of sport and entertainment should be banned.\n perspective: Animals are not percieved as part of the moral community when they are treated as property.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-5bcf34a27f9a4dc484b81db24d1f00e5", "input": "claim: The use of animals as objects of sport and entertainment should be banned.\n perspective: Objectifying animals enables people to absolve themselves from their moral treatment.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-40ac2349e00b40b8bbe9220490f545fe", "input": "claim: The use of animals as objects of sport and entertainment should be banned.\n perspective: Animals should not be treated as objects or property as doing so allows them to be treated amorally.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-9530a4d76039405cb2632da9bca01149", "input": "claim: The use of animals as objects of sport and entertainment should be banned.\n perspective: Animals are harmed when used as objects of entertainment, no matter how innocent that entertainment is", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-896c06e81ee34e46be24ed07993540d0", "input": "claim: The use of animals as objects of sport and entertainment should be banned.\n perspective: All uses of animals for entertainment harm the animals.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-8f9db29f276c4e31a53f4a44d0f1ab0d", "input": "claim: The use of animals as objects of sport and entertainment should be banned.\n perspective: Even the most innocent of entertainment using animals harms the animals.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-1205d06e7242471db9f52ed12dac9b42", "input": "claim: The use of animals as objects of sport and entertainment should be banned.\n perspective: Animals as entertainment is always harmful to the animals", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-fff906dab9ba44d08b31fda13690ba98", "input": "claim: The use of animals as objects of sport and entertainment should be banned.\n perspective: It is not possible to harmlessly have animals as entertainment", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-84d68656a4204735b38e3cfa59fc04e4", "input": "claim: The use of animals as objects of sport and entertainment should be banned.\n perspective: The use of animals in sport demeans humans", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-26184d88e8f64e628d81b6e099b0c90b", "input": "claim: The use of animals as objects of sport and entertainment should be banned.\n perspective: The use of animals in sport is demeaning to humans. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-85a805ffc24c45ed913020c368496121", "input": "claim: The use of animals as objects of sport and entertainment should be banned.\n perspective: The devaluation of animals as an object of sport, devalues life including human life.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-27982c3d42a64c3fa455ccdb11acdafa", "input": "claim: The use of animals as objects of sport and entertainment should be banned.\n perspective: Humans ultimately devalue their own lives when using animals as objects of sport.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-8ba24ccc157f49ffb3d3ad0256c4f078", "input": "claim: The use of animals as objects of sport and entertainment should be banned.\n perspective: Bullfighting is too dangerous to humans to justify", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ebb902acef674c59b99867c995ea2307", "input": "claim: The use of animals as objects of sport and entertainment should be banned.\n perspective: Bullfighting is dangerous for humans and should be banned.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c548cb53cf374d56a3dc5f70a472ab8c", "input": "claim: The use of animals as objects of sport and entertainment should be banned.\n perspective: We must ban bullfighting to keep humans from recklessly getting injured and even dying.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a71bf20370c247aaae65a8fce4658154", "input": "claim: The use of animals as objects of sport and entertainment should be banned.\n perspective: Harming animals for entertainment is immoral", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ff32b2997e364be5bdc983feffbdecf0", "input": "claim: The use of animals as objects of sport and entertainment should be banned.\n perspective: It is not moral to hurt animals for entertainment", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c067fcbbbc3d4b9f93ff8ca94ef5b512", "input": "claim: The use of animals as objects of sport and entertainment should be banned.\n perspective: Hurting animals for fun is immoral", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-4aa6c4c50d294bb19e1a53da96bc2131", "input": "claim: The use of animals as objects of sport and entertainment should be banned.\n perspective: Bullfighting is a form of animal torture", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-27b1febaa2b84302aac2c42c8b97e37e", "input": "claim: The use of animals as objects of sport and entertainment should be banned.\n perspective: Bullfighting is animal torture", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ab11b2f1853143e696178089ab4df660", "input": "claim: The use of animals as objects of sport and entertainment should be banned.\n perspective: One form of animal torture is bullfighting", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-6d5622c310c84c84a730064cd5579334", "input": "claim: The use of animals as objects of sport and entertainment should be banned.\n perspective: Bullfighting should be treated like other forms of animal torture", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-10288a9dbc7c4eba882012584bc1c0f4", "input": "claim: All nations should ban bullfighting.\n perspective: Bullfighting is too dangerous to humans to justify", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-8e4d237bba5f44a896fe1e33d4158633", "input": "claim: All nations should ban bullfighting.\n perspective: Bullfighting is dangerous for humans and should be banned.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-28b66802455749f6bfa92a77ef92db93", "input": "claim: All nations should ban bullfighting.\n perspective: We must ban bullfighting to keep humans from recklessly getting injured and even dying.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-3667ab345bc14302b976409581406c91", "input": "claim: All nations should ban bullfighting.\n perspective: Harming animals for entertainment is immoral", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-dd5ae889638540fcb38c3c5a11cb8ab2", "input": "claim: All nations should ban bullfighting.\n perspective: It is not moral to hurt animals for entertainment", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-bb63e8f7974f4d32bec9b45c97de95f4", "input": "claim: All nations should ban bullfighting.\n perspective: Hurting animals for fun is immoral", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-297412cbe7c4428c9d7aa4aa23d0a5d9", "input": "claim: All nations should ban bullfighting.\n perspective: Bullfighting is a form of animal torture", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-592a0d48711d4aa8b2dea61466baf742", "input": "claim: All nations should ban bullfighting.\n perspective: Bullfighting is animal torture", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-5ca31e819ff846479d37afac43518e5d", "input": "claim: All nations should ban bullfighting.\n perspective: One form of animal torture is bullfighting", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-67bddece4ca04fb9b3d786b17d2b2ab6", "input": "claim: All nations should ban bullfighting.\n perspective: Fighting bulls have a better quality of life than meat-producing bulls", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-f717c7244f214740ac21e7ff4ba0ae12", "input": "claim: All nations should ban bullfighting.\n perspective: Blood sports cannot be justified by reference to their role in pest control or conservation", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-35ca104c5dae4034a77a643bb8c274ca", "input": "claim: All nations should ban bullfighting.\n perspective: Blood sports are not justified by their role in pest control or conservation.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-202cf432f918489f9571a5927a115660", "input": "claim: All nations should ban bullfighting.\n perspective: The need for pest control or conservation does not justify blood sports. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-513175a495004306a7904b4ca7560d2a", "input": "claim: All nations should ban bullfighting.\n perspective: Pest control or conservation arguments does not rationalize our use of animals as objects in blood sports.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-8454fc6c4ec141b6a78bc71292f73631", "input": "claim: All nations should ban bullfighting.\n perspective: The use of animals as objects in blood sports cannot be justified by the week argument that it provides benefit through pest control or conservation.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-7009aca4792a4bc5a561eebe69fbeded", "input": "claim: All nations should ban bullfighting.\n perspective: Treating animals as property prevents them from being perceived as part of the moral community", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-14af8e65c64c447195a6d1861151e34c", "input": "claim: All nations should ban bullfighting.\n perspective: When animals are treated as property it prevents them from being perceieved as part of the moral community. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-b431449e65a44f7e9fda1a734eb816d6", "input": "claim: All nations should ban bullfighting.\n perspective: Animals are not percieved as part of the moral community when they are treated as property.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-baa39b393bd146f6880b601e59b4ca2e", "input": "claim: All nations should ban bullfighting.\n perspective: Objectifying animals enables people to absolve themselves from their moral treatment.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ca04e36794644721a2ae8c3399f1a2cd", "input": "claim: All nations should ban bullfighting.\n perspective: Animals should not be treated as objects or property as doing so allows them to be treated amorally.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-1095752488f24204aaaea3ab4ad1b3f6", "input": "claim: All nations should ban bullfighting.\n perspective: Animals are harmed when used as objects of entertainment, no matter how innocent that entertainment is", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-53c32032746a4bdba31a8d194cb27db3", "input": "claim: All nations should ban bullfighting.\n perspective: All uses of animals for entertainment harm the animals.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e2439e76ca2a46eaa5e8bf39ade0c337", "input": "claim: All nations should ban bullfighting.\n perspective: Even the most innocent of entertainment using animals harms the animals.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-1691865e3a4f4860a0d15f61cd29047d", "input": "claim: All nations should ban bullfighting.\n perspective: Animals as entertainment is always harmful to the animals", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-6b0e12319096445ba1571b9336880630", "input": "claim: All nations should ban bullfighting.\n perspective: It is not possible to harmlessly have animals as entertainment", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-880f96624bb5491eada3e69595bdf13f", "input": "claim: All nations should ban bullfighting.\n perspective: The use of animals in sport demeans humans", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-25ef5dd61d304d009d2d049c40be905b", "input": "claim: All nations should ban bullfighting.\n perspective: Using animals in sport demeans humans. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-4fa5c60764204a32a59b8655f35744c4", "input": "claim: All nations should ban bullfighting.\n perspective: The use of animals in sport is demeaning to humans. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a6003f27210c4865b18ef5b297a07612", "input": "claim: All nations should ban bullfighting.\n perspective: The devaluation of animals as an object of sport, devalues life including human life.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-22249d3d87e34b4cb0657d1784557ff5", "input": "claim: All nations should ban bullfighting.\n perspective: Humans ultimately devalue their own lives when using animals as objects of sport.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-bbcd78efc52e4828a94bbaece0a98ca1", "input": "claim: Christmas is a scam.\n perspective: Not a proper holiday", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-58e8bac345dd47aa8bc3b61b02b04ff9", "input": "claim: Christmas is a scam.\n perspective: There are many opinions about Christmas as a holiday. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a3412714bfb64bf0ac14e03a7d189b99", "input": "claim: Christmas is a scam.\n perspective: Many people believe that Christmas is a holiday. Many people think of it as a scam. Who is right?", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-3bd7cb3d688341caa273719ac9ca0c7d", "input": "claim: Christmas is a scam.\n perspective: It's not a true holiday.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-933f7d66b89a49e8aa627dd1fba28edf", "input": "claim: Christmas is a scam.\n perspective: It's not a real holiday.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-fb1b46921d8340f3869b48516702886e", "input": "claim: Christmas is a scam.\n perspective: Christmas is too commercial and people have forgotten what it is really about", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c1085895670e4485a755df178e71466c", "input": "claim: Christmas is a scam.\n perspective: Christmas is about family and generosity, not buying things.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-b648228fea9e4f6ea5f9390bd2274ae5", "input": "claim: Christmas is a scam.\n perspective: Christmas is more important than presents!", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-791e67696248410680891b8ddb881cd9", "input": "claim: Christmas is a scam.\n perspective: The spirit of Christmas moves us to give and presents are an expression of that spirit.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-1168f28730184576865f6641933d2e8e", "input": "claim: Christmas is a scam.\n perspective: Commerce is Necessary for Holidays and Festivals", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-96e559f8b3eb410a9214344c6a5ff1c1", "input": "claim: Christmas is a scam.\n perspective: Without commerce our holidays and festivals would cease to exist.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-878539ca67f64f979b712e52ab99cdb7", "input": "claim: Christmas is a scam.\n perspective: Commercialization effectively spreads the culture of holidays and festivals.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e203fb7778c14386b3e1f70a09057d7b", "input": "claim: Christmas is a scam.\n perspective: Jesus is Becoming Irrelevant to Christmas", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d164df65822a48f78bd2cad8c15910e8", "input": "claim: The Falklands should be given back to Argentina.\n perspective: Simply put, the Islanders strongly wish to remain British. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a5ea6346ef814c4ab4a8b31058797b34", "input": "claim: The Falklands should be given back to Argentina.\n perspective: The Falkland Islanders do not speak Spanish and WANT to be part of the UK", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b29b2531b49e4468b0dd44929d409801", "input": "claim: Increased taxes are good for America.\n perspective: 2. No - it discourages incentive, increases dependence upon the government, and, if carried too far, impoverishes and oppresses people. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-0e9d31a496ea4f7ea7e5361599206adb", "input": "claim: Increased taxes are good for America.\n perspective: Higher taxes encourage tax avoidance", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-2a41ba1999594883b9e10d1f537f0504", "input": "claim: Increased taxes are good for America.\n perspective: One problematic outcome is that higher taxes trigger tax avoidance.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-be497f4ed3e84869ac26fbd552f04cbd", "input": "claim: Increased taxes are good for America.\n perspective: The higher the taxes, the more often people will strive to dodge them. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-79525e5252c0457ca5f3a18e79eedb3e", "input": "claim: Increased taxes are good for America.\n perspective: Pays for common programs", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-912130ac6b6d4cf8922e80c72cd82c52", "input": "claim: Increased taxes are good for America.\n perspective: With an increased standard of living for all the reason for crime would almost disappear.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-b895545f649d4e0da9b096249a313567", "input": "claim: Increased taxes are good for America.\n perspective: People who enjoy a standard of living that allows them to be healthy and productive will decrease drug abuse.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a6d414796c7744869b195637273d0da3", "input": "claim: Increased taxes are good for America.\n perspective: Balancing governmental problems for society", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-872e2a2c58ef406c83f3321f9ce55223", "input": "claim: Increased taxes are good for America.\n perspective: balancing common deficits of the government for society ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-466cbd23193c4667abe7bd26186640b2", "input": "claim: Increased taxes are good for America.\n perspective: Balancing governmental deficits for common good of society", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-3c11c27900234961b6c5adb113474ed4", "input": "claim: Increased taxes are good for America.\n perspective: Redistributing wealth to balance the inequality of income disparity", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d20d0dd4af014a8593c6bde3a79ce216", "input": "claim: Increased taxes are good for America.\n perspective: It is immoral that some have nothing and a few others are enormously wealthy.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-101b50de848841528d47f28dc65ec611", "input": "claim: Increased taxes are good for America.\n perspective: Everyone should have the resources to live a healthy, productive life.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-939570f9bfa04bdb929ad57f295a67c7", "input": "claim: Teachers Should Have The Right To Punish Pupils Physically If The Parents Consent.\n perspective: Parental consent would create two 'classes’ of pupil.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e9c1bd6cee844a4b9b7c653a6853a372", "input": "claim: Teachers Should Have The Right To Punish Pupils Physically If The Parents Consent.\n perspective: The other options to discipline pupils are not helpful.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-86eb0d4ae80f46dbb33da0d85dbf9987", "input": "claim: Teachers Should Have The Right To Punish Pupils Physically If The Parents Consent.\n perspective: Corporal punishment is the appropriate discipline for certain children when used in moderation.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-6b514fe8fa9f41528a2b7fa42289f853", "input": "claim: Teachers Should Have The Right To Punish Pupils Physically If The Parents Consent.\n perspective: used in moderation corperal punishment can be appropriate for certain children", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-85d42f9a0c75499e962bf13af81302f9", "input": "claim: Teachers Should Have The Right To Punish Pupils Physically If The Parents Consent.\n perspective: certain children can appropriately be diciplined by corpral punishment", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-2c55f41493d544e2a5910bd6c41e2df3", "input": "claim: Teachers Should Have The Right To Punish Pupils Physically If The Parents Consent.\n perspective: Corporal punishment creates an unsafe and violent school environment.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-15968e49e7f64a32974b4b6367122725", "input": "claim: Teachers Should Have The Right To Punish Pupils Physically If The Parents Consent.\n perspective: an unsafe and violent school environment is the affect of corporal punishment", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-fdd92d61efec49ec90920b4f6b2777fa", "input": "claim: Teachers Should Have The Right To Punish Pupils Physically If The Parents Consent.\n perspective: corporal punishment will negatively affect the school experience for chiildren", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-d0188c3e2f2a43bf9fdb8138503b090f", "input": "claim: Teachers Should Have The Right To Punish Pupils Physically If The Parents Consent.\n perspective: Corporal punishment is an inappropriate punishment that harms the education of children.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-7d75fcfcdf99467f9600522d38a3ee69", "input": "claim: Teachers Should Have The Right To Punish Pupils Physically If The Parents Consent.\n perspective: the education of children will be hindered by corporal punishment", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-7d4f7cdabadf4e78a474d91158b7bcc8", "input": "claim: Teachers Should Have The Right To Punish Pupils Physically If The Parents Consent.\n perspective: it is inappropriate to use corporal punishment on children as it can affect their education", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-69774b0bc43d4b13b220b1ec7bfca485", "input": "claim: Teachers Should Have The Right To Punish Pupils Physically If The Parents Consent.\n perspective: Corporal punishment sets clear boundaries and motivates children to behave in school.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-18dd7d6169c84b52ba8221c798f577b5", "input": "claim: Teachers Should Have The Right To Punish Pupils Physically If The Parents Consent.\n perspective: the clear boundaries set by corporal punishment can promote children behaving in school.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-170d0755e1e549fbbb59828b679c8791", "input": "claim: Teachers Should Have The Right To Punish Pupils Physically If The Parents Consent.\n perspective: to motivate children to behave in school try corporal punishment", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-6d29a17b90064dc68073dd19f2bae89b", "input": "claim: Teachers Should Have The Right To Punish Pupils Physically If The Parents Consent.\n perspective: Corporal punishment can inflict long-lasting physical and mental harm on students.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-8bc77354486f4a4c95344ba1c75a2c63", "input": "claim: Teachers Should Have The Right To Punish Pupils Physically If The Parents Consent.\n perspective: long lasting physical and mental harm can be caused by corporal punishment", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-568afc67c8bd465c9a400a95491eea03", "input": "claim: Teachers Should Have The Right To Punish Pupils Physically If The Parents Consent.\n perspective: by using corporal punishment you can cause serious mental and physical damage", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-19606600273e49f48d8a2ae899734495", "input": "claim: Treat the desecration and destruction of high-value sites and property of cultural heritage as a crime against humanity.\n perspective: Making destruction of cultural property a crime against humanity would ensure it is protected.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-eb295edb7547416f8718adf2a257a9e6", "input": "claim: Treat the desecration and destruction of high-value sites and property of cultural heritage as a crime against humanity.\n perspective: Our world cultural heritage is extremely important and its destruction would constitute a crime against humanity. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-bc9d6a5ea8fe43f2b6e190c877a645ee", "input": "claim: Teachers must be banned from interacting with students via social networking websites.\n perspective: The law would violate freedom of speech and association. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-69d140f124fa4a2982cf8e6e2bbb5827", "input": "claim: Teachers must be banned from interacting with students via social networking websites.\n perspective: Banning electronic use would violate freedoms.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-477f2a29b55a495d96276cf31e9d4d3d", "input": "claim: Teachers must be banned from interacting with students via social networking websites.\n perspective: Freedoms would be limited with this law.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c1c349032eb64f1985941d47998b1444", "input": "claim: Teachers must be banned from interacting with students via social networking websites.\n perspective: It is easy to act in an inappropriate manner with electronic communications.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c3c77997a8104c96b31aa77d09517d61", "input": "claim: Teachers must be banned from interacting with students via social networking websites.\n perspective: Electronic communication facilitates sexual misconduct. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-4a7aa12e55774991ac97d6677582df2d", "input": "claim: Teachers must be banned from interacting with students via social networking websites.\n perspective: Social media enables \"sexting,\" which can lead to criminal charges and the unexpected proliferation of personal images.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-240029b4f03b4e0ea17536d6f70c7c94", "input": "claim: Teachers must be banned from interacting with students via social networking websites.\n perspective: Many young people talk sexually through social media.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-0f78911571994e87961334d1e9bbb314", "input": "claim: Teachers must be banned from interacting with students via social networking websites.\n perspective: If you are not careful, sexting can be a start of criminal activity.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-cd4c110f79d340a4b4d5193ae7d28e90", "input": "claim: Teachers must be banned from interacting with students via social networking websites.\n perspective: More educational resources can be made available through social media.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-90ca9efd3b634eb28bbb57d053c728b1", "input": "claim: Teachers must be banned from interacting with students via social networking websites.\n perspective: Social media provides academic research to a wider audience, allowing many people access to previously unavailable educational resources.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-995c9850ed6741af917e61e337725b6d", "input": "claim: Teachers must be banned from interacting with students via social networking websites.\n perspective: Social media can be powerful educational resources. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-dc5abc0d6716462bb4a46c42ba705043", "input": "claim: Teachers must be banned from interacting with students via social networking websites.\n perspective: Social medica can act as an educational tool.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c7652be0bff445989440af2c9d4d6d93", "input": "claim: Teachers must be banned from interacting with students via social networking websites.\n perspective: Social media can lead to stress and offline relationship problems.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ab26dfe4cf9246a79cdbc9d46580d75a", "input": "claim: Teachers must be banned from interacting with students via social networking websites.\n perspective: Social media sites often lead to relationship problems and other stress in real life.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-fb8ee65e350547feb2fad0edb1126f96", "input": "claim: Teachers must be banned from interacting with students via social networking websites.\n perspective: Social media has been linked to stress and problems in personal relationships in the real world.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-2967b50ffb80478699ea0805bc9d22bf", "input": "claim: Teachers must be banned from interacting with students via social networking websites.\n perspective: Using social media can harm students' chances for college admission.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-5c775e4398ff4ce6b05d8637c0bb5616", "input": "claim: Teachers must be banned from interacting with students via social networking websites.\n perspective: Social media use can harm students' chances to be admitted to colleges", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d40f5ed8d72c4f72b159110878ee1415", "input": "claim: Teachers must be banned from interacting with students via social networking websites.\n perspective: Social media can damage students' chances of admission to colleges", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c7922f61396c48b486a46d4c63e82c5b", "input": "claim: Teachers must be banned from interacting with students via social networking websites.\n perspective: Social media sites' advertising practices may constitute an invasion of privacy.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e4eaf447362f4ee4b342c1a87275853e", "input": "claim: Teachers must be banned from interacting with students via social networking websites.\n perspective: Social media sites' advertising practices might invade peoples' privacy.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-b31083dc179c445bad4957897aeedf6a", "input": "claim: Teachers must be banned from interacting with students via social networking websites.\n perspective: Social media sites can have advertising practices that are an invasion to privacy.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-1d434d9e741c45a8b858300e90173024", "input": "claim: Teachers must be banned from interacting with students via social networking websites.\n perspective: Social media can facilitate inappropriate student-teacher relationships.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-4a291dbb87b24ab7bd4d48abc0a80622", "input": "claim: Teachers must be banned from interacting with students via social networking websites.\n perspective: Social media can cause inappropriate student-teacher relations.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-4034f061dd394547b634971843c1599a", "input": "claim: Teachers must be banned from interacting with students via social networking websites.\n perspective: Social media can start inappropriate student-teacher problems.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a1980e60c3ff420c859f93c190270c5b", "input": "claim: Teachers must be banned from interacting with students via social networking websites.\n perspective: Social media facilitates cyberbullying.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-bd891347c19940149a0698490b083b7d", "input": "claim: Teachers must be banned from interacting with students via social networking websites.\n perspective: Many people use social media to bully people.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-64f47174c51f4252916914a91bfea8bc", "input": "claim: Teachers must be banned from interacting with students via social networking websites.\n perspective: Social media enables people to bully others online.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-0a3127df86634742a6dc44115f9bbffd", "input": "claim: Developed Countries Should Accept More Refugees.\n perspective: Many refugees are highly educated people who can contribute to our societies", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-cbc59eaf48744a08a0e0907bfa7b6d16", "input": "claim: Developed Countries Should Accept More Refugees.\n perspective: Many refugees have much to offer to our societies.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-14989a5a38f74fcbb5f3974d91191991", "input": "claim: Developed Countries Should Accept More Refugees.\n perspective: We have so much, we should give to those who don't", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-7973332193f6483f9df515f4eff25731", "input": "claim: Developed Countries Should Accept More Refugees.\n perspective: We should be charitable.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f8c6527d0a86472aa580d8311c14a6a5", "input": "claim: Developed Countries Should Accept More Refugees.\n perspective: When you have an abundance of something you should give to those who do not share in your fortune.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-de82327ae35542f9812da422120e46cc", "input": "claim: Developed Countries Should Accept More Refugees.\n perspective: It is our moral duty to give to the less-fortunate", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a25db65bf272424091a8a394c766bf72", "input": "claim: Developed Countries Should Accept More Refugees.\n perspective: We are morally obligated to help the needy.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-787564abc2404b15b2522ee27144f4c9", "input": "claim: Developed Countries Should Accept More Refugees.\n perspective: We are duty bound to aid the less fortunate.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-55bbec02cd394af293371def5a82db3c", "input": "claim: Developed Countries Should Accept More Refugees.\n perspective: It's what our country was built on", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d56c77f954be47af89a8558574c3af43", "input": "claim: Developed Countries Should Accept More Refugees.\n perspective: This is a founding principal of our country.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-82a8ff9077534522a27af6a08e34d416", "input": "claim: Developed Countries Should Accept More Refugees.\n perspective: Our country holds considers this very important.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-54b7cfe39f3441fa8daf2f0de9e574a8", "input": "claim: Developed Countries Should Accept More Refugees.\n perspective: The government has to take care of the problems in that nation first", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-098241c8ba3c4370bdd9f2e64b43f4a2", "input": "claim: In Parliamentary Democracies, A Change Of Prime Minister Should Automatically Trigger A General Election.\n perspective: It would create instability and logistical problems", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-82ca4fb6848a4a3c86aca1ba859318b7", "input": "claim: In Parliamentary Democracies, A Change Of Prime Minister Should Automatically Trigger A General Election.\n perspective: The concept overestimates the role of the Prime Minister", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-6d978747f5f640b5b648a3cc1e696b95", "input": "claim: We must hold all U.S. presidential primaries on the same day.\n perspective: The current system is hugely expensive; a national primary would control the scale of spending in campaigns ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-08f9696f31c64e78984111426931732f", "input": "claim: We must hold all U.S. presidential primaries on the same day.\n perspective: The current political system is hugely expensive, and a national primary could control the scale of spending in campaigns.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-106f8db571364b55b57f80dafa2fbbac", "input": "claim: We must hold all U.S. presidential primaries on the same day.\n perspective: The current system is very expensive so having a national primary could control the spending scale in campaigns.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ceb8dade04ac424d915f66ee2aed60ff", "input": "claim: We should allow military recruiting in schools.\n perspective: The Armed Forces are less than honest", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-f872ca59391c44548375bd2afb237368", "input": "claim: We should allow military recruiting in schools.\n perspective: All the military is interested in schools for is the chance to recruit students.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-af9715e6cdab4f90aefcb1c72340df39", "input": "claim: We should allow military recruiting in schools.\n perspective: Children are too young to decide for themselves", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-975e69a2776b4788a21f7481ee4c0a8a", "input": "claim: We should allow military recruiting in schools.\n perspective: Children in school aren't old enough to make this decision for themselves.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-20fdb7cfb2a141be9a2e551d5d23967d", "input": "claim: We should allow military recruiting in schools.\n perspective: Children in school are to young to make such a life altering decision for themselves.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-0f728b400cd04fb68349fdd9e705f4f7", "input": "claim: We should allow military recruiting in schools.\n perspective: Children are vulnerable to influences", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-2ed65743764b438cbea38642d0462fd4", "input": "claim: We should allow military recruiting in schools.\n perspective: The Armed Forces need recruits", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-34ea9b71c1bd4b48a5e286af4b4e6b19", "input": "claim: We should allow military recruiting in schools.\n perspective: Recruits are needed for the Armed Forces to continue to be a powerful force. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-553201ce6de443f4a2d75e24d8e637e7", "input": "claim: We should allow military recruiting in schools.\n perspective: Recruits are needed for the Armed Forces to be successful. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f58d5322f25a4f44bdaf9cf3a8e8f659", "input": "claim: We should allow military recruiting in schools.\n perspective: The Armed Forces are a legitimate career option", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-9c9fe314c41a4bba886a0279e7db67e1", "input": "claim: We should allow military recruiting in schools.\n perspective: Joining the Military is a good option as a career.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-3c6d4e825f444d138bf33afc1f317e70", "input": "claim: We should allow military recruiting in schools.\n perspective: The Armed Forces provides many career choices and is a legitimate decision. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-829aecf3fda4440c97cf8557db6fd524", "input": "claim: Make-up is bad for us.\n perspective: Animal-products, alcohol and their derivates are not good for the skin", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-40d6677242924f45ac56d1ad55886555", "input": "claim: Make-up is bad for us.\n perspective: Products derived from animals are not good for our skin.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-6078d3b0c2724dee8b8eec8c33fa288a", "input": "claim: Make-up is bad for us.\n perspective: Products derived from alcohol are not good for health.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-838d104b0b2d4a678ca62e3a43144c19", "input": "claim: It is a good idea to lease Crimea to Russia.\n perspective: Russia gets what it wants", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e9c65628366548a1bbfd7ab1c63a26f0", "input": "claim: It is a good idea to lease Crimea to Russia.\n perspective: Why would Ukraine trust a lease when the previous one was violated?", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b67df5be4bf94cdf90630b2020826fc0", "input": "claim: It is a good idea to lease Crimea to Russia.\n perspective: Does not provide guarantees for the protection of other Russian minorities", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-becd2319017c4f96b1d90f206b5d3421", "input": "claim: It is a good idea to lease Crimea to Russia.\n perspective: Helps Ukraine financially", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-eccc8587954b4dc09f334a060488151c", "input": "claim: It is a good idea to lease Crimea to Russia.\n perspective: A peaceful solution", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-36487e2f9dbb4d5eb09ab05378fa89d2", "input": "claim: Children should be allowed to have facebook accounts.\n perspective: Giving Out Personal Information Is Dangerous", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-7b1cfbc41ba24bc89f4c99447df0e4c6", "input": "claim: Children should be allowed to have facebook accounts.\n perspective: Under the age of 14, it is too dangerous to have a facebook account because it is dangerous to display personal information.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-f09fa64fa89045098a5e631233175bd9", "input": "claim: Children should be allowed to have facebook accounts.\n perspective: It is possible that can be put in danger if they give out too much information", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-f38f0230e3f248dfb14fac23b28f9c7a", "input": "claim: Children should be allowed to have facebook accounts.\n perspective: There could be dangerous consequences even the wrong information is revealed", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-6abcd25b3b404145a315875ed7778fcb", "input": "claim: Children should be allowed to have facebook accounts.\n perspective: Facebook will become another web-based venue for sexual predators fishing for jailbait", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-3bd5632a45444a98b44f865344714679", "input": "claim: Children should be allowed to have facebook accounts.\n perspective: It is unsafe for children to have facebook accounts because of personal information dissemination.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-fcdfa9bc7a064cfb9346dfabd01cf6fd", "input": "claim: Children should be allowed to have facebook accounts.\n perspective: Personal identifiers are the reason children should not have facebook accounts.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-5e1f720446b94591899d821dfbe92d82", "input": "claim: Children should be allowed to have facebook accounts.\n perspective: It can be a potentially dangerous mistake to give out personal info", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-1b61bf17872d4e5b874da7cdb30f204f", "input": "claim: Children should be allowed to have facebook accounts.\n perspective: There can be terrible consequences if you give out personal info", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-05923fadcb3b49439b7bf2d2dfa35418", "input": "claim: Children should be allowed to have facebook accounts.\n perspective: The smallest bit of information could be harmful", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-d75818c4f2424b5aab2f4981394956cf", "input": "claim: Children should be allowed to have facebook accounts.\n perspective: It is wrong for children to have facebook accounts because it is too easy, hence dangerous to get information about them.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-7b521eda4ef341feaf984e8625ff309e", "input": "claim: Children should be allowed to have facebook accounts.\n perspective: The ease of obtaining even minimal information about a facebook user is why children should not have a facebook account.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-7eb24f412ac2428c947e31a95e8f4521", "input": "claim: Children should be allowed to have facebook accounts.\n perspective: Even giving out a little information can be dangerous", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-eafd834423264137afb662acbd63d35a", "input": "claim: Children should be allowed to have facebook accounts.\n perspective: There can be harm even if you don't reveal that much info", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-fd0128f7f5c34ee6930a28f4262a1554", "input": "claim: Children should be allowed to have facebook accounts.\n perspective: Parental control, privacy settings and look at Myspace/Youtube", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a77e4dbb50604b8385234625546b577a", "input": "claim: Children should be allowed to have facebook accounts.\n perspective: Children should be allowed to have facebook accounts because privacy settings and parental conrols protect the children.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-7683d365ff5b4748a6532220697f6670", "input": "claim: Children should be allowed to have facebook accounts.\n perspective: Parental controls and setting privacy parameters in facebook are readons children should be allowed to have a facebook account.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-fdd4e4644cd6414188a4db4e4d276839", "input": "claim: Children should be allowed to have facebook accounts.\n perspective: There are ways to monitor like using parental control and privacy settings", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f950d29424694bdc9e119efe48baf741", "input": "claim: Children should be allowed to have facebook accounts.\n perspective: Features like parental control and privacy settings make it easier", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-092eacb0847043d690d9575cc7ba0f37", "input": "claim: Children should be allowed to have facebook accounts.\n perspective: If there's parental control and they use proper privacy settings . ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c156f754050d49da84517dd9c7a5c73f", "input": "claim: Children should be allowed to have facebook accounts.\n perspective: Parental controls and privacy settings should be activated ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ec2960941ae343dc9c958f2479694f15", "input": "claim: Children should be allowed to have facebook accounts.\n perspective: Facebook cannot monitor all users nor validate user information", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-3680e2c49306455aab2531e7156314e9", "input": "claim: We must support the use of truth and reconciliation commissions.\n perspective: The reconciliation process provides access to justice in post conflict states", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-936c6854883741609153866cbfe2bdd9", "input": "claim: We must support the use of truth and reconciliation commissions.\n perspective: Truth and reconciliation process paving way for justice", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-1818a943699240d39e9ba6a9e1989d31", "input": "claim: We must support the use of truth and reconciliation commissions.\n perspective: reconciliation helps with justice", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a98dafd18e914be3874b2a43f96da428", "input": "claim: We must support the use of truth and reconciliation commissions.\n perspective: Reconciliation can be used to conceal political corruption and patrimony", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-0e9a95bee03f43728e57470835966390", "input": "claim: We must support the use of truth and reconciliation commissions.\n perspective: reconciliation can be used for political corruption", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-154c463878344f3b9cfc185c79fa4784", "input": "claim: We must support the use of truth and reconciliation commissions.\n perspective: reconciliation can help to conceal corruption", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a6c546e158304a1fa0514b59ed4534c6", "input": "claim: We must support the use of truth and reconciliation commissions.\n perspective: Truth and reconciliation are more important than retribution following violent and long term conflicts", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-93bb497f472a42fe84db19967fe7f41f", "input": "claim: Puerto Rico should seek American statehood.\n perspective: Puerto Rico would benefit economically from statehood", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-55a6233d945d4ea7a747039276e27175", "input": "claim: Puerto Rico should seek American statehood.\n perspective: Statehood would be an economic benefit for Puerto Rico.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-3d52abbb784c41daa57d29bd841f9644", "input": "claim: Puerto Rico should seek American statehood.\n perspective: Statehood would bring economic gains to Puerto Rico. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-9227cff438614252b0fb610662ce10d8", "input": "claim: Puerto Rico should seek American statehood.\n perspective: Statehood is economically beneficial.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-bd69983f3dea48c2bf19129c0ec9a299", "input": "claim: Puerto Rico should seek American statehood.\n perspective: Puerto Rico would have a better economy if it were a state.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-2ae80af4dfb64bc4bb0dedad6597f699", "input": "claim: Puerto Rico should seek American statehood.\n perspective: Puerto Ricans deserve full political rights and citizenship", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-041b4b46e4774041b8c47170d0e525f5", "input": "claim: Puerto Rico should seek American statehood.\n perspective: Residents of Puerto Rico deserve the full political rights and citizenship of other Americans.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-6064e917f4d74e1dad6dce744d3c6250", "input": "claim: Puerto Rico should seek American statehood.\n perspective: Puerto Ricans should have political rights and citizenship status equal to other Americans.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f717fb46a01648e1a2d23d9a53fc5128", "input": "claim: Puerto Rico should seek American statehood.\n perspective: Puerto Ricans should be US citizens.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-41d64109a31a4075a676b8b9d95023ac", "input": "claim: Puerto Rico should seek American statehood.\n perspective: Peurto Rico should be an American state.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-076053d105404dc7ac4d33867e218892", "input": "claim: Puerto Rico should seek American statehood.\n perspective: English is not a problem for Puerto Rican statehood", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-3ee2165a4dce47189bf0384a2d685221", "input": "claim: Puerto Rico should seek American statehood.\n perspective: Puerto Rican statehood is not economical for the US", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-2e7501e041f1418484dc6ed63b2b3b24", "input": "claim: Puerto Rico should seek American statehood.\n perspective: Puerto Rican statehood will not benefit the US economically.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-72198b048fcc4e89aa89400ad0261914", "input": "claim: Puerto Rico should seek American statehood.\n perspective: Making Puerto Rico a state is not a good economic decision for the US. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-784683ff4e31488d8ae4144915b85940", "input": "claim: Puerto Rico should seek American statehood.\n perspective: Becoming a state would hurt the other 50 states.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-2a303cd788ed4d81ae1c1016718be5d8", "input": "claim: Puerto Rico should seek American statehood.\n perspective: It would be better for the US if Puerto Rico does not become a state. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-fd6e27ffc64142f0b5ecfaa390418bfe", "input": "claim: It is crucial to support the development of a missile defence system.\n perspective: The system is an incredibly expensive venture that may not even work", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4dbf04c7baa44609ae41954c68c790fc", "input": "claim: It is crucial to support the development of a missile defence system.\n perspective: A missilie defense system is a pricey gamble.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-beac93e1920e4bba94099e77e296dd29", "input": "claim: It is crucial to support the development of a missile defence system.\n perspective: As a matter of principle, every country, including the United States, has the right to defend itself to the best of its technological and economic ability", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-defbde4d5efb44d4b2eaa099e9c3f24f", "input": "claim: It is crucial to support the development of a missile defence system.\n perspective: Every country, including the United States, has a sovereign right to defend itself with every available means necessary", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-242f46dbf8f342ac95a0229fa5bb15ec", "input": "claim: It is crucial to support the development of a missile defence system.\n perspective: Every sovereign nation has the right to defend itself by all means necessary", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c5a85fa43304473bb679b5cfe7753662", "input": "claim: It is crucial to support the development of a missile defence system.\n perspective: A robust missile defense shield will provide the protection previously afforded by the doctrine of Mutually Assured Destruction, allowing the US to dismantle much of its dangerous nuclear arsenal", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-8a8b38a3e37c48ab8587d55ce6737604", "input": "claim: It is crucial to support the development of a missile defence system.\n perspective: A missile defense shield is a good alternative to a nuclear defense.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-592dd1f4b6964c768c6e5c0e2b32a95d", "input": "claim: It is crucial to support the development of a missile defence system.\n perspective: Missile defense is less dangerous than having a nuclear arsenal.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-47349b8e1e61429ca0f7bdf54b1af81f", "input": "claim: It is crucial to support the development of a missile defence system.\n perspective: Strategic missile defense technology is substantially more advanced and discriminating in application than nuclear weapons, making potential future wars less potentially devastating", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e3dbc2228a254c1698ee6bf28130b692", "input": "claim: It is crucial to support the development of a missile defence system.\n perspective: It is easier to target specific areas with a missile defense.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-651189ca1b984c70ad3b121b69ca2c66", "input": "claim: It is crucial to support the development of a missile defence system.\n perspective: Mutually Assured Destruction breaks down when national missile defense systems are introduced, destabilizing world security:", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-2b3b8f580e664d44838824fdcc6c718e", "input": "claim: It is crucial to support the development of a missile defence system.\n perspective: World security is threatened by employing a missile defense.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-7de16fde10ce4f878739967153c210ae", "input": "claim: It is crucial to support the development of a missile defence system.\n perspective: A strategic missile defense shield will be an effective defense against ballistic missile attacks targeted at the United States and its allies", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-3e0451ff7a724edeb255d5e7a25db3d2", "input": "claim: It is crucial to support the development of a missile defence system.\n perspective: Ballistic missile attacks can be counteracted by a missile defense shield.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f45980d631d848cfad987dda7a2c6ff1", "input": "claim: It is crucial to support the development of a missile defence system.\n perspective: The political consequences of the system make the world less safe", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-547caf65914a41058bb113b3a920d20a", "input": "claim: It is crucial to support the development of a missile defence system.\n perspective: There are potential dangers to taking this action.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-edc43229a83c405d96bbec35a96454e3", "input": "claim: It is crucial to support the development of a missile defence system.\n perspective: Politics involved in this system put world safety in jeopardy.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e68ee767dd604c4caed8a0b309172d78", "input": "claim: South Africa should host an Olympics.\n perspective: Economic benefits", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e3069750ffa64409bc3fa2664840b46f", "input": "claim: South Africa should host an Olympics.\n perspective: National “feel-good factor”", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d720d928a2eb40f8bf91b71c05d5bd72", "input": "claim: South Africa should host an Olympics.\n perspective: \"Feel-good factor\" can be national.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-480cad032f664c298eed7e8426bdf310", "input": "claim: South Africa should host an Olympics.\n perspective: Showcase for a nation and continent", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f720719fb0d24c319b72265de8026dae", "input": "claim: There is a good case for stating that there is a God.\n perspective: 'God' is merely a concept designed to promote a set of values", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-592a03ac306b403e9f47445c93821b2e", "input": "claim: There is a good case for stating that there is a God.\n perspective: People think that a benevolent God cannot exist because bad things happen...", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-190d1cb69d7e4192af1a7af6b6d00c73", "input": "claim: There is a good case for stating that there is a God.\n perspective: If there is a god, its the sun.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-6d86bbd109b84746a764a166f251359e", "input": "claim: There is a good case for stating that there is a God.\n perspective: Life is ridiculous without a God. Belief in God is the only sane thing we discuss.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-992cbd5d3b4f40148dbd0ed4a3436524", "input": "claim: There is a good case for stating that there is a God.\n perspective: Science can support the existance of God", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c8c40c0d28dd439db032563fb2739ff0", "input": "claim: There is a good case for stating that there is a God.\n perspective: According to Probability - a creator exists", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-99b8e1323f1949d4932c96da617eeacb", "input": "claim: There is a good case for stating that there is a God.\n perspective: God teaches forgiveness and love: an idea universally agreed upon as good.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-697b19f367aa420bb39111d6ed67c26c", "input": "claim: There is a good case for stating that there is a God.\n perspective: God is a concept dreamed up by optimistic people.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-20fd50c16df64588bec42df729361292", "input": "claim: It is fine to do random drug-testing in schools.\n perspective: No harm to non-drug users", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-4ff8bb78dd2743fca8896256afac2f9e", "input": "claim: It is fine to do random drug-testing in schools.\n perspective: If you have nothing to hide a random drug test is not a big deal.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-4bd3868095934b55af4d40c70d053c73", "input": "claim: It is fine to do random drug-testing in schools.\n perspective: If you are not using drugs, a drug test is not invasive.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d1438c339327436c8a178882c913064f", "input": "claim: It is fine to do random drug-testing in schools.\n perspective: School's duty of care", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-80560ed63bfe4807aa892f2ecf2c0e10", "input": "claim: It is fine to do random drug-testing in schools.\n perspective: Right to privacy", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-67891038e0ef4d029548f7c8453c4e07", "input": "claim: It is fine to do random drug-testing in schools.\n perspective: Drug testing without probable cause is invasive.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-85b28a1aaf01428e982a322517dba81f", "input": "claim: It is fine to do random drug-testing in schools.\n perspective: Students have a right to privacy.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-90c8831a05734cb2879d721092dd8cb8", "input": "claim: It is fine to do random drug-testing in schools.\n perspective: Prevent drug use", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-aecced714d3a46e3921046d1cb3e600f", "input": "claim: The law on self defence should cover ‘grossly disproportionate’ actions.\n perspective: We should not allow state sponsored revenge", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b7631c9173cc41e881baf59f25dbdfbc", "input": "claim: The law on self defence should cover ‘grossly disproportionate’ actions.\n perspective: There is already enough leeway in the law of self defence.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-2258389178ea4528b82381e415f5d653", "input": "claim: The law on self defence should cover ‘grossly disproportionate’ actions.\n perspective: The cases of burglars needs to be dealt with", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-8c3cef7d09e74199adb3ddf8dc32cf1a", "input": "claim: The law on self defence should cover ‘grossly disproportionate’ actions.\n perspective: We should be able to protect our homes from intruders", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ccc3be0b9a164cf4a6190dd4c7940c71", "input": "claim: Tunisia should not rely on tourism for economic growth.\n perspective: Produces Employment", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4e005bd223de494fb72c9344317ab14a", "input": "claim: Animal testing should be banned.\n perspective: Animals can suffer like humans do, so it is speciesism to experiment on them while we refrain from experimenting on humans.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-5e69be4fa69e4573822560893bb4e619", "input": "claim: Animal testing should be banned.\n perspective: While both people and animals both suffer, most animals suffer more than people do.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-7cca3f0aa94940eabb59b4aca603f43b", "input": "claim: Animal testing should be banned.\n perspective: Most animals can suffer more than some people", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-0fa1d46867704521958d7d4a65722bf3", "input": "claim: Animal testing should be banned.\n perspective: People can suffer, but most animals can suffer more. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-0f32c71570444a58a03b9f00f3e53d3b", "input": "claim: Animal testing should be banned.\n perspective: Animal researchers treat animals humanely, both for the animals' sake and to ensure reliable test results.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-1b268f9f1f27451892f9a4c9bd4e7368", "input": "claim: Animal testing should be banned.\n perspective: Animals are treated well during animal testing. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-9611bc5d00284160b532eaab72f93e7c", "input": "claim: Animal testing should be banned.\n perspective: Research animals are well treated ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c4b6f7e38d544671b1851a701a8b16d0", "input": "claim: Animal testing should be banned.\n perspective: Animals do not have rights, therefore it is acceptable to experiment on them.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-1ff5ffc142b74f26abed7b6da56d3c2b", "input": "claim: Animal testing should be banned.\n perspective: Animals don’t have human rights", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-df5b34ff3d024c06b76ba359e3c27307", "input": "claim: Animal testing should be banned.\n perspective: Animals don't have rights.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-be6e9437cc8c471cabba18757de8b26a", "input": "claim: Animal testing should be banned.\n perspective: Harming animals is a bad thing.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c3036a73f2984ccfa2ee3c1fbc59de39", "input": "claim: Animal testing should be banned.\n perspective: Animals shouldn't be put through harmful situations.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a446f0067fa74cccab9814bbce0dc222", "input": "claim: Animal testing should be banned.\n perspective: Animals are severely harmed by research done on them.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c04d7d29da88435fb723d6e6c17716fd", "input": "claim: Animal testing should be banned.\n perspective: When research is done on animals, it causes them severe harm.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-00dee60355aa4c4a8271aed598574351", "input": "claim: Animal testing should be banned.\n perspective: Animals shouldn’t be harmed", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-2f4badc29dfd4f80bdb0f08f80d43637", "input": "claim: Animal testing should be banned.\n perspective: Animal research causes severe harm to the animals involved", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a6b53c6937914d199110c912e56f2211", "input": "claim: Animal testing should be banned.\n perspective: Testing is needed for really new drugs", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-890e6826b7024955b1c2c48b94b50042", "input": "claim: Animal testing should be banned.\n perspective: We need to be able to test drugs on animals. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-0d05d75531024500b711d69ac82f7737", "input": "claim: Animal testing should be banned.\n perspective: Animal research is only used when it’s needed", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-cf47ac5347f14c17bfca43f6673d12a0", "input": "claim: Animal testing should be banned.\n perspective: We try to only use animal testing when it is needed. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-65a5f1bb03fd4b35beee42c9709f2de9", "input": "claim: Animal testing should be banned.\n perspective: Sometimes we have no other choices for Animal research, but then to do some animal testing. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e97830eb8eeb4d55b5fa16f82c529023", "input": "claim: Animal testing should be banned.\n perspective: Animal research ensures greater safety for humans", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-7c8ab7963d8643d4acbc0ed258055f04", "input": "claim: Animal testing should be banned.\n perspective: Animal testing has contributed to many life-saving cures and treatments.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-efec2620132e444689407e6e3f596387", "input": "claim: Animal testing should be banned.\n perspective: Without animal research, we would have fewer products", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a2fe04c20adb47d89f5737ef5b91cf4b", "input": "claim: Animal testing should be banned.\n perspective: Animal research has played a vital role in a great many of the major medical advances of the last century", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-8907548945364da0a2c6631cbc4fbfb2", "input": "claim: Animal testing should be banned.\n perspective: There are no satisfactory alternatives to animal research", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-72ce1f4cf0a14c5d8c73cc5a637cab3f", "input": "claim: Animal testing should be banned.\n perspective: Animal testing is cruel and inhumane.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-51662863ef694c699d353cf8ff260d19", "input": "claim: Animal testing should be banned.\n perspective: Drugs that pass animal tests are not necessarily safe.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-7543abe32a304881914862f267d4995f", "input": "claim: Animal testing should be banned.\n perspective: Animals themselves benefit from the results of animal testing.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-14b9944c69cf4da58ace7668d192167f", "input": "claim: Animal testing should be banned.\n perspective: Most animals that are used in scientific testing have better lives. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-1e7e0e507b514c4b934a1fe2421568b8", "input": "claim: Animal testing should be banned.\n perspective: Religious traditions allow for human dominion over animals.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b56c760fde8a4bd2aee8619a3c54f48d", "input": "claim: Animal testing should be banned.\n perspective: Alternative testing methods now exist that can replace the need for animals. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-5c907b17ff644a6abcbf6edfa643073f", "input": "claim: Animal testing should be banned.\n perspective: Number 2 is a lie, there ARE alternatives to animal testing! Other companies use them, and animal testing doesnt prove anything, because although close, they arent people.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a7158b1f67d4425d9a3e1eb4dbef8910", "input": "claim: Animal testing should be banned.\n perspective: Animal tests may mislead researchers into ignoring potential cures and treatments.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d8fbaa5a1deb422ea1d0977d2fc16fc5", "input": "claim: Animal testing should be banned.\n perspective: Animal tests do not reliably predict results in human beings.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-0db0ad5d507b412cbd2bf0f4a240a393", "input": "claim: Animal testing should be banned.\n perspective: Animal tests are more expensive than alternative methods and are a waste of government research dollars.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-8d0d12f19bae4b44bcdde5584200c10f", "input": "claim: Animal testing should be banned.\n perspective: Religious traditions tell us to be merciful to animals, so we should not cause them suffering by experimenting on them.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-b03a2f0ea5aa4b01907b7fa8309c9852", "input": "claim: Animal testing should be banned.\n perspective: Animals often make better research subjects than human beings because of their shorter life cycles.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-871514e7c8f74ebfbbdc240f9acd3a55", "input": "claim: Animal testing should be banned.\n perspective: Animals are the only choice for testing. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-75027d2651dc44a6b04a4d4d659c55c8", "input": "claim: Animal testing should be banned.\n perspective: Animals are appropriate research subjects because they are similar to human beings in many ways. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b6d26388c2a343e49a4685331fd33d69", "input": "claim: Animal testing should be banned.\n perspective: Some cosmetics and health care products must be tested on animals to ensure their safety.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-5fee5797ed354f4ebbda7dca44cef8b4", "input": "claim: Animal testing should be banned.\n perspective: Medical breakthroughs involving animal research may still have been made without the use of animals.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e8e4fc52d1124b53aee0d50ce98743dd", "input": "claim: Animal testing should be banned.\n perspective: Medical breakthroughs can be achieved without doing any scientific or commercial experiment on animals ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f7cf7b07d3294e1e8c5494dd925f1865", "input": "claim: Animal testing should be banned.\n perspective: 95% of animals used in experiments are not protected by the Animal Welfare Act.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-561ef35e9923483489c16a16e4cdd9b2", "input": "claim: Animal testing should be banned.\n perspective: many companies get accurate results without testing on animals", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-b7b1c0c8d1bd43c9a5f7c2ed57fdec9c", "input": "claim: Animal testing should be banned.\n perspective: Animal testing dosen't ensure good results", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-7f599e36a1ec432cb335b931d688db2e", "input": "claim: Animal testing should be banned.\n perspective: Animal experiments retard medical progress due to providing misleading results", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-eb16510fa4414287a22c690952dbd18a", "input": "claim: Animal testing should be banned.\n perspective: animal experiments are not always accurate", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a2ccb4ef6d484e9994f6d9c8db5c5951", "input": "claim: Instant Replay Should Be Used in Major League Baseball.\n perspective: Many plays don’t lend themselves to video review", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-f70a0c6ce50b4f3a9a4026cc09acfdc2", "input": "claim: Instant Replay Should Be Used in Major League Baseball.\n perspective: video cannot catch all plays at a game", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c2c50508c6434bebbb4176c4ec0e110b", "input": "claim: Instant Replay Should Be Used in Major League Baseball.\n perspective: With more accurate calls come more legitimate outcomes to games", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-162046b0d865413bacc98ad88c285a8b", "input": "claim: Instant Replay Should Be Used in Major League Baseball.\n perspective: Games can benefit from correct calls thanks to instant replay.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-586f5111c1f94a9e8ea30927b4179082", "input": "claim: Instant Replay Should Be Used in Major League Baseball.\n perspective: Wins and losses matter, so does the instant replay. It matters to get things right.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-17acc205e2cb42edadfc109c30a6ffc1", "input": "claim: Instant Replay Should Be Used in Major League Baseball.\n perspective: Accurate calls should be the top priority, and instant replay helps provide them", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-51349ae32cd44741955a8b6abcf92feb", "input": "claim: Instant Replay Should Be Used in Major League Baseball.\n perspective: Major League Baseball should expand instant replay for more accurate calls.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-1c765587b92d44eb876f44be98bd617f", "input": "claim: Instant Replay Should Be Used in Major League Baseball.\n perspective: Umpires Approve Instant Replay for Major League Baseball so they can make more accurate calls.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-abd87ddea28a4f1a892eb8a2e132bb57", "input": "claim: Instant Replay Should Be Used in Major League Baseball.\n perspective: Instant replay supports the goal of making accurate calls", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-222b5b64fcf2429892bd761be5e22532", "input": "claim: Instant Replay Should Be Used in Major League Baseball.\n perspective: Using instant replay helps make sure the right calls are made", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-7eb9bb7972eb4b59a11341a34b20daf5", "input": "claim: Instant Replay Should Be Used in Major League Baseball.\n perspective: Instant replay might be deceptive or inconclusive", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ebfb3441a7d14cadb9973c0a29954036", "input": "claim: Instant Replay Should Be Used in Major League Baseball.\n perspective: there is confusion in viewing instant replay", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-0b4dd0e74eda45d0bc07685aebe6697b", "input": "claim: Instant Replay Should Be Used in Major League Baseball.\n perspective: some things could be missed when viewing and instant replay during a game. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-eb7d44edf9fe45ca910f5ddee9dbcdc7", "input": "claim: Instant Replay Should Be Used in Major League Baseball.\n perspective: Instant replay will actually enhance umpires’ stature", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-23d013f93ac04bcca644cdc8f9af8e8b", "input": "claim: Instant Replay Should Be Used in Major League Baseball.\n perspective: Instant replay will make play caling easier on umpires.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-601ac0437bd74a99b72a43479b6784ca", "input": "claim: Instant Replay Should Be Used in Major League Baseball.\n perspective: Umpires will benfit greatly from instant replay in the MLB physically.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-909da5e3bf1f4240baa220c62ea16569", "input": "claim: Instant Replay Should Be Used in Major League Baseball.\n perspective: Instant replay will take the human element out of baseball", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-aaa4dac3a8844c26af4c457b22608fdb", "input": "claim: Instant Replay Should Be Used in Major League Baseball.\n perspective: Why even have an umpire if every play can be instantly replayed?", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-09435e1688a14a85836bca1bac6247a5", "input": "claim: Instant Replay Should Be Used in Major League Baseball.\n perspective: It’s not possible to get every call right, so instant replay is a necessary supplement to umpires’ skill", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-82bb82b76f29423caa15493689335b23", "input": "claim: Instant Replay Should Be Used in Major League Baseball.\n perspective: Instant replay allows the proper rules to be put in place in the MLB.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d0b63ee5d6674abc83d9d29e341560b9", "input": "claim: Instant Replay Should Be Used in Major League Baseball.\n perspective: The MLB should take up instant relay to make sure the umpires make the right calls.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d6ea2b17e07d48dbafee03d4eb38d592", "input": "claim: Instant Replay Should Be Used in Major League Baseball.\n perspective: Instant replay will take too long", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a3c5ae9b4b324d8c90f69f2cbdf71ba2", "input": "claim: Instant Replay Should Be Used in Major League Baseball.\n perspective: Instant replay will make long MLB games even longer.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-35e9f4060ce347fdb888f6c42674d430", "input": "claim: Instant Replay Should Be Used in Major League Baseball.\n perspective: Instant replay drags ut calls most umpires can make already.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-da4ab8c3c1c3409f95fab96d2237d506", "input": "claim: Instant Replay Should Be Used in Major League Baseball.\n perspective: Tradition demands that this instant replay not be used", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-8a8165acd2ba4379bd2cfc03fe738177", "input": "claim: Instant Replay Should Be Used in Major League Baseball.\n perspective: Instant replay is not beneficial to the game", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-866bba19f7a2438780ef83677e94bb01", "input": "claim: Instant Replay Should Be Used in Major League Baseball.\n perspective: Instant replay should not be used during baseball games", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-26bd50bc4cc24599a0c9d377412ab1da", "input": "claim: Online Shopping Is Better Than Offline Shopping.\n perspective: Online Shopping Takes Less Time", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-19a67d26283347fb8d1b13991beadb58", "input": "claim: Online Shopping Is Better Than Offline Shopping.\n perspective: Online shopping is fast.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-4b09a627eacb41068ae0a3db249aef0a", "input": "claim: Online Shopping Is Better Than Offline Shopping.\n perspective: Shopping online is quicker than in store.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-8da4499598964faa8d9e8f910a6d4dfe", "input": "claim: Online Shopping Is Better Than Offline Shopping.\n perspective: Offline Shopping Is Safer", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-0fed5362bd7d41c4a93bbe36ac791740", "input": "claim: Online Shopping Is Better Than Offline Shopping.\n perspective: Online Shopping Doesn’t Require You To Drive", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-984072f8b81f4ee79bc6ddb95affc43d", "input": "claim: Online Shopping Is Better Than Offline Shopping.\n perspective: You don't have to leave the house to shop online.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-af755134578e49dfb126f2300e7bc0f4", "input": "claim: Put taxes/revenue from oil into a trust fund independent of politicians influence.\n perspective: An independent trust fund discourages investment.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-d2e938cb744941578cbaa09a439cf358", "input": "claim: Put taxes/revenue from oil into a trust fund independent of politicians influence.\n perspective: trust funds do not help investing", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-9a952409b6414e7b8e4c308f18fdc6e5", "input": "claim: Put taxes/revenue from oil into a trust fund independent of politicians influence.\n perspective: Keeping funds from government has negative consequences for spending", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-509eefad749e4d72952fe708a9b9584a", "input": "claim: Put taxes/revenue from oil into a trust fund independent of politicians influence.\n perspective: Lack of government funds decreases spending.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e2d42015edf74bd68149ca3d4d4b6df3", "input": "claim: Put taxes/revenue from oil into a trust fund independent of politicians influence.\n perspective: There are negative consequences for spending if funds are kept from the government.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b67bd1fe732444dd8a3fe86e2ccf6dd3", "input": "claim: We should encourage building the Hyperloop.\n perspective: The Hyperloop is comparatively cheap", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-99b3005b54f4446a8257c38d29e800fa", "input": "claim: We should encourage building the Hyperloop.\n perspective: The Hyperlook is cost effective.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-4764946e4a8d4eb197d7abc43fd7073f", "input": "claim: We should encourage building the Hyperloop.\n perspective: Compared to other methods of transportation, the Hyperloop is inexpensive.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-8dbab3f40a0f43da97be4a1298adb76d", "input": "claim: We should encourage building the Hyperloop.\n perspective: Fastest possible transportation over a short distance", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-da6a101aa6fe4893be1be312958475d5", "input": "claim: We should encourage building the Hyperloop.\n perspective: The fastest route over a short distance", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-bb43226ee9d0459f82843c31ed94df12", "input": "claim: We should encourage building the Hyperloop.\n perspective: The fastest route over one short distance ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-4e9e0435ca7f4654998710207559b7ce", "input": "claim: We should encourage building the Hyperloop.\n perspective: It will never work", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-13ad08d7af554a2ebff266da474e5d39", "input": "claim: We should encourage building the Hyperloop.\n perspective: It's utility is doubtful.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-975db721fdd144399a066802baef1724", "input": "claim: We should encourage building the Hyperloop.\n perspective: It's unlikely it will function as planned.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-f22c6eee54d547b880d52e5c28d953ee", "input": "claim: We should encourage building the Hyperloop.\n perspective: The Hyperloop will be a low cost system for the user", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d115bb13ad2e4edd8228622fb473a665", "input": "claim: We should encourage building the Hyperloop.\n perspective: The Hyperloop will be affordable for consumers.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-11a9f39e0f02450596e9171a9275e15c", "input": "claim: We should encourage building the Hyperloop.\n perspective: People will be able to afford to use the Hyperloop.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-660d008b89c945538b657ddb92af28ad", "input": "claim: Tennessee is correct to protect teachers who wish to explore the merits of creationism.\n perspective: As it is not science creationism should not even be covered by the Tennessee law", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-11159d1ecb98472aa1f8128885905f57", "input": "claim: Tennessee is correct to protect teachers who wish to explore the merits of creationism.\n perspective: Freedom of speech should apply to teachers as much as anyone else", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-542f94d46c36435085ed0a785f6d5da9", "input": "claim: Tennessee is correct to protect teachers who wish to explore the merits of creationism.\n perspective: Everyone has the right to free speech including teachers. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-980d2f529fa541dfa62fde4aa6f91a3d", "input": "claim: Tennessee is correct to protect teachers who wish to explore the merits of creationism.\n perspective: Teachers should have freedom to explore ideas just as much as everyone else. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-dc1e3414399d41159d750db698472479", "input": "claim: Tennessee is correct to protect teachers who wish to explore the merits of creationism.\n perspective: The bill does not exclude evolution just allows room for other theories", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-74b5722b75154f8ba22fafdc199e3c6a", "input": "claim: Tennessee is correct to protect teachers who wish to explore the merits of creationism.\n perspective: Evolution is allowed to be explored along with other theories.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-4fd8d9818a214728bd6253c45edd576a", "input": "claim: Tennessee is correct to protect teachers who wish to explore the merits of creationism.\n perspective: This bill allows teachers and students to explore all theories including evolution. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ea7c8e65193045c089daf9dd0a299d76", "input": "claim: Tennessee is correct to protect teachers who wish to explore the merits of creationism.\n perspective: Teaching creationism as well as evolution gives students freedom to choose", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-2f05f65ffa1f4a3caaf9664a0f14813d", "input": "claim: Tennessee is correct to protect teachers who wish to explore the merits of creationism.\n perspective: Creationism and evolution both have merits and it should be up to the children to decide which to believe in.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e6449aed30014e6fb4128b6a797c819b", "input": "claim: Tennessee is correct to protect teachers who wish to explore the merits of creationism.\n perspective: Teachers should not have freedom to teach whatever they wish as fact", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-904bd504cb4848af9f80226cf2591c76", "input": "claim: Tennessee is correct to protect teachers who wish to explore the merits of creationism.\n perspective: Teachers should only teach what is agreed to as fact.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-702e2ed5c3c74f7bae74a11c072f2f4c", "input": "claim: Tennessee is correct to protect teachers who wish to explore the merits of creationism.\n perspective: There is no empirical evidence supporting Creationism, whereas all evidence supports abiogenesis and evolution.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-aff996b994384899b48f4432add47c5b", "input": "claim: Tennessee is correct to protect teachers who wish to explore the merits of creationism.\n perspective: Schools must teach what is evidence-based, which would mean to teach abiogenesis and not Creationism. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-8d76c8ebe6e24ad68024bc706a62fd2f", "input": "claim: Tennessee is correct to protect teachers who wish to explore the merits of creationism.\n perspective: Faith-based Creationism shouldn't be taught in schools because they must be fact-based, s abiogenesis and evolution are.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-5b0ef980ab7d49dbbe15871a66303527", "input": "claim: Tennessee is correct to protect teachers who wish to explore the merits of creationism.\n perspective: There is a very real controversy regarding the origin and development of life, and children deserve to hear both sides.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-11f0a90f9a5f4699bd0936d15bdaa290", "input": "claim: Tennessee is correct to protect teachers who wish to explore the merits of creationism.\n perspective: Children deserve to hear both sides of the argument over the origin of life.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a80a40118d034cc69186851559c3f525", "input": "claim: Tennessee is correct to protect teachers who wish to explore the merits of creationism.\n perspective: Creationism is as valid a scientific theory as those of evolution and abiogenesis, and should therefore be given equal time in the classroom.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-cea0901f89fb4ec3b88c624475d7ede3", "input": "claim: Tennessee is correct to protect teachers who wish to explore the merits of creationism.\n perspective: Because Creationism is a valid scientific theory, it should be given equal time in teaching.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-361f9387fd0c4ac68e49402f36cd3876", "input": "claim: Tennessee is correct to protect teachers who wish to explore the merits of creationism.\n perspective: We must teach Creationism as an alternative theory because it is scientifically valid.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-7741779fcd3f452689d47936b3cd5cb2", "input": "claim: Tennessee is correct to protect teachers who wish to explore the merits of creationism.\n perspective: Much of the complexity of life cannot be explained by evolution, but is perfectly explained by Creationism.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-fb610cf1e74445d6953063509bc99039", "input": "claim: Tennessee is correct to protect teachers who wish to explore the merits of creationism.\n perspective: Creationism has theoretical answers to questions evolution can't answer.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c8c9ecca44774ddcaa60ea14639bf4ba", "input": "claim: Tennessee is correct to protect teachers who wish to explore the merits of creationism.\n perspective: Evolution cannot answer irreducible complexity like Creationism can.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-32e1dd172d74400fb5fc2b215bbd5892", "input": "claim: Tennessee is correct to protect teachers who wish to explore the merits of creationism.\n perspective: The scientific community as a whole overwhelmingly rejects Creationism.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-997179c562c44853970c5e3e83072185", "input": "claim: Tennessee is correct to protect teachers who wish to explore the merits of creationism.\n perspective: Creationism isn't supported by the scientific community.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-88095d7414054b6584572abd3dfc27b0", "input": "claim: Tennessee is correct to protect teachers who wish to explore the merits of creationism.\n perspective: Communities should have a say in what is taught in schools, and many communities want to teach creationism.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-4b599ac0fce1406295a1c67e9051557d", "input": "claim: Tennessee is correct to protect teachers who wish to explore the merits of creationism.\n perspective: Communities have a right to insist on Creationism when it is popular.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-4d4f3d8e5ff641e2b8037cedb111f06a", "input": "claim: Tennessee is correct to protect teachers who wish to explore the merits of creationism.\n perspective: Education should be about truth and facts, not dogma and faith.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4c6dc4bf06494222a2d40bfc6c1c9609", "input": "claim: Tennessee is correct to protect teachers who wish to explore the merits of creationism.\n perspective: Society should educate based on objective facts, rather than subjective beliefs and opinion.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-5d5d594b6410416680db9ff9c832d276", "input": "claim: Tennessee is correct to protect teachers who wish to explore the merits of creationism.\n perspective: Unproven speculative beliefs have no place in education as it needs to be based on provable facts.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-0a282e04cc3646c6bfda5496f6539ff4", "input": "claim: We should make education compulsory to degree level.\n perspective: Benefit from the increase in skills through their standard of living", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-8a56e26b78244073868420bfd05010f8", "input": "claim: We should make education compulsory to degree level.\n perspective: The aging population and increasing retirement age requires higher skills", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-1326c8323e334430850ce033cf1e8ba0", "input": "claim: We should make education compulsory to degree level.\n perspective: Young people should have the choice to decide for themselves", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-177740d095284b88b89f958817f16ca6", "input": "claim: We should make education compulsory to degree level.\n perspective: Young people should have the freedom to make their own choices.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a72783cfdff44a4a859bb7b38cc3a416", "input": "claim: We should make education compulsory to degree level.\n perspective: Young people should be able to think for themselves and make their own decisions.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-96289deac0b34a7e8d1b154bd836aae0", "input": "claim: We should make education compulsory to degree level.\n perspective: The economy of the future requires more education", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-7db353d0ce5648709d73563f502866a0", "input": "claim: We should make education compulsory to degree level.\n perspective: In the future, the economy will rely on those with more education.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-65ab69b5560a45b8ab5b872c9507c133", "input": "claim: We should make education compulsory to degree level.\n perspective: The economy needs educated people in order to do well in the future.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-09c4f99016b0425287fb790fc4e338bf", "input": "claim: We should make education compulsory to degree level.\n perspective: Society has a moral responsibility to educate all its young people", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-71d5b9b63a184310bf96146a5b49eca3", "input": "claim: We should make education compulsory to degree level.\n perspective: Society should make it easier for all young people to receive an education.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a162e2314daa428db6accb06a9991aee", "input": "claim: We should make education compulsory to degree level.\n perspective: Unrealistically costly", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-377e7a63e9f34d09b0af8786bbd244b4", "input": "claim: We should make education compulsory to degree level.\n perspective: Not everyone is good at studying", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-d7179c1ba81b49f38eb7c588f62e7ead", "input": "claim: We should make education compulsory to degree level.\n perspective: Some people are unable to handle the rigor of university-level coursework.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-10a9b810488e43eca105e41ab3e40243", "input": "claim: We should make education compulsory to degree level.\n perspective: We shouldn't force people to study if they aren't good at it and choose not to.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-d6bd6ab341de43189655cccb71cce070", "input": "claim: We should make education compulsory to degree level.\n perspective: not everyone is good academically", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-f835474c304d4c969a6b65f70ad9ebca", "input": "claim: We should make education compulsory to degree level.\n perspective: some people are not good at studying", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-cb695c5db8ea419bba2b3f0e2c668870", "input": "claim: We should make education compulsory to degree level.\n perspective: Compulsory studying would be taking young people out of the workforce", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-aefb8a8b4c264009bd7fbb9f25637fc1", "input": "claim: We should make education compulsory to degree level.\n perspective: Making university education compulsory would take young people out of the workforce.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-6acbc7ef2a8545b6a905b36f6e4649b6", "input": "claim: We should make education compulsory to degree level.\n perspective: some young people would be taken out of workforce by compulsory studying", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-0985e0fbb5444afba626f783c264658a", "input": "claim: We should make education compulsory to degree level.\n perspective: compulsory studying may remove young people from the workforce", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-1a0dd9b43f414e748f7f5c1806a6967a", "input": "claim: We should make education compulsory to degree level.\n perspective: More education brings more opportunities", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-553cb79371b246b5aea2d94e146ee2e5", "input": "claim: We should make education compulsory to degree level.\n perspective: The more education you have the more opportunities", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-9597f2def718442e813ecb911f7db473", "input": "claim: We should make education compulsory to degree level.\n perspective: Opportunities are influenced by education", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-004d1ac3605842ba86398e6377db7151", "input": "claim: We should make education compulsory to degree level.\n perspective: The longer they are educated, the more opportunities they get", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ac58719071bd47ebbd9851591cd59cd4", "input": "claim: We should make education compulsory to degree level.\n perspective: With more education comes more opportunities", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-df54e7ea4fbe44fa8c9190fbd600cb49", "input": "claim: We should make education compulsory to degree level.\n perspective: Raising the school learning age promotes equal opportunities", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-65531b69da924bf0a36f8e22f04461c1", "input": "claim: We should make education compulsory to degree level.\n perspective: There are cases where leaving school early is necessary", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-46be610799fb4d8a901063a9d705b812", "input": "claim: We should make education compulsory to degree level.\n perspective: Forced education achieves little", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-aafaf5b09d81483db78cc2de146dc999", "input": "claim: We should make education compulsory to degree level.\n perspective: Education that is forced does little.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-39008e0507344a1ebd11f279b92c467e", "input": "claim: We should make education compulsory to degree level.\n perspective: Little is accomplished when education is forced.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-599a8c82cfca4310ab7c78269bc0606b", "input": "claim: We should make education compulsory to degree level.\n perspective: Not all skills are best learnt in a classroom environment.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-050f97cf70c24b48aec893e2c8019337", "input": "claim: We should make education compulsory to degree level.\n perspective: Some skills are better learned outside the classroom.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-579fa6613e2e427f8316a75c3edef9f7", "input": "claim: We should make education compulsory to degree level.\n perspective: The classroom environment is not ideal for all lessons.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-0a709c4f12ba499cbffa7e073ca1b49a", "input": "claim: We should make education compulsory to degree level.\n perspective: Raising the school-leaving age is a crucial investment in society's future", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-b05a84650f814ca38c0996f1c64e99d6", "input": "claim: We should make education compulsory to degree level.\n perspective: Society's future depends on raising the school-leaving age.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e51ec41364fe4ab2907eec9269aabfc0", "input": "claim: We should make education compulsory to degree level.\n perspective: A good investment in society would be to raise the school leaving age.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-15c92b9cfc7e4cd988f9269b19a15184", "input": "claim: We must have weapons inspectors leave Syria.\n perspective: A point on the path to peace", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-0aa2fb39f2a24149ab181544ab27ea9c", "input": "claim: We must have weapons inspectors leave Syria.\n perspective: One step in the direction of peace. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-07c25488cea2462ca26d661b20b1af40", "input": "claim: We must have weapons inspectors leave Syria.\n perspective: One step to a path leading to peace. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-bc3bd118c5b845b2a8b86bcba1e67273", "input": "claim: We must have weapons inspectors leave Syria.\n perspective: Syria has not lived up to its commitments", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-f6d58dd61fb84516b73e5ffafe8955ff", "input": "claim: Antarctica Should Be Opened Up For Resource Exploitation.\n perspective: Antartic resource exploitation is unevitable: Let's do it orderly!", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-517b2ef059fe4f988b1fe747a04e1889", "input": "claim: Antarctica Should Be Opened Up For Resource Exploitation.\n perspective: Exploiting Antartica for its resources must be done with careful planning, organization and care for the land.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-33155bc39219458bb8986d624078cb4f", "input": "claim: Antarctica Should Be Opened Up For Resource Exploitation.\n perspective: Eventually Antarctica will be be exploited for its resources, but will we be prepared to do it carefully?", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-924bf0c3735448ff94bf7087b828a0bb", "input": "claim: Antarctica Should Be Opened Up For Resource Exploitation.\n perspective: No possible over abuse on the resources, just a utilitarian, global benefit", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-637f8a68dbbe42a596809a877354ec27", "input": "claim: Antarctica Should Be Opened Up For Resource Exploitation.\n perspective: Only if the world benefits should Antartica's resources be exploited.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c87c6a0893ad4799804f0800e63a2cef", "input": "claim: Antarctica Should Be Opened Up For Resource Exploitation.\n perspective: A resource treasure for humanity", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-34e3bb9929594f5aa5443fddfb5b4384", "input": "claim: Antarctica Should Be Opened Up For Resource Exploitation.\n perspective: Antartica: A common heritage to the benefit of mankind", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e978f2074ec54ebd8afcef3f2e687060", "input": "claim: The world has to ignore North Korean provocations.\n perspective: Providing attention simply encourages the regime", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a1778f4d09d54441892e986f84dfcc79", "input": "claim: The world has to ignore North Korean provocations.\n perspective: Media attention only encourages North Korean provocations.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-9580172d091d4fa694055d7b6f703861", "input": "claim: The world has to ignore North Korean provocations.\n perspective: Less attention must be paid towards North Korea in order to stop encouragement of their regime..", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-59c91ffb1e4e4403a077bda60f2134a5", "input": "claim: The world has to ignore North Korean provocations.\n perspective: Ignoring North Korea wont resolve the situation", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-20f8787ae24940139bcab99d8031b006", "input": "claim: The world has to ignore North Korean provocations.\n perspective: North Korea is an unresolved conflict it can’t simply be ignored", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-8a97c6afa28e4a728f4700c7d7b641e1", "input": "claim: The Seychelles should buy territory and relocate due to climate change.\n perspective: Moving is an imperative", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-211e1605d898403db8cbf9f830eabac5", "input": "claim: The Seychelles should buy territory and relocate due to climate change.\n perspective: We shall move at once.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-71794b55b5914fd284e290cb88243935", "input": "claim: The Seychelles should buy territory and relocate due to climate change.\n perspective: We will move as soon as possible.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-830078f70d754e4d94020da8b0f5d22f", "input": "claim: The Seychelles should buy territory and relocate due to climate change.\n perspective: Other nations have an obligation to help", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ec16278515c44aa3af61a8b496d58518", "input": "claim: The Seychelles should buy territory and relocate due to climate change.\n perspective: Other nations are obliged to help. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e519ce81848c469f900216d53da75733", "input": "claim: The Seychelles should buy territory and relocate due to climate change.\n perspective: Other nations have the duty to help. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-fbb5bbcaafc745df8900fc3e4cc79c12", "input": "claim: Affirmative action is necessary.\n perspective: Affirmative action perpetuates prejudice", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-7986c82b282d4796b34fd0d8de04b734", "input": "claim: Affirmative action is necessary.\n perspective: There is a moral obligation to provide affirmative action programs", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d640cd098dd04be792f0e73ea1643984", "input": "claim: Affirmative action is necessary.\n perspective: We are obligated to promote racial equality and provide affirmative action programs.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f460f22a221249268d33ef6485da01b4", "input": "claim: Affirmative action is necessary.\n perspective: We have a moral obligation to stop discrimination with affirmative action.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-03e1cc5907684ed289299f0af2b08de6", "input": "claim: Affirmative action is necessary.\n perspective: Affirmative action removes the cyclical disadvantages of discrimination", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a12ecd80708d4b188697c9862ff2e8f6", "input": "claim: Affirmative action is necessary.\n perspective: Discrimination can be helped by affirmative action.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-da8019bd2fd74d3eae964feb601c7129", "input": "claim: Affirmative action is necessary.\n perspective: The cycle of racial discrimination can be broken through affirmative action programs.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-75fcf74716ad446bbd667e58e27562f0", "input": "claim: Affirmative action is necessary.\n perspective: Affirmative action reduces social prejudice", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-75f05c3b90f04034aff567d3674bb2a0", "input": "claim: Affirmative action is necessary.\n perspective: Affirmative action is needed to combat racial and gender prejudice.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f66b6015b9d34b589f7dd9812dd5df1f", "input": "claim: Affirmative action is necessary.\n perspective: We can help decrease social prejudice with affirmative action programs.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-0a926a9560e14e5d947ba519f185e29f", "input": "claim: Affirmative action is necessary.\n perspective: It has unnecessarily extended into sports which affects the success of our national teams.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-cc6ae542c24843b0a4ccaf55032275fe", "input": "claim: Affirmative action is necessary.\n perspective: It is a racist policy towards those it is trying to help", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e5cf887361f84c3ca4338eee3b485a0a", "input": "claim: Affirmative action is necessary.\n perspective: It becomes a weapon of revenge", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-bc820b7143d34f5fa3af5deb9ec537b2", "input": "claim: Affirmative action is necessary.\n perspective: AA does more good than harm", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-beba1ba132f049139a2160434185bbf3", "input": "claim: Affirmative action is necessary.\n perspective: Skilled individuals carry the underskilled individuals who have been appointed due to their colour", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-82b47bc446084d6aa5156c160deb7ec8", "input": "claim: Affirmative action is necessary.\n perspective: Time to remove Affirmative Action from the EE Act", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-5a7988d11aac4306ac98591245af83cf", "input": "claim: Affirmative action is necessary.\n perspective: AA is more harmful than good", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-64328c2d6d95436483612478cf2b983f", "input": "claim: Affirmative action is necessary.\n perspective: AA actually does more harm than it does good", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-cfec2093a58d4e0986e9e20dd526a0a5", "input": "claim: Affirmative action is necessary.\n perspective: It is possible that sometimes AA might not be that beneficial", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-93af58069d4446c0802d81bab9f912cb", "input": "claim: Affirmative action is necessary.\n perspective: AA may not be as helpful as originally intended.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ce1fb720c5954078bcc010096c816f1d", "input": "claim: Affirmative action is necessary.\n perspective: AA may not be helpful.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-29be2b7fc6de40dab790df8230692468", "input": "claim: Affirmative action is necessary.\n perspective: AA does more harm than good", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-5fd01fb2ddc24787865c6a8655c43fc7", "input": "claim: Affirmative action is necessary.\n perspective: Affirmative Action is necessary to combat racism.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-fac05a23f43c4df1a164ac67d01eb45d", "input": "claim: Kill One to Save Many.\n perspective: We cannot make any judgments about whose life is valuable and whose is not", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-3fc991a3d3334cfd9aabe2369b0d28fe", "input": "claim: Kill One to Save Many.\n perspective: Killing is worse than letting someone die", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e0eb4a20dc964c14b20978fe8c7c258b", "input": "claim: Kill One to Save Many.\n perspective: The act of killing is emotionally damaging", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a048805562e646008a94388b81a50650", "input": "claim: Kill One to Save Many.\n perspective: We instinctively know killing is wrong", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-97c5816e586d46478eabc78320616c7f", "input": "claim: Kill One to Save Many.\n perspective: We do not want a society in which killing can be acceptable", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-7c5d967f8f16406ba086455ab7e5c5a8", "input": "claim: Prostitution Should Be Legal.\n perspective: The law as it stands is wrong and patronising to women", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e3790da9620344bca9c814480110cbf8", "input": "claim: Prostitution Should Be Legal.\n perspective: The current laws on prostitution are not helpful to women.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-849a10ddaba74146afb590a3412792aa", "input": "claim: Prostitution Should Be Legal.\n perspective: Women are patronized by the current prostitution laws and therefore they are wrong.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-b0e59621804e42f884d3c1d86f4c749b", "input": "claim: Prostitution Should Be Legal.\n perspective: The law is patronizing to women", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-725fb595744e45638e055fac4a733afe", "input": "claim: Prostitution Should Be Legal.\n perspective: The law patronizes women", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a2c7072527494fcaa6317d74d30cc839", "input": "claim: Prostitution Should Be Legal.\n perspective: No, can you imagine the ADS on TV?", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-03d1a389381f4a3d811f4a52c63fb87e", "input": "claim: Prostitution Should Be Legal.\n perspective: Legalizing prostitution will result pornographic advertisements. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-aee7bea9993345b0a14a58049950e9b7", "input": "claim: Prostitution Should Be Legal.\n perspective: The advertising for prostitution would be against public decency.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-588dd64fdc784967bb454817521dae7b", "input": "claim: Prostitution Should Be Legal.\n perspective: Legalised prostitution still victimises the vulnerable.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-8c83152bd2be4289b7e28a719b9f6ca4", "input": "claim: Prostitution Should Be Legal.\n perspective: Prostitution hurts vulnerable women. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-1668a0a62595486383fe179d34e17170", "input": "claim: Prostitution Should Be Legal.\n perspective: Prostitution takes advantage of women, turning them into victims.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-dad51ced330c496b8166d230864fed62", "input": "claim: Prostitution Should Be Legal.\n perspective: Prostitution is responsible for preventing some incidence of sex crime.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-1a2b6e56156c4a4abcdaa58eaccdd97d", "input": "claim: Prostitution Should Be Legal.\n perspective: Would lead to similar policy towards drugs", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-d36608680eef46bd95050ce7137122dd", "input": "claim: Prostitution Should Be Legal.\n perspective: We should declare the war on prostitution", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-573e24425ce54cc6bface02e0fe7ff02", "input": "claim: Prostitution Should Be Legal.\n perspective: The law should not condone illicit behaviour", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-cb8d66580b4f4aadbc4aa9ddbd366f79", "input": "claim: Prostitution Should Be Legal.\n perspective: Prevent Prostitution From Going Underground", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-7e9aaa7564f5443eb7581db820ed14ea", "input": "claim: Prostitution Should Be Legal.\n perspective: If made illegal, prostitution will move to an underground black market.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-31114b75456640819869cf1b9091eb2c", "input": "claim: Prostitution Should Be Legal.\n perspective: It is best to have prostitution legal and regulated, as being made illegal won't stop it.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f5f185f34e6444178930832ed537ac2c", "input": "claim: Prostitution Should Be Legal.\n perspective: Many women who have nothing become prostitutes to survive", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-01fcc8ce7ba94b2a8b89991d11981391", "input": "claim: Prostitution Should Be Legal.\n perspective: It would not solve the violence of prostitution.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-11f7f3b9a92b42f9890a1c136e7b730f", "input": "claim: Prostitution Should Be Legal.\n perspective: Proposal will exacerbate the HIV problem", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-559bbc9359994503bff5bba85c8a5bcc", "input": "claim: Prostitution Should Be Legal.\n perspective: Legalizing prostitution would exacerbate the HIV problem.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ab31a3fe6bef4e5d8ce422e3b46c36da", "input": "claim: Prostitution Should Be Legal.\n perspective: Prostitutes will be safer under legalisation", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ed781267a026408ba76c88daec8fd93f", "input": "claim: Prostitution Should Be Legal.\n perspective: Prostitutes have some safety with this legalisation.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-0e3398ccbab943ef9dc9d85a506f4373", "input": "claim: Prostitution Should Be Legal.\n perspective: Legalisation Can Be A Part of a Wider Education Program", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-52d2d742dde5453790bec87b81daaa40", "input": "claim: Prostitution Should Be Legal.\n perspective: Prostitution Should Be Legalised to Protect and educate Sex Workers", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a2d3469592814b528bb00902dabe12a8", "input": "claim: Prostitution Should Be Legal.\n perspective: Legalized prostitution would protect sex workers from abuse and educate them about STDs.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-814444b8268c42d5ba1099e94e720484", "input": "claim: Prostitution Should Be Legal.\n perspective: Detrimental to womens rights", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b528fcd5f64c493490d6df348d2bb528", "input": "claim: Prostitution Should Be Legal.\n perspective: Legalizing prostitution opposes women's rights.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-99b2a98ccffa43bdaac3932dc617b04e", "input": "claim: Prostitution Should Be Legal.\n perspective: Markets in sex would corrupt non-market sexual relations, turning women and girls into commodities ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4a3e7080600b4afb981ce5b4a10d84b0", "input": "claim: Prostitution Should Be Legal.\n perspective: Legalization would free up resources that could be devoted to eliminating sex trafficking", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c75b640e4706416eafe88d5bd54acc9d", "input": "claim: Prostitution Should Be Legal.\n perspective: Markets in sexual services undermine the values of commitment and loyalty ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-0e64e3251a2c4f0088a3f9a2a7b81574", "input": "claim: Prostitution Should Be Legal.\n perspective: Sex markets undermine the institution of marriage.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-1293d32ef8fd49479c5c664e578d1686", "input": "claim: Prostitution Should Be Legal.\n perspective: Sex markets are bad for society.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-85f3d7a88d3245d3a4c6ae8e90653d67", "input": "claim: Prostitution Should Be Legal.\n perspective: Society benefits from prostitution.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f8d6b352ac924269b49c01814b439961", "input": "claim: Prostitution Should Be Legal.\n perspective: Prostitution has benefits.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e4fad02564c7461ea5dd2b8ea417edb8", "input": "claim: Prostitution Should Be Legal.\n perspective: Markets in sexual services can serve legitimate needs", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-549d6acd7e7f4d8a94e3b64eb25b9239", "input": "claim: Prostitution Should Be Legal.\n perspective: Sex satisfies certain markets.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f0913767690347cf8532702349e517ea", "input": "claim: Prostitution Should Be Legal.\n perspective: Markets in sexual services can respect sexual autonomy", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d58cf52e2ef642ea84b32c20307b986e", "input": "claim: Prostitution Should Be Legal.\n perspective: People can choose their sexual consumption.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-da4f6f1a97ba4aa5b76f54ef6c851b0f", "input": "claim: Prostitution Should Be Legal.\n perspective: Sex is a choice.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-7ab3bb4f910f45aca28cb2db379a67fe", "input": "claim: It is fine to kill one to save many.\n perspective: We should not will a world where killing is acceptable in to existencele in to existence", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-9663a1ab54624a83bb0c2487898182a5", "input": "claim: It is fine to kill one to save many.\n perspective: It is unacceptable to live in a world where killing is ever justified, no matter how many lives it may save.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-3e8f353de7b44dffb87486c650cfe75c", "input": "claim: It is fine to kill one to save many.\n perspective: We cannot support a world where killing is acceptable as long as it saves lives.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-74564b7d7d14470ba1d2c3ec90ed88ab", "input": "claim: It is fine to kill one to save many.\n perspective: Intuitively, it is possible to understand that participating in a decision to kill is a priori wrong", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-57f5cc47a23d4518b444f6ac456a8ef3", "input": "claim: It is fine to kill one to save many.\n perspective: Intiution explains the reason why the decision to kill is viewed as wrong ,as a general principle.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-fb6487b7972e4f09b347c6f9642b0db7", "input": "claim: It is fine to kill one to save many.\n perspective: The possibility for the universal recogonition that killing is wrong can be deduced by pure intuition.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-9122a27408bf4b09a3f61303d94163b0", "input": "claim: It is fine to kill one to save many.\n perspective: Give a choice, all rational individuals would prefer to live in a world in which behaviour prefered the choice to sacrifice one to save many", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-2eaafe9eb8304cc6bd0c9eec4c7230fc", "input": "claim: It is fine to kill one to save many.\n perspective: When presented with the choice, logical citizens would choose to live in a society that valued the will of the people versus the will of the few.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-05372a3b37b44a12816e461b53a90b14", "input": "claim: It is fine to kill one to save many.\n perspective: All educated people would prefer to live in a world that aligned itself with the principle of saving many at the expense of one, if presented the choice.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c661622bfdbd47e3a0132188c06b1d70", "input": "claim: School vouchers should be encouraged.\n perspective: School vouchers funnel money away from already-struggling public schools and children and redistribute tax dollars to private schools and middle-class children", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-3dc34bc496a04d6b83e7c8c1c6e5bbc2", "input": "claim: School vouchers should be encouraged.\n perspective: School vouchers don't support the poor income people who need it most.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-dee05576427e4f2d8fa87c9691dc52dc", "input": "claim: School vouchers should be encouraged.\n perspective: School vouchers only benefit people who don't need the help.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-98b28d8a68194a8b9ed6016c90413b10", "input": "claim: School vouchers should be encouraged.\n perspective: School vouchers take from the poor and give to other social classes", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4d8a0d445cd04f9097ddff8a7b4db368", "input": "claim: School vouchers should be encouraged.\n perspective: School vouchers will only help the middle-class instead of the poor", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-2c0bb7b24759439db3b9b15ea73ce031", "input": "claim: School vouchers should be encouraged.\n perspective: School vouchers fail to accommodate and support disabled and special-needs students", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-5b9fc3a0913146d1a8284f6532a75227", "input": "claim: School vouchers should be encouraged.\n perspective: School vouchers ignore the special needs community which need lots of extra help.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-aadc5802eb3041f7971550253efa2c24", "input": "claim: School vouchers should be encouraged.\n perspective: There will always be disabled students that need to be looked out for and vouchers ignore that.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-2a192a55283748b8a40ed1bd203b41df", "input": "claim: School vouchers should be encouraged.\n perspective: School vouchers ignore the needs of disabled and special-needs students", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b009b5f77092494ab813bca78622c2b8", "input": "claim: School vouchers should be encouraged.\n perspective: Disabled and special-needs students are not accounted for with school vouchers", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ccc23fdaf0bc42b58bc57e5bba15a152", "input": "claim: School vouchers should be encouraged.\n perspective: School vouchers do not improve students’ academic performance", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-6ff54359e7f5496dab61db9aad53fd88", "input": "claim: School vouchers should be encouraged.\n perspective: Vouchers have no direct correlation to improving academics.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-0957fcd5aed345718f7885644d2fea82", "input": "claim: School vouchers should be encouraged.\n perspective: Vouchers don't make schools better, it does not affect the eucation.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-0deed38acd0540909b0ffc14a44ce6e3", "input": "claim: School vouchers should be encouraged.\n perspective: School vouchers have no effect on the academic performance of the students", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-03e49e97924141b5adbdcbb976117670", "input": "claim: School vouchers should be encouraged.\n perspective: There is no academic impact that comes with the school vouchers", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-f2d24f8bc0464f2783acb3ef4a4da117", "input": "claim: School vouchers should be encouraged.\n perspective: School vouchers allow school districts to overcome racial and other segregations", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-04c8ae50e85548f5bd73331681e7b1d9", "input": "claim: School vouchers should be encouraged.\n perspective: School vouchers offer students in failing schools access to a better education", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-487f743f8a3447cc8ea950831bd51239", "input": "claim: School vouchers should be encouraged.\n perspective: Vouchers allow parents to choose their child’s education", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-edd76e282c684b2595162f3bc4d86d3e", "input": "claim: Polygamous Marriage Should Be Recognised.\n perspective: Psychological harms of polygamy", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-61401273416c454ebb38e1a1ab78c9fe", "input": "claim: Polygamous Marriage Should Be Recognised.\n perspective: Polygamy can cause emotional harm.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-3031adb512164ffaa8990dcfeb6322d9", "input": "claim: Polygamous Marriage Should Be Recognised.\n perspective: It would create demographic imbalance", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-76b3dfc2e3f44aeea2e034d1045ca636", "input": "claim: Polygamous Marriage Should Be Recognised.\n perspective: Demographics would be upset if polygamy was allowed.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-17b4a7c0f31a430f8bccb6eaa07df9bc", "input": "claim: Polygamous Marriage Should Be Recognised.\n perspective: Allowing polygamy to be acceptable would disrupt the structure of society.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-f4e99c4381534edd875b2619c923e068", "input": "claim: Man made climate change is a myth.\n perspective: Science is self correcting", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-2959446f1cd24484858d76d09dd260aa", "input": "claim: Man made climate change is a myth.\n perspective: Lack of scientific understanding", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-94537bc840a942a995e38ba4cb97cbd5", "input": "claim: Actively circumventing Internet censorship is a legitimate foreign policy tool.\n perspective: It is domestic not international legitimacy that matters", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-d91dcd3544f44c66b76b6585ab810a93", "input": "claim: Actively circumventing Internet censorship is a legitimate foreign policy tool.\n perspective: It is legitimate to enable freedom", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-9d8183a9a8d54b0fad7a6ebd061566bd", "input": "claim: Actively circumventing Internet censorship is a legitimate foreign policy tool.\n perspective: This policy is not necessary and may be counterproductive", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-02597f746d254c98bb3d65fdbc32f96b", "input": "claim: Actively circumventing Internet censorship is a legitimate foreign policy tool.\n perspective: It is legitimate to undermine illegitimate governments to promote human rights", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a2405334c5404a0a82d5346e05079b5d", "input": "claim: Actively circumventing Internet censorship is a legitimate foreign policy tool.\n perspective: Aggressive foreign policy is not legitimate foreign policy", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-2af4f2e3c089485287020891d2fcf19e", "input": "claim: Language does control thought.\n perspective: Do we think in words? Are our thoughts in our native language?", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-60d336be26c04fa2b4317271c6a95f10", "input": "claim: Language does control thought.\n perspective: Can we understand concepts we don't have words for?", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d316cffd5e2a4ade8158dba4445b5fd8", "input": "claim: Language does control thought.\n perspective: Can our brain/thoughts function without language?", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a84d078db42d451dbd9219d95a118192", "input": "claim: Language does control thought.\n perspective: Surely thought comes before language", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-02ce6de16fc64fc7bbef62be275a4452", "input": "claim: Language does control thought.\n perspective: Surely thought comes before language.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-90eb5c537f9d44c9b56873b5fb09b13e", "input": "claim: We must colonize moon.\n perspective: There’s nothing more to find out, at least nothing that can’t be done with much cheaper unmanned missions ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-5984d63641864dbd8c07bffecf34e427", "input": "claim: We must colonize moon.\n perspective: It would be the first step in colonizing space – the moon is preferential to Earth as a base for investigating life elsewhere in the universe", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d82eb4dfddca43029a8fca62a4514ca7", "input": "claim: We must colonize moon.\n perspective: Is colonizing the moon the first step to developing space?", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-00bbf097f075453c89df955f69a7bdae", "input": "claim: We must colonize moon.\n perspective: Is the moon the first start to space development?", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-14870d89809b42499b5fd7a1ef3f3356", "input": "claim: We must colonize moon.\n perspective: The technology required for colonizing ‘a second Earth’ would be easier to develop on the moon", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-7137d154eb4c4d438c7a428c1d0a7fa6", "input": "claim: We must colonize moon.\n perspective: A second Earth on the moon is technologically feasible.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-0d7f4a36de9a4b6c9f73771f0cdd1349", "input": "claim: Attorney-client privilege should be abolished.\n perspective: The principle behind attorney-client privilege is declining in relevance", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-64d9cb35be8f47ca8f8037b9499e21f5", "input": "claim: Attorney-client privilege should be abolished.\n perspective: Attorney client privilege need not be sacrosanct in all situations", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-0aa958bdb1bf4feca615cc7939f92fbd", "input": "claim: Companies should provide alternative interview methods.\n perspective: Can't get a realistic impression of a person in such a short space of time.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-7a05e82a940a49cb8b8abd94f69dee50", "input": "claim: Companies should provide alternative interview methods.\n perspective: Would create confusion.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-92dcd60d95754691b38d712a29e039cf", "input": "claim: Fast Food Advertising Should Be Banned.\n perspective: Its a business, a business doing its job", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-51066c4c711f488fabc8264549808bd4", "input": "claim: Fast Food Advertising Should Be Banned.\n perspective: Advertising is a part of a good business plan. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-3630d868bb044ab3ab90dd1b8225639f", "input": "claim: Fast Food Advertising Should Be Banned.\n perspective: A good business needs to look to promote its mission. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-81d20b3bb39449b5aab4891064277f1b", "input": "claim: Fast Food Advertising Should Be Banned.\n perspective: The ban is ineffective in addressing the problem of obesity. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ad0741d4553a4b5b9b07a26a0eef719b", "input": "claim: Fast Food Advertising Should Be Banned.\n perspective: Banning toys in fast food meals will not create healthier food choices.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-fbec4f45c5cd433b912e2fa01597dacb", "input": "claim: Fast Food Advertising Should Be Banned.\n perspective: Such bans are easy to side step. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4f9e0aef6dc6490699d993ae6f5723f1", "input": "claim: Fast Food Advertising Should Be Banned.\n perspective: A variant means to sell the toys separately can be used as an incentive for future food discounts.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-d909685af4984a7dbeab5beb25718a91", "input": "claim: Fast Food Advertising Should Be Banned.\n perspective: Bad nutrition habits start during childhood. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-1df978ba1d734bfcbfcd53b404ffcb46", "input": "claim: Fast Food Advertising Should Be Banned.\n perspective: Advertising should not be allowed to seduce vulnerable children who do not understand what they want.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c7a42e644c5c4a5687638230a93bb9da", "input": "claim: Fast Food Advertising Should Be Banned.\n perspective: Governemnt needs more power over fast food advertising to force children to make the correct choices about their food.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-b2b666f6351b4100a5590dc56a2cc75d", "input": "claim: Africa is really rising.\n perspective: Human development indicators have significantly improved in recent years.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-334ae3e0d8c640ef956c556a24f9b6de", "input": "claim: Africa is really rising.\n perspective: Africa’s Economies are growing rapidly", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-0f4d47242ae54973bcc856133f2f2f1d", "input": "claim: Africa is really rising.\n perspective: Majority of states are still undemocratic", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-be710cd2637a4db7acb622dfba2ddc12", "input": "claim: Africa is really rising.\n perspective: Greater Access to Technology ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-4b06b25d7600461e80590d28888623ac", "input": "claim: Africa is really rising.\n perspective: The Continent is still vulnerable to natural disasters", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-986bc52a1aa54a359b10276783d7bd82", "input": "claim: Africa is really rising.\n perspective: Foreign Direct Investment to the continent has increased", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f77ce6336c9a423d9454a245c784e2a5", "input": "claim: Lack of Parental Guidance Is Mainly Responsible for Children Being Violent and Aggressive in School.\n perspective: Parents are too busy with their careers which leads children to seek attention by being aggressive", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a15279d4daa54e89a4c6216fece8bc67", "input": "claim: Lack of Parental Guidance Is Mainly Responsible for Children Being Violent and Aggressive in School.\n perspective: Missing parents can lead to destructive behavior in their children.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c34b1dbc8276468ea02fc7d0009409db", "input": "claim: Lack of Parental Guidance Is Mainly Responsible for Children Being Violent and Aggressive in School.\n perspective: Parents need to spend time with their children or children's behavior may turn aggressive. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-59e8d5d846dd4d8c89236cc755b00beb", "input": "claim: Sanctions should be used to promote democracy.\n perspective: Sanctions are ineffective because they hurt ordinary people more than leadership.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-046847ba357d43b9aadddb7c3a009d2e", "input": "claim: Sanctions should be used to promote democracy.\n perspective: Sanctions do not harm the right people.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-92f845d390ac468595246b5200311814", "input": "claim: Sanctions should be used to promote democracy.\n perspective: Sanctions are ineffective because they can be counterproductive.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-3ad7410f90704327ab8395a46bfa18fd", "input": "claim: Sanctions should be used to promote democracy.\n perspective: Sanctions cause more harm than good.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-630e51ccff1040529f2aca039a02b9e7", "input": "claim: Sanctions should be used to promote democracy.\n perspective: Sanctions can backfire.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-2d13ea916bac4146a5d6567d338fadb9", "input": "claim: Goal line technology has to be adopted in football.\n perspective: The dynamics of football as a game are very different from other sports which currently use technology", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-f8b304d4d0584501bb4089d89060f43d", "input": "claim: Goal line technology has to be adopted in football.\n perspective: The introduction of technology is inevitable", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-06a78dd88b274dfcbff847e3aba3cbba", "input": "claim: Goal line technology has to be adopted in football.\n perspective: The cost would not match FIFA's aim of opening football to the world", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-2f9d51d2c6054ff1942cb147e8db93dc", "input": "claim: Goal line technology has to be adopted in football.\n perspective: The cost of GLT is unjustified for a relatively rare scenario", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-0022885f13094f70978577b2cc301032", "input": "claim: Goal line technology has to be adopted in football.\n perspective: GLT is used across a range of other sports", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-94e21a3d28ba4b05bffc2783bac23776", "input": "claim: Goal line technology has to be adopted in football.\n perspective: Technology is available", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e08bd1a965b34a0f91e2ba69c5cdf01a", "input": "claim: Goal line technology has to be adopted in football.\n perspective: Technology is more reliable than human judgement", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-39f939a0712f401fbeae32b742d9fc0a", "input": "claim: Goal line technology has to be adopted in football.\n perspective: Human judgement is never without prejudice which makes technology more reliable. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c360b4e0f06f49eab94c3a662e51a09e", "input": "claim: Goal line technology has to be adopted in football.\n perspective: Technology relies of facts and figures without the corrupting influence of opinions or morals. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-848056c19b3b44b6b7b09796a2a2be1d", "input": "claim: We should expand NATO.\n perspective: NATO expansion would benefit eastern European and post Soviet states", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-13b76665c6734da48e2caefc085f1d43", "input": "claim: We should expand NATO.\n perspective: Eastern European and post Soviet states would benefit from NATO expansion.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-55c8b8f29a6647aa83afae77aa7e1636", "input": "claim: We should expand NATO.\n perspective: The expansion of NATO would be beneficial for eastern European and post Soviet states.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a2656705dce54ba48d823b0893b640e5", "input": "claim: We should expand NATO.\n perspective: NATO development would profit eastern European and post Soviet states", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-aa0ad17be5f842d6b82c747c323a4815", "input": "claim: We should expand NATO.\n perspective: NATO establishments would profit eastern European and post Soviet states", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-7476037452664315aa744de0f3339efd", "input": "claim: We should expand NATO.\n perspective: Russia is no longer a threat", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ade9d37495084d05b9223136c6542e10", "input": "claim: We should expand NATO.\n perspective: NATO expansion was, and is, necessary for international stability", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d69539cc974b4ecfb348e0e41a3c610c", "input": "claim: We should expand NATO.\n perspective: NATO expansion has always been necessary for international stability. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-506fa15a161f446583ae311adda98072", "input": "claim: We should expand NATO.\n perspective: International stability is only possible with NATO expansion.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a9cf571c02ca47f296cc8b062af74d19", "input": "claim: We should expand NATO.\n perspective: NATO expansion was essential for international stability ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-1a9043e2fcb5446cb65c34b9bd38ebcb", "input": "claim: We should expand NATO.\n perspective: Further expansion of NATO will antagonise Russia", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-31d8e0116fd348fe8146d647c59c3d35", "input": "claim: The world should re-engage with Myanmar.\n perspective: Regional factors favour re-engagement", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-58d68a55eded4b1f956ef0681b7a40a5", "input": "claim: The world should re-engage with Myanmar.\n perspective: Regional factors show re-engagement would be positive.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e5cc95fa81a1471fabba545074271503", "input": "claim: The world should re-engage with Myanmar.\n perspective: Positive outcomes can be expected from re-engagement.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-5ed825e10ba34b0eb207ce0f18ea3095", "input": "claim: The world should re-engage with Myanmar.\n perspective: Re-engagement will weaken the reform movement", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-03c758fa0a284b1a9afc134ff146002b", "input": "claim: The world should re-engage with Myanmar.\n perspective: The reform movement will be harmed by re-engagement.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4d0dc009b08a41fe953483579d18cf3a", "input": "claim: The world should re-engage with Myanmar.\n perspective: Re-engagement will do more harm than good.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-7ac58a783f0e4d308a5e9f8bef2d3f14", "input": "claim: The world should re-engage with Myanmar.\n perspective: Vested international interest are harming Myanmar", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-698cd56ffd094b7aacdab042a11c5d2d", "input": "claim: The world should re-engage with Myanmar.\n perspective: Disengagement has done more harm than good in the region", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d6dba3e658db4b1f96e442524d413cdc", "input": "claim: The world should re-engage with Myanmar.\n perspective: This region would benefit from re-engagement.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-39c4d301d1bd47bbb7651edf7365280e", "input": "claim: The world should re-engage with Myanmar.\n perspective: Re-engagement is the best option for this region.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d65160986c3a4a85bf13bffef42307bd", "input": "claim: The world should re-engage with Myanmar.\n perspective: States should not be isolated on political grounds", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-b97981dc44db418380b15e3c9e9dd586", "input": "claim: The world should re-engage with Myanmar.\n perspective: political grounds should not isolate states", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-206d9275fe414d67a23c22e88c08ba3e", "input": "claim: The world should re-engage with Myanmar.\n perspective: states should be united despite political grounds.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-0e49c4e70d7e4af1a105cf808259e74e", "input": "claim: Those affected by climate change should get compensation.\n perspective: It is hard to apportion blame", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-7cce8e3b1bfb4441807f03fac58729ae", "input": "claim: Tablets should replace textbooks in K-12 schools.\n perspective: Tablets have too many distractions for classroom use.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-bfecbf62264b4387ae1519174a3879f5", "input": "claim: Tablets should replace textbooks in K-12 schools.\n perspective: There are too many ways the tablets could distract from education.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-f499de3ba91446049dd9b8096bebb030", "input": "claim: Tablets should replace textbooks in K-12 schools.\n perspective: Students could use the tablets in distracting ways.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-be789ef271804e9ca2e2b38764c62549", "input": "claim: Tablets should replace textbooks in K-12 schools.\n perspective: Tablets are unnecessary because print textbooks that are not brand new still convey relevant information to K-12 students.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-871676c4ddfd4ab19592804eb103b9d6", "input": "claim: Tablets should replace textbooks in K-12 schools.\n perspective: The textbooks that are already available still convey relevant info for students.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c26387d64e4e4785aadfd7c539cb6870", "input": "claim: Tablets should replace textbooks in K-12 schools.\n perspective: Students already get the relevant information needed with textbooks.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-77d316a0904542439472366ea7f1a4fa", "input": "claim: Tablets should replace textbooks in K-12 schools.\n perspective: The higher cost of tablets marginalizes poorer school districts and increases the \"digital divide.\"", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-dad924de7f95473c9fe5c8a053436741", "input": "claim: Tablets should replace textbooks in K-12 schools.\n perspective: Tablets in K-12 schools have higher costs than textbooks and therefore increases the digital divide.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-014f5d59d0054e968e1339bdf24ddb35", "input": "claim: Tablets should replace textbooks in K-12 schools.\n perspective: TOPIC #7: Should tablets replace textbooks in K 12 schools?", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-90896ca6e607406ba6fe4f1257632bfc", "input": "claim: Tablets should replace textbooks in K-12 schools.\n perspective: Using tablets is more expensive than using print textbooks.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-d012ab9a9c2f41aa8c6d5e82875fb157", "input": "claim: Tablets should replace textbooks in K-12 schools.\n perspective: It would be expensive to use tablets instead of books.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-aab384b494284419aba4d25d0af3110e", "input": "claim: Tablets should replace textbooks in K-12 schools.\n perspective: Print textbooks cannot crash, freeze, or get hacked.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-0f992101e5d34149a511af73ec175496", "input": "claim: Tablets should replace textbooks in K-12 schools.\n perspective: Written textbooks are safer because they do not suffer from risks technology does.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-fa07d22f8bb3496d9f7b15883bc4a4a0", "input": "claim: Tablets should replace textbooks in K-12 schools.\n perspective: Handheld technological devices including tablets are associated with a range of health problems.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-77e82714fe5e488cafab4b0c4f0e6258", "input": "claim: Tablets should replace textbooks in K-12 schools.\n perspective: Tablets lead to student health issues.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-7583bc3f18ad43929044145a35c50222", "input": "claim: Tablets should replace textbooks in K-12 schools.\n perspective: Student health is harmed by tablet use.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-8d8068d761824fe7b212132d32c88562", "input": "claim: Tablets should replace textbooks in K-12 schools.\n perspective: Many students do not have sufficient home internet bandwidth to use tablets.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-5c0b1d9b5ff84d599601ba7112481845", "input": "claim: Tablets should replace textbooks in K-12 schools.\n perspective: Not all students could use the tablets at home.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-337a6541a88b446d85baa929584621a5", "input": "claim: Tablets should replace textbooks in K-12 schools.\n perspective: Students without home internet would be at a disadvantage.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-8a0f074b156f4a929c40fc399f21e7c0", "input": "claim: Tablets should replace textbooks in K-12 schools.\n perspective: Tablets help students better prepare for a world immersed in technology.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-4fc6d234f65443f185ce880ba3a2d736", "input": "claim: Tablets should replace textbooks in K-12 schools.\n perspective: A world of technology needs education that uses said technology.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-2ef54ccebabe44228f5a7d052035e018", "input": "claim: Tablets should replace textbooks in K-12 schools.\n perspective: Plain text books do not adequately prepare students for the real technological world.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-26015aa0f6544701b9e3d5fceaf4168f", "input": "claim: Tablets should replace textbooks in K-12 schools.\n perspective: Files on one tablet can be downloaded onto any other tablet, increasing flexibility and convenience for teachers and students.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-174177711a2441428c477407d37e2ae1", "input": "claim: Tablets should replace textbooks in K-12 schools.\n perspective: Files on tablets can be easily shared.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f02ee71568264e6a9d32c946c7bae8ca", "input": "claim: Tablets should replace textbooks in K-12 schools.\n perspective: Tablets allow greater flexibility.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-0bc11e9b2e7f499aab1fb662cc952537", "input": "claim: Tablets should replace textbooks in K-12 schools.\n perspective: Files can be shared to any other tablet for easy sharing.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-b3c077ae990e4ca9b93a076e0ba4c5f4", "input": "claim: Tablets should replace textbooks in K-12 schools.\n perspective: Tablets can easily send and receive all information any other student and teacher may have.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c52193f05fd049189610bbaaec6f2ce3", "input": "claim: Tablets should replace textbooks in K-12 schools.\n perspective: Tablets lower the amount of paper teachers have to print for handouts and assignments, helping to save the environment and money.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-30c57cedf85140dda43a46f01aef4825", "input": "claim: Tablets should replace textbooks in K-12 schools.\n perspective: More e-books mean less environmental waste.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-4fa4503835914793a8a349023bbc3c66", "input": "claim: Tablets should replace textbooks in K-12 schools.\n perspective: Using a tablet is so intuitive that it makes learning fun and easy.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e90a1ae87eb743aa92d0b41d00364046", "input": "claim: Tablets should replace textbooks in K-12 schools.\n perspective: Because tablets are easy to use, students find them fun.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-35c5f51ed57145fbab5ab32c713482bc", "input": "claim: Tablets should replace textbooks in K-12 schools.\n perspective: Tablets are easy to understand and make learning fun.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-bf6eb6327dd14549a5e82c3c67a14c16", "input": "claim: Tablets should replace textbooks in K-12 schools.\n perspective: The average battery life of a tablet is 7.26 hours, shorter than the length of a school day.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-3cc2e61673a5431d908b48c7d89c3ce5", "input": "claim: Tablets should replace textbooks in K-12 schools.\n perspective: Tablets contain many technological features that cannot be found in print textbooks.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d9e503ebc4354fb8840009164ef6b971", "input": "claim: Tablets should replace textbooks in K-12 schools.\n perspective: Textbooks alone can't keep up with modern technology.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-6e0cb8c4018b45ef8ca248c04046def6", "input": "claim: Tablets should replace textbooks in K-12 schools.\n perspective: Tablets let the students see information in new ways.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-bc380bb254a941a59245a3fcc8ab37bc", "input": "claim: Tablets should replace textbooks in K-12 schools.\n perspective: Tablets allow teachers to better customize student learning.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a24a9ddb63174d1cb23436eb17c4ea9a", "input": "claim: Tablets should replace textbooks in K-12 schools.\n perspective: Student learning can be customized using tablets", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c1fd734cd2544fe4bc895a6f0b0c1efc", "input": "claim: Tablets should replace textbooks in K-12 schools.\n perspective: Tablets make it easier to adjust individual learning plans for students.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-6fcbdb36fe554440b2fad93081bb4079", "input": "claim: Tablets should replace textbooks in K-12 schools.\n perspective: 81% of K-12 teachers believe that \"tablets enrich classroom education.\"", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-8b8b7cd23d1a42a1a3f2dda483aed056", "input": "claim: Tablets should replace textbooks in K-12 schools.\n perspective: There is a ratio of 81% of the K-12 teachers who believe \"tablets enrich classroom education.\"", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-9467c0d4a38b42d189966cfc6ad899c8", "input": "claim: Tablets should replace textbooks in K-12 schools.\n perspective: A good 81% of K-12 teachers believe when it is said \"tablets enrich classroom education.\"", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-764a90d9fce94c1db021e2c621f9928d", "input": "claim: Tablets should replace textbooks in K-12 schools.\n perspective: High-level education officials support tablets over textbooks.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f47bc656694b4bb3ae903e72d7689ab7", "input": "claim: Tablets should replace textbooks in K-12 schools.\n perspective: High-level education likes the use of tablets over textbooks. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-b5ea0325d36b45b5af5f4592b3df923c", "input": "claim: Tablets should replace textbooks in K-12 schools.\n perspective: Tablets may be too difficult for less-technologically-savvy students to operate.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e8c43a56b56242ad93168f98804f16aa", "input": "claim: Tablets should replace textbooks in K-12 schools.\n perspective: Not all students are tech savvy enough to operate a tablet.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-572ad6f462ff41729e0c35b64bb0eb6f", "input": "claim: Tablets should replace textbooks in K-12 schools.\n perspective: Tablets may be too difficult for less technologically savvy students", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-062e81c3f69845edb647cc498fba380c", "input": "claim: Tablets should replace textbooks in K-12 schools.\n perspective: Students may increase the number of excuses for not doing their schoolwork if tablets replace textbooks.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-70f02bf82e4a4594aa146f483004fce6", "input": "claim: Tablets should replace textbooks in K-12 schools.\n perspective: If textbooks are replaced with tablets, students will come up with more excuses for not doing their schoolwork.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-1127e367ca2d46878f45923a06a0f3c8", "input": "claim: Tablets should replace textbooks in K-12 schools.\n perspective: Tablets increase the number of excuses", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b3d8f307e85e481d9b46838305884821", "input": "claim: Tablets should replace textbooks in K-12 schools.\n perspective: People who read print text comprehend more, remember more, and learn more than those who read digital text.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-528b321e73e44440bb420bf0f4db3b30", "input": "claim: Tablets should replace textbooks in K-12 schools.\n perspective: Students learn better from books than from screens.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-6558567055f0409c96474e2e402f9966", "input": "claim: Tablets should replace textbooks in K-12 schools.\n perspective: Tablets enable students to cut corners or cheat on schoolwork.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-f1b74990f30f4b01bcacf84f70211c91", "input": "claim: Tablets should replace textbooks in K-12 schools.\n perspective: Tablets pose greater risk to academic integrity than textbooks.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-528b25739314421aae7fb9964dfa6f17", "input": "claim: Tablets should replace textbooks in K-12 schools.\n perspective: Many textbooks are not available in digital format or on the specific tablet used by a school.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-530b967ec8e041ab97901df71ff3f87e", "input": "claim: Tablets should replace textbooks in K-12 schools.\n perspective: There are many types of tablets and some do not have the textbooks needed in the school.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c1f42568662a49d580975777f109db1b", "input": "claim: Tablets should replace textbooks in K-12 schools.\n perspective: If tablets replace textbooks in K-12, there may be instances where the required textbook is not available.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-2c9f2fc74f0c4c4d87dc308e6fc03969", "input": "claim: Tablets should replace textbooks in K-12 schools.\n perspective: Tablets help students learn more material faster.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-15ff6eae8f4d42b6b0978f01dc594172", "input": "claim: Tablets should replace textbooks in K-12 schools.\n perspective: Tablets increase student material absortion.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a5a150875ac04479a8222bac166098be", "input": "claim: Tablets should replace textbooks in K-12 schools.\n perspective: Tablets cause students to learn material more quickly.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-dbb61826b47b4186b80aada05e3a896a", "input": "claim: Tablets should replace textbooks in K-12 schools.\n perspective: E-textbooks on tablets cost on average 50-60% less than print textbooks.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-5edf88788b164a4db49067fb33e52c5b", "input": "claim: Tablets should replace textbooks in K-12 schools.\n perspective: There is a 50-60% cost reduction for getting books tablets than printing them physically.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-4f5027cae847449eaae218a91f5df892", "input": "claim: Tablets should replace textbooks in K-12 schools.\n perspective: The cost of printing textbooks vs getting them on a tablet means there is a 50-60% reduction in price to get them on a tablet than printed.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-0b2e6a3ef5bd49f495c96c2f92d5b81b", "input": "claim: Tablets should replace textbooks in K-12 schools.\n perspective: On a tablet, e-textbooks can be updated instantly to get new editions or information.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f040c2c133ca464bbec691e990dfaacf", "input": "claim: Tablets should replace textbooks in K-12 schools.\n perspective: Unlike textbooks, online texts are more easily updated.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-8fefeea7d6744a0a833535fe6e0071d0", "input": "claim: Tablets should replace textbooks in K-12 schools.\n perspective: New information is much easier to add to e-texts than traditional texts.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d3d793e76fdf47e98e12f6b8982138f3", "input": "claim: Tablets should replace textbooks in K-12 schools.\n perspective: Tablets can hold hundreds of textbooks on one device, plus homework, quizzes, and other files, eliminating the need for physical storage of books and classroom materials.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-7ba2b07228aa4aac8c26ccefcfa844d2", "input": "claim: Tablets should replace textbooks in K-12 schools.\n perspective: Tablets are able to store hundreds of textbooks on one single device, including homework, quizzes and files and it also takes away the need to have to store books and materials for the class physically.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f4a172d3c6aa4fb1a0ecf0b3f53df631", "input": "claim: Tablets should replace textbooks in K-12 schools.\n perspective: It is possible for a tablet to hold hundreds of textbooks on one device itself, which includes homework, quizzes, files of other nature and helps to remove the need to physically store classroom materials and books.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-cbfca233c81f42aeb5c7716d58382f6a", "input": "claim: Tablets should replace textbooks in K-12 schools.\n perspective: Tablets are more susceptible to theft than print textbooks.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-1ba6110e451a49c7a8159db06705f626", "input": "claim: Tablets should replace textbooks in K-12 schools.\n perspective: Print textbooks are less likely to be stolen than tablets.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e80072c4d28943a1b29a842abab4f8a2", "input": "claim: Tablets should replace textbooks in K-12 schools.\n perspective: Tablets pose a greater risk to personal security as they are more prone to theft.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a1ba98db238e459eb500aa748525b12e", "input": "claim: Tablets should replace textbooks in K-12 schools.\n perspective: Students who own tablets purchase and read more books than those who read print books alone.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-fb88b220c18b40849781dda4b42faad4", "input": "claim: Tablets should replace textbooks in K-12 schools.\n perspective: Tablets are shown to increase student reading.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-23d1caee7d9a49bfa69c875f5b577315", "input": "claim: Tablets should replace textbooks in K-12 schools.\n perspective: Students read more on tablets than on paper.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-359b83b6ad514d9fbcc1de124855be84", "input": "claim: Tablets should replace textbooks in K-12 schools.\n perspective: Manufacturing tablets is environmentally destructive and dangerous to human health.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-bcab6e1000e44523a69cab3e57063076", "input": "claim: Tablets should replace textbooks in K-12 schools.\n perspective: Replacing textbooks with tablets can lead to dangerous consequences for human and environmental health.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-bed13b3233cf4bfe9062e596ee4726fa", "input": "claim: Tablets should replace textbooks in K-12 schools.\n perspective: Tablets help to improve student achievement on standardized tests.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-08d75d02900449499dcbb6021bb75e99", "input": "claim: Tablets should replace textbooks in K-12 schools.\n perspective: Tablets assist students in passing exams.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-b9cfa9322f2d4688a55bf68a9ebefb59", "input": "claim: Provide breakfast for all school students.\n perspective: A school breakfast gives all students an equal start to the day", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-5d052851b1f84bf1b507bd02c1f0e681", "input": "claim: Provide breakfast for all school students.\n perspective: School breakfast is a great way to give all students a balanced and healthy start to their day.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ed934ca377fd405d81cffaf29a551913", "input": "claim: Provide breakfast for all school students.\n perspective: Free breakfasts for school children ensures a healthy start equally for all.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-4e40c0b4682a4cb186a6ac70e639437e", "input": "claim: Provide breakfast for all school students.\n perspective: Nutrition is the parents responsibility", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c5927b39aa834cf99fe7ec2ebcda59f4", "input": "claim: Provide breakfast for all school students.\n perspective: School students are to arrive every morning having had a nutritious breakfast.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-9e7388aab5f24a2589264198e9037d2e", "input": "claim: Provide breakfast for all school students.\n perspective: Parents should provide a nutritious breakfast to their children every morning before they arrive at school ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-5212f7f1280045068739b71ee37d92d2", "input": "claim: Provide breakfast for all school students.\n perspective: A school breakfast for all is a greater cost on schools", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b14ae5cfe5f34a6f9f271f18f704e7eb", "input": "claim: Provide breakfast for all school students.\n perspective: Schools are best places to ensure good nutrition", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-5dc8f5a40e78475a8dbb65e98e9a3bf4", "input": "claim: Provide breakfast for all school students.\n perspective: Good nutrition can be provided effectively to our children at school.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-05345c1bd96444e18faa6a638b63e53d", "input": "claim: Provide breakfast for all school students.\n perspective: Breakfast teaches about health", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-85a1ff723f784a4698480da3fc09fbec", "input": "claim: Provide breakfast for all school students.\n perspective: A healthy breakfast improves students concentration", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d046abfb464b4467ad336f107125dda3", "input": "claim: Provide breakfast for all school students.\n perspective: Government should focus on the most needy", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-0964273dd23e48f1ae9db3e7c8f082ca", "input": "claim: We have to consider a large scale cyber attack an act of war.\n perspective: Definition of a large scale cyber attack is extremely vague ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-954ee25743dd42fcaae3ecf7dea3ecd5", "input": "claim: The age of consent laws should be lowered.\n perspective: Lowering the age of consent will cause criminal dangers. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ada6e8ca22bf483696481c1bda891b26", "input": "claim: The age of consent laws should be lowered.\n perspective: If the consent age is lowered, more people will be in danger.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-f676e79c7af945339971f21c1f6cf232", "input": "claim: The age of consent laws should be lowered.\n perspective: Lowering the age of consent will increase crimes and potential victims.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a7b256976e49470cbd1fa09cdd3d4f87", "input": "claim: The age of consent laws should be lowered.\n perspective: There will be more criminal danger if the age of consent is lowered", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4c6ceb1f307549169bac5568705306a3", "input": "claim: It is a good idea to have a system of participatory democracy.\n perspective: Participation Is Good In Itself", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-3df4a7b561b44edcb8c18473d3048b8b", "input": "claim: It is a good idea to have a system of participatory democracy.\n perspective: Participatory Democracy Preserves our Natural Liberty ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c729f28d400e443a826a3022ecdc47ff", "input": "claim: It is a good idea to have a system of participatory democracy.\n perspective: Participatory Democracy Produces Better Decisions ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-3966391fafd2446086515e9fa44a2d49", "input": "claim: It is a good idea to have a system of participatory democracy.\n perspective: Participatory Democracy Facilitates the Misrepresentation of Issues ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-43f6ff1e36534b83b6f46dcec3a0fbad", "input": "claim: Subsidise the translation of academic work in the languages of developing countries.\n perspective: Translation allows greater participation by academics in global academia and global marketplace of ideas", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-3218ee45fa89466e956462c5b17dad6e", "input": "claim: Subsidise the translation of academic work in the languages of developing countries.\n perspective: Academic participation is improved on a global scale with the use of translation of academic work.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-83e23b0da9f849ed80c03545814f6fc9", "input": "claim: Subsidise the translation of academic work in the languages of developing countries.\n perspective: It is prohibitively expensive to translate everything and difficult to prioritize what to translate", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-afc80de95a55464983f50259ee31d2ac", "input": "claim: Subsidise the translation of academic work in the languages of developing countries.\n perspective: Deciding what to translate is timely and costly.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a525d137fa784f49bdba0d9220a68556", "input": "claim: Subsidise the translation of academic work in the languages of developing countries.\n perspective: It is better to have fewer languages in common use in global academic and economic interrelations", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-8d321ee3ad2049e9ac8ddc7b36a3153e", "input": "claim: Subsidise the translation of academic work in the languages of developing countries.\n perspective: Global relations between countries and academias benefit from fewer and more universal languages being implemented.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-7b82564b2ec542ab927bec329d46ee50", "input": "claim: Subsidise the translation of academic work in the languages of developing countries.\n perspective: The West has no particular obligation to undergo such a sweeping policy", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e8803672b08f4b55aa3143486b879320", "input": "claim: Subsidise the translation of academic work in the languages of developing countries.\n perspective: Countries in the West have no responsibility to translate their academic work.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-07150fe454124882b97ad4932880c495", "input": "claim: Subsidise the translation of academic work in the languages of developing countries.\n perspective: Translating academic work is not neccessary for countries in the West.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4968fe23a54145dc936391823ee64242", "input": "claim: Subsidise the translation of academic work in the languages of developing countries.\n perspective: Translation expands the knowledge base of citizens to help solve local problems", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d4141cba227749beab7f7964b4c9ec4c", "input": "claim: Subsidise the translation of academic work in the languages of developing countries.\n perspective: Citizens can resolve problems affecting them locally through the translation of various academic works.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-479093b1addb4ee28e87b39e183a2de2", "input": "claim: Subsidise the translation of academic work in the languages of developing countries.\n perspective: Translation gives access to students to learn valuable information and develop their human capital and to become academically and economically competitive", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-35c3989dd95b46da92651fd0179dbc3c", "input": "claim: Subsidise the translation of academic work in the languages of developing countries.\n perspective: The translation of academic work gives students a better oppurtunity to learn crucial info and improve their academic capabilities.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-05d06facb6524c71a9d10f624c651464", "input": "claim: Subsidise the translation of academic work in the languages of developing countries.\n perspective: A student can improve academically and become more competitive through the translation of important academic work.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-0b346f6057364149abaaa215f1af5837", "input": "claim: Technological advancement promotes materialistic society.\n perspective: \"Materialistic\" by whose standards - and why would technology make people more materialistic than what they already are? ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-5d53329f59f7402b825a1ae45135af34", "input": "claim: A legal qualification is worth the cost.\n perspective: The debt incurred in the pursuit of a law degree limits options both within the legal industry, and outside of it, by compelling recipients to seek out the highest paying jobs.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-673483a2e9904c54b657762a82049464", "input": "claim: A legal qualification is worth the cost.\n perspective: Failing a law degree can be extremely costly. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-33dd1fdc973544bc948d56e3c8408268", "input": "claim: Create an international treaty/ban on cyber-attacks.\n perspective: A cyber treaty benefits everyone", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-55bbe214500642c69459ee80383afed1", "input": "claim: Create an international treaty/ban on cyber-attacks.\n perspective: States will monitor each other, and an international body could be set up", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-48e4472e07d14a43874148454988008e", "input": "claim: Create an international treaty/ban on cyber-attacks.\n perspective: It would never work", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-650b135c9bae480ba6e03bca99f1b8d6", "input": "claim: Create an international treaty/ban on cyber-attacks.\n perspective: Arenas of potential conflict must be regulated", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-33df260158ac460eba0ff7b1b369677c", "input": "claim: Create an international treaty/ban on cyber-attacks.\n perspective: Unlike warfare cyber-attacks don’t kill so they don’t need to be restricted in the same way", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ab5af8224faa48c2865187f8a8d00353", "input": "claim: We have to employ mercenaries.\n perspective: PMCs are untrustworthy", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e75408d80a49471b90a5a343e88403c3", "input": "claim: We have to employ mercenaries.\n perspective: PMCs are unpredictable.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-772e76685c1f499cba6c4954c487edcb", "input": "claim: We have to employ mercenaries.\n perspective: PMCs can not be trusted.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a3b4413adddb4cbdbf58cda3c5688a64", "input": "claim: We have to employ mercenaries.\n perspective: PMCs can be made much more legitimate by regulation", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-9a61828d35794b1a96612eebc1060cdc", "input": "claim: We have to employ mercenaries.\n perspective: PMCs attract less attention and suspicion and can carry out their role more effectively.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-aee0bd07ced44c329ec2a228240faecd", "input": "claim: We have to employ mercenaries.\n perspective: PMCs are a valuable resource", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-584e9dcbdafc4ea29b187f14b8b86e8b", "input": "claim: We have to employ mercenaries.\n perspective: PMCs have an equally strong incentive to perform.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e93da74b4f1a40538159ebe8b818a9e8", "input": "claim: We have to employ mercenaries.\n perspective: strong incentive to perform is equal with PMCs", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-56d0ed0e99494844a02bf446ab1e0e61", "input": "claim: We have to employ mercenaries.\n perspective: PMCs provide a service that may be otherwise unavailable.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-2caff65d42c64e7b8e4f8d0caeaabe1e", "input": "claim: We have to employ mercenaries.\n perspective: there are some services that you cannot get without PMC's", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-9cd82f921dd94d1ab70a94a289f403b8", "input": "claim: Receiving multiple vaccines are safe.\n perspective: Multiple vaccines serve millions with improved immunity ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c4f73e8cd29b4ef1aabdabefb65df841", "input": "claim: Receiving multiple vaccines are safe.\n perspective: All vaccinations are tested rigorously before they are approved, and tracked afterwards ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-b708b1beeb444b7faf3df5ccd5ebbf78", "input": "claim: Receiving multiple vaccines are safe.\n perspective: Vaccinations have to past rigorous testing before and after approval", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-afb204a993a041f3a797af8ab03d6e3c", "input": "claim: Receiving multiple vaccines are safe.\n perspective: Cases prove that vaccines have bad consequences for children’s health", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-3d3f7f05665441a48512f8142f33906d", "input": "claim: Receiving multiple vaccines are safe.\n perspective: There are cases to prove that our children's health is negatively affected by vaccines. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c358cab6ca5741bd87c0be4a78e6c1f0", "input": "claim: Receiving multiple vaccines are safe.\n perspective: Childhood Vaccines are NOT Safe", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-11c4bd74dd6a4905b6ce90253959ca27", "input": "claim: Receiving multiple vaccines are safe.\n perspective: Vaccines are bad for children’s health, cases prove", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-bc84d0831e584b2493facadbc2741388", "input": "claim: Receiving multiple vaccines are safe.\n perspective: Multiple vaccines cause no harm ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c7bf14b19f384c8b9b5e50ee76e10cc0", "input": "claim: Receiving multiple vaccines are safe.\n perspective: There is no reason to believe that multiple vaccines, such as Tdap, cause any harm to the patient", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-8591d5c054484b2db291427b69d07636", "input": "claim: Receiving multiple vaccines are safe.\n perspective: There are no links between multiple vaccines and autism or multiple sclerosis", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e5f671552e884965932c0c0d42ee3141", "input": "claim: Receiving multiple vaccines are safe.\n perspective: More vaccines together destroy the immune system ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-86f5b9beaca64ea0ac393e2ac6dd89e3", "input": "claim: Receiving multiple vaccines are safe.\n perspective: The immune system is destroyed by more vaccines. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-1ba1bc0c376e40bd880b01c4947c78d5", "input": "claim: Receiving multiple vaccines are safe.\n perspective: Vaccines taken together are destroying the immune systems. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-0c6084629c1442acbe63b9d3d53c3e3b", "input": "claim: Receiving multiple vaccines are safe.\n perspective: Several vaccines Dysregulate The Immune System", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-32f04c501ae6432daf3b9d61036d9969", "input": "claim: Western democracies should openly try to circumvent Internet censorship in oppressive regimes.\n perspective: This policy alienates the oppressive regimes and stifles the change that discourse and positive interaction can bring", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-358a4e8357fc4b65b9273f0269bbb3a0", "input": "claim: Western democracies should openly try to circumvent Internet censorship in oppressive regimes.\n perspective: Circumvention of internet censorship will galvanize more severe, physical repression to compensate its need for security", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-2ce7fd142b5b476aa19e9ae4db770f89", "input": "claim: Gender quotas in the EU are advantageous for the economies of member states.\n perspective: Quota-led gender equality in executive boards will help shape a gender sensitive and highly performing business environment.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-3cc357a6e5ef42c98c0ad74fd40183c9", "input": "claim: Gender quotas in the EU are advantageous for the economies of member states.\n perspective: EU gender quotas have promoted gender equality in executive boards, creating an environment suited to producing high performance results, ultimately benefiting the greater economy of the member state", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e62f4ba1e5ff45ec97a9e9b8f47fd4ec", "input": "claim: Gender quotas in the EU are advantageous for the economies of member states.\n perspective: Executive boards are becoming more gender-equal, which has helped shape professional cultures that are gender sensitive and performance driven, increasing their overall contribution to the member state's economy", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-cded6edf25c04824a582dd8cf92565ae", "input": "claim: Gender quotas in the EU are advantageous for the economies of member states.\n perspective: More women in the labour market leads to higher GDP ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c0510009afc94799b05c64bae8d232f9", "input": "claim: Gender quotas in the EU are advantageous for the economies of member states.\n perspective: Increasing numbers of women workers due to gender quotas has increased the GDP in many EU countries", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d324d3c6c68641b0ac97fd78e71c481c", "input": "claim: Gender quotas in the EU are advantageous for the economies of member states.\n perspective: Gender quotas and increasing numbers of women workers continue to push EU member states' GDPs higher", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-5cc9f7b33da24717919b0a2a5ec57945", "input": "claim: Gender quotas in the EU are advantageous for the economies of member states.\n perspective: Quotas encourage women to pursue education and professional job positions ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-fe8cd7ca45a241e8a5058ffa4791af19", "input": "claim: Gender quotas in the EU are advantageous for the economies of member states.\n perspective: More women are attending college and entering the professional job market due to gender quotas that are proving economically advantageous for EU member states", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-9c7c6ad9dcfa451cb4403b1d124c2a4e", "input": "claim: Gender quotas in the EU are advantageous for the economies of member states.\n perspective: Gender quotas are proving to have significant advantages as more women are seeking education and increasing their economic potentials as they enter the job market. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-4be21a958708408da9db94fc4614c74b", "input": "claim: Gender quotas in the EU are advantageous for the economies of member states.\n perspective: There is no clear link between gender quota and economic growth", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e4a5864b19fe47e8819ca8b52a3f90d0", "input": "claim: Gender quotas in the EU are advantageous for the economies of member states.\n perspective: Economic growth is not associated with implementation of gender quotas.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-19b1e0c2eb9742a48292b451c5faba6d", "input": "claim: Gender quotas in the EU are advantageous for the economies of member states.\n perspective: Use of gender quotas has not been found to improve economic growth.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-5d2e6c8c5d684fbeb53649ac031c872e", "input": "claim: Gender quotas in the EU are advantageous for the economies of member states.\n perspective: The EU should be more active in combating the abuse of human rights.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-90277e6b6861476aa213cc99814f3a29", "input": "claim: Gender quotas in the EU are advantageous for the economies of member states.\n perspective: The EU needs to help those suffering from human rights abuses", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c7ef2c8c4b8f442090006bff8e8dcb5b", "input": "claim: Gender quotas in the EU are advantageous for the economies of member states.\n perspective: Gender equality is based on fundamental human rights endorsed by the EU which needs to be addressed", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-2305b80f35094309a03ea0d9168723ad", "input": "claim: Gender quotas in the EU are advantageous for the economies of member states.\n perspective: Public and private institutions should hire people based on skills not gender to achieve positive economic impact ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-2f0f49ac1af948cb90d9ab8e2f7bab89", "input": "claim: Gender quotas in the EU are advantageous for the economies of member states.\n perspective: Positive economic impact is only possible if institutions hire people on the basis of skill not gender.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c1e492ce30334801b17df0ca63e50f5d", "input": "claim: Gender quotas in the EU are advantageous for the economies of member states.\n perspective: Institutions should focus on hiring people on the skills they possess, not their gender to ensure a positive economic impact.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4cdbb1f5dcea4e2f98dbb2b4f1ceed32", "input": "claim: Gender quotas in the EU are advantageous for the economies of member states.\n perspective: There are other policy options that are less distortive and more advantageous for the economy. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-f244ed9fa6cc4cca89da7ea5b11ab9f6", "input": "claim: Gender quotas in the EU are advantageous for the economies of member states.\n perspective: Other policies exist that are more beneficial to the economy than gender quotas.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-0ecfcfaf94164a76a10275752cc57a62", "input": "claim: Gender quotas in the EU are advantageous for the economies of member states.\n perspective: The situation in these countries is improving, no need for a new policy. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-d2aff28780f24dd2880b9b2304b0f07c", "input": "claim: Gender quotas in the EU are advantageous for the economies of member states.\n perspective: We should not try to fix what isn't broken and what is fixing itself.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b397356a88934813b0e666764b05ea5b", "input": "claim: Gender quotas in the EU are advantageous for the economies of member states.\n perspective: The EU’s reputation can only benefit from a strong policy on women’s rights ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-33c650275cdc49cd89a7755880cab20d", "input": "claim: Gender quotas in the EU are advantageous for the economies of member states.\n perspective: There is no down side to a strong policy on women's rights being adopted by the EU.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-2fe574869df14253ab1d709aad749265", "input": "claim: The leaking of military documents by Anat Kamm was justified.\n perspective: National security should come before freedom of information", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-30a9ac3428a9442a9d7364b78aea2e7d", "input": "claim: The leaking of military documents by Anat Kamm was justified.\n perspective: The military can only be held to account if there is transparency", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e14bdad04f7649e98af03a828d57ca2d", "input": "claim: The leaking of military documents by Anat Kamm was justified.\n perspective: Transparency can only hold the military accountable", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-4af8ca4850a04638a007cd684a6dc000", "input": "claim: The leaking of military documents by Anat Kamm was justified.\n perspective: There should be transparency to hold the military accountable", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-802572b2eb514a99ab078c15b81fe718", "input": "claim: Ten Commandments: Display in Schools.\n perspective: The State should be separated from the Church or churches.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-192d697839554a699b96b7ae1b4b02e0", "input": "claim: Ten Commandments: Display in Schools.\n perspective: There should be separation of Church and State . ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-0f42f90c5e6f465790bb884c6fcedec8", "input": "claim: Ten Commandments: Display in Schools.\n perspective: The State should be separated from the Church. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-99c54cdc37e84c079cf6459092023e2f", "input": "claim: Ten Commandments: Display in Schools.\n perspective: Morality and religion should not have to be linked.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-387f9e0f48db4550a1a6229db9d86cfc", "input": "claim: Ten Commandments: Display in Schools.\n perspective: We do not need to link morality and religion together. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-078d115cff3c4a4ea976ce8730760043", "input": "claim: Ten Commandments: Display in Schools.\n perspective: Morality and religion are two different things. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-98359f32effa45da86183c0b119ac9a8", "input": "claim: Ten Commandments: Display in Schools.\n perspective: Religious instruction should be taught inside the home, not in public schools.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-df2909cb6c474f39a7be8970394c2449", "input": "claim: Ten Commandments: Display in Schools.\n perspective: Religion belongs in the home, not schools. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e6abd4a499a84b9c94ae5dcb2ce61f50", "input": "claim: Ten Commandments: Display in Schools.\n perspective: There is not a place for religion in public schools. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-559a6f85189b41979a37e0ec22ecc868", "input": "claim: Celebrities who commit drug-related offences should be punished more harshly than non-celebrities.\n perspective: Punishments should be the same", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-810142d0ca924f268caafc2b44228359", "input": "claim: Celebrities who commit drug-related offences should be punished more harshly than non-celebrities.\n perspective: The penalties for these crimes should be the same for everyone.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-453adf225fa74286bcafef5cec696484", "input": "claim: Celebrities who commit drug-related offences should be punished more harshly than non-celebrities.\n perspective: Everyone should be punished in the same way. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-61db0cc13cc3442faa9843b32df2a5b0", "input": "claim: Celebrities who commit drug-related offences should be punished more harshly than non-celebrities.\n perspective: Everyone should be treated equally", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-456f3bb93ac1480ca8aa66ffee5079e1", "input": "claim: Celebrities who commit drug-related offences should be punished more harshly than non-celebrities.\n perspective: Under the law everyone is equal, and fair treatment is mandated for all. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-2b661d7b379944f296790c79d7fd2f06", "input": "claim: Celebrities who commit drug-related offences should be punished more harshly than non-celebrities.\n perspective: Such measures would be unfair and unjust", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-0d3ce6d781ff4426b9b3a339caeef6b0", "input": "claim: Celebrities who commit drug-related offences should be punished more harshly than non-celebrities.\n perspective: Doing this would not be the right thing to do.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-baf89737aaea47d8b03d71e4c4e4d3c3", "input": "claim: Celebrities who commit drug-related offences should be punished more harshly than non-celebrities.\n perspective: These acts would not be fair or in accord with the law. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-511ce72e98f8473f81f8db2b36035ead", "input": "claim: Celebrities who commit drug-related offences should be punished more harshly than non-celebrities.\n perspective: Celebrities endorse drug abuse", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-926c9f4164044f959af56641720a3a9b", "input": "claim: Celebrities who commit drug-related offences should be punished more harshly than non-celebrities.\n perspective: Celebrity behavior makes drug abuse look glamorous.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c64ea881620e4f5fa2fafabea2ffebb5", "input": "claim: Celebrities who commit drug-related offences should be punished more harshly than non-celebrities.\n perspective: The way celebrities act can seem to make doing drugs a good thing. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a288c347e5484ff88f5b10dcdd5f2f91", "input": "claim: Celebrities who commit drug-related offences should be punished more harshly than non-celebrities.\n perspective: Drug addiction isn't the addict's fault.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-f1c230fbdf3e4fecb0caf2c19a7b3aba", "input": "claim: Intellectual property rights have to be abolished.\n perspective: The product of an individual's intellectual endeavour is the property of that individual, who deserves to profit from it", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a1e384ec055f445b934d11bb77b4556c", "input": "claim: Intellectual property rights have to be abolished.\n perspective: Individuals deserve to profit from the product of their intellectual endeavor because it is their property.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-8e6f5fba6b8c4f549b772813b84c6490", "input": "claim: Intellectual property rights have to be abolished.\n perspective: The product of an individuals intellectual endeavour is their property and therefore they deserve a profit from it.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4652cebd51db4750be5f13743c88ee82", "input": "claim: Intellectual property rights have to be abolished.\n perspective: Intellectual property rights allow individuals to release their inventions into the public domain", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-d15a668a12314167b03f2dfa30c6728e", "input": "claim: Intellectual property rights have to be abolished.\n perspective: Individuals are allowed to release their inventions into the public domain because of intellectual property rights.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-880d6dad8d614429b2a52f43a182b574", "input": "claim: Intellectual property rights have to be abolished.\n perspective: It is possible for individuals to release their inventions into the public domain because of intellectual property rights.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c28d846cc1874221baadaea5a4482634", "input": "claim: Intellectual property rights have to be abolished.\n perspective: Costs of monitoring intellectual property rights by states and companies outweigh the benefits, and is often ineffective:", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-1e966a7359ff4a2fb95e494c4f323115", "input": "claim: Intellectual property rights have to be abolished.\n perspective: Monitoring intellectual property rights by states and companies outweighs the benefits because of the cost and is often in effective.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-73d2a7cb7b0d4f0fa1283cc9880b1bcc", "input": "claim: Intellectual property rights have to be abolished.\n perspective: The benefits of monitoring intellectual property rights by states and companies is outweighed and often ineffective because of the cost.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-1189fb7c340e40f79ba01d9acb346e12", "input": "claim: Intellectual property rights have to be abolished.\n perspective: There is no such thing as intellectual property, since you cannot own an idea:", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-3eaaa7cbf2724997bf37b5db92a0e4c5", "input": "claim: Intellectual property rights have to be abolished.\n perspective: Intellectual property rights incentivize investment of time and money in developing new products", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-73c1ad8f6b34492d9f0cf3fdc0bb18db", "input": "claim: Intellectual property rights have to be abolished.\n perspective: The investment of time and money in developing new products is incentivised by intellectual property rights.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4f3520ff5a9d4f009221b9f7737ae579", "input": "claim: Intellectual property rights have to be abolished.\n perspective: Developing new products and the investment of time and money it takes is incentivized by intellectual property rights.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-05fa90cdc863400abb38858a8cda3715", "input": "claim: Intellectual property rights have to be abolished.\n perspective: The complicated legal arrangements created by intellectual property raise costs of doing business:", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-cfe78ec70f5046a19072ab32855833b2", "input": "claim: Intellectual property rights have to be abolished.\n perspective: The cost of doing business is raised by intellectual property because of complicated legal arrangements.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-8de1636ae6574a0196ca974655e53244", "input": "claim: Intellectual property rights have to be abolished.\n perspective: Because the legal arrangements created by intellectual property is complicated the cost of doing business is raised.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-52b449123f0b49f4b00f04b2c7a5607c", "input": "claim: Intellectual property rights have to be abolished.\n perspective: Firms and individuals misallocate resources trying to race others to the same goal, and spend resources stealing from one another:", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-5a4a80dd607849879d175c1a2604eb56", "input": "claim: Corporations’ Use of IP Laws in Relation to Event Sponsorship Poses a Threat to Freedom of Expression.\n perspective: Governments and corporations have been complicit in an effective ‘privatization of language’.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-5b2a0f84e2954b0fb209b2ad7722d55e", "input": "claim: Abolish collective bargaining rights for unions.\n perspective: Collective bargaining leades to pay crises in the public sector", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-828cf631f02d4411bfd4183e88120c33", "input": "claim: Abolish collective bargaining rights for unions.\n perspective: Collective bargaining causes public sector pay crises", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d8f1098892c84d0ab31951c60f06d1bd", "input": "claim: Abolish collective bargaining rights for unions.\n perspective: Collective Bargaining Leads to an Overpaid Public Sector", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-394d51276b6b4b7db9b85f3efc5181ea", "input": "claim: Abolish collective bargaining rights for unions.\n perspective: Collective Bargaining can lead to overpaying the public sector.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-0ca9bbc4069c4593976555644e02b678", "input": "claim: Abolish collective bargaining rights for unions.\n perspective: Collective Bargaining leads to overpayment of the public sector.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-1f628533319e40d8a777c699e831b581", "input": "claim: Abolish collective bargaining rights for unions.\n perspective: Collective Bargaining is Needed to Voice Opinion", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-62fc1dfdc8884ca5ac92e61ac8e8b947", "input": "claim: Abolish collective bargaining rights for unions.\n perspective: In order to have voices heard, collective bargaining is needed.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-d8c66bd172df4493973c18a1de9cdbad", "input": "claim: Abolish collective bargaining rights for unions.\n perspective: We must maintain collective bargaining to hear all voices.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-8c082c5dea2b4850ab2dd74108c2dd81", "input": "claim: Abolish collective bargaining rights for unions.\n perspective: Collective bargaining has been recognised as an enforcable right", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-f3aa97be058e4a27bb181d2816e18d8d", "input": "claim: Abolish collective bargaining rights for unions.\n perspective: Collective Bargaining is a Right.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c628d69e5bdd4150b562063f58e53888", "input": "claim: Abolish collective bargaining rights for unions.\n perspective: We have the right to collective bargaining.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-8424d5215c7047eaa541e99fd524cd5e", "input": "claim: Abolish collective bargaining rights for unions.\n perspective: Collective bargaining is detrimental to democracy.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-1c16451cb4e34878a87cc0e8906f4218", "input": "claim: Abolish collective bargaining rights for unions.\n perspective: Collective bargaining undermines the democractic process", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-cb2e5e27fa7a429a9a3b777b8abcf8b3", "input": "claim: Abolish collective bargaining rights for unions.\n perspective: Collective bargaining is undemocratic", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-68049ab4d62345bebe45cddb2de5f486", "input": "claim: Abolish collective bargaining rights for unions.\n perspective: Collective Bargaining Hurts the Democratic Process", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-3345cb5b8bba41fdb412954f36051712", "input": "claim: Abolish collective bargaining rights for unions.\n perspective: Democracy is hurt by collective bargaining.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-0a801db8b91b421d8b5727e9b39eda60", "input": "claim: Abolish collective bargaining rights for unions.\n perspective: Collective bargaining is a counter to the creation of natural monopolies", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-2fa262bbb46a4c22b2742e0847557840", "input": "claim: Abolish collective bargaining rights for unions.\n perspective: Natural monopolies require collective bargaining.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b2fa05d5e5b8440fbcd59639a0555954", "input": "claim: Abolish collective bargaining rights for unions.\n perspective: Collective bargaining is helpful with monopolies.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-5f9b74eb0d42416d8039602b784a2e3a", "input": "claim: Abolish collective bargaining rights for unions.\n perspective: Collective bargaining counters the power of natural monopolies", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-664a31c6087742ab88d136f76356607d", "input": "claim: Abolish collective bargaining rights for unions.\n perspective: Collective Bargaining is Especially Necessary in the Case of Natural Monopolies", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-153201e0245b4cd392ec6b7e58563217", "input": "claim: Abolish collective bargaining rights for unions.\n perspective: Collective bargaining is a necessary aspect of democracy", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-05a6ec2bb0624b3593e7ba49c3ef846b", "input": "claim: Abolish collective bargaining rights for unions.\n perspective: Democracy requires collective bargaining", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-0c49b9f448334935bc70dfc3b6727cfa", "input": "claim: Abolish collective bargaining rights for unions.\n perspective: Collective bargaining is not a right", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-1229ff5f94fa4264be6717bbde0fc38d", "input": "claim: Abolish collective bargaining rights for unions.\n perspective: There is no right to collective bargaining", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-532ed2baede44a518a21948104f4e5c2", "input": "claim: Abolish collective bargaining rights for unions.\n perspective: No one has a right to collective bargaining", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a8db94df00584b7894abb25d8db9caad", "input": "claim: Transparency is necessary for security.\n perspective: Transparency prevents, or corrects, mistakes", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-0e4bbd25d7b24969a13316c494cc5974", "input": "claim: Transparency is necessary for security.\n perspective: Transparency would make mistakes easier to prevent or identify.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-37e4b44b530645e49d27af0a71ce5a2a", "input": "claim: Transparency is necessary for security.\n perspective: Without transparency, mistakes would be easier to come by and more difficult to correct.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-3dea6a34584c4bfc8f55e00206879af1", "input": "claim: Transparency is necessary for security.\n perspective: In security too much transparency endangers lives", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-39565a12f6704575a05cda2a8f137d6f", "input": "claim: Transparency is necessary for security.\n perspective: Too much transparency can be dangerous.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-466bf970b46647de808f4224e9b5f363", "input": "claim: Transparency is necessary for security.\n perspective: Putting all your information out there is not safe.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ac8b81af5bab42b2a2a4b94b7eb92fa1", "input": "claim: Transparency is necessary for security.\n perspective: Too much transparency can come at the cost of human lives", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c539462aa551462fa5f9269a3b8bfaff", "input": "claim: Transparency is necessary for security.\n perspective: Lives can be endangered if there is too much transparency ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-de48c69552d541a3942e9402d3699746", "input": "claim: Transparency is necessary for security.\n perspective: Transparency can result in normalisation", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-456c79ce366a4b148938cf6b384f2b6b", "input": "claim: governments should choose open source software in order to encourage its use.\n perspective: Governments can re-define industry standards by choosing open source software.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-45907ec0f7a049e6baa049f17631e734", "input": "claim: governments should choose open source software in order to encourage its use.\n perspective: Open source software can help the government re-define the industry.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e558b8552ae64ef2a1d68cd515b135a4", "input": "claim: governments should choose open source software in order to encourage its use.\n perspective: Industry standards can be re-defined by governments choice to use open source software.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-11964b0c8a9840449610fe2d8e4d6927", "input": "claim: governments should choose open source software in order to encourage its use.\n perspective: Open source software is more adaptable to government needs. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-0665f0aa91834133b03c4d03141ba868", "input": "claim: governments should choose open source software in order to encourage its use.\n perspective: Open source software is more expensive for governments in the long run. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-0a771e5aa49a409193b87da52505800b", "input": "claim: governments should choose open source software in order to encourage its use.\n perspective: Open source software is too costly int he long run for governments.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-838d0359f00f424ba22b1b66c13cf085", "input": "claim: governments should choose open source software in order to encourage its use.\n perspective: Government would incur too much of an expense in the long run using open source software.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-999874f9fd2348a1992a4d503fe72024", "input": "claim: governments should choose open source software in order to encourage its use.\n perspective: Government contracts can change the software industry for the better.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-628a76702f7b42589b3766be216418f5", "input": "claim: governments should choose open source software in order to encourage its use.\n perspective: The software industry can better positively affected by government contracts.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-692e4963655f4394afb2799c1aea7f87", "input": "claim: governments should choose open source software in order to encourage its use.\n perspective: It's possible for the software industry to be benefited by government contracts.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-7c5810fe51e540abb94974857437cccc", "input": "claim: governments should choose open source software in order to encourage its use.\n perspective: Open source software undermines national security.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-8e82caccd69d4e118ebb40a685087858", "input": "claim: governments should choose open source software in order to encourage its use.\n perspective: The national security is undermined by open source software.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-f2bf5036349e457b80435bc3f88b9a32", "input": "claim: There should be a presumption in favour of publication for information held by public bodies.\n perspective: Considering the amount of data governments produce, compelling them to publish all of it would be counterproductive as citizens would be swamped. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4299da3a20724202bb80fe51789326a0", "input": "claim: There should be a presumption in favour of publication for information held by public bodies.\n perspective: The government produces too much data to make it all available to the public.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-7147b3f6002b4d2c8b51f73e0155a27f", "input": "claim: There should be a presumption in favour of publication for information held by public bodies.\n perspective: It would take citizens too long to go through all of the government data so they only produce what is necessary for understanding.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ab67ad4d775c45aeae2e564cc28eb44a", "input": "claim: There should be a presumption in favour of publication for information held by public bodies.\n perspective: Compelling public bodies to publish information ensures that non-citizens, minors, foreign nationals and others have access to information that affects them.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f7df16cd3cab440299f1474002aa2903", "input": "claim: There should be a presumption in favour of publication for information held by public bodies.\n perspective: Less incentive to study at university", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-91af68fcdbcb47d5aa981fd5c7a6cc82", "input": "claim: There should be a presumption in favour of publication for information held by public bodies.\n perspective: Most universities are publically funded so should have to be open with their materials.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-40717c8332bf4c37a3f84077af3e1531", "input": "claim: There should be a presumption in favour of publication for information held by public bodies.\n perspective: Since tax dollars fund most public universities, the general public should have free access to these materials.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d1d3bd680c9e4fd5a9b2c854148f5132", "input": "claim: There should be a presumption in favour of publication for information held by public bodies.\n perspective: Most universities are supported by government funds, so they should have to make their course material open.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c2178236ec384a689109b2534044a3dd", "input": "claim: There should be a presumption in favour of publication for information held by public bodies.\n perspective: Making everything free to access will damage universities ability to tap private funding", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-913875af82fa4bfa801fc61bc608146e", "input": "claim: There should be a presumption in favour of publication for information held by public bodies.\n perspective: Universities will struggle with private funding if all provided resources become free", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-2aa194fdf09e44528c77b3290f43acb5", "input": "claim: There should be a presumption in favour of publication for information held by public bodies.\n perspective: Opening up resources to free access can be damaging to universities", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-5ff7407a680140b49721435536e81566", "input": "claim: There should be a presumption in favour of publication for information held by public bodies.\n perspective: Universities deserve to profit from their work", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-676f4c782fd5492cb8238bccda53da0b", "input": "claim: There should be a presumption in favour of publication for information held by public bodies.\n perspective: Universities should be directly profiting from their services", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-62d4983011b34d91a83acfbfbc2c8f0f", "input": "claim: There should be a presumption in favour of publication for information held by public bodies.\n perspective: Universities deserve to add costs to their resources instead of leaving them open to the public, restricting profits", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a2f980e8c5404aecb6df14133b9335b2", "input": "claim: There should be a presumption in favour of publication for information held by public bodies.\n perspective: Openness benefits research and the economy", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-5ffbdde9a7264834909ee3c645c0af49", "input": "claim: There should be a presumption in favour of publication for information held by public bodies.\n perspective: Openness benefits all parties involved, including research and the economy", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a2c60d478ea04dc68118c1636a117ead", "input": "claim: There should be a presumption in favour of publication for information held by public bodies.\n perspective: Openness is widely beneficial", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-5f816d8a0dfc4e798b15ea7d6285de25", "input": "claim: There should be a presumption in favour of publication for information held by public bodies.\n perspective: Students would be able to benefit from being able to use resources at other universities", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-3d2a028d703e48b99ef73ee2766e271c", "input": "claim: There should be a presumption in favour of publication for information held by public bodies.\n perspective: Universities being open with resources can benefit students a great deal", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-3693b09b1b954321b3898eec7009604b", "input": "claim: There should be a presumption in favour of publication for information held by public bodies.\n perspective: Students do better when other universities have open resources", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-b177085d85204d2c85a06f5c1ad7c841", "input": "claim: There should be a presumption in favour of publication for information held by public bodies.\n perspective: Opens up education", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-6044f10541c041dbb298184d47e5c6a6", "input": "claim: There should be a presumption in favour of publication for information held by public bodies.\n perspective: Education should be open to all.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-395cdfbd340d4acf9b3f76d97a4052e8", "input": "claim: There should be a presumption in favour of publication for information held by public bodies.\n perspective: Everyone should have access to education.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ce007872b4364c3f8547f10e5cdd44f4", "input": "claim: There is a world Water crisis.\n perspective: Desalination plants can rapidly overcome water scarcity.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-fe5ab4bb7aad4171885729fa53ff4e7a", "input": "claim: There is a world Water crisis.\n perspective: Water scarcity can be addressed by desalination plants.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-f79ab1a4b08b4525a8a6bfa0d22af448", "input": "claim: There is a world Water crisis.\n perspective: 3900 children die everyday in the World due to water-related diseases.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-9833c31fc1854193b61f35cf5bfeb0b4", "input": "claim: There is a world Water crisis.\n perspective: In 2020, an additional 17% of fresh water will be required to satisfy human needs", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-9c073aa852944215b64f878cd3b6fd4d", "input": "claim: There is a world Water crisis.\n perspective: In the near future we will require more fresh water to sustain human needs.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-9c2de91bd6ef4d179fef6412ea4b0911", "input": "claim: There is a world Water crisis.\n perspective: Our water requirements will be higher in the future.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-011d9337b47f4de4b79c002ae876c91c", "input": "claim: There is a world Water crisis.\n perspective: As far as we pay for the water we consume, we can use it as we wish.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a2565a0d668f455195deaeb14429e29b", "input": "claim: There is a world Water crisis.\n perspective: Countries can depend on rainfall to get more water supply", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-53ee6e4444674f6c819e279946899704", "input": "claim: There is a world Water crisis.\n perspective: Countries water supply depend on rainfall", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-24ade81c9ee942918efae2cd70308ea2", "input": "claim: Nollywood could be an effective instrument to change perceptions of Africa.\n perspective: Encouraging film entrepreneurs", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-4d419b5e517b47958b2d227a9eb61baa", "input": "claim: Nollywood could be an effective instrument to change perceptions of Africa.\n perspective: Development from within", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c9f1c0284afb4cbd96c5374958bf256d", "input": "claim: Nollywood could be an effective instrument to change perceptions of Africa.\n perspective: By developing from withing their community, perception could improve", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-dfb75f92b9b64dbb8611997e03a0fc04", "input": "claim: Nollywood could be an effective instrument to change perceptions of Africa.\n perspective: Building from withing could improve perceptions from outsiders", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e9f4dc9cfd8e4695a2b062083be8857f", "input": "claim: Nollywood could be an effective instrument to change perceptions of Africa.\n perspective: Epitomising rising Africa", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-00d3f413ead14361a42ca0c008902ba1", "input": "claim: Animals should be kept in zoos.\n perspective: By observing animal behaviour we can help those in the wild", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c557cb7e4f5e4aed8b8d2983d8425e1a", "input": "claim: Animals should be kept in zoos.\n perspective: Animals should be left in the wild", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-231970706c69407c9b602b537026ab1f", "input": "claim: Animals should be kept in zoos.\n perspective: Animal research may be valuable, but it does not need to happen in the context of confinement and human entertainment.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-f782cdf8fbb24a99a88b6ff133bc8b9a", "input": "claim: Animals should be kept in zoos.\n perspective: Human understanding can help animals", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-4cd8fc9d18534fd6930652d625a067bf", "input": "claim: Animals should be kept in zoos.\n perspective: Wild Animals Are Not Domesticated", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c141ffa64a1a490dbd65fc0979d1a8b7", "input": "claim: Climate Change is the end of the world.\n perspective: NO. It has become a new and fashionable way of attacking capitalism", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-6d3898605c8249958c19cda0f48790c4", "input": "claim: Climate Change is the end of the world.\n perspective: It will affect everybody", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d9b9fe19c8824bf3abf72ae2064b8a83", "input": "claim: Climate Change is the end of the world.\n perspective: The significant bulk of scientific research says it is happening", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-b61f967010454635aab4204e15c6b676", "input": "claim: Climate Change is the end of the world.\n perspective: climate change theory is supported by physical data", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-4f93122850024e9397fb7936cf78a2d8", "input": "claim: Climate Change is the end of the world.\n perspective: climate change can be currently oberved in real time data", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-3eeefdeb222445098399181fd40ebfcb", "input": "claim: Student loan debt should be easier to discharge in bankruptcy.\n perspective: Student loan discharge would incite colleges to raise tuition", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-eb0ac529c0a245fcbd0184d9343cf6c4", "input": "claim: PHILOSOPHY – Utilitarianism isn’t as fair as it initially seems.\n perspective: INDIVIDUAL HEDONISM NOT ALWAYS POSITIVE FOR SOCIETY/INDIVIDUALS THEMSELVES.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-bd00f64e6c7e4c5ab00f6d660c8fa421", "input": "claim: Europe should be federal.\n perspective: The concept of federalism lacks political support", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-2855d8018a7c466c973a55fbf1daa8bc", "input": "claim: Europe should be federal.\n perspective: The federal model has proved to be a success previously", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-b99b9724efbb46618212d95e43bb7a72", "input": "claim: Europe should be federal.\n perspective: Previous federal models have proven to be successful", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-dc94e318ef164168844438e856a426bc", "input": "claim: Europe should be federal.\n perspective: A federal Europe will protect the cultural diversity of its member states", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-89e6feb8eb6e4eb48b07251d85a4a47c", "input": "claim: Europe should be federal.\n perspective: Protection of cultural diversity is one benefit of a federal Europe.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a3e320911795490590c0813d89a92e8d", "input": "claim: Europe should be federal.\n perspective: Existing contributive inequalities within the Union would be amplified by a formal federal system", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e8fba475df6f4c0a85d3484b887265b2", "input": "claim: Europe should be federal.\n perspective: Formal federalism creates extra inequalities.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-0eb8c178e0b34cc186e89196cacf39b9", "input": "claim: Europe should be federal.\n perspective: A federal Europe will benefit the citizens of its member states", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-70ee55d266b141eab666d90df7b32746", "input": "claim: Europe should be federal.\n perspective: Citizens will benefit from a federal Europe.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ae6a2a389aab4fa38e56ed8a689c2000", "input": "claim: Europe should be federal.\n perspective: A federal Europe will be a stronger international actor", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-187a529994b04045bed99972a11fcfa5", "input": "claim: Europe should be federal.\n perspective: Europe is stronger if federal.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-156b94137ff3413e93b2aa57e21acd6e", "input": "claim: Europe should be federal.\n perspective: If Europe went federal, they would have a larger international impact", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-613e7df9c86149b9ac6a112215ab3cca", "input": "claim: Europe should be federal.\n perspective: A federal Europe will ensure that large, multinational businesses remain accountable for their actions", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-9309225064ae45098398c382e8f84a97", "input": "claim: Europe should be federal.\n perspective: Federalism holds massive corporations accountable.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-015b49ae15a641b6a957db603bc2bf3b", "input": "claim: Europe should be federal.\n perspective: Moves toward federalism will endanger the stability of the EU", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-417db5003ae14d3bbea7e8b2eae2b5a2", "input": "claim: A permanent UNSC seat with veto power must be reserved to an African country.\n perspective: An African voice would change priorities for the better", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-5efb1391ffdf458e84b50d6c80669c4f", "input": "claim: A permanent UNSC seat with veto power must be reserved to an African country.\n perspective: an african voice would give another point of view", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-63efe4df67484186a1f710b04db33f88", "input": "claim: A permanent UNSC seat with veto power must be reserved to an African country.\n perspective: Giving Africa a voice would improve priority", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-6c196cb7bafa4b99992c8c04c589598a", "input": "claim: A permanent UNSC seat with veto power must be reserved to an African country.\n perspective: Having an African voice would make sure that their priorities are in order", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-6ded011c66344d96a8b5d84ea8690c5c", "input": "claim: A permanent UNSC seat with veto power must be reserved to an African country.\n perspective: More vetoes mean less action", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-cc37220d874642f0845501dea781dcd2", "input": "claim: A permanent UNSC seat with veto power must be reserved to an African country.\n perspective: it is easy to do nothing and veto with no african voice in the mix.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-6623d5f58c2e44aa93c28cef0ab4cea1", "input": "claim: A permanent UNSC seat with veto power must be reserved to an African country.\n perspective: If we give too many countries the ability to veto, then less will get done.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-f5ab8b5ae789410fa4d247001683c580", "input": "claim: A permanent UNSC seat with veto power must be reserved to an African country.\n perspective: Proportionality", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-b7e43def124e4e54831b58c372ae54dc", "input": "claim: A permanent UNSC seat with veto power must be reserved to an African country.\n perspective: The UNSC mostly deals with Africa", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-63fb253e4403422b8815e56a975d0141", "input": "claim: A permanent UNSC seat with veto power must be reserved to an African country.\n perspective: The UNSC already deals a lot with Africa anyway", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-afa01b97280e4f6e8edfe9acc3fe304f", "input": "claim: A permanent UNSC seat with veto power must be reserved to an African country.\n perspective: The UNSC already has a heavy influence in Africa", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-0b79ca5387fe49b990c96128a7c5ec25", "input": "claim: Place Cameras in Courtrooms to Televise Court Cases.\n perspective: Invoking public reaction can damage the lives of those concerned in the court case.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-003a7266446e4037a77818173597b4d7", "input": "claim: Place Cameras in Courtrooms to Televise Court Cases.\n perspective: This turns court cases into entertainment, rather than legitimate legal proceedings.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-f55af8d2b1a24a0288edb084c2a75bdb", "input": "claim: Place Cameras in Courtrooms to Televise Court Cases.\n perspective: The legitimacy of the legal proceedings is compromised and becomes just entertainment.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-1cf99992cd5249bc8bfa720218c0116a", "input": "claim: Place Cameras in Courtrooms to Televise Court Cases.\n perspective: People are entertained and the legal proceedings lose their legitimacy.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-abc7cfc9db3847d5b7b14400fceb480f", "input": "claim: Place Cameras in Courtrooms to Televise Court Cases.\n perspective: this will turn a court case into a circus", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-53260a32d3f941e6acce1bc341c37f5f", "input": "claim: Place Cameras in Courtrooms to Televise Court Cases.\n perspective: court cases will be turned into circuses ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-bea10c9a357f4576abe895e90ffa8d48", "input": "claim: Place Cameras in Courtrooms to Televise Court Cases.\n perspective: Witnesses and jurors could easily become involved in the media coverage of the case and place the trial at jeopardy.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-bb553cd6123e4ffc8ec70e20fbc31ae4", "input": "claim: People should be allowed to do what they want to their own bodies.\n perspective: The Right To Express Ones Self", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-58e1e50abdf6480d90e9e034dc5c26d1", "input": "claim: People should be allowed to do what they want to their own bodies.\n perspective: Freedom of expression is a right.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-690564af98684a8d8e140ca5b0f0c9e9", "input": "claim: People should be allowed to do what they want to their own bodies.\n perspective: Freedom of expression is a basic right.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ad0d4d780e544960bb27fe16add05edc", "input": "claim: People should be allowed to do what they want to their own bodies.\n perspective: Not everyone is able to make informed decisions", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-1b074bc6104543eb9b20e22fe607ea77", "input": "claim: People should be allowed to do what they want to their own bodies.\n perspective: Everyone is not equally equipped to make good decisions.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4a3ab26c64be4d7eb5fdb5ec06039496", "input": "claim: People should be allowed to do what they want to their own bodies.\n perspective: Informed decision making is not guaranteed.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-092364000ca241bb9e0498b132e2dfc0", "input": "claim: People should be allowed to do what they want to their own bodies.\n perspective: It can be selfish", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-99ed29985a124bf2af97aac4e4cdcd43", "input": "claim: People should be allowed to do what they want to their own bodies.\n perspective: It can be inconsiderate to others.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c0450653fdb14ba392d3a275da174ade", "input": "claim: People should be allowed to do what they want to their own bodies.\n perspective: It is self absorbed.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c8f631054b4c4c6894251e59507263e3", "input": "claim: A move to the left is good for Labour.\n perspective: Going left is step back not a step forward", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-1edf54b291654534ac90024796255c81", "input": "claim: A move to the left is good for Labour.\n perspective: Labour would be foolish to move to the left.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-12ac8c7d7ea643878c56a42bf259fb25", "input": "claim: A move to the left is good for Labour.\n perspective: A poor decision for Labour would be a move to the left.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a63f100735b84bae92d2b0abe14688ab", "input": "claim: A move to the left is good for Labour.\n perspective: Going left would actually be a step backward", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-87b3df3d167a4e58bea30f8eabc16d6f", "input": "claim: A move to the left is good for Labour.\n perspective: If they went left, it would be a step back and not a step forward", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ad232d4281fc4012b1c2423de41f0803", "input": "claim: A move to the left is good for Labour.\n perspective: Presents a bold new path", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-5ca1f69e3d1d43afb20db8f8828bc523", "input": "claim: A move to the left is good for Labour.\n perspective: Shifting to the left is a strong move by Labour.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c1ecbf81ba4044d992320a3fae9a6c90", "input": "claim: A move to the left is good for Labour.\n perspective: An aggressive move by Labour would be to the left.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-8edbf90f5eb34973a9810a47b9ec99c1", "input": "claim: A move to the left is good for Labour.\n perspective: It would present a bold new path for them", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-7264702d2f1e49919dc1e5325c379343", "input": "claim: A move to the left is good for Labour.\n perspective: It would show that they are on a new path", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ff77b8c1bd9142e39712a07896189ad9", "input": "claim: 1-child policy for every single country in the world!.\n perspective: The punishment for failing to follow the rules would infringe on women's right to control their own bodies. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-425a237612174364aa2969df50a8373c", "input": "claim: 1-child policy for every single country in the world!.\n perspective: Punishing someone for not sticking to the rule can be seen as violating a women's rights", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e2030e1f22f4490c9503950baf4c7b44", "input": "claim: 1-child policy for every single country in the world!.\n perspective: Trying to enforce this rule would mean that women's rights are infringed upon", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-68c97e7110e24d0fa3d13aec03e33762", "input": "claim: 1-child policy for every single country in the world!.\n perspective: 1 child policy can infringe on women's rights.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-6d7ed214636541a4a6cbc1e6957acad3", "input": "claim: 1-child policy for every single country in the world!.\n perspective: Universal world policies can infringe on rights.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a06497eeded14225855e69759b0dd221", "input": "claim: 1-child policy for every single country in the world!.\n perspective: Overpopulation poses environmental hazards ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-8ac9683e396d4c97bf768a34839102f9", "input": "claim: 1-child policy for every single country in the world!.\n perspective: The environment is worsened by overpopulation.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f433767ad2cf4f63a27a44cf62a20077", "input": "claim: 1-child policy for every single country in the world!.\n perspective: Overpopulation is threatening to the environment.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-db00334a79214d349de1a8d2e768f730", "input": "claim: 1-child policy for every single country in the world!.\n perspective: Exerts a preference for conventional families ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-602fc415bd4a414ba399969392209773", "input": "claim: 1-child policy for every single country in the world!.\n perspective: Personal responsibility would improve in general ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-2f3f9dec1c1b4948a2a2adf5a0ba8ae9", "input": "claim: 1-child policy for every single country in the world!.\n perspective: There would be fewer unwanted children in the world ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a935752187cb4b68bbbe37d2e8ed7336", "input": "claim: 1-child policy for every single country in the world!.\n perspective: Less unwanted children would be around.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-b1b965dbd75f44fdaf3785890136d678", "input": "claim: Paparazzi and press intrude too much into celebrities lives.\n perspective: A celebrities job is to entertain, when did watching a real life marriage fall apart or a real life person in depression become entertaining?", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a4cd9e08c4fe4394b71ed50c74b8c70d", "input": "claim: Paparazzi and press intrude too much into celebrities lives.\n perspective: Addiction to celebrity culture and information is unhealthy", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-18353a33e82c423f9d192cb21af9d9d4", "input": "claim: Paparazzi and press intrude too much into celebrities lives.\n perspective: Everyone deserves a right to privacy", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-186e479c342347f0aa64c26162bf490e", "input": "claim: Paparazzi and press intrude too much into celebrities lives.\n perspective: Public figures have a responsibility to be role models", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-472334da68234787b7c11bcdc9e17b5e", "input": "claim: Paparazzi and press intrude too much into celebrities lives.\n perspective: In the case of paparazzi lives are put at risk", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ec87c29eb8734c05a447e646b1176198", "input": "claim: Parents should have the right to do background checks on those looking after their children.\n perspective: Would be very hard to maintain", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4498707709b6450d95e7c82938824244", "input": "claim: Parents should have the right to do background checks on those looking after their children.\n perspective: Could lead to vigilante attacks", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-33e2b9008e4349faa624f1558d12198d", "input": "claim: Parents should have the right to do background checks on those looking after their children.\n perspective: This could cause Parents to take matters into their own hands.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-f2fb0daafe8e4a789c69ddd169ef1dd4", "input": "claim: Parents should have the right to do background checks on those looking after their children.\n perspective: Vigilante attacks can possible happen because of that.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b4480aa9a8bf436fb2008565ad0ac691", "input": "claim: Parents should have the right to do background checks on those looking after their children.\n perspective: Children should not be exposed to sex, violence, drug use, or other inappropriate topics in school or public libraries.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d01084f44dd34c6a90c2ff614646fa8c", "input": "claim: Parents should have the right to do background checks on those looking after their children.\n perspective: Children should not be exposed to inappropriate topics like sex, violence, or drug use in school or public libraries.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d1e19ec78c3d45dbb6d4a2ec8335238f", "input": "claim: Parents should have the right to do background checks on those looking after their children.\n perspective: School and public libraries should not expose children to sex, violence, drug use, or other inappropriate topics. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-51e2dd0852b24c3eb60c0c99cf1ddb79", "input": "claim: Privacy Online is Important.\n perspective: The internet is a public space.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ff25142a7f954764b4d667d07c668198", "input": "claim: Privacy Online is Important.\n perspective: Only Criminals benefit from internet Privacy", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b023cb44fffe44609ba7195212a05d4e", "input": "claim: Privacy Online is Important.\n perspective: Internet privacy only helps criminals.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-13651f8e040b48428d34207429b1d8fa", "input": "claim: Privacy Online is Important.\n perspective: Only wrong-doers benefit from internet privacy.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-60e2e85e197e46d2a2ffc4f6d7d45c75", "input": "claim: Privacy Online is Important.\n perspective: Online privacy only benefits those who commit crimes on the internet.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c15c7ae50dc84ae6957b6699861bc841", "input": "claim: Privacy Online is Important.\n perspective: Criminals will be the only group benefited by online privacy.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-3e6fd9fddb604dcdb697cdd2efa88c86", "input": "claim: Privacy Online is Important.\n perspective: It Protects Those Vulnerable to Exploitation", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-bbd89b859c1f481e86212e55b200682e", "input": "claim: Privacy Online is Important.\n perspective: People vulnerable to explotation are protected.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-6713de5c83a34fa98c3458bfce66d881", "input": "claim: Privacy Online is Important.\n perspective: Those who might be exploited are protected. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-14651f0213ea40f3bbea8b9c1fbc3913", "input": "claim: Privacy Online is Important.\n perspective: Privacy on the internet is important for protecting users from being exploited.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ff756df16c27433590941c609ca3e334", "input": "claim: Privacy Online is Important.\n perspective: Users online would be unprotected from exploitation if it weren't for online privacy.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-7cbcad36f81c4b42816e029f79b1aac8", "input": "claim: Grant the EU a permanent seat on the UN Security Council.\n perspective: Only a more representative United Nations Security Council is legitimate.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d47a3563bead4557a4d3d28dda0795b2", "input": "claim: Grant the EU a permanent seat on the UN Security Council.\n perspective: The UNSC is legitimate only if it has the best representation", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f09bca642dc84ad19d06fd9b6427d3ef", "input": "claim: Grant the EU a permanent seat on the UN Security Council.\n perspective: The UNSC will only be seen as legitimate if it is representative", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f8e1fa564cc544369b657aec8ab9b151", "input": "claim: Grant the EU a permanent seat on the UN Security Council.\n perspective: The EU now has the necessary foreign policy organs.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-0e778f57baea4146b4976da51282df38", "input": "claim: Grant the EU a permanent seat on the UN Security Council.\n perspective: France and Britain should be willing to give up their seats for the European Union.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-5a5753140e3147579e0923cb2dd5c7dd", "input": "claim: Grant the EU a permanent seat on the UN Security Council.\n perspective: The only way the United Nations Security Council can be reformed is through expansion.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-61583565356f46f8a4622927815afa67", "input": "claim: Grant the EU a permanent seat on the UN Security Council.\n perspective: The United States Security Council should expand", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-7ebde46c6df04e03a7d378d933652e60", "input": "claim: Grant the EU a permanent seat on the UN Security Council.\n perspective: The US Security Counsel neds to expand", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-671ab7c72d23409dacdb8a834b600912", "input": "claim: University education should be free.\n perspective: Maintaining a system of free university education leads to an inefficient allocation of state resources. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ca67f1ed49934226b1229b84dd7a3778", "input": "claim: University education should be free.\n perspective: State resources could be better used in areas other than supporting free university education", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c210c6a9d9ad40c9980cba3a4c36cca4", "input": "claim: University education should be free.\n perspective: Maintaining methods of free university education takes away resources from programs that are more useful to the population", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a1c3887af9964c739f8a44a5669b0727", "input": "claim: University education should be free.\n perspective: The fees and loans create a substantial burden on our young adults.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a8a9b0b016d6456d888f451bd79c5ad1", "input": "claim: University education should be free.\n perspective: The burden of fees and loans are too great to expect young people to shoulder ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-430371e86dd24528bc374066287a0f06", "input": "claim: University education should be free.\n perspective: Young people are too burdened by fees and loans.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-0c18e6a11e214ec58522e923646c73fe", "input": "claim: University education should be free.\n perspective: The cost of fees and loans are to substantial for younger people to handle.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-fbafc8e7d4424438b06b8a420289fcd1", "input": "claim: University education should be free.\n perspective: The cost to the state is far too great to sustain universal free university education ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e456511fbe3943618338995d73f9ed0e", "input": "claim: University education should be free.\n perspective: Universal free higher education cost too much for the state to maintain.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-38323c0b82754da3ad0f6ec8cbd68590", "input": "claim: University education should be free.\n perspective: The financial burden is too high for the state to handle a universal free university education system.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-55826d532c9f49028b1f7628b2a12039", "input": "claim: University education should be free.\n perspective: Universal free education may be a great idea in practice, but it is not feasible for the government to handle the expenses.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4227f40430e648f695d4a0eaa62c88e9", "input": "claim: University education should be free.\n perspective: The experience of higher education have is a right of individuals.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-48337d38929c4ea7813d9e4b3ea2eaa5", "input": "claim: University education should be free.\n perspective: People have a right to have a higher education.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-babc6f1f992c42d6bb6348492c4065b3", "input": "claim: University education should be free.\n perspective: Every individual has the right to higher education.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-76d7daa7da3a42609b3dfe76a05f2565", "input": "claim: University education should be free.\n perspective: Higher education is the right of all.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-97936d5c2d7c485aab22df9636ffd1ef", "input": "claim: University education should be free.\n perspective: Individuals have a right to the experience of higher education", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-5664c00a939943e593c0aa7e76f46ba2", "input": "claim: University education should be free.\n perspective: Individuals have a right to equal opportunities that free university provides. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-11503a8ef4ed4cdb88f4a16de2ef3a6d", "input": "claim: University education should be free.\n perspective: People have a right to equal chance that is provided by free university education.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-2561ab10c76247b2a37d8032cf9041bf", "input": "claim: University education should be free.\n perspective: Everyone deserves the equal opportunities presented by free universities.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-3a3deddbc8ba45228eb6f1ff57a3bc75", "input": "claim: University education should be free.\n perspective: Free universities would promote equal opportunities, a right all deserve.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-880fdbcdb953405282b19ae84b09fcba", "input": "claim: University education should be free.\n perspective: Free university provides equal opportunities to all which is a right of individuals.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-3935b460c1a7445a852a6f5f9d011c15", "input": "claim: University education should be free.\n perspective: The quality of education suffers when university education is free ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ae7407a9234047a3bc4018f2e44f7535", "input": "claim: University education should be free.\n perspective: If education is free, students may put in less effort and get less out of it", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a82f8e66dc7149e7a43b7913d1e6c8fd", "input": "claim: University education should be free.\n perspective: The state benefits from the skills of a university educated populace ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-921f64137c6147b9b5992cc75827a87b", "input": "claim: University education should be free.\n perspective: An educated population is for the benefit of the state", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-0f028f7b195648f7ae6df8b75a90a733", "input": "claim: University education should be free.\n perspective: The state is benefited by those with university educated skills.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-6778ca233d4d48bca3272a3e5f2a0010", "input": "claim: University education should be free.\n perspective: State control of acceptance/curriculum criteria has negative effects ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-14cc804a74ef4f87aeb254d0305bd732", "input": "claim: University education should be free.\n perspective: Free university education unjustly benefits one subset of society at the expense of everyone ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4439da9ff40542ffb81f37e96a5a936e", "input": "claim: University education should be free.\n perspective: Free university education can unjustly give benefits to some in society at other peoples' expense.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c35b29d9a5d7440ab67d0ae656d501fa", "input": "claim: University education should be free.\n perspective: If free university education is offered then it can give benefits to some in the social system while causing an expense to others.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-9c7118184d7541b78cb629a2aa1d013d", "input": "claim: Encourage fewer people to go to university.\n perspective: We must retain a respect for academia", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a1bcc00e71c948599f5e5d82cbcc7454", "input": "claim: Encourage fewer people to go to university.\n perspective: University education gives people something to aim for", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ae98fe9f0cb945e7b0d7f822ad5dbf8b", "input": "claim: Encourage fewer people to go to university.\n perspective: Universities don’t have unlimited places available", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-59c38f46b76d46e9817129e0475e0506", "input": "claim: Encourage fewer people to go to university.\n perspective: College graduates are more productive as members of society.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-79df13b14fd444909c131a1b6912bccf", "input": "claim: Encourage fewer people to go to university.\n perspective: An increase of graduates from college is beneficial to those in society who never attend college.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-463c2e14cb2c4caa89c058fbefffd11f", "input": "claim: Encourage fewer people to go to university.\n perspective: Many people succeed without college degrees.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-547d3dadad7d41d386abf7d212e9ace1", "input": "claim: Encourage fewer people to go to university.\n perspective: Some argue that a college education may not be necessary, since there are many people who have succeeded despite not having college degrees. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-703144a133834e44bd79be27b00accd8", "input": "claim: Encourage fewer people to go to university.\n perspective: The question of whether or not a college education is necessary for success is one that is debated, as many successful people are not college educated.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-97fac43d1db043da979edbdbb5ef6d86", "input": "claim: Encourage fewer people to go to university.\n perspective: Many college graduates are employed in jobs that do not require college degrees.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-bc187365188740aa8236b315a2fb43f4", "input": "claim: Encourage fewer people to go to university.\n perspective: Many people with college degrees find themselves working in positions in which their degrees are not a requirement. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-1c9aed30155f407b8d22fc4e4b63357c", "input": "claim: Encourage fewer people to go to university.\n perspective: More and more college educated people are accepting jobs for which they do not need a college education. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-b34d466f2d744268ab7fdf4da7219165", "input": "claim: Encourage fewer people to go to university.\n perspective: College exposes students to diverse people and ideas.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-8ae1e47dd7f84fdbb6dfebf4723624d3", "input": "claim: Encourage fewer people to go to university.\n perspective: One of the benefits of a college education is the exposure it provides to a multitude of people and ideas.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-04c53ab75fe74cd1a13129d5a9bc0532", "input": "claim: Encourage fewer people to go to university.\n perspective: College exposes students to a wide range of experiences and world perspectives.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-eb7a713775a541f1922d715eb8913cf1", "input": "claim: Encourage fewer people to go to university.\n perspective: College graduates are more likely to have health insurance and retirement plans.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b74d79f78d544562aa129a7b22a458ca", "input": "claim: Encourage fewer people to go to university.\n perspective: Those who graduate from college are more likely to have retirement plans and health insurance.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ae4a1655530447699c37e3c5877431a9", "input": "claim: Encourage fewer people to go to university.\n perspective: Graduating from college increases the likelihood of having health insurance and a retirement plan.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-00b23635bf44481dba9a2c9691dc4f8d", "input": "claim: Encourage fewer people to go to university.\n perspective: Colleges may be indoctrinating students instead of educating them.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-6c509bee872b4f2591881e88fce470ed", "input": "claim: Encourage fewer people to go to university.\n perspective: Colleges may be brainwashing their students rather than helping them further their education.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-703b5a69318d4d7a989df291661f6b5b", "input": "claim: Encourage fewer people to go to university.\n perspective: There are more students that are having their views and values shifted during college than in the past.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-b3d57d62ad5b4be6a2749025ff95dfdb", "input": "claim: Encourage fewer people to go to university.\n perspective: The children of college graduates are healthier and more prepared for school.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-fa3aca02318b4199a8e49e08ff5bee91", "input": "claim: Encourage fewer people to go to university.\n perspective: College graduates tend to have healthier, better educated offspring.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-d88a9e85fcf24487b986d82f84d2287e", "input": "claim: Encourage fewer people to go to university.\n perspective: Children are typically healthier and more studious when their parents have graduated college.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-3d79a45abc4e47ac8633506cb6ac00de", "input": "claim: Encourage fewer people to go to university.\n perspective: More and more jobs require college degrees.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-59ee9ae6965249f79138640bc4daa8d4", "input": "claim: Encourage fewer people to go to university.\n perspective: A college degree is required for an increasing number of jobs.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ae407c0d7e044bd7aba79f09534adfd4", "input": "claim: Encourage fewer people to go to university.\n perspective: More jobs only hire those with college degrees.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-2d7f0484cb7c4e4e834db615c5e8a131", "input": "claim: Encourage fewer people to go to university.\n perspective: Too many students earning degrees has diluted the value of a bachelor's degree.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-556a8cde51a9428da38663bd8c6e3b55", "input": "claim: Encourage fewer people to go to university.\n perspective: The value of a bachelor's degree has lessened.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-2876cc37959e4c1e8fb2244fca2ddb1f", "input": "claim: Encourage fewer people to go to university.\n perspective: A bachelor's degree is considered standard now.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-3c210f49489b42009d2fd6a2542f51ac", "input": "claim: Encourage fewer people to go to university.\n perspective: College graduates have more and better employment opportunities.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-8f59d8ce5ac8411b97589dc6fbcfbf58", "input": "claim: Encourage fewer people to go to university.\n perspective: Graduating from college increases employment opportunities.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4ccdc7d5664b429db7aa4fece3141b0a", "input": "claim: Encourage fewer people to go to university.\n perspective: The variety and quality of employment opportunities increases for college graduates.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-5f763192251c4bf19fb44772a1005aba", "input": "claim: Encourage fewer people to go to university.\n perspective: Earning a college degree is a major life achievement.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e9ee8bf1c752449e8f24adeb04694b0f", "input": "claim: Encourage fewer people to go to university.\n perspective: A college education is a significant accomplishment.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-714a73b3d2e549f684c559e5e9b2512e", "input": "claim: Encourage fewer people to go to university.\n perspective: One of the most important things that one can achieve in their lifetime is a college education. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-243dddb8199a4e8aa04cdc4922be0f22", "input": "claim: Encourage fewer people to go to university.\n perspective: Young adults learn interpersonal skills in college.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-cced822997d8456ca5f7ad2e82375d55", "input": "claim: Encourage fewer people to go to university.\n perspective: College imparts interpersonal skills to students.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-0e209968df8045119df76c214198950b", "input": "claim: Encourage fewer people to go to university.\n perspective: Graduating from college can keep poverty at bay.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-24eb6e5d91344cb0a3818b5606cbec72", "input": "claim: Encourage fewer people to go to university.\n perspective: College graduates make more money.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ef964a65390240a5a00daab4cd3a2a42", "input": "claim: Encourage fewer people to go to university.\n perspective: College graduates have lower poverty rates.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-db90437cd7604bdabbbc1dde4be1ac54", "input": "claim: Encourage fewer people to go to university.\n perspective: College graduates do better financially.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-edda7c413a73458499a8824878e70a51", "input": "claim: Encourage fewer people to go to university.\n perspective: People who graduate from college have more earning power.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-7c6e4d7c640d4a16b2c0aab5ec4e4c49", "input": "claim: Encourage fewer people to go to university.\n perspective: College education has a high return as an investment.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-899a3220268a45f6a54e83f9bf2d0731", "input": "claim: Encourage fewer people to go to university.\n perspective: Gaining a college education is money well spent. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c9aee564ce5d4038b9cf39e4238c722a", "input": "claim: Encourage fewer people to go to university.\n perspective: Earning college education is always a worthwhile investment. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b542a4059379462bbd17cb3555ed5df9", "input": "claim: Encourage fewer people to go to university.\n perspective: Learning is always worthwhile.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-d345f9737acc49c9ab9a0411ab87f042", "input": "claim: Encourage fewer people to go to university.\n perspective: Learning will always pay off. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-762d8b7b98ac437bb7ec2d51738d8d0a", "input": "claim: Encourage fewer people to go to university.\n perspective: Learning and education is always a good investment. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-1b4c096485044ecf9bbae35986c061e0", "input": "claim: Encourage fewer people to go to university.\n perspective: Many recent college graduates are un- or underemployed.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ad026369655842e2b96fcfa8fd1ea8ba", "input": "claim: Encourage fewer people to go to university.\n perspective: In recent times, there are significant numbers of unemployed and underemployed college graduates. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-5f23c6a5dcf04f4dbc99d60a0de3f8b1", "input": "claim: Encourage fewer people to go to university.\n perspective: Among those who are unemployed and underemployed, there are many college graduates. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e290558642fd443eb7d5362135375349", "input": "claim: Encourage fewer people to go to university.\n perspective: Colleges provide networking value.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-77339221de4d47fa820ade69feacb17f", "input": "claim: Encourage fewer people to go to university.\n perspective: Attending college is a great way to network. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-1b216bbc92264e0f90011ce3550f8727", "input": "claim: Encourage fewer people to go to university.\n perspective: Going to college provides many opportunities to network. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-2cd723a676304bf693eb51eed30170e3", "input": "claim: Encourage fewer people to go to university.\n perspective: A college degree is no guarantee of workplace benefits.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-05b023c1063d447694741b896970e8cd", "input": "claim: Encourage fewer people to go to university.\n perspective: There is no guarantee there will be benefits.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-7868ff3144b8423f8082d03bfbed41d1", "input": "claim: Encourage fewer people to go to university.\n perspective: Learning a trade profession is a better option than college for many young adults.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-b59e988ea92a4289a795504e3edddfeb", "input": "claim: Encourage fewer people to go to university.\n perspective: Young adults should consider learning a trade instead of going to college.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-978a4b93de164faa99fa710127ff696c", "input": "claim: Encourage fewer people to go to university.\n perspective: Trade professions are in need of more individuals and it may be more profitable than going to college.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-bace0d9ee6e54592899c175c07a6e5b7", "input": "claim: Encourage fewer people to go to university.\n perspective: College graduates are healthier and live longer.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4b4bf8a2844046439d07257fd82a160d", "input": "claim: Encourage fewer people to go to university.\n perspective: Health and longevity are associated with graduating from a college.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-441624ed7ddd43fd9ec052dfa9630f13", "input": "claim: Encourage fewer people to go to university.\n perspective: College is an investment in health and longevity.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-470db92d2b9d441fbc5b9b7b5bee7e47", "input": "claim: Encourage fewer people to go to university.\n perspective: College graduates attract higher-paying employers to their communities.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-09d7adb9df074b88a597804b69b378f4", "input": "claim: Encourage fewer people to go to university.\n perspective: Employers are attracted to locales with college graduates. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-8ac8733873aa4a62bbc533fa30f3b4e6", "input": "claim: Encourage fewer people to go to university.\n perspective: The more college graduates in one geographical area, the more higher-paying employers will be found", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e59dda22709a4102b92da7e17b33f906", "input": "claim: Encourage fewer people to go to university.\n perspective: College allows students to explore career options.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-7b3c19563fd84a929d3652c7531a15d2", "input": "claim: Encourage fewer people to go to university.\n perspective: Attending college affords great chances to check out career options. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-9f3a7f7d923c49d4872cb3d3d014a7c1", "input": "claim: Encourage fewer people to go to university.\n perspective: The total cost of going to college also includes the cost of missing opportunities to make money at a job.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a74773ecaa9a43b1846dca632a95eadd", "input": "claim: Encourage fewer people to go to university.\n perspective: College stress can lead to health problems and other negative consequences.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-21dab7b4bf4046f0ab596675d5bd2e30", "input": "claim: Encourage fewer people to go to university.\n perspective: College degrees do not guarantee learning or job preparation.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-1d8328b8a9b340c39e091f1e38c70a5e", "input": "claim: Encourage fewer people to go to university.\n perspective: Acquiring a degree does not guarantee you a job.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-47fc67c8eac745f094754d532ea1eebf", "input": "claim: Governments should ban the media from reporting hostage-taking.\n perspective: Exaggeration by the media hurts the situation more than helping it along", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-210f6559975a49358bc2c035594483f9", "input": "claim: Governments should ban the media from reporting hostage-taking.\n perspective: They make the domestic government appear to be weak and defenseless", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-4960aefee351445d80932ae0e21d7d4d", "input": "claim: Governments should ban the media from reporting hostage-taking.\n perspective: Hostage situations hurt the country's tourism industry", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-803b87ed0d5c4656ba611f6081318203", "input": "claim: Governments should ban the media from reporting hostage-taking.\n perspective: Can Lead To Wars after sparking hateful sentiment across the board", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-314035c0469c4976b968df2ad08c1398", "input": "claim: Governments should ban the media from reporting hostage-taking.\n perspective: Reporting on these events can lead to hateful sentiment and ultimately war.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-4f93469533f444c08f2c08dec2ddd06a", "input": "claim: Governments should ban the media from reporting hostage-taking.\n perspective: Secrecy in hostage-taking events could cool passions and prevent war.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-8232cd5d26f0429584992c2e02f5c4d2", "input": "claim: Governments should ban the media from reporting hostage-taking.\n perspective: Iraq, five British hostages and a compiracy theory about embezzled funds is unchecked propaganda: That damages the host Country's reputation and thus economy . And only a small group of people made larger than life, by the media are to blame.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-4c2c55abe97e4db7a5d0ad1d30b69ad8", "input": "claim: Liberal democracies are better at providing people’s needs than non-democracies.\n perspective: Democracies are more likely to be economically successful", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a1c490f8895c411196ab49ee153ebebc", "input": "claim: Liberal democracies are better at providing people’s needs than non-democracies.\n perspective: Democracies do better at meeting economic needs.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f2d9520e838b45cc95fe3fffc3e8e118", "input": "claim: Liberal democracies are better at providing people’s needs than non-democracies.\n perspective: People's needs are met best in democracies.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-165fc32370584924813bf89cc223d981", "input": "claim: Liberal democracies are better at providing people’s needs than non-democracies.\n perspective: Democracy acts in the interest of the general population, which is good for development", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-883e66e83be7483d9b1ce31c5e7482a7", "input": "claim: Liberal democracies are better at providing people’s needs than non-democracies.\n perspective: Dictatorship outperforms democracy in growth and economic develpment", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-dfb622c2ca504b04b8faead33e5f73b7", "input": "claim: Liberal democracies are better at providing people’s needs than non-democracies.\n perspective: The loger lasting and biggest economic miracles have ocurred under dictatorships", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-08e0693528754ffeb17de93e0ec2e384", "input": "claim: Liberal democracies are better at providing people’s needs than non-democracies.\n perspective: Democracies can't mobilize a country as fast as a dictatorship can.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-547392d406844af88e8eb871afda692f", "input": "claim: Liberal democracies are better at providing people’s needs than non-democracies.\n perspective: In order to develop quickly, a dictator must be in power to sped things up.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-5269e88492064b46b71f3086ce877662", "input": "claim: Liberal democracies are better at providing people’s needs than non-democracies.\n perspective: A dictatorship breeds order and it's a needed step for both development and liberal democracy", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a670de2be9cf4da7a75cc50ceb0d3047", "input": "claim: Liberal democracies are better at providing people’s needs than non-democracies.\n perspective: Dictatorships breed development and liberal democracy.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-d86aea1d2c0440ac9a105300af7d7a4a", "input": "claim: Liberal democracies are better at providing people’s needs than non-democracies.\n perspective: Breeding of development and liberal democracy under dictatorial rule. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-2217ff91e8754d0b80026dec82f80f50", "input": "claim: Liberal democracies are better at providing people’s needs than non-democracies.\n perspective: Dictatorships are more effective than democracies at mobilizing resources for investment.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b32bf8c1bf294bb4bde6ec09c539fd8f", "input": "claim: Liberal democracies are better at providing people’s needs than non-democracies.\n perspective: Dictatorships better control the variables of human development", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-bfb04f73547b4119b664311c3e03c24e", "input": "claim: Boycott the Euro 2012 in Ukraine unless Yulia Timoshenko is released from prison.\n perspective: A boycott won’t help resolve the issues at question", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-1a79c11a028744038d2dc49753d115c7", "input": "claim: Boycott the Euro 2012 in Ukraine unless Yulia Timoshenko is released from prison.\n perspective: Boycotting Euro 2012 will highlight Ukraine’s backsliding on human rights", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-8b368cab35c14b8ca7f2dedc7435703d", "input": "claim: Boycott the Euro 2012 in Ukraine unless Yulia Timoshenko is released from prison.\n perspective: This is a sports event not a political event", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-f8c20035446d4238a44ae9dc13fdd2b1", "input": "claim: The US and its allies were justified in taking military action against Iraq following Iraq’s invasion of Kuwait.\n perspective: The US did not have legitimate authority", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e0e4bef124614f4eb21767bc75a2c4dc", "input": "claim: The US and its allies were justified in taking military action against Iraq following Iraq’s invasion of Kuwait.\n perspective: The US did not have proper authority to act.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-8c65753613704441a585b637c2831079", "input": "claim: The US and its allies were justified in taking military action against Iraq following Iraq’s invasion of Kuwait.\n perspective: It was illegal for the US to act.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e2893c57f5814e9e9f8397660b1be29b", "input": "claim: The US and its allies were justified in taking military action against Iraq following Iraq’s invasion of Kuwait.\n perspective: Precedent established that unjust aggression would not be accepted. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-23be8dc367494dcfb902e06dd584f38b", "input": "claim: The US and its allies were justified in taking military action against Iraq following Iraq’s invasion of Kuwait.\n perspective: The US did not have the right intentions", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-18b16773065343aaa71ffa9f33ccad76", "input": "claim: The US and its allies were justified in taking military action against Iraq following Iraq’s invasion of Kuwait.\n perspective: The intentions of the US were suspect.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-03acf091dc5b409fa09f34a1047e91a0", "input": "claim: The US and its allies were justified in taking military action against Iraq following Iraq’s invasion of Kuwait.\n perspective: Iraq could have posed a threat to other US allies in the region, e.g. Saudi Arabia and Israel", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-978e0378abd542009bf30b0a6506bd04", "input": "claim: The US and its allies were justified in taking military action against Iraq following Iraq’s invasion of Kuwait.\n perspective: Iraq acted in a way that threatened the sovereignty of the US allies Saudi Arabia and Israel.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-28e1f1880153437bbbef683e36e01c38", "input": "claim: The US and its allies were justified in taking military action against Iraq following Iraq’s invasion of Kuwait.\n perspective: Iraq's actions were a direct threat to the United States regional allies, chiefly Saudi Arabia and Iran.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c8c392ec55704dbd8138b4760885e8fa", "input": "claim: The US and its allies were justified in taking military action against Iraq following Iraq’s invasion of Kuwait.\n perspective: The US had Legitimate Authority to go to war", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-648a05a410fc42b5aeb803b4015488a2", "input": "claim: The US and its allies were justified in taking military action against Iraq following Iraq’s invasion of Kuwait.\n perspective: The US had just cause for exerting force in responce to perceived aggression.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-60a92854626142749782b9208c343a2b", "input": "claim: The US and its allies were justified in taking military action against Iraq following Iraq’s invasion of Kuwait.\n perspective: The US had every right to engage in the emerging conflict.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-0517935fecc74c3f8d8fef091f4a4eb9", "input": "claim: News organisations should be free to exclude news of homosexuality where it causes offence to their viewers.\n perspective: Journalism should report the experiences of the vulnerable and oppressed just as much as those of the elite and powerful. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-88a611070d534f8f8928434254d5e4c0", "input": "claim: News organisations should be free to exclude news of homosexuality where it causes offence to their viewers.\n perspective: It is the responsibility of journalists to report on both the powerful and oppressed.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-979c4715424c4c3084da012c548a2721", "input": "claim: News organisations should be free to exclude news of homosexuality where it causes offence to their viewers.\n perspective: Journalism must cover experiences of all members of a society, the rich and the poor, the powerful and oppressed.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-10276c75d942414c94c87509c1242070", "input": "claim: News organisations should be free to exclude news of homosexuality where it causes offence to their viewers.\n perspective: Broadcasters almost never show scenes of torture or torment because they know this will cause offence, the same principle should apply here.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-9ac9359d38a04c5e8e64a1f3a47fab34", "input": "claim: News organisations should be free to exclude news of homosexuality where it causes offence to their viewers.\n perspective: Networks should not show offensive material.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-8c66ca242a284da192fa00236b8170c9", "input": "claim: News organisations should be free to exclude news of homosexuality where it causes offence to their viewers.\n perspective: Torturous scenes should be kept from publication.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-b8f012dea9a044bf8c2c015717272bce", "input": "claim: News organisations should be free to exclude news of homosexuality where it causes offence to their viewers.\n perspective: The job of a journalist is to report the world and events as they see them. Cultural sensibilities do not alter the fact that these events have happened.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-f9a4ed26586141fea5bc0b6c81675523", "input": "claim: News organisations should be free to exclude news of homosexuality where it causes offence to their viewers.\n perspective: Cultures cannot determine news.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ba6edbe237a94472bf85b6d62edef8cd", "input": "claim: News organisations should be free to exclude news of homosexuality where it causes offence to their viewers.\n perspective: These events have happened, whether cultures approve of them or not.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-2581bd8da6ae47d6af69213731023d25", "input": "claim: Should Turkey Be Accepted In The EU.\n perspective: Animosity Between Turkey and Existing Member States, i.e. Greece", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-fddcaf747d0f4993821f24c07ecd9e48", "input": "claim: Should Turkey Be Accepted In The EU.\n perspective: There is significant animosity between Turkey and some existing member states.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-2c4fca0556c34bcc9131dbbf5d3eef96", "input": "claim: Should Turkey Be Accepted In The EU.\n perspective: Some members of the EU have poor relationships with Turkey.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-2a17607fadb644069b84113120622b4d", "input": "claim: Should Turkey Be Accepted In The EU.\n perspective: Fear of a Backlash Due to Turkey's Political and Religious Influences", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-d15d405b1963481c9d57901d7a65b089", "input": "claim: Should Turkey Be Accepted In The EU.\n perspective: Turkey's political and religious influences could result in backlash.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c942e8a5775f43e7b109969f0f4416d5", "input": "claim: Should Turkey Be Accepted In The EU.\n perspective: Turkey has different political and religious influences than other member states, which could cause issues.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e172229992444bd889530afed0027db5", "input": "claim: Should Turkey Be Accepted In The EU.\n perspective: Other similarly situated countries including Romania and Bulgaria have be accepted into the EU.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-473dcfe21d0f4f498097091a06c3d3b3", "input": "claim: Should Turkey Be Accepted In The EU.\n perspective: There are precedents including the admission of Romania and Bulgaria into the EU.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-0247ab2ee26f4fa88bf5cc57b7acec4b", "input": "claim: Should Turkey Be Accepted In The EU.\n perspective: Both Romania and Bulgaria have joined the EU, so it is appropriate for Turkey to be allowed in as well.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-56e39d3a0f3649babcb12109b883d4d1", "input": "claim: Should Turkey Be Accepted In The EU.\n perspective: Turkey has precedents, such as Romania and Bulgaria, both of whom were accepted into the EU", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-38f2dcc98ca848bc991a34bae24eda80", "input": "claim: Should Turkey Be Accepted In The EU.\n perspective: Precedent (Romania and Bulgaria)", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f5ad6941ecdc47468818947043cfee9d", "input": "claim: Should Turkey Be Accepted In The EU.\n perspective: Turkey would be an unstable Muslim state in a traditionally Christian union", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-7286003b241345679ac70841368da6ae", "input": "claim: Should Turkey Be Accepted In The EU.\n perspective: Turkey does not fit well because it is an unstable Muslim country while the EU has a Christian history.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-90321ac933df4ce6bcd3ecdf42b7a74c", "input": "claim: Should Turkey Be Accepted In The EU.\n perspective: The religious backgrounds of the EU being Christian and Turkey being Muslim and also not being stable are problems.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-38fd9e3dbdee478486191444bdb9356a", "input": "claim: Should Turkey Be Accepted In The EU.\n perspective: Turkey has a poor human rights record", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-cc9ace0668ea47beb1954495b334130e", "input": "claim: Should Turkey Be Accepted In The EU.\n perspective: Turkey joining the EU would help the international fight against terrorism", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a3bee115222944d895c05c1239e1628d", "input": "claim: Should Turkey Be Accepted In The EU.\n perspective: Turkey is a highly unstable democracy in an unstable part of the world", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-7625c34670f04f08b46be71e2bc51663", "input": "claim: Should Turkey Be Accepted In The EU.\n perspective: The lack of stability in Turkey's democracy and in the area around Turkey are factors that argue against admission to the EU.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-bbcf8a685f06410480e53aaee05fafd6", "input": "claim: Should Turkey Be Accepted In The EU.\n perspective: The EU will not benefit by adding a country with an unstable democracy in an unstable part of the world.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-8e2ffe1f65ce4b7eb9887741f71021d3", "input": "claim: Should Turkey Be Accepted In The EU.\n perspective: Any country that fulfils the accession criteria should be allowed to join", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-29ed47471126497eadd59c2e449c057c", "input": "claim: Should Turkey Be Accepted In The EU.\n perspective: The geographical definition of Europe must be limited and does not include Turkey", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-dff582f6e2464d9d998d73290bdbbfa5", "input": "claim: Governments should introduce a flat tax.\n perspective: Why a flat tax isn't 'fair': ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-adb26166d02444878b8517f2cf2e3202", "input": "claim: Governments should introduce a flat tax.\n perspective: Why a flat tax is regressive", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ce1810ebfebe4cedaa0cd008fd909464", "input": "claim: Governments should introduce a flat tax.\n perspective: Why a flat tax is fairer", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-721c04978635405ebf6b1efb3ef15f0a", "input": "claim: We must enforce term limits on the legislative branch of government.\n perspective: The longer a single leader remains in power, the more entrenched his grip becomes, and the more likely he is to use his office to his personal advantage.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-679f2e782eb748f186a5449ebfb88d9c", "input": "claim: We must enforce term limits on the legislative branch of government.\n perspective: Longer terms for Politicians could lead to unfairness in governing", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-9a202410cde64079a111c4ee05f35e44", "input": "claim: We must enforce term limits on the legislative branch of government.\n perspective: If a single leader sits on the throne for too long, it's more likely for the leader to exploit his or her power. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d44f68a9ac1e4b28ba680f7ddeb1b4df", "input": "claim: We must enforce term limits on the legislative branch of government.\n perspective: The longer a politician remains in office, the more entrenched his grip becomes, and the more likely he is to use his office to his personal advantage:", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-10b21ae2bf84467f8551da6389ef3e3c", "input": "claim: We must enforce term limits on the legislative branch of government.\n perspective: If there's no term limit, the leader will likely exploit his power to personal advantages by staying too long in the office. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f77976cb8d074ddd8a1581af6b3a436e", "input": "claim: We must enforce term limits on the legislative branch of government.\n perspective: the longer someone is in power, the more likely he will use it for personal advantage", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-6b29be3a0b6f4735af412bee00f7a055", "input": "claim: We must enforce term limits on the legislative branch of government.\n perspective: as times went one, the more someone is in control of his power, the more likely he will succumb to use such power for personal advantage", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-30cc7b6a982b40d3a84a15ce9370aa8e", "input": "claim: We must enforce term limits on the legislative branch of government.\n perspective: By imposing mandatory term limits on politicians, we are saying the citizens are not capable of making good decisions about their elected officials.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-7edd1838e3c04d638c67899d62173be5", "input": "claim: We must enforce term limits on the legislative branch of government.\n perspective: Term limits are undemocratic and suggest, falsely, that voters cannot make intelligent decisions about their leaders on their own.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-cdfd7cfcf33a43a5ab5274753ae95779", "input": "claim: We must enforce term limits on the legislative branch of government.\n perspective: The use of term limits in politics shows a lack of faith in the ability of voters to choose the best candidate for office.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-71ed387be4534eb5b03b330bcf35fa84", "input": "claim: We must enforce term limits on the legislative branch of government.\n perspective: Term limits should be voted on ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-577888bab236454f809907f555028b6e", "input": "claim: We must enforce term limits on the legislative branch of government.\n perspective: By having term limits, it makes voters feel that they can't decide on a leader by themselves", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-2ff911ed02dc4cbebfcdefadad113ed8", "input": "claim: We must enforce term limits on the legislative branch of government.\n perspective: With term limits, voters are not seen as intelligent voters", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-22cbb24b01e246beb07240d2ef63201d", "input": "claim: We must enforce term limits on the legislative branch of government.\n perspective: Term limits are undemocratic and suggest, falsely, that voters cannot make intelligent decisions about their representatives without guidance:", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-135c2af5184043b98b1106ea2baa513c", "input": "claim: We must enforce term limits on the legislative branch of government.\n perspective: congress needs term limits to ensure different points of views ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c29ee3583a68454f83d1ae82836c8f44", "input": "claim: We must enforce term limits on the legislative branch of government.\n perspective: term limits help with fresh ideas", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-6584f1738e514119ba9addda4bbdfc0f", "input": "claim: We must enforce term limits on the legislative branch of government.\n perspective: Term limits allows new blood in the office and prevents one leader from staying in power for too long.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-6ff80648073b423cb8caaa7fc8925e6e", "input": "claim: We must enforce term limits on the legislative branch of government.\n perspective: Term limits check the power of incumbency as an election-winning tool and allow new and energetic leaders and ideas to flourish.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-37798b53c04943c4acd8709a3d854b5d", "input": "claim: We must enforce term limits on the legislative branch of government.\n perspective: term limits allow a balance check and allow for new fresh leaders to take position", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-9ce764745c054184b2f47654f26eeb9c", "input": "claim: We must enforce term limits on the legislative branch of government.\n perspective: it is our best interest to have term limits for diversity", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-75506a1c947b4470a8aa9ccdfba5f91f", "input": "claim: We must enforce term limits on the legislative branch of government.\n perspective: Term limits create more competitive elections for public office that empower new leaders and ideas:", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d34457bedf594d6180bde0a393bd400c", "input": "claim: We must enforce term limits on the legislative branch of government.\n perspective: Having a new leader allow new ideas and thoughts in the office. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-916fd8dd70984c2fbb804cd4e74c88f6", "input": "claim: We must enforce term limits on the legislative branch of government.\n perspective: The incentive for corruption and self-enrichment in office is increased by term limits:", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-9a0c63474eac4710a5ea20480b341bca", "input": "claim: We must enforce term limits on the legislative branch of government.\n perspective: Term limits could lead one to be more dishonest to get the job done quicker", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-7313394b10e64387b700b61a78a3d926", "input": "claim: We must enforce term limits on the legislative branch of government.\n perspective: Having term limits on some leaders, puts too much power in the hands of non-limited officials.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-5a55f616f6574f05a64b74ccd7412559", "input": "claim: We must enforce term limits on the legislative branch of government.\n perspective: When some leaders are subject to term limits and some are not, the balance of power in uneven.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-84ea6366b93c4f2abec9a99a2e6c3e81", "input": "claim: We must enforce term limits on the legislative branch of government.\n perspective: With term limits, there is too much power given to those that aren't leaders", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ce24b876a3bd447ebcabde695fb65a36", "input": "claim: We must enforce term limits on the legislative branch of government.\n perspective: Term limits take too much power away from the leaders that were chosen", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-f939ffec127142d58cf22499f37c9226", "input": "claim: We must enforce term limits on the legislative branch of government.\n perspective: A strong, consistent executive may be desirable in many cases.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c47f1d1124b0471bb12d218202b5aa29", "input": "claim: We must enforce term limits on the legislative branch of government.\n perspective: There are some circumstances when one would want a strong, consistent executive branch of government in place.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-bbe2f69a557c42a5912fe4f2c00e7333", "input": "claim: We must enforce term limits on the legislative branch of government.\n perspective: There are many instances when having a powerful, unlimited executive branch of government is best.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4c25946db33a4796999b5573c73fc7f9", "input": "claim: We must enforce term limits on the legislative branch of government.\n perspective: It may at some point be desirable to keep around a certain executive longer than terms decide", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b9d88880f8714b05bc0104d4ab87e188", "input": "claim: We must enforce term limits on the legislative branch of government.\n perspective: In some instances it may be better to not have term limits if there is a good leader at the time", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-07c13ab3c00a4f0cb1390114a522e258", "input": "claim: We must enforce term limits on the legislative branch of government.\n perspective: Freeing the executive from re-election concerns can help focus attention on the public interest", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-006bcb4f74ab4847aa717b28a42d0c79", "input": "claim: We must enforce term limits on the legislative branch of government.\n perspective: The executive branch of government, having no countervailing voices to the leader s’ within it, must be checked by limiting tenancy in office.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-8be085ce78634973b302a65f94bf1096", "input": "claim: We must enforce term limits on the legislative branch of government.\n perspective: By imposing a term limit in office, we can limit the power of executive branch of government.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-0ea3a69017834db0b4b33aa7352132bd", "input": "claim: We must enforce term limits on the legislative branch of government.\n perspective: The power of executive branch of government must be checked by having a term limit for the leader in the office. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-39fc3af385ac4edca05ad8310852e07f", "input": "claim: We must enforce term limits on the legislative branch of government.\n perspective: there should be a tenancy for the executive branch of government as to keep in check the power of its leaders", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-1e47a57bcf6b4685b0de529dfc92690a", "input": "claim: We must enforce term limits on the legislative branch of government.\n perspective: the executives brances with no opposing voices to the leaders must be imposed term limits", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-db28976ed8e34a1ba016d838756801a9", "input": "claim: The EU should significantly reduce the amount it spends on agricultural production subsidies.\n perspective: Farmers can’t survive", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-23f9901041284180b45b584c35b1b4eb", "input": "claim: The EU should significantly reduce the amount it spends on agricultural production subsidies.\n perspective: It is impossible for farmers to survive.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-74db0329e2fd470180f3ae2743f6e19c", "input": "claim: The EU should significantly reduce the amount it spends on agricultural production subsidies.\n perspective: It becomes unreasonably difficult for farmers to survive.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-230e745f89f64d70bb539ba5ef908018", "input": "claim: The EU should significantly reduce the amount it spends on agricultural production subsidies.\n perspective: Market flexibility is stifled", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-305f0e3a71c449e89836d53ff74c53a3", "input": "claim: The EU should significantly reduce the amount it spends on agricultural production subsidies.\n perspective: The money could be spent elsewhere", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-22310153944545fb92f52eb3e7850c4b", "input": "claim: The EU should significantly reduce the amount it spends on agricultural production subsidies.\n perspective: The money could be used for other things.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-99af35c190804a458c265f457b6e67fc", "input": "claim: The EU should significantly reduce the amount it spends on agricultural production subsidies.\n perspective: We could spend the money elsewhere.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-25a0286dc7cf43048309e06864d99f76", "input": "claim: We can trust Republicans with the economy.\n perspective: Deregulation contributed to the banking crises and, therefore the 2009 economic crash ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-90f51c2bf2df49eeaf1866f79e634732", "input": "claim: Less time outdoors is severely detrimental to the physical and emotional wellbeing of children.\n perspective: Children need to have fun", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ddab5b13527c41eda0dd10b674f92fae", "input": "claim: Less time outdoors is severely detrimental to the physical and emotional wellbeing of children.\n perspective: Children should have fun by going outdoors as its crucial for their wellbeing.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e267e74c2b3840c19e398fb020a2cf90", "input": "claim: Less time outdoors is severely detrimental to the physical and emotional wellbeing of children.\n perspective: Nature encourages mental wellbeing", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-df6462b9290f4be68926abfc9380fc5a", "input": "claim: Less time outdoors is severely detrimental to the physical and emotional wellbeing of children.\n perspective: Being outdoors is great for someone's mental wellbeing.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-72fc5650fb744b00a173f465c9b8f357", "input": "claim: Less time outdoors is severely detrimental to the physical and emotional wellbeing of children.\n perspective: Children should enjoy nature by being outdoors more.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-32648d6d04b34bcab0860f9e0e5d408d", "input": "claim: Less time outdoors is severely detrimental to the physical and emotional wellbeing of children.\n perspective: Children need to socialise with other children", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-9821515846fd4c8db1feef379e00598f", "input": "claim: Less time outdoors is severely detrimental to the physical and emotional wellbeing of children.\n perspective: Children greatly benefit when they socialize with other kids.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d7172d33d22c4ce8b17248a9694794c0", "input": "claim: Less time outdoors is severely detrimental to the physical and emotional wellbeing of children.\n perspective: Children need to be exposed to germs", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-5c473c505560428893d48fec4a81af3b", "input": "claim: Abolish the security council veto.\n perspective: The veto power was granted legally to the P5 by the other participating states, and therefore the P5 have a right to those powers.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-9072460dad114d7d892d7352895dfa65", "input": "claim: Abolish the security council veto.\n perspective: It is appropriate for the veto power to remain in place.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-07ad75c029bf44278a5e8e45124c4985", "input": "claim: All our actions are determined in some way.\n perspective: Our actions are determined by external factors or by choice", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-60bdfca34ffd4d76bb3d12e8703f9744", "input": "claim: All our actions are determined in some way.\n perspective: This implies falsely that man operates on pure instinct from which he cannot vary, placing him on the level of animals.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-d1e6da28fd6a447e9d5f523e4de0cef0", "input": "claim: A celebrity would make a good minister.\n perspective: Celebrities are generally selfish", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-09a696f44acb4d25b6bd81d013e4e61c", "input": "claim: A celebrity would make a good minister.\n perspective: Celebrities only think about themselves", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-334b64f364ab4e51ad47fcb3380984f8", "input": "claim: A celebrity would make a good minister.\n perspective: It will inspire children into politics", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a156732f4c4f4f62bf5ae241cc37786a", "input": "claim: A celebrity would make a good minister.\n perspective: A celebrity minister can interest children with politics", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-7bd5a829bcb1462ba9257a9d6a777887", "input": "claim: A celebrity would make a good minister.\n perspective: Politics will be more interesting to children if inspired by a celebrity minister", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-0fa1edaa62a74610b068d634c1f2d7a8", "input": "claim: Homework is a waste of time.\n perspective: Homework puts students off learning", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-270e268b17c64708acfb93b086894dd2", "input": "claim: Homework is a waste of time.\n perspective: Homework has little educational worth, and therefore is a waste of students' time", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a25d1db0e1dd46f7a74038336740fd59", "input": "claim: Homework is a waste of time.\n perspective: Homework is an essential part of education, allowing students to learn information beyond that which they are taught at school.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-1c14397b38bb45b8bb00408300eeea0a", "input": "claim: Homework is a waste of time.\n perspective: Homework is crucial to a well rounded education as it is the means by which students are encouraged to learn beyond the school curriculum.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-2fc939bbf43e4e29873c1df10c15c376", "input": "claim: Homework is a waste of time.\n perspective: Homework allows students to explore and learn beyond the instruction they are given in the classroom.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ace84f78fd3d40f6be82afcd567a53ab", "input": "claim: Homework is a waste of time.\n perspective: Homework ensures that students practise what they are taught at school", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a2242ba9cb3044279c75523879f8bc01", "input": "claim: Homework is a waste of time.\n perspective: Homework provides a link between child, school and the home", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ae1d4cbfc9544190b886ed46a61f7f46", "input": "claim: Homework is a waste of time.\n perspective: Yes, kids need to balance out mental and physical exercise.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-18138f2a81204fe8b9a4ca805003d577", "input": "claim: Homework is a waste of time.\n perspective: Kids need time to do many different kinds of activities. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-9d98271fc06845dc944fafe790edd895", "input": "claim: Homework is a waste of time.\n perspective: There needs to be a balance for kids between mental and physical stimulation.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-68c9d513dbfc4d25bd43156c6f350a5e", "input": "claim: Homework is a waste of time.\n perspective: Mental stimulation and physical exercise need to have the proper balance in children.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-0614d9c9727d4b518f2c57e73dfd4907", "input": "claim: Homework is a waste of time.\n perspective: There is no evidence that homework makes a difference for young children.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-63a782f4bfd3413d88d963b0aab8e4ce", "input": "claim: Homework is a waste of time.\n perspective: There is a lack of evidence that homework helps younger children", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-858b6d32b95b4746818b263735c74ddf", "input": "claim: Homework is a waste of time.\n perspective: Small children are not helped by having homework.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d95a66de099b47a69b33088692760295", "input": "claim: Homework is a waste of time.\n perspective: Yes Homework Should Have A Limit", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-8d2eb34c5af448ed89f5a5a9d96c342d", "input": "claim: Homework is a waste of time.\n perspective: Yes, it should.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-32b72f9dd4a84c7aa022afa11a0a9eef", "input": "claim: Homework is a waste of time.\n perspective: Assigning large amounts of homework isn't good for students.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-22422ca18cd44daeb976050e79037b8f", "input": "claim: Homework is a waste of time.\n perspective: Too much homework is detrimental.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-b59eab00563345af9d488c95a6197863", "input": "claim: Homework is a waste of time.\n perspective: Homework disadvantages low-income students", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f8343b861aee44b185516b52100d57d5", "input": "claim: Homework is a waste of time.\n perspective: Low-income students are at a disadvantage when it comes to homework.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-4d47ec5896914366879d922ca7a7a85e", "input": "claim: Homework is a waste of time.\n perspective: Homework doesn't help low-income students succeed.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-0548817945be45be8610b6768367321f", "input": "claim: Homework is a waste of time.\n perspective: Homework allows parents to be involved with their child's learning", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-58f4fc4fcb944ccc8b67b80035b0d783", "input": "claim: Homework is a waste of time.\n perspective: Homework is beneficial because of parent/child involvement", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c207ed2e55734becb82d990ba9d600f5", "input": "claim: Homework is a waste of time.\n perspective: Homework helps parents understand what their children are learning.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-0ef03ffde64045d181a440e6d64083a8", "input": "claim: Homework is a waste of time.\n perspective: Homework can get parents involved", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-129120ac29f7451ab5159d0134c6ae38", "input": "claim: Homework is a waste of time.\n perspective: Homework helps involve parents ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-dc2f986d4b4f4c6fad4da13902bc58a8", "input": "claim: Homework is a waste of time.\n perspective: Homework improves student achievement", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e541b9142a8a46ee90be781ae4fe2fb0", "input": "claim: Homework is a waste of time.\n perspective: Assigning homework to students improves their level of achievement", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-8c97110553fe4a268990fc238199e9e8", "input": "claim: Homework is a waste of time.\n perspective: homework is good for students", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-bd1033df140e4862b92b04aa1cd64e29", "input": "claim: Homework is a waste of time.\n perspective: Homework helps to reinforce learning and develop good study habits and life skills", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-6eee8f87204d48e19b216cf9b2d8fcdc", "input": "claim: Homework is a waste of time.\n perspective: Homework teaches good habits and responsibility", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-9e582f26d78c43bf9d5b81540e664762", "input": "claim: Homework is a waste of time.\n perspective: Homework is good for learning", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c061fe76b19f48889ce5c2e11dfe4330", "input": "claim: Homework is a waste of time.\n perspective: Homework is good to create study habits", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-d6100e7fa40c4f8fb94a65fe3955aefe", "input": "claim: Beauty contests should be banned.\n perspective: Beauty contests are culturally insensitive", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-695cfdfab00a4329b820407c6fe8edcc", "input": "claim: Beauty contests should be banned.\n perspective: Beauty contests are patriarchal", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f305ca48277e4c24a14539e945229e58", "input": "claim: Beauty contests should be banned.\n perspective: Beauty contests objectify women", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c2ee38807fcb48cc92de0beba800fed2", "input": "claim: Beauty contests should be banned.\n perspective: Beauty contests can be harmful to women and their self esteem.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-450527115a71412895f78aad616ff646", "input": "claim: Beauty contests should be banned.\n perspective: Due to the degrading nature of beauty pageants towards women, they should be banned.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e17917f3223b49bcb73aac94f34c2d74", "input": "claim: Government must be Big and Beefy.\n perspective: Government was required to drive through major changes such as drives for equality within society, universal education, and preservation of the environment. Mostly in the teeth of big business ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e99162e10b484961995a089cfed85f44", "input": "claim: Terrorism can be justified.\n perspective: Terrorism can bring attention", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-77e9f27381b14a5ea8b8a2978843f210", "input": "claim: Terrorism can be justified.\n perspective: Terrorism is relative", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-80edf377562941128c4126bde18d0c44", "input": "claim: Terrorism can be justified.\n perspective: Terrorism can lead to discussion", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-6efbf6085ca54cb9baa8c9537e6d8e88", "input": "claim: Junk Food Should Be Banned.\n perspective: Junk Food Can Increase The Risk Of Diabetes", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-613d9f03c7d94867ab9abac4d9406e0e", "input": "claim: Junk Food Should Be Banned.\n perspective: Unhealthy foods lead to a higher risk of diabetes.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-2f502b0cb6f0424d9bc6b1abaa732dae", "input": "claim: Junk Food Should Be Banned.\n perspective: Eating junk food can make it more likely to receive a diagnosis of diabetes.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c93b5b421d51410f9ad2fddd254b6afe", "input": "claim: Junk Food Should Be Banned.\n perspective: Junk Food Can Cause Obesity", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-5839e74b2b544127854931c298cf4753", "input": "claim: Junk Food Should Be Banned.\n perspective: Eating junk food leads to obesity.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e1b38238fe4f40699b24fabeb413f220", "input": "claim: Junk Food Should Be Banned.\n perspective: Obesity is caused by junk food.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-864f4988d4664b4799f443504837e019", "input": "claim: Junk Food Should Be Banned.\n perspective: Unhealthy Food May Be Bad For Brain Function", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ef3bfdc2f0ab4485a2aec878d96767d1", "input": "claim: Junk Food Should Be Banned.\n perspective: Junk food can hinder the brain's performance.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c2deec5e573040d6bd1273719d37718c", "input": "claim: Junk Food Should Be Banned.\n perspective: Brain function is inhibited by unhealthy foods.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d35d238a3d564d77874975d21e86a885", "input": "claim: Junk Food Should Be Banned.\n perspective: Banning Junk Food In Schools Could Decrease The Frequency Of Heart Disease", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-8a27c0a8c3664c779811d6b698a3082c", "input": "claim: Junk Food Should Be Banned.\n perspective: Heart disease can be caused by junk food.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-3ae4051d5add495898b6f93c275fe6e5", "input": "claim: Junk Food Should Be Banned.\n perspective: The frequency of heart disease in schools could be lowered by banning junk food.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-cd38cb9d4ab846d5b49ee95a59062c0e", "input": "claim: Junk Food Should Be Banned.\n perspective: Junk Food Can Have Negative Affects On Bone Health", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-9a05c14d13aa4cdb869d8fd0862a4b92", "input": "claim: Junk Food Should Be Banned.\n perspective: Eating junk food can be detrimental to bone health. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-b91dbbd614ca433286ba1c20c313fc19", "input": "claim: Junk Food Should Be Banned.\n perspective: Junk food has been associated with poor bone health. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-540aa36419264b81986e75b5d14ebc02", "input": "claim: Junk Food Should Be Banned.\n perspective: A healthy diet starts from home and starts early. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-abbb73faef6c45e79c55c0f7e7fe499e", "input": "claim: Junk Food Should Be Banned.\n perspective: Schools are the best place to create lasting lifestyle changes.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a228af3eb5894ab58f22ce9d462dcf83", "input": "claim: Junk Food Should Be Banned.\n perspective: Schools are the best at changing lifestyles", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c4b5d0fc71bf480fb6f942b9bb8d3056", "input": "claim: Junk Food Should Be Banned.\n perspective: Schools set the foundation for life", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-5c8c41c931ad40b6898d40d57334596c", "input": "claim: Junk Food Should Be Banned.\n perspective: Schools are the best place to create lasting positive habits. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-688996f52ede4ad3bdbff2ab7f1e6760", "input": "claim: Junk Food Should Be Banned.\n perspective: Schools are the best place to implement long lasting lifestyle changes. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-09ebb0880bf544cc9f317cdba490f976", "input": "claim: Junk Food Should Be Banned.\n perspective: Habits Are Often Formed During Childhood And It's Important To Ensure That Kids Eat A Healthy Diet In School", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-6221e468741a46e29c159d1cd32b39b2", "input": "claim: Junk Food Should Be Banned.\n perspective: Bans On Junk Food Have Been Successful", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-fc2ed631856c4cd0ae41a3b3e40201ce", "input": "claim: Junk Food Should Be Banned.\n perspective: Start your children early on the habit of good healthy food and it will stay with them throughout their lives. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ed1ec6be880b4759b3c74f499350da6a", "input": "claim: Junk Food Should Be Banned.\n perspective: Schools should educate about healthy choices, not make them on the students’ behalf.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a6574228ae8740d0b1c104441d81ca53", "input": "claim: Junk Food Should Be Banned.\n perspective: Students should be educated to make healthy dietary choices.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-f670b51121d04503aaab6224d7209d96", "input": "claim: Junk Food Should Be Banned.\n perspective: schools should educate on health", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ca73ebba5b4e4d97b17debaa4b3a9303", "input": "claim: Junk Food Should Be Banned.\n perspective: Students should not be forbidden from eating certain foods, they should be educated about them.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c5de2f61135d4448baa19a2cb5535cff", "input": "claim: Junk Food Should Be Banned.\n perspective: schools should educate the masses on healthy choices", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c3c7a51745e6425cb8b7f46e0b36ff8b", "input": "claim: Junk Food Should Be Banned.\n perspective: Better nutrition leads to better students.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-1d9ae79f553d4ee49a7cb325826444eb", "input": "claim: Junk Food Should Be Banned.\n perspective: Good food is better for students", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ec65bb32d09b41c8b2cd7c3c6cc09d0a", "input": "claim: Junk Food Should Be Banned.\n perspective: Good food helps create better students", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a5bb51f34be24123ba623f6b34178cb9", "input": "claim: Junk Food Should Be Banned.\n perspective: Better nutrition leads to more productive students.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-788cb7716c78453d8de5eca9515f1143", "input": "claim: Junk Food Should Be Banned.\n perspective: Better nutrition leads to a better student body. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-69d2b973209541d6beb2603ffd1bcec9", "input": "claim: Junk Food Should Be Banned.\n perspective: Pupils will bring unhealthy food with them to schools. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-7b69bd80ae3745449488324d8117e599", "input": "claim: Junk Food Should Be Banned.\n perspective: If \"junk food\" is banned, students will simply bring their own food to school.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-2c87deb930864ccea63b76f843934c28", "input": "claim: Junk Food Should Be Banned.\n perspective: Banning \"junk food\" is not the answer because then students will simply bring their own \"junk food\" from home.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-feef64875f80484dbbcce9f4758f04cc", "input": "claim: Junk Food Should Be Banned.\n perspective: “Junk food” sales are an important source of funding for schools. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-dbadf67295804fe0aec9a2e90c49b848", "input": "claim: Junk Food Should Be Banned.\n perspective: \"Junk food\" revenues provide schools with much needed financial assistance.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-65b61b1fd73d4f96acf409b48963609c", "input": "claim: The African Union should create a standing army.\n perspective: Showing Africa can solve its own problems", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-9179124696624c19953fb242e5245b5c", "input": "claim: The African Union should create a standing army.\n perspective: There is no need for an AU force", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-6973ebf6cae145859b142426a5f306ef", "input": "claim: The African Union should create a standing army.\n perspective: An African Army will be a drain on the economy and ineffective.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-9721ddfd943744a7b0c90062f91a142f", "input": "claim: The African Union should create a standing army.\n perspective: An AU force will be inexperienced", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ab7de828b9b74e86a88a906cc56fcea4", "input": "claim: The African Union should create a standing army.\n perspective: African forces will be trusted by Africans", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-1bba6c6151fb43f2a476a11bb8d2bd41", "input": "claim: We should make new years resolutions.\n perspective: There is pressure on you to fail New Year's Resolutions.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b239b2c7fe00480f8518e75c0bedca50", "input": "claim: We should make new years resolutions.\n perspective: We shouldn't just do something because it is New Year.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-9c09fd0173204feb983cd8989627d9c2", "input": "claim: We should make new years resolutions.\n perspective: It is the best time to start planning your year.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d6208c3fc73448ba99a703226aad0da2", "input": "claim: We should make new years resolutions.\n perspective: A goal for a whole year is unrealistic.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-096fe0d9e3f14bb5a3126ef2eb6ecbdb", "input": "claim: People should have a right to private education.\n perspective: Private schools encourage elitism", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-d3170bae449c47bba001fda619c88cdb", "input": "claim: People should have a right to private education.\n perspective: Private schools lack diversity", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-6e2f65b5b2e44174878629769a8762c6", "input": "claim: People should have a right to private education.\n perspective: Private schools aren't diverse", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b7a39387682c49c7add15dabdc626314", "input": "claim: People should have a right to private education.\n perspective: Private schools don't have unique demographics", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-3d8c3681039c4e14a5303bf4ece4690d", "input": "claim: People should have a right to private education.\n perspective: One problem with private schools is that they lack diversity", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-71447c44fdba452d92a0d6a63b315c75", "input": "claim: People should have a right to private education.\n perspective: A lack of diversity is one issue with private schools", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-3b17ca3133c64110975fdb3715a67d0e", "input": "claim: People should have a right to private education.\n perspective: Private schools are financially beneficial for state schools", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-4dea93f87f7e4cd7ba0942a4164bfab9", "input": "claim: People should have a right to private education.\n perspective: State schools receive financial benefits because the private schools", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-99340090bc814197bc3948c647d4926a", "input": "claim: People should have a right to private education.\n perspective: One benefit of private schools is that they financially help state schools", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-b8962109985240e89f701c2f3c3599a0", "input": "claim: People should have a right to private education.\n perspective: Private schools can also be good for state schools", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c18605ef36034f79901cbe1f00bc943c", "input": "claim: People should have a right to private education.\n perspective: It creates stereotypes and tensions within society", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-5ebb2075e00d48909b59196076b75a9d", "input": "claim: People should have a right to private education.\n perspective: Removing 'choice' will improve the overall standard of our schools.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-30168b788618465ea127f323c0d6eb0b", "input": "claim: People should have a right to private education.\n perspective: too many choices lead to substandard outcomes", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-86890ceeba0243ddbebe633e3e314bb4", "input": "claim: People should have a right to private education.\n perspective: Private schools aren't necessarily good for the child.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-850838cd11f24af6b74ca442fce1ee2f", "input": "claim: People should have a right to private education.\n perspective: what is the best for the child is not always the private education", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-98170bdc6cce4007aba186b730c579f1", "input": "claim: People should have a right to private education.\n perspective: Private Schools inhibit reform of the public system", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-21f7124c611e4457a258f94ebd951f17", "input": "claim: People should have a right to private education.\n perspective: Abolishing a good service on the basis that some cannot afford it is absurd", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e8a319a08c35437d99f7bd7424eb2870", "input": "claim: People should have a right to private education.\n perspective: Abolishing a good service that is unaffordable is a disservice to humanity.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-0a80cc4fbf584607b6265545a8da3d61", "input": "claim: People should have a right to private education.\n perspective: It's ridiculous to abolish a good service based on inability to afford.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-0cfd476eaab84b0eb6ad5c63d7e25a46", "input": "claim: People should have a right to private education.\n perspective: Private schools create competition ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-7846c346d47b487a98885c4a7888a365", "input": "claim: People should have a right to private education.\n perspective: better schools lead to better schools", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-7fa2500429ee4240b532f647fc85786d", "input": "claim: People should have a right to private education.\n perspective: In a civilised society, there should be plenty of choice", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-926ae92ae31f40a7863b402584f6153b", "input": "claim: People should have a right to private education.\n perspective: choices are integral to modern civilized society", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-abb865579458435da3ed52fe11a84c6d", "input": "claim: People should have a right to private education.\n perspective: The goverment can't afford to take on more school children", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d1cf5d2f7ebe46369124286fc9a3e052", "input": "claim: People should have a right to private education.\n perspective: More school children would be a hardship on the government.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-7f267e35b20746408446ffa4a0d9a0a6", "input": "claim: People should have a right to private education.\n perspective: The government needs financial help to take on more school children.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-64173605646b4aafa600e84be3dfbd59", "input": "claim: People should have a right to private education.\n perspective: Private schools one on one time with individual teacher and student enables better results in the long run.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c8777e7712f34bacb2f01f78795d05ea", "input": "claim: People should have a right to private education.\n perspective: Private schools provide individual time for students and teachers for best results.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-1546963495fe483bad4f38c520582f64", "input": "claim: People should have a right to private education.\n perspective: Teachers can benefit students better with one on one time in private schools.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e7d946d382a04f11bfae9b676e4c06db", "input": "claim: Build the Grand Inga Dam.\n perspective: Such a big project is beyond DRC’s capacity", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-58962592982f441f96ab74d1039d3219", "input": "claim: Build the Grand Inga Dam.\n perspective: THe dam project is too complex", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4ea35e29a85d4365aaa834bbf9d54bae", "input": "claim: Build the Grand Inga Dam.\n perspective: The area isn't developed enough to take on the dam project", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e1572491518548248d5ffb568824b5cc", "input": "claim: Build the Grand Inga Dam.\n perspective: A dam would damage the environment", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-99b8e7bcf8f44514bdc87d8caeb0f766", "input": "claim: Build the Grand Inga Dam.\n perspective: the dam could harm the area around it.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-7d8c0462a88c479a810b8efe5b552665", "input": "claim: Build the Grand Inga Dam.\n perspective: A dam could make the Congo more usable", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-40dd0e8be5ba451e84d7cd41cb42d8c8", "input": "claim: Build the Grand Inga Dam.\n perspective: The dam would power Africa", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-7b845f156a5142d8a50fc7df22493cd5", "input": "claim: Build the Grand Inga Dam.\n perspective: the dam would improve the lives of people", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-7a1e2b361937495b901b5ddb01bf9aed", "input": "claim: The right to trial can be limited by jury in some criminal cases.\n perspective: Having trial by jury for people accused of very small offences is a waste of resources.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-375fc64dc8aa4ddfb333b8efd5bce342", "input": "claim: The right to trial can be limited by jury in some criminal cases.\n perspective: It may be necessary to limit trial by jury in cases where it is impossible to recruit an impartial jury.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-83329d820e6e427cbe0a28d97c664713", "input": "claim: The right to trial can be limited by jury in some criminal cases.\n perspective: trials need be limited", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-eecbb71fff0246ab8f0210181bd7977a", "input": "claim: The right to trial can be limited by jury in some criminal cases.\n perspective: Judges are better at delivering justice than juries are.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-b9aef911d8d94990901449dcb7b0dc6f", "input": "claim: The right to trial can be limited by jury in some criminal cases.\n perspective: Judges are good at justice", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-2f5c046748974e43985205ccb8becda2", "input": "claim: The right to trial can be limited by jury in some criminal cases.\n perspective: Trial by jury is a fundamental right and should never be abridged.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-252671740d8d492e912c033ce8fd7706", "input": "claim: The right to trial can be limited by jury in some criminal cases.\n perspective: Limiting trial by jury in some cases sets the stage for limiting it in other, unjustified, cases.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-976c7be155ad4b0fb90b03a56e6d91c5", "input": "claim: The right to trial can be limited by jury in some criminal cases.\n perspective: It may be necessary to limit trial by jury in terrorism cases, or other cases surrounding large national security issues.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-13263df75ef34d558c2672daab347d50", "input": "claim: The right to trial can be limited by jury in some criminal cases.\n perspective: In cases involving national security, limiting the jury can be a necessity.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-b86ab64267e942228798937afc1bd5f5", "input": "claim: The right to trial can be limited by jury in some criminal cases.\n perspective: Cases involving terrorism or national security issues may need to be limited.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-24075de2f5284a92a4feb93f60bb4cb5", "input": "claim: The right to trial can be limited by jury in some criminal cases.\n perspective: It may be necessary to limit trial by jury in cases where there is a real danger of jury tampering or intimidation.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ef2f5f1556ea416bafa002b6b1c35845", "input": "claim: The right to trial can be limited by jury in some criminal cases.\n perspective: When there is evidence of jury tampering or intimidation, limiting the choice of trial be jury is necessary.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-488b21176f9d4e13ad8352279997fe6b", "input": "claim: The right to trial can be limited by jury in some criminal cases.\n perspective: Limiting trial by jury is necessitated by times of jury tampering or intimidation.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-5408a823d5d64dcdb8f783cedd58176b", "input": "claim: Fund education using a voucher scheme.\n perspective: Equality of opportunity between richer and poorer children", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-55103d2613af4d89856d7349a651255c", "input": "claim: Fund education using a voucher scheme.\n perspective: The most vulnerable children would be left behind by the scheme", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ef2f90bc859847788887c2e400f426c3", "input": "claim: Fund education using a voucher scheme.\n perspective: The scheme leaves behind the most vulnerable children.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-f46f54c810b644178a7c4df98b7c3433", "input": "claim: Fund education using a voucher scheme.\n perspective: The children left behind by the scheme are the most vulnerable.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-edb21677d8cf4b7d820c7970994e41e9", "input": "claim: Fund education using a voucher scheme.\n perspective: If the scheme leaves out any children it is not worth it.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-de129a3b656048faa727e3b155f0d5da", "input": "claim: Fund education using a voucher scheme.\n perspective: The scheme should be for all children.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4484e89c3df845d6a2f5e7419e2ef08a", "input": "claim: Fund education using a voucher scheme.\n perspective: Increasing parents' freedom of choice", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e793ec0f62a94153a543c64082bffdd0", "input": "claim: Fund education using a voucher scheme.\n perspective: A voucher system increase parents' freedom of choice.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-5f6ecac2d13f4785a6ebf9887bbabbfc", "input": "claim: Fund education using a voucher scheme.\n perspective: The use of a voucher system increases parents' freedom of choice.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-8264e41a2a60464cb394dd94f55075f3", "input": "claim: Fund education using a voucher scheme.\n perspective: Parents must not give up their voice.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-83d2cf194b2d42b0b6bb2c64b6299c9c", "input": "claim: Fund education using a voucher scheme.\n perspective: Parents are their child's voice.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-2fbdb0b7b24e4801bcb4a5c4cdb0e8a2", "input": "claim: Fund education using a voucher scheme.\n perspective: Only well-off families will benefit from increased freedom of choice", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-f7e6b0ab056c4f40bdc219779abac9f1", "input": "claim: Fund education using a voucher scheme.\n perspective: Wealthy families are the people that will gain more from being able to determine their own actions.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-02132237ff2e42bab70fcf2e1872ea53", "input": "claim: Fund education using a voucher scheme.\n perspective: Being able to choose freely will help rich households even more.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-74f69b5ebeb74843a4ee956c864f5899", "input": "claim: Using Rewards to Motivate Students.\n perspective: Rewards are relatively ineffective for motivating students", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-358118d2f10d4941b16a5440fd0b9353", "input": "claim: Using Rewards to Motivate Students.\n perspective: Inner motivation is key to a students success; not rewards. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-7c11e52aebd74e3d85bbb6b4f116383b", "input": "claim: Using Rewards to Motivate Students.\n perspective: Rewards do not always work in motivating students. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-80d951d7ea32460abf2c5d030c10b481", "input": "claim: Children should do part time and summer work.\n perspective: Children can use the money.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-184fa467835342489a74665b795eb454", "input": "claim: Children should do part time and summer work.\n perspective: Children should work because they need the money.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e92d389b1aec45dd829b37c49be58b31", "input": "claim: Children should do part time and summer work.\n perspective: Children have many expenses and a job would help pay for them.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f0ce5235112d44ccb1dbbdfc4fc8c19a", "input": "claim: Children should do part time and summer work.\n perspective: children will be exploited", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-17a1e3bc158e40cfbab1141bd066aecf", "input": "claim: Children should do part time and summer work.\n perspective: They will have the satisfaction of a job well done.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-36e276e4e6b54e2abd7864ce7352e3f7", "input": "claim: Children should do part time and summer work.\n perspective: Children should work because a job provides satisfaction.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-adf5a572b3f146bda27ba9a9d9d4b67f", "input": "claim: Children should do part time and summer work.\n perspective: Doing a good job provides satisfaction to workers, including children.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-09f08fe146e84feeb270d7009420b195", "input": "claim: Children should do part time and summer work.\n perspective: a good option for an un-academic child", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-7a5ae2369ab94eae92658947a70e4819", "input": "claim: Children should do part time and summer work.\n perspective: Teaches them valuable life skills", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ccb977b6d7f04478a30df6b54e49c00a", "input": "claim: Children should do part time and summer work.\n perspective: Working part time prepares children for the real world.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-721672516f0e40268914db7e46aaa0d2", "input": "claim: Children should do part time and summer work.\n perspective: Children should work because a job teaches valuable life skills.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-6285e70451cf4bfd831d1b17653723de", "input": "claim: Children should do part time and summer work.\n perspective: they don't have time", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e9f462e2e84a4167828f20d18a2abef0", "input": "claim: Children should do part time and summer work.\n perspective: Children are busy with school and activities and don't have time for work.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-81a1cadba7794cff87448d406367e533", "input": "claim: Children should do part time and summer work.\n perspective: School is demanding and doesn't allow children time to work.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-533969f41ebc423289920b23b54839f4", "input": "claim: Abolish the Superdelegate System for Democratic Party Conventions.\n perspective: One person, one vote is a basic principal of democracy when the vote of one person is worth 10,000 time as much as that of another is simply undemocratic", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-86c8916376334461a848a74cf80ff886", "input": "claim: Abolish the Superdelegate System for Democratic Party Conventions.\n perspective: All votes should be equal.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-90a0a9bfc6a4403e9f31c725af11f0f2", "input": "claim: Abolish the Superdelegate System for Democratic Party Conventions.\n perspective: It is not democratic for some votes to be worth more than others.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-79d88a430ae547ddb08476c48c9f8a73", "input": "claim: Abolish the Superdelegate System for Democratic Party Conventions.\n perspective: The disproportionate influence of former politicians inevitably benefits old, powerful, white men ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e38cf23033bc4021b919762c7d947844", "input": "claim: Abolish the Superdelegate System for Democratic Party Conventions.\n perspective: Candidates solicitation of superdelegates damages the political system and requires candidates to go through contortions to secure their support", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-012bc938cb004864862e3a82148050c3", "input": "claim: The republican party has lost its way.\n perspective: The Republican Party has been hijacked by the Tea Partiers who simply don’t have a coherent message or ideology", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-727db1868f7e4f34a4558e847ebb3716", "input": "claim: The republican party has lost its way.\n perspective: The Tea party has totally hijacked the Republican Party with their incoherent ideas.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ad148fd97f554553812e0cdaae9940be", "input": "claim: The republican party has lost its way.\n perspective: The incompetent ideologies and messages from the Tea Party have taken over the Republican Party.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-df9cdfe7356f4e29a189b8a40623c7a8", "input": "claim: The republican party has lost its way.\n perspective: Having won the economic argument during the Reagan years – both with Russia and the Democratic Party – the Republicans now address social concerns and do so with a consistent message.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-7ebb7952f8384e9c8c51d1e5eef9e4d0", "input": "claim: The republican party has lost its way.\n perspective: The leadership of the Republican Party simply has nothing to do with its membership as a result no candidate has, or can, capture the imagination.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-56d348040b5b40b2bf8d1bd12c017b8f", "input": "claim: The republican party has lost its way.\n perspective: Just as with other parties around the world, once the dominant argument of a political party proves to be a busted flush it takes about a decade to recover", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d27c42abc692410fb9ac1e6419b2e281", "input": "claim: Wire-tapped and ‘intercepted’ evidence must be allowed as admissible in court.\n perspective: Intercept evidence is simply not reliable enough to be effective evidence in court.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a4cf7d7bcc2143a6bd2ee14b941aced3", "input": "claim: Wire-tapped and ‘intercepted’ evidence must be allowed as admissible in court.\n perspective: Evidence needs to be more reliable than intercept evidence if it is to used in court.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c7cee6e8779240518686572c7522f9f2", "input": "claim: Wire-tapped and ‘intercepted’ evidence must be allowed as admissible in court.\n perspective: Common authorisation for wiretapping would result in misallocation of resources.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-882438d3ddbd47bd898c6a80e050006c", "input": "claim: Wire-tapped and ‘intercepted’ evidence must be allowed as admissible in court.\n perspective: Intercept evidence deals particularly well with cases of conspiracy and criminal gangs which have a widespread network.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-2cddac557c4c47f2a37c0041274cabd4", "input": "claim: Wire-tapped and ‘intercepted’ evidence must be allowed as admissible in court.\n perspective: Widespread criminal networks can be dealt with using intercepted evidence. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-fe1bfd97e1834d03a61389abf90f8236", "input": "claim: Wire-tapped and ‘intercepted’ evidence must be allowed as admissible in court.\n perspective: Wiretapping can actually threaten the success of intelligence services in preventing crime and helping to prove criminals guilty.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-035b589960444deb96bcf7f9bd403a03", "input": "claim: Wire-tapped and ‘intercepted’ evidence must be allowed as admissible in court.\n perspective: Wiretapping can jeopardize investigations.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-908acfb5acf24374878d33c4a7ee4094", "input": "claim: Wire-tapped and ‘intercepted’ evidence must be allowed as admissible in court.\n perspective: Wiretapping can be couterproductive.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-00c759594c554b9b8a30ca6daeb8a3ab", "input": "claim: Wire-tapped and ‘intercepted’ evidence must be allowed as admissible in court.\n perspective: Intercepted evidence could be incredibly useful for both prosecution and defence cases in many trials.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-749ff37b7853477bb75cb22a3361da49", "input": "claim: Wire-tapped and ‘intercepted’ evidence must be allowed as admissible in court.\n perspective: Intercepted evidence is very useful to both sides of a trial.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-838cbe0c1f7e43869a194466d37707d7", "input": "claim: Wire-tapped and ‘intercepted’ evidence must be allowed as admissible in court.\n perspective: Interception of evidence aids both prosecution and defense.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ec163b03872147dfa473a33bf3534d6d", "input": "claim: Wire-tapped and ‘intercepted’ evidence must be allowed as admissible in court.\n perspective: Both sides of a criminal case would benefit from intercepted evidence.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-10cc3903dfcb49989ee029d1c574a477", "input": "claim: Wire-tapped and ‘intercepted’ evidence must be allowed as admissible in court.\n perspective: In many trials the use of intercepted evidence would be beneficial to both the prosecution and the defense teams.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-9e10c15501324572a0f92b64a0947ed7", "input": "claim: Wire-tapped and ‘intercepted’ evidence must be allowed as admissible in court.\n perspective: Wiretapping is a highly effective method which helps to prevent serious crime and secure convictions for criminals.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-1ca04608b90a45f092dcaccdb175f7ad", "input": "claim: Wire-tapped and ‘intercepted’ evidence must be allowed as admissible in court.\n perspective: Wiretapping is effective in preventing crime and catching criminals.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-6ce39aefab7e46569216adc566c5fb35", "input": "claim: Wire-tapped and ‘intercepted’ evidence must be allowed as admissible in court.\n perspective: Wiretapping makes it easier to stop crimes and catch the bad guys.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c6883b84c70a46b392dfad7371ed892c", "input": "claim: Wire-tapped and ‘intercepted’ evidence must be allowed as admissible in court.\n perspective: The use of wiretapping is highly successful and helps to both prevent crime and provide justice. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f6213864b47e42b4b29883eb94b4420f", "input": "claim: Wire-tapped and ‘intercepted’ evidence must be allowed as admissible in court.\n perspective: Wiretapping has a high level of benefit to both reduce serious crime and prosecute criminals.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-541344b75c5541638c75d4d214710015", "input": "claim: Most people are a little bit gay.\n perspective: Gay people are going to hell.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-d6c91dd4e88648dba1e2253eace13f3b", "input": "claim: Most people are a little bit gay.\n perspective: Gay - Nature or Nurture?", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-cd73a16e09a145838ad8ba8e80f512d2", "input": "claim: Most people are a little bit gay.\n perspective: The simple continuation of mankind proves the heterosexuality is predominant", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-817a908b17b24a5ba923bffe345aaab1", "input": "claim: Anti-Social Behaviour Orders (UK) must be scraped.\n perspective: ASBOS encourage antisocial behavour", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-5cd96529749d4e4da2230cdbf00b4fe1", "input": "claim: Anti-Social Behaviour Orders (UK) must be scraped.\n perspective: There is no respect among the population for ASBOS", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-1b78aef6ca4b4444b2cbfeaf96e6c0a5", "input": "claim: Anti-Social Behaviour Orders (UK) must be scraped.\n perspective: The classicification of some behavior as anti-social (Anti-Social Behavior Orders or ASBOS) is not respected by the people.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-973179abca9f434a979a383ea878aa9c", "input": "claim: Anti-Social Behaviour Orders (UK) must be scraped.\n perspective: Most people no longer agree with the Anti-Social Behavior Orders (ASBOS) classifications.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-b4c534d4fb9b4e64926eaa63cc1f2073", "input": "claim: Anti-Social Behaviour Orders (UK) must be scraped.\n perspective: ASBOs do not address the real problem", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-7190759550554d41b137cc7a5644c3e3", "input": "claim: Anti-Social Behaviour Orders (UK) must be scraped.\n perspective: ASBOS breach basic principles of justice", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-4ac2d1ec00c24d2a9a78b4cacbb8979f", "input": "claim: Governments should spend their way out of the recession.\n perspective: Government spending is the only way to increase much needed consumption", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e985dfc750774d048f663d17c3dabeab", "input": "claim: We must grant those diagnosed with terminal illnesses the right to access treatments that have not completed clinical testing.\n perspective: This gives people false hope", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ac910f87ffac450e8006cb6df55398aa", "input": "claim: We must grant those diagnosed with terminal illnesses the right to access treatments that have not completed clinical testing.\n perspective: Terminally ill patients would be getting false hope", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-808e486df40e409ca3dc10f2f09d3921", "input": "claim: We must grant those diagnosed with terminal illnesses the right to access treatments that have not completed clinical testing.\n perspective: This would give terminally ill patients and their families false hopes.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-2b113ec4b50f4c6da64c0a50a0b70446", "input": "claim: We must grant those diagnosed with terminal illnesses the right to access treatments that have not completed clinical testing.\n perspective: This policy enhances the role of drug reps and advertising, at the cost of evidence-based medicine", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-293d33383d0743d981395abef9368b79", "input": "claim: We must grant those diagnosed with terminal illnesses the right to access treatments that have not completed clinical testing.\n perspective: It is cruel to deny people the last hope", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d3b97924c8f04545b52f9e183790d2bd", "input": "claim: We must grant those diagnosed with terminal illnesses the right to access treatments that have not completed clinical testing.\n perspective: It is amoral to deny terminal patients last hope treatments", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-bd4380209e4442a5bd409e08ad8fde8e", "input": "claim: We must grant those diagnosed with terminal illnesses the right to access treatments that have not completed clinical testing.\n perspective: Denying terminally-ill people last hope treatments is cruel", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-7cb541d2cf4640b0ab471e52404cc95f", "input": "claim: We must grant those diagnosed with terminal illnesses the right to access treatments that have not completed clinical testing.\n perspective: Freedom of Choice", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-eb1340a30d8a4bc6a6f5d60d18e42cc9", "input": "claim: We must grant those diagnosed with terminal illnesses the right to access treatments that have not completed clinical testing.\n perspective: This reduces the incentive for pharmaceutical companies to complete the testing process", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-cc0fe046caa2427e9605098cefc97db7", "input": "claim: We must grant those diagnosed with terminal illnesses the right to access treatments that have not completed clinical testing.\n perspective: Disastrous impact on medical trials", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-f4f7471eb1f24d8aa251150ccee0fd41", "input": "claim: We must grant those diagnosed with terminal illnesses the right to access treatments that have not completed clinical testing.\n perspective: Medical trials of experimental treatments would be greatly jeopardized", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-d7b8694f610040df940ee985c78786ff", "input": "claim: We must grant those diagnosed with terminal illnesses the right to access treatments that have not completed clinical testing.\n perspective: The consequences on clinical testing of experimental treatments would be disastrous", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c91498bc8fdb47cf96b986278cf9293c", "input": "claim: permit the use of performance enhancing drugs in professional sports.\n perspective: There is no distinction between \"natural\" and synthetic methods of performance enhancement", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-96790aaf8d9a4133b429609a2659a5d6", "input": "claim: permit the use of performance enhancing drugs in professional sports.\n perspective: Controlling, rather than ignoring, performance enhancing substances will improve competitive standards in sport", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-6e7202a5d9514c38b1f62d5b85d12130", "input": "claim: permit the use of performance enhancing drugs in professional sports.\n perspective: Allowing performance enhancing drugs in sports will lead to better competition and improved athletics.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f29de9fa9f8f428fa4f329c0f8cccb09", "input": "claim: permit the use of performance enhancing drugs in professional sports.\n perspective: Athletes should be free to take risks when training and competing", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d1b987277fb44c71a200eda293556108", "input": "claim: permit the use of performance enhancing drugs in professional sports.\n perspective: Taking more risks in training and competition would allow athletes the freedom to become the best competitors they can be.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c3e8ed318f6b41e08071d394aade596d", "input": "claim: permit the use of performance enhancing drugs in professional sports.\n perspective: Protecting young and vulnerable athletes", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-d6d22d4355c64bbb92f894ab47bc4643", "input": "claim: permit the use of performance enhancing drugs in professional sports.\n perspective: we must sanction the use of performance enhancing drugs in pro sports to protect young and vulnerable athletes.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e6266091564f4e56999e8a953f62001f", "input": "claim: permit the use of performance enhancing drugs in professional sports.\n perspective: Performance enhancing drugs are particularly dangerous to young and vulnerable athletes and should therefore be sanctioned.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-32d77b5849f8488bb550021beec62440", "input": "claim: permit the use of performance enhancing drugs in professional sports.\n perspective: Drugs will undermine the central philosophy of sport", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ff6d12c939314a448c7e2422b95ffd79", "input": "claim: permit the use of performance enhancing drugs in professional sports.\n perspective: Sports is about competing on a level playing field and allowing drugs will ruin that.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-2b349ecb2e2a4f72b1f83dd3a03a40b2", "input": "claim: Allow women to compete in the same leagues as men.\n perspective: This could simply swap inequalities around", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-61be6a5813d34075b159092f8bf43037", "input": "claim: Allow women to compete in the same leagues as men.\n perspective: Destroying the pleasure of watching certain sports", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-81e9a2a3676e482bb65335fdd9f9203f", "input": "claim: Allow women to compete in the same leagues as men.\n perspective: Encouraging future female athletes", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-6a3334a718994d4b99e27a4cc7291fd4", "input": "claim: Allow women to compete in the same leagues as men.\n perspective: promote sport for future female athlese", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-363c6df89ebb40d9ae6cb358f388a608", "input": "claim: Allow women to compete in the same leagues as men.\n perspective: Athletes should decide for themselves.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-7055bb65edfc4d3a977a9a26e963dadb", "input": "claim: Allow women to compete in the same leagues as men.\n perspective: Athletes should be able to make their own decisions.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-63346bd572464b87acc4716d8365eb39", "input": "claim: Allow women to compete in the same leagues as men.\n perspective: stop discrimination in sport", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-4d3414de67fa4c4fb7875a57945102d1", "input": "claim: Allow women to compete in the same leagues as men.\n perspective: discrimination in sport should be removed", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d20f511cd06547dc9a0f274ce7557255", "input": "claim: Allow women to compete in the same leagues as men.\n perspective: Preventing discrimination in sport", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-253525b1b3de4aa5a052153863916cbd", "input": "claim: Allow women to compete in the same leagues as men.\n perspective: The sports world is unfairly dominated by a male-orientated world-view. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ccd67e123ac640e0a5cb51aa5a52b8f0", "input": "claim: Allow women to compete in the same leagues as men.\n perspective: There should be equality between men and women. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-41384d3c646a4a85b551b9a1d81a4164", "input": "claim: Allow women to compete in the same leagues as men.\n perspective: Equality Between the Sexes", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-54e1faf1d82b41028efd2da9e601f0aa", "input": "claim: Allow women to compete in the same leagues as men.\n perspective: Equality in the sexes is of vital importance.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-8e3187a7cbef4530955c4c0d09d5e9cb", "input": "claim: Allow women to compete in the same leagues as men.\n perspective: Male and female equality is vital to society.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-9b0b83a5c18647b6baccca10285c6ff1", "input": "claim: Allow women to compete in the same leagues as men.\n perspective: Women must accept the same risks as men if they want to be judged on an equal scale.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-af1886aa55c042c7b3de89d11b0c8fa8", "input": "claim: Allow women to compete in the same leagues as men.\n perspective: If women want the equal benefits with men they must be willing to do the same things.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-190acfb6915d488b87152f36bfb581d8", "input": "claim: The Guantanamo Bay detention centre should be closed.\n perspective: Conditions at Guantanamo are unjust and unacceptable: ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-df820855367b4aa781c0eddcd7c2d273", "input": "claim: The Guantanamo Bay detention centre should be closed.\n perspective: Prisoners at Guantanamo experience unconscionable treatment. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-bdf965588a394d4d92c713f6bd268c60", "input": "claim: The Guantanamo Bay detention centre should be closed.\n perspective: The conditions at Guantanamo violate prisoners' basic rights.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-28478e24fd2f4229aeea1b40c86d4582", "input": "claim: The Guantanamo Bay detention centre should be closed.\n perspective: Guantanamo Bay’s Lack of Transparency Counters American Interests.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f2fdcedfcd9649c183f75ee8dc284f5e", "input": "claim: The Guantanamo Bay detention centre should be closed.\n perspective: American interests are counted by Guantanamo Bay's lack of transparency.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-3e13532689ae41bb8a27b20612616221", "input": "claim: The Guantanamo Bay detention centre should be closed.\n perspective: The interests of America are undone by the lack of transparency of Guantanamo Bay.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-afb71d534b4346988947449622a32cfd", "input": "claim: The Guantanamo Bay detention centre should be closed.\n perspective: Release is not the Solution", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-02bfa61d55504a7a88c8cbdbbe61f849", "input": "claim: The Guantanamo Bay detention centre should be closed.\n perspective: Gauntanamo Bay is detrimental to foreign relations for United States.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-cbf60628713d444989abbce6dc8b05e4", "input": "claim: The Guantanamo Bay detention centre should be closed.\n perspective: Guantanamo Bay Violates Fundamental Human Rights.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-72ef3b7460314eff8b17e1506daef967", "input": "claim: The Guantanamo Bay detention centre should be closed.\n perspective: Human Rights are violated by the continued use of Guantanamo Bay.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-51b63bdb24b54af1a7a932716fc3f173", "input": "claim: The Guantanamo Bay detention centre should be closed.\n perspective: The Guantanamo Bay facility is detrimental to Human Rights.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-61db2a3c1c294e7080eee1b079176ea2", "input": "claim: The Guantanamo Bay detention centre should be closed.\n perspective: Guantanamo Bay is a Symbol of Muslim Discrimination that Fuels Terrorist Sentiments", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ac2bf0b93cea4e73ab00e30a3e86ee88", "input": "claim: The Guantanamo Bay detention centre should be closed.\n perspective: Terrorist sentiments are fueled by the symbol of Muslim discrimination that is Guantanamo Bay.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-220706bd74a349799b8f09cad49f178e", "input": "claim: The Guantanamo Bay detention centre should be closed.\n perspective: Guantanamo Bay creates an image of Muslim discrimination that continues to increase terrorist sentiments.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-dfa432368ad3468681631f913d7043ff", "input": "claim: social networking sites should be banned at the workplaces.\n perspective: of course they should", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c8b87ac47d8b4cba940da064dfdf3109", "input": "claim: social networking sites should be banned at the workplaces.\n perspective: Much time can be wasted on social networking sites.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-dea4691a585a413f8b8ebd2c5187bb9a", "input": "claim: social networking sites should be banned at the workplaces.\n perspective: Social networking sites are a massive time drain.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-de15f9ad34bb43e6a432f10aeed95725", "input": "claim: social networking sites should be banned at the workplaces.\n perspective: Social media can entice people to waste time.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-288d0a2209854c0293847038eaeac549", "input": "claim: social networking sites should be banned at the workplaces.\n perspective: Social media tends to have people getting too immersed in it.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-210bce441d4f4e8f81f985d1e793d77d", "input": "claim: social networking sites should be banned at the workplaces.\n perspective: Employees should not waste time on social networking sites. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-1e1005aadcb74e63a6aeac9c852cd19c", "input": "claim: social networking sites should be banned at the workplaces.\n perspective: Using social networking sites at workplaces wastes valuable amount of work-time. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-4c75de99b03b4338ba36f8aa4301863b", "input": "claim: social networking sites should be banned at the workplaces.\n perspective: Soicial Networking Sites are a Time-Waster", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-2f420934559d47ad814c1f794d8db599", "input": "claim: social networking sites should be banned at the workplaces.\n perspective: Work is work.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-5146aca66bfb4640858a8b588a6e3b17", "input": "claim: social networking sites should be banned at the workplaces.\n perspective: Social media can lead to stress and offline relationship problems.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-39daf3f3b7ca488f89698246356b8866", "input": "claim: social networking sites should be banned at the workplaces.\n perspective: Social media sites often lead to relationship problems and other stress in real life.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-53cb1388dc6743879fd3bf3be5b1102d", "input": "claim: social networking sites should be banned at the workplaces.\n perspective: Social media has been linked to stress and problems in personal relationships in the real world.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-9c8fcbe89497483eab74f78baf065b9b", "input": "claim: social networking sites should be banned at the workplaces.\n perspective: Social media sites empower individuals to make social change and do social good on a community level.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-2284ee8720354d9c86d8608246b4d784", "input": "claim: social networking sites should be banned at the workplaces.\n perspective: Social media sites have helped people raise money for medical procedures. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-2c556307d1824dab988952f20d8ca73e", "input": "claim: social networking sites should be banned at the workplaces.\n perspective: \"Crowdsourcing\" and \"crowdfunding\" on social media allows people to collectively accomplish a goal.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a419700a828f43b1a10041695f87d4b7", "input": "claim: social networking sites should be banned at the workplaces.\n perspective: People can come together to accomplish a goal through \"crowdsourcing\" and \"crowdfunding\" on social media websites.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c971cea275994609906e08dd85fb4906", "input": "claim: social networking sites should be banned at the workplaces.\n perspective: \"Crowdsourcing\" and \"crowdfunding\" via social media, allows people to assist in a worthy cause.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e1c47cde7a43469abb0e39e593e6b707", "input": "claim: social networking sites should be banned at the workplaces.\n perspective: Social media allows for quick, easy dissemination of public health and safety information from reputable sources.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-15465ef547ef4c25a13c6deb4143e7b6", "input": "claim: social networking sites should be banned at the workplaces.\n perspective: Health and safety officers can quickly and easily provide important information to the public when needed.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c13adaef316844d5a9751f95be384911", "input": "claim: social networking sites should be banned at the workplaces.\n perspective: Social media spreads information faster than any other media.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ad36e7c44a64449ab25f7a5798df71b1", "input": "claim: social networking sites should be banned at the workplaces.\n perspective: Social media allows people to improve their relationships and make new friends.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-769441dbb12248f1a7d0eb68bff28ca5", "input": "claim: social networking sites should be banned at the workplaces.\n perspective: social media help people find friends", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-7f9c1b91cdc74bcc97769ee7a252ab4d", "input": "claim: social networking sites should be banned at the workplaces.\n perspective: people who may not have many friends can use social media to get more", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-60288589a94a408a9abd47f56c8c2439", "input": "claim: social networking sites should be banned at the workplaces.\n perspective: People can improve relationships and make new friends with social media.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a0ca885fc3e74dc185ddf0dff3b402b5", "input": "claim: social networking sites should be banned at the workplaces.\n perspective: Making new friends and improving relationships is a perk of social media.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-d8fa5ef128214a1bbebf031cc3387385", "input": "claim: social networking sites should be banned at the workplaces.\n perspective: Social media sites' advertising practices may constitute an invasion of privacy.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-16e45aaa1d1c48f7af792a5828739de5", "input": "claim: social networking sites should be banned at the workplaces.\n perspective: Social media sites' advertising practices might invade peoples' privacy.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-dae0fd5b09154027a6ae70268c50aabc", "input": "claim: social networking sites should be banned at the workplaces.\n perspective: Social media sites can have advertising practices that are an invasion to privacy.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-65c30cf8d3e441229d236e02da9dd428", "input": "claim: social networking sites should be banned at the workplaces.\n perspective: Social media helps empower business women.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-3cbe24c160e442aa89ce04e24aa6a53a", "input": "claim: social networking sites should be banned at the workplaces.\n perspective: business women can improve their life by social media", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-079b3350a89747a398f43617cdeb925e", "input": "claim: social networking sites should be banned at the workplaces.\n perspective: Business women are empowered through social media.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-3ac047252ef34d3a899788f435e21d6d", "input": "claim: social networking sites should be banned at the workplaces.\n perspective: Social media allows business women to flourish.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-bec9a73b4aac435390cf4eb68c364232", "input": "claim: social networking sites should be banned at the workplaces.\n perspective: Social media can endanger the military, journalists, and activists.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-1ad445e9e5d74e5488045d98f52db548", "input": "claim: social networking sites should be banned at the workplaces.\n perspective: Social media can bring harm to groups such as the military, journalists and activists.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-84f3c59dfa3a476683dc107572cb5493", "input": "claim: social networking sites should be banned at the workplaces.\n perspective: There is a danger that social media can bring to the military, journalists and activists.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-5d27f829f9d04e7d8f898c5ba055d6ed", "input": "claim: social networking sites should be banned at the workplaces.\n perspective: Social media sites help employers find employees and job-seekers find work.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b2b9fefa4a4a4bd6ad384127cb752666", "input": "claim: social networking sites should be banned at the workplaces.\n perspective: When looking for a job social media can help", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-d8bbf921769b4b8f8ba92229cbb18847", "input": "claim: social networking sites should be banned at the workplaces.\n perspective: employers can search social media for new empolyees", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-d8ff5b11224b485fa6c6b6c8afe22b34", "input": "claim: social networking sites should be banned at the workplaces.\n perspective: Job-seekers may find work with social media sites.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-686c03b4a39747adb002c61e09a5d9c0", "input": "claim: social networking sites should be banned at the workplaces.\n perspective: Social media helps job-seekers connect with employers", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-443c80719c56438b907838d84ad66cd9", "input": "claim: social networking sites should be banned at the workplaces.\n perspective: Social media can help disarm social stigmas.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a5df096aaea249f998697b6ef5e6a567", "input": "claim: social networking sites should be banned at the workplaces.\n perspective: Social media can help alleviate the shunning of the socially marginalized.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4ec3cb25fac34b298dee3fded88b10f7", "input": "claim: social networking sites should be banned at the workplaces.\n perspective: Social media can be a tool in the fight against social discrimination.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-25c97c5e75a84759839260ef77c472e2", "input": "claim: social networking sites should be banned at the workplaces.\n perspective: Social media allows for rapid communication during crisis events.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-cb4547ac76574fc9846c2cee7d7e006b", "input": "claim: social networking sites should be banned at the workplaces.\n perspective: Social media facilitates quick and easy contact during times of crisis.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-2dc473e9139c46bbbb26b80b8b268e48", "input": "claim: social networking sites should be banned at the workplaces.\n perspective: Social media is useful in times of emergencies as it enables instant contact.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-127d1d23d5714530842422427aeee4c8", "input": "claim: social networking sites should be banned at the workplaces.\n perspective: Unauthorized sharing on social media exposes artists to copyright infringement, loss of intellectual property, and loss of income.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-583b8988b9d9448689a09f7069a9a7c5", "input": "claim: social networking sites should be banned at the workplaces.\n perspective: Sharing on social media without permission can expose artists to copyright infringement, loss of intellectual property, and income loss", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-0700095644434fdfa53c95813bd1cc1f", "input": "claim: social networking sites should be banned at the workplaces.\n perspective: Unauthorized sharing on social media sites can lead to artists being infringed on their copyrights, loss of intellectual property, and income loss", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-07b658c93ef44d1d9f237a5d43d6a8eb", "input": "claim: social networking sites should be banned at the workplaces.\n perspective: Social media helps people who are socially isolated or shy connect with other people.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-5c863e3058bb4498bdef026f4c133580", "input": "claim: social networking sites should be banned at the workplaces.\n perspective: Those who are more shy and introverted can connect with others through social media.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-9386e7ea5a674b878a81df25412ad325", "input": "claim: social networking sites should be banned at the workplaces.\n perspective: A bashful individual can fulfill his or her social needs through social media.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-07aca2cec2fb407793685d7c2951aef8", "input": "claim: social networking sites should be banned at the workplaces.\n perspective: Social media increases voter participation.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-dc64fb2a23c646dda6f8e7bb407b56e7", "input": "claim: social networking sites should be banned at the workplaces.\n perspective: Getting the word out about how to vote on social media gives more people the chance to participate. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-6a2344b2778a43bfa55aead2be276852", "input": "claim: social networking sites should be banned at the workplaces.\n perspective: Social media helped to motivate people to get out and vote. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-96996f17d2744abd820002c9584bcc3b", "input": "claim: social networking sites should be banned at the workplaces.\n perspective: Social media is good for the economy.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-2175dd2c6d5e42ff85fb0daba3bc535b", "input": "claim: social networking sites should be banned at the workplaces.\n perspective: If you need a local part-time job than post it to social media. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-dddcf1033f6745edbed6eb7f4a0fa9fe", "input": "claim: social networking sites should be banned at the workplaces.\n perspective: Social media helps small businesses find talented workers. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b6ee0249b38e4797a6410c2e046c7a33", "input": "claim: social networking sites should be banned at the workplaces.\n perspective: Social media harms employees' productivity.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-9e5b831f628d42a9babb036b0a45c797", "input": "claim: social networking sites should be banned at the workplaces.\n perspective: Employees are constantly losing their focus due to social media.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-85805a63bcfc4be78f2da3bbe007a239", "input": "claim: social networking sites should be banned at the workplaces.\n perspective: Social media posts cannot be completely deleted and all information posted can have unintended consequences.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-bba7438b239b4770aa21f189af702ef9", "input": "claim: social networking sites should be banned at the workplaces.\n perspective: Social media posts can't be deleted permanently and the information that is posted can have unintended consequences.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a2bfdc185a7548d0b628c93479063948", "input": "claim: social networking sites should be banned at the workplaces.\n perspective: Social media posts are not able to be completely deleted and all the information that was posted can have unintended consequences.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ec73b389d7214f1b8a48b06a95423d65", "input": "claim: social networking sites should be banned at the workplaces.\n perspective: Social media enables \"sexting,\" which can lead to criminal charges and the unexpected proliferation of personal images.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-bb0792905f704abf9ce3dc41066c5f75", "input": "claim: social networking sites should be banned at the workplaces.\n perspective: Many young people talk sexually through social media.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-b74575b2cba543f08555d3468567c95b", "input": "claim: social networking sites should be banned at the workplaces.\n perspective: If you are not careful, sexting can be a start of criminal activity.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f6ce80ef4c1b48e79235eca3f35a6e17", "input": "claim: social networking sites should be banned at the workplaces.\n perspective: Social media lacks privacy and exposes users to government and corporate intrusions.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-0d64a76bc36d4f2baa9bc90ad4e82af5", "input": "claim: social networking sites should be banned at the workplaces.\n perspective: A potential drawback of social media on societies is that it opens users up to privacy invasions by government and private entities.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-1ed69f11ffab43f2bcf8236a9fb3862b", "input": "claim: social networking sites should be banned at the workplaces.\n perspective: Social media enables government and business interests to invade the privacy of its users.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-b04c953eb41f42afbd02a106d51e97d7", "input": "claim: social networking sites should be banned at the workplaces.\n perspective: Social media enables the spread of unreliable and false information.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-eea6a18b66584960a4ff2eebffd976e7", "input": "claim: social networking sites should be banned at the workplaces.\n perspective: Social media allows for the rapid dissemination of untrue data.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-243a78ba01854afca50055b005c6cca7", "input": "claim: social networking sites should be banned at the workplaces.\n perspective: One drawback of social media is that it quickly facilitates the spread of rumors and falsities. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-0f09367780e94a7f8dbc09c80721bc0a", "input": "claim: social networking sites should be banned at the workplaces.\n perspective: Social media causes people to spend less time interacting face-to-face.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-782ad0b9e4db4654ba0664b66841a2f6", "input": "claim: social networking sites should be banned at the workplaces.\n perspective: When people use social media they tend to reduce their personal face-to-face time with others.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-5dc5f0fb214b49edadbaf03da88538a9", "input": "claim: social networking sites should be banned at the workplaces.\n perspective: Using social media takes time away from real, in-person interaction.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-5742f8cba61f41fea26f6eed9611e6f8", "input": "claim: social networking sites should be banned at the workplaces.\n perspective: Social media offers a way for musicians and artists to build audiences even if they don't have a corporate contract.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-3dd6af0c71c641cca47019a5436daf36", "input": "claim: social networking sites should be banned at the workplaces.\n perspective: Those in the arts can increase their audience using social media.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-525a8d40a46d46729e43f07c48b07e8e", "input": "claim: social networking sites should be banned at the workplaces.\n perspective: Social media provides academic research to a wider audience, allowing many people access to previously unavailable educational resources.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-555fce4d104f4b93a47eebef439c5f1a", "input": "claim: social networking sites should be banned at the workplaces.\n perspective: More educational resources can be made available through social media.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-01671fad03bc4600b4c35d7dc0a1b973", "input": "claim: social networking sites should be banned at the workplaces.\n perspective: Social media facilitates cyberbullying.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-9a9c972139df4a078316853352e0009c", "input": "claim: social networking sites should be banned at the workplaces.\n perspective: Many people use social media to bully people.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-8c04e86fcfcf47d8a2d69ffeb73b26ee", "input": "claim: social networking sites should be banned at the workplaces.\n perspective: Social media enables people to bully others online.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-be74488f8087476f811cf018dbc29624", "input": "claim: social networking sites should be banned at the workplaces.\n perspective: Being a part of a social media site can increase a person's quality of life and reduce the risk of health problems.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-666f131b3c32486c850b7aa205407f3c", "input": "claim: social networking sites should be banned at the workplaces.\n perspective: Social media can help a person connect with people to alleviate depression. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-8ce91f791cac4252b930290c48e07992", "input": "claim: social networking sites should be banned at the workplaces.\n perspective: Social media is good for people who want to interact, but have social anxiety in person. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-51006b5a7b604e61a4e5839a1be0aa9b", "input": "claim: social networking sites should be banned at the workplaces.\n perspective: Social media allows people from around the USA to gather together to discuss political ideas and make change. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-825263e033164314a2e4d624a11c9127", "input": "claim: social networking sites should be banned at the workplaces.\n perspective: The use of social media is correlated with personality and brain disorders.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-fe8a37ee218a4e3eb19cd092780db210", "input": "claim: social networking sites should be banned at the workplaces.\n perspective: There are some personality and brain disorders that appear to connect to social media usage.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a44d6a78dec64e5ebecfb5778be9d8bd", "input": "claim: social networking sites should be banned at the workplaces.\n perspective: Corporations and small businesses use social media to benefit themselves and consumers.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-d2c26dad8fee4e2ba741a7012a6d5266", "input": "claim: social networking sites should be banned at the workplaces.\n perspective: Social media is beneficial to corporations and businesses.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-6b160964c98c43d5b35ec00024490fb9", "input": "claim: social networking sites should be banned at the workplaces.\n perspective: Colleges and universities use social media to recruit and retain students.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-abf3147ff7654af4afb9acec15149396", "input": "claim: social networking sites should be banned at the workplaces.\n perspective: Students can be recruited to universities through social media.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e3684db7abdb4487a03ee4b26b9cb949", "input": "claim: social networking sites should be banned at the workplaces.\n perspective: Social media is often used by higher education to find new students.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a5baff9fb49843cabb71ede71f3a504c", "input": "claim: social networking sites should be banned at the workplaces.\n perspective: Law enforcement uses social media to catch and prosecute criminals.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-8098ea85eb1c49cbbc8efb58319db972", "input": "claim: social networking sites should be banned at the workplaces.\n perspective: Social media can help prosecute criminals", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-044466bfbb524b9ca0816c23030d8f5e", "input": "claim: social networking sites should be banned at the workplaces.\n perspective: Social media allows law enforcement to catch and prosecute criminals.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b0316b1234df4f79aa093b47b7510c89", "input": "claim: social networking sites should be banned at the workplaces.\n perspective: Criminals can be caught using social media.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-d69800da3baf4256a521f5baa817e78b", "input": "claim: social networking sites should be banned at the workplaces.\n perspective: Social media aids the spread of hate groups.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-6a09791b46cf4092b3c93ade5f340f84", "input": "claim: social networking sites should be banned at the workplaces.\n perspective: Hate groups use social media to get their message out there.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-500ca5922beb496587073d2200236adb", "input": "claim: social networking sites should be banned at the workplaces.\n perspective: Many individuals report to have seen some groups of hate using social media.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ef1d076cefb14565b67072f29dddfe11", "input": "claim: social networking sites should be banned at the workplaces.\n perspective: Criminals use social media to commit and promote crimes.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f4b191baafd64e6a8813551bbc43cb09", "input": "claim: social networking sites should be banned at the workplaces.\n perspective: Social media has been found to be used for criminal activity.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-3601a9ab7c004db390c8bc4b162ca75a", "input": "claim: social networking sites should be banned at the workplaces.\n perspective: Criminals can use social media to commit crimes.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-b707706c8ee54a17baa6178fa8d981f8", "input": "claim: Joe Calzaghe deserves to be recognized as one of the greatest boxers of all time.\n perspective: of course not he had 5 good fights and four of them were past there best.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-d788236e481147aaa45f7bb29a6db8ba", "input": "claim: Joe Calzaghe deserves to be recognized as one of the greatest boxers of all time.\n perspective: I disagree. Four of his five good fights were his oppenents best fights. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-7009dcbaf9ea466289052f8362fe9ca2", "input": "claim: Joe Calzaghe deserves to be recognized as one of the greatest boxers of all time.\n perspective: No way. Out of his five \"good\" fights, he lost four of them. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-7517fbdd439d4e99ac07bbf208b5d50d", "input": "claim: Joe Calzaghe deserves to be recognized as one of the greatest boxers of all time.\n perspective: He has beaten the best of his generation", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-955a00ffe9da40f5ae02a1bea7ff5ef7", "input": "claim: Joe Calzaghe deserves to be recognized as one of the greatest boxers of all time.\n perspective: Calzaghe...An All Time Great? Not a Puncher's Chance.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-bb512b11001a41e68eeebc01717b2e13", "input": "claim: Handguns must be banned in Washington D.C.\n perspective: Handguns are uniquely dangerous when compared with other weapons", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-fcad3524e4d047749f1bd0ad9e3782ad", "input": "claim: Handguns must be banned in Washington D.C.\n perspective: A handgun ban reduces crime and deaths", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d61b315fc7d240f0b5c387413e148128", "input": "claim: Handguns must be banned in Washington D.C.\n perspective: The result of a handgun ban is lower crime and fewer deaths.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-9f5f3528397147a68f149962a03e8eb4", "input": "claim: Handguns must be banned in Washington D.C.\n perspective: Lower crime rates and fewer deaths result when handguns are banned in a city.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-35a63c76c0bb492db4d04b1427bd1900", "input": "claim: Handguns must be banned in Washington D.C.\n perspective: Individuals Should Not Have the Right to Bear Arms in DC", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c549e0af6f014be6ba7ca8350c02ecec", "input": "claim: Handguns must be banned in Washington D.C.\n perspective: DC is unique and individuals should not have the right to bear arms.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-25e1bcc331bf439dac7f7497b265d90e", "input": "claim: Handguns must be banned in Washington D.C.\n perspective: The individual right to bear arms should be restricted in DC.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-3786197bde744806a6ae0a49508835de", "input": "claim: Handguns must be banned in Washington D.C.\n perspective: The DC Handgun ban is inconsistent with other legislation in the U.S.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-eb8b537401ae4faf87362575a76815b3", "input": "claim: Handguns must be banned in Washington D.C.\n perspective: The majority of Americans support allowing the concealed carry of handguns.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-3ff1c70f50c34212ad171068b02fba55", "input": "claim: Handguns must be banned in Washington D.C.\n perspective: Many of the American adults are in favour of carrying concealed handguns", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-7604f342d5bb49e08485eb6a4c8a128a", "input": "claim: Handguns must be banned in Washington D.C.\n perspective: Carrying a concealed handgun could help stop a public shooting spree.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-69a46f975920488d925ff682bf003229", "input": "claim: Handguns must be banned in Washington D.C.\n perspective: In view of the continuous public shooting , carrying a concealed handgun by adults can stop such shooting spree", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-90c4aa48d80b438289c3f76e43a06333", "input": "claim: Handguns must be banned in Washington D.C.\n perspective: The occurrence of public shooting spree can be prevented by the usage of concealed handguns by adults", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-eb8a1add322e46f5bd3734fb2235bd9a", "input": "claim: Handguns must be banned in Washington D.C.\n perspective: Hand Guns Are Required For Self Defence.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-7fc0e6eb4320454d9fcf66a6d67a5cf6", "input": "claim: Handguns must be banned in Washington D.C.\n perspective: Concealed carry application requirements and background checks do not prevent dangerous people from acquiring weapons.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-353d23effb7f472cac73304f4fbaecd4", "input": "claim: Handguns must be banned in Washington D.C.\n perspective: Individuals who should not own weapons are not prevented from purchasing them despite the requirements and background investigations of concealed carry applications", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-9641ece7c032423c84e1166a064434dd", "input": "claim: Handguns must be banned in Washington D.C.\n perspective: The conditions for concealed carry permits and background checks do not inhibit criminals from obtaining weapons", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d8660e2adb864fa9b37fa1bb2d9ec0da", "input": "claim: Handguns must be banned in Washington D.C.\n perspective: Public safety should be left to professionally qualified police officers, not private citizens with little or no expert training.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-21cf2cc24e584790b919a19451ccef07", "input": "claim: Handguns must be banned in Washington D.C.\n perspective: The safety of the public should be the responsibility of trained police officers, rather than private citizens with minimal training", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-22729e86cf654b17b0c6691302485331", "input": "claim: Handguns must be banned in Washington D.C.\n perspective: Only police officers, who have received professional qualifications, should protect the safety of the public, not private individuals who have not received such training", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a6a306dfa9b1429ca5a5c187ddaa4cf6", "input": "claim: Handguns must be banned in Washington D.C.\n perspective: Carrying a concealed handgun increases the chances of a confrontation escalating and turning lethal.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-26ac831e61604c1c91c6c69cb604e03b", "input": "claim: Handguns must be banned in Washington D.C.\n perspective: The act of having a concealed handgun on one's person increases the likelihood of an argument increasing in intensity and resulting in death", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-5a5a56169b9d4cd88bae33102d4c22b4", "input": "claim: Handguns must be banned in Washington D.C.\n perspective: Concealed carrying of weapons results in a greater chance of a conflict becoming more intense to the point of death of one party.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-6528ccc961e84b3a925fe3b94dd2531c", "input": "claim: The imprisoned members of Pussy Riot should be considered political prisoners.\n perspective: The blasphemy charge looks suspiciously convenient for Putin", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-bbbe10d732fc4cc78e50b46bcec25bc9", "input": "claim: The imprisoned members of Pussy Riot should be considered political prisoners.\n perspective: Blasphemy is just a way for Putin to go after his enemies.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-37398c475f0a460487d075c5e29179e0", "input": "claim: The imprisoned members of Pussy Riot should be considered political prisoners.\n perspective: Putin uses blasphemy charges in order to solidify his hold on power.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-b5e46ec5c659451287072a455165e97e", "input": "claim: The imprisoned members of Pussy Riot should be considered political prisoners.\n perspective: Why use the form of a prayer and mention the Virgin in a political protest?", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4348488ab828412b80b18ae188d6f583", "input": "claim: The imprisoned members of Pussy Riot should be considered political prisoners.\n perspective: What does religion have to do in a political protest?", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-21bf0ff8eaa447469774a9a3f085c5c4", "input": "claim: We should use torture to obtain information from suspected terrorists.\n perspective: In the event of an imminent attack it is only reasonable to use force to find information ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-0244250495a9483e88449a23778605b6", "input": "claim: We should use torture to obtain information from suspected terrorists.\n perspective: It Should Be Permissible to Torture Suspected Terrorists", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c2ba3fa58f904de7873d1663ac2e2559", "input": "claim: We should use torture to obtain information from suspected terrorists.\n perspective: Terrorist organisations such as Al Qaida do not respect the rights of individuals and the only way to fight fire is with fire", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a3af14cc2aef495e914a915fce94cceb", "input": "claim: We should use torture to obtain information from suspected terrorists.\n perspective: Time is of the essence in a crisis. When confronted with extremists who see a virtue in their own death, extraordinary methods may be required. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-13b982cea37945d0807ed2e5ce460f2c", "input": "claim: We should use torture to obtain information from suspected terrorists.\n perspective: Introducing the use of violence into the justice system means that liberties that have taken centuries to secure are lost ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-bf18b397662e4ef7b63796a5d8625b95", "input": "claim: We should use torture to obtain information from suspected terrorists.\n perspective: Torturing suspects undermines the rights of all Americans.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-80636a91a2154fa4a3932ab968cc4bea", "input": "claim: We should use torture to obtain information from suspected terrorists.\n perspective: If legal principles are abandoned then there is little point in defending the liberties that democratic governments say they are so keen to defend ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-9dc9f79f8bcb46f1939a83892c786fad", "input": "claim: We should use torture to obtain information from suspected terrorists.\n perspective: Allowing torture under any circumstances will allow the prospect of its routine use ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ee9b7c3e9d0f4122bcd723edce9a84a5", "input": "claim: We should use torture to obtain information from suspected terrorists.\n perspective: Allowing torture will make it an every day procedure.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-06ff8212d0f9474d8243a122b6fa6e95", "input": "claim: We should use torture to obtain information from suspected terrorists.\n perspective: If torture is allowed it will become commonplace.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-85a8e23193ee43959157c2e79db7d26c", "input": "claim: The development of genetically modified organisms have to be banned.\n perspective: Genetically modified organisms can solve the problem of food supply in the developing world. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-86192dfdc0404b5e8c3891e0f7db9d2d", "input": "claim: The development of genetically modified organisms have to be banned.\n perspective: The problem of food supply in the developing world could be solved by genetically modified organisms.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a2547c28d069411bab03fca8a9ac93d4", "input": "claim: The development of genetically modified organisms have to be banned.\n perspective: The developing world's food supply problem could be solved by genetically modified organisms.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-5cf304daae174bc283e4eb4645c57734", "input": "claim: The development of genetically modified organisms have to be banned.\n perspective: Genetically modified food is no different from any other scientific advance, thus should be legal to use.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-0e36411efc9a40a98d4d426b4ec832d9", "input": "claim: The development of genetically modified organisms have to be banned.\n perspective: Genetically modified food should be legal to use because it is no different from any other scientific advance.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-f00712c1b3a64ad1b7426377a7329d62", "input": "claim: The development of genetically modified organisms have to be banned.\n perspective: The scientific advance of genetically modified food isn't different from any other advance and therefore should be legal to use.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e677ac522bcf432e846b7e360839701c", "input": "claim: The development of genetically modified organisms have to be banned.\n perspective: GMOs would create too much dependency on biotechnology companies", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-29269ab7b91e4215b92b20162279e16b", "input": "claim: The development of genetically modified organisms have to be banned.\n perspective: Too much dependency on biotechnology companies would be created by GMOs.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-0a7f190a5f86415489cad85c5e6a1894", "input": "claim: The development of genetically modified organisms have to be banned.\n perspective: We don’t need to eat GM food to be healthy ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f00809cbb7ec451f8c92d83192e76d9f", "input": "claim: The development of genetically modified organisms have to be banned.\n perspective: We can eat non-GM food and still be healthy", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-3cca5e9de26e4618a412ba23ee2f1852", "input": "claim: The development of genetically modified organisms have to be banned.\n perspective: It is possible to be healthy even without eating GM food", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a6a25e55295541458e362b844bc22854", "input": "claim: The development of genetically modified organisms have to be banned.\n perspective: Eating GM foods is not the only way to be healthy.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-81f4e805cc6a40309f04f1bc84b1ec5e", "input": "claim: The development of genetically modified organisms have to be banned.\n perspective: If we allow GM foods, where will science stop?", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-5f1231d3c9074c8f9538ccec72c008e4", "input": "claim: The development of genetically modified organisms have to be banned.\n perspective: Allowing GM foods is the beginning of a slippery slope.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-b4958df03dab44e7a5c76ff1cadfeb1e", "input": "claim: The development of genetically modified organisms have to be banned.\n perspective: If GM foods are allowed, then it might extend further and further.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-5bd3d193005d401fa7ca66a6214cc61c", "input": "claim: The development of genetically modified organisms have to be banned.\n perspective: The use of GM foods can become to reliant on science and not nature.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-6ec7b1a12ec241ad836fd93ca8bd9201", "input": "claim: The development of genetically modified organisms have to be banned.\n perspective: GM can make crops easier to grow by making them resistant to insects and herbicides.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a6840b2e8ca74b5c85485d6464b257d4", "input": "claim: The development of genetically modified organisms have to be banned.\n perspective: GM makes crops resistant to insects and herbicides, improving their ease of growth.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-2283003a6e1940bcabc1f36e24b01a81", "input": "claim: The development of genetically modified organisms have to be banned.\n perspective: GM reduces the difficulty of growing crops by making them resistant to insects and herbicides.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-fc2a8e9a9be64c0a85d1f6a9c792ffbc", "input": "claim: Rupert Murdoch is not a fit person to run an international media corporation.\n perspective: There was a lack of transparency in News Corp", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-beabe4cecb8d46088d710e6df69b3cb7", "input": "claim: Rupert Murdoch is not a fit person to run an international media corporation.\n perspective: News Corp's lack of transparency make it a suspect organization.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-b50e98d674f347db92605b32c6dbfb15", "input": "claim: Rupert Murdoch is not a fit person to run an international media corporation.\n perspective: The lack of transparency in News Corp creates a overwhelming distrust in the public view.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-61b8c8e36c1f4203b00792702d4cf4fd", "input": "claim: Rupert Murdoch is not a fit person to run an international media corporation.\n perspective: Murdoch is morally unfit to run a powerful media company.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f0070b7cda164ffcadd4bacc67c38ac1", "input": "claim: Rupert Murdoch is not a fit person to run an international media corporation.\n perspective: Rupert Murdoch is unfit to run a media company that has such broad influence.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f6fba6f879914a31ac6bee53e2c749f5", "input": "claim: Rupert Murdoch is not a fit person to run an international media corporation.\n perspective: Murdoch is unfit to run a company where morals need to matter.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-71b5b6a154d4437789c8353b41154f29", "input": "claim: Rupert Murdoch is not a fit person to run an international media corporation.\n perspective: Murdoch is effective at selling news", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4b080d8a81c24b99a21294aba4b5540f", "input": "claim: Rupert Murdoch is not a fit person to run an international media corporation.\n perspective: Murdoch is effective at selling news to the masses, sadly because of his lack of morals.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e0be8da81f044a61b2e5ac7d2ff7a549", "input": "claim: Rupert Murdoch is not a fit person to run an international media corporation.\n perspective: Murdoch excels at sensational headlines making for effective sales.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-349c546d3aee4edf8fbe242249d80dcc", "input": "claim: Government should be required to obtain warrants to access data that can be used to track an individual.\n perspective: Reducing trust in the state", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b3e463c9295f48528f976d3b94409695", "input": "claim: Government should be required to obtain warrants to access data that can be used to track an individual.\n perspective: People do not trust a state that allows individual monitoring.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ed88676ab6b84e139a4bedbb0f1fbf6e", "input": "claim: Government should be required to obtain warrants to access data that can be used to track an individual.\n perspective: If governments track people without warrants then people lose trust in the state.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-d83e29a9b07e40109d666f970a78cfda", "input": "claim: Government should be required to obtain warrants to access data that can be used to track an individual.\n perspective: Warrants are needed to prevent abuse", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c84f3201d4df4c6bafd3d05c85ab36f8", "input": "claim: Capitalism is better than socialism.\n perspective: Incentive in form of profit benefits society as a whole", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-8403b1c595584dc8bf132bc984bc1423", "input": "claim: Capitalism is better than socialism.\n perspective: Socialism is a more secure system than the free market in Capitalism", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-3fd02a40929f45acb41a08d87ab7a60f", "input": "claim: Capitalism is better than socialism.\n perspective: Socialism outranks capitalism in security.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-9932fc2f014b45f4a3552828f4d94b84", "input": "claim: Capitalism is better than socialism.\n perspective: Capitalism is less secure than socialist systems. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-00c9cfc339c340a89c3175d541bbf605", "input": "claim: Capitalism is better than socialism.\n perspective: Socialism was a twentieth century ideology which ran its course and ran out of steam when it became clear that Capitalism worked better", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-80ca5fc11920410f8b3afe8732c4af78", "input": "claim: Capitalism is better than socialism.\n perspective: Capitalism replaced Socialism because it's the better system.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-bf6b429fac3b489c9517d7f2ce93d83f", "input": "claim: Capitalism is better than socialism.\n perspective: Socialism died out, making way for Capitalism.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-19b5fd863fba47c7945102083945ad65", "input": "claim: Capitalism is better than socialism.\n perspective: Socialism has changed historically to meet the challenges of the moment and is addressing those of the 21st century in new ways", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-7c6c91bb727846e6a0bbdd2ea052b25d", "input": "claim: Capitalism is better than socialism.\n perspective: Socialism can be molded to fit the needs of the moment. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4c47c58b333847adb764639a87196ee3", "input": "claim: Capitalism is better than socialism.\n perspective: Socialism is a an ever changing set of principles that can be applied in new ways to meet the challenges of a changing world.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-f5132b7b01ee4580bb5d7391fa42be5d", "input": "claim: Capitalism is better than socialism.\n perspective: socialism have changed and adapted to meet the upcoming challenges of the 21st century", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4231b80d6feb4a0f80c0819fb41935ba", "input": "claim: Capitalism is better than socialism.\n perspective: Even the leaders of the Left have given up on Socialism as a creed and have now accepted the vast majority of modern Capitalist principles", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-6648b890a6e94c3781359c647b77b7c2", "input": "claim: Capitalism is better than socialism.\n perspective: Socialism is no longer seen as a viable option and even the Left has accepted that Capitalism is a better system.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-57ff4b08b3e443d6bec5e10a47e3577f", "input": "claim: Capitalism is better than socialism.\n perspective: Capitalist principles are now being seen as a better option than Socialism even by the leaders of the Left. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-fea9b4b548414a1e8204b28e28acbf0f", "input": "claim: Capitalism is better than socialism.\n perspective: even left side leaders have accepted capitalism pirnciples and have given up on socialism as a creed", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-0deca6bbd3f44bccadc7d21b5fcdf585", "input": "claim: Capitalism is better than socialism.\n perspective: Even the left fielders are now accepting capitalist principles over socialism in term of real way of life", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-eec9a16541024a788f1d65f34226dfe5", "input": "claim: Capitalism is better than socialism.\n perspective: Globalisation has made socialism impractical to implement", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-608090c3dccb4131b8e7aabce27fe16a", "input": "claim: It is worth voting.\n perspective: Hold politicians to account", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-22bba61221b44579b94f77e51d220c59", "input": "claim: It is worth voting.\n perspective: Have your say", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-bb875b01d94448cdad99adedb286f05e", "input": "claim: It is worth voting.\n perspective: Voice your opinions.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c9ec33201ff641c5a0b587fc255c452d", "input": "claim: It is worth voting.\n perspective: My vote does not count", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-012c988fbd41478a986aa67eeb94cd04", "input": "claim: It is worth voting.\n perspective: My vote is not helpful.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-f3cb23c7e02446b3944653639f0d246f", "input": "claim: It is worth voting.\n perspective: When I vote, I don't feel like the vote I have is important.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-88f68f40198d4da3a13840fdf8abcd7f", "input": "claim: It is worth voting.\n perspective: Civic duty", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-074e57cba67e4c649e058f072afe337b", "input": "claim: It is worth voting.\n perspective: Politicians will simply ignore how we vote", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c000e2cda2c546e4ba54cf23f6426e24", "input": "claim: It is worth voting.\n perspective: Politicians will not pay any attention to our votes.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-d65f09fab17c4017a257f895ad42883c", "input": "claim: It is worth voting.\n perspective: Our votes will not be acknowledged by our representatives.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-64b7486e7eb342ad83b510bd89a36374", "input": "claim: It is worth voting.\n perspective: Politicians don’t engage with issues that are important to me", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-df5c3b0b818748c2bd200dc5f66a8178", "input": "claim: It is worth voting.\n perspective: Politicians don't care about engaging with me about issues that matter for me.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b839fa6b76c64176b58cb727712e5796", "input": "claim: It is worth voting.\n perspective: We don’t just vote for ourselves ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-885e52255f6746bc913726300b8bf404", "input": "claim: It is worth voting.\n perspective: We vote not just for ourselves.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-435759d1763d479391ad562325cc6f57", "input": "claim: It is worth voting.\n perspective: When we vote, its not just for ourselves.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-892c569e08a647a69ec55f8256cda6fb", "input": "claim: Civil liberties should be sacrificed for the greater good.\n perspective: The threat of terrorism and security risks are overstated.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-f993c5cafb14436898edebabbd8087f5", "input": "claim: Civil liberties should be sacrificed for the greater good.\n perspective: The loss of individual liberty is the start of a slippery slope.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-020cfab41e9643eda99d83ba15b38ea0", "input": "claim: Civil liberties should be sacrificed for the greater good.\n perspective: Losing individual liberties leads to dangerous times.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-375a662c66e043f08c8868ff8af99dcd", "input": "claim: Civil liberties should be sacrificed for the greater good.\n perspective: The loss of individual freedoms is the beginning of dark times.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-3d3406825d4d44c7a167071c95db6969", "input": "claim: Civil liberties should be sacrificed for the greater good.\n perspective: It would be letting the terrorists win", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-3a1b847af68f48128339fd80ea557fc7", "input": "claim: Civil liberties should be sacrificed for the greater good.\n perspective: The terrorists would win in that case!", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-09195360a91446debe589e6cb17898b6", "input": "claim: Civil liberties should be sacrificed for the greater good.\n perspective: That is an open invitation for the terrorists.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-048a0b899b3c47d682a7ed4acba6a898", "input": "claim: Civil liberties should be sacrificed for the greater good.\n perspective: National security is something that must be protected even at the cost of", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-605a16d9f356467fb3399be7f4ecbffb", "input": "claim: Civil liberties should be sacrificed for the greater good.\n perspective: The protection of national security is worth the loss of some civil liberties.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-7ed82c094def4fb9b2a9a9212b105cc8", "input": "claim: Fighting should be allowed in hockey.\n perspective: Fighting in hockey leads to concussions, mental health problems, and death.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-3b218fed43f34d86a7ffa4596f0d0d96", "input": "claim: Fighting should be allowed in hockey.\n perspective: Fighting draws fans and increases the game's entertainment value.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-2e4deaf7065545de98f05f7f94b9ef0a", "input": "claim: Fighting should be allowed in hockey.\n perspective: Fighting is a hockey tradition that exists in the official rules and as an unwritten code among players.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-dccc586561a64d0b8f3558a61972343a", "input": "claim: Fighting should be allowed in hockey.\n perspective: Fighting at the professional level sets a bad example for kids.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4969f6f7d6e243d68d9b5719c010a981", "input": "claim: Fighting should be allowed in hockey.\n perspective: Fighting in hockey glorifies violence.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-fffb24acd81b4a1d95a4c3556bcd2eaa", "input": "claim: Fighting should be allowed in hockey.\n perspective: Fighting in hockey can promote violence", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-93506d6258034916b40014563fbbc712", "input": "claim: Fighting should be allowed in hockey.\n perspective: Hockey fights can glorify violence", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a5177f81d08e4c1e998f2d32142966fd", "input": "claim: Fighting should be allowed in hockey.\n perspective: The great aspect of the game of hockey are overshadowed by the unnecessary brutality displayed during brawls.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ff6d15d31c724900bfc57989755763c2", "input": "claim: Fighting should be allowed in hockey.\n perspective: An overemphasis is given to the violence that accompanies fighting in hockey.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c45336271be347df966c6f845c1b2f8c", "input": "claim: It is good to gossip.\n perspective: We have forgotten to mind our own business", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e467623a034f4af29d7866cd26e03a96", "input": "claim: It is good to gossip.\n perspective: Malevolent gossip can have a devastating impact on the person involved", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-aae1134eb793452fb6afd6a819cfdf56", "input": "claim: It is good to gossip.\n perspective: Gossip is not necessarily destructive", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c7884cc8915a4097bf936eece379b1b1", "input": "claim: It is good to gossip.\n perspective: Gossip isn't always detrimental.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-153d9f7e862c409db19ec270e2c23b18", "input": "claim: It is good to gossip.\n perspective: Gossip is important for moulding society", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-8021730e077749aab965c77578bd63ad", "input": "claim: It is good to gossip.\n perspective: The gossip market is too large as it is. We should be careful about encouraging this intellectual dumbing down of our reading material. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-78646069abfd4651b8a5365ee9d67b60", "input": "claim: The Republika Srpska must be allowed to secede from Bosnia & Herzegovina.\n perspective: Republika Srpska cannot survive economically as an independent state.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-957be1942ce34cdf93a0a9464750cd4d", "input": "claim: The Republika Srpska must be allowed to secede from Bosnia & Herzegovina.\n perspective: Republika Srpska isn't economically viable.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-cd34f7fcd88347b3ad498d378e403611", "input": "claim: The Republika Srpska must be allowed to secede from Bosnia & Herzegovina.\n perspective: If independent, Republika Srpska wouldn't survive economically.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-049c4f80a25b4194864c52256eea3143", "input": "claim: The Republika Srpska must be allowed to secede from Bosnia & Herzegovina.\n perspective: The present state structure does not work.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-3779eb2bd62d4655b179686613ceae07", "input": "claim: The Republika Srpska must be allowed to secede from Bosnia & Herzegovina.\n perspective: The current structure of the state is flawed. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-761a37e743894d6dba3cb72965159252", "input": "claim: The Republika Srpska must be allowed to secede from Bosnia & Herzegovina.\n perspective: The structure of the current state is broken. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d468a59193b1479dab49ab1d66ebd529", "input": "claim: The Republika Srpska must be allowed to secede from Bosnia & Herzegovina.\n perspective: Secession will lead to renewed conflict.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-95da8d3d7f954103b53596fb8ed495d2", "input": "claim: The Republika Srpska must be allowed to secede from Bosnia & Herzegovina.\n perspective: Renewed conflict will come about from secession. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-daf6a8f995b54402a5b9c4da018d1b98", "input": "claim: The Republika Srpska must be allowed to secede from Bosnia & Herzegovina.\n perspective: Conflict will be begin again if secession takes place. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-05029cee5715413f87a2c27f04464cff", "input": "claim: The Republika Srpska must be allowed to secede from Bosnia & Herzegovina.\n perspective: Serbs have a right to Self-Determination.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-71f23b13956242beabb8db3f71437c39", "input": "claim: The Republika Srpska must be allowed to secede from Bosnia & Herzegovina.\n perspective: Serbs are entitled to control their own future. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-4eb92a4d54ff43e38bbe4aeedf89f582", "input": "claim: The Republika Srpska must be allowed to secede from Bosnia & Herzegovina.\n perspective: Self-Determination is a right that all Serbs are entitled to. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-feee9d5a5f7948f1b17b0ff4e8392aad", "input": "claim: The Republika Srpska must be allowed to secede from Bosnia & Herzegovina.\n perspective: There is legitimate precedent.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-6cfcac5116dd45d2b1c1ef604f4c5630", "input": "claim: The Republika Srpska must be allowed to secede from Bosnia & Herzegovina.\n perspective: The precedent is valid. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-52820d0801a44688be338876fdc730da", "input": "claim: The Republika Srpska must be allowed to secede from Bosnia & Herzegovina.\n perspective: The is a valid criterion. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d8adf46e019f49978e0a79dfce51dcf6", "input": "claim: Creationism should be discussed in school science lessons.\n perspective: Creationism lacks scientific support, therefore should not be taught in a science lesson", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-7eab4d3a772b49079bebb59a9d3d4b80", "input": "claim: Creationism should be discussed in school science lessons.\n perspective: Creationism would need to be based on scientific support in order to be taught in these classes. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-3538e12eba7b42eb84d287930581a313", "input": "claim: Creationism should be discussed in school science lessons.\n perspective: Creationism should not be taught because it is not based on factual science. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-9f919d5a73ed4966aca05b350e63bd52", "input": "claim: Creationism should be discussed in school science lessons.\n perspective: creationism has no science support and need not be taught", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-3b18bbe35b684eb4b3589486f15ee5bd", "input": "claim: Creationism should be discussed in school science lessons.\n perspective: creationism should not be taught due to lack of evidence", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-47b3813c8c464e02a1a063788783d188", "input": "claim: Creationism should be discussed in school science lessons.\n perspective: It may be damaging to some students in a compulsory science lesson", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-217bf06ade60484198a5ddeeaea3a6b2", "input": "claim: Creationism should be discussed in school science lessons.\n perspective: Creationist lessons may be damaging to some students. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-8de2292996794d8aa8c10e6bb145db63", "input": "claim: Creationism should be discussed in school science lessons.\n perspective: In a compulsory science lesson, creationism may be damaging to certain students. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-94e114e0b853416db60e1f9ef975b012", "input": "claim: Creationism should be discussed in school science lessons.\n perspective: it can be damaging to many students in a compulsory lesson of science", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-d92fbdfa04f04829b800d0bd402bebed", "input": "claim: Creationism should be discussed in school science lessons.\n perspective: compulsory science lessons can be damaging ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-3689d979626a452e9fa343a8c3f7affc", "input": "claim: Creationism should be discussed in school science lessons.\n perspective: Science lessons are not always comprised of undisputed fact", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e9b8f738d28949d0a40e13d3530a2969", "input": "claim: Creationism should be discussed in school science lessons.\n perspective: Science lessons do not always represent undisputed facts. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c3b39307970046c08913a8a6cfeb5959", "input": "claim: Creationism should be discussed in school science lessons.\n perspective: Science lessons are sometimes centered on theories instead of facts. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-04d5d59e7cc747329d3efa8f31d20586", "input": "claim: Creationism should be discussed in school science lessons.\n perspective: science does not mean fact", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-82c28a15b20548f1abf824cd3e1e7a40", "input": "claim: Creationism should be discussed in school science lessons.\n perspective: scientific inquiry does not come up with facts", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-8f4b7c3bb891427e90f2365841e0932f", "input": "claim: Creationism should be discussed in school science lessons.\n perspective: Creationism is not based on scientific principles", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-148ffb86c5fd4f25bc7b976454bca1e9", "input": "claim: Creationism should be discussed in school science lessons.\n perspective: Even though creationism does not have scientific basis, it should be discussed at school.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e884abdf52a84accb6e2d7bd5196af40", "input": "claim: Creationism should be discussed in school science lessons.\n perspective: Science lessons tend to deal with fact, as opposed to opinion as in a religious education lesson", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b8da23f9b3b64c989696a2180cb0111a", "input": "claim: Creationism should be discussed in school science lessons.\n perspective: Science is grounded in fact whereas religion is not. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-aa3d53fe058745a3ba49155d60a0f930", "input": "claim: Creationism should be discussed in school science lessons.\n perspective: Religious education is not based on scientific facts. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-228d66e478a2460ebad86dac1ab5f19b", "input": "claim: Creationism should be discussed in school science lessons.\n perspective: science is fact and religious education is opinion", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e1254ff6b4334d1995cb80a224a932ca", "input": "claim: Creationism should be discussed in school science lessons.\n perspective: Creationism is fact, according to a creationist", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ac34dfa1754843dda692d44d7e660632", "input": "claim: Creationism should be discussed in school science lessons.\n perspective: Students deserve to learn about different theories from each religion", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-da8c58880c48432aaf885f8ef53ed9a0", "input": "claim: Creationism should be discussed in school science lessons.\n perspective: Students should learn about all theories of our beginnings. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-9d5d1ff5bf4a4d0abf736fc6406e28fe", "input": "claim: Creationism should be discussed in school science lessons.\n perspective: Students should learn creationist throeries from all religions. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-96bb598e67cd410d9a0a5dae3ae2986d", "input": "claim: Creationism should be discussed in school science lessons.\n perspective: students should learn different ideas from religion", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-2e8281dafcdb45fc970d1dd77453b7c1", "input": "claim: Creationism should be discussed in school science lessons.\n perspective: students need new ideas from religion", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c77046c8c373486e923b968b53ef4fdc", "input": "claim: Creationism should be discussed in school science lessons.\n perspective: Parents may choose to raise their children according to a specific religion but that does not require that society must follow", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-829330048efc415ba25c9e136eaef072", "input": "claim: Creationism should be discussed in school science lessons.\n perspective: Everyone can choose their own beliefs. Nobody should be forced to follow a specific religion against their will.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-d65a7aff54b74bbfa91edd3cbb580152", "input": "claim: Creationism should be discussed in school science lessons.\n perspective: Science teachers should be sympathetic to each individual student", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-b2593311803c44d8901db395d1641a3e", "input": "claim: Post Office Should Be Privatized.\n perspective: If the government can save the banks, why not the Post Office?", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e4d6c034d78043cabd4a511d839de62c", "input": "claim: Post Office Should Be Privatized.\n perspective: The Post Office is inefficient", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-2ee4f22b1f0f445483b7e4e3c44bc80f", "input": "claim: All nations have a right to nuclear weapons.\n perspective: Humanitarian intervention becomes impossible in states that possess nuclear weapons", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-7e5603c7a1cd4a2e8d09187c6d532325", "input": "claim: All nations have a right to nuclear weapons.\n perspective: Humanitarian missions would not be possible in states that have nuclear weapons.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b3cdd78f8e134c7cba61e4d3e81193c0", "input": "claim: All nations have a right to nuclear weapons.\n perspective: It is very difficult to intercede in humanitarian crises in states wherein nuclear weapons are present.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-cd7d89707d9842de8e5a65b5717b2929", "input": "claim: All nations have a right to nuclear weapons.\n perspective: The threat of a state developing nuclear weapons could instigate pre-emptive strikes from its neighbours and rivals to prevent the acquisition of such weapons", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b43e270a03da45fda2eb9cbe0534c89c", "input": "claim: All nations have a right to nuclear weapons.\n perspective: Other countries could strike against those developing nuclear weapons to protect themselves.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ddf0d66ab6a6496c85c8b02e8ca66852", "input": "claim: All nations have a right to nuclear weapons.\n perspective: To keep other countries from obtaining a nuclear arsenal, other nations may pre-emptively strike.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-8f3277653a4441189942b2b3ecdefa8a", "input": "claim: All nations have a right to nuclear weapons.\n perspective: The intention of a state to develop nuclear weapons may incite military attacks by enemies and by other supporting countries.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-72b1c2f3b6394aaabf13e75600a73a01", "input": "claim: All nations have a right to nuclear weapons.\n perspective: Nuclear weapons are required for deterrence ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f6679380c3524e2e905df333f7c4aa9d", "input": "claim: All nations have a right to nuclear weapons.\n perspective: Public acknowledgement of the right to nuclear deterrence will benefit the public regulation of nuclear weapons generally", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ba6f42947484479ca9edbec8d272c2ad", "input": "claim: All nations have a right to nuclear weapons.\n perspective: Nuclear weapons give states valuable agenda-setting power on the international stage", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-6f353beddcc8490dbe2b17ffb9c17a95", "input": "claim: All nations have a right to nuclear weapons.\n perspective: Countries with nuclear weapons have the ability to set their own agenda.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-79d317ca66da4eb3b755b4b88621ef8b", "input": "claim: All nations have a right to nuclear weapons.\n perspective: States with nuclear weapons are afforded more authority to set agendas at international levels.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-2839226346b04910b0b088782878251d", "input": "claim: All nations have a right to nuclear weapons.\n perspective: All countries have a right to defend themselves with nuclear weapons, even when they lack the capacity in conventional weapons", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-55aaf162917d4ab89584af8ca6e2218e", "input": "claim: All nations have a right to nuclear weapons.\n perspective: All states have a right to nuclear self-defense.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d48624f1588540e9afad0315ff53b072", "input": "claim: All nations have a right to nuclear weapons.\n perspective: To use nuclear weapons in defense of the nation is lawful for all countries.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-fb102b6722994f618d3ab86edd6b77c4", "input": "claim: All nations have a right to nuclear weapons.\n perspective: countries have to right to self defense with nuclear weapons, even when they lack capacity in conventional weapon", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c6124adb7517415f81360ae318c8178d", "input": "claim: All nations have a right to nuclear weapons.\n perspective: all countries are entitled to self defense with nuclear weapons, even when they do not have the capacity to carry conventional weapons", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-06ddc4fc7e5646b688394b364962af9e", "input": "claim: All nations have a right to nuclear weapons.\n perspective: All countries have an inherent right to self-defense even when they lack the capacity to do so with conventional weapons.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-423528a90ece4f9c9cd423e716b26b29", "input": "claim: All nations have a right to nuclear weapons.\n perspective: Possessing nuclear weapons will be counter to the peaceful interests of states", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-7ae2910fa0d9452cbe6b39e0881a7f31", "input": "claim: All nations have a right to nuclear weapons.\n perspective: The United States has an obligation to protect international stability due to its unique military strength.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-cc0cda6de0a94ed2b11de24722acdd90", "input": "claim: All nations have a right to nuclear weapons.\n perspective: The US must protect the international community.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-d365aab169cb44dba0005aa66757736d", "input": "claim: All nations have a right to nuclear weapons.\n perspective: The US military is needed to ensure peace.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a70ca931e9954507af97c7f2b33f8eb9", "input": "claim: All nations have a right to nuclear weapons.\n perspective: Nuclear waste disposal is rarely safe/efficient; it is too much to expect a sqeaky clean disposal/disarmament of nuclear weapons ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-9476fb5058224fcfb4a623ef270af844", "input": "claim: All nations have a right to nuclear weapons.\n perspective: Disarmament is impossible, rendering efforts to disarm pointless and simply wasteful", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-140e7b63f43743c0a847bf324668b6c1", "input": "claim: All nations have a right to nuclear weapons.\n perspective: Abolishment is an unrealistic goal", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-331178b1a50e497c8e2aa1b38b2e29e4", "input": "claim: All nations have a right to nuclear weapons.\n perspective: Small countries would be able to pursue their independence without having to rely on larger countries.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-5c2217b167c44633ab7d93bab0d6a755", "input": "claim: All nations have a right to nuclear weapons.\n perspective: Disarmament would actually cause increased insecurity among nations, it is near impossible to guarantee that a nation has disarmed.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-972b1d561ee440fd850c3c2a149e14e7", "input": "claim: All nations have a right to nuclear weapons.\n perspective: Small countries would no longer need the protection of larger ones, so could become more politically independent.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-4d58000bacf54178ac8678d5e9818c5e", "input": "claim: All nations have a right to nuclear weapons.\n perspective: Disarmament would actually cause increased insecurity among nations, you can never really know for sure whether they have disarmed.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d51260f3315743868a1b7a82250f6879", "input": "claim: All nations have a right to nuclear weapons.\n perspective: Disarmament would actually cause increased insecurity among nations, as there can never be any guarantee that a nation has disarmed", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-67938e8ed3c04e0496a0b4905a62f484", "input": "claim: All nations have a right to nuclear weapons.\n perspective: Thus the super power model will be broken and small countries will be finally given the chance to have political independence without the need of protection from a ‘big brother’.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c52569adc42f44f2a5185d6c2a2ce3ab", "input": "claim: All nations have a right to nuclear weapons.\n perspective: The abolition of nuclear weapons would actually incentivize the development and use of even more dangerous weapons, such as chemical and biological weapons", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ae6b5e9f6d164c8699173383e059aa0a", "input": "claim: All nations have a right to nuclear weapons.\n perspective: Proliferation of nuclear weapons increases the chances of nuclear accidents", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-175513764c584b4aa2860fb3aa51d48f", "input": "claim: All nations have a right to nuclear weapons.\n perspective: Nuclear weapons can fall into the wrong hands.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b9b3ada949b848d29f127c9626f4df6c", "input": "claim: All nations have a right to nuclear weapons.\n perspective: Risk of nuclear weapons falling into the wrong hands", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b794afe061a548bcbed831cb1a927b42", "input": "claim: All nations have a right to nuclear weapons.\n perspective: States will give terrorists nuclear weapons", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-cb8a101784e5444c88f427a4838cf392", "input": "claim: All nations have a right to nuclear weapons.\n perspective: It's conceivable that the wrong people will have the weapons.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-0d816a5483164b7cacefcca39f1aca25", "input": "claim: All nations have a right to nuclear weapons.\n perspective: The nukes can end up being used against us.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-d2999bfee6084ea8952139290c8a4407", "input": "claim: All nations have a right to nuclear weapons.\n perspective: Terrorists will steal nuclear weapons from poorly guarded arsenals", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b01152e6a5ab458c9afad1aa22a953c1", "input": "claim: All nations have a right to nuclear weapons.\n perspective: Irrational leaders make the possession of nuclear weapons dangerous", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-793e1a9f98374d8e9f0d5b30e4cd49a2", "input": "claim: All nations have a right to nuclear weapons.\n perspective: It is immoral to use the threat of nuclear annihilation in order to achieve foreign policy aims", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-22dd6dad8c3d48478841bb83a38e5339", "input": "claim: All nations have a right to nuclear weapons.\n perspective: All the people worldwide have the same rights and are equal to one another. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-2d967a4411334fd59cf0fc360ab1191a", "input": "claim: All nations have a right to nuclear weapons.\n perspective: The pursuit of nuclear defence (respectively the possession of nuclear weapons) by more countries is a guarantee for peace. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d9853dd233e3454dbebc8057a1ac9fe1", "input": "claim: All nations have a right to nuclear weapons.\n perspective: any conflict will rapidly de-escalate", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-96e6a3150ca24e22a561749746ab31e5", "input": "claim: All nations have a right to nuclear weapons.\n perspective: Nuclear weapons will rapidly de-escalate conflicts.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-0441ea256be74a72959a6c0c33f24649", "input": "claim: All nations have a right to nuclear weapons.\n perspective: Conflicts can be circumvented with nuclear weapons", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ab4048b260534d59b3eed7afdb6c2126", "input": "claim: All nations have a right to nuclear weapons.\n perspective: both sides will avoid threatening vital interests", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-b0abb071eb8e4b06931193555016b62f", "input": "claim: All nations have a right to nuclear weapons.\n perspective: Both the use and threat of nuclear weapons are illegal", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-1dbd2a0184864b749690295ab2ade420", "input": "claim: All nations have a right to nuclear weapons.\n perspective: The development of tactical nuclear weapons by one state would lead to a new global arms race.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-62a94c734314470580760b2945101a0b", "input": "claim: All nations have a right to nuclear weapons.\n perspective: Countries need to design nuclear devices to adapt with changing defensive technology.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-fd1195b245f543439141b06b9a5f042b", "input": "claim: All nations have a right to nuclear weapons.\n perspective: Tactical nuclear weapons are very expensive to design and build, yet will likely have no new strategic value.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-bd8c381015fb4a0a93e66cafd267b0d7", "input": "claim: All nations have a right to nuclear weapons.\n perspective: Tactical nuclear warheads are more serviceable for use in intimidation and retaliation toward enemies, as they are considerably less catastrophically destructive than those of current nuclear arsenals.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-b9584ec4e54c40009f3c824dcacaff3b", "input": "claim: All nations have a right to nuclear weapons.\n perspective: The way tactical nuclear weapons need to be deployed control of their use is devolved to field commanders, vastly increasing the probability that in the event of conflict they would be used.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-2ac64b5adb334b60ba92a6b1a6465585", "input": "claim: All nations have a right to nuclear weapons.\n perspective: [Iran specific] Others, particularly Israel, would act if the United States did not", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-29089b1175154e0db24e27d93a523751", "input": "claim: All nations have a right to nuclear weapons.\n perspective: If the US does not act on Iran, Israel will", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-5a83ffee58ad4dcf99e3401215b48158", "input": "claim: Boys should go to boys only schools.\n perspective: boys are more aggressive, violent, stereotypically masculine in boys schools", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ec40d92090f2481493849f01b21a6efe", "input": "claim: Boys should go to boys only schools.\n perspective: thbt boys and girls should be educated serparatley", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-1962dac9ccfa4e26860bb9ecc40ba35a", "input": "claim: Boys should go to boys only schools.\n perspective: Kids regardless of gender should be taught in school together.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-523b5031506f444698e01de6fb205533", "input": "claim: Boys should go to boys only schools.\n perspective: Schools need to be gender neutral in order to ensure the kids safety.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-02e1d9d54f8a49eb967b77560447bdcb", "input": "claim: Boys should go to boys only schools.\n perspective: some boys and girls should be educated seperately", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-dea604f20d2c46d19d5319c34e9eb8ee", "input": "claim: Boys should go to boys only schools.\n perspective: seperate education for boys and girls have its own benefit", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-0d2215b096364eed901fd707741b807a", "input": "claim: We believe in world government.\n perspective: A world government would add another, laborious level of bureaucracy", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b748d2b60f4342f5ba2a6851a09c6702", "input": "claim: We believe in world government.\n perspective: A world government would take more power away from the people.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-20c21a754c8f41899bc4b27d2050d2aa", "input": "claim: We believe in world government.\n perspective: A world government would be inefficient.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-bac77ad3bc1144edac6b86d32b9b188a", "input": "claim: We believe in world government.\n perspective: The forces of nationalism are too strong to permit the loosening of state sovereignty any further", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-2df7714aae3a41ad8318ca08344f7f41", "input": "claim: We believe in world government.\n perspective: It is unrealistic to expect less state sovereignty.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-2392221d37fd48f3b1cd5263aa099338", "input": "claim: We believe in world government.\n perspective: The balance is too strong to expect it to change.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-02aaf3490fac4b9da99195e4c6ef20ef", "input": "claim: We believe in world government.\n perspective: There is no feasible transition path to a world government model", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-20ec89c57f5d4f8fb98181c292cf3ec2", "input": "claim: We believe in world government.\n perspective: A world government is too difficult to implement.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-f3c5ba0ee5f44b4caf80f351614f7017", "input": "claim: We believe in world government.\n perspective: The steps to a smooth transition to a world government are unclear.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-3374c807fc174b21ba21e0a1c15871bf", "input": "claim: We believe in world government.\n perspective: A world government would foster a constructive cosmopolitanism", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-1d0575d967694d0e8ba802e5c5eba1f5", "input": "claim: We believe in world government.\n perspective: There are benefits to a world government. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-bd03c9c8b0de41e9b87a95787c039cec", "input": "claim: We believe in world government.\n perspective: A world government would help us move forward as a whole.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c90311d3e8bc4c2680d86da242deff4f", "input": "claim: We believe in world government.\n perspective: A world government would be ineffective in practice", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-f8ed3e7f5ace4b148b5d141d7bb27d26", "input": "claim: We believe in world government.\n perspective: A world government is not realistic.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-65e16b68456748db8963e28972398f7a", "input": "claim: We believe in world government.\n perspective: World government would create more problems than it would fix.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-d75d6087d202499686e82e48c4185e88", "input": "claim: The United Nations has failed.\n perspective: : Main purpose of UN, to prevent war, has clearly not been achieved. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-67ad986e27ad425da7c23e07eb6c2a8b", "input": "claim: The United Nations has failed.\n perspective: The UN has performed a valuable service in preventing wars and in peacekeeping. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-2f97f4269ccc43179ce3415cc0ea9b36", "input": "claim: The United Nations has failed.\n perspective: UN is keeping its mission for peace", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-73173b2192ea46439d2ed234f92b5df9", "input": "claim: The United Nations has failed.\n perspective: The UN has done a great job with preventing wars ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-23e2ffa1fb39467f933e26aee2a48c85", "input": "claim: The United Nations has failed.\n perspective: The UN does good at maintaining peace", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-2ff0ce7e53e1477daa1c868ad25ac1ca", "input": "claim: Adolf Hitler Does Not Deserve His Reputation as Evil.\n perspective: He was not in his right mind", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-633950f2144d49bdab8694101caad265", "input": "claim: Animals have rights.\n perspective: Even if we did think that animals were less intelligent than humans beings they should be protected by rights", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-8a3417a8a2aa42bda0c89c2e97c3ba6b", "input": "claim: Animals have rights.\n perspective: animals are entitled to rights", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f38e25e8b382435dbbab7ac3ced12138", "input": "claim: Animals have rights.\n perspective: living beings have basic rights", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-46823d1106b04d9b9618a9a99a659ec4", "input": "claim: Animals have rights.\n perspective: Animals should be left in the wild", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-cfe13d2538334ad5aca2a6616396151c", "input": "claim: Subsidize poor communities.\n perspective: Subsidies are the most efficient way for a state to redistribute wealth within its borders.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d227dfa1ca1e42b280c8a29cec0e2e85", "input": "claim: Subsidize poor communities.\n perspective: Redistribution of wealth internal to a country is done most efficently through the use of subsidies.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ca21ba0dea4b4111a3dcbfdf180871ff", "input": "claim: Subsidize poor communities.\n perspective: Wealth redistribution is best done through the use of subsidies.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f0ef003d702d4a29836012c682de278c", "input": "claim: Subsidize poor communities.\n perspective: Government supervised redistribution of wealth is inefficient", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-23e4b1298994486fb17a5dbfbfb59721", "input": "claim: Subsidize poor communities.\n perspective: Government supervision of wealth redistribution is inefficient.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c3906f0d967a4b5d84ab3eea0e4fb573", "input": "claim: Subsidize poor communities.\n perspective: Government supervised redistribution of wealth is ineffective", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-1241d637fd7945babe27581b6b038f8e", "input": "claim: Subsidize poor communities.\n perspective: Subsidies create a sense of social equality", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-9400780110514123a15753a83d01f500", "input": "claim: Subsidize poor communities.\n perspective: Substandard living conditions have a broad environmental impact", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ded0f85c9923436cbe6587cb76336642", "input": "claim: Subsidize poor communities.\n perspective: There are environmental impacts to people living in substandard conditions.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-438e0f21815546769f441f7b5954d2f7", "input": "claim: Subsidize poor communities.\n perspective: Poor living conditions have many impacts on the environment.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-1e6f9c80aca049b5acb09c297d7dcb84", "input": "claim: Subsidize poor communities.\n perspective: The risk of creating dependence", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4aa4097721114b68868e989e1d1f3eed", "input": "claim: Subsidize poor communities.\n perspective: Social change", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a93e575e0d6e4c2394d39a242a3d4131", "input": "claim: The best way to protect Scottish interests in the EU is to vote for independence.\n perspective: Scottish independence might be a faster route out of the EU than a referendum. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-4c67d032dfa64e1d81c75398d0421ef9", "input": "claim: The best way to protect Scottish interests in the EU is to vote for independence.\n perspective: Scottish independence should be considered in lieu of a referendum.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-4a262c433a0143c6b2b916b4a7c16a5a", "input": "claim: The best way to protect Scottish interests in the EU is to vote for independence.\n perspective: Instead of a referendum, it might be quicker to enable Scottish independence.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c19ab213924d4e77b1692632330e7ce2", "input": "claim: The best way to protect Scottish interests in the EU is to vote for independence.\n perspective: Scotland has different interests to rUK", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-61d47c28989f4b5fa81b1fe1fef032de", "input": "claim: The best way to protect Scottish interests in the EU is to vote for independence.\n perspective: The many hidden subsidies to SE England would end.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e59a784342c141eda8799105460043da", "input": "claim: The best way to protect Scottish interests in the EU is to vote for independence.\n perspective: Independence would give Scotland clout where it matters", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-0182468afb944c40917e6caefb3bc360", "input": "claim: The best way to protect Scottish interests in the EU is to vote for independence.\n perspective: If Scotland were independent then it would have more power in important areas.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-883eb1ba60354b5cad58942c348e20a1", "input": "claim: The best way to protect Scottish interests in the EU is to vote for independence.\n perspective: An independent Scotland nation-state would give it more influence.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-fd118066b5184c3aac275f45ce1dc515", "input": "claim: The best way to protect Scottish interests in the EU is to vote for independence.\n perspective: Scotland will be unable to survive economically without England", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c106693c84b04aecb962fe09ad8f24b5", "input": "claim: The best way to protect Scottish interests in the EU is to vote for independence.\n perspective: Scotland's economy cannot survive if it doesn't have England to lean on.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a927b40b3c254001ae7dcae531d2853a", "input": "claim: The best way to protect Scottish interests in the EU is to vote for independence.\n perspective: Scotland would not be able to survive independently without England.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-cd1453987c0a4671a56140aed7b3aa9b", "input": "claim: The best way to protect Scottish interests in the EU is to vote for independence.\n perspective: Relations between Scots and English are deteriorating", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-b95ac2899f15405e95e9fb7181bc0f63", "input": "claim: The best way to protect Scottish interests in the EU is to vote for independence.\n perspective: Other small nation-states like Norway and the Republic of Ireland are successful", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-5da246ff85454916a1315e32fb0d17be", "input": "claim: The best way to protect Scottish interests in the EU is to vote for independence.\n perspective: Norway and the Republic of Ireland are examples of successful nation-states.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-cbcb148440444741b4f417f710ca3075", "input": "claim: The best way to protect Scottish interests in the EU is to vote for independence.\n perspective: You can look at Norway and the Republic of Ireland to see successful nation-states.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-1fce70383cdb49bc80f6c5f514edc0bb", "input": "claim: The best way to protect Scottish interests in the EU is to vote for independence.\n perspective: The Scots themselves would vote against independence if there was a referendum.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-3dc1e17925814109b62f174bdfd9379a", "input": "claim: The best way to protect Scottish interests in the EU is to vote for independence.\n perspective: If it should come to it, the Scottish people would not vote for independence.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-bea41f4c5b9f4eecbdae0fc21bcb955b", "input": "claim: The best way to protect Scottish interests in the EU is to vote for independence.\n perspective: Scots would not be in favor of voting for independence. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-376554b4aafe4fdbaee1bbbc3f1bee50", "input": "claim: Disclose previous convictions in court.\n perspective: Occasional disclosure of convictions leads to an inconsistent justice system.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-fc4bf97f41574a5b8b07fcae82276c40", "input": "claim: Disclose previous convictions in court.\n perspective: The justice system becomes inconsistent when convictions records are disclosed on an occasional basis", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-f5cf60fc48944672baebed83a241b9df", "input": "claim: Disclose previous convictions in court.\n perspective: Juries need to have all the information possible in order to reach a fair verdict.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-946c17d50d04482abb4844eaad859f54", "input": "claim: Disclose previous convictions in court.\n perspective: Juries should have complete information to come to a verdict", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-147fd684255a46b89a23841d4d1e8445", "input": "claim: Disclose previous convictions in court.\n perspective: To reach their verdict, juries should be give the most information possible", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-6102d78525684e8c94486e1acc297a15", "input": "claim: Disclose previous convictions in court.\n perspective: Justice will be denied with this motion.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c2f468a9c6b346ed906c8c8a10647894", "input": "claim: Disclose previous convictions in court.\n perspective: This motion will result in a bias in trial. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-50045901795a44128f77f3a0f9e05f87", "input": "claim: Disclose previous convictions in court.\n perspective: Allowing the motion would be wrong for justice.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-51bc3b9dce04470d8b5b91414eeb7cf3", "input": "claim: Disclose previous convictions in court.\n perspective: The disclosure of previous convictions could falsely characterize the defendant. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-614c33e3cadd4a70a85ae37009f9145e", "input": "claim: Disclose previous convictions in court.\n perspective: Discussing past convictions would hurt the defendant.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-5c42131cb01e4e52b6b5f4f7d621116f", "input": "claim: Disclose previous convictions in court.\n perspective: Talking about the defendants past would wrongly accuse his character.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-d98860ee618b44e28449a43b059e2ad2", "input": "claim: Disclose previous convictions in court.\n perspective: The motion completely undermines the assumption of innocence which accompanies a fair trial.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b5457284a7334e11b733679455fe2a49", "input": "claim: Disclose previous convictions in court.\n perspective: Having this motion goes against the presumption of innocence. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-47cfa5f2c96a43a78f0195d5469f956c", "input": "claim: Disclose previous convictions in court.\n perspective: The current system is unfairly weighted in favour of criminals.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-02b7d94622284bd692ba7a256d5bc01a", "input": "claim: Disclose previous convictions in court.\n perspective: We already recognise that we cannot place complete trust in juries.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-abe97cf6ce214d798510a35b0902afc9", "input": "claim: ID cards and the National Identity Register should be scrapped.\n perspective: ID cards will help protect cardholders against identity theft and fraud", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-18cc57df98da454f9d5d507943aa6cc5", "input": "claim: ID cards and the National Identity Register should be scrapped.\n perspective: ID cards will allow the police more quickly to identify suspects and people they arrest.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-6a3198e972e3492f9711cda74c7b44b0", "input": "claim: ID cards and the National Identity Register should be scrapped.\n perspective: ID cards will lead to increased discrimination", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f3d4f4b57581411a8411352156c0633a", "input": "claim: ID cards and the National Identity Register should be scrapped.\n perspective: ID cards will provide a reliable way of checking the identity of people in positions of trust", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a95dc7ec44fd4bf694b25ad8b0e0ab06", "input": "claim: ID cards and the National Identity Register should be scrapped.\n perspective: ID cards will help combat illegal working and reduce illegal immigration to the UK", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-2b5805df54ef40c0a14cf845fe9b4cde", "input": "claim: ID cards and the National Identity Register should be scrapped.\n perspective: They will provide a secure way of applying for financial products and making financial transactions, including those made over the internet", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-59b4f3b3580945c0a03a4166442fe9a1", "input": "claim: ID cards and the National Identity Register should be scrapped.\n perspective: The UK is a liberal society and unused to ID cards", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-8f5741aebec747569d2ca4cc9a88cf09", "input": "claim: ID cards and the National Identity Register should be scrapped.\n perspective: It will make it easier to travel in Europe", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a01627b05cd04ddabd86b5c3b413b95c", "input": "claim: ID cards and the National Identity Register should be scrapped.\n perspective: The UK is not that liberal a society and will adapt to ID cards", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-87661a606d484367b619d742a68a2973", "input": "claim: ID cards and the National Identity Register should be scrapped.\n perspective: ID cards will help to confirm your eligibility for public services and benefits – and reduce fraud relating to these services and benefits", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c5553d678cf84f34b764fdc358cafb26", "input": "claim: ID cards and the National Identity Register should be scrapped.\n perspective: ID Cards will not protect us from terrorism and crime!", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-3b46598bd5cd40b39ac3bc8ed6a41289", "input": "claim: Turkey should be let join the European Union.\n perspective: Turkey would be an unstable Muslim state in a traditionally Christian union", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-1c71b9f9ccf2456882196791b536af54", "input": "claim: Turkey should be let join the European Union.\n perspective: Turkey does not fit well because it is an unstable Muslim country while the EU has a Christian history.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-70d8da76dacb4e96878786f8dc945d84", "input": "claim: Turkey should be let join the European Union.\n perspective: The religious backgrounds of the EU being Christian and Turkey being Muslim and also not being stable are problems.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-143f618adb1446ab959f3195b548db4e", "input": "claim: Turkey should be let join the European Union.\n perspective: Turkey has a poor human rights record", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-62a8c8f73694412ba491ee0074ffa059", "input": "claim: Turkey should be let join the European Union.\n perspective: Turkey joining the EU would help the international fight against terrorism", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-6b10658720184bf88913243b8b51df4c", "input": "claim: Turkey should be let join the European Union.\n perspective: Turkey is a highly unstable democracy in an unstable part of the world", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-aca731eb31654d9b8f7cf9f1bed7c29c", "input": "claim: Turkey should be let join the European Union.\n perspective: The lack of stability in Turkey's democracy and in the area around Turkey are factors that argue against admission to the EU.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-82266f6b816c45b8ab09dcafc59556f8", "input": "claim: Turkey should be let join the European Union.\n perspective: The EU will not benefit by adding a country with an unstable democracy in an unstable part of the world.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-5ba07ae61d9b4dbba315d5c4373d8444", "input": "claim: Turkey should be let join the European Union.\n perspective: Any country that fulfils the accession criteria should be allowed to join", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-5c99e6bc227a4cf6bee7232ff12c8274", "input": "claim: Turkey should be let join the European Union.\n perspective: The geographical definition of Europe must be limited and does not include Turkey", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a618299f72db40b2992742ab3554cbbd", "input": "claim: Turkey should be let join the European Union.\n perspective: Other similarly situated countries including Romania and Bulgaria have be accepted into the EU.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-36fdbb722a284e8e83f2eeb7f5eb6d1c", "input": "claim: Turkey should be let join the European Union.\n perspective: There are precedents including the admission of Romania and Bulgaria into the EU.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-85dc013216a44c3cb820390023ef6a12", "input": "claim: Turkey should be let join the European Union.\n perspective: As a matter of precedent, Turkey should be allowed into the EU.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-9b9cb86651d94f82b74a655e81440764", "input": "claim: Turkey should be let join the European Union.\n perspective: Both Romania and Bulgaria have joined the EU, so it is appropriate for Turkey to be allowed in as well.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-cee73d36f1334f9e851507e912f212f9", "input": "claim: Turkey should be let join the European Union.\n perspective: Turkey has precedents, such as Romania and Bulgaria, both of whom were accepted into the EU", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a806f698123c4703b8d7f6aa1eb2bfd4", "input": "claim: Turkey should be let join the European Union.\n perspective: Precedent (Romania and Bulgaria)", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ccf8c42b4b1b4c5bbf0d6710954e2c5e", "input": "claim: Turkey should be let join the European Union.\n perspective: Animosity Between Turkey and Existing Member States, i.e. Greece", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-3e1275bc2cb94f4f9968d40c82611cbd", "input": "claim: Turkey should be let join the European Union.\n perspective: There is significant animosity between Turkey and some existing member states.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-891f29d6b01e445ebb12bcc402ecf435", "input": "claim: Turkey should be let join the European Union.\n perspective: Some members of the EU have poor relationships with Turkey.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e771780a8f544edab95ec3ec4b55e48b", "input": "claim: Turkey should be let join the European Union.\n perspective: Fear of a Backlash Due to Turkey's Political and Religious Influences", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-9d51d737a1ce4c55b9f0af9b57d24d7a", "input": "claim: Turkey should be let join the European Union.\n perspective: Turkey's political and religious influences could result in backlash.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-7bb2a96516a44fd9a710a92d2ba58561", "input": "claim: Turkey should be let join the European Union.\n perspective: Turkey has different political and religious influences than other member states, which could cause issues.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-9b20e2a878f94b0885c412860ad35607", "input": "claim: The ICC is biased against Africa.\n perspective: ICC treats Africa differently", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-2166a518ff53447180f8b29eb080267a", "input": "claim: The ICC is biased against Africa.\n perspective: ICC is biased against Africans ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f225af84f5e1469db7179c5d48440990", "input": "claim: The ICC is biased against Africa.\n perspective: The ICC is against African ideals.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-da4efb8cacb540acb96ced076c215328", "input": "claim: The ICC is biased against Africa.\n perspective: The ICC is in direct opposition of African beliefs. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-962daf782ec34879a2b6d41109230ec6", "input": "claim: The ICC is biased against Africa.\n perspective: The ICC has an anti-African bias", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-3df5d56ab21d4ae0a906fac3e3fcdf04", "input": "claim: The ICC is biased against Africa.\n perspective: Africa is overtly prosecuted", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-951e90dba8cc41718df048a52705bad3", "input": "claim: The ICC is biased against Africa.\n perspective: The ICC's Africa prosecutions are overtly biased.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-72d307bc52b949af9318951252b0d79c", "input": "claim: The ICC is biased against Africa.\n perspective: The ICC's bias against Africa is overt.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f0c7fe8bc8d04635a86f7d618285043d", "input": "claim: The ICC is biased against Africa.\n perspective: Africa has invited ICC intervention ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-1b08ed1968054e6b9775b384ce1e8d46", "input": "claim: The ICC is biased against Africa.\n perspective: Africa has a strong voice in the ICC ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-7d7023fab31840c592530bce6d74057b", "input": "claim: The EU, USA and other western donors should not fund any Palestinian government in which terrorist organisations participate.\n perspective: The outcome of the Palestinian elections should not be rewarded with aid. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-5c0055fe2ca74313ba84ce6a465fa19b", "input": "claim: The EU, USA and other western donors should not fund any Palestinian government in which terrorist organisations participate.\n perspective: Palestinian elections, although a significant step toward democracy, do not qualify their government for aid.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-5cb07116b5f749089c2464eff3ce6392", "input": "claim: The EU, USA and other western donors should not fund any Palestinian government in which terrorist organisations participate.\n perspective: Aid shouldn't be given to aid the outcome of the Palestinian elections.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-146ca566be8f4e92935dcc6f0871e9a7", "input": "claim: The EU, USA and other western donors should not fund any Palestinian government in which terrorist organisations participate.\n perspective: Western donors shouldn't fund the outcome of the Palestinian elections.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ebbb011798b04101a2e2c13f082b0e84", "input": "claim: The EU, USA and other western donors should not fund any Palestinian government in which terrorist organisations participate.\n perspective: Withholding funds will prevent PNA terrorism and anti-Semitism. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-0c5596d4b6774cd49af8da4ea6c8ce9d", "input": "claim: The EU, USA and other western donors should not fund any Palestinian government in which terrorist organisations participate.\n perspective: Withholding funds will increase security and stability in Palestine.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-167ea1c9a3544508a139cd8f77df8fea", "input": "claim: The EU, USA and other western donors should not fund any Palestinian government in which terrorist organisations participate.\n perspective: With no funding, PNA terrorism and anti-Semitism will be prevented.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-bd04101536744c2c9d95b3495645770a", "input": "claim: The EU, USA and other western donors should not fund any Palestinian government in which terrorist organisations participate.\n perspective: Withholding funds will cause Palestine to rely on anti-Israeli regimes. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-2c7051fabd204cd6ae21d102f7724993", "input": "claim: The EU, USA and other western donors should not fund any Palestinian government in which terrorist organisations participate.\n perspective: Withholding funds will further alienate Palestine and strengthen their reliance on anti-Israeli regimes.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-14f717a8266546c7bf969721b8f2936f", "input": "claim: The EU, USA and other western donors should not fund any Palestinian government in which terrorist organisations participate.\n perspective: The best way to reduce Palestine's allegiance to anti-Israeli organizations is the fund the Palestinian governments.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ead62dcd3ba248149bcefedf36cc84e8", "input": "claim: The EU, USA and other western donors should not fund any Palestinian government in which terrorist organisations participate.\n perspective: Without aid, Palestine will be forced to rely on anti-Israeli regimes. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4c86c7554cd94fc6a6ca1c4157b5cd53", "input": "claim: The EU, USA and other western donors should not fund any Palestinian government in which terrorist organisations participate.\n perspective: Palestine will have no other choice but to rely on anti-Israeli regimes if funds are withheld.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a0c8a6c33acf4f8090381e434c4c30f9", "input": "claim: The EU, USA and other western donors should not fund any Palestinian government in which terrorist organisations participate.\n perspective: The loss of funding would destabilise and radicalise Palestine. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-beadf4642237489a831d549d38a2ef83", "input": "claim: The EU, USA and other western donors should not fund any Palestinian government in which terrorist organisations participate.\n perspective: Engaging with Hamas is the best way to secure a peace deal between Israel and Palestine.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-0098d70abcc34c058628a3ba239e0a80", "input": "claim: The EU, USA and other western donors should not fund any Palestinian government in which terrorist organisations participate.\n perspective: The law prevents US and EU governments from funding terrorist groups. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-939678ad61594be2a4b3dde0522788dc", "input": "claim: The EU, USA and other western donors should not fund any Palestinian government in which terrorist organisations participate.\n perspective: Laws preventing US and EU governments from funding terrorist groups are sufficient.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-7130e14aa79a42078572980de3a36b7d", "input": "claim: The EU, USA and other western donors should not fund any Palestinian government in which terrorist organisations participate.\n perspective: US and EU governments cannot and will not fund any terrorist groups.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-40ebc2e3d24f49d48d9b8ee58599e713", "input": "claim: The EU, USA and other western donors should not fund any Palestinian government in which terrorist organisations participate.\n perspective: It's against the law for US and EU governments to fund terrorist groups originating from Palestine.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-df90bb55eadb4ff2bfe727d9c53ae2c5", "input": "claim: The EU, USA and other western donors should not fund any Palestinian government in which terrorist organisations participate.\n perspective: Palestinian government related terrorist groups cannot be funded by US and EU governments by law.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f95b21b90a9c4ceb9f1a05acc3ae567a", "input": "claim: Christians should be allowed to wear the Cross at work.\n perspective: Employers impose rules relating to conduct in the workplace, it’s one of the things that everyone accepts when they take and continue in a job.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e2855d60f45546fdb3acbe2c5506d46b", "input": "claim: Christians should be allowed to wear the Cross at work.\n perspective: It is the employer's rule so all employees should follow them", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-61e6e1d2e3e44df083bbb27897fbde02", "input": "claim: Christians should be allowed to wear the Cross at work.\n perspective: It is a workplace rule that has already been enforced and should have been expected", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-33a620d2664d4fe38125f4b56d2562f8", "input": "claim: Christians should be allowed to wear the Cross at work.\n perspective: Other religions have the right to wear prescribed clothing enshrined in British law, it is hypocritical not to offer Christianity the same protection. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-34ae283b2071477c90e2ff20119b150f", "input": "claim: Christians should be allowed to wear the Cross at work.\n perspective: It would be hypocritical to ban Christian items when those of other religions are protected", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e309b5fcb9034a3a9b75cd7e1f1bcff2", "input": "claim: Christians should be allowed to wear the Cross at work.\n perspective: Allowing other religious clothing but no a cross would not be fair", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-3fdf2a4a3aee44f887f67b2eb8c470c8", "input": "claim: Christians should be allowed to wear the Cross at work.\n perspective: If this were about wearing a badge with a political slogan or something similar, everyone would agree that it was inappropriate. The same principle should apply to iconography.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-8f561d297bef40f7a30ff1d591d83e57", "input": "claim: Christians should be allowed to wear the Cross at work.\n perspective: The way it is applied to political icons is how it should be applied to religious icons", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-8d3d0d1ecc8b456c9e46c0772978c28d", "input": "claim: Christians should be allowed to wear the Cross at work.\n perspective: People agree that political slogans aren't allowed and that same stance should apply here.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-d7517b82636845ccaf581710c1786b73", "input": "claim: Christians should be allowed to wear the Cross at work.\n perspective: The confession of religious faith is far more important than the rather petty rules that banned the wearing of the cross.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-59818e9cd889487b95aaa08698c426fe", "input": "claim: Christians should be allowed to wear the Cross at work.\n perspective: It is a fundamental right to practice the religion you wish.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-004af1cc8bf74af2afe8b5a55457b488", "input": "claim: Christians should be allowed to wear the Cross at work.\n perspective: Practicing your religion is a right, not a priveledge. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-17be2ad7bcdf4f538131b2a3fba8bc76", "input": "claim: Christians should be allowed to wear the Cross at work.\n perspective: Human rights demand that we are free to express our religion.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-2030dcc514a948428482d31cde6f2c40", "input": "claim: Christians should be allowed to wear the Cross at work.\n perspective: Religious expression needs to be guaranteed for all of us as part of our most fundamental rights!", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-246e8b94d7b947198bcdeba4be0ef241", "input": "claim: Christians should be allowed to wear the Cross at work.\n perspective: Freedom of expression, like any right is fairly meaningless if it’s only respected when it’s convenient.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-667dddcb10054afeb899ea82106bcd76", "input": "claim: Christians should be allowed to wear the Cross at work.\n perspective: It is a fundamental part of OUR Human Rights", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e73b47602b674d52b146362c56e4dd73", "input": "claim: Christians should be allowed to wear the Cross at work.\n perspective: Declaration of the faith is a key part of Christianity and that should be respected.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-93690b7fa9a247a784fae06e20dea141", "input": "claim: Christians should be allowed to wear the Cross at work.\n perspective: Declaring one's faith is something that should be allowed and respected by others", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-287350d90bc246728c20000ce263a28e", "input": "claim: Christians should be allowed to wear the Cross at work.\n perspective: Showing one's Christian faith is important to the religion and should be approved", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-7749535f115c4d07ba946ab87942035c", "input": "claim: Christians should be allowed to wear the Cross at work.\n perspective: Religious symbols harm no one", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-50852513cdb14bb98deb972300ecad35", "input": "claim: Christians should be allowed to wear the Cross at work.\n perspective: symbols for religious benefit bothers no one", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ac206677cf714b29a1fd5315b97ea268", "input": "claim: Christians should be allowed to wear the Cross at work.\n perspective: religious expression should be freely decided", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-0c4475ca1660484c9b60cd5dd9beec99", "input": "claim: The Internet must be censored.\n perspective: Censorship is fundamentally incompatible with the notion of free speech.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-0e47f7eeed2b4f6083b5ceb4edfd1d35", "input": "claim: The Internet must be censored.\n perspective: Internet Content must not be Censored because we are a country of free speech!", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-1af80893868f4068ba9343b4d652f35c", "input": "claim: The Internet must be censored.\n perspective: Internet censorship a violation of freedom of speech", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-2badd084c05e4bea90f9fb3bf3289299", "input": "claim: The Internet must be censored.\n perspective: People often react poorly to being censored by their governments.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-414bf8b575cd4928b2ca887f1947c07f", "input": "claim: The Internet must be censored.\n perspective: Governments have a moral duty to protect its citizens from harmful sites.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-217e792c1e17472791968e7b8ae9b8bb", "input": "claim: The Internet must be censored.\n perspective: The internet must be censored to protect society", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-2c834fbdb89e4adba0ba5c95ca50f4ca", "input": "claim: The Internet must be censored.\n perspective: Internet Nazis must be censored!", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-8ed90077392746db8cdfcd41b0abc52a", "input": "claim: The Internet must be censored.\n perspective: Even sites that appeared innocent have had a devastating effect on society.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f4648630d3804d88927117e0bfd9fcbd", "input": "claim: The Internet must be censored.\n perspective: It is difficult to ascertain at a glance which websites are harmful.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-9abfa47a28ce48389d22b0eb24d9ba8a", "input": "claim: The Internet must be censored.\n perspective: The Internet is a free domain and cannot becontrolled by the government.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-3108c326459d42c18982fb8ba989f17c", "input": "claim: The Internet must be censored.\n perspective: The government has no control over free domain and therefore cannot censor the internet.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-32a9c0eecc7a408ba7001801603ae102", "input": "claim: The Internet must be censored.\n perspective: As an extensive form of media, the Internet should be subject to regulation just as other forms of media are.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-9c35dfd277504aa8b7826f5d0d7fe960", "input": "claim: The Internet must be censored.\n perspective: Other forms of media are regulated and the internet is no different.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f10505920091459d96de931e2d918a15", "input": "claim: The Internet must be censored.\n perspective: We must apply the same standards to internet regulation that we apply to all media.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-7a9f5aab8b1440e1b4d84229b9f427d9", "input": "claim: The Internet must be censored.\n perspective: The government here may legitimately limit ‘free speech’.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f34a1e8ec17346719b68e8b0d5aab187", "input": "claim: USA must sign the Ottawa Convention banning landmines.\n perspective: Landmines are a useful military tool", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-261d5b25b6904251a121198534229286", "input": "claim: USA must sign the Ottawa Convention banning landmines.\n perspective: Landmines keep certain areas safe from wanderers.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-882a8accf1f7453388b93b38c5246d5a", "input": "claim: USA must sign the Ottawa Convention banning landmines.\n perspective: Landmines are an effective deterrent against guerrilla attacks.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-19319ef2fca84b41a83440b49551509c", "input": "claim: USA must sign the Ottawa Convention banning landmines.\n perspective: Banning Landmines is a step towards reducing the horror of war", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-6d87a7d1727e4790bdf4388863babef0", "input": "claim: USA must sign the Ottawa Convention banning landmines.\n perspective: Banning landmines would reduce how many innocent victims there are.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-701d648b132f4599bca8c240af34e6f5", "input": "claim: USA must sign the Ottawa Convention banning landmines.\n perspective: The ban fails to distinguish between different kinds of mines", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-6d4cab5ca5bc45f1851fdfc87a4d11dd", "input": "claim: We support the New START Treaty.\n perspective: The New START treaty helps Russia more than the US", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-2c963059c0e44054b583ad424a6e2d62", "input": "claim: We support the New START Treaty.\n perspective: The New START treaty favors Russia over the US.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-8a219f3055ac435eb6c6579811e91f32", "input": "claim: We support the New START Treaty.\n perspective: The New START treaty is better for Russia than for the US. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-8f0b7edbbcd94a15a285f5c0ccc345ce", "input": "claim: We support the New START Treaty.\n perspective: The New START treaty harms US nuclear capabilities ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-1fa815a28f2f491c8fe8560ab948d542", "input": "claim: We support the New START Treaty.\n perspective: The US Nuclear capabilities are hurt by the New START treaty.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-42d1b6df3bf14eaaaf6ebc28ef5201e7", "input": "claim: We support the New START Treaty.\n perspective: There is harm to the nuclear capabilities of the US by New START treaty.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-72143e486ef14b8eb29e02520909f8c3", "input": "claim: We support the New START Treaty.\n perspective: The New START treaty maintains US nuclear and missile defence.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d590211d854c4cf594c853a4d61525c7", "input": "claim: Basic income tax should be abolished.\n perspective: Abolishing Income Tax will grow the economy", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-368456b09b16460b8132ff79ee006108", "input": "claim: Basic income tax should be abolished.\n perspective: The economy will boom if we get rid of the income tax.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-032f3b062c1e4bc0b1d5e5aefa3017a4", "input": "claim: Basic income tax should be abolished.\n perspective: Income Tax is a cause of inequity in society", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d8748e49e6b647bc961362d3c87d653a", "input": "claim: Basic income tax should be abolished.\n perspective: income tax is not good", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e5faf57adede4c90815ed53cb195d954", "input": "claim: Basic income tax should be abolished.\n perspective: Balancing governmental deficits for common good of society", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-11b4a09c5ebc4d04a61a8e17a967bc2d", "input": "claim: Basic income tax should be abolished.\n perspective: With an increased standard of living for all the reason for crime would almost disappear.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ca1cd2c1a930462098e2f119e51e6ab1", "input": "claim: Basic income tax should be abolished.\n perspective: People who enjoy a standard of living that allows them to be healthy and productive will decrease drug abuse.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-96aeb0145b624da195df7b38d02a0789", "input": "claim: Basic income tax should be abolished.\n perspective: balancing common deficits of the government for society ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ae14c522ee83434db5a18348933994d9", "input": "claim: Basic income tax should be abolished.\n perspective: Redistributing wealth to balance the inequality of income disparity", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-5725181621f943f7af1450826b66c3e2", "input": "claim: Basic income tax should be abolished.\n perspective: It is immoral that some have nothing and a few others are enormously wealthy.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-57999b93c7dd4d009cfeef358f7a3f30", "input": "claim: Basic income tax should be abolished.\n perspective: Everyone should have the resources to live a healthy, productive life.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-65183dc4821a42908ae5816308bc7a14", "input": "claim: Basic income tax should be abolished.\n perspective: Changing the wealth around to help income disparity ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-6a39f55278a84720b66a59751eb33afc", "input": "claim: Basic income tax should be abolished.\n perspective: The best way to grow the economy is not by taxing the rich.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-83e55234b9504c5eb101ca508b587068", "input": "claim: Basic income tax should be abolished.\n perspective: Increasing an income tax won't fix the economy.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d934d66a31b74e7c96f63fe1d42c462e", "input": "claim: Basic income tax should be abolished.\n perspective: There are many better ways to redistribute wealth and pay for public goods and services besides raising income tax.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-169634ccf05b417a91091779e3fc017a", "input": "claim: Basic income tax should be abolished.\n perspective: When looking for ways to change the inequality of wealth and increase money available for public goods, income tax should not be the focus.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ef5336f89ac1490bb0ea32f2140348be", "input": "claim: The US intervention in Libya, lacking congressional approval, was illegal.\n perspective: The United States engaged in \"hostilities\" under War Powers", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4aadb62108694b3884f7a6e480ed55b5", "input": "claim: The US intervention in Libya, lacking congressional approval, was illegal.\n perspective: The US were not completely innocent under War Powers.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-33f6900a83af4b3f9b8ad99f5cd3fe3b", "input": "claim: The US intervention in Libya, lacking congressional approval, was illegal.\n perspective: The US intervention was acceptable as it was done under War Powers", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-f1664a47146c45fb83fe01cf925fded8", "input": "claim: The US intervention in Libya, lacking congressional approval, was illegal.\n perspective: The US had to take action in the circumstances under War Powers.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-dfcc15f44a8b471aa9255df9477bff68", "input": "claim: The US intervention in Libya, lacking congressional approval, was illegal.\n perspective: Congress was appropriately and openly consulted", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-754b9c130c9147938bedfbc366e01a6b", "input": "claim: The US intervention in Libya, lacking congressional approval, was illegal.\n perspective: Despite claims, congress was consulted.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4e5b31006ee54be0a9e844de5bbe3818", "input": "claim: The US intervention in Libya, lacking congressional approval, was illegal.\n perspective: Congress was aware of the action as they were consulted", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a9f9a65c96da44939814f82e98b424a8", "input": "claim: The US intervention in Libya, lacking congressional approval, was illegal.\n perspective: The intervention was necessary in order to protect US interests in the region", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-65a7a9fe87ee429ba37890af74021885", "input": "claim: The US intervention in Libya, lacking congressional approval, was illegal.\n perspective: The US had to interfere to protect their interests.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-70d24fbc101440c6b76f1a3942401000", "input": "claim: The US intervention in Libya, lacking congressional approval, was illegal.\n perspective: In order to maintain their interests, the US had to intervene.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-081ec03846bb4ca88125e85cc8a5e107", "input": "claim: The US intervention in Libya, lacking congressional approval, was illegal.\n perspective: US intervention is not consistent with other aspects of US law", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-72b25d61bb7f4ac0a0ba88244a173266", "input": "claim: The US intervention in Libya, lacking congressional approval, was illegal.\n perspective: An intervention contradicts US policy.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ae6f74b17c6140f5a179400bc8993afb", "input": "claim: The US intervention in Libya, lacking congressional approval, was illegal.\n perspective: A long ruling and ruthless dictator was toppled.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a766ea8f065c4f6f8c4c3af632387e35", "input": "claim: The US intervention in Libya, lacking congressional approval, was illegal.\n perspective: The tyrannical dictator was removed of his long reign.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-84667d230c974255ae838fbeb0e4e9af", "input": "claim: The US intervention in Libya, lacking congressional approval, was illegal.\n perspective: The regime has been overturned after its long and terrible reign.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ba53990899a24df7bdea558d8f85c20f", "input": "claim: The US intervention in Libya, lacking congressional approval, was illegal.\n perspective: The intervention backfired.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-63bd51e335ce4d718576d08f582ca231", "input": "claim: The US intervention in Libya, lacking congressional approval, was illegal.\n perspective: The intervention in Libya is a complete disaster.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-af98e870d73f4746a948659240fe8a59", "input": "claim: The US intervention in Libya, lacking congressional approval, was illegal.\n perspective: What intervention in Libya, are you sure?", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-38c1527c373c404789c0e48d22ac8e4a", "input": "claim: Introduce year round schooling.\n perspective: Damaging to extra-curricular activities. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-462114d807bc4d1fbd479a4f4189f305", "input": "claim: Introduce year round schooling.\n perspective: Year-round learning can help reduce the burden on parents.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-4dc8a4e55bba482e8d755f5490508b86", "input": "claim: Introduce year round schooling.\n perspective: Reduce “summer learning loss”. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-eed35b061e2e4bf3b8547c541a701478", "input": "claim: Introduce year round schooling.\n perspective: Places unfair burden on students. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-eaa4970557a44aab928118a6b438a330", "input": "claim: Introduce year round schooling.\n perspective: Imposes extra costs on education system.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ed7d23958595401abccdab77222297d1", "input": "claim: Introduce year round schooling.\n perspective: Reduce social problems from disaffected, bored youth. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f5f67db903ef4d3ba2bedd755258bbb5", "input": "claim: HIV/AIDS: There Should Be Compulsory Testing and Labeling of People with HIV.\n perspective: Labelling is against human rights", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-8cba9be3e12446829104a5e1c66ea9fd", "input": "claim: HIV/AIDS: There Should Be Compulsory Testing and Labeling of People with HIV.\n perspective: Labeling of people with HIV is against Human Rights", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-5bbd734db5a244beaec5a974a46e4a24", "input": "claim: HIV/AIDS: There Should Be Compulsory Testing and Labeling of People with HIV.\n perspective: Human Rights would be violated if people with HIV were labeled", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-7f072339a980480ea1e895b86edb0235", "input": "claim: HIV/AIDS: There Should Be Compulsory Testing and Labeling of People with HIV.\n perspective: labeling damage human rights", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-8a65ca30dbb04a5ebd686341e16dbf9a", "input": "claim: HIV/AIDS: There Should Be Compulsory Testing and Labeling of People with HIV.\n perspective: labeling of hiv demean a person's right", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-0e0d2b916c184b8d8a222d85a47dc082", "input": "claim: HIV/AIDS: There Should Be Compulsory Testing and Labeling of People with HIV.\n perspective: Tackling HIV requires a responsible and active position by everyone", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-5a1f71e3bfb0422996b196c0b4cf653d", "input": "claim: Global Warming is not an issue.\n perspective: People are losing their lives because of climate change.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-90e836ae6fd242dcb1605fd477c6f35a", "input": "claim: Global Warming is not an issue.\n perspective: The climate is changing and people are dying.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-bb1d8dbb70f9484ca8fd19cdd0b622be", "input": "claim: Global Warming is not an issue.\n perspective: Global temperatures have always been changing despite Co2 increases", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-9c8f37cb77b04fa0a202d6e4ef491b52", "input": "claim: Global Warming is not an issue.\n perspective: The 'Global warming' phenomenon could be caused by other things", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-08c55f2674334c8baf81bf2bf6aff253", "input": "claim: Global Warming is not an issue.\n perspective: This situation we are in with global warming may have other causes.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-9c63ae8c2a7e459c9c5b903289c40213", "input": "claim: Global Warming is not an issue.\n perspective: 7 Global warming is based on computer modelling and has had no empirical confirmation", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-434153412c414784beeae411971f25ef", "input": "claim: Global Warming is not an issue.\n perspective: There is no evidence that 7 Global warming is accurate as it is based on computer modelling.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-dce256f71d564e85821eef23a740ff81", "input": "claim: Global Warming is not an issue.\n perspective: Computer modelling showing 7 Global warming may not be accurate as there is no proof supporting it.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-1dcb6c2c6edd46e0b6315e1098163273", "input": "claim: Global Warming is not an issue.\n perspective: There is no scientifically valid mechanism for CO2 causing global warming.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-8a79bac8452249039baea0109c4f36b4", "input": "claim: The use of mobile phones has lowered active social life and has become an addiction.\n perspective: The use of a mobile phone requires a social life.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b8ba055736f64bb8a9303b7c0c82ed5a", "input": "claim: The use of mobile phones has lowered active social life and has become an addiction.\n perspective: Mobile phones make it easier to stay in contact with others.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-165096aa958449dfa8812b54bbc3d5f7", "input": "claim: The use of mobile phones has lowered active social life and has become an addiction.\n perspective: You have little reason to have a mobile phone if you do not have anyone to talk to on it.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-79b3e46d4cd34a0faa1592c45d57c4ac", "input": "claim: The use of mobile phones has lowered active social life and has become an addiction.\n perspective: Mobile phones enable us to keep in touch", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b602f20b5826472cae04b49e2d6ecc80", "input": "claim: The use of mobile phones has lowered active social life and has become an addiction.\n perspective: Cellphones are used to avoid emotional confrontation and real human contact", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a6f7acbab1be44a79bc2b521880d0b6c", "input": "claim: The use of mobile phones has lowered active social life and has become an addiction.\n perspective: Cellphones are used as an escape from the real world.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-1672dc3aae164f45abab3729b86ebb53", "input": "claim: The use of mobile phones has lowered active social life and has become an addiction.\n perspective: People are more comfortable using cellphones than they are interacting with each other.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-889139b154ba4d33b6bedda1890282f6", "input": "claim: The use of mobile phones has lowered active social life and has become an addiction.\n perspective: Mobile phones make sure that we are safe", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-9fd70716a5424ba9bd32d93b0bcf0604", "input": "claim: The use of mobile phones has lowered active social life and has become an addiction.\n perspective: Mobile phones lead to increased independence", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-05a9db3041074c2aaccc99f163af74f9", "input": "claim: Military action to intervene during atrocities without United Nations Security Council approval can be legal.\n perspective: Military action is only legal with UN Security Council approval", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-22966b62bbc24cf09a530b1fb315a713", "input": "claim: Military action to intervene during atrocities without United Nations Security Council approval can be legal.\n perspective: Disarming illegal weapons", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-3d6255cf135f4cfda408eb80246685e2", "input": "claim: Rain Man is such a bad image of autism.\n perspective: A bad stereotype of an autistic person.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-3a969460a87c41d49330ee0bf6718723", "input": "claim: Rain Man is such a bad image of autism.\n perspective: Rain Man does not portray all autistic people fairly", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-99d7a919f60642caafdd0590a3ed830e", "input": "claim: Rain Man is such a bad image of autism.\n perspective: Rain Man is a poor stereotype of Autism.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e64bbe2bbc1e4274814f69da8cd0e65c", "input": "claim: Rain Man is such a bad image of autism.\n perspective: Rain Man provides a bad example of stereotypes.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f42d47877f7043a69f89e6402d59da4f", "input": "claim: Rain Man is such a bad image of autism.\n perspective: Stereotypes about autistic people are highlighted in Rain Man.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-37d7de762ec948c8b2c0b87f73c12d19", "input": "claim: Rain Man is such a bad image of autism.\n perspective: At least people know what autism is now.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-0327064256ba47e0a8ece2b08318b406", "input": "claim: Rain Man is such a bad image of autism.\n perspective: Rain Man portrays a type of Autism, but it shouldn't stereotype all people who have Autism", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a55f2c8df8bd475eb2304823724247a3", "input": "claim: Rain Man is such a bad image of autism.\n perspective: Rain man is an example of Autism, it doesn't cover the all the types of Autism.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4a09e5b7535a494d9701980803847eeb", "input": "claim: Rain Man is such a bad image of autism.\n perspective: People are more aware about autism now.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-849ea881db7444edbc9df6c967cd2581", "input": "claim: Rain Man is such a bad image of autism.\n perspective: Because of this, people are now more aware about autism.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-7c6e2ed5e8da4218b14156d928a9196e", "input": "claim: Rain Man is such a bad image of autism.\n perspective: People think(sometimes wrongly) that ALL Autistic persons are geniuses", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-4ca756b3debc4fed8b2c177adb1ae526", "input": "claim: Rain Man is such a bad image of autism.\n perspective: People may think all Autistic people are geniuses after seeing Rain Man", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-55bfe0ec2fc4420b89b820e43469c914", "input": "claim: Rain Man is such a bad image of autism.\n perspective: Some Autistic people are geniuses.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-cfce5d073b13489ba69513fecca4e408", "input": "claim: Rain Man is such a bad image of autism.\n perspective: The stereotype that \"all autistic people are geniuses\" is now a common misbelief.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-5bd18a23cbee4320887097079db736f3", "input": "claim: Rain Man is such a bad image of autism.\n perspective: People now may be inclined to believe that all autistic people are geniuses.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-5c2fdb4f2a914b17bcd196048721b78e", "input": "claim: Rain Man is such a bad image of autism.\n perspective: Making autism 'popular' caused a rise in self-diagnosis", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ff76d46fa2044e00a0f4c131ff2fe0fd", "input": "claim: The European Union should lift its ban on member states selling arms to China.\n perspective: China is a threat to regional stability", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-fd8767912860495a97a71468ea078321", "input": "claim: The European Union should lift its ban on member states selling arms to China.\n perspective: China will simply get similar products elsewhere", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-9a66eeddf754450cb1170360aabc8aa1", "input": "claim: The European Union should lift its ban on member states selling arms to China.\n perspective: There is no reason to strengthen China militarily", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-9e1cbd51b9b64a57a23e4e595d744eea", "input": "claim: The European Union should lift its ban on member states selling arms to China.\n perspective: Lifting the ban will damage relations with the U.S.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-f316cf1b423d433e9482ae01309f7c25", "input": "claim: The Palestinian Statehood should be recognised by the United Nations General Assembly.\n perspective: Palestine is a legal entity and deserves to have its voice heard on an equal footing with Israel ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-44f7f849641a48b59c79852811eb1834", "input": "claim: The Palestinian Statehood should be recognised by the United Nations General Assembly.\n perspective: Palestine is a sovereign state and Israel should recognize that. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-4bd5bbca5e5e4253b3edd61d0ebed435", "input": "claim: The Palestinian Statehood should be recognised by the United Nations General Assembly.\n perspective: Israel and Palestine are two legal countries that should have their voice heard equally. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a78b2341aa324217a1af25d8cc18dadd", "input": "claim: The Palestinian Statehood should be recognised by the United Nations General Assembly.\n perspective: Palestine is a legal place and should be treated just like Israel", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-55998996efe74345bbf6d214fa3b0ad0", "input": "claim: The Palestinian Statehood should be recognised by the United Nations General Assembly.\n perspective: Because Palestine is a legal entity, they should have the same rights as Israel", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-871cf198cf4c4c49ad0346505530143a", "input": "claim: Store nuclear waste underground.\n perspective: Underground Nuclear Storage is Safe", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-6828cf83af17493ab9fd559e793cd24a", "input": "claim: Store nuclear waste underground.\n perspective: Underground Nuclear Storage is Expensive.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-5fd4fb126a904b8a804823a6a44dcbc5", "input": "claim: Store nuclear waste underground.\n perspective: Underground Nuclear Storage is Necessary", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-9552971a74bb4353b7a6f4cfbc6f3304", "input": "claim: Store nuclear waste underground.\n perspective: There Are Better Alternatives to Underground Nuclear Waste Storage", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-7c7b743fceab4b2ea44fbc868e42d309", "input": "claim: The United States should maintain its embargo against Cuba.\n perspective: The embargo enables the United States to apply pressure on the Cuban government to improve human rights. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-82d21b96b69e4ff39e8f2d2636b6f22f", "input": "claim: The United States should maintain its embargo against Cuba.\n perspective: The people of Cuba are the victims of the embargo, opposed the intended target of the government.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c0b709db69ed4c88a26d6b8a6f2c17c0", "input": "claim: The United States should maintain its embargo against Cuba.\n perspective: Cuban citizens are paying the price for their government's actions.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-61bd2f6259d74fd29c7ee0be851e1293", "input": "claim: The United States should maintain its embargo against Cuba.\n perspective: The casualties of the embargo are the civilians of Cuba, not the government as ideal.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a728e214ce664e51b2718432fe27d8ec", "input": "claim: The United States should maintain its embargo against Cuba.\n perspective: The embargo harms the people of Cuba, not the government as intended. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-80243833e4d248c2b7fb0a12a424e157", "input": "claim: The United States should maintain its embargo against Cuba.\n perspective: Sanctions harm the Cuban people. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-419aa2f992d14c529ae138b4647f3007", "input": "claim: The United States should maintain its embargo against Cuba.\n perspective: The United States should not have different trading and travel policies for Cuba than for other countries with governments or policies it opposes. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-426c0fb6a01742b89ddbad42406c9c34", "input": "claim: The United States should maintain its embargo against Cuba.\n perspective: Cubans can't join the digital era while under embargo due to lack of electronic access.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-af0a398111564d45a3f412a0afdedaba", "input": "claim: The United States should maintain its embargo against Cuba.\n perspective: The United States should maintain the Cuba embargo because Cuba has not met the conditions required to lift it. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-9b37bb8d89034801a6b3366da8d774aa", "input": "claim: The United States should maintain its embargo against Cuba.\n perspective: Ending the embargo before the Cuban government meets the conditions specified by US law would make the United States look weak. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d810b6c2e675494b9c526b82aea6dd86", "input": "claim: The United States should maintain its embargo against Cuba.\n perspective: The embargo is a relic of Cold War Era thinking and is unnecessary because Cuba does not pose a threat to the United States. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c0cfa1a0bd834316a6740da6900e964d", "input": "claim: The United States should maintain its embargo against Cuba.\n perspective: The Cuba embargo is a product of Cold War Era mentality thus obsolete for Cuba is not a threat to the US.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-8f27a7eaede94f88aa1135a4c5d8f9f6", "input": "claim: The United States should maintain its embargo against Cuba.\n perspective: Cuba should be subject to sanctions because it is known to have repeatedly supported acts of terrorism. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-9a49d2474afa474b8225fa9e16d480a4", "input": "claim: The United States should maintain its embargo against Cuba.\n perspective: Cuba is knows to sponsor terrorism so sanctions are appropriate.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-8235f5d6d2764a0fb9f3dc7a2bade019", "input": "claim: The United States should maintain its embargo against Cuba.\n perspective: Because Cuba supports terrorism, it should have sanctions levvied against it.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-b279dfd0fb7341ebb616ee230b761ea9", "input": "claim: The United States should maintain its embargo against Cuba.\n perspective: The United States is able to target the Cuban government with its embargo while still providing assistance to Cuban citizens. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-86ec3bca5ed04de0b1c89c47a0480e52", "input": "claim: The United States should maintain its embargo against Cuba.\n perspective: The embargo should be maintained because open travel is insufficient to promote change in Cuba; many democratic countries already allow travel to Cuba with no results. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-6ccd020a4c1e4005bb3423e0cc883552", "input": "claim: The United States should maintain its embargo against Cuba.\n perspective: The embargo must be upheld as others have allowed open travel with no results.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a48e04e6cd3441d5adcc20db55b6e790", "input": "claim: The United States should maintain its embargo against Cuba.\n perspective: Open travel to Cuba has not yielded change so the embargo should continue.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-0d111a7090d94a0d8d1fb19db5db741d", "input": "claim: The United States should maintain its embargo against Cuba.\n perspective: Lifting the embargo would put pressure on Cuba to address problems that it had previously blamed on US sanctions. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-d04b266b92cc4921a2239d7dc1657813", "input": "claim: The United States should maintain its embargo against Cuba.\n perspective: Sanctions are not working", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-6cfb1995bd8b411e88381de1f4511cab", "input": "claim: The United States should maintain its embargo against Cuba.\n perspective: The Cuban government is unaffected by the sanctions.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-52d3a47c8cad4d5ebefb1fd700212d1d", "input": "claim: The United States should maintain its embargo against Cuba.\n perspective: Where the people and not the government shoulder the burden, sanctions don't work.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ba5fc8196d2542b190f49cbb18d178d8", "input": "claim: The United States should maintain its embargo against Cuba.\n perspective: The United States should end the Cuba embargo because its 50-year policy has failed to achieve its goals. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-0a1fc2fa5d9f4ce1ae6b182c3d08f9fb", "input": "claim: The United States should maintain its embargo against Cuba.\n perspective: After 50 years the Cuba embargo has shown no results so the US should end it.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ec9ffafa19e547fda2d1e9a34bdfc683", "input": "claim: The United States should maintain its embargo against Cuba.\n perspective: The Cuba embargo has failed to achieve its goal after 50 years so the US should end it.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-26765917aad04e988cac4cc9b6cb93b7", "input": "claim: The United States should maintain its embargo against Cuba.\n perspective: Most of the world opposes the embargo, and maintaining it is detrimental to the reputation of the United States among the international community. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-2f1ea87fa7ad465f978dccd0a8beda45", "input": "claim: The United States should maintain its embargo against Cuba.\n perspective: Maintaining a widely-reviled embargo damages the US's diplomatic reputation.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-9e541c5080974ff59e966afbb53858b4", "input": "claim: The United States should maintain its embargo against Cuba.\n perspective: The global community opposes the embargo, and maintaining it hurts the US diplomatically.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-35ebe77c4e494529a571ef2085efef43", "input": "claim: The United States should maintain its embargo against Cuba.\n perspective: The Cuban government has consistently responded to US attempts to soften the embargo with acts of aggression, raising concerns about what would happen if the sanctions were fully lifted. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-822a00d509da45c1a1b92b8058a41dd7", "input": "claim: The United States should maintain its embargo against Cuba.\n perspective: Free trade, not the isolation of an embargo, can promote democracy in Cuba. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-fcdf481f6bf54bf2ba9a9d07c355fa34", "input": "claim: The United States should maintain its embargo against Cuba.\n perspective: Free trade in lieu of embargo can promote Cuban democracy.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4382be7be18b4b6ab1ec767f1d34f115", "input": "claim: The United States should maintain its embargo against Cuba.\n perspective: Instead of embargo, free trade will promote democracy in Cuba.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c2050b80a0454499bf8108cbe78259ea", "input": "claim: The United States should maintain its embargo against Cuba.\n perspective: The uncertainty over who will succeed Raúl Castro makes it unwise for the United States to change its policy before a new leader is in place. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-df6a2249195140af8930cff5f0e80477", "input": "claim: The United States should maintain its embargo against Cuba.\n perspective: There is no definitive replacement for Raul Castro, which makes it unwise for the US to implement new policies at this time.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-3de8e06389564254b2fb23014e0588fb", "input": "claim: The United States should maintain its embargo against Cuba.\n perspective: Until the US knows who will replace Raul Castro, it does not make sense to put new policies in place.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-b0be142f56484bdf9adaf3fbca93bc9b", "input": "claim: The United States should maintain its embargo against Cuba.\n perspective: Cuba has not demonstrated a willingness to negotiate in good faith with the United States. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-8ff52b6786c944cd9b60a34b604a379f", "input": "claim: The United States should maintain its embargo against Cuba.\n perspective: Cuba seems unwilling to negotiate with the US.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-7c19e70ffdaa4c3a84a9f53b6a6aa910", "input": "claim: The United States should maintain its embargo against Cuba.\n perspective: Cuba seems reluctant to genuinely engage with the US.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-526d4efada0641dd94b11e4fb8f1cd33", "input": "claim: The United States should maintain its embargo against Cuba.\n perspective: Sanctions are necessary for national security", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-908b076859df495abdbe24fbb173881c", "input": "claim: The United States should maintain its embargo against Cuba.\n perspective: The national well-being is best served by the continuation of economic sanctions against Cuba", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c49595aa613b4db5a0b2d09dd0e6b0ab", "input": "claim: The United States should maintain its embargo against Cuba.\n perspective: Cuba deserves sanctions", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-9d75b79c703446259802e37f7f2229c9", "input": "claim: The United States should maintain its embargo against Cuba.\n perspective: Economic punishment is what Cuba should be subject to", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-6395ba0f210a4f5490fffa5e5167ce18", "input": "claim: The United States should maintain its embargo against Cuba.\n perspective: The actions of the Cuban government have merited the Cuban government economic penalty", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f57f4d75384e444899bd2b531534d8c5", "input": "claim: The United States should maintain its embargo against Cuba.\n perspective: Economic benefits of ending sanctions", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e241f6142cc54d1ba825e4789cc5756e", "input": "claim: The United States should maintain its embargo against Cuba.\n perspective: If sanctions were lifted trade benefits would flow to all parties to trade.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e1df478326fa462f96c11addcb6acafa", "input": "claim: Christianity is the greatest deception of today.\n perspective: Christianity may be a deception but it's not the \"greatest\" one", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-3cbe83886bac47d89ceefebe44bed870", "input": "claim: Christianity is the greatest deception of today.\n perspective: There are greater deceptions than Christianity.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-4150a978acfb450381f80af3dd8aae12", "input": "claim: Christianity is the greatest deception of today.\n perspective: There are a great many of deceptions in the world today that are bigger than Christianity.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a8154dbfd50148efa72eb174d79047c9", "input": "claim: Christianity is the greatest deception of today.\n perspective: It isn't christianity that's the deception, organised religion is!", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-89b44803abb74e32821c49a712a1b5bf", "input": "claim: Christianity is the greatest deception of today.\n perspective: Christianity is not a deception!", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-2370861431c84c72ad639862c60a41e0", "input": "claim: Christianity is the greatest deception of today.\n perspective: Christianity is not a lie!", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-05768b0093314ec4a999878aac3a689e", "input": "claim: Christianity is the greatest deception of today.\n perspective: Christianity is not dishonest!", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-998812878b204995b90d4d12cb893c91", "input": "claim: The Reproductive Health Bill will undermine families and values.\n perspective: Poor families would be helped far more by investment in education and healthcare", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-23a4974b07db48b28920cc6aa26af84a", "input": "claim: Democracy Is the Best Form of Government.\n perspective: Better governance due to transparency", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-0cbd8ad02f4f4bfeb91f78c5907e7a73", "input": "claim: Democracy Is the Best Form of Government.\n perspective: Respect of Human Rights", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a4c28c9df9bd43709ced333c332f8994", "input": "claim: Democracy Is the Best Form of Government.\n perspective: Respect for the rights of other humans.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-06d8f7f06d8b44e0b18d01a28b3e1d31", "input": "claim: Democracy Is the Best Form of Government.\n perspective: Respect for the rights of people.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-6544d72d53b945dd906fd7ee9c1d2c80", "input": "claim: Democracy Is the Best Form of Government.\n perspective: Electorate is not motivated", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-0e1774f719144d838d124a55c6d14d4f", "input": "claim: Democracy Is the Best Form of Government.\n perspective: Peace can only be achieved only through a well functioning democracy", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-5a8d513e974a48098c5afad6184dc189", "input": "claim: People should have the right to die.\n perspective: Suicide is a rational choice in many situations.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-cb14f9ec50304ca59ca2df5d021568c7", "input": "claim: People should have the right to die.\n perspective: Medical science allows us to control death, suicide and euthanasia are sensible corollaries to that.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-6c1279d906d249d2ade478bf0118d0e6", "input": "claim: People should have the right to die.\n perspective: The death of one individual has implications for others, which by definition, do not affect the suicide herself.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e4358fb3e926487c8a1deca09b53b9e2", "input": "claim: People should have the right to die.\n perspective: The decision to die is a deeply personal one - it is no business of the state.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-901cda4823d440a5a01a6a526629b280", "input": "claim: The EU should impose a special Europe-wide tax on meat consumption to help save the planet.\n perspective: Livestock production threatens the world’s water supply", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e0ced02881774565a839207e13e9c2e3", "input": "claim: The EU should impose a special Europe-wide tax on meat consumption to help save the planet.\n perspective: Excessive meat production threatens the world’s biodiversity", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-00d97191732a427cb2fa9dc226d5973e", "input": "claim: The EU should impose a special Europe-wide tax on meat consumption to help save the planet.\n perspective: A special EU wide tax on meat consumption would reduce the threat to the planet", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-153c7a1654e54d5eae4453236c86b407", "input": "claim: The EU should impose a special Europe-wide tax on meat consumption to help save the planet.\n perspective: The UN disagrees.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-34d02dbadbc247a087255f625167cf6f", "input": "claim: The EU should impose a special Europe-wide tax on meat consumption to help save the planet.\n perspective: The UN does not think a meat consumption tax is worth it.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-789f1be3037d401bacad30534a29577a", "input": "claim: The EU should impose a special Europe-wide tax on meat consumption to help save the planet.\n perspective: The UN is in disagreement with the EU and does not want to see a Europe-wide tax on meat consumption as a plant-saving measure.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-fde9fc74822245379f1ce30599c362c6", "input": "claim: The EU should impose a special Europe-wide tax on meat consumption to help save the planet.\n perspective: The United Nations does not agree with the EU and does not feel that a meat consumption tax would have the effects desired.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-95863e289a5146d681c7a89d5bca431c", "input": "claim: Religious freedom abroad should be one of the primary foreign policy concerns for any country.\n perspective: Promoting religious freedom exacerbates conflict", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-af25db7a44994656b6d5c4d0565fc11c", "input": "claim: Religious freedom abroad should be one of the primary foreign policy concerns for any country.\n perspective: Restrictions on religious freedom creates conflict", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-01b9719af9994741be699305d3597ad5", "input": "claim: Religious freedom abroad should be one of the primary foreign policy concerns for any country.\n perspective: Religious pluralism creates a more tolerant and peaceful society", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f22e7d5e77ce499da4ca28a0e9b28e2b", "input": "claim: Religious freedom abroad should be one of the primary foreign policy concerns for any country.\n perspective: Religious pluralism enables a more blended and inclusive society.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-597e151855b24633b20e3ad669c53d03", "input": "claim: Religious freedom abroad should be one of the primary foreign policy concerns for any country.\n perspective: Concentrating on religious freedom is too narrow, instead human rights in general should be considered", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-de5d9176d89e4f7a8d3250034e28fd79", "input": "claim: The money we spend on our Olympic medal count is money well spent.\n perspective: The money is not going towards a good cause", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-7a7139628b04408c834494af0a31df29", "input": "claim: The money we spend on our Olympic medal count is money well spent.\n perspective: The Olympics gives athletes a goal and young people a chance to believe in themselves", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-68940f7c35cc4eea8ce67beae7e0b3a6", "input": "claim: The money we spend on our Olympic medal count is money well spent.\n perspective: The bidding process is too long, tying up funds and land", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-1fe3ca0461b741b2a2af2f6b063eb662", "input": "claim: The money we spend on our Olympic medal count is money well spent.\n perspective: bidding takes a long time", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-8eb948cc384140e3ad9ccb0987e01609", "input": "claim: The money we spend on our Olympic medal count is money well spent.\n perspective: the bidding process is long", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c59d9cca175e46b8898efb2b26dd4145", "input": "claim: The money we spend on our Olympic medal count is money well spent.\n perspective: Hosting has wide-reaching economic benefits", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-29751c8f37744367a2d308101cfc5d88", "input": "claim: The money we spend on our Olympic medal count is money well spent.\n perspective: The large investment needed to host the olympics will have outstanding economic rewards.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ff09764b44584df19ed8731d665e367a", "input": "claim: The money we spend on our Olympic medal count is money well spent.\n perspective: The economy will benefit largely from the amount of people they hosting the olympics will bring.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a708be137a8741ccbc356e58037ae06f", "input": "claim: The money we spend on our Olympic medal count is money well spent.\n perspective: Hosting is good for economy", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f68ffb7add53492ba20e1532e15bf5db", "input": "claim: The money we spend on our Olympic medal count is money well spent.\n perspective: Any large expenditure in one area will stimulate regeneration. Considering that the cost of hosting the London 2012 Olympics is predicted at £2.375 billion, expected to rise far higher, regeneration is the least that can be expected as a le", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-779d636dbdc84d5880a44f67d2e2e14d", "input": "claim: The money we spend on our Olympic medal count is money well spent.\n perspective: the london olympics are expensive ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-6087847117b248c788916ea67f280a7c", "input": "claim: The money we spend on our Olympic medal count is money well spent.\n perspective: the Olympics in London are expensive", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-3967cc5ada534f8ea119b32f3e270814", "input": "claim: The money we spend on our Olympic medal count is money well spent.\n perspective: Hosting only affects one city", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4a0b08e5e2e143e08f8b40aaeffaf01c", "input": "claim: The money we spend on our Olympic medal count is money well spent.\n perspective: Hosting is very expensive", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-7ae5b1d461774831beb42d31c8777d89", "input": "claim: The money we spend on our Olympic medal count is money well spent.\n perspective: Even though hosting the olympics is very expensive it is worth the effort.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-bd025516384648f4ade41b9218115005", "input": "claim: The money we spend on our Olympic medal count is money well spent.\n perspective: Hosting costs a lot", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-06d45aca6e4b48d4b9e7c2c00d7c91cb", "input": "claim: The money we spend on our Olympic medal count is money well spent.\n perspective: Hosting stimulates regeneration in local areas", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-be71e744acb44a6ba657ea67b226f08f", "input": "claim: The money we spend on our Olympic medal count is money well spent.\n perspective: Hosting the Olympics will bring revenue to surrounding areas as people flock to the games.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-8b88011ffe734d6cb2dfe96585f966b5", "input": "claim: The money we spend on our Olympic medal count is money well spent.\n perspective: Hosting the Olympics may require an investment of resources but the localities will reap the rewards.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-1183c00f01e942efa719e5057e7c029a", "input": "claim: The money we spend on our Olympic medal count is money well spent.\n perspective: If a nation hosts the Olympics, it will give new life to the local economy.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-6fe955830718428c8e0604bbeb80e3c2", "input": "claim: The money we spend on our Olympic medal count is money well spent.\n perspective: Hosting the Olympics has a positive impact on local areas.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ef4c80b267924f1cb342e057fcfdbd82", "input": "claim: Force think tanks to reveal all of their sources of funding.\n perspective: People have a right to know where their information comes from", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-06732324934a43deab00355d2f70da17", "input": "claim: Force think tanks to reveal all of their sources of funding.\n perspective: People should know where information came from. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c90e63a6866d4d06b3e68552026db6a9", "input": "claim: Force think tanks to reveal all of their sources of funding.\n perspective: Legally requiring disclosure from all benefits think tanks", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-55421740f73949e29b738069953f1e77", "input": "claim: Force think tanks to reveal all of their sources of funding.\n perspective: Disclosure should be require initially by law. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-725b3c3a68214a0bb4c5b4efced96f22", "input": "claim: Force think tanks to reveal all of their sources of funding.\n perspective: By law disclosure should be discussed at the start.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-08adaba5e47949e0a38f44d0d0a06c5d", "input": "claim: Force think tanks to reveal all of their sources of funding.\n perspective: Overregulating think tanks sets a dangerous precedent", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c63395a7fd0a4c768f3c434683cb3fba", "input": "claim: Force think tanks to reveal all of their sources of funding.\n perspective: A dangerous precedent is set when you regulate think tanks.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-075f2d6ed6ea474993bab615dc98f882", "input": "claim: Force think tanks to reveal all of their sources of funding.\n perspective: Private investors have a right to privacy", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-09e34d08c0214c1f998a26e5bacd96e2", "input": "claim: Force think tanks to reveal all of their sources of funding.\n perspective: Privacy is a right to private investors.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-9671c78fade24cac9b1b0b351616183d", "input": "claim: Force think tanks to reveal all of their sources of funding.\n perspective: The right to privacy includes private investors.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a902bf6511a3482e864a80ab6f57cea1", "input": "claim: Force think tanks to reveal all of their sources of funding.\n perspective: Think tanks should be able to choose not to know who funds them", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b12c4e74df964eb4aaef6e478cd7ebbb", "input": "claim: Force think tanks to reveal all of their sources of funding.\n perspective: Think tanks do not need to know where their funding is from.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-09ddd8d5035444559c57e665aa732836", "input": "claim: Force think tanks to reveal all of their sources of funding.\n perspective: It is not neccesary for think tanks to know who funds them.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-87cfab68e3624fe39aac7bd084feefc3", "input": "claim: Force think tanks to reveal all of their sources of funding.\n perspective: Think tanks may become smoke screens for criminal groups", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-6c99aefd7a8b4dc9bdff776c1ae7ff68", "input": "claim: Force think tanks to reveal all of their sources of funding.\n perspective: Crime groups use think tanks to confuse people.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c15fd8de243e43eaab7cf01c87491bf7", "input": "claim: Force think tanks to reveal all of their sources of funding.\n perspective: Think tanks should be assessed by the value of their ideas, not by who funds them", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a4a707e6dfbe41dca1346d63ad444acb", "input": "claim: Force think tanks to reveal all of their sources of funding.\n perspective: Who funds a think tank is unimportant to the value of their ideas.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-5d60a6acab4147a6badd39ff2f90f1a7", "input": "claim: Fines should be made relative to income.\n perspective: Creates the perception that the rich are not immune to the consequences of their actions", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ac0ea99cae954b8188b5a1e2faa3b560", "input": "claim: Fines should be made relative to income.\n perspective: The rich are now also deterred", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-505a82f04c664e419fc0b72be193cba6", "input": "claim: Fines should be made relative to income.\n perspective: Creates the perception that fines are like taxes, rather than a punishment", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-0022dbd918124e318861c887468ce0c9", "input": "claim: Fines should be made relative to income.\n perspective: A flat rate is more just", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-1ae7254d50314b468f09a4fcf5d4d005", "input": "claim: Fines should be made relative to income.\n perspective: It is unfair to penalize a higher income with a larger fine.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a618a3ad9d27400fadf4806a05a29099", "input": "claim: Fines should be made relative to income.\n perspective: Fines should be according to crime, not income.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-fd263aaee10546acb25e428d260ae93f", "input": "claim: University education needs to be capped and more selective.\n perspective: We need more universities as the population is growing!", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-d57aa7c5f348475da37b0f4a1d388b85", "input": "claim: University education needs to be capped and more selective.\n perspective: Selective education leads to an unfair bias towards the rich and the middle classes", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-64ac8e1e010a4965a553be476c155c6b", "input": "claim: University education needs to be capped and more selective.\n perspective: Wide university education produces a literate, multi-skilled and widely knowledgeable nation", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-9363d1bbe10d4f398d67825b70a344af", "input": "claim: University education needs to be capped and more selective.\n perspective: Many don't 'use' their degree after graduating, yet still end up in huge debt", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-72d68ff3816644be9c0e9c29e8948a5c", "input": "claim: University education needs to be capped and more selective.\n perspective: Many don’t ‘use’ their degree after graduating, yet still end up in huge debt", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a794397f11ca4ea5a48696ef26033066", "input": "claim: University education needs to be capped and more selective.\n perspective: With so many new universities and colleges, employers can't tell the difference between the good and bad.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-9c56b89a3fa0430a937e2503096df203", "input": "claim: University education needs to be capped and more selective.\n perspective: A university degree has far less worth than it once did", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f1dd26d0c9ef4d199c4785dc4103b719", "input": "claim: The iPhone is better than the Blackberry.\n perspective: iPhone is great tech.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-22da9238bcf04bf8b2da3e671b775774", "input": "claim: The iPhone is better than the Blackberry.\n perspective: The IPhone has more features", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-0e152cde38154531817c9bdcd85cdcce", "input": "claim: The iPhone is better than the Blackberry.\n perspective: Apple has a winner with iPhone, much better features than the Blackberry.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e8759a6c9773459fa1037ca972cde47d", "input": "claim: The iPhone is better than the Blackberry.\n perspective: Blackberries are best for teens and up ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a556293945cb495c88f46a5828464140", "input": "claim: The UN should impose sanctions on countries that destroy their rainforests.\n perspective: Sanctions give rise to a whole new set of problems", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ced89d6b1b7046c791f5c8b2c1ae891b", "input": "claim: The UN should impose sanctions on countries that destroy their rainforests.\n perspective: Sanctions only cause more problems.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a8745917b6bc40218d82d76213eeebc8", "input": "claim: The UN should impose sanctions on countries that destroy their rainforests.\n perspective: The implementation of sanctions cause unforeseen problems.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-380e6f45c82644e593013c14587888a5", "input": "claim: The UN should impose sanctions on countries that destroy their rainforests.\n perspective: Sanctions are the most effective response to an urgent crisis.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-2f8fc843d1784c368f624014ebd35bcc", "input": "claim: The UN should impose sanctions on countries that destroy their rainforests.\n perspective: Urgent crisises are best responded to with sanctions.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ff548b3fff2445b58d2a89b8d1566983", "input": "claim: The UN should impose sanctions on countries that destroy their rainforests.\n perspective: Sanctions are the fastest and most effective measures when a crisis is urgent.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-441e15488d1b46b1b1c43bdbfb512832", "input": "claim: The UN should impose sanctions on countries that destroy their rainforests.\n perspective: [Response to rebuttal] Sanctions are the most effective response to an urgent crisis.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f85a7d44a82640c0b32956e9d812369a", "input": "claim: The UN should impose sanctions on countries that destroy their rainforests.\n perspective: The most effective response to a true crisis is the implementation of sanctions.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ea6ae06030d9473fba5f31930d942eb4", "input": "claim: The UN should impose sanctions on countries that destroy their rainforests.\n perspective: Sanctions are the most effective manner in which to respond to a real crisis.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-41950350d156441ab102de6e1b21a5f3", "input": "claim: Poverty is the most important security issue facing Africa.\n perspective: Poverty creates a vicious circle", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-be173dff774143fa8e9c67b88cde8659", "input": "claim: Poverty is the most important security issue facing Africa.\n perspective: people in poverty usually never get out", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-79045347deb149c49f345c7a270e3d85", "input": "claim: Poverty is the most important security issue facing Africa.\n perspective: Poor states have trouble providing security", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-2aa9e54f565c4fa68bcac0e94b373b65", "input": "claim: Poverty is the most important security issue facing Africa.\n perspective: a state in financial trouble can not provide proper security", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a5d21c5b1dfe480baf62d81427fff158", "input": "claim: Poverty is the most important security issue facing Africa.\n perspective: a state needs to be secure to provide its people with sercurity", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-cff247a24498458980fdfd2ff2950544", "input": "claim: Blasphemy has no place on the statute books.\n perspective: If the courts did not handle these issues, the mob likely would.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-3c630fc8af6f4400bc375d4219fb7b03", "input": "claim: Blasphemy has no place on the statute books.\n perspective: Citizens will take matters into their own hands. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-10c6975712844c728013d6758ef8aa0f", "input": "claim: Blasphemy has no place on the statute books.\n perspective: If the courts did not handle the issues, then the mob would", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-651669d1e38c4990a08a290cc3448d6b", "input": "claim: Blasphemy has no place on the statute books.\n perspective: If the courts did not do it, then the mob would", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-20b3333fb1d04fba9cc0db839baa353e", "input": "claim: Blasphemy has no place on the statute books.\n perspective: People have a right to blaspheme", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-1c7fb3c752ba4107acd6337579fd5b0e", "input": "claim: Blasphemy has no place on the statute books.\n perspective: Blasphemy causes offence to groups and individuals", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-6729c75cb6014aa9a6b144f18c597c66", "input": "claim: Discipline In Schools Needs To Be Improved.\n perspective: the majority of people respond to discipline", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-b6806512414c4a6683463c456177df36", "input": "claim: The United States is a ‘benign’ hegemon.\n perspective: The US is not a hegemon at all, but an imperialist power-an empire. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c6d7f735d575472b969e4eefb349aeeb", "input": "claim: The United States is a ‘benign’ hegemon.\n perspective: The United States is a de facto empire.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-bf994fdb19834ebebcb872b323ab4602", "input": "claim: The United States is a ‘benign’ hegemon.\n perspective: In reality, the United States is an empire, not a hegemon.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-3de92a6838b74f308cf54493cecb3d2d", "input": "claim: The United States is a ‘benign’ hegemon.\n perspective: The US is less of a hegemon and more of an imperial empire", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-9b7a51fb84694138a1802ea5fa171c04", "input": "claim: The United States is a ‘benign’ hegemon.\n perspective: The US is more like an imperial power and less like a hegemon", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-1fc4c6db1ba9428688ffdbd2d6f15155", "input": "claim: Build a third Heathrow runway to maintain its position as a hub airport.\n perspective: The economic case for expansion does not add up", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-fa76c2d556ee48fb998a45197ea05769", "input": "claim: Build a third Heathrow runway to maintain its position as a hub airport.\n perspective: The economic case for expansion is not good", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-8625a30616dc41d6ba281137cf7213cf", "input": "claim: Build a third Heathrow runway to maintain its position as a hub airport.\n perspective: The case for economic expansion is not sound", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-3134edc6b99946658d3eba569a05fcbc", "input": "claim: Build a third Heathrow runway to maintain its position as a hub airport.\n perspective: The economic argument made for expansion is not a compelling one.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-0045e7157629416e8a257cb0298b8edd", "input": "claim: Build a third Heathrow runway to maintain its position as a hub airport.\n perspective: The economic reasons given for expansion are hardly persuasive.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-0dc721911ae64e8f81ee6e89220f7e38", "input": "claim: Build a third Heathrow runway to maintain its position as a hub airport.\n perspective: The third run-way would cause noise and pollution problems", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ea0b8f5eac6442808ddb3c5057372d04", "input": "claim: Build a third Heathrow runway to maintain its position as a hub airport.\n perspective: The third run way would cause issues", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-f72e3e6751a946c9aa0bdb05330c21c4", "input": "claim: Build a third Heathrow runway to maintain its position as a hub airport.\n perspective: The third run way would not be good", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-3f38e6472d0b4606b19d320ba4adb53e", "input": "claim: Build a third Heathrow runway to maintain its position as a hub airport.\n perspective: Any runway beyond the existing two would give rise to problems, including noise and pollution.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-5970b9443a4344d3b11c0f7e17eafb98", "input": "claim: Build a third Heathrow runway to maintain its position as a hub airport.\n perspective: An additional runway would inevitably lead to pollution and noise issues. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-35d3807f840f4d9f8aade6a972d7bea2", "input": "claim: Eritrea is responsible for its isolation.\n perspective: Eritrea is surrounded by hostile nations ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4702296202a84146a7d93e04dbe8126e", "input": "claim: The UN intervention in the Democratic Republic of Congo has been a success.\n perspective: Peace may finally be at hand", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-4dc016faa073473c94f3bd815dea27ba", "input": "claim: The UN intervention in the Democratic Republic of Congo has been a success.\n perspective: The violence may have finally stopped bringing peace to the Democratic Republic of Congo.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-9d971db1a57f4fad8e8cd94de08dbd16", "input": "claim: The UN intervention in the Democratic Republic of Congo has been a success.\n perspective: UN intervention may have finally stopped the conflict. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-5bae2a3545e7448cbb674657206387c3", "input": "claim: The UN intervention in the Democratic Republic of Congo has been a success.\n perspective: Peace may be near", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-86dec2d97a64400d999316a9ce562132", "input": "claim: The UN intervention in the Democratic Republic of Congo has been a success.\n perspective: Allegations of misconduct by peacekeepers", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-46334c1dc0a84dcaa4212e9da8988fae", "input": "claim: The UN intervention in the Democratic Republic of Congo has been a success.\n perspective: Even though the UN has reported success in the Democratic Republic of Congo, there have been disturbing allegations of misconduct by peacekeepers in the area.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-8973bc4b295847648840e9cc0140177d", "input": "claim: The UN intervention in the Democratic Republic of Congo has been a success.\n perspective: Allegations of misconduct has darkened the reports of success by the UN.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ff411785cab94667b2154180a36d5176", "input": "claim: The UN intervention in the Democratic Republic of Congo has been a success.\n perspective: Resources still flow out of the country", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-fc2d4758de2e4330a3f189e2388ef26d", "input": "claim: The UN intervention in the Democratic Republic of Congo has been a success.\n perspective: Even though it has seen some success, the UN hasn't stopped the rush of resources leaving the country.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e2e6817271a7427db8c7ada7ff03f34d", "input": "claim: The UN intervention in the Democratic Republic of Congo has been a success.\n perspective: resources still flow out", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b4fe0ac1cd2546ecb3023ee0b16ca72f", "input": "claim: The UN intervention in the Democratic Republic of Congo has been a success.\n perspective: resources flow out still", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-6c35e12b825e48118417f72a9e3514e2", "input": "claim: The UN intervention in the Democratic Republic of Congo has been a success.\n perspective: The government is not in control", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-d5cef688044b41b8a310fb41bf0d3df6", "input": "claim: The voting age should be lowered to 16.\n perspective: YES, give them the rights they deserve!", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c2557eb20ab24608b893f67a06865f77", "input": "claim: The voting age should be lowered to 16.\n perspective: Sixteen years would be a better option in developed countries", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-bd47a53bfc9f433fb19120d92cb41b44", "input": "claim: The voting age should be lowered to 16.\n perspective: I think they should have these rights.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-b9b1de04109745dfb868e2bdf7910308", "input": "claim: The voting age should be lowered to 16.\n perspective: I would say give them the rights that they should have.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ef6b89594ce3438db6d859a07e6652cc", "input": "claim: The voting age should be lowered to 16.\n perspective: Parents are guardians and should be trusted to vote in their children’s interests", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-def8034da92545f8a2ecde7424cdff43", "input": "claim: The voting age should be lowered to 16.\n perspective: Minor's interests can be appropriately taken into consideration by the votes of their parents.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-3fdf5cd8b25b4a858bba1e2ac8af8943", "input": "claim: The voting age should be lowered to 16.\n perspective: A parent's vote should be counted as a vote in the interest of their child.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-3f591bbe945240c1a37bf551eec37bac", "input": "claim: The voting age should be lowered to 16.\n perspective: Voting at a lower age would increase participation", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-bb2ae3e66b9e421eb7ff52de9d1a2a90", "input": "claim: The voting age should be lowered to 16.\n perspective: More citizens would participate if the voting age were lowered.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f59f8e665cf44195bffa25bfc7a3f7fc", "input": "claim: The voting age should be lowered to 16.\n perspective: A lower voting age would result in an increase in participation.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-89089d9d10be41bc99e89847f3029094", "input": "claim: The voting age should be lowered to 16.\n perspective: Young people would be more likely to misuse their vote", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-5726dd4b2814434b9da2ac54938434a0", "input": "claim: The voting age should be lowered to 16.\n perspective: Younger people are more likely to not take the impact of their vote seriously.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-49b280959ec2468997372e536e1d2508", "input": "claim: The voting age should be lowered to 16.\n perspective: Allowing young people to vote would be likely to result in inappropriate votes.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-5e7142186ae64bf69906b9c2545b6ddb", "input": "claim: The voting age should be lowered to 16.\n perspective: 16 year olds are mature enough to vote", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a2cfac4a7d194056b79da49a4b90bbbb", "input": "claim: The voting age should be lowered to 16.\n perspective: 16 year olds are informed enough to cast a vote.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f92d75c256904962b9448448d756bea7", "input": "claim: The voting age should be lowered to 16.\n perspective: It is appropriate for 16 year olds to have the right to vote.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ce8e0944c5e04b95aefa5ea648a2d807", "input": "claim: The voting age should be lowered to 16.\n perspective: At sixteen there is a lack of maturity that is necessary to vote responsibly.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-2ac59790fbd6475884c9266061838779", "input": "claim: The voting age should be lowered to 16.\n perspective: 16 year olds don't have a high enough level of maturity to vote.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-5d345b4a28b94f829339fc54d70e9d0c", "input": "claim: The voting age should be lowered to 16.\n perspective: 16 years old is too much of an immature age to vote.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e16a4eb1995d419d8d578d30340fa216", "input": "claim: The voting age should be lowered to 16.\n perspective: children at 16 have no sense of decesion making", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-729b2afb2350473d8d276150368be0ba", "input": "claim: The voting age should be lowered to 16.\n perspective: No. too immature.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-65593526a6a440c9bd6d1192d1e08331", "input": "claim: The voting age should be lowered to 16.\n perspective: Sixteen is too young to make decisions.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-9a3dcf5abef94e9e8fd5caadc633e431", "input": "claim: The voting age should be lowered to 16.\n perspective: At sixteen the brain is not developed enough to make decisions.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-6750050b3250402d987782f59a2c7f91", "input": "claim: The voting age should be lowered to 16.\n perspective: 16 year olds are not responsible enough to vote. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-56f3cba40544487b9fa66f5403539876", "input": "claim: The voting age should be lowered to 16.\n perspective: 16 year olds are not wise enough to vote at elections.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ee7c79cf9ad74799a5f8e04b537d789a", "input": "claim: The voting age should be lowered to 16.\n perspective: Sixteen year olds are too immature to judge the validity of political arguments.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-8942d52ce6054a8695abb6ea69023104", "input": "claim: Reheat tea in the microwave.\n perspective: Reheating is 5 times better for the environment", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-b7a417801dc14835a8cb58faedcf9735", "input": "claim: Reheat tea in the microwave.\n perspective: Reusing, reheating tea using the stove is environmentally unsound.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f63862fb944e47c8850701060d74d4c4", "input": "claim: The sale of children’s toys as part of fast food meals must be prohobited.\n perspective: The ban is ineffective in addressing the problem of obesity. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-7c815732275244678a8c2aa9a373540a", "input": "claim: The sale of children’s toys as part of fast food meals must be prohobited.\n perspective: Banning toys in fast food meals will not create healthier food choices.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-3b753f9688934b129e817e469203f9aa", "input": "claim: The sale of children’s toys as part of fast food meals must be prohobited.\n perspective: Such bans are easy to side step. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-87acabbb17104c16a2e4aa3399c237e7", "input": "claim: The sale of children’s toys as part of fast food meals must be prohobited.\n perspective: There are alternative methods of distributing the toys.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-5817c39e347f44e483ede72e39413f80", "input": "claim: The sale of children’s toys as part of fast food meals must be prohobited.\n perspective: A variant means to sell the toys separately can be used as an incentive for future food discounts.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-fe49cea7bf4149c9b63ae83b1d0620cd", "input": "claim: The sale of children’s toys as part of fast food meals must be prohobited.\n perspective: Bad nutrition habits start during childhood. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ae157cfda3af452ba55ca9a99f407b59", "input": "claim: The sale of children’s toys as part of fast food meals must be prohobited.\n perspective: Marketing aimed at children should be subject to strict regulations.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-8076920c85da4a8f8b39a4ce22898538", "input": "claim: The sale of children’s toys as part of fast food meals must be prohobited.\n perspective: Advertising should not be allowed to seduce vulnerable children who do not understand what they want.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c978a8e50e5d4c3ba371a7642cd02a7a", "input": "claim: The sale of children’s toys as part of fast food meals must be prohobited.\n perspective: Governemnt needs more power over fast food advertising to force children to make the correct choices about their food.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a1ac12a5df8a4ab787d6bdd401237caf", "input": "claim: The sale of children’s toys as part of fast food meals must be prohobited.\n perspective: Its a business, a business doing its job", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-0eb2c3e1a24745a990a9cdfd6875e74b", "input": "claim: The sale of children’s toys as part of fast food meals must be prohobited.\n perspective: Advertising is a part of a good business plan. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-fffee9e231cd4b09bd4385212c4d1847", "input": "claim: The sale of children’s toys as part of fast food meals must be prohobited.\n perspective: A good business needs to look to promote its mission. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-1de79948431a459e8873e8cdad81d3ae", "input": "claim: Teachers should get merit pay.\n perspective: A good motivater to improve teaching and test standards.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d6d8c0d9eb0347e7a6fc2340fb7517d0", "input": "claim: During riots it might make sense to block access to social messaging networks.\n perspective: Social networks serve as a powerful signalling device for the expansion of violent behaviour", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-71ed1f8b11384f44ae6ad5308fcbb3dc", "input": "claim: During riots it might make sense to block access to social messaging networks.\n perspective: It is better to monitor riots through the social media rioters are using", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4cc9148236c64aec972bdb5e3c22636c", "input": "claim: During riots it might make sense to block access to social messaging networks.\n perspective: Non violent methods of disrupting riots must be tried before using force", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-08a949356a6445e7a07d9f07ad1e3f3e", "input": "claim: During riots it might make sense to block access to social messaging networks.\n perspective: Would stop riots from spreading", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-59dfbf97368441c089791972f047fddb", "input": "claim: Parents should introduce children to alcohol (in moderation) at an early age.\n perspective: Positive association with alcohol", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-4056da79f5e44de6a12a50089a437f9a", "input": "claim: Parents should introduce children to alcohol (in moderation) at an early age.\n perspective: Young adults drinking could cause more problems in the future", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-35c6f591182c4fcbb2180b259605b418", "input": "claim: Parents should introduce children to alcohol (in moderation) at an early age.\n perspective: Allowing 18- to 20-year-olds to drink alcohol in regulated environments with supervision would decrease unsafe drinking activity.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-5d8ad2215bdc4afba4a4ee9152d714bd", "input": "claim: Parents should introduce children to alcohol (in moderation) at an early age.\n perspective: Lowering the age will cut down on young adults drinking", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-985d3e4f780b4f1cbfc94f81ec37080d", "input": "claim: Parents should introduce children to alcohol (in moderation) at an early age.\n perspective: Lowering the age to drink will make it less interesting since everyone can do it.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ad64d25451384c379af740114cdc9c15", "input": "claim: Parents should introduce children to alcohol (in moderation) at an early age.\n perspective: Use reverse psychology on kids to remove the appeal of drinking. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-96eec8aa94094732accb17ffbe3e88d4", "input": "claim: The full financial history of all candidates for political office must be posted online.\n perspective: The focus of elections should be on policy, not personal issues like financial records", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-1b664c209a0d40389cac209fc1989db2", "input": "claim: The full financial history of all candidates for political office must be posted online.\n perspective: Financial records are personal, not political, issues.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ad58857439c54649b2285eae289764e7", "input": "claim: The full financial history of all candidates for political office must be posted online.\n perspective: Political candidates should focus on policy and not be subjected to scrutinization of their financial records.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-f119bbab2dcd43fbad6dbf4eea4b635f", "input": "claim: The full financial history of all candidates for political office must be posted online.\n perspective: Individuals have a right to privacy, including to their own financial records", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-2e25f98365364eea8d5265eee97cba51", "input": "claim: The full financial history of all candidates for political office must be posted online.\n perspective: Forcing candidates to post their full financial history violates their privacy.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-849738c22c8e4a8e8f0809cf96b7ed4c", "input": "claim: The full financial history of all candidates for political office must be posted online.\n perspective: Political candidates' rights would be violated if they were forced to post their financial records online.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-762955e0905d4c7eab54f3c08f908b3f", "input": "claim: The full financial history of all candidates for political office must be posted online.\n perspective: Financial dealings can indicate candidates’ willingness to circumvent the system/play by the rules", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-8ccb7cfcedba4a91b2b2cc8a1729caad", "input": "claim: The full financial history of all candidates for political office must be posted online.\n perspective: By releasing financial info, a candidate shows his honesty", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-6473caccf86242b3b1d272c312e11381", "input": "claim: The full financial history of all candidates for political office must be posted online.\n perspective: By releasing financial info, a candidate shows his openess and willingness to comply", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-7276193046f54fdd9fed11f945000282", "input": "claim: The full financial history of all candidates for political office must be posted online.\n perspective: Candidates' willingness to circumvent the system/play by the rules can be indicated by financial dealings.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-41333ef78a834051a9f67e8a71d60959", "input": "claim: The full financial history of all candidates for political office must be posted online.\n perspective: Financial dealings can tell a candidates' willingness to circumvent the system/play by the rules.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-5cd13b6f3a3e4c9b8fa7034afbf8dce4", "input": "claim: The full financial history of all candidates for political office must be posted online.\n perspective: Voters have a right to know the background of their would-be representatives, including financial background", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-dc025da075be448eb91da6a0d5fc5602", "input": "claim: The full financial history of all candidates for political office must be posted online.\n perspective: Every one running for office must show their tax returns", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-bfbccca460324694a5a5f698fa8b4515", "input": "claim: The full financial history of all candidates for political office must be posted online.\n perspective: Running for office should make your life an open book", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-3a7e88cf69154c569d121b0319b5bed2", "input": "claim: The full financial history of all candidates for political office must be posted online.\n perspective: Voters deserve to know the background including financial background of their would-be representatives.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-799515e1d045426595704b2c2888b99c", "input": "claim: The full financial history of all candidates for political office must be posted online.\n perspective: The would-be representatives should disclose their complete background including financial background to the voters who have a right to know.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-380a9b6656484106beb19e65048d00f1", "input": "claim: The full financial history of all candidates for political office must be posted online.\n perspective: Fixating on candidates’ financial records fuels the fire of class war", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-09b4f3e28e6b4d1895ec826e6a22eb84", "input": "claim: The full financial history of all candidates for political office must be posted online.\n perspective: Too much focus on candidates' finances only leads to class wars. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-6afc18effda34835904b2d138a32d59b", "input": "claim: The full financial history of all candidates for political office must be posted online.\n perspective: Candidates posting their full financial history online would only intensify class wars.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-0642c03df63040b789d8d660b1fce84c", "input": "claim: The full financial history of all candidates for political office must be posted online.\n perspective: This information offers valuable texture to the financial proposals candidates offer as potential policy", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-307cce3ec2134f28abd0dae165d2a84f", "input": "claim: The full financial history of all candidates for political office must be posted online.\n perspective: Candidates' full financial history allows voters to consider the financial proposals candidates may offer as potential policy.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-794716e6a798473880204d57ba79d02e", "input": "claim: The full financial history of all candidates for political office must be posted online.\n perspective: Political candidates' full financial history offers valuable texture with regard to potential financial policies candidates may offer.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d1c47100561641b8ab1c7f692c234eea", "input": "claim: The American Jobs Act should pass.\n perspective: The American Job Acts came in handy for the people that are unemployed for a long time,", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-305217b7a8c74c3ab9c02fcfd350a70e", "input": "claim: The American Jobs Act should pass.\n perspective: The American Jobs Act Will Not Help Successful Businesses", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-d44304c64b984d289d7410cdbd1d6a38", "input": "claim: The American Jobs Act should pass.\n perspective: The Jobs Act Redresses the Balance Between the Wealthy and the Middle Class", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-08bf8a3e7b9948ccab6e3b02cd93c9c6", "input": "claim: The American Jobs Act should pass.\n perspective: The Jobs Act balances between having money and having no money.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d6e5495dfb4b47b6b2ac23d1b6b1d579", "input": "claim: The American Jobs Act should pass.\n perspective: The American Jobs Act Helps Small Business and Creates Jobs", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-087a12da8fac4767b31bbf4ae473d5d4", "input": "claim: The American Jobs Act should pass.\n perspective: The American Jobs Act is good for the economy", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-9bd1bd64c4344fb0aa3feaa3ae4f7cc2", "input": "claim: The American Jobs Act should pass.\n perspective: Creation of job is central the the American Jobs Act", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-bc86eb353ff340c691171f339c278d56", "input": "claim: The American Jobs Act should pass.\n perspective: The American Jobs Act is Not Deficit Neutral", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-1f6a2d2fd49141c6910d3296b618492b", "input": "claim: Pre-nuptial agreements should not be recognised in divorce courts.\n perspective: Pre-nuptial agreements conditions differ from future reality", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-bd22187ff55d409486092f095214dac3", "input": "claim: Pre-nuptial agreements should not be recognised in divorce courts.\n perspective: The State imposed system is not objectively right for everybody", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f72b2ef312cd47d2bfca1ff978b1bdd5", "input": "claim: Pre-nuptial agreements should not be recognised in divorce courts.\n perspective: Prenuptial agreements should not be recognized in divorce courts", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f16bd9f4dcde4dfdb8a5285a5e5877af", "input": "claim: Pre-nuptial agreements should not be recognised in divorce courts.\n perspective: Pre-nuptial agreements reduce trauma associated with divorce", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-2bc65e693de141b38706e012a1f20d42", "input": "claim: Pre-nuptial agreements should not be recognised in divorce courts.\n perspective: Pre-nuptial agreements increase security", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-fa7891543ea14f46a36b9d05c7b429b4", "input": "claim: Pre-nuptial agreements should not be recognised in divorce courts.\n perspective: Liberty to decide what you want is good and because pre-nuptial agreements can be considered rational decisions", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-783ce5ff35fc4563a8a06f6a737d86aa", "input": "claim: Pre-nuptial agreements should not be recognised in divorce courts.\n perspective: Pre-nuptial agreements constitutes a serious chance of abuse", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-063e368524e143428ae865e5108965b2", "input": "claim: Pre-nuptial agreements should not be recognised in divorce courts.\n perspective: Prenuptial agreements are either too lovely or not as lovely as they appear", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-8760884de02946d1b35cc5ce5191b490", "input": "claim: Hacking Can Be Justified.\n perspective: Hacks to improve a product.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-165e13ee73c64e76ae5a784a227a3268", "input": "claim: Hacking Can Be Justified.\n perspective: Stealing and invading privacy is fundamentally wrong.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-376fc3aa6de74344a736a1dd4bb85cec", "input": "claim: Hacking Can Be Justified.\n perspective: Hacks as artistic expression.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-72ce64a64b2144b0ab099c5ed16a611d", "input": "claim: Hacking Can Be Justified.\n perspective: Hacks always negatively affect someone.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-1a973d5783724b4d9ad5921d8d4c314c", "input": "claim: Hacking Can Be Justified.\n perspective: Hacks as political statements.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d575ca462e7446ceaf4235ed85d35042", "input": "claim: Hacking Can Be Justified.\n perspective: 5. Hacks to uncover or expose criminal activity, corruption or corporate malpractice", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-11b29b54ab1e4cb4b3fdb1e4ef6dd314", "input": "claim: Downloading music without permission is morally equivalent to theft.\n perspective: A legal transaction is the only way to achieve free exchange of value", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-48239daee0944ae78a28f73ad9c1bee1", "input": "claim: Downloading music without permission is morally equivalent to theft.\n perspective: Downloaders spend more on music", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-1d2ace1762fa41afa3fee07e077b8c12", "input": "claim: Downloading music without permission is morally equivalent to theft.\n perspective: It is well know that people that download also purchase the most.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b3cb7ef8b883440eabd4cda683e6f405", "input": "claim: Downloading music without permission is morally equivalent to theft.\n perspective: Downloads are also big spenders.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-84f96167c71d4320a9398925a9c4c638", "input": "claim: Violent Video Games Contribute to Youth Violence.\n perspective: Research has shown violent video games encourage criminal and anti-social behaviour", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-483fb3a9d9874f299cf092c517f90a48", "input": "claim: Violent Video Games Contribute to Youth Violence.\n perspective: people immitate video games.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-3fbef272ab624359afb57ae08b936f92", "input": "claim: Violent Video Games Contribute to Youth Violence.\n perspective: violent games make people agressive.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-6ccd9ae2e9fa46b8bb626a969aa10091", "input": "claim: Violent Video Games Contribute to Youth Violence.\n perspective: Playing violent video games leads to violent behaviors.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-0bd2bde32eab4a479813b9c3fe55e72e", "input": "claim: Violent Video Games Contribute to Youth Violence.\n perspective: Playing violent video games causes more aggression, bullying, and fighting.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-30f8d9b6ca9d4b10a4a8923b2a6fae0d", "input": "claim: Violent Video Games Contribute to Youth Violence.\n perspective: Simulating violence such as shooting guns and hand-to-hand combat in video games can cause real-life violent behavior.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-37caa44a820a4ccdafedc9fd594dd4d4", "input": "claim: Violent Video Games Contribute to Youth Violence.\n perspective: The American Psychological Association (APA) lists violent video games as a risk factor for aggressive behavior.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c4a27b14682f4859b646eb8029b32c1c", "input": "claim: Violent Video Games Contribute to Youth Violence.\n perspective: Violent Video Games cause Violent Behaviour", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-6dd6bf877d87421b91de639cc08c42d9", "input": "claim: Violent Video Games Contribute to Youth Violence.\n perspective: real life violent behaviors may be stimulated by video games", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-6da93c29f39248d380aa0d57142055d5", "input": "claim: Violent Video Games Contribute to Youth Violence.\n perspective: Violent video games are seen as a risk factor for aggressive behavior, according to the American Psychological Association (APA)", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-44e9ccd1dbbb4a6ca1988153b99e744e", "input": "claim: Violent Video Games Contribute to Youth Violence.\n perspective: Gun violence is less prevalent in countries with high video game use.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a61c23c39c8545a98e45e59a5b22b7df", "input": "claim: Violent Video Games Contribute to Youth Violence.\n perspective: Countries with high video game use see less gun violence", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ffbe89b58f9a43bbb8e2311ab7398863", "input": "claim: Violent Video Games Contribute to Youth Violence.\n perspective: Studies have shown that violent video games can have a positive effect on kindness, civic engagement, and \"prosocial” behaviors.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e6cd07c0de4643858c64d40753ed8777", "input": "claim: Violent Video Games Contribute to Youth Violence.\n perspective: Violent video games have been shown to have positive effect on kindness and cooperative behavior.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c0e6a9b0e27b486587d4d490ea80db34", "input": "claim: Violent Video Games Contribute to Youth Violence.\n perspective: Violent video game players know the difference between virtual violence in the context of a game and appropriate behavior in the real world.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-18ec9fb1df044377b067484dd4c1e8f6", "input": "claim: Violent Video Games Contribute to Youth Violence.\n perspective: There are many flaws to the theory that violent video games cause real life violence.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ecdb05f0c8cc4be9a32c692dcf6b7724", "input": "claim: Violent Video Games Contribute to Youth Violence.\n perspective: Studies claiming a causal link between video game violence and real life violence are flawed.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e00589a33f6b41ff95d6d6cbd2845cf5", "input": "claim: Violent Video Games Contribute to Youth Violence.\n perspective: Playing violent video games does not cause kids to commit mass shootings.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-892838d9f7e44c25a9899496541b1092", "input": "claim: Violent Video Games Contribute to Youth Violence.\n perspective: The Responsibility Lies With Parents", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-7c2ad97967b6480d86d7392135ab222c", "input": "claim: Violent Video Games Contribute to Youth Violence.\n perspective: Violent Video Games Cause Social Interaction Problems", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-efb355d1d51d4454991a2ca217085bd8", "input": "claim: Violent Video Games Contribute to Youth Violence.\n perspective: Violent video games lead to inappropriate social interactions.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-b9798c6173dd43e0bb3b996eaea05c37", "input": "claim: Violent Video Games Contribute to Youth Violence.\n perspective: Violent video games are detrimental to social interaction.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-08c0f23c9df54a5599cf07b5fbe24225", "input": "claim: Violent Video Games Contribute to Youth Violence.\n perspective: Violent video games desensitise users", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-664de9453cda40d6a554afc00c5e5fb6", "input": "claim: Violent Video Games Contribute to Youth Violence.\n perspective: Violent games normalizes forms of violence.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-236a40001aaa496d99147cdb186fb4e4", "input": "claim: Violent Video Games Contribute to Youth Violence.\n perspective: Restrictions would be ineffective", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-56433d87e3d74901ae38c3bf515ded37", "input": "claim: Violent Video Games Contribute to Youth Violence.\n perspective: Restricting video games only makes people more interested in them. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-97f1f60f13564506a5f36d40767155ff", "input": "claim: Violent Video Games Contribute to Youth Violence.\n perspective: Restricting violent video games will have no correlation to a reduction in societal crime.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a4f26ecbe0a74a4698fcc4748754e4a7", "input": "claim: Violent Video Games Contribute to Youth Violence.\n perspective: The government has a right to restrict the sale of violent video games, in order to protect law and order.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-9ad27e67ca2c43e589022daa6769d4c1", "input": "claim: Violent Video Games Contribute to Youth Violence.\n perspective: In order to maintan a well funcitoning society, the government has a right to restrict violent games which could hurt people.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-43ca91fcc6d840e4ad81c366ff82b63c", "input": "claim: Violent Video Games Contribute to Youth Violence.\n perspective: Video games are content that has a right to be censored for the mass majority's public safety.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-80a8c587e4d444a799470ff16ec833d3", "input": "claim: Governments Should Actively Promote Multiculturalism.\n perspective: Multiculturalism is antithetical to liberal democracy‏.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b78f63fba04446f18edd5ccbdeef1e18", "input": "claim: Governments Should Actively Promote Multiculturalism.\n perspective: Multiculturalism means that everyone is the same, and then nobody is happy. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-bf199715e7074f24bbc9626d69f1d048", "input": "claim: Governments Should Actively Promote Multiculturalism.\n perspective: Multiculturalism promotes more tolerant societies ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ecfb951c13d04b529d3e1cf498dc7fae", "input": "claim: Governments Should Actively Promote Multiculturalism.\n perspective: Those countries that embrace and exchange cultures usually have healthier democracies.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-b4ba9d42ca1f4be88c4b96c585026460", "input": "claim: Governments Should Actively Promote Multiculturalism.\n perspective: Multiculturalism is morally justified ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-5f300b43522a4f1da734d4e5a18020e0", "input": "claim: Governments Should Actively Promote Multiculturalism.\n perspective: Multiculturalism promotes healthier new generations", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-2f744bd41ba447aea5100cc364ae8846", "input": "claim: Governments Should Actively Promote Multiculturalism.\n perspective: Multiculturalism doesn't create diverse societies; it creates politically correct societies.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-db763ae0593546909d006a63e5c53947", "input": "claim: Governments Should Actively Promote Multiculturalism.\n perspective: Politically correct societies remain so until someone decides that homogeneity is not a good thing and then trouble begins.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-9ab58d85058544e6ba030abee4b9ef48", "input": "claim: Governments Should Actively Promote Multiculturalism.\n perspective: Multiculturalism greatly facilitates advancement and progress by advancing cultural exchange in both products and ideas.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-2c9f1094874342e1b7894a25ef2b3eda", "input": "claim: Governments Should Actively Promote Multiculturalism.\n perspective: Understanding diversity and all the different cultures around the world is the key to world peace.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-2af6acd59c46454ab6dc84684c85f326", "input": "claim: Governments Should Actively Promote Multiculturalism.\n perspective: True progress comes when people take the time to understand other cultures - other people's beliefs and customs.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-43351229d8f04dfa9b82d69300df63cc", "input": "claim: The United States should keep daylight saving time.\n perspective: Daylight Saving Time (DST) Is Bad for Your Health.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b552e9d70adb4145810b799acd72d349", "input": "claim: The United States should keep daylight saving time.\n perspective: Should DLS continue dispite of the health risks", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-365e56efda8747d698a3e267a97e2059", "input": "claim: The United States should keep daylight saving time.\n perspective: Healthy risks associated with DLS", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-170b225c58254c49a7cfa05603e64eb9", "input": "claim: The United States should keep daylight saving time.\n perspective: DST brings with it additional risks for the population's health", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-09afa9367aea4108ba66afb983ab53f1", "input": "claim: The United States should keep daylight saving time.\n perspective: Negative health consequences can be a potential negative with the arrival of Daylight Savings Time.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-7aa436d61efc4379a4f6ea5245972439", "input": "claim: The United States should keep daylight saving time.\n perspective: Daylight Saving Time's (DST) Longer Daylight Hours Promote Safety", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d9eb39f9d8db4441834c06c23e009244", "input": "claim: The United States should keep daylight saving time.\n perspective: Daylight savings allows for more light hours in the day", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-aa4046ba4cd443fc93b9d0ba8391f4da", "input": "claim: The United States should keep daylight saving time.\n perspective: Daylight savings promotes safety with the extra hours of daylight", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-2babd023558e457683b8087a58365330", "input": "claim: The United States should keep daylight saving time.\n perspective: One of the residual advantages of DST is enhancement of a safe environment.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-2095ebbb9e7b4613b930a8a895046540", "input": "claim: The United States should keep daylight saving time.\n perspective: Longer periods of daylight hours assist in a calmer, safer community.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-6cf315e67aba4b01acbfde19b98868c9", "input": "claim: The United States should keep daylight saving time.\n perspective: DST Is Expensive. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-0ff8059b30bf4c04b5821c6cabca3419", "input": "claim: The United States should keep daylight saving time.\n perspective: Daylight savings time is expensive in us", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-d1931f767af7458ba25d5f44076fb169", "input": "claim: The United States should keep daylight saving time.\n perspective: Is daylight savings time worth the extra expense", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-fc47b537f49445279bb9347f8bcfddea", "input": "claim: The United States should keep daylight saving time.\n perspective: Daylight Savings Time bringing with it some undesirable cost components.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-248672db871a4c20991a050a332cbdf1", "input": "claim: The United States should keep daylight saving time.\n perspective: The additional economic constraints of DST are usually not examined.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-df1616b1d7da4140b8f2d8c82a1d93d7", "input": "claim: We should believe in corporal punishment for adult offenders.\n perspective: Social problems can be solved without resorting to physical punishments.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-32e88331878f4be58be00ac30e7ed87e", "input": "claim: We should believe in corporal punishment for adult offenders.\n perspective: States' duty to avoid the use of force when solving social problems", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b53b584ab3d9413fb8db4126e423badd", "input": "claim: We should believe in corporal punishment for adult offenders.\n perspective: It is the duty of the state to avoid using corporal punishment when they need to solve social problems.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-88af4f18ce1741b39bdcd94a8470285f", "input": "claim: We should believe in corporal punishment for adult offenders.\n perspective: Corporal punishment isn't a good idea when solving social problems.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-9b636e2ba3254fd38d908e5cc2d50358", "input": "claim: We should believe in corporal punishment for adult offenders.\n perspective: States’ duty to avoid the use of force when solving social problems", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-966618d9e9bb424894b34b43b413b414", "input": "claim: We should believe in corporal punishment for adult offenders.\n perspective: Flogging will be over-utilised, rehabilitation will be under-utilised ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-8435575c30c34d43ac118ede78f5ea07", "input": "claim: Religions Should Not Qualify as Charities.\n perspective: Normal Charities Are More Focused on Their Mission", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-3545b5e0d3a64116a03c2ce0495ea762", "input": "claim: Smoking should be banned in public places.\n perspective: smoking should be banned in public places", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e9cfb36b65c84eed92d7822ca8c808dd", "input": "claim: Smoking should be banned in public places.\n perspective: people have the right to smoke ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-2328e0578e794a2ea3b1beba24fbc1ac", "input": "claim: Smoking should be banned in public places.\n perspective: You should be able to smoke in public.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b95a627f2e054cf49940538707ba76d7", "input": "claim: Smoking should be banned in public places.\n perspective: Smoking is a personal choice, and should not be restricted.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-df5f9269a60d4c309f92f205d5912674", "input": "claim: Smoking should be banned in public places.\n perspective: The decision to smoke is a human right.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-278c48056f3c4d9d8c0ee594456da913", "input": "claim: Smoking should be banned in public places.\n perspective: Smoking is a human right.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e3a2070b24a049e7b8b25d3b5973cc9c", "input": "claim: Smoking should be banned in public places.\n perspective: WHAT HAPPEN TO A FREE CANADA. WE ARE GOING BACK TO THE TIME WERE SLAVES HAD NO RIGHT, NOW IT IS SMOKERS HAVE NO RIGHT", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-371b8d17e63d4cc99e57a17e971ee80f", "input": "claim: Smoking should be banned in public places.\n perspective: Taking away a smoker's rights to smoke in public is akin to the time of slavery!", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-7134ddac65944b64adcf239e88bb37b6", "input": "claim: Smoking should be banned in public places.\n perspective: How can this be a free Canada, if our right to smoke in public is taken away?", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c63173e3555e446d8f52323f5b3fb57d", "input": "claim: Smoking should be banned in public places.\n perspective: Canada is a free country, so we should be free to be able to smoke.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4d78e4bef5e742aeaf61707422e337bf", "input": "claim: Smoking should be banned in public places.\n perspective: Being free to smoke is a basic right that someone in a free country should have.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b2b3c25d4f804415a79bdbe7badd5785", "input": "claim: Smoking should be banned in public places.\n perspective: No - it should not be banned in places people CHOOSE to go ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-2a82544cc2ec4e0290ba18b2ee7e57e9", "input": "claim: Smoking should be banned in public places.\n perspective: A smoker should be allowed to smoke in any place that they have a choice to go to.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-192d59a019034accb29fdcb28b67d0ae", "input": "claim: Smoking should be banned in public places.\n perspective: If I choose to go somewhere, I should be allowed to smoke there.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-827f00392c5545acad53a882a2b60e46", "input": "claim: Smoking should be banned in public places.\n perspective: Since people are choosing whether to go to places, smoking shouldn't be banned there,", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-2965e5c6fed044a1a05dedcd6b6b5d8c", "input": "claim: Smoking should be banned in public places.\n perspective: Smoking shouldn't be banned in places where people choose to be.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c3c0020409924ab48512305b378597dd", "input": "claim: Smoking should be banned in public places.\n perspective: Banning smoking isn't necessary.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-fc4f9805dc27450195b9857d01ac6543", "input": "claim: Smoking should be banned in public places.\n perspective: smoking don't necessarily have to be banned", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-9d59fccc40c94bd2916f60d334caeda9", "input": "claim: Smoking should be banned in public places.\n perspective: It isn't necessary to ban smoking.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-36fdcf8b55784b629f9a3b91f4996d1b", "input": "claim: Smoking should be banned in public places.\n perspective: It's not necessary to ban smoking.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-5300574c2a00401eacd1c04591d6655a", "input": "claim: Smoking should be banned in public places.\n perspective: Banning smoking is not something that's necessary.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-52b0a86447f843f2a5054ce0c597f71a", "input": "claim: Smoking should be banned in public places.\n perspective: Banning smoking in public places is not right.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e462a82a6bf646d2bd4e42d93f269e14", "input": "claim: Smoking should be banned in public places.\n perspective: It is not right to ban smoking.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-dc9b2881082640338edabec71faec493", "input": "claim: Smoking should be banned in public places.\n perspective: Banning smoking is a bad idea.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a558874766274400ae3316a89aa66359", "input": "claim: Smoking should be banned in public places.\n perspective: It's a bad idea to ban smoking.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-3a735e2a9a014f1db93effa227e87782", "input": "claim: Smoking should be banned in public places.\n perspective: Smoking shouldnt be banned", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-0f4eb4d9fbf343fd9fad809017e84752", "input": "claim: Smoking should be banned in public places.\n perspective: Pack labelling or taxation a better alternative", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-5c6ad6212ec94e27aed6508c8d9928f2", "input": "claim: Smoking should be banned in public places.\n perspective: Ban would harm the wider economy", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ccb5c3a3c0d7493997c1299d55cffe81", "input": "claim: Smoking should be banned in public places.\n perspective: A smoking ban in public places is harmful to the economy", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-87ab89c0aeaf47b88857eabc6a294144", "input": "claim: Smoking should be banned in public places.\n perspective: Economic hardship would follow a public place smoking ban", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e8ee2dc712244132b8a846765815f1d7", "input": "claim: Smoking should be banned in public places.\n perspective: Lower healthcare costs", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-5214b0e1fdb140bdb5d0bf1b869446c4", "input": "claim: Smoking should be banned in public places.\n perspective: Unenforceable", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-09234867c5024865ba6e27c87e1f9983", "input": "claim: We should abolish speed cameras.\n perspective: Speed cameras are a dangerous distraction to motorists", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d42780c3af5f418d9d6e257432894bc7", "input": "claim: We should abolish speed cameras.\n perspective: Speed cameras take motorists by surprise and distract them.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-4c1513c485af4959a2d33e57597c054f", "input": "claim: We should abolish speed cameras.\n perspective: Speed cameras distract mororists and are therefore dangerous.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c2ecb462dd474ab0bcf39709a44c6af0", "input": "claim: We should abolish speed cameras.\n perspective: Speed cameras encourage responsibility for our actions ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-0f43c0f61a9e464db245a99c43699769", "input": "claim: We should abolish speed cameras.\n perspective: Caught on film you can't deny responsibility for your actions.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-af08392c11824d018572001e04553d57", "input": "claim: We should abolish speed cameras.\n perspective: Traffic cams can't be avoided and neither can you avoid responsibility for driving actions.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-f24dbcc56e8a4cfc8430a5b368d3a5d1", "input": "claim: We should abolish speed cameras.\n perspective: Abolishing speed cameras makes drivers feel less responsible.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-d42882ffbb8d4814a51c5c9f9b4950ea", "input": "claim: We should abolish speed cameras.\n perspective: Speed cameras were meant to encourage good driving.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-02763f4ddae347e5addffb2d51159ecb", "input": "claim: We should abolish speed cameras.\n perspective: Driving behaviour has not changed since cameras were introduced", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a69ead8d18de49b5ba952d5915896762", "input": "claim: We should abolish speed cameras.\n perspective: Traffic cams have not altered driver behaviors.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-5af188fad8704d74895e68f95593d498", "input": "claim: We should abolish speed cameras.\n perspective: Traffic cams have failed in their mission to alter drivers' behaviors.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-10d14d7852d84cceac5609d9b5cd6bb7", "input": "claim: We should abolish speed cameras.\n perspective: Better car and medical technology has saved lives, not cameras", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-25a75a76988b4cb691e6a10daff7a326", "input": "claim: We should abolish speed cameras.\n perspective: Cameras don't save lives, better car and medical technology do,", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-79de5e203ca64b4a9bb5cb5fc599c166", "input": "claim: We should abolish speed cameras.\n perspective: Improved car and medical technology save lives, cameras do not", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d49c2e13219b4f44a30307915bc11da6", "input": "claim: We should abolish speed cameras.\n perspective: Cameras are money making, not life saving", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-8cb66530587b448aa60ce762c18868c9", "input": "claim: We should abolish speed cameras.\n perspective: Traffic cams are just automated speed traps.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-efdf47205c3444789f652e3da055dafb", "input": "claim: We should abolish speed cameras.\n perspective: Speed cameras were meant for monetary gains, not to improve driving.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-b03e6e7a0f6948a49179262fee226863", "input": "claim: We should abolish speed cameras.\n perspective: Cameras increased fatalities creating a “fatality gap” as decades of declining fatalities flattened out", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-11578aa1554b40899a2752bf9f1490a5", "input": "claim: We should abolish speed cameras.\n perspective: Speed cameras only detect 5% of all road accidents", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c065ba7f53f64d61b1ef6ab027497eba", "input": "claim: We must bring back corporal punishment.\n perspective: Social problems can be solved without resorting to physical punishments.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-1437b394d42b4fa4bacf7e8e2fe6caa7", "input": "claim: We must bring back corporal punishment.\n perspective: States' duty to avoid the use of force when solving social problems", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-2648d9f6682544aeb4e8a2bf494600ea", "input": "claim: We must bring back corporal punishment.\n perspective: It is the duty of the state to avoid using corporal punishment when they need to solve social problems.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e4811783a5754f5bb05985731130eed5", "input": "claim: We must bring back corporal punishment.\n perspective: Corporal punishment isn't a good idea when solving social problems.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a5ea4061d89b49b8bdc22f7168af4b99", "input": "claim: We must bring back corporal punishment.\n perspective: States’ duty to avoid the use of force when solving social problems", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-02209ebaf823405d880b3ce662ed2b0b", "input": "claim: We must bring back corporal punishment.\n perspective: Flogging will be over-utilised, rehabilitation will be under-utilised ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c704c1db07214a22b12927ad6e7de1e4", "input": "claim: The US should immediately close Guantanamo Bay.\n perspective: Guantanamo Bay’s Lack of Transparency Counters American Interests.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-2c336a16353a4b4da7d21ee808e7b338", "input": "claim: The US should immediately close Guantanamo Bay.\n perspective: American interests are counted by Guantanamo Bay's lack of transparency.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-7ddc1a9994c94bbdad5480f3c657c2c5", "input": "claim: The US should immediately close Guantanamo Bay.\n perspective: The interests of America are undone by the lack of transparency of Guantanamo Bay.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c4352068b2c84edeb278e8820b4ccd88", "input": "claim: The US should immediately close Guantanamo Bay.\n perspective: Gauntanamo Bay is detrimental to foreign relations for United States.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a86cdd1d0e74422992ff76c579e68120", "input": "claim: The US should immediately close Guantanamo Bay.\n perspective: Guantanamo Bay Violates Fundamental Human Rights.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-b1c098a2231d4a6591f81a42cfdee392", "input": "claim: The US should immediately close Guantanamo Bay.\n perspective: Human Rights are violated by the continued use of Guantanamo Bay.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-36bf3384098e4200a7cf4b3425e2d8af", "input": "claim: The US should immediately close Guantanamo Bay.\n perspective: The Guantanamo Bay facility is detrimental to Human Rights.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-6262d972428b4dc4be73301d0d52899d", "input": "claim: The US should immediately close Guantanamo Bay.\n perspective: Guantanamo Bay is a Symbol of Muslim Discrimination that Fuels Terrorist Sentiments", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-3d63d54ef90149b9b007b2c3d44067da", "input": "claim: The US should immediately close Guantanamo Bay.\n perspective: Terrorist sentiments are fueled by the symbol of Muslim discrimination that is Guantanamo Bay.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a94b359128aa43e78509acac6e33150d", "input": "claim: The US should immediately close Guantanamo Bay.\n perspective: Guantanamo Bay creates an image of Muslim discrimination that continues to increase terrorist sentiments.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e5bdc5b4a6d04b9a836573639c4e3140", "input": "claim: The US should immediately close Guantanamo Bay.\n perspective: Conditions at Guantanamo are unjust and unacceptable: ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-54f0269d4d8942228b0be66bf350a4cb", "input": "claim: The US should immediately close Guantanamo Bay.\n perspective: Prisoners at Guantanamo experience unconscionable treatment. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-8357715065084147a9713fb4192ae30c", "input": "claim: The US should immediately close Guantanamo Bay.\n perspective: The conditions at Guantanamo violate prisoners' basic rights.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-40cbe1baceda47248aa6178aac3a506e", "input": "claim: We should limit the right to bear arms.\n perspective: Sports shooting desensitizes people to the lethal nature of firearms", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-b3550d005a9a4aaf80a40f06bc095728", "input": "claim: We should limit the right to bear arms.\n perspective: It's a slippery slope from sports shooting to increased desensitization of the lethal nature of guns. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-987a927fdd544cf495d84e0162370700", "input": "claim: We should limit the right to bear arms.\n perspective: To engage in sports shooting is a step towards complete desensitization to the harm imposed by firearms. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-44309d64d8594235ab80d3e1dcb5061c", "input": "claim: We should limit the right to bear arms.\n perspective: A handgun ban reduces crime and deaths", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-869d9ae092ad474fa1e46e363087a540", "input": "claim: We should limit the right to bear arms.\n perspective: The result of a handgun ban is lower crime and fewer deaths.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-1a3bf79011364495b28d99def0c81926", "input": "claim: We should limit the right to bear arms.\n perspective: Lower crime rates and fewer deaths result when handguns are banned in a city.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-bc522404bac24af3a12d7b51edecc04e", "input": "claim: We should limit the right to bear arms.\n perspective: Hand Guns Are Required For Self Defence.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-9e620ee3bdca4621b785d589441cefe3", "input": "claim: We must limit anonymous contributions from corporations and individuals to super PACs.\n perspective: Further campaign finance reform is simply unrealistic and too ambitious. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b317aaa179104eeb8f6e96b1e1e780cf", "input": "claim: We must limit anonymous contributions from corporations and individuals to super PACs.\n perspective: It is unrealistic to believe campaign finance can be further reformed.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-9ea774fdd3ef4d2faa221e96d8bdc845", "input": "claim: We must limit anonymous contributions from corporations and individuals to super PACs.\n perspective: Additional reformation of campaign finance is unrealistic.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-3d62053827934a4ca4f826854569a811", "input": "claim: We must limit anonymous contributions from corporations and individuals to super PACs.\n perspective: Neither individuals nor corporations should be permitted to make unlimited contributions", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-482924bfca0c46fb9d0e8932c43c52e5", "input": "claim: We must limit anonymous contributions from corporations and individuals to super PACs.\n perspective: Anonymity Ensures that Campaigning Rises above Identity Attacks.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-92d2219216ed4617b6d3cf25972bd6cc", "input": "claim: We must limit anonymous contributions from corporations and individuals to super PACs.\n perspective: Corporations are fundamentally different than individuals and have the right to influence politics differently.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e4828c61774e423aa5724feb4a163ae6", "input": "claim: Scotland should cede from the union.\n perspective: The many hidden subsidies to SE England would end.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-6215c5279d894b3f8895577758f5c1cf", "input": "claim: Scotland should cede from the union.\n perspective: Independence would give Scotland clout where it matters", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-1baf4c33b2b949f1bbb33246759b2f5e", "input": "claim: Scotland should cede from the union.\n perspective: If Scotland were independent then it would have more power in important areas.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-0897f4ae6603448dbc38409a68fbc333", "input": "claim: Scotland should cede from the union.\n perspective: An independent Scotland nation-state would give it more influence.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-fa86164281da422498bca49b6e6e8c7a", "input": "claim: Scotland should cede from the union.\n perspective: Scotland will be unable to survive economically without England", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-8422b64978ba488bbfbffbe2bd0906dd", "input": "claim: Scotland should cede from the union.\n perspective: Scotland would not be able to survive independently without England.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-7d139f0984644cf3adfb147435c3f43c", "input": "claim: Scotland should cede from the union.\n perspective: Relations between Scots and English are deteriorating", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-3f367eb9edb44a24818b2d21e8333ca3", "input": "claim: Scotland should cede from the union.\n perspective: Other small nation-states like Norway and the Republic of Ireland are successful", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-14e41399a47b400cb0a6f13ef31d3cd1", "input": "claim: Scotland should cede from the union.\n perspective: Norway and the Republic of Ireland are examples of successful nation-states.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e69fbe4bc3d044c0a9df81e04bfe1445", "input": "claim: Scotland should cede from the union.\n perspective: You can look at Norway and the Republic of Ireland to see successful nation-states.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ee7baf75f8e0430895223f650bccca88", "input": "claim: Scotland should cede from the union.\n perspective: The Scots themselves would vote against independence if there was a referendum.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-7ff3581cf23c4361a55762feeb05db2d", "input": "claim: Scotland should cede from the union.\n perspective: If it should come to it, the Scottish people would not vote for independence.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-1a482316ca4b4e139e1014160df15e67", "input": "claim: Scotland should cede from the union.\n perspective: Scots would not be in favor of voting for independence. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-f0ab0c6ba17646cfa09146553bee3ca5", "input": "claim: Scotland should cede from the union.\n perspective: Scotland has different interests to rUK", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-3b2957c2ef0841eeb3b1c69d1056bae7", "input": "claim: US must get rid of the double jeopardy rule.\n perspective: Double jeopardy ensures defendants are not brought to trial on weak grounds", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-9a3744bfa1004271af6a1bbd965e1fcc", "input": "claim: US must get rid of the double jeopardy rule.\n perspective: Defendants aren't brought to trial unnecessarily because of double jeopardy.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-00d5851b72084f54afcfadc75dc1f6d8", "input": "claim: US must get rid of the double jeopardy rule.\n perspective: The double jeopardy principle ensures that only strong cases are brought against defendants.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-df8e756c458441fba2d9cef26f325f3f", "input": "claim: US must get rid of the double jeopardy rule.\n perspective: Abolishment of double jeopardy would ensure the guilty do not escape punishment", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a1dccfff75164c149e584f7efe6bf838", "input": "claim: Music containing lyrics that glorify violent and criminal lifestyles should be banned.\n perspective: Defending hip hop artists’ right to free speech", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-41fbba66d8cc473ca13fbb70cdc4a6ee", "input": "claim: Music containing lyrics that glorify violent and criminal lifestyles should be banned.\n perspective: everyone deserves free speech", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-0dc2969f647f46ea85d2f9c7272372c3", "input": "claim: Music containing lyrics that glorify violent and criminal lifestyles should be banned.\n perspective: ban music that glorifies crime because of the influence it has on children", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-59c30ac3254c4b9789d716c1dba0fcd3", "input": "claim: Music containing lyrics that glorify violent and criminal lifestyles should be banned.\n perspective: music that glorifies crime should be banned", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-eb011ec17870422287384b03d5c80777", "input": "claim: Music containing lyrics that glorify violent and criminal lifestyles should be banned.\n perspective: music that glorifies crime needs to be banned", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-2f6a94ce42b14afdb86c7133f9e85d85", "input": "claim: Music containing lyrics that glorify violent and criminal lifestyles should be banned.\n perspective: Censoring Art Is Dangerous", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-256e2312755642b5906f13ed6a8bbbb9", "input": "claim: Music containing lyrics that glorify violent and criminal lifestyles should be banned.\n perspective: It is dangerous to censor art.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-9f8771f2e9f5420785c92a882a4771dc", "input": "claim: Music containing lyrics that glorify violent and criminal lifestyles should be banned.\n perspective: Censoring art is extremely bad.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-f67ccafc05d642feb3b4153fadc745d1", "input": "claim: Music containing lyrics that glorify violent and criminal lifestyles should be banned.\n perspective: Music depicting violence to women causes and sustains the cycle of violence.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e7278ede0b7142179b81172e8a6ae09b", "input": "claim: Music containing lyrics that glorify violent and criminal lifestyles should be banned.\n perspective: people are influenced by violent music", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d40a2d5ffc4d4ed99051ad372247e8ba", "input": "claim: Music containing lyrics that glorify violent and criminal lifestyles should be banned.\n perspective: violent music harms families ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-1e040e5eeac840ac97e0e268bf7cd8c0", "input": "claim: Music containing lyrics that glorify violent and criminal lifestyles should be banned.\n perspective: To ban music that encourages violence against women would be done with the intention of protecting women; if it is necessary to paint them as the victims of violence that they are, that is a small price to pay. Furthermore, bans on child pornography would", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-47c54458701c4534af70f8c42af9d98c", "input": "claim: Music containing lyrics that glorify violent and criminal lifestyles should be banned.\n perspective: If we change violent music, we can end the violence in society.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-18f2720900274097bb34ffc1f63c2334", "input": "claim: Music containing lyrics that glorify violent and criminal lifestyles should be banned.\n perspective: Violence is music leads to violence in real life, so ending violent music would lessen violence in real life.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f8459f96e407467eb1ccca63fe04a9d1", "input": "claim: Music containing lyrics that glorify violent and criminal lifestyles should be banned.\n perspective: A change is needed to stop the cycle of violence.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c91e573f76f24a3d8a720fc321490e8f", "input": "claim: Music containing lyrics that glorify violent and criminal lifestyles should be banned.\n perspective: Harmful speech needs to be filtered", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-0fc93564f84d4f68aec8f5ac429477f6", "input": "claim: Music containing lyrics that glorify violent and criminal lifestyles should be banned.\n perspective: When harmful speech is glorified in music, it leads to bad things in real life. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a120769538de415f96f8919ccd77ac26", "input": "claim: Music containing lyrics that glorify violent and criminal lifestyles should be banned.\n perspective: Filtering hate speech will keep it out of the mainstream and out of our lives.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-34f56940559a4357942975342bbd7643", "input": "claim: Music containing lyrics that glorify violent and criminal lifestyles should be banned.\n perspective: People are justified in listening to violent music", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-6982358e58b445fc90f2890e8a3d698b", "input": "claim: Music containing lyrics that glorify violent and criminal lifestyles should be banned.\n perspective: People have the right to listen to whatever music they want to.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-d8b897cb3d524da4983680b3bcc4cadb", "input": "claim: Music containing lyrics that glorify violent and criminal lifestyles should be banned.\n perspective: Violent music can be listened to without people going out and doing what the music says.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c8029291d36c40e78acad09d650acc99", "input": "claim: Music containing lyrics that glorify violent and criminal lifestyles should be banned.\n perspective: A ban is necessary for progress in the status of women.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-384f4f802f0149aca546908dde1e7a5a", "input": "claim: Music containing lyrics that glorify violent and criminal lifestyles should be banned.\n perspective: To ban violent music against weapon is to support positive status of women in society.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-59c53877467a4b159a19105d018f6b9e", "input": "claim: Music containing lyrics that glorify violent and criminal lifestyles should be banned.\n perspective: Music depicting violence against women encourages men (and women) not to respect women.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-117badb9bb2642c492cc4daa4be2bd8e", "input": "claim: Music containing lyrics that glorify violent and criminal lifestyles should be banned.\n perspective: Both sexes are encouraged lose respect for women when music depicts violence against women.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-aa9d4b891e774c698c8650367e1c3acd", "input": "claim: Music containing lyrics that glorify violent and criminal lifestyles should be banned.\n perspective: Music depicting violence against women discourages respect of women in men and women.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-5706a89ea9334eb895e67ba187c8d0f0", "input": "claim: Music containing lyrics that glorify violent and criminal lifestyles should be banned.\n perspective: The violent music encourages disrespect toward women", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-0e47cbf9ff05416796648af9c176a871", "input": "claim: Music containing lyrics that glorify violent and criminal lifestyles should be banned.\n perspective: Music about violence against women doesn't help the perception of women", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-2a2a1c3f225441aa8e036088d628c889", "input": "claim: Music containing lyrics that glorify violent and criminal lifestyles should be banned.\n perspective: It would be easy to apply restrictions on music.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e8e5968bdbd74f86aab9ce718b8d0e40", "input": "claim: Music containing lyrics that glorify violent and criminal lifestyles should be banned.\n perspective: It would be highly impractical to ban this music glorifying violence.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-f7552a601474467d95cc4a0b8271e467", "input": "claim: Music containing lyrics that glorify violent and criminal lifestyles should be banned.\n perspective: It would not be at all practical to ban music glorifying violence.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b4bcb3b58d4848fca09bb2cbae21ebd4", "input": "claim: Music containing lyrics that glorify violent and criminal lifestyles should be banned.\n perspective: Banning this music that glorifies violence is totally impractical.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a1e5bd0505b140289f639cfde8f8020f", "input": "claim: Music containing lyrics that glorify violent and criminal lifestyles should be banned.\n perspective: It is not realistic to expect a ban of violent music", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-0c09a72d46954dd7942bb8b86230599c", "input": "claim: Music containing lyrics that glorify violent and criminal lifestyles should be banned.\n perspective: To ban this type of music encourages the viewing of women as helpless, victim figures.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-0451c0ebdc21413c94752bf181d4748f", "input": "claim: Music containing lyrics that glorify violent and criminal lifestyles should be banned.\n perspective: Women would be seen as helpless victims if we banned this type of music.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-30bf7ce936124472ab37877337b741e0", "input": "claim: Music containing lyrics that glorify violent and criminal lifestyles should be banned.\n perspective: It would encourage the viewing of women as helpless victims if this type of music was banned.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-339a386fdcf847b387b69ffa7448220b", "input": "claim: Music containing lyrics that glorify violent and criminal lifestyles should be banned.\n perspective: Banning the music would only make women seen more like victims", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-48160c99f4d64dad9e920b8e4f3d9556", "input": "claim: Music containing lyrics that glorify violent and criminal lifestyles should be banned.\n perspective: By banning the music, women will continue to be viewed as helpless", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-98260c6d558c42458d3da24fc2cddb84", "input": "claim: Music containing lyrics that glorify violent and criminal lifestyles should be banned.\n perspective: This type of music is degrading to everyone, not just women.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-95255d0a5c5a4c85b3f89ac9c850f9b7", "input": "claim: Music containing lyrics that glorify violent and criminal lifestyles should be banned.\n perspective: this music harms women and others", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-185f4b111439495b9e9e100a19844beb", "input": "claim: We must ban negative advertising in political campaigns.\n perspective: Negative campaigning reduces the diversity and representativeness of government.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-eea73a3ab4324afb9cbeb6b748344838", "input": "claim: We must ban negative advertising in political campaigns.\n perspective: Negative campaign divides the nation and its people", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-4378159bfc43425daedf4ee503918a24", "input": "claim: We must ban negative advertising in political campaigns.\n perspective: Negative campaigns helps reduce diversity", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-779f8f96b41b4d89905b471d7d0647ad", "input": "claim: We must ban negative advertising in political campaigns.\n perspective: Existing methods of disciplining and controlling candidates are ineffective.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-1c37b619c2404622b48b7ecdcf9706bf", "input": "claim: We must ban negative advertising in political campaigns.\n perspective: Negative campaigning can create voter apathy", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-97d08239d23145f7ae64510ddd9cc979", "input": "claim: We must ban negative advertising in political campaigns.\n perspective: Negative campaigning leads to negative governance.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-b68ebc56be1d4284ae8dc1dedcf86bc5", "input": "claim: We must ban negative advertising in political campaigns.\n perspective: Negative campaigns can lead to negative governing.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-b8910dd94ecd43d192f4df42f9ca6ffb", "input": "claim: We must ban negative advertising in political campaigns.\n perspective: Negativity in campaigns can lead to a government that is negative.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c0c4cbcd7a654294bd418c4328dcf491", "input": "claim: The niqab and other face coverings in schools must be banned.\n perspective: It causes problems in schools", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-2df3de2fabd543bbb8790e27ebf7edf4", "input": "claim: The niqab and other face coverings in schools must be banned.\n perspective: The veil is a symbol of oppression on women", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-6ebbf2af0e22485cbe92d05adb804be5", "input": "claim: The niqab and other face coverings in schools must be banned.\n perspective: Women are oppressed by face and hair coverings", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-7be1584e23a1479fbd76406789dfe868", "input": "claim: The niqab and other face coverings in schools must be banned.\n perspective: It’s a personal matter – it doesn’t concern others", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-213930e25fb242ee8d8db0d682c06328", "input": "claim: The niqab and other face coverings in schools must be banned.\n perspective: Religious clothing is a matter of personal choice", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-cc01c7073efc4853a8663ce58434dcd0", "input": "claim: The niqab and other face coverings in schools must be banned.\n perspective: No one should tell others how to dress", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-21d854c3ad33434391a014b266bd9005", "input": "claim: The niqab and other face coverings in schools must be banned.\n perspective: Who cares if someone wears a veil?", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-9946dfda3aa941b385de9f307fb78341", "input": "claim: The niqab and other face coverings in schools must be banned.\n perspective: Why does it concern you if another person wears a veil?", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-48321f494e5e4fc7882807a7d278ccb5", "input": "claim: The niqab and other face coverings in schools must be banned.\n perspective: Its personal. Why does it matter to others.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-f7e585bda5484cd2aa23f07ca3020b9a", "input": "claim: The niqab and other face coverings in schools must be banned.\n perspective: It’s their culture and religion", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-9eaabcaff40a40ad994982e5c43ec810", "input": "claim: The niqab and other face coverings in schools must be banned.\n perspective: It is their culture and religion!", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-521dad4cc4474113ac3341a6b3a2f398", "input": "claim: The niqab and other face coverings in schools must be banned.\n perspective: Face coverings like niqab are a part of their religion and should be allowed.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-aade5ee7e3b6479bacefa0f38e549249", "input": "claim: The niqab and other face coverings in schools must be banned.\n perspective: It's not right for people to be forced to cover their religious face coverings since it's their culture.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-0386658c72b94473b01a3a8718007f5f", "input": "claim: The niqab and other face coverings in schools must be banned.\n perspective: If you ban it, you have to ban everything else", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-0e484940a2284634b4ca1cf1c2f6970e", "input": "claim: The niqab and other face coverings in schools must be banned.\n perspective: Bans on religious clothing could be a slippery slope", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-90b10c0277dc4b1f9c60cfb7de8a58d8", "input": "claim: The niqab and other face coverings in schools must be banned.\n perspective: If you ban muslim clothing than you'll have to start banning catholic or jewish clothing too", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-aac0169bb2014c2eb55f56828feafb7e", "input": "claim: The niqab and other face coverings in schools must be banned.\n perspective: It is a racism starter", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-0ead324040794016af552da179accd08", "input": "claim: The niqab and other face coverings in schools must be banned.\n perspective: The muslim veil brings out the racism in people. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-0f8a0ef5454c464a98192ef0b89248a7", "input": "claim: Humans should eat meat.\n perspective: Humans need meat in their diet", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-9e8c1dd4c2a640b79a221d1287726af0", "input": "claim: Humans should eat meat.\n perspective: Humans need to eat meat.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-90511c7758f64ae09894542bbc96ddfe", "input": "claim: Humans should eat meat.\n perspective: Humans need to consume meat.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-10b673323d404af3ac43821190550e91", "input": "claim: Humans should eat meat.\n perspective: We shouldn't eat as muh meat.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-0be00da40cce46619bdaad30b9871344", "input": "claim: Humans should eat meat.\n perspective: We should eat less meat.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a10f0f10003e4c08a2091d6425a637b6", "input": "claim: Humans should eat meat.\n perspective: We should stop eating so much meat.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-816fdac4c24b4505882c93cdb1ab9f05", "input": "claim: Humans should eat meat.\n perspective: If humans are like animals they should be able to eat them", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-0827e539e0764067a32bf6c03ff424dc", "input": "claim: Humans should eat meat.\n perspective: Humans should be allowed to eat animals. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f1105361db76498b866aaf778af6430b", "input": "claim: Humans should eat meat.\n perspective: It is okay for humans to eat animals.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e6b8a0cacbc14f63aa171495c7b47a47", "input": "claim: Humans should eat meat.\n perspective: There's nothing inherently wrong with eating animals", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e6472e377b3143a790a369c3c0bd7c38", "input": "claim: Humans should eat meat.\n perspective: It if fine to eat animals. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-7a20b07a181145aeaeefccdab9413804", "input": "claim: Humans should eat meat.\n perspective: It is not immoral to eat animals.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-fd02157f76164381a326b9a02dbf9d9d", "input": "claim: Humans should eat meat.\n perspective: The farming of animals causes suffering. Causing suffering is wrong. The farming of animals is wrong", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-bec9508bfae441ccb82a0dc6fcfc323b", "input": "claim: Humans should eat meat.\n perspective: Farming of animals causes suffering and is wrong.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e06c413736b7443fa5610342483815c9", "input": "claim: Humans should eat meat.\n perspective: Animal suffering is wrong; therefore, farming them is too, since it causes them to suffer.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-0964df4833cd40399d9641f8e88e0f03", "input": "claim: Humans should eat meat.\n perspective: Animals are below humans, therefore humans can eat them", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-cf7804c880734f879f7eb7a9364789c3", "input": "claim: Humans should eat meat.\n perspective: vegetarians visit hospitals 22% less often than meat eaters ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a51c946d4cf24780a379a4e31482b091", "input": "claim: Humans should eat meat.\n perspective: Vegetarians visit hospitals 22% less than meat eaters.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-3dd7e0acb69c419eba90b2535cf7daad", "input": "claim: Humans should eat meat.\n perspective: Vegetarians go to hospitals 22% less than meat eaters.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ee82430ee2cc4d2dbc036c151b71d606", "input": "claim: The world should go vegan.\n perspective: It will facilitate world food distribution", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-1cdf0f02e1104a90a4baf6c686d210ce", "input": "claim: The world should go vegan.\n perspective: Eating meat has been an essential part of human evolution for 2.3 million years. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-d9d933cb560347f1bd467a17e26053a6", "input": "claim: The world should go vegan.\n perspective: Our bodies were not designed for a vegan diet", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-5322441778fe4827a9141cf53cd08c4d", "input": "claim: The world should go vegan.\n perspective: The evolution of humanity has progressed due to meat eating for 2.3 million years.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-93df5014fa914aab91c307e6555e628d", "input": "claim: The world should go vegan.\n perspective: It has been vital for humans to eat meat for over 2 million years.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-8da3fd5df5c140eea8ccf50923ec5d80", "input": "claim: The world should go vegan.\n perspective: Meat consumption should be reduced, but does NOT need to be eradicated", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e5c6050f0be245c79fa9cf915caf4753", "input": "claim: The world should go vegan.\n perspective: A Vegan diet would not be practical in most parts of the world", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-6f365e223cc542688793aa8d36bc03f6", "input": "claim: The world should go vegan.\n perspective: A vegetarian diet reduces overuse of antibiotics. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-0957a8c6dd1e4565a06cff3b97fc972f", "input": "claim: The world should go vegan.\n perspective: Anitbiotics aren't used in vegetarian foods.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-1668d04668b7450db17e004e3d35af8b", "input": "claim: The world should go vegan.\n perspective: Vegetarian diets result in a reduction of antibiotic usage.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-3e5c778c55254daaa12c675975ca7845", "input": "claim: The world should go vegan.\n perspective: Vegetarian diets are not necessarily better for the environment. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-169b8595e55047638b7ef411b9e9c21e", "input": "claim: The world should go vegan.\n perspective: There is no evidence that vegetarian diets help the environment. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-03ff696658fd4ef8a4c85ec8dea96be9", "input": "claim: The world should go vegan.\n perspective: People who eat meat are not harming the environment. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-d813ddbd976c49319297cf5993086b42", "input": "claim: The world should go vegan.\n perspective: Vegetarian diets aren't always more environmentally friendly", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-59ab65c5bec549cea9aba18ac78bc114", "input": "claim: The world should go vegan.\n perspective: Vegetarianism doesn't always help the environment", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-8947ec169a584574950c6a2a11830e54", "input": "claim: The world should go vegan.\n perspective: Human anatomy has evolved to support a primarily vegetarian diet. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a344febf14ea4fa9bdc3019038a01194", "input": "claim: The world should go vegan.\n perspective: The human body has changed over time to be able to handle a largely vegetarian diet", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-23a944399a40431b9e7d71541bdea2db", "input": "claim: The world should go vegan.\n perspective: The internal organs of humans have changed over time to support a diet that is free of meat", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-7248d9d39442448084ecbe31b11f2587", "input": "claim: The world should go vegan.\n perspective: A vegetarian diet reduces the chances of developing kidney stones and gallstones. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d4a4c49d98ea4a43bf8d0136b8d4e014", "input": "claim: The world should go vegan.\n perspective: Risk of kidney stones and gallstones can be reduced with a vegetarian diet.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e1addb178445466db0450ee9fd5cd02c", "input": "claim: The world should go vegan.\n perspective: Vegetarians do not live longer. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b1a35465fbed4bb78f24255b2ca5fdf6", "input": "claim: The world should go vegan.\n perspective: People who eat meat live just as long as vegetarians.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-727f36a0e7c641f3b94f5396ae6b10b1", "input": "claim: The world should go vegan.\n perspective: Vegetarians die at the same rate as meat eaters.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-cd91d4db0f964bee911801d9f5d84cf3", "input": "claim: The world should go vegan.\n perspective: Vegetarians have average lifespans", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-65351ff24dcc440f847b437e66e0dc82", "input": "claim: The world should go vegan.\n perspective: Vegetarianism makes no difference in longevity", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e0fe07220fdd41739e10dcbd53df8f88", "input": "claim: The world should go vegan.\n perspective: Studies show that vegetarians are up to 40% less likely to develop cancer than meat eaters. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-1facc82a47d44621b4a60df34a78081a", "input": "claim: The world should go vegan.\n perspective: vegetarians are 40 % less likely to have cancer", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-1069055a9a26468bb1c59537f8ab82e6", "input": "claim: The world should go vegan.\n perspective: A vegetarian diet lowers the risk of heart disease. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-24a632f94aa14da0905ee9af5ef21886", "input": "claim: The world should go vegan.\n perspective: A diet devoid of meat lowers the risk of heart disease.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a1a1edec77d8498d9b5ee99a25202053", "input": "claim: The world should go vegan.\n perspective: A vegetarian diet provides a more healthful form of iron than a meat-based diet. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-7220a9a81ecb43d88dfc35d4a342d49f", "input": "claim: The world should go vegan.\n perspective: Iron from a vegetarian diet is healthier than from a meat-based diet.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-1a439eab77b2428db1c9dfb8ab785026", "input": "claim: The world should go vegan.\n perspective: A vegetarian diet is a healthier way to get iron than from a meat-based diet.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-0ff3cc236b42436b86cc43a235421055", "input": "claim: The world should go vegan.\n perspective: A vegetarian diet can help alleviate world hunger. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a2b27ec5bb6a4a32a724c604cd5d3e5c", "input": "claim: The world should go vegan.\n perspective: World hunger can be reduced with a vegetarian diet.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-6c602f1e2fa647c5921501bc5fabc6ce", "input": "claim: The world should go vegan.\n perspective: Eating a vegetarian diet can lead to less hunger around the world.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-78c9c03885fc4be19dda2119379d2da1", "input": "claim: The world should go vegan.\n perspective: Eating meat provides healthy saturated fats, which enhance the function of the immune and nervous systems. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-50dbeb82d75f427688c366a495f82da7", "input": "claim: The world should go vegan.\n perspective: Saturated fats in meat help the immune and nervous system.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b2c66e7f08f846b78ec93bb406c2e148", "input": "claim: The world should go vegan.\n perspective: Lean red meat, eaten in moderation, can be a healthful part of a balanced diet. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-54f15434e06e49cca75a3f5c3bf56420", "input": "claim: The world should go vegan.\n perspective: Red meat can be unhealthy if eaten in large quantities and too often but is healthy in moderation. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-991f7099a1244af1b81fb7a26f36f243", "input": "claim: The world should go vegan.\n perspective: A balanced and healthy diet consists of vegetables and lean red meat. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-9d427771b00042c3a25ab959876b8d98", "input": "claim: The world should go vegan.\n perspective: Lean red meat can be healthy", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-193a8ea317544cdaa11a691c8f2ba634", "input": "claim: The world should go vegan.\n perspective: Lean red meat is not necessarily unhealthy", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-2b17456854aa4d108756adf22a6ccc8c", "input": "claim: The world should go vegan.\n perspective: Vegetarian diets can cause the death of animals too. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-703c176855a34aa896717aa41726503a", "input": "claim: The world should go vegan.\n perspective: Animals can also die as a result of vegetarian diets.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-6cbd5e1f0a644f609795b163d5ae9569", "input": "claim: The world should go vegan.\n perspective: Animals will still die even if everyone were to follow a vegetarian diet.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c0ff80b6529e41f99b82cfc07a155d71", "input": "claim: The world should go vegan.\n perspective: Vegetarian diets can cause the death of animals too", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-add8d43cf2a94a84b9d4a57c4ca355c5", "input": "claim: The world should go vegan.\n perspective: Eating meat increases the risk of getting type 2 diabetes. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-af044a0c7b60433b9bf33eccb84f923a", "input": "claim: The world should go vegan.\n perspective: Eating More Meat is Linked to Higher Risk of Type 2", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-8a0ebf1c0e104a93901189ff036ca66e", "input": "claim: The world should go vegan.\n perspective: Processed vegetarian protein options such as tofu can cause more greenhouse gas pollution than farming meat. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-dd58017ad5094231be7e9fadcffe5027", "input": "claim: The world should go vegan.\n perspective: Farming meat can produce less pollution than companies that process vegetarian proteins like tofu.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-41ae38b9cee943db9376c700907eb039", "input": "claim: The world should go vegan.\n perspective: Some vegetarian options cause more greenhouse gas emissions than meat production", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c1bafa3e821d44928c5f8a1b39ef65bd", "input": "claim: The world should go vegan.\n perspective: Processed vegetarian protein is less environmentally friendly than eating meat", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-3fec7e22decf475697643f4598e6af17", "input": "claim: The world should go vegan.\n perspective: It is not necessary to become vegetarian to lower our environmental footprint. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e3a10ea627444e0191f5251a7fe6db9f", "input": "claim: The world should go vegan.\n perspective: There are ways other than giving up meat to help the environment.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-7cf10f0fadf4492eaea2ed5f8a914773", "input": "claim: The world should go vegan.\n perspective: People do not have to stop eating meat to improve environmental conditions.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-53249a13d77d421a964f20eef40c33dc", "input": "claim: The world should go vegan.\n perspective: A vegetarian diet conserves water. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-46c1ea956dfd40489c54e71a61d3f8fa", "input": "claim: The world should go vegan.\n perspective: People can conserve water by becoming a vegetarian.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-2c45863ef2dc4f9598e864ad7129dd2e", "input": "claim: The world should go vegan.\n perspective: Becoming a vegetarian is healthy for the environment because people conserve more water.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-2cc168974ff24cda8fb85654d286496d", "input": "claim: The world should go vegan.\n perspective: It is cruel and unethical to kill animals for food when vegetarian options are available. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-1efec85627624a478ead34c8c5b99d03", "input": "claim: The world should go vegan.\n perspective: If there are meat-free options available, it is brutal and immoral to kill animals for food", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ada1635a3fc74ce788c5f0911caad05a", "input": "claim: The world should go vegan.\n perspective: It is deplorable and unconscionable to take the life of an animal for food when one has a choice to eat vegetarian meals", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-dbd589fe542a4ea39ae647ab4caaed4a", "input": "claim: The world should go vegan.\n perspective: The right to eat what we want, including meat, is a fundamental liberty that we must defend. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-8c3c34ae4e9e4245a50f0875e879c77a", "input": "claim: The world should go vegan.\n perspective: Individuals have a right to eat meat if they want to.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-7f8154cd4e424f0aa861605a73a0ec75", "input": "claim: The world should go vegan.\n perspective: People have a right to eat meat or anything else that they want to.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-22e9ae38fec7419f99966bf673aea245", "input": "claim: The world should go vegan.\n perspective: We may accept that we have the right to eat meat", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-09fe51c9d08845629b521471ad7de47b", "input": "claim: The world should go vegan.\n perspective: Becoming vegetarian will not help alleviate world hunger. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c8f375455ad2491b9d82ba389cfd442d", "input": "claim: The world should go vegan.\n perspective: World hunger can not be fixed by vegetarianism. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c4f65be9e58d42b6b9b57e0d41852318", "input": "claim: The world should go vegan.\n perspective: There must be access to meats in order to alleviate world hunger. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-137f224792eb4b1b91e7c7d6ff77f8ff", "input": "claim: The world should go vegan.\n perspective: Vegetarian diets won't help world hunger", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-d5168324e10048aabbe1b39a9158f792", "input": "claim: The world should go vegan.\n perspective: Vegetarianism doesn't reduce world hunger", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-af38c4e5600b4b459609dd7ca8d0d6e7", "input": "claim: The world should go vegan.\n perspective: Raising animals for food contributes to air and water pollution. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d481efdc87f942cea05d17fe08825dfc", "input": "claim: The world should go vegan.\n perspective: Vegetarians live longer. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d9c09662179748e28174b50e008d0be9", "input": "claim: The world should go vegan.\n perspective: It has been proven that Vegetarians Live Longer", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f1352c611e3047babb0efeacb92fa3c7", "input": "claim: The world should go vegan.\n perspective: Eating meat provides a better source of iron than a vegetarian diet. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-27d1cd22d85a4602b77e04f8f41ca1aa", "input": "claim: The world should go vegan.\n perspective: Iron from meat is often cited as better than vegetables.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-1c9e308772d0427fa70302c713092612", "input": "claim: The world should go vegan.\n perspective: I think iron from meat eating is healthier than the vegetarian way.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-7e4ee0b70bef4be98f650168992bc0ed", "input": "claim: The world should go vegan.\n perspective: Producing one hamburger destroys 55 square feet of rainforest. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ebb712687aee46a08f645e56f6422691", "input": "claim: The world should go vegan.\n perspective: Rainforests are destroyed to support animals used for food.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-395a4378014d482d813783ea0bbd75fc", "input": "claim: The world should go vegan.\n perspective: There is nothing inherently cruel about raising animals for food. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-560f1f3a22524fc990ce07400ecd9669", "input": "claim: The world should go vegan.\n perspective: Eating meat is part of the cycle of life.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a9585eff17ad4436b7cb13290a415871", "input": "claim: The world should go vegan.\n perspective: Raising animals for food is not cruel.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-970cc2a53a384438838d3add016874d2", "input": "claim: The world should go vegan.\n perspective: It is not cruel or wrong to raise animals to be eaten.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-5cb68a85f758432fa005d875ab379f85", "input": "claim: The world should go vegan.\n perspective: There is nothing inherently cruel about raising animals for food", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-6622551edce44db499feaaaeeb390b03", "input": "claim: The world should go vegan.\n perspective: Eating meat is not cruel or unethical; it is a natural part of the cycle of life. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-cbb3c147abd84a6a8cda60c70252babd", "input": "claim: The world should go vegan.\n perspective: Meat is the best source of vitamin B12, a vitamin necessary to nervous and digestive system health. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-42c40138894b4fa4a4d850113bdf3ad6", "input": "claim: The world should go vegan.\n perspective: It was proven the b12 from meat is helps the nervous and digestive system.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-db5bbd542c1c484ca39669462b530dbe", "input": "claim: The world should go vegan.\n perspective: For optimum nervous and digestive health, b12 from meat is ideal.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-40f539e07e3049b483f94b93e706dd60", "input": "claim: The world should go vegan.\n perspective: A vegetarian diet leads to lower greenhouse gas emissions. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ebc629356201481e973f939a912c1423", "input": "claim: The world should go vegan.\n perspective: If people became vegetarian, greenhouse gases would reduce. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-7ef4ab9290f042d3b5880fa2ae3d7fea", "input": "claim: The world should go vegan.\n perspective: A vegetarian diet is better for the planet because it reduces greenhouse gases.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a0dc517f7fe74bb081441daeadb2ac03", "input": "claim: The world should go vegan.\n perspective: A vegetarian diet delivers complete nutrition and can provide health benefits. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d9789441ad6740f3a04445ce5077c9f9", "input": "claim: The world should go vegan.\n perspective: In addition to health benefits, a vegetarian diet also gives you everything your body needs.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e832468a5c57485986dc2c756f100ea1", "input": "claim: The world should go vegan.\n perspective: Complete nutrition and health benefits can be had with a vegetarian diet.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-28257c7704cd4e90a4af9ad96f26d0e3", "input": "claim: The world should go vegan.\n perspective: A vegetarian diet promotes a healthy weight. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-bd07657331ce4335993cc552227c1873", "input": "claim: The world should go vegan.\n perspective: Healthy weight can be achieved with a vegetarian diet", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a0aa5bae694e49ae87fe24c000cdbdfa", "input": "claim: The world should go vegan.\n perspective: A vegetarian diet contributes to a healthy weight", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f0408e08df21457caec07004498f7497", "input": "claim: The world should go vegan.\n perspective: A vegetarian diet helps build healthy bones because vegetarians absorb more calcium than meat eaters. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-8c3c9c13ee5b4b23b17a4e909a0cd771", "input": "claim: The world should go vegan.\n perspective: Vegetarian diets allow more calcium to be absorbed than from meat and leads to healthy bones.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-219c64a2229d45ad8edf45004dd1538e", "input": "claim: The world should go vegan.\n perspective: Meat is the most convenient protein source available. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-8931057cf3044d9a8eaf114a72051ccb", "input": "claim: The world should go vegan.\n perspective: Meat is the most readily available protein.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-431b4f356bd548e69193086ec647ff52", "input": "claim: The world should go vegan.\n perspective: Most find that meat is a very convenient source of protein.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-aabf7595270d4476a2e605e857c26d19", "input": "claim: Governments of resource-rich nations should impose high taxes on mining and extraction.\n perspective: Sustainability of such taxes and their effect on sustainability within a country.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-6257637810204f69ad73d2387a8c07ef", "input": "claim: Governments of resource-rich nations should impose high taxes on mining and extraction.\n perspective: High taxes on mining and extraction would cause many adverse affects on the country and its citizens.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e57b71c660324827b531f37baf924e87", "input": "claim: Governments of resource-rich nations should impose high taxes on mining and extraction.\n perspective: The effect a high tax will have on businesses.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-71745905001747e1a28383d8c38e611b", "input": "claim: Governments of resource-rich nations should impose high taxes on mining and extraction.\n perspective: Domestic and Global impact of such a tax will be too great.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-bb89e26529544b6d8775ebb3766f85f9", "input": "claim: Governments of resource-rich nations should impose high taxes on mining and extraction.\n perspective: The domestic and global impact of high mining taxes will have huge a negative impact.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c48a3290f97c41c0a4de5defd075ab5d", "input": "claim: Governments of resource-rich nations should impose high taxes on mining and extraction.\n perspective: The impact of having high mining taxes will be bad on a domestic and a global scale.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-26c5b4950d4846de890f5de8d5882157", "input": "claim: Governments of resource-rich nations should impose high taxes on mining and extraction.\n perspective: Sustained Overexploitation Leads to Depletion", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-7868d7d36e224ebbb74436b392c13c0b", "input": "claim: Governments of resource-rich nations should impose high taxes on mining and extraction.\n perspective: Sterilising Boom Revenues Helps Saving.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-13642caa2fee48adb77f1f95e65c8868", "input": "claim: Governments of resource-rich nations should impose high taxes on mining and extraction.\n perspective: High taxes protect domestic resources.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-06ec02476e29438b966471f7d776e047", "input": "claim: Governments of resource-rich nations should impose high taxes on mining and extraction.\n perspective: High Mining Taxes would Balance the Economy", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-70d12924c89e4ee4b93986c6b82ecedd", "input": "claim: Governments of resource-rich nations should impose high taxes on mining and extraction.\n perspective: The economy could benefit from the imposition of mining taxes.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-b30fcd371fa6466a8f993afc67345fc3", "input": "claim: Governments of resource-rich nations should impose high taxes on mining and extraction.\n perspective: Mining taxes could reduce the deficit.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-91b69f190f5143d0bf7ee5a31f190636", "input": "claim: Governments of resource-rich nations should impose high taxes on mining and extraction.\n perspective: Governments of resource-rich nations should impose high taxes on mining and extraction.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-94013161bf9a4a96a02da50e0edf3a76", "input": "claim: Governments of resource-rich nations should impose high taxes on mining and extraction.\n perspective: Government's Obligation to Benefit Citizens", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-60e33887ecd94bd38658f734a1b029a8", "input": "claim: We must all believe in fundamental human rights.\n perspective: Universal benefits of human rights", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-060e2bbbe136471aa6d9171d3cf30268", "input": "claim: The environment is being sacrificed for the economy.\n perspective: Air pollution will get even worse. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a0967080c2b44a37b173dc5f5fac22e5", "input": "claim: The environment is being sacrificed for the economy.\n perspective: Air pollution gets worse over time.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-be76c6766f7c495286e354f1f9a5bf7d", "input": "claim: The environment is being sacrificed for the economy.\n perspective: air pollution is going to get worse", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e3c5a961762e43ec9171214cf91ae9dd", "input": "claim: The environment is being sacrificed for the economy.\n perspective: the pollution in the air is going to get worse", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-824bc17250a94617818574b7c4897ef0", "input": "claim: Restrictions must be imposed on overseas players in football.\n perspective: It will improve the quality of the national team", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-68a2e815e108473b88499a335e67b0d0", "input": "claim: Restrictions must be imposed on overseas players in football.\n perspective: It makea the National team a better quality.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-3909558ed9cf4a3fb592fa201bc4631d", "input": "claim: Restrictions must be imposed on overseas players in football.\n perspective: The national team will be helped by it", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d17b360c058c4697be4dc561a555da3d", "input": "claim: Restrictions must be imposed on overseas players in football.\n perspective: The quality of the national team will improve.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a4b3b88d54b0448c8313d61a525fb15e", "input": "claim: Restrictions must be imposed on overseas players in football.\n perspective: The improvement of quality of the national team is likely.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f7f620cf08094c6195d49afbd5e9bcf4", "input": "claim: School uniforms must be banned.\n perspective: School uniforms are often expensive", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c61ddb67d358420da7a8304c588ed401", "input": "claim: School uniforms must be banned.\n perspective: Individuality and creativity should be encouraged", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-0080fde9311840418cc4087d5f248e8b", "input": "claim: School uniforms must be banned.\n perspective: School uniforms create a sense of equality", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b22305c1ab0b4bd8970dada7c8615aea", "input": "claim: School uniforms must be banned.\n perspective: School uniforms contribute to the sense of school unity", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c5bdc8b8738d43cf968cd68402f2502a", "input": "claim: Targeted online advertising on the basis of user profiles and demographics must be banned.\n perspective: Individual targeting undermines market and political fairness", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-aa992f44045a40c6ac3f042cd646c5b5", "input": "claim: Targeted online advertising on the basis of user profiles and demographics must be banned.\n perspective: This advertising strategy provides benefits by making marketing more efficient and allows smaller markets to develop", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-043978302054475e876a25e8470e997a", "input": "claim: Targeted online advertising on the basis of user profiles and demographics must be banned.\n perspective: This advertising strategy undermines people’s right to personal privacy", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-eb9c9787f6c04d59a9c356cbdfbd62ae", "input": "claim: Gorbachev Was Responsible for The Collapse Of The USSR.\n perspective: Perestroika put the final nails in the USSR’s economy", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-84cafa1111e24d2d8f52334eccdcf3df", "input": "claim: Gorbachev Was Responsible for The Collapse Of The USSR.\n perspective: The System Needed to Change in Order to Survive in the Longer Term; That Mikhail Gorbachev’s Reforms Failed Showed that the USSR Could Not be Saved", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-fe2a3683c856493e9085bcffa52a99c2", "input": "claim: Gorbachev Was Responsible for The Collapse Of The USSR.\n perspective: It was dead from the time Stalin took control", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ec67321ac603491ba4cb45129e89d5f7", "input": "claim: Gorbachev Was Responsible for The Collapse Of The USSR.\n perspective: Lenin and Stalin the real destroyers of the USSR for destroying Socialism’s Appeal", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4b71036711164496b91fd044c78e2946", "input": "claim: History has no place in the classroom.\n perspective: History lessons can be used as state-sponsored propaganda, distorting the events of the past", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-db226c27107040968dec4ef9fc19250e", "input": "claim: History has no place in the classroom.\n perspective: where we have been can help us with where we are going", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-477cf4f196f74e528e5e9bf29d015b5e", "input": "claim: History has no place in the classroom.\n perspective: Teaching history ensures that events of the past are not forgotten, and lessons are learned", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a3c921d19e4d45938752fe7e1eba7493", "input": "claim: History has no place in the classroom.\n perspective: We learn from the mistakes and successes of others", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-49206e7dd42c444484db4035135d4971", "input": "claim: History has no place in the classroom.\n perspective: History teaching will reflect the erroneous preconceptions and aims of those who set the curriculum", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-551df69031264e1e81126d0ec73d9795", "input": "claim: History has no place in the classroom.\n perspective: History should be taught to school-children, they form an integral part of understanding oneself and one's nation", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-bb54a9a61a1b4131b508e938032e328e", "input": "claim: History has no place in the classroom.\n perspective: History should always have a place in the schoolroom because it is vital to an understanding of why things are the way they are. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ff90b216ffc242518590ea371cb6d028", "input": "claim: History has no place in the classroom.\n perspective: To understand how things came to be, school children should be taught historical facts and figures. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c828688872d84c2fb81bdd90ca35d83c", "input": "claim: History has no place in the classroom.\n perspective: Schoolchildren need to learn history since it is an integral part of learning about one's country.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-0bed2f28c5de4642981e7857e2e6315f", "input": "claim: History has no place in the classroom.\n perspective: History teaches useful skills applicable in other areas of education and life", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-6e28a8075fa74e54823c4e4a842b6598", "input": "claim: History has no place in the classroom.\n perspective: Without a firm foundation of historical knowledge, children will have a harder time learning necessary skills. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-6ab69d4514ab4230841797256cd75d10", "input": "claim: History has no place in the classroom.\n perspective: A good education relies on a strong foundation of historical knowledge.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-6af6efac9b4944e9b79c499b0a6554f2", "input": "claim: History has no place in the classroom.\n perspective: History is a useful subject because it teaches useful skills.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-5b7bc1d3b4e94bfabedd3e327e76e0e2", "input": "claim: History has no place in the classroom.\n perspective: It's a good idea to teach history since kids can learn useful skills they can use throughout their lives.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a3de0619682543caa04ebe2896e9ba96", "input": "claim: History has no place in the classroom.\n perspective: Historical facts can be established to a sufficient degree to be taught to schoolchildren", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a330276ea5d54662a363a35df3da0a07", "input": "claim: History has no place in the classroom.\n perspective: Schools should teach historical facts. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-aac5df3c253e43c382d1634136ddbdb0", "input": "claim: History has no place in the classroom.\n perspective: Children need to learn historical facts in order to be competitive in a global job market.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4729fac7c3d3453782febd6b0786f7e6", "input": "claim: History has no place in the classroom.\n perspective: If taught properly, historical facts can be taught to schoolchildren without problems.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-552142cec0494a06b59041940f8d5ce4", "input": "claim: History has no place in the classroom.\n perspective: History is a good thing to teach to schoolchildren if taught the right way,", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-be256446f7cc4e22bf28e861431f09f2", "input": "claim: History has no place in the classroom.\n perspective: History offers knowledge that coincides with other subjects", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-1064b43b8300424ab7b14b602280ef62", "input": "claim: History has no place in the classroom.\n perspective: History is something that people need to know. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-223251d764204dfea974c63131ee9204", "input": "claim: History has no place in the classroom.\n perspective: history is an important subject", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a73be43e0d3c4c44aacf5c77ddbdb7dd", "input": "claim: History has no place in the classroom.\n perspective: history repeats itself if not known", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e3631860d0214e0a94b4d22ddfa74ab8", "input": "claim: Homework should be banned.\n perspective: There is no evidence that homework makes a difference for young children.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-74845017835444cbab47dcfa60dc5b96", "input": "claim: Homework should be banned.\n perspective: Homework has little educational worth, and therefore is a waste of students' time", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-76516918f24a442e877514ad1a6f1e52", "input": "claim: Homework should be banned.\n perspective: There is a lack of evidence that homework helps younger children", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-b9be9218a46d4c038a4ad8681a6667b0", "input": "claim: Homework should be banned.\n perspective: Small children are not helped by having homework.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-52ec881ce2c24120b33f42feb7c4a458", "input": "claim: Homework should be banned.\n perspective: Homework is an essential part of education, allowing students to learn information beyond that which they are taught at school.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-f84a98c7b76b4f35b5f5487701150096", "input": "claim: Homework should be banned.\n perspective: Homework is crucial to a well rounded education as it is the means by which students are encouraged to learn beyond the school curriculum.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-9f05c04484e6444f9c5d44e0ab44d467", "input": "claim: Homework should be banned.\n perspective: Homework allows students to explore and learn beyond the instruction they are given in the classroom.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-fb6c415bbf9b4d2897a1702b6fd795e0", "input": "claim: Homework should be banned.\n perspective: Homework ensures that students practise what they are taught at school", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-46d53c9067d644feaed3948ad590ba71", "input": "claim: Homework should be banned.\n perspective: Homework provides a link between child, school and the home", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c49f3a107f8d4a9bb6af67aad29ffa2f", "input": "claim: Homework should be banned.\n perspective: Yes, kids need to balance out mental and physical exercise.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-2c139630ea9a4c4f8984a6b89c5ad293", "input": "claim: Homework should be banned.\n perspective: Kids need time to do many different kinds of activities. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-05fe1597cba84c038ad284e597269575", "input": "claim: Homework should be banned.\n perspective: There needs to be a balance for kids between mental and physical stimulation.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ebac600c67cc4514ae6057efc7bfe33c", "input": "claim: Homework should be banned.\n perspective: Mental stimulation and physical exercise need to have the proper balance in children.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-9d1bb196fa57469a961a5a46ebf766c8", "input": "claim: Homework should be banned.\n perspective: Too much homework can be harmful", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-601d153785e14745967e8885018c97a1", "input": "claim: Homework should be banned.\n perspective: Yes Homework Should Have A Limit", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-1e4d89683c4149a5823c42b502f54dc1", "input": "claim: Homework should be banned.\n perspective: Yes, it should.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-31305cfee89040fa895264804dfcfebc", "input": "claim: Homework should be banned.\n perspective: Assigning large amounts of homework isn't good for students.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-3bca348605b346deb8359cb072be4047", "input": "claim: Homework should be banned.\n perspective: Too much homework is detrimental.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-83b03e9263e64ce3919349d65715264f", "input": "claim: Homework should be banned.\n perspective: Homework puts students off learning", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-71937626fbca4a65bd10ee4180ed21c8", "input": "claim: Homework should be banned.\n perspective: Homework disadvantages low-income students", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-08239f9f5a824f0ea26d0f63690bf76c", "input": "claim: Homework should be banned.\n perspective: Low-income students are at a disadvantage when it comes to homework.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-33899bd557e44e0c98dffa269a2be6a0", "input": "claim: Homework should be banned.\n perspective: Homework doesn't help low-income students succeed.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-dd8f65022ed749afae4af294b96bc667", "input": "claim: Homework should be banned.\n perspective: Homework allows parents to be involved with their child's learning", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4547ab42ea5d4fa3b38ba4291992ad05", "input": "claim: Homework should be banned.\n perspective: Homework is beneficial because of parent/child involvement", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-7cb5095972f44c8ca81a2bc5c1fab275", "input": "claim: Homework should be banned.\n perspective: Homework helps parents understand what their children are learning.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-da57b08184cc4483962cce5a94191497", "input": "claim: Homework should be banned.\n perspective: Homework can get parents involved", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-fa371c3e37724471995588868ba79fe5", "input": "claim: Homework should be banned.\n perspective: Homework helps involve parents ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-61851cf70c944869a6209ee1f1479455", "input": "claim: Homework should be banned.\n perspective: Homework improves student achievement", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-f2926cb3920f45a9835dcf00ea8cc8d2", "input": "claim: Homework should be banned.\n perspective: Assigning homework to students improves their level of achievement", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-222eba95a8954df48fb370d60d3f61b2", "input": "claim: Homework should be banned.\n perspective: homework is good for students", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-1b52113edf1b444cbc103f26ce842d29", "input": "claim: Homework should be banned.\n perspective: Homework helps to reinforce learning and develop good study habits and life skills", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-6bab4784c34443e99bc2cab9d8bc6c4a", "input": "claim: Homework should be banned.\n perspective: Homework teaches good habits and responsibility", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a0374e87835a4618bb16d0ad8d7c651a", "input": "claim: Homework should be banned.\n perspective: Homework is good for learning", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b4e4c18a13e947baa4a63548f0f725f7", "input": "claim: Homework should be banned.\n perspective: Homework is good to create study habits", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a054b43e26ff4df3b5d63dd3c2eb18b6", "input": "claim: Major league baseball should continue to allow collisions at home plate.\n perspective: Collisions are an example of violence that has no place in baseball. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c728903517634adf8ce4b7c495498d60", "input": "claim: Major league baseball should continue to allow collisions at home plate.\n perspective: collisions and violence should not be in baseball", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-21693ac09934498fa3b09d955007bac8", "input": "claim: Major league baseball should continue to allow collisions at home plate.\n perspective: Collisions are not as dangerous as they’re feared to be. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-33b3138301804dd0abb2892756d45a5e", "input": "claim: Major league baseball should continue to allow collisions at home plate.\n perspective: Collisions are not necessarily dangerous.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-4e8c1030f790459baa89bfc06c01d914", "input": "claim: Major league baseball should continue to allow collisions at home plate.\n perspective: Collisions in MLB aren't all that bad.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-bcf704afa83d4ec999aa2a1f1452cec1", "input": "claim: Major league baseball should continue to allow collisions at home plate.\n perspective: The safety concerns about collision are overblown", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-7718e0dfcb7947f5a2dea61dbabce704", "input": "claim: Major league baseball should continue to allow collisions at home plate.\n perspective: There is an overreaction to the dangers of collisions", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-0cbf28b697724a9f972c89cc12f252c7", "input": "claim: Major league baseball should continue to allow collisions at home plate.\n perspective: Collisions are unnecessary. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-6e6bb3c8a1174dd0bced03fbdcdf1d46", "input": "claim: Major league baseball should continue to allow collisions at home plate.\n perspective: collisions are not good", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-589ef2d88d3844629b4cd6190b38a209", "input": "claim: Major league baseball should continue to allow collisions at home plate.\n perspective: Collisions are a part of the game. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-8ebd391578a3449689848cc120b15f0c", "input": "claim: Major league baseball should continue to allow collisions at home plate.\n perspective: It's a major part of the game.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-657625e2b1064746889c39f94b18ca5d", "input": "claim: Major league baseball should continue to allow collisions at home plate.\n perspective: Collisions happen in baseball and should be left as is.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-60e0f2e4a2cf47e285d6a51fe0532314", "input": "claim: Major league baseball should continue to allow collisions at home plate.\n perspective: Collisions are just part of the game of baseball", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ac711be8e8d547fd83d93ca7655367eb", "input": "claim: Major league baseball should continue to allow collisions at home plate.\n perspective: One of the things that is part of baseball is having collisions", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-736194621eb94bcd85905b0d13d9ec41", "input": "claim: Major league baseball should continue to allow collisions at home plate.\n perspective: Collisions are dangerous and lead to injury. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-15481368709a4fe9834488710793f5cc", "input": "claim: Major league baseball should continue to allow collisions at home plate.\n perspective: collisions are very dangerous", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-8e6c4ca01b504b758d762ad32b883a12", "input": "claim: Major league baseball should continue to allow collisions at home plate.\n perspective: Without collisions, either the catcher or the runner would have an enormous and unfair advantage. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-96ea02bbd26c4203af1e543ca054227a", "input": "claim: Major league baseball should continue to allow collisions at home plate.\n perspective: The catcher or runner would have a ridiculous advantage if collisions were not allowed.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-4cd3c356d14846809e6ff259963b4ce2", "input": "claim: Major league baseball should continue to allow collisions at home plate.\n perspective: Banning collisions would fundamentally change portions of the game.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-79bb767fe63c469f9e5f37870c948eac", "input": "claim: Major league baseball should continue to allow collisions at home plate.\n perspective: Taking away collisions would give an advantage to one side", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-10eb73e7838e4188b3b4fedbc1d6de22", "input": "claim: Major league baseball should continue to allow collisions at home plate.\n perspective: By taking away collisions, you would give one side an unfair advantage", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ffe3addfa1d64f2ba4b05c91bbee9a93", "input": "claim: Major league baseball should continue to allow collisions at home plate.\n perspective: Collisions are exciting and fun to watch. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-b3dc68beef724881b80b8ee27180c20f", "input": "claim: Major league baseball should continue to allow collisions at home plate.\n perspective: Collisions are an exciting part of the sport.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-0d5c95321769410daeeaca3069f13046", "input": "claim: Major league baseball should continue to allow collisions at home plate.\n perspective: Physicality is an important and fun part of major league baseball.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a3d24aa1cd3c4d77bb234a6a10c7f50b", "input": "claim: Major league baseball should continue to allow collisions at home plate.\n perspective: Collisions are an exciting part of the game", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-792c45d9c96440f59fff5d5cc0dc84b6", "input": "claim: Major league baseball should continue to allow collisions at home plate.\n perspective: It is exciting to watch a collision", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-5bf51b3b4f6642919935f08f81d5a05d", "input": "claim: The internet’s anonymity is beneficial.\n perspective: cyber-bullying ubiquitously leads to child solicitation,murder,identity theft and all sorts of other crimes & misdemeanors", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-41d21b418ccf4f3e8fc5e5f7b9a8ece1", "input": "claim: Provision of higher education must be funded by taxing graduates.\n perspective: Alternative- and more efficient- methods of funding universities are available", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4de665ef700a4068a0765949d6425eee", "input": "claim: Provision of higher education must be funded by taxing graduates.\n perspective: There are more efficient alternative methods of funding universities available.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-2c4222d78b1e4b46a26777a341a81e73", "input": "claim: Provision of higher education must be funded by taxing graduates.\n perspective: Alternative methods of funding universities that are more efficient are available.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-2df6fed9c0324c9a8805fb4c77500653", "input": "claim: Provision of higher education must be funded by taxing graduates.\n perspective: University's could use alternate funding. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c88d241a79cd4ec68d113920aef28c0e", "input": "claim: Provision of higher education must be funded by taxing graduates.\n perspective: It is time to make higher education more affordable. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-8e67b486c0f048c19ab42063ef75a382", "input": "claim: Provision of higher education must be funded by taxing graduates.\n perspective: Graduates may move abroad to avoid tax payments", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ed9a9614a96e4089be76cbe17c2d3505", "input": "claim: Provision of higher education must be funded by taxing graduates.\n perspective: Setting up a graduate tax system would be damagingly expensive", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-01d13eae9b8d4fc6a0ed2df36857a351", "input": "claim: Provision of higher education must be funded by taxing graduates.\n perspective: A graduate tax would reduce teh autonomy of universities", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-d80ed41d46fa4effa3b5cb40d231b741", "input": "claim: Provision of higher education must be funded by taxing graduates.\n perspective: A graduate tax would make university funding more sustainable", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-5a0ce830dc11402da9ad4f0d2e6d623f", "input": "claim: Provision of higher education must be funded by taxing graduates.\n perspective: Delivering funding via a graduate tax is the best way to encourage more students to enter higher education", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-255ca0e96f5344399f1a5c8a33b4f5c2", "input": "claim: Provision of higher education must be funded by taxing graduates.\n perspective: A graduate tax would make access to higher education fairer and more equitable", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f1011e3f779c4a3da84a21a4161b0c7e", "input": "claim: More gun control laws should be enacted.\n perspective: Gun control laws such as background checks and micro-stamping are an invasion of privacy. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-34272e7f728e4d1fa90294a3f11d9756", "input": "claim: More gun control laws should be enacted.\n perspective: Background checks and micro-stamping to purchase a gun are an invasion of privacy.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-6a53e6fb061b46e4914f1d07121277e3", "input": "claim: More gun control laws should be enacted.\n perspective: The privacy of citizens is invaded if they are forced into background checks and micro-stamping to purchase guns.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-fd7e44f1fd014a46a04fbe29f5fce46d", "input": "claim: More gun control laws should be enacted.\n perspective: A majority of adults, including gun owners, support common sense gun control such as background checks, bans on assault weapons, and bans on high-capacity magazines.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-77075c10e9eb4621b152b503af1bff42", "input": "claim: More gun control laws should be enacted.\n perspective: A majority of adults with the inclusion of gun owners support common sense gun control including background checks, bans on assault weapons and high-capacity magazines.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-0f58189cc8834f1d9740934022f50a3f", "input": "claim: More gun control laws should be enacted.\n perspective: A majority of adults with the inclusion of gun owners support common sense gun control such as background checks, banning assault weapons, and bans on high-capacity magazines.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-680faef35d8846549825909b3e4bbf52", "input": "claim: More gun control laws should be enacted.\n perspective: The Second Amendment of the US Constitution protects individual gun ownership.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ec7c9bab6b9f4c29ab6f18ddc542201a", "input": "claim: More gun control laws should be enacted.\n perspective: An assault weapons ban would violate the second amendment", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-fc7b222abf854b85bb12d5cc7a03e4e8", "input": "claim: More gun control laws should be enacted.\n perspective: Individual gun ownership is guaranteed via the Second Amendment.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-9135eb4d549e4b569a59cc9e3c69015d", "input": "claim: More gun control laws should be enacted.\n perspective: It is by the protection of a Second Amendment to the US constitution, that people might have individual gun ownership.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b5064cc0cc6b4c988d0363a2de52cfbb", "input": "claim: More gun control laws should be enacted.\n perspective: The Second Amendment is not an unlimited right to own guns.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-1db6f6146b1a45b9a8d1279c9d81e83f", "input": "claim: More gun control laws should be enacted.\n perspective: The right to own guns is not unlimited because of the Second Amendment. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-91c5f7e9750e44458e7aef5edde4db46", "input": "claim: More gun control laws should be enacted.\n perspective: The constitutional second amendment does not mean you can own guns in an unlimited way.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-99bff43eecb541b6afcba1f0dc160baf", "input": "claim: More gun control laws should be enacted.\n perspective: Civilians, including hunters, should not own military-grade firearms or firearm accessories. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-b7eab08685d140348938a70273fecb51", "input": "claim: More gun control laws should be enacted.\n perspective: The military grade firearms and accessories should not be owned by civilans, which include hunters.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c32ae566900e411da6f772090d5e81a6", "input": "claim: More gun control laws should be enacted.\n perspective: No civilians, including the ones who hunt, should have any military grade firearms, or accessories.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f337ff43073a419d8f19af27d814eac4", "input": "claim: More gun control laws should be enacted.\n perspective: More gun control is not needed; education about guns and gun safety is needed to prevent accidental gun deaths.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4e77e5cebc5343198d6439f4c51b11f6", "input": "claim: More gun control laws should be enacted.\n perspective: More gun control is unnecessary because relatively few people are killed by guns.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-f477f9af82614f268dee49ac4c181ed7", "input": "claim: More gun control laws should be enacted.\n perspective: fewer people are getting killed by guns so no new laws are needed", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-229c95d9f2334e3ead8f60950d3a0614", "input": "claim: More gun control laws should be enacted.\n perspective: High-capacity magazines should be banned because they too often turn murder into mass murder.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-0eda89feb1a24fc784f5c314b72c62df", "input": "claim: More gun control laws should be enacted.\n perspective: High-capacity magazines could be banned because they too turn murder into mass murder.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-458d61822c9e443a87ec06ecbc595c8f", "input": "claim: More gun control laws should be enacted.\n perspective: Far reaching magazines should be banned because they often turn murder into mass murder.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-8ccb19edddf7412f94f81d1d95bdd77f", "input": "claim: More gun control laws should be enacted.\n perspective: Gun control laws and lower gun ownership rates do not prevent suicides.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4649c07faab74039ab853bb0c5dd402e", "input": "claim: More gun control laws should be enacted.\n perspective: If criminals want to obtain guns, they will no matter the laws.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-cc5aa1c5a3b2405f880e7059fa88637a", "input": "claim: More gun control laws should be enacted.\n perspective: Criminals do not respect laws and will still obtain guns.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-3f61f00d16dd4806914dce09a746ad29", "input": "claim: More gun control laws should be enacted.\n perspective: Gun control laws will not prevent criminals from obtaining guns or breaking laws.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-9b579cd9d9444322bb413252d23a41d7", "input": "claim: More gun control laws should be enacted.\n perspective: Gun control laws would prevent citizens from protecting themselves from foreign invaders.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-0000c5c72d694ceca7ddd23d35953568", "input": "claim: More gun control laws should be enacted.\n perspective: Gun control efforts have proved ineffective. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e1ec99fd97af4f62aebf3d226abb52f7", "input": "claim: More gun control laws should be enacted.\n perspective: The homicide rates and suicide rates are less in countries that have strict gun control, versus the US.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-612892a26ab04702adc795b5c1ac1545", "input": "claim: More gun control laws should be enacted.\n perspective: The rates of gun crime are less in the countries who restrict guns, versus the United States.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-fd55a965da6c4a2992c367613274c68d", "input": "claim: More gun control laws should be enacted.\n perspective: More gun control leads to fewer suicides.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d2a86503139042bf9ce05f0bd1b70a1b", "input": "claim: More gun control laws should be enacted.\n perspective: Countries with restrictive gun control laws have lower gun homicide and suicide rates than the United States.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-479e2065351c4eabb0ab0d573db6109c", "input": "claim: More gun control laws should be enacted.\n perspective: More gun control is leading to fewer suicides.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-288b226926a447058ec5f507995017eb", "input": "claim: More gun control laws should be enacted.\n perspective: More gun control can lead to fewer suicides.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-2cd8797b911d4ed1b35d3f6b0b4b2b38", "input": "claim: More gun control laws should be enacted.\n perspective: More gun control laws are needed to protect women from domestic abusers and stalkers.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e68c7a6baf054c4f9c100033aa578c90", "input": "claim: More gun control laws should be enacted.\n perspective: More gun control laws are needed in the protection of women from domestic abusers and stalkers.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-0041c06ac82a44fd9a9266f7cefabcc5", "input": "claim: More gun control laws should be enacted.\n perspective: Armed civilians are unlikely to stop crimes and are more likely to make dangerous situations, including mass shootings, more deadly. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c19a8ec7ecde412aa608d2ecb94e439b", "input": "claim: More gun control laws should be enacted.\n perspective: Crimes, like mass shootings, are unlikely to be stopped by armed civilians and would likely make it more dangerous, instead.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-0f489a98d17244d0acf7f644a0d3e7e0", "input": "claim: More gun control laws should be enacted.\n perspective: When a crime takes place that can be really difficult, it will not help to have armed civilians, as they will only escalate it.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-774a8461950247d48359bf39f2de8a5d", "input": "claim: More gun control laws should be enacted.\n perspective: Gun control laws, especially those that try to ban \"assault weapons,\" infringe upon the right to own guns for hunting and sport.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-09ccdcb742b84f38acfb61efcbf5b367", "input": "claim: More gun control laws should be enacted.\n perspective: A ban on assault weapons infringes on an individuals right to own guns for sport.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b812cfb33e5a40dcb6e6c1d676ef65ae", "input": "claim: More gun control laws should be enacted.\n perspective: The presence of a gun makes a conflict more likely to become violent.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-4efdc23ba2754fa69a22f41c67ea044d", "input": "claim: More gun control laws should be enacted.\n perspective: Gun control laws give too much power to the government and may result in government tyranny and the government taking away all guns from citizens.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-3640c36d05404eb3bca6f01dba6fe105", "input": "claim: More gun control laws should be enacted.\n perspective: Gun control laws take power away from the people and set up an environment ripe for tyranny.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-228b8853774a45f1bf965469d1a519b2", "input": "claim: More gun control laws should be enacted.\n perspective: Government tyranny is likely if the government takes away guns from citizens.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-467b041f3eac4c1c93855b72c0996992", "input": "claim: More gun control laws should be enacted.\n perspective: Gun control laws infringe upon the right to self-defense and deny people a sense of safety.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-12896b9f93c440daa3e27f561a32b3e5", "input": "claim: More gun control laws should be enacted.\n perspective: Gun control laws decrease the sense of individual safety and the right to self-defense.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-2671ec6eff724a738ee7ca4a3e1d0d7c", "input": "claim: More gun control laws should be enacted.\n perspective: Individual safety and the ability to protect oneself are hurt by gun control laws.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-dfd8efdc975b454989b4bddafa9d1341", "input": "claim: More gun control laws should be enacted.\n perspective: Assault weapons are not used in most crimes", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-5ff1719a532b4f3c8953ca4175c6bfcc", "input": "claim: More gun control laws should be enacted.\n perspective: Strict gun control laws do not work in Mexico, and will not work in the United States.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-5e91692bd2e547108a36b3b447078839", "input": "claim: More gun control laws should be enacted.\n perspective: A ban on assault weapons would not work, it will simply encourage a black market", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-12378a40bdf94db7a04aebaa5a27a62e", "input": "claim: More gun control laws should be enacted.\n perspective: An assault weapons ban would stop the manufacture of many of the deadliest guns.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-5ce0320b8628452596217f299b3990e4", "input": "claim: More gun control laws should be enacted.\n perspective: Assault weapons are not necessary for self defence or hunting.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-25b09aae49264fb89c83e4e3d9c39893", "input": "claim: More gun control laws should be enacted.\n perspective: There are no compelling reasons to have assault weapons.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d5f631cec9ce45cd98291e6810d59272", "input": "claim: More gun control laws should be enacted.\n perspective: Assault weapons are not used for practical purposes like self defense or hunting.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-59003ae810314a669abacf2b028849b1", "input": "claim: More gun control laws should be enacted.\n perspective: It is incoherent to ban some guns", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-6138ea8d14cb4e2492284c24aca69575", "input": "claim: More gun control laws should be enacted.\n perspective: More gun control laws would reduce gun deaths.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-2aea77c18f90439280cdeae69918ba09", "input": "claim: More gun control laws should be enacted.\n perspective: Gun control laws would reduce the societal costs associated with gun violence.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-7398162b815b4c63844bff6f2c451791", "input": "claim: More gun control laws should be enacted.\n perspective: Enacting gun control laws such as mandatory safety features would reduce the number of accidental gun deaths. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-4256bcb94c5c4c30a9968d56b2477354", "input": "claim: More gun control laws should be enacted.\n perspective: A ban would save lives ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-b2e58db8ec364597aa2685df26e978c1", "input": "claim: More gun control laws should be enacted.\n perspective: Having increased gun control laws would reduce deaths by guns.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-67c5d8d083884ae7a863346e3f7e1a8e", "input": "claim: More gun control laws should be enacted.\n perspective: Providing gun control laws can reduc societal costs associated with gun violence.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-6058af2b2c574360973c62fddc6b410d", "input": "claim: More gun control laws should be enacted.\n perspective: Gun control laws can reduce societal costs associated with gun violence.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-370709bf86f544208af4067413ea452c", "input": "claim: More gun control laws should be enacted.\n perspective: Lives could be saved with this measure.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-2b80e04966f64165af077e316c398a6f", "input": "claim: More gun control laws should be enacted.\n perspective: A ban would lower mortality.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a671696f5f024159b8283e3deac09d37", "input": "claim: More gun control laws should be enacted.\n perspective: It would lessen the amount of accidental deaths from gun accidents if enacting some mandatory safety features.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f618c6fc910947f596145b9d76eeda1e", "input": "claim: Individuals have a moral obligation to assist people in need.\n perspective: Only help those who ask for it and that too at your discretion", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-154eb9b25fcb4f2a85dd6f264bbb7edf", "input": "claim: Individuals have a moral obligation to assist people in need.\n perspective: Should we as people help everyone or only certain ones.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-56fe6b3d71d34a6f918510cecae8401f", "input": "claim: Individuals have a moral obligation to assist people in need.\n perspective: Individuals should help everyone.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-97e6f84b933d4f4f9aaed79121fc3511", "input": "claim: Individuals have a moral obligation to assist people in need.\n perspective: People have the freedom to choose whether they want to dedicate their time to helping others, and help should only be given to those who ask for it.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-1f9fb39a7c9f492287d8bcafaf94385a", "input": "claim: Individuals have a moral obligation to assist people in need.\n perspective: Help should only be provided to those that want it, and individuals should be able to choose if they want to help or not.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-6bde4def13d9455a9cf467afc140a8a4", "input": "claim: Individuals have a moral obligation to assist people in need.\n perspective: It would be nice if everyone would help those in need but it cant't be forced and people have to make those decisions on their own. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-71e8f5522c7946dea8c59a2891751141", "input": "claim: Individuals have a moral obligation to assist people in need.\n perspective: 2. consequentialism - we must reduce overall suffering, helping people reduces suffering in the world", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-4ad3532c08244627ad8f8a3e584cfff5", "input": "claim: Individuals have a moral obligation to assist people in need.\n perspective: It's none of your business", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-34eb7e53e7dc41dc879ec7f218bea501", "input": "claim: Individuals have a moral obligation to assist people in need.\n perspective: virtue ethics - we become better people", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-167b1c3dda0e429987819819c733c0df", "input": "claim: Violent video games cause violent crime.\n perspective: 'Violence' is a blurry concept and could lead to banning good games.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-19935d985f254993b2a63b442669ec2a", "input": "claim: Violent video games cause violent crime.\n perspective: Rate of violence has been steadily dropping as violent games are being released", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-2e778d98c71245a0944023e98e566119", "input": "claim: Violent video games cause violent crime.\n perspective: Violent video games reduce crime", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e942b928176d4b31ad83df721b27b917", "input": "claim: Violent video games cause violent crime.\n perspective: Violent Video Games Contribute to decreased Crime Rates", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-083a5a03d95846ccb00abd73adc1360c", "input": "claim: Violent video games cause violent crime.\n perspective: violence drops with video games", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-1285d868ba204e6c86b5f772146b07ed", "input": "claim: Violent video games cause violent crime.\n perspective: violent video games decrease violence", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-8d44117cc9d8438fb54aee3ef3e2b074", "input": "claim: Violent video games cause violent crime.\n perspective: The violence in games isn't represented negatively, but instead shown to be rewarded", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-875a4f4e608f406ca3eea32a1e8adc91", "input": "claim: Violent video games cause violent crime.\n perspective: No games influence their players", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-aadb3d6f5df441cb86e953143923c7da", "input": "claim: Violent video games cause violent crime.\n perspective: No, Violent Video Games Don't Cause Mass Shootings", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4b23212c40f24c78bb0cd2063f15b8ef", "input": "claim: Violent video games cause violent crime.\n perspective: Video games do not influence players to commit real world violence.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c4fe019c984e4d25b6e763fcf282798a", "input": "claim: Violent video games cause violent crime.\n perspective: Games have no influence on players", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c81a0042288345d39f819eda61919985", "input": "claim: Violent video games cause violent crime.\n perspective: Games do not influence the player", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-823b62f9c2514b48bdad6480f8c564bd", "input": "claim: Violent video games cause violent crime.\n perspective: There are far larger contributing factors to violent crime.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e210a7d9ac0e407786b251b97d70154a", "input": "claim: Violent video games cause violent crime.\n perspective: There has always been violence", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-2f0fe74e17f745c1bc27b36a9c370aa1", "input": "claim: Violent video games cause violent crime.\n perspective: Violence existed before video games. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e0c120c2006c4fc18025b688caab31d8", "input": "claim: Violent video games cause violent crime.\n perspective: There was always violence", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c693add8c9a34d22a8e4d75b4c8f2af8", "input": "claim: Violent video games cause violent crime.\n perspective: There always was violence ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-90c7346c875e486e8acfca7f734b2bb7", "input": "claim: Violent video games cause violent crime.\n perspective: The Responsibility Lies With Parents", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-35018c3ed917485da98281d21a9d7aa9", "input": "claim: Violent video games cause violent crime.\n perspective: Research has shown violent video games encourage criminal and anti-social behaviour", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-b179f19d59d4457b962a2a576c4df85f", "input": "claim: Violent video games cause violent crime.\n perspective: people immitate video games.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-7675e72a0c40410da01f0a036a06ec32", "input": "claim: Violent video games cause violent crime.\n perspective: violent games make people agressive.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-208391153b284d2786aa0a6b595cb615", "input": "claim: Violent video games cause violent crime.\n perspective: Playing violent video games leads to violent behaviors.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-6e72b668c2cf4273bb6bdece9c4cfcb5", "input": "claim: Violent video games cause violent crime.\n perspective: Playing violent video games causes more aggression, bullying, and fighting.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-5255955c008b4f35881fa34fc0472661", "input": "claim: Violent video games cause violent crime.\n perspective: Simulating violence such as shooting guns and hand-to-hand combat in video games can cause real-life violent behavior.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e22ef242c8ce43cfab7587800c53121d", "input": "claim: Violent video games cause violent crime.\n perspective: The American Psychological Association (APA) lists violent video games as a risk factor for aggressive behavior.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-b38710e5a1594d3793cb60a77fc1695b", "input": "claim: Violent video games cause violent crime.\n perspective: Violent Video Games cause Violent Behaviour", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-24ee8379b7174493aaa3d137a4bb57a0", "input": "claim: Violent video games cause violent crime.\n perspective: real life violent behaviors may be stimulated by video games", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ec9f2b2b2b24435e9152d4b1c7a5680b", "input": "claim: Violent video games cause violent crime.\n perspective: Violent video games are seen as a risk factor for aggressive behavior, according to the American Psychological Association (APA)", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f51a16efebb647bda19c306e6236c5ef", "input": "claim: Violent video games cause violent crime.\n perspective: Violent Video Games Cause Social Interaction Problems", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-fbbf4c1515a04ff288cb4403aff96310", "input": "claim: Violent video games cause violent crime.\n perspective: Violent video games lead to inappropriate social interactions.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-3c45e982b8a747e18737896245b55a44", "input": "claim: Violent video games cause violent crime.\n perspective: Violent video games are detrimental to social interaction.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-b3130e6ad9834d20ae4b673e563419e3", "input": "claim: Violent video games cause violent crime.\n perspective: Violent video games desensitise users", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-59f5d0572f0b4f1a8c928900b88b7357", "input": "claim: Violent video games cause violent crime.\n perspective: Violent games normalizes forms of violence.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d5a90676e22e4bdf885d335f8eb27660", "input": "claim: Violent video games cause violent crime.\n perspective: Restrictions would be ineffective", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-3a597e2310654c9da2af3b8d6999cfb6", "input": "claim: Violent video games cause violent crime.\n perspective: Restricting video games only makes people more interested in them. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-f6e734f891344a57961210bf7e96b94a", "input": "claim: Violent video games cause violent crime.\n perspective: The government has a right to restrict the sale of violent video games, in order to protect law and order.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-3139faa914064726bde090339bd14b9b", "input": "claim: Violent video games cause violent crime.\n perspective: In order to maintan a well funcitoning society, the government has a right to restrict violent games which could hurt people.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-44fe047c9b774128ab06582c6072dc67", "input": "claim: Violent video games cause violent crime.\n perspective: Video games are content that has a right to be censored for the mass majority's public safety.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-eda7f0bb4bd74201ba5d9b112410c084", "input": "claim: Violent video games cause violent crime.\n perspective: Gun violence is less prevalent in countries with high video game use.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e7210ae28d2048f08a6cf6cd7198a46c", "input": "claim: Violent video games cause violent crime.\n perspective: Countries with high video game use see less gun violence", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-362aeda4a1b44b65ae064f56960d44a0", "input": "claim: Violent video games cause violent crime.\n perspective: Studies have shown that violent video games can have a positive effect on kindness, civic engagement, and \"prosocial” behaviors.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-27e62531f5cd4a23ada3ec7827c8f7de", "input": "claim: Violent video games cause violent crime.\n perspective: Violent video game players know the difference between virtual violence in the context of a game and appropriate behavior in the real world.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c19a64c6f4294645bfde14207e03d7e9", "input": "claim: Violent video games cause violent crime.\n perspective: There are many flaws to the theory that violent video games cause real life violence.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a11a8c5a53b74f40a6ee62ef576bea74", "input": "claim: Violent video games cause violent crime.\n perspective: Studies claiming a causal link between video game violence and real life violence are flawed.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-2f668c65e4cb466398541517579592e1", "input": "claim: Violent video games cause violent crime.\n perspective: Playing violent video games does not cause kids to commit mass shootings.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-1d12c06b95bb4f7ca6943876da0ee878", "input": "claim: We have to produce high quality generic drugs for Africa.\n perspective: Easily affordable drugs will mean greater access", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-5a1f5a5f340545e793a78cbaa5762e04", "input": "claim: We have to produce high quality generic drugs for Africa.\n perspective: Cheaper drugs aren’t trusted by consumers", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-9819f75f7f2148328a16513f390345ed", "input": "claim: We have to produce high quality generic drugs for Africa.\n perspective: Consumers don't trust drugs that are cheaper than others.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-f37e4493664c440496c88d9a141759c7", "input": "claim: We have to produce high quality generic drugs for Africa.\n perspective: Consumers don't place as much trust in drugs that are cheaper.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-f5f75f3a8a8e47dfb380db8401ee71b8", "input": "claim: We have to produce high quality generic drugs for Africa.\n perspective: Dominance of generic drugs will reduce reinvestment and innovation in donating countries", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-7f8d8063af3c4b8bad5804b0b242405b", "input": "claim: We have to produce high quality generic drugs for Africa.\n perspective: If generic drugs flourish innovation will decrease.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-39e548882d134122bb6f65c2f71e0402", "input": "claim: We have to produce high quality generic drugs for Africa.\n perspective: Generic drugs threaten innovation.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-8c444061490c417983713a92a5b91f1b", "input": "claim: We have to produce high quality generic drugs for Africa.\n perspective: Reduce the prominence of bad and fake drugs", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-9dbc9bdf98554de58accde2692e3eb6b", "input": "claim: We have to produce high quality generic drugs for Africa.\n perspective: Unfair to apply same patent laws universally", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-3e0f41574b9048ab8b3c232da8dd48a2", "input": "claim: Historical Artefacts Should Be Repatriated to Their Country of Origin.\n perspective: Artefacts are enriched by being viewed in their place of origin", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-6f347cc7628243b9acc38c3699ef6d00", "input": "claim: Historical Artefacts Should Be Repatriated to Their Country of Origin.\n perspective: Artifacts are best viewed where they came from.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-fef17e7406ed48519e870772b427d2b8", "input": "claim: Historical Artefacts Should Be Repatriated to Their Country of Origin.\n perspective: Viewing an artifact in its native area is beneficial to its perception.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a18b17ed94224ee1b21749ef618bc195", "input": "claim: Historical Artefacts Should Be Repatriated to Their Country of Origin.\n perspective: Having artefacts in different locations encourages us to think of our common origins", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-2355650067d1483d8f1cc923c6b8d9f7", "input": "claim: Historical Artefacts Should Be Repatriated to Their Country of Origin.\n perspective: Artefacts should be repatriated....including the people which were stolen and scattered world wide!", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f0911b5e56a24da79678b8ccd7c6a5ab", "input": "claim: Historical Artefacts Should Be Repatriated to Their Country of Origin.\n perspective: These artefacts should bring revenue to the counties of origin", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-01ea6756a2ca47eda8fe477c77c101ac", "input": "claim: Historical Artefacts Should Be Repatriated to Their Country of Origin.\n perspective: Artefacts should be accessible to the largest amount of visitors possible ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-71453272867844dca3b796d149fbc5ec", "input": "claim: Historical Artefacts Should Be Repatriated to Their Country of Origin.\n perspective: The historical significance of artefacts extends beyond their culture of origin", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-0c9ad1a373c8449fb5b3e82fee821801", "input": "claim: Historical Artefacts Should Be Repatriated to Their Country of Origin.\n perspective: Scholars will have better access to artefacts, and more opportunities for study and collaboration, if they are stored in the west", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e36b88e1d1204fb09ff78a9aed7a2e89", "input": "claim: Historical Artefacts Should Be Repatriated to Their Country of Origin.\n perspective: Artifacts should be kept where they are safest so that everyone has access to them. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-f55523e549554ba3b6c7e409279720b2", "input": "claim: Historical Artefacts Should Be Repatriated to Their Country of Origin.\n perspective: Many countries do not have the means to protect precious artifacts so they should remain in the West where they are safe. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-cf4ef0bcd7374cd59d3fb2118de9b2ca", "input": "claim: Historical Artefacts Should Be Repatriated to Their Country of Origin.\n perspective: Artefacts should be made accessible to the largest possible number of visitors", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-7896f3dc1a0f4eb88f128dba409aab4e", "input": "claim: Historical Artefacts Should Be Repatriated to Their Country of Origin.\n perspective: In many cases, returning an artefact may prove to be unreasonably expensive", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-8db69ef47c364057af0f6282aab81762", "input": "claim: Historical Artefacts Should Be Repatriated to Their Country of Origin.\n perspective: The West should not have to spend enormous sums of money to return artifacts to their original locations.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-341b035d931c4ee0949c13c3073ae8da", "input": "claim: History as a subject in school is needed.\n perspective: History offers knowledge that coincides with other subjects", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-792a90b83d364df881a9400b3bcc5ea9", "input": "claim: History as a subject in school is needed.\n perspective: History is something that people need to know. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d64f284dc4b145b29f65df8bf06bca6e", "input": "claim: History as a subject in school is needed.\n perspective: history is an important subject", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-533613b74e414897a7bc2b1a50f02167", "input": "claim: History as a subject in school is needed.\n perspective: history repeats itself if not known", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-7568665930f3430abb6c2ea2316c04f9", "input": "claim: History as a subject in school is needed.\n perspective: where we have been can help us with where we are going", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-3764fd068041466dbfbcc7a7b224107d", "input": "claim: History as a subject in school is needed.\n perspective: Teaching history ensures that events of the past are not forgotten, and lessons are learned", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-07907984abe34620852f8df7412cd2fa", "input": "claim: History as a subject in school is needed.\n perspective: We learn from the mistakes and successes of others", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-aeb68ac133224302957c52b333cc601d", "input": "claim: History as a subject in school is needed.\n perspective: History lessons can be used as state-sponsored propaganda, distorting the events of the past", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-254d71c362cb4fd898e28fae9abdb8c5", "input": "claim: History as a subject in school is needed.\n perspective: History teaching will reflect the erroneous preconceptions and aims of those who set the curriculum", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-7377c7e12ecd4a12b34a5423e4f1a723", "input": "claim: History as a subject in school is needed.\n perspective: History should be taught to school-children, they form an integral part of understanding oneself and one's nation", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ce549c2d4c5649d9b6a45d4026ebbe3a", "input": "claim: History as a subject in school is needed.\n perspective: History should always have a place in the schoolroom because it is vital to an understanding of why things are the way they are. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ae6a240584694bcea307f94f4e79b600", "input": "claim: History as a subject in school is needed.\n perspective: To understand how things came to be, school children should be taught historical facts and figures. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c0de7086da1b4cdf88f676afc7cc7a63", "input": "claim: History as a subject in school is needed.\n perspective: Schoolchildren need to learn history since it is an integral part of learning about one's country.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-b45a40949d914029b2b7df7c72a5d445", "input": "claim: History as a subject in school is needed.\n perspective: History teaches useful skills applicable in other areas of education and life", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-24f4bb4a2d164986891c63ae3205f755", "input": "claim: History as a subject in school is needed.\n perspective: Without a firm foundation of historical knowledge, children will have a harder time learning necessary skills. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-35da8016a4a642368486c356e2e9d6c2", "input": "claim: History as a subject in school is needed.\n perspective: A good education relies on a strong foundation of historical knowledge.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-dc4b16db423d4c69a2f6b0a92598eb8f", "input": "claim: History as a subject in school is needed.\n perspective: History is a useful subject because it teaches useful skills.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-6c5729ccf3134ef8aa0daccf786564b9", "input": "claim: History as a subject in school is needed.\n perspective: It's a good idea to teach history since kids can learn useful skills they can use throughout their lives.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d44148fc8c93400d86686b886d22c76f", "input": "claim: History as a subject in school is needed.\n perspective: Historical facts can be established to a sufficient degree to be taught to schoolchildren", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-bdd7ab14f2cb41a4a4b92b840dc92c3e", "input": "claim: History as a subject in school is needed.\n perspective: Schools should teach historical facts. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f1f6524aa338465d984c8edc2845f937", "input": "claim: History as a subject in school is needed.\n perspective: Children need to learn historical facts in order to be competitive in a global job market.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-efee767f5b7c41a6864a867e28ea8105", "input": "claim: History as a subject in school is needed.\n perspective: If taught properly, historical facts can be taught to schoolchildren without problems.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ec0b0defaa6048a59198ff8dc539bd3a", "input": "claim: History as a subject in school is needed.\n perspective: History is a good thing to teach to schoolchildren if taught the right way,", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c02a094437d94fa9b3ad8d1d1c40968c", "input": "claim: Newspapers Are a Thing of the Past.\n perspective: Newspapers wont die, they’ll adapt", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-f4633bafb5024b8ab50e21b66d321acd", "input": "claim: Newspapers Are a Thing of the Past.\n perspective: Newspapers will evolve with the times and remain relevant. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-6b1d28c7ab5541d6bb408e306f766dc5", "input": "claim: Newspapers Are a Thing of the Past.\n perspective: Newspapers will adapt to the modern world. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-599558a59f5e479aa75e1f930624c7f1", "input": "claim: Newspapers Are a Thing of the Past.\n perspective: newspapers are more versatile", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-f99176887e964f0db182e7f39604f41e", "input": "claim: Newspapers Are a Thing of the Past.\n perspective: newspapers are more convenient", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ee6d111dbf6b4c0aaa8db72b1ec4f317", "input": "claim: Newspapers Are a Thing of the Past.\n perspective: Newspapers are much more convenient than the alternatives. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-39dfb6eaf9414755a9c8ecff4248bc44", "input": "claim: Newspapers Are a Thing of the Past.\n perspective: A tangible newspaper is more convenient than other alternatives. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-652ab1a7f68948f781ec6540d1006eb5", "input": "claim: Newspapers Are a Thing of the Past.\n perspective: Newspapers are a more trustworthy source of information than independent bloggers", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-671e2b41023545f786284605ade11c00", "input": "claim: Newspapers Are a Thing of the Past.\n perspective: Independent bloggers lack the credibility of newspapers.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-95da49155a724aa3a0fc084914442c81", "input": "claim: Newspapers Are a Thing of the Past.\n perspective: Newspapers are more credible than independent blogger reports.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c2272ac5fa4b4c698dcbb36df33b8aee", "input": "claim: Newspapers Are a Thing of the Past.\n perspective: Newspapers offer a better reading experience than digital alternatives", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-deab5340ab834cdb964e5b158de19719", "input": "claim: Newspapers Are a Thing of the Past.\n perspective: Newspapers are financially unviable", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-0d66320fae704aff86ab35195eb81c23", "input": "claim: Newspapers Are a Thing of the Past.\n perspective: Newspapers provide higher quality journalism than other media", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-46859da02e3e448fbda14533867cc790", "input": "claim: Newspapers Are a Thing of the Past.\n perspective: Newspapers employ credentialled reporters.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-d32331c19b764acb9e195720f6801dcd", "input": "claim: Newspapers Are a Thing of the Past.\n perspective: Newspapers have a reputation to uphold.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-bbcfea94c4a44e509011d8754188a151", "input": "claim: Newspapers Are a Thing of the Past.\n perspective: People no longer consume media in a linear way, people prefer to pick and choose what news they consume", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-130945deaa3a4d0dae1a03138e3b19a7", "input": "claim: Newspapers Are a Thing of the Past.\n perspective: Newspapers cannot be environmentally sustained.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-dcb2aa100b5a4833889ebb2da58a0f1d", "input": "claim: Newspapers Are a Thing of the Past.\n perspective: Newspapers are over-consumers of paper products which results in loss of woodland habitats.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-373f08d091024582b6e73ec467d8b52a", "input": "claim: Newspapers Are a Thing of the Past.\n perspective: Newspapers use valuable resources in production whereby the internet does not.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-2f81bb875f2b48a9ba702f735660c1a3", "input": "claim: Newspapers Are a Thing of the Past.\n perspective: In the internet age immediacy is everything, newspapers can often contain out of date information by the time they hit the shelves.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-6dc12d62723d4b04a6be21d8a00b58a9", "input": "claim: Newspapers Are a Thing of the Past.\n perspective: Newspapers are too slow to keep up with the flow of news.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-16989903c68b4945b8dd53d006f6d715", "input": "claim: Newspapers Are a Thing of the Past.\n perspective: Immediately the internet picks up news and the newspaper has to wait for the next publication to report it.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f272b4c994bc416cbc7ca219a486ca0e", "input": "claim: Newspapers Are a Thing of the Past.\n perspective: The balance of analysis and relevancy is better struck by newspapers", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-3f92fdfc996c44969bb73e688c89f682", "input": "claim: Developing nations should place restrictions on rural-urban migration.\n perspective: The government has a right to make decisions in the best interest of the people", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-04b2026f85e0430b9cc6bc596b74237e", "input": "claim: Developing nations should place restrictions on rural-urban migration.\n perspective: It is government's responsibility to work for the betterment of the people", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-51cc33a0163e42d9b947f6043aa8960b", "input": "claim: Developing nations should place restrictions on rural-urban migration.\n perspective: The government must make decisions about what is best for the people", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-77b3e52ed3384a0f87a6c5a80c2d5b65", "input": "claim: Developing nations should place restrictions on rural-urban migration.\n perspective: The movement of people cannot practically be controlled", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-5f6cdceabc174073a0645d5b50f280ac", "input": "claim: Developing nations should place restrictions on rural-urban migration.\n perspective: Rural life is miserable and has higher mortality rates than cities", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-df734e24a2434e1195456c0827e1fc8f", "input": "claim: Developing nations should place restrictions on rural-urban migration.\n perspective: Despite increased mortality and a depressing lifestyle, rural-urban migration must be controlled to prevent rapid urbanisation and disruption of the economy", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-256a19de6f3e4667bc55131ef5f624cb", "input": "claim: Developing nations should place restrictions on rural-urban migration.\n perspective: Restrictions on migration would benefit people in the cities economically and socially", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-88b1befa761f45f7b774b9ce8ee3e5c3", "input": "claim: Developing nations should place restrictions on rural-urban migration.\n perspective: City-dwellers are best off economically and socially when emigration to cities is restricted", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-471e14bd805c4945bed6a7cf94a291fb", "input": "claim: Developing nations should place restrictions on rural-urban migration.\n perspective: Restrictions cause an incredible loss of potential", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-6b5183208a5546849f7733d982f88ae4", "input": "claim: Developing nations should place restrictions on rural-urban migration.\n perspective: The governments of developing nations want to impose restrictions to control rural-urban migration, but these restrictions can shut out significant potential for improved quality of life for many rural citizens living in poverty", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a2b76f7fbec545ae9104eb2437d7b67e", "input": "claim: Developing nations should place restrictions on rural-urban migration.\n perspective: If developing nations place restrictions on rural-urban migration, the potential for poor rural citizens to improve their quality of life will be lost in these regulations. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-94f2b80c195849a899d17bdadd926f5a", "input": "claim: Jerusalem should be divided.\n perspective: International law supports dividing Jerusalem", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-fed26355ceb24282b53533d513ab9521", "input": "claim: Jerusalem should be divided.\n perspective: Dividing Jerusalem would harm Israeli society: ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-bdadee084843412d9df9cc2e7ecec06f", "input": "claim: Jerusalem should be divided.\n perspective: Division would do more harm than good.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a6849dc0121844a498dfaecbe9760a0c", "input": "claim: Jerusalem should be divided.\n perspective: Unfavorable societal outcomes from division mean that it is not worth it.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-dd9586a53cc9462fbce33c482db32b23", "input": "claim: Should the United States increase the foreign aid budget?.\n perspective: Foreign aid benefits the United States", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-0c2637023a1e4076981f618ece8aef5b", "input": "claim: Should the United States increase the foreign aid budget?.\n perspective: The United States has much to gain from giving Foreign Aid.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c027ce398e8e42d480640e25f09243ab", "input": "claim: Should the United States increase the foreign aid budget?.\n perspective: Foreign aid is something that benefits the United States if it engages in it.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-09dee7cc0c2a49109f974a075e8f10a0", "input": "claim: Should the United States increase the foreign aid budget?.\n perspective: Aid benefits National Security", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-78a539ffdb7e43999e3a98e76741bca6", "input": "claim: Should the United States increase the foreign aid budget?.\n perspective: One of the benefits of Foreign Aid is that it also improves National Security.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-69e2e1c83e1f4e8bb66b5da71206ffb3", "input": "claim: Should the United States increase the foreign aid budget?.\n perspective: To improve National Security, the US should engage more often in Foreign Aid.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a6c8b56fa6d6402ba3a089ea907c320b", "input": "claim: Should the United States increase the foreign aid budget?.\n perspective: Violation of Sovereignty ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-f9974b457a3b47e28be3b42aaad2da71", "input": "claim: Should the United States increase the foreign aid budget?.\n perspective: Aiding foreign journalists in the evasion of censorship is a violation of sovereignty.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-3fa1f8e611dc496bb776945a27055a8f", "input": "claim: Should the United States increase the foreign aid budget?.\n perspective: Concealing online activities undermines a sovereign government.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-2503af0b78ec47df9b76edba87980b0d", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: Social media can lead to stress and offline relationship problems.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-75c738674c9b40c0b071f5aa07b0d0c8", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: Social media sites often lead to relationship problems and other stress in real life.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4d838905b47444bb89eae147dca4664c", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: Social media has been linked to stress and problems in personal relationships in the real world.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-2d32e1c5841c467d950734538cab4f80", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: \"Crowdsourcing\" and \"crowdfunding\" on social media allows people to collectively accomplish a goal.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-cd34ba4d03ab415d86204ee5fc6e8040", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: People can come together to accomplish a goal through \"crowdsourcing\" and \"crowdfunding\" on social media websites.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-808610401827423e958365f7c087dab0", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: \"Crowdsourcing\" and \"crowdfunding\" via social media, allows people to assist in a worthy cause.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f4387a2b6e994ca9a978613d02218531", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: Much time can be wasted on social networking sites.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-cb43b9c4a684412ab4acc123126a9719", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: Social networking sites are a massive time drain.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4a1e1247357c41e9bef174ff798d2451", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: Social media can entice people to waste time.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-7dfd2c4ca7794f83a7e57306fd2a18d1", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: Social media tends to have people getting too immersed in it.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-67738c6c39fd4459ae6d3a528b66924b", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: Employees should not waste time on social networking sites. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-2b1005c4ce8c40d189bfabc402a5b542", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: Using social networking sites at workplaces wastes valuable amount of work-time. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-5abe9e3725ae4b5fabfda5653d822029", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: Soicial Networking Sites are a Time-Waster", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-0369a1e09e6e4dca8f077e63c417759c", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: Using social media can harm students' chances for college admission.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-71fc6f5924a74a42a4378f7dd960c4dd", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: Social media use can harm students' chances to be admitted to colleges", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ba194af4df7b404fa35b8eae4dd8be48", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: Social media can damage students' chances of admission to colleges", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-347189bc00244617a7822fca14624d05", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: Social media allows for quick, easy dissemination of public health and safety information from reputable sources.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-dc9a0e63e67643769e29d060f40129f0", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: Health and safety officers can quickly and easily provide important information to the public when needed.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-896363b51da34a8abe6b5eabeab05bfa", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: The public has a reliable source of essential public health and safety information through their social media accounts.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-8346df28fc0e4d91963427e73432b0df", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: Children may endanger themselves by not understanding the public and viral nature of social media.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-137c78e0b5154f069fbf1bb0fb46bfd0", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: There are many people who are endangering their future with social media.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-9701f2c1d7584d0fbaab93423de93d87", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: Social media sites help students do better at school.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-dfd5de3140924e6d99328bbb8e2dded3", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: Using social media can improve students grades", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-334f50b226ed44f1b47e92684abaf29c", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: students grades have gone up from social media", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-6eb06be42d914ea6b0c9aafcdaa845cf", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: Students do better using social media sites.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-711b255fe8ff4f9eb673458c432a3205", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: Social media offers students a chance to do better in school.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d6aa18cba1f4463d9de5405174ae78c4", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: Social media spreads information faster than any other media.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-415e7c7e487c41d996872822636ff310", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: Social media allows people to improve their relationships and make new friends.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-790cc59b17274d56b259900b8a1442ce", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: social media help people find friends", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-3ff342789bfa45b0bc874ced4b92859c", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: people who may not have many friends can use social media to get more", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-aab432d573f449838e0832d2f96e6e24", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: People can improve relationships and make new friends with social media.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-5681b39b6f6d4859aba0be45c0d7de96", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: Making new friends and improving relationships is a perk of social media.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-2c7635aa890f4a45b67d1c22208c1901", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: Social media sites' advertising practices may constitute an invasion of privacy.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-d43fe4b11cef4d4abc31ff99216d4130", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: Social media sites' advertising practices might invade peoples' privacy.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-3d8f651419f3465fb1771e3ea6bbc572", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: Social media sites can have advertising practices that are an invasion to privacy.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-abd69b5b657b43c39f1a1751197db6d5", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: Social media helps empower business women.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d24d213f13444d7a8861fc25d32687f3", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: business women can improve their life by social media", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-2e1ad48f1aec474ca6cbe52c930895d6", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: Business women are empowered through social media.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-5eacdbc96e1c4cb58b81fd8e10322949", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: Social media allows business women to flourish.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-98b0e1a7bcff403eade8df214c25b376", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: Social media can endanger the military, journalists, and activists.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4cb3a238a95a43c19fd746bfb8f3facb", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: Social media can bring harm to groups such as the military, journalists and activists.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-007e0ea3c9c14f01ab82c2f91d48638d", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: There is a danger that social media can bring to the military, journalists and activists.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-fac165f557cc4ce1bf5882101c72bdfe", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: Social media can facilitate inappropriate student-teacher relationships.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a2ccb152672b4f86b786f2c78b5faa06", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: Social media can cause inappropriate student-teacher relations.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c0a702a9277e4c648f3dda853c20ece3", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: Social media can start inappropriate student-teacher problems.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-d0a0667531b445229fb3d0a19ccf3816", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: Social media sites help employers find employees and job-seekers find work.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-740503da81ee4615b72d6264f3ba595c", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: When looking for a job social media can help", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-cb3bd5af04dd496f96c07fdc2538a7c1", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: employers can search social media for new empolyees", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e37ecedaa1674c87a1306a741c4ea004", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: Job-seekers may find work with social media sites.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-801c42e91a464e01b617e28df860fd15", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: Social media helps job-seekers connect with employers", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ee04b12910ec4e0495c58a74e3c03c62", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: Social media can help disarm social stigmas.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-af4bde7c9d1d4a3eb52a4430102cbfad", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: Social media can help alleviate the shunning of the socially marginalized.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-11e34df781c84e178eda58addbadae2d", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: Social media can be a tool in the fight against social discrimination.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-2117dee6c1ba4b3db74227f68435239c", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: Social media allows for rapid communication during crisis events.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-921a45e152ca4659af22cd7ed203edfd", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: Social media facilitates quick and easy contact during times of crisis.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-1a3125a9865c4991bdfc9a08d2cf7a05", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: Social media is useful in times of emergencies as it enables instant contact.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c454784d5bb645e9988900142f084f6b", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: Unauthorized sharing on social media exposes artists to copyright infringement, loss of intellectual property, and loss of income.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-36d3474fcbf8419d8568f2315416600c", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: Sharing on social media without permission can expose artists to copyright infringement, loss of intellectual property, and income loss", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-1875b4faf4464e65b5a474de09068f47", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: Unauthorized sharing on social media sites can lead to artists being infringed on their copyrights, loss of intellectual property, and income loss", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-87093687f8b342e994408e4f67aee854", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: Social media helps people who are socially isolated or shy connect with other people.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e1e09c153edc4e32b1c3f0563b38f632", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: Those who are more shy and introverted can connect with others through social media.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e821608631f6409b9520e125cd899060", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: A bashful individual can fulfill his or her social needs through social media.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-853628395e504adfa2ff862c8ef3289a", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: Social media increases voter participation.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-6422541622a84c75b4ec94066187429f", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: Getting the word out about how to vote on social media gives more people the chance to participate. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-8a40ae5a2349480aa841d91d7fa1eb65", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: Social media helped to motivate people to get out and vote. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a65f683e4aa84ac5ae3040e181eb169a", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: Social media is good for the economy.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-34732861433744bd9c1a6f6c192a4ee0", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: If you need a local part-time job than post it to social media. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-6545a94bed9d49ecb400fb8a588d9f38", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: Social media helps small businesses find talented workers. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-8d98d9cafe394acf98aa9d0199a6d169", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: Social media offers teachers a platform for collaboration with other teachers and communication with students outside the classroom.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e9700d7aedb24ac8b29c8273f80e234f", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: Teachers are able to collaborate with one another using social media.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-36b1e79d0c684dc39d1c91a20ce9b87e", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: Social media harms employees' productivity.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-55d1917ab7ec45ebae56f8fd4572910b", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: Employees are constantly losing their focus due to social media.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-1cd93478316c43dbbfedab20b3473729", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: Social media posts cannot be completely deleted and all information posted can have unintended consequences.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-54679e1910ff4978af092a4a1fd42e71", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: Social media posts can't be deleted permanently and the information that is posted can have unintended consequences.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-f3b03a2c612240c2817f00f01cede92c", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: Social media posts are not able to be completely deleted and all the information that was posted can have unintended consequences.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-2d7c5772545c4cacb623814e9d6bc634", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: It is easy to act in an inappropriate manner with electronic communications.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c61e360010f248ff9594a937185a323f", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: Electronic communication facilitates sexual misconduct. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-1e5d27d20322477d8a5349971fa8675c", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: Social media enables \"sexting,\" which can lead to criminal charges and the unexpected proliferation of personal images.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-d8351ca4f5ff4d08b2ae7c2925ed7a18", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: Many young people talk sexually through social media.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b82337affc0b4c1cbc6a88a8fc9cf06a", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: If you are not careful, sexting can be a start of criminal activity.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-afe5ead3609c464f9542ad04106c1bb6", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: Social media helps senior citizens feel more connected to society.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-2bc44295b4414c62a262271daf801376", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: The elderly do not feel alienated from society when they are on social media.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-2b710c5904464dc490448224547502f2", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: Being active on social media, helps seniors feel more involved in society at large.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-0c0da74403c245fa86d07b7235442675", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: Social media lacks privacy and exposes users to government and corporate intrusions.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-908cad20b0f7417fa57c59c8ad76fbc7", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: A potential drawback of social media on societies is that it opens users up to privacy invasions by government and private entities.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-5eef8411316947aab81c95b208833bf0", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: Social media enables government and business interests to invade the privacy of its users.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-1e1af5b64b8b4414882e47a93ec43c96", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: Social media enables the spread of unreliable and false information.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-070f0792cac54cf18b7eacd0efedc533", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: Social media allows for the rapid dissemination of untrue data.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b9ca34c8ff684b0ebbbb746e786e64f9", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: One drawback of social media is that it quickly facilitates the spread of rumors and falsities. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-9fdde3ff08de4973b42aa37eb94d9f57", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: Social media causes people to spend less time interacting face-to-face.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e1949949a6ab4a028969c1949115b877", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: When people use social media they tend to reduce their personal face-to-face time with others.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4022c46b956b4060b3124d3ff51a233e", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: Using social media takes time away from real, in-person interaction.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-7e1a3a9971194257984eec2a7b61daa6", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: Social media offers a way for musicians and artists to build audiences even if they don't have a corporate contract.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e2d99466515e4cca93b1169b65a418db", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: Those in the arts can increase their audience using social media.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-15af55d93f9c43dc8db05e96246f9e07", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: More educational resources can be made available through social media.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-fd34d011e61e410088797cdc3c7a1403", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: Social media provides academic research to a wider audience, allowing many people access to previously unavailable educational resources.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ed490fcf43894bcbb11326b8a905a471", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: Social media can be powerful educational resources. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f9c138a1ebab4d50ba4979bb9d314402", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: Social medica can act as an educational tool.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-3fb6c62ed11c449988604c4ccd4dff18", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: Social media facilitates cyberbullying.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-8e0f667d13e645348b0442abbefa269b", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: Many people use social media to bully people.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-924a48e42e0448a3882605476bd56911", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: Social media enables people to bully others online.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-5e9dff85402d4129a94c87a4d46aa83f", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: Being a part of a social media site can increase a person's quality of life and reduce the risk of health problems.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-921834b3af8144b8acdb90760b730a92", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: Social media can help a person connect with people to alleviate depression. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-0a3cbfdff4bd4dabb0e63678e87133e7", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: Social media is good for people who want to interact, but have social anxiety in person. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-8793218528aa44e6b71464706bd48b7b", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: Students who are heavy social media users tend to have lower grades.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-f3d7fe13488c412b82b714eb24c93a38", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: Among students, heavy social media usage is correlated with lower grades. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e39b04f842374f6099feb4278b4c45c5", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: Social media allows people from around the USA to gather together to discuss political ideas and make change. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e3287e4e41f74080a5323c31f9ba6ba6", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: Social media sites empower individuals to make social change and do social good on a community level.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-9dba3648c30b4736804bbbf8ebdc1490", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: Social media sites have helped people raise money for medical procedures. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-78d17ccb98a6488a9d98e28bd148c19b", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: The use of social media is correlated with personality and brain disorders.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-d8802e9f2ca84c4a84c254aac90e5636", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: There are some personality and brain disorders that appear to connect to social media usage.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ba48c19386a0477a9cf310a704686abd", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: Corporations and small businesses use social media to benefit themselves and consumers.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-fc13a241ff254d849a06d788ce13cd92", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: Social media is beneficial to corporations and businesses.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-42c40059a9ce41fbb1bfd20f0aeefb37", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: Colleges and universities use social media to recruit and retain students.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-9d14cb7ea8c749ab83dd96dd29cd227f", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: Students can be recruited to universities through social media.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-13a84508a1a840c8a865d4a2df0a7d1d", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: Social media is often used by higher education to find new students.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f32d11f612bf4e28a04f82ebc175fa73", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: Law enforcement uses social media to catch and prosecute criminals.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-fa5493becd20488aa8f85aba76d5f131", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: Social media can help prosecute criminals", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-34c03449a72c47fe93c2ed197a7ade39", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: Social media allows law enforcement to catch and prosecute criminals.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-b364ec858f4943ef8afa755318d7d8eb", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: Criminals can be caught using social media.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-b3831fb0eb7a4b7c9f1f9007046dd72c", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: Social media aids the spread of hate groups.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-eb250a59405a4500b76c756b0553f1b9", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: Hate groups use social media to get their message out there.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-cd21afd2557440328da489cc9ea8ca93", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: Many individuals report to have seen some groups of hate using social media.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-414e106e67c74cc69cbe346d294c55bd", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: Criminals use social media to commit and promote crimes.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-5c3e7290733442f39719986e12cf8395", "input": "claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.\n perspective: Criminals can use social media to commit crimes.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-7e72d88191c64b6fae65ff50092e9ed8", "input": "claim: School Uniforms Should Be Mandatory.\n perspective: Students can express their individuality in school uniforms by introducing variations and adding accessories.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-6d28fe126efe4027b6c198260e18535d", "input": "claim: School Uniforms Should Be Mandatory.\n perspective: School uniforms restrict students' freedom of expression.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c1b4ad0e830f45c2a17e36ecfb7b5b1c", "input": "claim: School Uniforms Should Be Mandatory.\n perspective: Personality and Expressing yourself", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-9b4ddae935674bf9b380d4a349d8d1ac", "input": "claim: School Uniforms Should Be Mandatory.\n perspective: School uniforms promote conformity over individuality.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-f7a68a8a66444e228fa6fb9ba3b4623b", "input": "claim: School Uniforms Should Be Mandatory.\n perspective: Creates a sense of equality", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-b3a08054542c4c0f8e8543dabf27eafc", "input": "claim: School Uniforms Should Be Mandatory.\n perspective: Wearing uniforms enhances school pride, unity, and community spirit.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-9dfdcc65e7334a9db08d4428d7ea5907", "input": "claim: School Uniforms Should Be Mandatory.\n perspective: It contributes to the sense of school's unity", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a6b53ef3acc24dc18e443d67b226b60c", "input": "claim: School Uniforms Should Be Mandatory.\n perspective: Uniforms make everyone appear equal since there is no variation in clothing styles, costs, etc.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-b91e9836beb7408280fed2a4b86288e3", "input": "claim: School Uniforms Should Be Mandatory.\n perspective: makes a sense of equality", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-771b9c924edc43e1be988864713dbbb6", "input": "claim: School Uniforms Should Be Mandatory.\n perspective: School uniforms keep students focused on their education, not their clothes.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d07343a5f2e94715959e3ae37a361f22", "input": "claim: School Uniforms Should Be Mandatory.\n perspective: School uniforms emphasize the socio-economic divisions they are supposed to eliminate. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-1efb5644081c408d83b67f7655610b34", "input": "claim: School Uniforms Should Be Mandatory.\n perspective: School uniforms make getting ready for school easier, which can improve punctuality.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-2bfd14796c25454a97baabf91615a487", "input": "claim: School Uniforms Should Be Mandatory.\n perspective: School uniforms may improve attendance and discipline.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-8e92356f93d34989b94f468522f041e0", "input": "claim: School Uniforms Should Be Mandatory.\n perspective: Students oppose school uniforms.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-18f760fe25144181abb3e484d7dae1cf", "input": "claim: School Uniforms Should Be Mandatory.\n perspective: Students stand against school uniforms.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b0a287439f70423181c5a8c1d3f1aa78", "input": "claim: School Uniforms Should Be Mandatory.\n perspective: Students don't want school uniforms.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-9b75e477de7c4547b21cefb19d245865", "input": "claim: School Uniforms Should Be Mandatory.\n perspective: School uniforms may delay the transition into adulthood.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-7b4083d7716c4342a3649d54bf108bd9", "input": "claim: School Uniforms Should Be Mandatory.\n perspective: Parents should be free to choose their children's clothes without government interference.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-92b113e10bde43e29d07b3165e9a823c", "input": "claim: School Uniforms Should Be Mandatory.\n perspective: Parents have a right to dress their children.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-89b8753a53114c6992d270a22b1312bd", "input": "claim: School Uniforms Should Be Mandatory.\n perspective: The government shouldn't dictate children's clothing to parents.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-78c91762976345e48470af2b16e67d2a", "input": "claim: School Uniforms Should Be Mandatory.\n perspective: Focusing on uniforms takes attention away from finding genuine solutions to problems in education. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-6edf6b6be2ec418abc531b7af5b6b009", "input": "claim: School Uniforms Should Be Mandatory.\n perspective: Most parents and educators support mandatory school uniforms.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ad88c8240bef408cb2a5a5e912d45cdc", "input": "claim: School Uniforms Should Be Mandatory.\n perspective: The push for school uniforms is driven by commercial interests rather than educational ones.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-3fe0cbefc436420eba9cc84318c232be", "input": "claim: School Uniforms Should Be Mandatory.\n perspective: School uniforms can save parents money.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d450dfd37acb482d85fc95cf23c3b4fd", "input": "claim: School Uniforms Should Be Mandatory.\n perspective: Uniforms make it easier for parents to afford clothes for their kids.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-34b3bbaf2c7848a7a71faedcf6d09965", "input": "claim: School Uniforms Should Be Mandatory.\n perspective: Uniform policies save valuable class time because they are easier to enforce than a standard dress code.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-2dcbf631008041a8ad550a4bf69bacfa", "input": "claim: School Uniforms Should Be Mandatory.\n perspective: Time can be better devoted to class and teaching when uniforms are implemented because it avoids dress code issues.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-90f4684dfb7c4a2a951b9bba43db6353", "input": "claim: School Uniforms Should Be Mandatory.\n perspective: Uniforms may have a detrimental effect on students' self-image.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-d352d823aba040c7a6bffea484010f8c", "input": "claim: School Uniforms Should Be Mandatory.\n perspective: School uniforms in public schools undermine the promise of a free education by imposing an extra expense on families.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-d86f28a653c0469c9405eb1f834039c2", "input": "claim: School Uniforms Should Be Mandatory.\n perspective: School uniforms undermine access to education by imposing expenses.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a4b15e4cb38643cd8334aab9af6e58b5", "input": "claim: School Uniforms Should Be Mandatory.\n perspective: School uniforms create a level playing field among students, reducing peer pressure and bullying.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e71b9ba409b54f48b3c06477328f2fd3", "input": "claim: School Uniforms Should Be Mandatory.\n perspective: School uniforms do not stop bullying and may increase violent attacks.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b8d56e49e85c4859af4caaf1c2b05416", "input": "claim: School Uniforms Should Be Mandatory.\n perspective: The key findings used to tout the benefits of uniforms are questionable.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-8da823563e954e9eb2642a47783fcaf0", "input": "claim: School Uniforms Should Be Mandatory.\n perspective: Students dressed in uniform are better perceived by teachers and peers.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-4588c654623a4ee196eca1ffb5731fbe", "input": "claim: School Uniforms Should Be Mandatory.\n perspective: Students are more respected when they wear uniforms.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-6128c1d453ab4209b6c81f43f737a807", "input": "claim: School Uniforms Should Be Mandatory.\n perspective: Students' legal right to free expression remains intact even with mandatory school uniforms.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-7509f1f2ff63457c9ec59347bc4ffc04", "input": "claim: School Uniforms Should Be Mandatory.\n perspective: Student's rights are not violated when wearing uniforms.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-dbbc6a8519c346ff84fe61a42bf51ee7", "input": "claim: School Uniforms Should Be Mandatory.\n perspective: School uniforms may deter crime and increase student safety.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-cf505311c4064a1ba2653a52811733ce", "input": "claim: School Uniforms Should Be Mandatory.\n perspective: School uniforms prevent the display of gang colors and insignia. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ecc41cb4e00345a8ba0df1551878911e", "input": "claim: School Uniforms Should Be Mandatory.\n perspective: School uniforms do not improve attendance, academic preparedness, or exam results.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-3ba27d984c6b4219afe368995f08b52e", "input": "claim: We must have a criminal DNA database.\n perspective: DNA testing is fallible, and therefore should not be used as the basis of convictions", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c8b24c0dba6c4d2bbc79e29a5433c02d", "input": "claim: We must have a criminal DNA database.\n perspective: DNA testing isn't 100% accurate, so it shouldn't be used to convict people.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-6d09340a271245dd83f42498912e9900", "input": "claim: We must have a criminal DNA database.\n perspective: People shouldn't be convicted based on DNA evidence because it's not always accurate.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-bf41645fb8a94cd18793849a3f76348c", "input": "claim: We must have a criminal DNA database.\n perspective: DNA evidence would reduce the risk of wrongful conviction", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c6088977f4934fbabc075e8f9162aa87", "input": "claim: We must have a criminal DNA database.\n perspective: Wrongful convictions can be reduced through DNA evidence.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-11ba62778a294f1787d63f346a820d31", "input": "claim: We must have a criminal DNA database.\n perspective: DNA evidence can lower the chance that a wrongful conviction happens.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d713ea5155f64d508489ebaeb4b74ed1", "input": "claim: We must have a criminal DNA database.\n perspective: A DNA database would reduce the time spent tracking down suspects", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-58fb6ab97ee841e2b3ebe954898d20c7", "input": "claim: We must have a criminal DNA database.\n perspective: Time spent tracking down suspects can be reduced with a database of DNA.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e34b1cf573874fa1a40cdde9f0546aad", "input": "claim: We must have a criminal DNA database.\n perspective: Creating a database for DNA can help expedite the process of tracking down suspects.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a64fa76514374b009e1d28ae2a49c954", "input": "claim: Advertising is harmful.\n perspective: Advertising helps us choose between different goods.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-5ee273309f6343138e285fd028681730", "input": "claim: Advertising is harmful.\n perspective: Advertisements try to make people feel bad about not having the product", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d216534e344645f28b0e5bb22901535b", "input": "claim: Advertising is harmful.\n perspective: Advertising reduces consumers self-esteem.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-4115602fc9d04148a1e5a715da417309", "input": "claim: Advertising is harmful.\n perspective: Advertisements are an attempt to brainwash customers.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-15807ede70cf42519255c062e8de0055", "input": "claim: Advertising is harmful.\n perspective: Ads can sway customers uneccassarily one way or the other.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-1aeae5aeabcf4d6887a380064147b7e7", "input": "claim: Advertising is harmful.\n perspective: Ads can be immoral and need to be limited.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d208a4b6c331451e9cb26fd600a2ddce", "input": "claim: Advertising is harmful.\n perspective: There are too many advertisements in everyday life.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-bc770ef1dd97484186613a08da3bd945", "input": "claim: Advertising is harmful.\n perspective: There are too many ads everywhere you look.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-9543563b23554ff4a37c9f49a4e392e6", "input": "claim: Advertising is harmful.\n perspective: Advertisements promote healthy products and lifestyles.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-23cb4a792eaa45afbb442763e7704f69", "input": "claim: Advertising is harmful.\n perspective: Advertising is a powerful medium to communicated about healthy lifestyles.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-bf42b122fdfd4f02a397e3f354461f78", "input": "claim: Advertising is harmful.\n perspective: Advertisements tell children that they should have everything they want.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d8737ae843094c2d9c67fae3de884f3c", "input": "claim: Alternative medicine poses a threat to public health.\n perspective: Many alternative remedies, such as homeopathy, offer nothing but a false hope and can discourage patients from consulting a doctor with what may be serious symptoms", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f8ce00687b4f4f9aafdade6cf6f902a6", "input": "claim: Endangered species should be protected.\n perspective: The term \"endangered\" is inconsistently applied", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e7cd6d965c1146eaa8c5087cc06351e6", "input": "claim: Endangered species should be protected.\n perspective: Protecting endangered species protects the interests of humans", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-b37dace22e744a939f5599c9a8d401b9", "input": "claim: Endangered species should be protected.\n perspective: The interests of humans are protected when endangered species are protected.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-779a5b026de7426eba8f7fa93d8a92dc", "input": "claim: Endangered species should be protected.\n perspective: Endangered species protection also protects the interests of humans.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d7c40c2bb9ec48e7a1d339850522caab", "input": "claim: Endangered species should be protected.\n perspective: Human rights trump those of lower animals", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-9f7a51f6e4b846e9a5e05c15481c8036", "input": "claim: Endangered species should be protected.\n perspective: Human rights are more important that the rights of lower animals.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b8716d793ab846d9af9a3cb1f66b4dff", "input": "claim: Endangered species should be protected.\n perspective: The rights of lower animals are trumped by the rights of humans.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a089a655caf14477ad2452759896d80c", "input": "claim: Golf is a Sport.\n perspective: The International Olympic Committee considers golf a sport. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-939b0625433547aaafd6166769942de4", "input": "claim: Golf is a Sport.\n perspective: Golf involves competition, keeping score, and declaring a winner, but those qualities alone do not make it a sport. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-58c2e9ab616d4aa9953bf4ed13245b43", "input": "claim: Golf is a Sport.\n perspective: Golf involves many elements of competition, but that does not make it a sport.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-f802e8aa3258453394810f170f4fcb7e", "input": "claim: Golf is a Sport.\n perspective: Sports experts agree that golf lacks the athletic rigor needed to be a real sport. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-d360bf1838054179bfb1da78b69936fe", "input": "claim: Golf is a Sport.\n perspective: Experts believe golf does not require enough physical fitness to be considered a sport.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-01c56de364d94b129f002851cf35ba77", "input": "claim: Golf is a Sport.\n perspective: If you can compete in a professional tournament with a broken leg, it is not a sport. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-0a3c79c329a247efb7455b6f84e69612", "input": "claim: Golf is a Sport.\n perspective: Golf does not have the physical rigors that sports do.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-0e9d85d9f0a848e38440fab6e3574216", "input": "claim: Golf is a Sport.\n perspective: Golf is not physically demanding enough to be a sport.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-1b109153571243d08a96e15dabe56a3d", "input": "claim: Golf is a Sport.\n perspective: Even people with broken limbs can play golf, which makes it not a real sport.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-604216d0a1cc455197b90340527890ce", "input": "claim: Golf is a Sport.\n perspective: If an activity does not make you break a sweat, or if it can be done while drinking and smoking, then it is not a sport. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-3e5c1bab1f864b81994994fa996a4ef5", "input": "claim: Golf is a Sport.\n perspective: Because you can play golf without breaking a sweat, and drink and smoke while doing it, it is not a sport. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-1e2ee4c3a30a4772835cbb680e5eb918", "input": "claim: Golf is a Sport.\n perspective: Golf is not a sport because you can play it without breaking a sweat and while you are drunk. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-abe3265f03834649a492b38b90217153", "input": "claim: Golf is a Sport.\n perspective: The fact that golf can be difficult and requires practice and skill to achieve proficiency does not mean it qualifies as a sport. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ef8525b849fb41de9057c30d567e8199", "input": "claim: Golf is a Sport.\n perspective: That golf can be difficult and skills and practice are required does not qualify it as a sport. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-428a1ee583364adb9bb821f9266dceaf", "input": "claim: Golf is a Sport.\n perspective: Skill is required for a person to be proficient in golf doesn't make it a sport. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-70954be8e36d4dd4ade01caebc4fbf2e", "input": "claim: Golf is a Sport.\n perspective: The possibility of getting injured while playing golf does not make it a sport. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-3a1a9ca872a74a22a1a5f0ecd75abc8c", "input": "claim: Golf is a Sport.\n perspective: the probability of getting injured while playing golf is extremely low therefore it is not a sport.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e4f8d794a2fc4cb58265321b9dceab65", "input": "claim: Golf is a Sport.\n perspective: There should be some risk to be considered a real sport, which golf does not have.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e1cf74b3916746349b8800789c7ef5bb", "input": "claim: Golf is a Sport.\n perspective: Sports agents, sponsors, and sporting goods manufacturers consider golf to be a sport. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a813dd2347ba4c8f990b514e5e5668d7", "input": "claim: Golf is a Sport.\n perspective: The decision to include golf in the 2016 Summer Olympics is questionable. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-fcaf9bb9e9904c2b9fea3e72e298b4b1", "input": "claim: Golf is a Sport.\n perspective: Professional golfers are considered athletes by mainstream media. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-99dd90b4c9054379a7662eb49983f304", "input": "claim: Golf is a Sport.\n perspective: Athleticism does not correlate with performance when it comes to golf. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b26e62ea67c94ff9b0c5f320f463a43a", "input": "claim: Golf is a Sport.\n perspective: Even if you are really athletic does not mean you will do well at golf.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-2c5d78ce76f748d08ebe5f52472833b2", "input": "claim: Golf is a Sport.\n perspective: You do not need to be physically fit to be good at golf.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ddce5af9fa8b427a80c2a13a9b55caab", "input": "claim: Golf is a Sport.\n perspective: Golf better matches the definition of a game than a sport. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-d9b965f899874f60acb2bd2555d88ef5", "input": "claim: Golf is a Sport.\n perspective: The definition of a game is a better match to golf than the definition of a sport. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-597aefe06e744f6ba15bc4aa6636a800", "input": "claim: Golf is a Sport.\n perspective: Golf is the match to a game more than a match to a sport. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-3e695f62a3994be99cda76ca8d012af9", "input": "claim: Golf is a Sport.\n perspective: Golf meets the definition of the word \"sport\" found in many dictionaries. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-5413379692764b64bccea172d7ddc183", "input": "claim: Golf is a Sport.\n perspective: Golf is categorized as a sport according the definitions found in many dictionaries", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-02d15055be0b457686cddfe9292f53e2", "input": "claim: Golf is a Sport.\n perspective: Golf is one of dozens of independent sports like running or swimming. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d8c48abfac034a6cbd01a3b05ea042d3", "input": "claim: Golf is a Sport.\n perspective: Golf has many more commonalities with other sports. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-047f28cb35f249e6913d92a11665fc92", "input": "claim: Golf is a Sport.\n perspective: There are many commonalities between golf and other sports. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-82c79f81e9f8413099e42bc835258af0", "input": "claim: Golf is a Sport.\n perspective: Contrary to public opinion golf does have a lot more commonalities with other sports than most realize. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-569ab65ae16746a0a3b95ea2390e3ff6", "input": "claim: Golf is a Sport.\n perspective: College and university athletic departments classify golf as a sport. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-0d88f2501a184d2f9dda669915ba8683", "input": "claim: Golf is a Sport.\n perspective: Unlike a sport, golf does not require rigorous physical activity. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b840935252974c348e85a7fff63d0aad", "input": "claim: Golf is a Sport.\n perspective: You are not required to endure rigorous physical activity to play golf. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e7ba75e161b944f59f138127089dbbec", "input": "claim: Golf is a Sport.\n perspective: Golf is unlike sports in which rigorous physical activities are required. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-aa25ff5492ff44f89b03fcc0cd9b2fd4", "input": "claim: Gay marriage should be legal.\n perspective: Marriage is for procreation and should not be extended to same-sex couples because they cannot produce children together. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-367003328f9140298dc612cf4cc4312c", "input": "claim: Gay marriage should be legal.\n perspective: Legalizing gay marriage often leads to an end to domestic partnership benefits for gay and straight couples, which disadvantages couples who choose not to get married. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4a680e248e63488d822ca9cc3c9eb341", "input": "claim: Gay marriage should be legal.\n perspective: If gay couples don't get married it means they lose benefits through the legalization of gay marriage.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-f8e1723590774bf6bcbc1badfc3a8adc", "input": "claim: Gay marriage should be legal.\n perspective: Allowing gay couples to wed could further weaken the institution of marriage. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-aab6c2ea71304a2f88086ca59330c002", "input": "claim: Gay marriage should be legal.\n perspective: The institution of marriage has been weakened in recent years and allowing gay marriage will only further damage an already crumbling institution.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-511a0653f89f4bc88d5f4a6e8013e9d5", "input": "claim: Gay marriage should be legal.\n perspective: Gay marriage will not be a positive boost to the institution of marriage.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-7051637122674a3caaee3613acbf2baf", "input": "claim: Gay marriage should be legal.\n perspective: Same-sex marriage is a civil right. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d40cd2c38b31424d842ab6e8ba61e3da", "input": "claim: Gay marriage should be legal.\n perspective: Our constitution is based on the idea that all people are equal and thus getting married is a civil right. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-9dbf2eaef46b492a91ab1dd1432c9ae3", "input": "claim: Gay marriage should be legal.\n perspective: People have fought for civil rights and same sex marriage is a civil right. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-18482ca45abd4e3e8d727dc609c691c4", "input": "claim: Gay marriage should be legal.\n perspective: Denying some people the option to marry is discriminatory and creates a second class of citizens. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e7e8a39a958c44a694c5a6a19820deec", "input": "claim: Gay marriage should be legal.\n perspective: Marriage is an outmoded, oppressive institution that should be weakened, not expanded. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-6a55db3019c245399b79c4d212b0f699", "input": "claim: Gay marriage should be legal.\n perspective: Marriage is not something we should encourage or support.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-933f959ec5ba4f8bb144af0f3c8420f8", "input": "claim: Gay marriage should be legal.\n perspective: Legalizing gay marriage could lead down a \"slippery slope,\" giving people in polygamous, incestuous, bestial, and other nontraditional relationships the right to marry. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-9e7765c9d9434ae896f024cf6dc1ad69", "input": "claim: Gay marriage should be legal.\n perspective: There are many types of marriage which are innaporpoate and dangerous which may be allowed if gay marriage is legalized. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-754d5416589041ddbc32c9f62e14f592", "input": "claim: Gay marriage should be legal.\n perspective: Legalizing gay marriage is a stepping stone toward disgusting and harmful marriage practices such as incestuous, bestial and child marriages. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a45ae4329ec94fde8c8824dd7d0db8ea", "input": "claim: Gay marriage should be legal.\n perspective: Legalizing gay marriage advances the \"homosexual agenda\" and unfairly paints opponents as bigots. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-7f35a69a63494207a3b3f662bbbe18ea", "input": "claim: Gay marriage should be legal.\n perspective: Those against gay marriage are called names if gay marriage is legalized.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-d293b465e6b54c5eac021933e5481363", "input": "claim: Gay marriage should be legal.\n perspective: Legalizing marriage by gays leads to the oppression of those who are against the practice.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-bb61eb01b839431b954971229f2c12ab", "input": "claim: Gay marriage should be legal.\n perspective: Gay marriage is protected by the US Constitution's commitments to liberty and equality. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-0a82540269ba4b4d9393d3cfbc2ddcc5", "input": "claim: Gay marriage should be legal.\n perspective: The institution of marriage has traditionally been defined as being between a man and a woman. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-f1ef47f7e8ea46799f2504de520a4028", "input": "claim: Gay marriage should be legal.\n perspective: The concept of \"traditional marriage\" has changed over time, and the definition of marriage as always being between one man and one woman is historically inaccurate. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-93d64d93c92742609258ccfaee271d0a", "input": "claim: Gay marriage should be legal.\n perspective: The idea of a \"traditional marriage\" is a modern convention and has not remained static over the centuries. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-78e0e9f59277480fa1fe8d1a8f22e1ee", "input": "claim: Gay marriage should be legal.\n perspective: There is no historical basis for believing so called \"traditional marriages\" have been changeless over the centuries. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-b7f684c9ac6d44769bd6ea220d69222e", "input": "claim: Gay marriage should be legal.\n perspective: Many religious leaders and churches support gay marriage and say it is consistent with scripture. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-bd644ef05cf74cb5abd17a73c1e6f55f", "input": "claim: Gay marriage should be legal.\n perspective: There is much debate about gay marriage but many religious leaders are in support of it regardless. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e54b502847c14292afe2dcbbd0746758", "input": "claim: Gay marriage should be legal.\n perspective: Even though a vocal group of religious people disagrees with gay marriage, there is a growing number of religious leaders who support it and can back up their opinions with scripture. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-3efd3b442f1041168f26eda73cb690be", "input": "claim: Gay marriage should be legal.\n perspective: Legal marriage is a secular institution that should not be limited by religious objections to same-sex marriage. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d82eb8312d6f4dcaad5550fc7e6b9551", "input": "claim: Gay marriage should be legal.\n perspective: Religion does not have power over marriage and it should not be limited to heterosexual marriage based on that religion. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-fe0bbe38ee5f446cabbb61f1090be66d", "input": "claim: Gay marriage should be legal.\n perspective: As a secular institution, marriage can not be limited to heterosexuals only based on religious ideals. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-1deac4009c154a41afd9d1cbc981c35c", "input": "claim: Gay marriage should be legal.\n perspective: Marriage provides both physical and psychological health benefits, and banning gay marriage increases rates of psychological disorders. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-15abef39a4c9458da929fa949f20b648", "input": "claim: Gay marriage should be legal.\n perspective: If gay marriage is banned, there is likely to be increased rates of psychological disorders. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-77643995d83949f7a7d3c5789d5d64a1", "input": "claim: Gay marriage should be legal.\n perspective: We can reduce the prevalence of psychological disorders in the gay community by allowing gay marriage. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-efce65bf5f3e450888d856d4e87d63b3", "input": "claim: Gay marriage should be legal.\n perspective: Gay marriage is contrary to the word of God and is incompatible with the beliefs, sacred texts, and traditions of many religious groups. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-5b88d9c254874ea58b263fad1f2cced8", "input": "claim: Gay marriage should be legal.\n perspective: God condemns gay marriage in the Bible and it is not supported by a lot of churches. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-266fc17e387b4cc0b3b38b722b760dd4", "input": "claim: Gay marriage should be legal.\n perspective: Same sex couple should have the same rights as heterosexual couples", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-552dcc017acb4dcbbe3b1f779c4f9c1e", "input": "claim: Gay marriage should be legal.\n perspective: Who says who can marry and who can't", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-b8527e088d6d4644a69a64f0bcd684a2", "input": "claim: Gay marriage should be legal.\n perspective: Marriage is an internationally recognized human right for all people. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-6f4365577ed649d98ee6a77e122198ea", "input": "claim: Gay marriage should be legal.\n perspective: All people have the right to marry.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-38b31082c00449ba9526cff83622e727", "input": "claim: Gay marriage should be legal.\n perspective: Legalizing gay marriage will not harm the institution of marriage, and same-sex marriages may even be more stable than heterosexual marriages. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-175ae9974e9b4f08bd7142ce2b01a460", "input": "claim: Gay marriage should be legal.\n perspective: The institution of marriage cannot be harmed by giving more people the freedom to marry and it may become the case that heterosexual marriage is less stable than same-sex marriage. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-062c2aaeaa8a4e75a5367c5b554ee119", "input": "claim: Gay marriage should be legal.\n perspective: Same-sex marriage may have a lower divorce rate than heterosexual marriage proving once and for all that gay marriage is good for the institution of marriage. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-4d6e19f286304118a940ea408cb64bb6", "input": "claim: Gay marriage should be legal.\n perspective: Same-sex couples should have access to the same benefits enjoyed by heterosexual married couples. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-1a8d33d749774cf5af65a37c3515fd67", "input": "claim: Gay marriage should be legal.\n perspective: Same-Sex marriages should have the same legal protections as regular marriages.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d816e29c436d4282989c54f843be5af3", "input": "claim: Gay marriage should be legal.\n perspective: Gay marriages can bring financial gain to federal, state, and local governments and can help boost the economy. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-37dacc1c3ec54fa98d34595e656918d7", "input": "claim: Gay marriage should be legal.\n perspective: There are economic advantages for states to approve gay marriages. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d821aee3a8844e8095158303ed46d05f", "input": "claim: Gay marriage should be legal.\n perspective: The economy of states can be boosted by allowing same-sex marriages. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-7f4d076b30dc441c9a43a3575a485e25", "input": "claim: Gay marriage should be legal.\n perspective: Two people who want to get married should be able to, no matter their sexuality. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-1ccdec6e040145a0822fd94be57ab918", "input": "claim: Gay marriage should be legal.\n perspective: Homosexuals should have the same rights as straight people.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-296c5e2bebc84ab5ba4f6a9cd4d07bc1", "input": "claim: Gay marriage should be legal.\n perspective: Heterosexuals shouldn't enjoy greater rights than homosexuals.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-4f1b01113e414cf7a9cf58d9e8e6137a", "input": "claim: Gay marriage should be legal.\n perspective: Gay people should have the same human rights as Heterosexuals", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-06f0ac3fe738476089dca1ce92d72d77", "input": "claim: Gay marriage should be legal.\n perspective: It Would Cause controversy in religious countries such as Ireland and Italy", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-128da5109fe64521978e32004237664e", "input": "claim: Gay marriage should be legal.\n perspective: Homosexuals would Change the Institution of Marriage for the Better", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a6d149eee59e4014b76df35bf0496a07", "input": "claim: Gay marriage should be legal.\n perspective: Gay marriage would improve all marriages.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f99a0edb0c664c838203fa2a48fd9d37", "input": "claim: Gay marriage should be legal.\n perspective: Nature Suggests That Same Sex Marriage is Illogical", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-09b6d973b53f48d69c93fef9ec67a479", "input": "claim: Gay marriage should be legal.\n perspective: From a logical standpoint same sex marriage is illogical.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b4d28106a8e14bbe89dd3dc43b9e40dc", "input": "claim: Pay state school teachers based on merit.\n perspective: It is fair to reward teachers on the actual results they achieve.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-2e4bf1449a614bd599e559fffe955429", "input": "claim: Pay state school teachers based on merit.\n perspective: Teachers being rewarded on the actual results they achieve can be fair.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-40fe7c87df40446596b2c3db3aff10d2", "input": "claim: Pay state school teachers based on merit.\n perspective: It is fair to give rewards to teachers based upon results they achieve.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-8e3f581806364958a14888fe6342d248", "input": "claim: Pay state school teachers based on merit.\n perspective: It will give teachers an incentive to improve their teaching.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a09c6231de6e47609c2f3ce7195baa1c", "input": "claim: Pay state school teachers based on merit.\n perspective: Teachers will have an incentive to improve their teaching.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-0da3ebc46b0f41b7b5f513771c4671b0", "input": "claim: Pay state school teachers based on merit.\n perspective: Teachers can be given an incentive to improve their teaching.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-14682259b11a4ceb89fc36e120dba642", "input": "claim: Pay state school teachers based on merit.\n perspective: It will create uncritical 'learning drone' students.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-583fea01434e48268ac6f45c0983989a", "input": "claim: Pay state school teachers based on merit.\n perspective: Teachers will attempt to cheat the system", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-453e4153b9ec4da8bf39c76dd652210c", "input": "claim: Pay state school teachers based on merit.\n perspective: It is unfair to reward teachers for results they can’t influence", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-cf93b2a6ce3e4248a27bba05f80423e9", "input": "claim: Pay state school teachers based on merit.\n perspective: It would be unfair to reward teachers for results they cannot influence.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-7c72b5a2fbcc45fa99fd03e10811860d", "input": "claim: Pay state school teachers based on merit.\n perspective: It will attract more teachers", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f6818644f8734b6b8ed32131eead770c", "input": "claim: Roger Federer Is Not the Greatest Tennis Player of All Time.\n perspective: Rod Laver is without doubt the greatest ever!", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-947d8e29263e492bb06297066667828c", "input": "claim: Roger Federer Is Not the Greatest Tennis Player of All Time.\n perspective: Laver has a record that is hard to match.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-56b11a2a98fc47ff8872a9041e0d10a9", "input": "claim: Roger Federer Is Not the Greatest Tennis Player of All Time.\n perspective: He has not won The Grand Slam, the single greatest, and most difficult, feat in tennis.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-6e43a4cd47844e5498144a5ee2f3cd73", "input": "claim: Roger Federer Is Not the Greatest Tennis Player of All Time.\n perspective: He has dominated like no one else before", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-2a5bd7256c6a42c6b7e2dc8c5a5d0726", "input": "claim: Roger Federer Is Not the Greatest Tennis Player of All Time.\n perspective: Federer has a great tennis record.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-09deafcce51c41b4a224882d4621b730", "input": "claim: Roger Federer Is Not the Greatest Tennis Player of All Time.\n perspective: Federer is one of the best tennis players of all time.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-73c1561f64dc46be888ff5c1204c2d2d", "input": "claim: Roger Federer Is Not the Greatest Tennis Player of All Time.\n perspective: He has a losing record against Rafael Nadal. How can you be the best of all time if you're not even the best of your own era?", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-1958a1ad2dc044e6ad656fa58bd96ee0", "input": "claim: Roger Federer Is Not the Greatest Tennis Player of All Time.\n perspective: Is not even the best in his current generation", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-86b173c5d655463aaeabc41ca8c7b66a", "input": "claim: Roger Federer Is Not the Greatest Tennis Player of All Time.\n perspective: He has just won Wimbledon 2012 (17th grand slam) and gone back to number 1 again", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-055e871d9b3b4ed2a9da09089a8e5afd", "input": "claim: Roger Federer Is Not the Greatest Tennis Player of All Time.\n perspective: Federer has won 17 grand slams.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-3ad6d779b78b47db85881523208627e4", "input": "claim: Roger Federer Is Not the Greatest Tennis Player of All Time.\n perspective: Lack of serious competition", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-fdbbfdda32b742bb99d4964df414b6ef", "input": "claim: Roger Federer Is Not the Greatest Tennis Player of All Time.\n perspective: Was not ranked number one for the most years", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-be4b3dcf12864f0293c9efb0125a5595", "input": "claim: Roger Federer Is Not the Greatest Tennis Player of All Time.\n perspective: He is the all-time career money leader", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-77fb3fdf7ffa456fb13b83d7c88689c4", "input": "claim: Roger Federer Is Not the Greatest Tennis Player of All Time.\n perspective: Federer is the Greatest EVER!", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-73e46a54b4ef4da4a6466b52c3a3f1cd", "input": "claim: Roger Federer Is Not the Greatest Tennis Player of All Time.\n perspective: Federer has a record that will be hard to beat.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-3a5a3d4000994cd9b6fde3c7bc17c64e", "input": "claim: Roger Federer Is Not the Greatest Tennis Player of All Time.\n perspective: Federer has won many games which is very hard for peopple to do.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-3f27f9f37fd74704b22c784e4250075b", "input": "claim: We should be investing in public transport.\n perspective: businesses need transport to remain cost efficient; we need good business to get out of the recession", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-8febce85344840559173980143ba65a1", "input": "claim: We should be investing in public transport.\n perspective: Public transport helps keep business profitable", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e075b486faad49a8912f392bab4eb16a", "input": "claim: We should be investing in public transport.\n perspective: Investing in transport means investing in the businesses that will get us out of the recession", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-63bd44533b1d4243951d1c39c8cabf56", "input": "claim: We should be investing in public transport.\n perspective: The commercial community relies upon quality transportation infrastructure to function efficiently.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-6d2ca903029b48f4976c4d2fd4067f4a", "input": "claim: We should be investing in public transport.\n perspective: Economic stability and growth is assisted by a strong, economically viable transport network.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-494ce648b45740e991b4ffb488593606", "input": "claim: We should be investing in public transport.\n perspective: the recession will go, our public transport will remain", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-870939c9c0ca46febbefd7738c0cde69", "input": "claim: We should be investing in public transport.\n perspective: Even after the recession, there will still be public transit needs", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f81f326e811e4ece8c5c160d3ccb1677", "input": "claim: We should be investing in public transport.\n perspective: It will stop lazy people from driving everywhere.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-b581270b5c7042f8a020e5b7678d726d", "input": "claim: We should be investing in public transport.\n perspective: it is the environmentally friendly thing to do", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a7f13e1cbff14f2d8893976453bec495", "input": "claim: We should be investing in public transport.\n perspective: Public transport is more green.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-5920611a6d8d4397b38a3f35260304f8", "input": "claim: We should be investing in public transport.\n perspective: It is better for the environment.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-22868423f2e64dcea5c79509c154bca5", "input": "claim: We should be investing in public transport.\n perspective: Will encourage people not to drive", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c503b9d125b04b5fba8e11de0d98ae22", "input": "claim: We should be investing in public transport.\n perspective: People will use alternatives to driving.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-76ac4e0ebbf347a2b4b71f0926af4fe5", "input": "claim: We should be investing in public transport.\n perspective: People will drive less.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-3445e3a1c9f24359a03cdcfa774374d8", "input": "claim: Parents should be able to choose the sex of their children.\n perspective: Gender selection will prevent incidents of infanticide", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-0f96a579ac57457b9f1d1ecc687da6cb", "input": "claim: Parents should be able to choose the sex of their children.\n perspective: The lottery of childbirth should not be interfered with", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-698d0dbafc794a5fb6cd10b033b5ee57", "input": "claim: Parents should be able to choose the sex of their children.\n perspective: We shouldn't interfere with our current childbirth lottery.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-39aebb354bfb4578a25887d627fb2d64", "input": "claim: Parents should be able to choose the sex of their children.\n perspective: We should not disrupt our existing childbirth lottery.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-dc458a43779a4644bb42bb9ddf6e0a41", "input": "claim: Parents should be able to choose the sex of their children.\n perspective: Sex-specific, generic diseases can be avoided", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e369ad99c25a4350a4dee2ba7ecae465", "input": "claim: Parents should be able to choose the sex of their children.\n perspective: Diseases of a sex-specific and generic nature are avoidable.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ee8083b812c24016addaaa8c93f63746", "input": "claim: Parents should be able to choose the sex of their children.\n perspective: Pre-selection of gender uses expensive medical care for frivolous purposes", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4fcd74c832ca4fd5b632d6850c3c5e83", "input": "claim: Parents should be able to choose the sex of their children.\n perspective: Children should not be designed to specifications", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-9fe173fdd6854bf8b257a37904ae1536", "input": "claim: Parents should be able to choose the sex of their children.\n perspective: Parents should have freedom of choice", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-8e2621ec5b6345c4921e1e84f7614253", "input": "claim: Parents should be able to choose the sex of their children.\n perspective: Parents have the right to choose.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-eb316926b1d440609f9c08da29664da2", "input": "claim: Parents should be able to choose the sex of their children.\n perspective: Being a parent allows for freedom of choice.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-06297d0308ff4bfb970db67cf42da8dd", "input": "claim: The UN should be reformed or replaced.\n perspective: Reform would never be agreed upon.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-061d3acb67e74d3082a720f56b6ccfae", "input": "claim: The UN should be reformed or replaced.\n perspective: UN reform is almost impossible to be agreed on.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-fe966051870f46b9ad029c91c80d4a48", "input": "claim: The UN should be reformed or replaced.\n perspective: The UN needs a new approach with complete reform and replacement.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-feaf627e17414b94adb69a7a621dedc1", "input": "claim: The UN should be reformed or replaced.\n perspective: it would be impossible to find agreement for reform", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-5804fa81929e427da4452ad5d7884517", "input": "claim: The UN should be reformed or replaced.\n perspective: reform would not be agreed upon", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-10c99e8f73ca4d2ea9e9e346d2ca865d", "input": "claim: The UN should be reformed or replaced.\n perspective: : Main purpose of UN, to prevent war, has clearly not been achieved. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-bd43b5708b3743afbbf34eb615d14c62", "input": "claim: The UN should be reformed or replaced.\n perspective: UN is keeping its mission for peace", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-8fb72156836249c8b9edbc038e94ca80", "input": "claim: The UN should be reformed or replaced.\n perspective: The UN has done a great job with preventing wars ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-7b625f6d82fa472dabef87c465ef22c4", "input": "claim: The UN should be reformed or replaced.\n perspective: The UN does good at maintaining peace", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-7922f0d1dfc941dabc63acde9f82b77e", "input": "claim: Adaptation should be the most urgent response to Climate Change.\n perspective: Increasing oil costs make this the best time to be focussing on alternative energies", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-35857c6900ad4f6397e6a755e784b989", "input": "claim: Adaptation should be the most urgent response to Climate Change.\n perspective: Adaptation is likely to hurt poorer nations", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b9da52ac285e4aceab673da9fe5f5f7c", "input": "claim: Adaptation should be the most urgent response to Climate Change.\n perspective: Prioritising prevention hasn’t worked", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-befed0a93642456b83a0d80a2af5a17e", "input": "claim: The United States should use the electoral college in presidential elections.\n perspective: The reasons for which the Founding Fathers created the Electoral College are no longer relevant.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b7aa64d0ccfe4bf3bee0aafa1a3a6424", "input": "claim: The United States should use the electoral college in presidential elections.\n perspective: The Electoral College ensures that all parts of the country are involved in selecting the President of the United States. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-1197040aec9340359b4daea4bad442b6", "input": "claim: The United States should use the electoral college in presidential elections.\n perspective: The electoral college prevents a tyranny of the majority.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-2c85b4bc28fd4fb3b50e4c825103da1f", "input": "claim: The United States should use the electoral college in presidential elections.\n perspective: The Electoral College gives too much power to \"swing states\" and allows the presidential election to be decided by a handful of states.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-edd4389f28e74f868306d32095637fe8", "input": "claim: The United States should use the electoral college in presidential elections.\n perspective: The Electoral College ignores the will of the people. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-78acd596c73f4a0cafd80f9caef410e9", "input": "claim: The United States should use the electoral college in presidential elections.\n perspective: The Electoral College guarantees certainty to the outcome of the presidential election.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-fe1d6cce66d641cfa4783c26dddbe1b4", "input": "claim: The United States should use the electoral college in presidential elections.\n perspective: The electoral college weakens incentives for voting and party building.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-9f02b1eb79f74250814d2ca48805e782", "input": "claim: The United States should use the electoral college in presidential elections.\n perspective: The electoral college makes certain voters decline to vote.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-edd61df239d14856bcb3e5261a23ef84", "input": "claim: The United States should use the electoral college in presidential elections.\n perspective: Voters and party builders are undermined by the electoral college.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b3485d128d2a43e7aa323d0252064458", "input": "claim: The United States should use the electoral college in presidential elections.\n perspective: The electoral college goes against the democratic system because it hinders party building and has a negative impact on voting.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c96df28f32cf4d72ba8896c01697ee0b", "input": "claim: The United States should use the electoral college in presidential elections.\n perspective: The electoral college forces candidates to win broad coalitions across the country, encouraging national harmony.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a646a30342f843f2a70400fb383ba742", "input": "claim: The United States should use the electoral college in presidential elections.\n perspective: Casting votes by state forces candidates to be attentive to local interests, which they would otherwise ignore in a national campaign.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-5bbf23844380490dabea7cc5d3d4760c", "input": "claim: The United States should use the electoral college in presidential elections.\n perspective: The electoral college violates the democratic principle of equality in voting", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-9413fb7801f2419d9bd1bbe8a2f0f270", "input": "claim: The United States should use the electoral college in presidential elections.\n perspective: The electoral college violates principles of equity.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4c252fd6e8434dfaa5598d9dd5b31b42", "input": "claim: The United States should use the electoral college in presidential elections.\n perspective: America's electoral college should be done away with because it violates the democratic principle of equality in voting.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e9b93fc287dd432aa31af0a7bd486e7d", "input": "claim: The United States should use the electoral college in presidential elections.\n perspective: The electoral college is just a violation of voter equality.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-5ebbc10f83054fe8974efd4df8af02e9", "input": "claim: The United States should use the electoral college in presidential elections.\n perspective: The electoral college violates the democratic principle that the winner should be the candidate receiving the most votes. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-6361cacb2a6d406085d3c598b86efc51", "input": "claim: The United States should use the electoral college in presidential elections.\n perspective: The electoral college goes against the idea that whoever earns the most votes wins.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-3c0e8b4f50ea49bbb4a4bac8aa5b80f4", "input": "claim: The United States should use the electoral college in presidential elections.\n perspective: The electoral college is just a violation of democratic principles and should be abolished.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-8190044279c6440db5773cf6bae9f72d", "input": "claim: Parents of obese children be prosecuted with neglect.\n perspective: Children can access food without their parents knowledge", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b54df6c802c040b2a9864988e6e1c44e", "input": "claim: Parents of obese children be prosecuted with neglect.\n perspective: Some study's suggest that obesity may be more linked to your genes than your lifestyle", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-0746f1a7a37645d6b79d97e8cab3c70d", "input": "claim: Parents of obese children be prosecuted with neglect.\n perspective: It is possible that genes affect obesity more than personal lifestyle.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b0d530e3369e4ca0a49970ff5ef22c16", "input": "claim: Parents of obese children be prosecuted with neglect.\n perspective: Genetics make a difference in how your body reacts to different circumstances.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-2cb58268492e45e1a2c5eed92796562b", "input": "claim: Parents of obese children be prosecuted with neglect.\n perspective: Ignoring the countless warnings about the dangers surrounding obesity is neglect and neglecting a child is a prosecutable offence", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-7cea3142010e45859248ec60ec226eec", "input": "claim: Personality is more important than ability.\n perspective: we can used diabled people as an example", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-2b54144017484e0fa62be182cce023e5", "input": "claim: Personality is more important than ability.\n perspective: Ability can change, personality can't.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-26a0ec9b1ad54405aa1fe7e8e65feca7", "input": "claim: Romeo and Juliet do promote knife crime.\n perspective: Modern teenagers do not relate to Shakespearian plays ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-0ee32519b3114cd2bcb2c3b794c580fe", "input": "claim: Romeo and Juliet do promote knife crime.\n perspective: Presentation of fictional events glamourises knife crime ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-02cfe1f9b76941669c1269e8f7ff8109", "input": "claim: Romeo and Juliet do promote knife crime.\n perspective: Fiction glorifies violence.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ba0fa161931849a68e267d2bc1b1d4bc", "input": "claim: Romeo and Juliet do promote knife crime.\n perspective: Social learning theory supports such a correlation ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-84c9f3c5d93e4a3d89a3bfd76c5f11fe", "input": "claim: Romeo and Juliet do promote knife crime.\n perspective: It does not focus on moral condemnation of the couple but of passion of love", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a7017bc072734476b049370342b8fbf0", "input": "claim: Targeted sanctions have to be used to respond to cyber-attacks.\n perspective: There needs to be action to deter more cyber attacks", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-50af5a8c21eb4c3ba0e2f1892ff7c49b", "input": "claim: Targeted sanctions have to be used to respond to cyber-attacks.\n perspective: Sanctions are indiscriminate", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-15a8666bcf8544699ce1b678e28f2ebe", "input": "claim: Targeted sanctions have to be used to respond to cyber-attacks.\n perspective: Sanctions won't work", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-0a4b0b8d14e44d5b935cb139054ff46e", "input": "claim: Targeted sanctions have to be used to respond to cyber-attacks.\n perspective: Sanctions will prevent escalation in cyber conflict", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-cfc8dc1e10fe42fe8355d219215c51a3", "input": "claim: Targeted sanctions have to be used to respond to cyber-attacks.\n perspective: Sanctions require international agreement to be effective", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-5b1f4dcbfdf9468fb28fac38eaeda1aa", "input": "claim: Targeted sanctions have to be used to respond to cyber-attacks.\n perspective: Sanctions are a proportionate response", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-7b496e7db38c4f2dade609c2b811e782", "input": "claim: Capitalism is creating an expanding gap between the rich and the poor.\n perspective: It is those who do not work who reap the rewards from those who do", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-64b7561cfb8d479eb5f4860e8e890d0f", "input": "claim: Maths should be a compulsory subject at GCSE.\n perspective: Mathematics is a niche subject", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-9667c03267fa444e8ec04401759b8933", "input": "claim: Maths should be a compulsory subject at GCSE.\n perspective: Mathematics is pointless for the un-mathematically minded, the extreme right-brained, and the creative etc. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-f6bdbbd8323044a5878f6a6a532d76d8", "input": "claim: Maths should be a compulsory subject at GCSE.\n perspective: The skills are already taught by science.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b4be03051ed24b7e9e5153a8954af17e", "input": "claim: Maths should be a compulsory subject at GCSE.\n perspective: Maths is too wide a discipline.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-1146ab8da1814f5ca9c36ae81829d765", "input": "claim: The people's republic of China should abandon the one-child policy.\n perspective: The one child policy is needed for population control", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-96b728fbd74540aab247ec4f3093620c", "input": "claim: The people's republic of China should abandon the one-child policy.\n perspective: Single child families are economically efficient", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-01135cdb48d042399f85884ea7e428d8", "input": "claim: The people's republic of China should abandon the one-child policy.\n perspective: One child benefits women", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-16cff479a4344ba28d50a72a02b4d859", "input": "claim: Aboriginal culture must be protected.\n perspective: All of society benefits from protection of indigenous culture", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-9773409c11d14e4b8b85654035bf8538", "input": "claim: Aboriginal culture must be protected.\n perspective: Indigenous culture brings things to the table that are of benefit to society.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-9200882ba3924b32808c8d03443019e0", "input": "claim: Aboriginal culture must be protected.\n perspective: We cannot understand ourselves if we cannot understand others, so protection of indigenous culture is important.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-6b8afadc6b9f4ab3a0f5b7d1488f1881", "input": "claim: Aboriginal culture must be protected.\n perspective: The preservation of displaced cultures is important in preventing future oppression.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-aecbe30c83d643bc94ddc6a95619751a", "input": "claim: Aboriginal culture must be protected.\n perspective: We must learn from past mistakes and preserve displaced cultures .", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-78a9c9d9d73a47cda216ae2887a7f4db", "input": "claim: Aboriginal culture must be protected.\n perspective: In the past we have oppressed native peoples and we must learn from that so we do not do it again.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-53772a2a0f1647c08fa65f97cb495327", "input": "claim: Aboriginal culture must be protected.\n perspective: Government interference is not necessary to preserve culture", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-0c4f445333a4418689ffde408c45fab7", "input": "claim: Aboriginal culture must be protected.\n perspective: Existing states are responsible for the destruction of indigenous populations and their societies, and thereby have an obligation to help reverse the effects of their actions", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-128a150ee9154fcd9c9623213d4f54a2", "input": "claim: Aboriginal culture must be protected.\n perspective: Wrongs must be righted where indigenous populations have been harmed.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-bc9c6d8611814327a9d5cef9bf03fbdd", "input": "claim: Aboriginal culture must be protected.\n perspective: Repair of past errors in treatment of indigenous peoples is an obligation of those who benefited.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a60f448893d9414fb5a454da6c805247", "input": "claim: Aboriginal culture must be protected.\n perspective: Culture provides no tangible benefit that justifies the use of government funds to preserve it.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ab31af403fda4d1eab24feb986bb2eed", "input": "claim: Russia has the right to send troops into Crimea.\n perspective: Any cross border troop movements are a violation of sovereignty", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-87acb5eccfc142858b1e33f6b2874c8e", "input": "claim: Russia has the right to send troops into Crimea.\n perspective: Need to protect Russian civilians", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-693ff7a9abe94eb5921736c3ec224729", "input": "claim: Russia has the right to send troops into Crimea.\n perspective: Russian civilians need to be protected", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ec70208fe7d64635ae678e4f528d519a", "input": "claim: Russia has the right to send troops into Crimea.\n perspective: Russia has a need to protect civilians", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-0e561d0726ef41fe821e8f52cea1422b", "input": "claim: Russia has the right to send troops into Crimea.\n perspective: Necessary response to an illegal coup", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-4c91a92f0e19432ea06cbf6a306b88d9", "input": "claim: Russia has the right to send troops into Crimea.\n perspective: It is a necessary response to an illegal coup", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-28b82e05de244fb79f17f4a1f84f7b1b", "input": "claim: Russia has the right to send troops into Crimea.\n perspective: To an illegal coup is a necessary response", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-12f2cf29214248dc97f9907442626e14", "input": "claim: Russia has the right to send troops into Crimea.\n perspective: Russia should negotiate with the new government", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-0e5b4d1f05674990b0cf0b687d70391b", "input": "claim: Music That Glorifies Crime Should Be Banned.\n perspective: ban music that glorifies crime because of the influence it has on children", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c362724067484838b0474e81a217e7fc", "input": "claim: Music That Glorifies Crime Should Be Banned.\n perspective: music that glorifies crime should be banned", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-74597296b5cd4cc0ab7c3788fbda2f92", "input": "claim: Music That Glorifies Crime Should Be Banned.\n perspective: music that glorifies crime needs to be banned", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-57553b5502284c46a913480d6746a193", "input": "claim: Music That Glorifies Crime Should Be Banned.\n perspective: Censoring Art Is Dangerous", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-7f7943a29b1c4a96ace6d15fe89bc365", "input": "claim: Music That Glorifies Crime Should Be Banned.\n perspective: It is dangerous to censor art.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ea947cf7888144fe9b9bcb9fc3623841", "input": "claim: Music That Glorifies Crime Should Be Banned.\n perspective: Censoring art is extremely bad.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-3567cd44bd2149758df843bca28143d5", "input": "claim: Music That Glorifies Crime Should Be Banned.\n perspective: Music depicting violence to women causes and sustains the cycle of violence.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c330d6f585ca4f7393a93588739c9248", "input": "claim: Music That Glorifies Crime Should Be Banned.\n perspective: people are influenced by violent music", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a84d50db9e334ebaae564578aad91db5", "input": "claim: Music That Glorifies Crime Should Be Banned.\n perspective: violent music harms families ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d1c85bd2d03a4d72b980e96db729e947", "input": "claim: Music That Glorifies Crime Should Be Banned.\n perspective: To ban music that encourages violence against women would be done with the intention of protecting women; if it is necessary to paint them as the victims of violence that they are, that is a small price to pay. Furthermore, bans on child pornography would", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-6d839c347cf04ed680d97c45008e5550", "input": "claim: Music That Glorifies Crime Should Be Banned.\n perspective: If we change violent music, we can end the violence in society.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-18bc4060db2648ff8f5beb166b984ab5", "input": "claim: Music That Glorifies Crime Should Be Banned.\n perspective: Violence is music leads to violence in real life, so ending violent music would lessen violence in real life.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-52c04206e0664504bb0a8817c2614186", "input": "claim: Music That Glorifies Crime Should Be Banned.\n perspective: A change is needed to stop the cycle of violence.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-64af13c8457c4477a5fb91e40430f4a9", "input": "claim: Music That Glorifies Crime Should Be Banned.\n perspective: Harmful speech needs to be filtered", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-1c4bc67ebe7a4d25b9985ea4f3b3b4cf", "input": "claim: Music That Glorifies Crime Should Be Banned.\n perspective: When harmful speech is glorified in music, it leads to bad things in real life. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-fcdc11d41d714ef3996284253eee92fe", "input": "claim: Music That Glorifies Crime Should Be Banned.\n perspective: Filtering hate speech will keep it out of the mainstream and out of our lives.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-2801c464803944b580a030de5773117b", "input": "claim: Music That Glorifies Crime Should Be Banned.\n perspective: People are justified in listening to violent music", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-2fcf55c1f1764e0dbb40679b5d82467e", "input": "claim: Music That Glorifies Crime Should Be Banned.\n perspective: People have the right to listen to whatever music they want to.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-5a90633dabe34b3f928517b59d584ab8", "input": "claim: Music That Glorifies Crime Should Be Banned.\n perspective: Violent music can be listened to without people going out and doing what the music says.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b0cbd33f54d242c69c8355813c574a0b", "input": "claim: Music That Glorifies Crime Should Be Banned.\n perspective: A ban is necessary for progress in the status of women.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-8185a330ed574812b78534db97502df9", "input": "claim: Music That Glorifies Crime Should Be Banned.\n perspective: To ban violent music against weapon is to support positive status of women in society.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f097e7878c2f419490f648be02baa394", "input": "claim: Music That Glorifies Crime Should Be Banned.\n perspective: Music depicting violence against women encourages men (and women) not to respect women.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-0b9099d2ae6849bd8931cd0162eb41f3", "input": "claim: Music That Glorifies Crime Should Be Banned.\n perspective: Both sexes are encouraged lose respect for women when music depicts violence against women.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-009b685550c642eab6bb6ad675e5c77e", "input": "claim: Music That Glorifies Crime Should Be Banned.\n perspective: Music depicting violence against women discourages respect of women in men and women.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c07b29d449ca4271a0d9b462be77fccf", "input": "claim: Music That Glorifies Crime Should Be Banned.\n perspective: The violent music encourages disrespect toward women", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-b790b89ec2f44641a9111febf3fa42b2", "input": "claim: Music That Glorifies Crime Should Be Banned.\n perspective: Music about violence against women doesn't help the perception of women", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-dd3895f202c34421b09824f19df14a86", "input": "claim: Music That Glorifies Crime Should Be Banned.\n perspective: It would be easy to apply restrictions on music.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-8fe02fdaa6ca4b3597382db6f586d3f8", "input": "claim: Music That Glorifies Crime Should Be Banned.\n perspective: It would be highly impractical to ban this music glorifying violence.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4f0ca2501eb64c04a5a2554a067c9112", "input": "claim: Music That Glorifies Crime Should Be Banned.\n perspective: It would not be at all practical to ban music glorifying violence.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-6a601d6fd392470da69ef318a9cacbe3", "input": "claim: Music That Glorifies Crime Should Be Banned.\n perspective: Banning this music that glorifies violence is totally impractical.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-979741f8f4cf4d9c8b85cd850c0b0c67", "input": "claim: Music That Glorifies Crime Should Be Banned.\n perspective: It is not realistic to expect a ban of violent music", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a647f52117734ba19cb1e8a21d6d91cb", "input": "claim: Music That Glorifies Crime Should Be Banned.\n perspective: Defending hip hop artists’ right to free speech", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-28c266cf13a341ff8ab04585aa7d5af1", "input": "claim: Music That Glorifies Crime Should Be Banned.\n perspective: everyone deserves free speech", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-14d4ac1bf6ea4f7fae4fd68a4899bf75", "input": "claim: Music That Glorifies Crime Should Be Banned.\n perspective: hip hop artists have a right to free speech", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-236007245ea74542ad02f8a608d6ada3", "input": "claim: Marriage is an outdated institution.\n perspective: Unreasonable commitment to expect of people", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e06d4fb2166045b29327e153c56d71dd", "input": "claim: Marriage is an outdated institution.\n perspective: Marriage should not be expected.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f2f7d3ffe68445adbd04c10a14db1713", "input": "claim: Marriage is an outdated institution.\n perspective: This level of commitment is unreasonable to expect.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-21a382a7d2ac452e8374d073d129f880", "input": "claim: Marriage is an outdated institution.\n perspective: Expectations of people is an commitment that is unreasonable. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d58e8aefaf6d41cb9637639710099c77", "input": "claim: Marriage is an outdated institution.\n perspective: Marriage promotes a better way to raise children", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-5602ef86038d4ae69e0808fa14f6770f", "input": "claim: Marriage is an outdated institution.\n perspective: It's better to raise children within a marriage.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-cb5086a1ed274a58a2c9ea0cfb7fa7ef", "input": "claim: Marriage is an outdated institution.\n perspective: Marriage represents a legal bond which protects both parties in a relationship", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-f034e8d9a9eb455db6bb1b55975376a8", "input": "claim: Marriage is an outdated institution.\n perspective: Marriage is a legal contract with protections for both parties.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-feafc4adeb1b43ea9c6be49593f04936", "input": "claim: Marriage is an outdated institution.\n perspective: Marriage provides protection to both parties in the form of legal protection.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-90fc5ef3da384786a1c6cd8fbded8da5", "input": "claim: Marriage is an outdated institution.\n perspective: Marriage is an important institution to religious people", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ad87b905a01f4f6b80d4b37d49c72626", "input": "claim: Marriage is an outdated institution.\n perspective: Marriage is an important religious aspect to some couples.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-9064ef5724374d76818dc25cf4c183df", "input": "claim: UK should have a second Brexit referendum before leaving the EU.\n perspective: Britain should honour the 2016 vote", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-859a5936160b43eaabe7c6dd5e6dc665", "input": "claim: UK should have a second Brexit referendum before leaving the EU.\n perspective: The 2016 vote in Britain should be upheld. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-0bcb379acff54868a625d3fd81a7d3cd", "input": "claim: UK should have a second Brexit referendum before leaving the EU.\n perspective: Britain should implement the vote in 2016. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-06988d5625594324a572827b16abed5c", "input": "claim: UK should have a second Brexit referendum before leaving the EU.\n perspective: A referendum could not provide the nuanced policy the UK needs", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-2612eaba0e53403a9b5c85ea933dd051", "input": "claim: UK should have a second Brexit referendum before leaving the EU.\n perspective: Even though the UK needs it , a direct vote couldn't provide the subtle policy. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-6a231c47da4042789d706ffcd7a109d6", "input": "claim: UK should have a second Brexit referendum before leaving the EU.\n perspective: A referendum couldn't produce the nuanced policy that the UK needed. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b65b1fb7bd494ea287df300313c4f04a", "input": "claim: UK should have a second Brexit referendum before leaving the EU.\n perspective: There is no time to hold a second referendum", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-bfd02cf7eeec4622b0db197992cc35ce", "input": "claim: UK should have a second Brexit referendum before leaving the EU.\n perspective: We are out of time to hold a second referedum. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a312e6492f1b4bfd848ffe7f713dfc28", "input": "claim: UK should have a second Brexit referendum before leaving the EU.\n perspective: There is no time left to have a second direct vote. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ca251ade51b746f48b97f68f9a0f6392", "input": "claim: UK should have a second Brexit referendum before leaving the EU.\n perspective: Other countries have had second referendums ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-95df49374a4c47ec85099fb16941589c", "input": "claim: UK should have a second Brexit referendum before leaving the EU.\n perspective: Other countries have had second popular votes. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a32e9db585b34ff7835b43b76d960b91", "input": "claim: UK should have a second Brexit referendum before leaving the EU.\n perspective: Second referendums have been done in other countries. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-67ad98c67b28404ba23f473c9a0b5840", "input": "claim: UK should have a second Brexit referendum before leaving the EU.\n perspective: An in or out referendum would be legitimate.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ca84973dbcc8404790522a5ea7efb5ea", "input": "claim: UK should have a second Brexit referendum before leaving the EU.\n perspective: Any referendum is legitimate in this case.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-31f7d66096734236be3c83a88795ec01", "input": "claim: UK should have a second Brexit referendum before leaving the EU.\n perspective: The vote will be illegitimate.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-d848a7d1d9a249b1925ea0de4957b518", "input": "claim: UK should have a second Brexit referendum before leaving the EU.\n perspective: The vote won't be legitimate.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-82ae0a22ef0d41d9b1f66e3b56239876", "input": "claim: UK should have a second Brexit referendum before leaving the EU.\n perspective: The vote would be wrongful.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-6981e5fdf33a41078fd23e197f415f37", "input": "claim: UK should have a second Brexit referendum before leaving the EU.\n perspective: the vote will not be legitimate", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-98d75d528c1042f9886ef9f32ca1b235", "input": "claim: UK should have a second Brexit referendum before leaving the EU.\n perspective: the vote will be rendered illegitimate", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4b0947063e2c4a10b07f8d53af994eed", "input": "claim: UK should have a second Brexit referendum before leaving the EU.\n perspective: A referendum will create a better political climate.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-6d8a6c0b6724402e93172426f1c88388", "input": "claim: UK should have a second Brexit referendum before leaving the EU.\n perspective: Referendums are good politically.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-229600efc30c46a8a52f4381563a4cc7", "input": "claim: UK should have a second Brexit referendum before leaving the EU.\n perspective: Politics are enriched by referendums.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-40cc8d72f5094814a538d7913c7c914e", "input": "claim: UK should have a second Brexit referendum before leaving the EU.\n perspective: The public have a right to a referendum.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-390a6b3ab75b47c594cde83c3cc01b79", "input": "claim: UK should have a second Brexit referendum before leaving the EU.\n perspective: The people have a right to hold a referendum", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-28697f51c24f47a4912426a08944cfba", "input": "claim: UK should have a second Brexit referendum before leaving the EU.\n perspective: Holding a referendum is a civil right.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-b527d3abff7a4e2e8cb55f8b7dfdfbd8", "input": "claim: UK should have a second Brexit referendum before leaving the EU.\n perspective: people have the right to a referendum", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-9be0015f94104980b19fe0d6daea1cb6", "input": "claim: UK should have a second Brexit referendum before leaving the EU.\n perspective: The referendum doesn't match the UK's democratic history.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-24f205f58a094d179df4798f7316ac61", "input": "claim: UK should have a second Brexit referendum before leaving the EU.\n perspective: Holding a vote would be inconsistent with the UK's democratic traditions.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-92db619989be4a1aa0d53726a893e693", "input": "claim: UK should have a second Brexit referendum before leaving the EU.\n perspective: the referendum is inconsistent with the UK's tradition of represtative democary EU members", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-5d8dc297aaeb439aa7e568cc52c25841", "input": "claim: UK should have a second Brexit referendum before leaving the EU.\n perspective: it may be inconsistent to use a referendum relative to Uk's tradition as a representative democracy eu member", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-bd75c0fc842548ff96dcc75d50facf15", "input": "claim: UK should have a second Brexit referendum before leaving the EU.\n perspective: The referendum is good PR for the UK.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a3a89cf4230744e6968679629de9b7ee", "input": "claim: UK should have a second Brexit referendum before leaving the EU.\n perspective: The referendum will be good PR.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-19678e8c0dd84ea99ead927171b3060b", "input": "claim: UK should have a second Brexit referendum before leaving the EU.\n perspective: The referendum will look good.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-b5e0df8bae954339bc06ddf8b4fd4a85", "input": "claim: UK should have a second Brexit referendum before leaving the EU.\n perspective: a referendum is good pr option for the UK", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c6219e0180ca4e0686880025fe3566c6", "input": "claim: UK should have a second Brexit referendum before leaving the EU.\n perspective: the UK may be benefitted with good pr from a referendum", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-fc4cf7bfacc1462097ce5db8d01297fb", "input": "claim: Teachers should get tenure.\n perspective: Tenure lets experienced teachers pick easier assignments and leaves difficult assignments to the least experienced teachers. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-99128e2864514a458a8e559c5126d3bd", "input": "claim: Teachers should get tenure.\n perspective: Tenure provides a hierachy for experienced teachers in choosing easy or difficult assignments.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-f567d2351fc6482a92bf88a3ea9e9489", "input": "claim: Teachers should get tenure.\n perspective: Tenure prohibits school districts from firing experienced teachers to hire less experienced and less expensive teachers. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e3e96a9cc77b471b93e68df842891b2a", "input": "claim: Teachers should get tenure.\n perspective: The formal dismissal process guaranteed by tenure protects teachers from punitive evaluation systems and premature dismissal. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-baa6e2b5645e4606a1dbc599184bcd4e", "input": "claim: Teachers should get tenure.\n perspective: Tenure is a formal dismissal process which protects teachers from punitive or premature dismissal", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d78dda8458034d8abc0fd75d79233172", "input": "claim: Teachers should get tenure.\n perspective: Teachers are protected with the formal dismissal process under tenure.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-b74a850f0140432687aac121205fcad8", "input": "claim: We should encourage increased use of referendums.\n perspective: Modern technology makes consultation easier than ever.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a03a37e62a2c42228397dc0962283ef8", "input": "claim: We should encourage increased use of referendums.\n perspective: Ensures that all views are represented in political debate. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-28898a4112674f62a22ad7bd144ade26", "input": "claim: We should encourage increased use of referendums.\n perspective: This will ensure all views are represented in a political debate.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-0f5045ca6b6d4538aaedf2059b9b9d0e", "input": "claim: We should encourage increased use of referendums.\n perspective: All views can be represented in a political debate.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-6e9b86da8521492e9339c82bf53b4908", "input": "claim: We should encourage increased use of referendums.\n perspective: Referendums are very artificial. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-14ade3720b7740699ef43dff8fafd296", "input": "claim: We should encourage increased use of referendums.\n perspective: Referendums can lend greater validity to political outcomes", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-6b67410574aa43b885520601e989cf42", "input": "claim: We should encourage increased use of referendums.\n perspective: Referendums allow for greater validity in political outcomes.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-bce495b5f51f4c96807266ac60611676", "input": "claim: We should encourage increased use of referendums.\n perspective: Improves standards in political governance. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-5d038d8021354c29ab394c2b926d3b60", "input": "claim: We should encourage increased use of referendums.\n perspective: Reduces public apathy about, and disengagement from, politics. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d55396ebd8ac4e27a3eb4eadbdc1959e", "input": "claim: A nation's history and mythology is part of its national security.\n perspective: Predicting and protecting the future nation", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-de28ef33df074f02bcf7edeaa68344e3", "input": "claim: We should give cash to the poor to reduce poverty.\n perspective: Giving money to the poor is the fairest way of eliminating poverty", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-08d8e271018e49ec8496538b1d77971d", "input": "claim: We should give cash to the poor to reduce poverty.\n perspective: giving to poor prevents poverty", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-b51ab671ba684033ac53ae97359a2a85", "input": "claim: We should give cash to the poor to reduce poverty.\n perspective: Money cannot be targeted to meet specific needs", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-65874c0c455444c8a5ca57491df25226", "input": "claim: We should give cash to the poor to reduce poverty.\n perspective: money can't be good for specific needs", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4ca28113ebe2419a9561038af9c09cc0", "input": "claim: We Should Have a Quota for Women on Corporate Boards.\n perspective: Quotas are Inherently Helpful", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-b742aa1c2bc34c35a39b31c83110c306", "input": "claim: Eliminate All Nuclear Weapons.\n perspective: Nuclear waste disposal is rarely safe/efficient; it is too much to expect a sqeaky clean disposal/disarmament of nuclear weapons ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-2a7c657463dd4b3ba17d7a4b6d0f0695", "input": "claim: Eliminate All Nuclear Weapons.\n perspective: Disarmament is impossible, rendering efforts to disarm pointless and simply wasteful", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-46212b5446264c769c63b96f6b773ce9", "input": "claim: Eliminate All Nuclear Weapons.\n perspective: Disarmament would actually cause increased insecurity among nations, as there can never be any guarantee that a nation has disarmed", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b3fa18d5ea2a43aaa6569baac825aa51", "input": "claim: Eliminate All Nuclear Weapons.\n perspective: Disarmament would actually cause increased insecurity among nations, it is near impossible to guarantee that a nation has disarmed.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-48eaf968f72246c0a50ae5112273a63c", "input": "claim: Eliminate All Nuclear Weapons.\n perspective: Disarmament would actually cause increased insecurity among nations, you can never really know for sure whether they have disarmed.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-eaaea75825aa4d0fab37248766737994", "input": "claim: Eliminate All Nuclear Weapons.\n perspective: The abolition of nuclear weapons would actually incentivize the development and use of even more dangerous weapons, such as chemical and biological weapons", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-9cf907088ef3435ca36cb4e6f43673b7", "input": "claim: Eliminate All Nuclear Weapons.\n perspective: Proliferation of nuclear weapons increases the chances of nuclear accidents", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-28fccc5568154fb0847f6422db53bf21", "input": "claim: Eliminate All Nuclear Weapons.\n perspective: Irrational leaders make the possession of nuclear weapons dangerous", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-97bb8933b4664a06a30c9d12a9a460d1", "input": "claim: Eliminate All Nuclear Weapons.\n perspective: It is immoral to use the threat of nuclear annihilation in order to achieve foreign policy aims", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-80d6e7b8d615481092dc84944a42016e", "input": "claim: Eliminate All Nuclear Weapons.\n perspective: Nuclear weapons can fall into the wrong hands.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-6299574ea028414fb8e139a239cc812e", "input": "claim: Eliminate All Nuclear Weapons.\n perspective: States will give terrorists nuclear weapons", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-6fa91ca4d4ae4a0e91b250e6378a7f05", "input": "claim: Eliminate All Nuclear Weapons.\n perspective: Terrorists will steal nuclear weapons from poorly guarded arsenals", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-1a67cc369af342fcaeae68445af9f040", "input": "claim: Eliminate All Nuclear Weapons.\n perspective: The nukes can end up being used against us.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f846371b04654fceb14db4ba1780be31", "input": "claim: Eliminate All Nuclear Weapons.\n perspective: It's conceivable that the wrong people will have the weapons.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-6a0f13b05de241faaab2654ae04769b6", "input": "claim: Eliminate All Nuclear Weapons.\n perspective: Humanitarian intervention becomes impossible in states that possess nuclear weapons", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-eb489e9432974693b69e233b54a2ba44", "input": "claim: Eliminate All Nuclear Weapons.\n perspective: Humanitarian missions would not be possible in states that have nuclear weapons.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-5044fe5cefad411481ac1886a4eae30a", "input": "claim: Eliminate All Nuclear Weapons.\n perspective: It is very difficult to intercede in humanitarian crises in states wherein nuclear weapons are present.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-861302d0f7f7448dbe839f0a5488e5a7", "input": "claim: Eliminate All Nuclear Weapons.\n perspective: The threat of a state developing nuclear weapons could instigate pre-emptive strikes from its neighbours and rivals to prevent the acquisition of such weapons", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ccf91e5b9c1a44e68a0c97d9cd44e2a2", "input": "claim: Eliminate All Nuclear Weapons.\n perspective: Other countries could strike against those developing nuclear weapons to protect themselves.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-5de5e2986e7c4a7c88b344b5cc12ea95", "input": "claim: Eliminate All Nuclear Weapons.\n perspective: To keep other countries from obtaining a nuclear arsenal, other nations may pre-emptively strike.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-2ddc4235a0be480da5b94dbb6f8b8081", "input": "claim: Eliminate All Nuclear Weapons.\n perspective: The intention of a state to develop nuclear weapons may incite military attacks by enemies and by other supporting countries.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f6f0263bedf349abb162b1499c6d8156", "input": "claim: Eliminate All Nuclear Weapons.\n perspective: Public acknowledgement of the right to nuclear deterrence will benefit the public regulation of nuclear weapons generally", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-9d59dc6646274d1b83c8f06f9639fc47", "input": "claim: Eliminate All Nuclear Weapons.\n perspective: Nuclear weapons give states valuable agenda-setting power on the international stage", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-835616ca7610421b936ad04b12e34158", "input": "claim: Eliminate All Nuclear Weapons.\n perspective: Countries with nuclear weapons have the ability to set their own agenda.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-72f2a8d6aff84000a26c0e741c688788", "input": "claim: Eliminate All Nuclear Weapons.\n perspective: States with nuclear weapons are afforded more authority to set agendas at international levels.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c066889f98cb4a4b8d87a2d5ba2c1bf6", "input": "claim: Eliminate All Nuclear Weapons.\n perspective: All countries have a right to defend themselves with nuclear weapons, even when they lack the capacity in conventional weapons", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-1f0aa5f9c1ed445789eb6691b8b7849a", "input": "claim: Eliminate All Nuclear Weapons.\n perspective: All states have a right to nuclear self-defense.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e886ae25616c41de860b54605dfb7e52", "input": "claim: Eliminate All Nuclear Weapons.\n perspective: To use nuclear weapons in defense of the nation is lawful for all countries.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-23c3aefd278046f09431cd7ccb23e96d", "input": "claim: Eliminate All Nuclear Weapons.\n perspective: all countries are entitled to self defense with nuclear weapons, even when they do not have the capacity to carry conventional weapons", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-83682d0609734b2e95e2f01aa7c35682", "input": "claim: Eliminate All Nuclear Weapons.\n perspective: Possessing nuclear weapons will be counter to the peaceful interests of states", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-8295c545c1174c878e604094d12a52b5", "input": "claim: Eliminate All Nuclear Weapons.\n perspective: [Iran specific] Iran has threatened to destroy Israel", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c6da28ed14a84fe5b1f0867bb7b344b9", "input": "claim: Eliminate All Nuclear Weapons.\n perspective: Iran has Israel targeted.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-8ab45448061e4f94a7e8e6d4bd842909", "input": "claim: The European Union should adopt a single working language through which to operate.\n perspective: It is more practical to work through one language that all Member States understand in order to ensure the effectiveness of communication.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-97346447198c494d8bd0f76db07bd6ba", "input": "claim: The European Union should adopt a single working language through which to operate.\n perspective: we should speak one common language", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-0f8a1c0afd3745f58334bf3eadb5df6e", "input": "claim: The European Union should adopt a single working language through which to operate.\n perspective: Speaking one language that all members can understand is the best way to ensure effective communication.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-3d09ccdbf00244ff8abe24217e7d4e13", "input": "claim: The European Union should adopt a single working language through which to operate.\n perspective: If the EU ‘elects’ a single working language, it will be deliberately contributing to the narrow-minded, anglicising of the entire world, despite being a union of diverse cultures with the power to fight it.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b2ff455fa5e14f1bab5bcf0f8d51827b", "input": "claim: The European Union should adopt a single working language through which to operate.\n perspective: Adopting a single language would be counter-cultural.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-de93010672294f6ab9d0b5365bf18c40", "input": "claim: The European Union should adopt a single working language through which to operate.\n perspective: Electing a single language would hurt the EU's efforts towards cultural diversity.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-13a19921c2fd4053946bfed42a673364", "input": "claim: The European Union should adopt a single working language through which to operate.\n perspective: One working language understood by all Member States is a more practical way of communicating often untranslatable yet vital EU-specific vocabulary.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-b048eb7b258042bf83861ffce817f2b4", "input": "claim: The European Union should adopt a single working language through which to operate.\n perspective: One language would be best to help understand EU jargon.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-39f8a672b77b4097873e47a55c83972d", "input": "claim: The European Union should adopt a single working language through which to operate.\n perspective: Communication regarding EU jargon would benefit within the EU if one universal language was used.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-8b58345607f04e93a09674d88e63e029", "input": "claim: Force the media to display, promote and report women’s sport equally to men’s sport.\n perspective: Increased media coverage changes public perceptions towards gender roles and women’s sport.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-4ced94b930df4315aab0371cc2a79b0b", "input": "claim: Force the media to display, promote and report women’s sport equally to men’s sport.\n perspective: Equalising media coverage will cause a drop in funding for sport in general", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-2477691de32d4e57b02da0a7d76f87de", "input": "claim: Force the media to display, promote and report women’s sport equally to men’s sport.\n perspective: Men’s sports are more popular than women’s and so should receive more media coverage.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-3a33c9f6a00e466488e49f9eda563126", "input": "claim: Force the media to display, promote and report women’s sport equally to men’s sport.\n perspective: Women's sports are less popular than men's and so should get less media coverage.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e65ae15545a34b9b9cf71b067e83ef6e", "input": "claim: Force the media to display, promote and report women’s sport equally to men’s sport.\n perspective: Media coverage should focus on men's sports because they are more popular than women's.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-7984b580b8504d7ea5b3e13472fb6ec6", "input": "claim: Force the media to display, promote and report women’s sport equally to men’s sport.\n perspective: Increased media coverage creates more role models for young girls to engage in sport.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f7e2986941e04d6397631c1117fd9fdb", "input": "claim: Force the media to display, promote and report women’s sport equally to men’s sport.\n perspective: promote sport for future female athlese", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ffe3054a5d504c23b510b90e43a52df2", "input": "claim: Force the media to display, promote and report women’s sport equally to men’s sport.\n perspective: Encouraging future female athletes", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-52bb574dfbec477aa692daaf1de100b8", "input": "claim: Force the media to display, promote and report women’s sport equally to men’s sport.\n perspective: More sports role models for young girls are created with increased media coverage. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-0dbdc64ecab548e8be1be42e7051741d", "input": "claim: Force the media to display, promote and report women’s sport equally to men’s sport.\n perspective: Young girls are given more role models for participating in sports with increased media coverage.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-5fc8627c18aa44f48bfdd94850c7347d", "input": "claim: Force the media to display, promote and report women’s sport equally to men’s sport.\n perspective: This could simply swap inequalities around", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c8ace037fb284d019b971b00087c3575", "input": "claim: Force the media to display, promote and report women’s sport equally to men’s sport.\n perspective: Destroying the pleasure of watching certain sports", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-336b9ebef9a94f3e83f8115d2b1823ff", "input": "claim: Force the media to display, promote and report women’s sport equally to men’s sport.\n perspective: stop discrimination in sport", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e47b00da4b6a46e781885eefdc34f55b", "input": "claim: Force the media to display, promote and report women’s sport equally to men’s sport.\n perspective: discrimination in sport should be removed", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-286966c318134665a2c10e60e36e5c9e", "input": "claim: Force the media to display, promote and report women’s sport equally to men’s sport.\n perspective: The sports world is unfairly dominated by a male-orientated world-view. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a2c6d065fcbd44af8714be635ec832c1", "input": "claim: Force the media to display, promote and report women’s sport equally to men’s sport.\n perspective: Preventing discrimination in sport", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-daee28dbe1a347f09bbad8c697adfce8", "input": "claim: Force the media to display, promote and report women’s sport equally to men’s sport.\n perspective: Athletes should decide for themselves.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-af2dbd9c6cfd4f09834f460a3b3e0c54", "input": "claim: Force the media to display, promote and report women’s sport equally to men’s sport.\n perspective: Athletes should be able to make their own decisions.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-408f98086a6944a7b78a24f4e153de14", "input": "claim: We should be free to express our religion as we wish.\n perspective: Religious symbols harm no one", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-292827d4eb1c4e3fad6320e7ae4e947d", "input": "claim: We should be free to express our religion as we wish.\n perspective: symbols for religious benefit bothers no one", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-1c243163c8e745098f6064780ae78e05", "input": "claim: We should be free to express our religion as we wish.\n perspective: religious expression should be freely decided", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-704afaa266ed40429bb5fd2b812efbc0", "input": "claim: We should be free to express our religion as we wish.\n perspective: It is a fundamental right to practice the religion you wish.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-06d0cfb8b5514f3081bc4412e08d2b2a", "input": "claim: We should be free to express our religion as we wish.\n perspective: Practicing your religion is a right, not a priveledge. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-6a833f762239426383de263f654f5c97", "input": "claim: We should be free to express our religion as we wish.\n perspective: Human rights demand that we are free to express our religion.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-cddbd727f009423b982bdaa1c2eb16ba", "input": "claim: We should be free to express our religion as we wish.\n perspective: Religious expression needs to be guaranteed for all of us as part of our most fundamental rights!", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-1b2c7a8241854d4a81b501aec981524e", "input": "claim: We should be free to express our religion as we wish.\n perspective: Freedom of expression, like any right is fairly meaningless if it’s only respected when it’s convenient.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-abd97ce7cd37455599415555a2e06c21", "input": "claim: We should be free to express our religion as we wish.\n perspective: It is a fundamental part of OUR Human Rights", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-8d085c9a1fef4dbc9e113b4e72dba8e3", "input": "claim: We should be free to express our religion as we wish.\n perspective: It is politically incorrect", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-dc050d35d21148b3ac3719adaf9201f8", "input": "claim: Dictatorship Is the Best Path to Development.\n perspective: Dictatorship outperforms democracy in growth and economic develpment", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-4a858fc1eb9c4164a88748d9e02f3651", "input": "claim: Dictatorship Is the Best Path to Development.\n perspective: Democracies can't mobilize a country as fast as a dictatorship can.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-1018c225015041eaaef7f282d8a2426d", "input": "claim: Dictatorship Is the Best Path to Development.\n perspective: In order to develop quickly, a dictator must be in power to sped things up.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-19c839a67f8f4dbd99ddfc3bb7614cf6", "input": "claim: Dictatorship Is the Best Path to Development.\n perspective: Dictatorships are more effective than democracies at mobilizing resources for investment.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-176b4bc39ffa4977ad2f4a006044a52a", "input": "claim: Dictatorship Is the Best Path to Development.\n perspective: The loger lasting and biggest economic miracles have ocurred under dictatorships", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-71ee9ac0e7d740419d46a079a0a9df32", "input": "claim: Dictatorship Is the Best Path to Development.\n perspective: A dictatorship breeds order and it's a needed step for both development and liberal democracy", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-13ab0b60cf854f23a12bdf4a93ab30cc", "input": "claim: Dictatorship Is the Best Path to Development.\n perspective: Dictatorships breed development and liberal democracy.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c4e6e297e9e64db68d9bc4c55bcc3bc5", "input": "claim: Dictatorship Is the Best Path to Development.\n perspective: Breeding of development and liberal democracy under dictatorial rule. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-36f980da4336462aa2f453978fd95fd3", "input": "claim: Dictatorship Is the Best Path to Development.\n perspective: Development occurs when a dictatorship revert into democracy", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a75427e35019458a964b3d6096d45baf", "input": "claim: Dictatorship Is the Best Path to Development.\n perspective: Democratic rule of law is the best ground for political stability and growth", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-d571b72e8a3c408c973b92d0cac4cd8a", "input": "claim: Dictatorship Is the Best Path to Development.\n perspective: Democracy lets a country grow naturaly", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-2a0bdc4edffa420592bebd0f0b3abf88", "input": "claim: Dictatorship Is the Best Path to Development.\n perspective: Dictatorships have a flexibility in economic policy that breeds growth", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-60989430ffac41648facb08006c7a1b9", "input": "claim: Dictatorship Is the Best Path to Development.\n perspective: Dictators have incentives to promote development and diminish social differences", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-67d8108de7e54912a694d561b26efeb3", "input": "claim: Dictatorship Is the Best Path to Development.\n perspective: Dictator’s decisions undermines the people and are unaccountable", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-043cb416b6894726b572af481f77e338", "input": "claim: Dictatorship Is the Best Path to Development.\n perspective: Dictatorships regimes can be a path for countries move on from civil wars and focus on development", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-4868de18253847dfbb17f5032974def0", "input": "claim: Dictatorship Is the Best Path to Development.\n perspective: Dictatorial regimes can move countries from civil wars toward development.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-87a3645f0121479e9a0689471342f741", "input": "claim: Dictatorship Is the Best Path to Development.\n perspective: Dictatorship is a threat to diversity and multi ethnicity", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-201eb88a52284e699deaddec5d2abce7", "input": "claim: Dictatorship Is the Best Path to Development.\n perspective: Imposing dictatorship will be a threat to diversity and multi ethnicity. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-1cf66889ef434f6282373ab08712082d", "input": "claim: Dictatorship Is the Best Path to Development.\n perspective: Dictatorship will stop all path of development in a democratic country ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c8ca07bcf6a940c58a3e3e94038bff83", "input": "claim: Dictatorship Is the Best Path to Development.\n perspective: Dictatorships better control the variables of human development", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-3b1a6fa803a54b8d9a3af89617d601c7", "input": "claim: Dictatorship Is the Best Path to Development.\n perspective: Dictatorship brings profit to dictators and its clique, but not to the citizens", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-7c7de19f4eb44d3a8263d5174cb9fd4a", "input": "claim: Dictatorship Is the Best Path to Development.\n perspective: Dictatorships breed development though efficient and straighfoward decision making", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f338b8d3d9bb49a49ddbe149492a8d2f", "input": "claim: Dictatorship Is the Best Path to Development.\n perspective: Social stability through the use of dictatorships.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-4e36284b23874d29bd0cfa8e6e4ee79a", "input": "claim: Dictatorship Is the Best Path to Development.\n perspective: Dictatorships can prevent social unrest", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-02714cd6b21940bb921fc104be0b64c0", "input": "claim: Dictatorship Is the Best Path to Development.\n perspective: Society is put at ease when everyone is as equally under the thumb of the dictator as everyone else.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-5d8a89e6969f4d2d8587d47607422404", "input": "claim: Dictatorship Is the Best Path to Development.\n perspective: Dictatorship helps achieve social stability", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a8a9e8195eb64b299612b0fe70cf0db3", "input": "claim: Dictatorship Is the Best Path to Development.\n perspective: Dictatorship is a good breeding ground for personal discipline and order", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-374d2862ddfc42a291874e0c3ead64b2", "input": "claim: Dictatorship Is the Best Path to Development.\n perspective: Democracy acts in the interest of the general population, which is good for development", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-926d73694e1f48d79803d462ae189e23", "input": "claim: Dictatorship Is the Best Path to Development.\n perspective: Dictatorships assure low cost political stability", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-48affd5209b84e44b1ca3ce8bf2eb566", "input": "claim: Dictatorship Is the Best Path to Development.\n perspective: Dictatorships offer political stability by eliminating competition.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-99c674fff93a489996c86861903fb077", "input": "claim: Job applicants should have to disclose their spent criminal convictions.\n perspective: Provision of care services requires such disclosure", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-6bd9b955d66b4474a339d305e91e2825", "input": "claim: Job applicants should have to disclose their spent criminal convictions.\n perspective: In order to provide care for employees, they must disclose their criminal history.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ab1f86eb6a6f4d30b9a2bd77d681a3e4", "input": "claim: Job applicants should have to disclose their spent criminal convictions.\n perspective: Employees should be required to submit their criminal history in order to receive care services.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f20f61916f554050a4afb8d22eda5f02", "input": "claim: Job applicants should have to disclose their spent criminal convictions.\n perspective: When applying for jobs, it's important that former felons disclose their records.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-af446c2129694da397fc470a8b24dbf1", "input": "claim: Wind power should be a primary focus of future energy supply.\n perspective: The financial support required to further develop wind technology would be better deployed in more consistent processes such as geo-thermal and nuclear ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b6074bb954b14894b20b346f3aaf41f2", "input": "claim: Wind power should be a primary focus of future energy supply.\n perspective: Money would be better spent on geo-thermal and nuclear power than wind power.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e47829634a09467dbb2cafc821b01319", "input": "claim: Wind power should be a primary focus of future energy supply.\n perspective: The money needed to develop wind technology is wasted and would be more useful in developing geo-thermal and nuclear power.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b2f42366f68742bb9b82982ed64b4ea1", "input": "claim: Wind power should be a primary focus of future energy supply.\n perspective: Wind turbines represent a threat to the local wildlife habitat ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-112277eea6bb4d66b8f5a4ee8e1bc629", "input": "claim: Wind power should be a primary focus of future energy supply.\n perspective: Wind turbines are dangerous to animals and their habitats.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-3a36c0674acd4a819fee6675526666d3", "input": "claim: Wind power should be a primary focus of future energy supply.\n perspective: Wind energy provides for price stability in the long-term, wind will be with us for the duration", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f61d080f4e0d40f6a2102cfc934357c9", "input": "claim: Wind power should be a primary focus of future energy supply.\n perspective: Wind energy costs can be projected long term and wind will not go away.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ec75c7e80d964e2f92ac6a46eb536c59", "input": "claim: Wind power should be a primary focus of future energy supply.\n perspective: Wind energy prices will be stable and wind will always be around.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-84607ab6d3b54eca9d97c66bba727dc3", "input": "claim: Wind power should be a primary focus of future energy supply.\n perspective: Wind energy has a stable price in the long-term, it will be with us for the long haul", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-b563ef8b1c324ba4b082a6be9d57dc69", "input": "claim: Wind power should be a primary focus of future energy supply.\n perspective: Wind energy has a stable price in the long-term, it will be with us in perpetuity. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a008469d17b040868de6e4be9785f538", "input": "claim: Wind power should be a primary focus of future energy supply.\n perspective: Wind energy is unreliable and provides only an irregular source of supply – and even then only in some countries ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-984f0cd45f074d238857dfb8a00273a2", "input": "claim: Wind power should be a primary focus of future energy supply.\n perspective: Wind energy isn't reliable and is inconsistent.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-8cb3673d957f4a1987aef7ee59156cff", "input": "claim: Wind power should be a primary focus of future energy supply.\n perspective: Consistent and reliable wind energy isn't an option in all countries.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ac0afcafea234fee9b4ff8f6f37e18e0", "input": "claim: Wind power should be a primary focus of future energy supply.\n perspective: Wind energy is an economic form of energy generation reducing both running costs and environmental harm", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-5b60c6d0784c43c6bd79c3e93c4f70b3", "input": "claim: Wind power should be a primary focus of future energy supply.\n perspective: Wind energy costs less to operate and is better for the environment.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-8206aaaca51549288c9afd811973286a", "input": "claim: Wind power should be a primary focus of future energy supply.\n perspective: Wind energy lessens two things - cost to operate and environmental impact.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-0840fb50608d4bfca69e0f1b6f68f335", "input": "claim: Wind power should be a primary focus of future energy supply.\n perspective: Wind energy is an economically sound form of energy generation, which reduces both running costs and environmental harm .", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-434cb5619b444dffb025d46939af3fee", "input": "claim: Wind power should be a primary focus of future energy supply.\n perspective: Wind energy is an economical form of energy generation, it is good at reducing both running costs and environmental harm ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-78aa976410bd446f912599cb2ca596e2", "input": "claim: Wind power should be a primary focus of future energy supply.\n perspective: Wind energy provides a sustainable alternative to fossil fuels and nuclear power", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-60b57f881ec14f5dab0cbd3aab6bc112", "input": "claim: Wind power should be a primary focus of future energy supply.\n perspective: Wind energy is more sustainable than burning fossil fuels or using nuclear power.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-30529a46a477475b9279fadc146f1bdb", "input": "claim: Wind power should be a primary focus of future energy supply.\n perspective: Wind energy is a renewable energy option, whereas fossil fuels and nuclear power are not.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-32028587dfc2472997b4d1ea23ce7606", "input": "claim: Wind power should be a primary focus of future energy supply.\n perspective: Wind energy provides a sustainable alternative to our other more limited resources.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-77d6fa17a72743ad9c48fa1b22655ee7", "input": "claim: Wind power should be a primary focus of future energy supply.\n perspective: Wind energy provides a sustainable alternative as opposed to our use fossil fuels and nuclear power.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d4fe075db979400694ee95ce92eedb3e", "input": "claim: Wind power should be a primary focus of future energy supply.\n perspective: There is no instance in which renewable energy has been able to provide a major share in the energy market ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-77e71bce4bde4416ae9c2ee44de1b6ef", "input": "claim: Social Media should be part of the curriculum.\n perspective: It would be too difficult to get the class to concentrate.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-893ef1feddee46a4b9230aed55df5cc7", "input": "claim: Social Media should be part of the curriculum.\n perspective: Social media creates a positive atmosphere in the classroom.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-8cf9efde1d7d4cb498fb01ad1ae5c8b4", "input": "claim: Social Media should be part of the curriculum.\n perspective: Social media relates school to life.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-cb31addc44bd41ecab75e774fee8836e", "input": "claim: Social Media should be part of the curriculum.\n perspective: Social media is a good tool in a classroom.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c2d91f70d22a4201bc92afd796502610", "input": "claim: Social Media should be part of the curriculum.\n perspective: It teaches social responsibility", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ea855ac3b04d4b8e94bb0c8a9bccbc93", "input": "claim: Social Media should be part of the curriculum.\n perspective: Why teach someone to do what they already know how to do?", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-956ea91d33a34f68b8f78ae8f4789e3e", "input": "claim: We should show more compassion to drug addicts.\n perspective: We should obviously not like drug users", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-d7aeb347bcc94fa591bec59f4bbbbfbb", "input": "claim: We should show more compassion to drug addicts.\n perspective: Just because drug users deserve compassion doesn't mean we should like them in their drug addicted state. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4f138c8076ba4fd1b027e35cc33ea1ba", "input": "claim: We should show more compassion to drug addicts.\n perspective: Drug addiction isn't the addict's fault.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e76ba0ab717c4cd99159a80c974f54bc", "input": "claim: We should show more compassion to drug addicts.\n perspective: Drug addicts suffer from a disease.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-0abe6ee8a6db4b18bf26bb22b2e8e7fd", "input": "claim: We should show more compassion to drug addicts.\n perspective: Drug addiction is a disease that deserves the same compassionate care that cancer patients receive. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d8111ddfa3204167b53652f1a17168de", "input": "claim: We should show more compassion to drug addicts.\n perspective: Addiction is as much a disease as cancer and deserves the same compassionate care", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-33bcef2b1bf04a16a0e2533bbfbc6370", "input": "claim: Physical Education In Schools Should Be Compulsory.\n perspective: Participation in sport promotes a healthy lifestyle ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-5797e547803449b2a526e2662051971f", "input": "claim: Physical Education In Schools Should Be Compulsory.\n perspective: Compulsory physical education risks unnecessary and costly injury ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-0fd1fb54c0d440708ae1173344d036e6", "input": "claim: Physical Education In Schools Should Be Compulsory.\n perspective: Requiring physical education can cause unexpected and unnecessary injuries.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-2d3b461e2fe44bf1b9cd0eee5d8c67c8", "input": "claim: Physical Education In Schools Should Be Compulsory.\n perspective: The risk of a physical education requirement results in the risks of injury.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-1322c26bfd3a46ab991068c7830fd61a", "input": "claim: Gay couples should be allowed to marry.\n perspective: Gay marriage is good for society", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a08c5a4c388c4dec86077838d9a7471d", "input": "claim: Gay couples should be allowed to marry.\n perspective: Prominent religious bodies believe that non-heterosexuals seeking to be wed devalue the crucible of the marriage relationship.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b2ec199fcdfc43d49d003efa0659ea37", "input": "claim: Gay couples should be allowed to marry.\n perspective: Religion does not embraces marriage bonds between same-sex couples.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4e1cfb5fa1584653806d947518854a62", "input": "claim: Gay couples should be allowed to marry.\n perspective: Gay marriage is contrary to the word of God and is incompatible with the beliefs, sacred texts, and traditions of many religious groups. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c66b0f8502454cb193a109b1fa39e20d", "input": "claim: Gay couples should be allowed to marry.\n perspective: God condemns gay marriage in the Bible and it is not supported by a lot of churches. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-94d2c88df70546f98b919c998f17bd82", "input": "claim: Gay couples should be allowed to marry.\n perspective: Marriage is a religious institution, and the major world religions frown upon homosexuality", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-2eb651a3e065488fa2cba34fa4440f42", "input": "claim: Gay couples should be allowed to marry.\n perspective: Same-sex couples should have access to the same benefits enjoyed by heterosexual married couples. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-4c528435dad346268101ef46caeac43b", "input": "claim: Gay couples should be allowed to marry.\n perspective: Same-Sex marriages should have the same legal protections as regular marriages.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ef8a6527ccea4f5e8faa9803b991421b", "input": "claim: Gay couples should be allowed to marry.\n perspective: gays should be able to use thier rights", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-dcc23667270e441b99cc5d85f03565fa", "input": "claim: Gay couples should be allowed to marry.\n perspective: Gay couples should be able to take advantage of the fiscal and legal benefits of marriage", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-3b03402b26604041bc26f077f2bc48fc", "input": "claim: Gay couples should be allowed to marry.\n perspective: The institution of marriage has traditionally been defined as being between a man and a woman. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-8da02af09d8e41948d8f66fea5b96f85", "input": "claim: Gay couples should be allowed to marry.\n perspective: Matrimony is a bond between man and woman only.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c3c88f4365fb46829aa3a835ec644838", "input": "claim: Gay couples should be allowed to marry.\n perspective: Marriage should be between a man and a woman", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-1c05121706cf420b87792d10c5e0a5e1", "input": "claim: Gay couples should be allowed to marry.\n perspective: A proper marriage is between two heterosexual people of different genders.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-7333b526efc6488d88732b1464b32d3a", "input": "claim: Gay couples should be allowed to marry.\n perspective: State registrars conducting marriage ceremonies could not discriminate between homosexual and heterosexual couples", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a9e45a7344fa46c59ae6e91e40df9e3c", "input": "claim: Gay couples should be allowed to marry.\n perspective: Denying some people the option to marry is discriminatory and creates a second class of citizens. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d4617e86bea9424bbf7b6cd6fc46fe76", "input": "claim: Gay couples should be allowed to marry.\n perspective: It is discriminatory to refuse gay couples the right to marry", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-1f21d7502e264754bc89fae8ea3b2f39", "input": "claim: Gay couples should be allowed to marry.\n perspective: gay should not be refused to marry", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c65d93a7a2604a59b12a0a8d5debfa4d", "input": "claim: Gay couples should be allowed to marry.\n perspective: Marriage is about more than procreation, therefore gay couples should not be denied the right to marry due to their biology.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c1ab69e01fff4ba5b4985c1a6e797a72", "input": "claim: Gay couples should be allowed to marry.\n perspective: gay people should be able to marry", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-eb90904675e5483a874e9b17b09a2f53", "input": "claim: Gay couples should be allowed to marry.\n perspective: no matter what sexuality all should be able to marry", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-6f5df07291a24b3a9003a039a057e604", "input": "claim: Gay couples should be allowed to marry.\n perspective: Homosexuals would Change the Institution of Marriage for the Better", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-b71bb362c31b42629e8e133bb75f8769", "input": "claim: Gay couples should be allowed to marry.\n perspective: Gay marriage would improve all marriages.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-fc48700ac7574ad2b589f677ff671525", "input": "claim: Gay couples should be allowed to marry.\n perspective: EU Should Push Forward Equality for All of its Citizens Regardless of Sexuality", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-394a29cb26524746b4a9150689213575", "input": "claim: Gay couples should be allowed to marry.\n perspective: The EU should press for full equality regardless of sexuality.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ce7eb75796344e78936f899896f3259c", "input": "claim: Gay couples should be allowed to marry.\n perspective: The EU should remove obstacles to equality in sexual preference.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f76e649b4e424904a61e9c452bf5c92e", "input": "claim: Gay couples should be allowed to marry.\n perspective: Two people who want to get married should be able to, no matter their sexuality. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e7fa9f57f6464852a0616d1627868ebd", "input": "claim: Gay couples should be allowed to marry.\n perspective: Homosexuals should have the same rights as straight people.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d5588d63c59d4292a82e98350a44f42e", "input": "claim: Gay couples should be allowed to marry.\n perspective: Heterosexuals shouldn't enjoy greater rights than homosexuals.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-71420a9e37394b83af8655ff3fd092c4", "input": "claim: Gay couples should be allowed to marry.\n perspective: Same sex couple should have the same rights as heterosexual couples", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-21b00ec5d4ad4238a86d42b4bacfa2f9", "input": "claim: Gay couples should be allowed to marry.\n perspective: Marriage is an internationally recognized human right for all people. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ee761f1a9b024ba4be3e9396549058e4", "input": "claim: Gay couples should be allowed to marry.\n perspective: Gay people should have the same human rights as Heterosexuals", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-5a36789e8d21409eac41ea6133ed6e95", "input": "claim: Gay couples should be allowed to marry.\n perspective: Who says who can marry and who can't", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-3c3fc25ca60842578e36e1106fb71ca5", "input": "claim: Gay couples should be allowed to marry.\n perspective: All people have the right to marry.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ed53ddc027c2476db3f7753d2111246a", "input": "claim: Gay couples should be allowed to marry.\n perspective: Nature Suggests That Same Sex Marriage is Illogical", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-3fe0d879b85e47e59a42ec8e76015f2b", "input": "claim: Gay couples should be allowed to marry.\n perspective: From a logical standpoint same sex marriage is illogical.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b79519beff944fcb878ded2bea5ae14c", "input": "claim: Gay couples should be allowed to marry.\n perspective: Marriage is for procreation and should not be extended to same-sex couples because they cannot produce children together. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-7fd60edcffcf40ed83ab68478e42d5d0", "input": "claim: Gay couples should be allowed to marry.\n perspective: Legalizing gay marriage often leads to an end to domestic partnership benefits for gay and straight couples, which disadvantages couples who choose not to get married. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-0775cb88474646afbec576769debfe91", "input": "claim: Gay couples should be allowed to marry.\n perspective: If gay couples don't get married it means they lose benefits through the legalization of gay marriage.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-3c5ebe5c055744e0bf0c3c435f00075b", "input": "claim: Gay couples should be allowed to marry.\n perspective: Allowing gay couples to wed could further weaken the institution of marriage. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-05786a9cb58e463abe714cf749f5256a", "input": "claim: Gay couples should be allowed to marry.\n perspective: The institution of marriage has been weakened in recent years and allowing gay marriage will only further damage an already crumbling institution.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-7326f3af96ff4393909357ed3fcb6a43", "input": "claim: Gay couples should be allowed to marry.\n perspective: Gay marriage will not be a positive boost to the institution of marriage.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-2a265d9a4af6454faa6730029e28a17e", "input": "claim: Gay couples should be allowed to marry.\n perspective: Same-sex marriage is a civil right. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-0481c6b7ef394384ac321241e23ab4a5", "input": "claim: Gay couples should be allowed to marry.\n perspective: Our constitution is based on the idea that all people are equal and thus getting married is a civil right. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-8b31c864eaf94826b9641439dfe7711c", "input": "claim: Gay couples should be allowed to marry.\n perspective: People have fought for civil rights and same sex marriage is a civil right. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-9989360c158341acaccb51b249bde883", "input": "claim: Gay couples should be allowed to marry.\n perspective: Marriage is an outmoded, oppressive institution that should be weakened, not expanded. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a1a1e8f3dc5e4c53a2c21327c7206a2d", "input": "claim: Gay couples should be allowed to marry.\n perspective: Marriage is not something we should encourage or support.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-36307bfa40b447d091d2dc77ddb3b9db", "input": "claim: Gay couples should be allowed to marry.\n perspective: Legalizing gay marriage could lead down a \"slippery slope,\" giving people in polygamous, incestuous, bestial, and other nontraditional relationships the right to marry. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-3589ce46795f4efc875fc695bb9f85a2", "input": "claim: Gay couples should be allowed to marry.\n perspective: There are many types of marriage which are innaporpoate and dangerous which may be allowed if gay marriage is legalized. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-08b43595ce6945d7b27ff11d770a6d25", "input": "claim: Gay couples should be allowed to marry.\n perspective: Legalizing gay marriage is a stepping stone toward disgusting and harmful marriage practices such as incestuous, bestial and child marriages. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c1112ea459f74fe5a1ce1f4929de1b78", "input": "claim: Gay couples should be allowed to marry.\n perspective: Legalizing gay marriage advances the \"homosexual agenda\" and unfairly paints opponents as bigots. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-d03d5dc71d6b40f7ab4eeff6ebc88345", "input": "claim: Gay couples should be allowed to marry.\n perspective: Those against gay marriage are called names if gay marriage is legalized.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-07ac706fca0b4facaa2909a742aa1e1b", "input": "claim: Gay couples should be allowed to marry.\n perspective: Legalizing marriage by gays leads to the oppression of those who are against the practice.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-fd303835f6ce493b8b277b86b81523a9", "input": "claim: Gay couples should be allowed to marry.\n perspective: The idea of a \"traditional marriage\" is a modern convention and has not remained static over the centuries. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-fb0ccd6d2b5a4d3b9081cae828e887f3", "input": "claim: Gay couples should be allowed to marry.\n perspective: There is no historical basis for believing so called \"traditional marriages\" have been changeless over the centuries. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-5ce99d54d7164a8b8cc7fed4eda54d69", "input": "claim: Gay couples should be allowed to marry.\n perspective: Many religious leaders and churches support gay marriage and say it is consistent with scripture. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-84597528a9354f63af99d74fc7ffbc3c", "input": "claim: Gay couples should be allowed to marry.\n perspective: There is much debate about gay marriage but many religious leaders are in support of it regardless. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-69ce4ff4277f44d48c7b71c2eefcbb69", "input": "claim: Gay couples should be allowed to marry.\n perspective: Even though a vocal group of religious people disagrees with gay marriage, there is a growing number of religious leaders who support it and can back up their opinions with scripture. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-6eaef6ae6b6247a6aadbce5db203429f", "input": "claim: Gay couples should be allowed to marry.\n perspective: Legal marriage is a secular institution that should not be limited by religious objections to same-sex marriage. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-6eec54ccb54d40349960054526f4703f", "input": "claim: Gay couples should be allowed to marry.\n perspective: Religion does not have power over marriage and it should not be limited to heterosexual marriage based on that religion. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-7abfaa01745e4c99a9b07694f4a38931", "input": "claim: Gay couples should be allowed to marry.\n perspective: As a secular institution, marriage can not be limited to heterosexuals only based on religious ideals. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-538ff2275e8342e5804b2b729399020f", "input": "claim: Gay couples should be allowed to marry.\n perspective: Marriage provides both physical and psychological health benefits, and banning gay marriage increases rates of psychological disorders. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-071dfff84a7a41be85da5fe4f2309cba", "input": "claim: Gay couples should be allowed to marry.\n perspective: If gay marriage is banned, there is likely to be increased rates of psychological disorders. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-6cbe4a5a86784951afe098c88ff8bd3d", "input": "claim: Gay couples should be allowed to marry.\n perspective: We can reduce the prevalence of psychological disorders in the gay community by allowing gay marriage. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-81b28b2ad77847a4ac80f86562bc932c", "input": "claim: Gay couples should be allowed to marry.\n perspective: Legalizing gay marriage will not harm the institution of marriage, and same-sex marriages may even be more stable than heterosexual marriages. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-eece07b39ab44f6f9c4ccb61f10446f0", "input": "claim: Gay couples should be allowed to marry.\n perspective: The institution of marriage cannot be harmed by giving more people the freedom to marry and it may become the case that heterosexual marriage is less stable than same-sex marriage. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-03c7062a1b7d4a45b744364973848ddd", "input": "claim: Gay couples should be allowed to marry.\n perspective: Gay marriages can bring financial gain to federal, state, and local governments and can help boost the economy. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-5b4e78d73ef942d0875394950d2b6546", "input": "claim: Gay couples should be allowed to marry.\n perspective: There are economic advantages for states to approve gay marriages. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-444289809dda4d46a3233d5dea4e0fe7", "input": "claim: Gay couples should be allowed to marry.\n perspective: The economy of states can be boosted by allowing same-sex marriages. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-05f1426dd1fe49eaabb04b48decdad8e", "input": "claim: Money undermines sport’s values.\n perspective: It adds to sports value", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-0e7baa7a8a214321b81c49ebfe70ba2a", "input": "claim: Money undermines sport’s values.\n perspective: Sports loses its value because of the large amount of money involved.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-0a2a3956b84c460da8fc3f26eff42de1", "input": "claim: Money undermines sport’s values.\n perspective: College sports should be for competition not money.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ea401ed5bd8c40e481b701230c9959bf", "input": "claim: Money undermines sport’s values.\n perspective: Money adds value to sports.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-457eac1bf4c24c34bf82e1ddf796407e", "input": "claim: Money undermines sport’s values.\n perspective: Sports gain value through money.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-9ed8c86031b04102ac33de07db966aac", "input": "claim: Money undermines sport’s values.\n perspective: monetary pursuits outside of professional winnings take a players' attention off the game,close friends & family and their own health.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-7b91bb7e6e3d4996aa9de3e2fc0c4e77", "input": "claim: Abolish all collective bargaining rights claimed by trades unions.\n perspective: Collective bargaining leades to pay crises in the public sector", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-6cd02a07f0034c5babd5ec52d677d7c8", "input": "claim: Abolish all collective bargaining rights claimed by trades unions.\n perspective: Collective bargaining causes public sector pay crises", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-9881c76addd34e59bd505d0982c3c8d8", "input": "claim: Abolish all collective bargaining rights claimed by trades unions.\n perspective: Collective Bargaining Leads to an Overpaid Public Sector", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-623236840a4b49878a7c4ffaa2f98b5a", "input": "claim: Abolish all collective bargaining rights claimed by trades unions.\n perspective: Collective Bargaining can lead to overpaying the public sector.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-b70e3017a8dc4c2488cacc368985b0e8", "input": "claim: Abolish all collective bargaining rights claimed by trades unions.\n perspective: Collective Bargaining leads to overpayment of the public sector.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-b5bd81d6ae9347f0aff78f6f0f15a0b5", "input": "claim: Abolish all collective bargaining rights claimed by trades unions.\n perspective: Collective bargaining has been recognised as an enforcable right", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-782d1deee9bd4b40b8234ad101877878", "input": "claim: Abolish all collective bargaining rights claimed by trades unions.\n perspective: Collective Bargaining is a Right.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c0c5cc89cfad470a87527e4bb9c667a2", "input": "claim: Abolish all collective bargaining rights claimed by trades unions.\n perspective: We have the right to collective bargaining.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-92302cea60b34bdcb9e2ca1c3508f429", "input": "claim: Abolish all collective bargaining rights claimed by trades unions.\n perspective: Collective bargaining is detrimental to democracy.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-5527747fb44c4b0599b7cd4754758824", "input": "claim: Abolish all collective bargaining rights claimed by trades unions.\n perspective: Collective bargaining undermines the democractic process", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-4770b116f48e41cbab35af4fdbe46974", "input": "claim: Abolish all collective bargaining rights claimed by trades unions.\n perspective: Collective bargaining is undemocratic", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-70612f56ce2240bf94942ef58ba0f21a", "input": "claim: Abolish all collective bargaining rights claimed by trades unions.\n perspective: Collective Bargaining Hurts the Democratic Process", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-68cb7ec53a164782a4a3366610a422b7", "input": "claim: Abolish all collective bargaining rights claimed by trades unions.\n perspective: Democracy is hurt by collective bargaining.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-17422849092e474b81fa356866545712", "input": "claim: Abolish all collective bargaining rights claimed by trades unions.\n perspective: Collective bargaining is a necessary aspect of democracy", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-f62b34e1cbbe4c7db1b99fb3b8d9a8b4", "input": "claim: Abolish all collective bargaining rights claimed by trades unions.\n perspective: Democracy requires collective bargaining", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-7a22d8c8991a43ab9e19ab1602df1c18", "input": "claim: Abolish all collective bargaining rights claimed by trades unions.\n perspective: Collective bargaining is not a right", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-4c657b799d6e4eecb3fbeef8d3cb0470", "input": "claim: Abolish all collective bargaining rights claimed by trades unions.\n perspective: There is no right to collective bargaining", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-795ef4c4115b4f49bcd985feffa836c3", "input": "claim: Abolish all collective bargaining rights claimed by trades unions.\n perspective: No one has a right to collective bargaining", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-b8e83264730b4d978f29d73c451fd13f", "input": "claim: Abolish all collective bargaining rights claimed by trades unions.\n perspective: Collective bargaining is a counter to the creation of natural monopolies", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-216dbad499a34c8a877598efdddd67e6", "input": "claim: Abolish all collective bargaining rights claimed by trades unions.\n perspective: Natural monopolies require collective bargaining.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-63182698dc7744549931b26b41f4f0fd", "input": "claim: Abolish all collective bargaining rights claimed by trades unions.\n perspective: Collective bargaining is helpful with monopolies.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-17bd71f503fa479caddee8b59f57b719", "input": "claim: Abolish all collective bargaining rights claimed by trades unions.\n perspective: Collective bargaining counters the power of natural monopolies", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-af9b217afcb3400badacbea1d1e9147e", "input": "claim: Abolish all collective bargaining rights claimed by trades unions.\n perspective: Collective Bargaining is Especially Necessary in the Case of Natural Monopolies", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e897888e6c494460a6562211b4e6999a", "input": "claim: Abolish all collective bargaining rights claimed by trades unions.\n perspective: Collective Bargaining is Needed to Voice Opinion", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-75c5252c3d214131bff483493a3ea983", "input": "claim: Abolish all collective bargaining rights claimed by trades unions.\n perspective: In order to have voices heard, collective bargaining is needed.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-3cd1d16c4df348159118a40956d8332c", "input": "claim: Abolish all collective bargaining rights claimed by trades unions.\n perspective: We must maintain collective bargaining to hear all voices.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ac1b366cc97743bcb3f4c79b25140686", "input": "claim: There must be a system of universal healthcare.\n perspective: Universal healthcare is not affordable", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-02c01c8b979e4dd0bc78f32582684fbf", "input": "claim: There must be a system of universal healthcare.\n perspective: It costs too much money to support universal healthcare.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-8a799b04d6a9429ca98a1d9d13b14a68", "input": "claim: There must be a system of universal healthcare.\n perspective: Universal healthcare is just too expensive.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-bafc38f6fe3541b29a6e46a8a3390f26", "input": "claim: There must be a system of universal healthcare.\n perspective: Healthcare has been recognised as a right", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-b73469c2ab6741d5b957fde90f4218c3", "input": "claim: There must be a system of universal healthcare.\n perspective: Universal healthcare stifles innovation", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-cd7bd33a3efb49208eddde5a3156f3e6", "input": "claim: There must be a system of universal healthcare.\n perspective: Universal healthcare prevents healthcare advances.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-74b6cc5952b5492aa4b49bfb5a8c0d62", "input": "claim: There must be a system of universal healthcare.\n perspective: Universal healthcare doesn't allow for any new medical breakthroughs.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-9401d4f74bbd4f5d9ceb14a3e7a7ff4b", "input": "claim: Bottled water should be banned.\n perspective: In areas with bad drinking water we should use bottled water.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-770ef30878894d26b0aa9c480e5c2430", "input": "claim: Bottled water should be banned.\n perspective: Bottled water is a healthy alternative to sugar drinks.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-8d7b9551488043a1b24ac088aec52480", "input": "claim: Bottled water should be banned.\n perspective: Bottled water is good where there is a lack of healthy water", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-820d9d7d095a4f55a60171b1751ba05b", "input": "claim: Bottled water should be banned.\n perspective: Banning bottled water removes a healthy choice and leads to increased consumption of unhealthy sugary drinks.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-fa5e3639b55a4e1396a99d7c9f0de58a", "input": "claim: Bottled water should be banned.\n perspective: In some cases bottled water is useful.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a0d35412e3394f6c9a67c60a651bac52", "input": "claim: Bottled water should be banned.\n perspective: Bottled water is a practical emergency water supply. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-7e68f1b9c79240b6849c64c7fc33d22c", "input": "claim: Bottled water should be banned.\n perspective: We must have bottled water for emergency water.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4e929db6ffd4450ab7814fcc14073ab1", "input": "claim: Bottled water should be banned.\n perspective: Water must be stored in containers for emergencies and bottled water is the ideal solution.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-65402eeb99d947f296fe92d122ef123b", "input": "claim: Bottled water should be banned.\n perspective: Banning bottled water would save money, and public water fountains are convenient and plentiful. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-2aeeba9a546045e68188298748f7e0ed", "input": "claim: Bottled water should be banned.\n perspective: There are sufficient numbers of public water fountains to support banning bottled water to save money.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ba65525f9b7b4cdd96a3d318d0318628", "input": "claim: Bottled water should be banned.\n perspective: Banning bottled water restricts consumers' access to a product they want, and negatively affects small businesses. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e0a9ce911b3f4651b0ccf9d9541cc689", "input": "claim: Bottled water should be banned.\n perspective: Banning bottled water will negatively affect businesses.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-475f82dd56954cfa8003bfb1184d3a5a", "input": "claim: Bottled water should be banned.\n perspective: Banning bottled water restrict consumers ability to obtain water.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-889d04f9b7d1480496bb8e00556f0dc2", "input": "claim: Bottled water should be banned.\n perspective: Other types of beverages have plastic containers that are more harmful than plastic water bottles, and bans don't necessarily reduce waste.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-1cd0a68384704751b698cd91842042ed", "input": "claim: Bottled water should be banned.\n perspective: Most beverage have plastic containers so banning plastic water bottles is not the answer.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-efffa251e8c54bbaae42224a1f32286f", "input": "claim: Bottled water should be banned.\n perspective: With plastic container being so prevalent banning plastic water bottles will not reduce plastic waste.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-cf4c7d8e886e431997d7fcbeb598a4c8", "input": "claim: Bottled water should be banned.\n perspective: Banning bottled water would protect local water supplies", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-b9f2677723b843d5bace82962d71eeac", "input": "claim: Bottled water should be banned.\n perspective: Local water supplies would benefit from the banning of bottled water.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ef6008eee7d24557a7ef859f06f016aa", "input": "claim: Bottled water should be banned.\n perspective: Ending the use of bottled water would save local water supplies.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-5933da4aa95a46269b1bdadef71b5ffb", "input": "claim: Bottled water should be banned.\n perspective: Invaluable for travellers in areas with unsafe tap water", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-6c8cee38beb442759a33659a2a2f2c73", "input": "claim: Bottled water should be banned.\n perspective: Bottled water is important for travelers to avoid illnesss.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-626c7e0cf9564dc59670e1908867d39b", "input": "claim: Bottled water should be banned.\n perspective: Bottled water helps travelers avoid illness in areas with unsafe taps.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e7c8ffd1fa5e466891384fd1f2070bc8", "input": "claim: Bottled water should be banned.\n perspective: Invaluable for aid in natural disasters/famine", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-9a806c3f001943479eb1e363000f817a", "input": "claim: Bottled water should be banned.\n perspective: Bottled water costs up to 1,000 times the price of tap water", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d0fcb2de4be046b68fed7cea434b204f", "input": "claim: Bottled water should be banned.\n perspective: Bottled water is expensive.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-498306cf25e34102b9b6aed364abdea7", "input": "claim: Bottled water should be banned.\n perspective: The expense of bottled water is much greater than tap water.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-29df0842a31a450e94336bd9300d8ae1", "input": "claim: Bottled water should be banned.\n perspective: Its harmful to the environment", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-0bd1a0a725fb4b9b851a9888494e39e2", "input": "claim: Bottled water should be banned.\n perspective: Bottled water is not environmental friendly.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e9e3d8d6488d4395b7f631fb419dd46b", "input": "claim: Bottled water should be banned.\n perspective: The environment is hurt by bottled water.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-6d8f361d445a4aeba87ad645e380196e", "input": "claim: Books should have content warnings.\n perspective: People want to know what they're buying.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-3c763dcc2d114dbea8e3b3b084684634", "input": "claim: Books should have content warnings.\n perspective: People want to understand the contents of the book.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-99664eada65241569bb9faa69f76433c", "input": "claim: Books should have content warnings.\n perspective: People should be able to easily understand what is in the book.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-5d03376b82ed433ca16c56d1372bfa92", "input": "claim: Books should have content warnings.\n perspective: Danger of censorship.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b12d2b6901864699b7c50881a734dc19", "input": "claim: Books should have content warnings.\n perspective: Having warnings could lead to the censorships of books.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-af141f54fbb14110998e6940b4dae183", "input": "claim: Books should have content warnings.\n perspective: Content warnings are a slippery slope towards censorship.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-f1a3794eaac648118e8fedbdcd8f25d8", "input": "claim: Books should have content warnings.\n perspective: Written works should be subject to the same types of ratings systems as other entertainment media", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c401350b20784803935382b668eb8a13", "input": "claim: Books should have content warnings.\n perspective: Rating systems for other media have been effective for other media and should be used for books.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-407f8837306241d3917ed8d1b2265a06", "input": "claim: Books should have content warnings.\n perspective: Other entertainment media has used a rating system for a long time and books should start too.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-20ffa3deca4246f08ab07bf41d4056c0", "input": "claim: Books should have content warnings.\n perspective: Parents need advice when buying for children.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-787ffe80c5654896bd909467a1f73d62", "input": "claim: Books should have content warnings.\n perspective: Parents need to know if a book is appropriate for children.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-3e863f75969b4837ba888c1f61741db1", "input": "claim: Books should have content warnings.\n perspective: Parents want to make sure the books they get for kids could be inappropriate.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-5a6b5d1e7fc14a46bb458d9db4ef10b2", "input": "claim: Penalise religious hate speech.\n perspective: Regardless of the views expressed, freedom of speech means that all opinions should be heard. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-6f1aee8d557342b1be3bffc5c33a27c2", "input": "claim: Penalise religious hate speech.\n perspective: All speech should be free, no matter the content.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-9aae9d21b28847f7b8eb554b003214f1", "input": "claim: Penalise religious hate speech.\n perspective: Freedom of speech should be upheld, no matter what.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ec8c7987c5ed49ab8b2fc478bb22ca5d", "input": "claim: It is time to stop buying bottled water.\n perspective: Invaluable for travellers in areas with unsafe tap water", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b50fa23e097946efa85075e56f994bf2", "input": "claim: It is time to stop buying bottled water.\n perspective: Bottled water helps travelers avoid illness in areas with unsafe taps.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-694985eb3c6847c08420c452fbe96bbd", "input": "claim: It is time to stop buying bottled water.\n perspective: In areas with bad drinking water we should use bottled water.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a3ddf3982fc7482b998bb58b8bb1bdf4", "input": "claim: It is time to stop buying bottled water.\n perspective: Bottled water is a healthy alternative to sugar drinks.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b60498748428423eaac0bd65bb9ace46", "input": "claim: It is time to stop buying bottled water.\n perspective: Bottled water is good where there is a lack of healthy water", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-007887629f714404901f1db77cd7521a", "input": "claim: It is time to stop buying bottled water.\n perspective: Banning bottled water removes a healthy choice and leads to increased consumption of unhealthy sugary drinks.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-0649c87acab146038261ed6d9a06a822", "input": "claim: It is time to stop buying bottled water.\n perspective: In some cases bottled water is useful.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ff24eef5e6cb48b8b3ac2da26865b86b", "input": "claim: It is time to stop buying bottled water.\n perspective: Invaluable for aid in natural disasters/famine", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-1b5d23fa2cdd41b1be1827e6d1547f24", "input": "claim: It is time to stop buying bottled water.\n perspective: Bottled water costs up to 1,000 times the price of tap water", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-26ca5c4deaa54d9082541e1d87c53693", "input": "claim: It is time to stop buying bottled water.\n perspective: Bottled water is expensive.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-66182d1347584f02b8084fa143974d52", "input": "claim: It is time to stop buying bottled water.\n perspective: The expense of bottled water is much greater than tap water.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d2a73ca5ef734535931b8105700dd24a", "input": "claim: It is time to stop buying bottled water.\n perspective: Its harmful to the environment", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-5f2dcf0ea6314de8a06543d236a9400b", "input": "claim: It is time to stop buying bottled water.\n perspective: Bottled water is not environmental friendly.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-97adecd54b2c4e47b9454c2fbddcc4b8", "input": "claim: It is time to stop buying bottled water.\n perspective: The environment is hurt by bottled water.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-57d0f49759d74cc39a31b50e58b9d89a", "input": "claim: It is time to stop buying bottled water.\n perspective: Bottled water is a practical emergency water supply. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-eef21727546a4616bb64dcb0d265f813", "input": "claim: It is time to stop buying bottled water.\n perspective: We must have bottled water for emergency water.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a332bda162264781afeb486ac4516a5d", "input": "claim: It is time to stop buying bottled water.\n perspective: Water must be stored in containers for emergencies and bottled water is the ideal solution.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e2793a56f0e349179d36c7fb7653b551", "input": "claim: It is time to stop buying bottled water.\n perspective: Banning bottled water would save money, and public water fountains are convenient and plentiful. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-dc50bc48cd9f4d7a81c596a61a58a36c", "input": "claim: It is time to stop buying bottled water.\n perspective: There are sufficient numbers of public water fountains to support banning bottled water to save money.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-34a38139f4e44c8aa9b729e8195d54ab", "input": "claim: It is time to stop buying bottled water.\n perspective: Banning bottled water restricts consumers' access to a product they want, and negatively affects small businesses. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-563c96d352d4458b9b7cec1f7e752a40", "input": "claim: It is time to stop buying bottled water.\n perspective: Banning bottled water will negatively affect businesses.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-8871da7e186041609b6af131eacbd816", "input": "claim: It is time to stop buying bottled water.\n perspective: Banning bottled water restrict consumers ability to obtain water.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a2708a49e5f94691bdd0236909d5a3c1", "input": "claim: It is time to stop buying bottled water.\n perspective: Other types of beverages have plastic containers that are more harmful than plastic water bottles, and bans don't necessarily reduce waste.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-83019cb7753e4d45956b5716073fe5d7", "input": "claim: It is time to stop buying bottled water.\n perspective: Most beverage have plastic containers so banning plastic water bottles is not the answer.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-6eb6a678e0b548a0836b0f07908f4edc", "input": "claim: It is time to stop buying bottled water.\n perspective: With plastic container being so prevalent banning plastic water bottles will not reduce plastic waste.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-8be7ad923d61408293feb2c3cc01db1f", "input": "claim: It is time to stop buying bottled water.\n perspective: Banning bottled water would protect local water supplies", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ccea9145d0684291b6bd31f8211faacd", "input": "claim: It is time to stop buying bottled water.\n perspective: Local water supplies would benefit from the banning of bottled water.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-7fbf08f337124b6da363c9bcf5cc79f7", "input": "claim: It is time to stop buying bottled water.\n perspective: Ending the use of bottled water would save local water supplies.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a9a4b37efcd445bca5dddc51cc4f9584", "input": "claim: Britain should become a republic.\n perspective: Most other countries in Europe have abandoned the monarch", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-2bb56ea40c7e4c5095138578c582e79a", "input": "claim: Britain should become a republic.\n perspective: The Monarchy is backward and prejudiced", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a3fe81afd72340e586f8f1eb87277686", "input": "claim: Britain should become a republic.\n perspective: The Monarchy system is biased and inefficient.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-99831f5e09c44b2296dd6c45311c05a2", "input": "claim: Britain should become a republic.\n perspective: Regressive and biased is how the Monarchy system is.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-fdf1c9cf22154f0d9a6c3d2ebf1dfc9c", "input": "claim: Britain should become a republic.\n perspective: The Monarchy contrasts the meaning of Democracy", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-06e291501c2a4d8fbf0169bfc3387b1e", "input": "claim: Britain should become a republic.\n perspective: It is costing the tax payers money which could be better spent", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-92895fe5bca64b13b9e588b69ef61a82", "input": "claim: Britain should become a republic.\n perspective: Tax payers money could be spent more appropriately.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-b0abc18791664104aa4af24baf26bdfa", "input": "claim: Britain should become a republic.\n perspective: The tax payers are the ones losing out on money that could be spent properly.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-1635378eae0b46b8853e0bb193dfb752", "input": "claim: Britain should become a republic.\n perspective: tax payers money is valuable", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-6c10496e44ca4d0d8f5722161a31f43c", "input": "claim: Britain should become a republic.\n perspective: tax payers money should be useful only to the public", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a2f2803dc7c34d819cbc8665ba9e9181", "input": "claim: Britain should become a republic.\n perspective: Monarchy is a child's creation", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-defee24af9b04e87bec78bf1f8cafa30", "input": "claim: Britain should become a republic.\n perspective: Monarchy is just childish.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-5ca974b833054b3dbf491f1ff1e40ee5", "input": "claim: Britain should become a republic.\n perspective: Monarchy is an infantile idea.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-910a0129d71b48e49154a21599811bb7", "input": "claim: Britain should become a republic.\n perspective: it is high time to scrap monarchy", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-3725c3691cb543a2bf4dd86bb0f699de", "input": "claim: Britain should become a republic.\n perspective: monarchy in britain led to lots of chaos in the past", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-7491e20155e245ce8a8cbe5bcee39a83", "input": "claim: Forced marriage should be banned.\n perspective: Yes its slavery and rape.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a824b2edbddf40d18ff288afb9908ff1", "input": "claim: Forced marriage should be banned.\n perspective: The ban will give powers to police to crack down on the murky underworld of forced marriages", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-27ce7783110e461d9430aaf9f8727a24", "input": "claim: Forced marriage should be banned.\n perspective: Forced marriage is a barrier to integration", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-7d7e47a7bf6a42878fc93433498545b6", "input": "claim: Forced marriage should be banned.\n perspective: Regulating arranges marriages in EU countries would be impossible.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a8933d3583704b4d8697016476d5376e", "input": "claim: Forced marriage should be banned.\n perspective: It would be impossible to enforce a ban on arranged marriages in EU countries.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-772df6e79c3141d983be866cd7c178b4", "input": "claim: Forced marriage should be banned.\n perspective: The state should not regulate such personal matters. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-d29b9f93eec44c22baf7d3954f38bf0f", "input": "claim: Forced marriage should be banned.\n perspective: Personal matters should not be regulated by the state", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ee391ea3ebe24ca69c096d66fb244a04", "input": "claim: Forced marriage should be banned.\n perspective: Arranged marriages remains a personal choices and as such shouldn't be banned by the state.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-f7dd274e388b4c86b5d3ae2927d2f778", "input": "claim: Forced marriage should be banned.\n perspective: To ban arranged marriages in EU countries would initiate resentment from certain communities.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-11b601fdf0da4a2dad2f60d9a74a3626", "input": "claim: Forced marriage should be banned.\n perspective: Several communities in EU countries would feel targeted and begin to resent authorities should arranged marriages be banned.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-644c2e40d27541f8b6a0001b98d2c4a9", "input": "claim: America should have universal healthcare.\n perspective: Universal healthcare is not affordable", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-167d26c857ce44a4bf0bd714d9d3e075", "input": "claim: America should have universal healthcare.\n perspective: It costs too much money to support universal healthcare.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ce9ab843ddc846de99d6c161662cb47b", "input": "claim: America should have universal healthcare.\n perspective: Universal healthcare is just too expensive.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-0e400766fbe14047ac1ca53d1605f124", "input": "claim: America should have universal healthcare.\n perspective: Healthcare has been recognised as a right", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ede29ace7315478eaf2bc5df51246840", "input": "claim: America should have universal healthcare.\n perspective: Universal healthcare stifles innovation", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-04a2bf56520c46a58111e84907ed3784", "input": "claim: America should have universal healthcare.\n perspective: Universal healthcare prevents healthcare advances.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-884ba232698e474fbee37d891e8ce034", "input": "claim: America should have universal healthcare.\n perspective: Universal healthcare doesn't allow for any new medical breakthroughs.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-0c3e69d9bfb34ddf8492b7b334d5cae8", "input": "claim: Widen the East African Community.\n perspective: Education standards will be improved across the region", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ba9e1cbbed0f42bcaad84d05c4073de5", "input": "claim: Terrorists should be subject to the Geneva Conventions.\n perspective: With no hope of reciprocity, adherence to the Geneva Conventions would undermine the fight against terrorism.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ee49739273d144da9a2c503346fea9aa", "input": "claim: Terrorists should be subject to the Geneva Conventions.\n perspective: There are other means by which to protect the rights of terrorists without needing to apply the Geneva Conventions.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e1a38e73557a4f03a7ae7a943cea6a11", "input": "claim: We have to cut the length of copyright protection.\n perspective: Long copyright stifles creative responses to and re-workings of the original work", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-5ac7b096cd84456788a24dbac75624e0", "input": "claim: We have to cut the length of copyright protection.\n perspective: Artists deserve to profit from their work and copyright provides just recompense", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4a91850467504250bbfa0f1c1628173a", "input": "claim: It is morally permissible for victims to use deadly force as a deliberate response to repeated domestic violence.\n perspective: No, because the resolution states the action as \"in response\" rather than \"in defense\". ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-15bc1690cb15467db1d07a11a1a96243", "input": "claim: It is morally permissible for victims to use deadly force as a deliberate response to repeated domestic violence.\n perspective: It is not morally allowed unless someone is defending themselves", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a4cf8b70f1a14b14a21aad4ce9749d9f", "input": "claim: It is morally permissible for victims to use deadly force as a deliberate response to repeated domestic violence.\n perspective: They are allowed to defend themselves but not to actively engage ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-037e6d6b20ae4b9da15714f749ba5e9b", "input": "claim: It is morally permissible for victims to use deadly force as a deliberate response to repeated domestic violence.\n perspective: It is not acceptable for victims to use deadly force, no matter what the reason", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-3ef6c771e85f48a2a26338541620ce90", "input": "claim: It is morally permissible for victims to use deadly force as a deliberate response to repeated domestic violence.\n perspective: It is not morally acceptable for a person to harm another for any reason", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-83e64b91cd894c658e518ff99e5d1772", "input": "claim: It is morally permissible for victims to use deadly force as a deliberate response to repeated domestic violence.\n perspective: Deadly force is justifiable for domestic violence.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e983b1a7a7624272952f62a718779d44", "input": "claim: It is morally permissible for victims to use deadly force as a deliberate response to repeated domestic violence.\n perspective: If victims experience domestic violence repeatedly, it's morally okay for them to use deadly force to defend themselves", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-eafe89b134ed4f5c9588d25af6877163", "input": "claim: It is morally permissible for victims to use deadly force as a deliberate response to repeated domestic violence.\n perspective: It is morally acceptable for victims to defend themselves from repeated domestic abuse", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d16156f370764918aac11579c009d07a", "input": "claim: Airbrushing of women’s bodies in the media be banned.\n perspective: A ban may make the problem worse", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-88e041c04b8945a2b30c944cc15bb723", "input": "claim: Airbrushing of women’s bodies in the media be banned.\n perspective: Prohibiting it will make the situation even more dire.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-844c852649b841deb990b2ec7cf8ac02", "input": "claim: Airbrushing of women’s bodies in the media be banned.\n perspective: Restrictions will not help, instead will will worsen the problem.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-1052d835f3ec40b2af22958b1b2ee8ae", "input": "claim: Airbrushing of women’s bodies in the media be banned.\n perspective: Allows everyone to be perfect", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-28b293abad7e40208c5ae292741c92b0", "input": "claim: Airbrushing of women’s bodies in the media be banned.\n perspective: Banning would help create a beneficial cultural shift", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-9011bb5698bf44d1a520f7778b8eee8c", "input": "claim: Airbrushing of women’s bodies in the media be banned.\n perspective: Objectification of women’s bodies", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-bf73e110fef64154b6f9f91743522fc2", "input": "claim: Airbrushing of women’s bodies in the media be banned.\n perspective: Would give women the opportunity to speak out", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d7ef3dfa1f0d4452820e3e3fe834485d", "input": "claim: There must be a ban the sale of 3D printers to households.\n perspective: The state should refrain from imposing bans", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-438e69d1f03d4966b1a5e35b6ea60a0a", "input": "claim: There must be a ban the sale of 3D printers to households.\n perspective: The states should not impose bans.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c50dbc8123614c54af886adeb449459a", "input": "claim: There must be a ban the sale of 3D printers to households.\n perspective: The states should hold back on imposing bans.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b285e0b4de3f49328afc6aa310476e27", "input": "claim: There must be a ban the sale of 3D printers to households.\n perspective: Household 3D printing can, in the short term, destroy developing economies", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f63d8c45af8d46b1998a503fc3c8b0f7", "input": "claim: There must be a ban the sale of 3D printers to households.\n perspective: House printers are destroying developing economies in the short term.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-40cffb929d8c4646bd6725d6f27c0232", "input": "claim: There must be a ban the sale of 3D printers to households.\n perspective: Private 3D printers make it impossible to regulate illegal products", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e58bcb81c4a64a39a525f2f1e253c56c", "input": "claim: There must be a ban the sale of 3D printers to households.\n perspective: It is too easy to create illegal products when individuals own 3D printers.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-7f2a4be0e9354da1b24d0d80ff8d4f54", "input": "claim: There must be a ban the sale of 3D printers to households.\n perspective: 3D printers owned by individuals can be used to create illegal products.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a7610445a583420dab2c02e2f845e428", "input": "claim: There must be a ban the sale of 3D printers to households.\n perspective: Democratising manufacturing gives people more freedom", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-8ac32150e19d49cba1a95ab528c145a3", "input": "claim: There must be a ban the sale of 3D printers to households.\n perspective: Democratization gives people more freedom.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-07fcac594f99444989247ac9ac49913c", "input": "claim: There must be a ban the sale of 3D printers to households.\n perspective: Democratization gives people more freedom than having to be limited to a company.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-9c1f284d43bf474faf657e5ff9de8f65", "input": "claim: There must be a ban the sale of 3D printers to households.\n perspective: Banning 3D printers wastes a chance for innovation", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-5d41da7293f84de0b8de3504dac3295f", "input": "claim: There must be a ban the sale of 3D printers to households.\n perspective: Banning 3D printers is a waste of time.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-366140cd974b4f60be4a6e02d58fe220", "input": "claim: There must be a ban the sale of 3D printers to households.\n perspective: Banning 3D printers is a waste of a chance at pure innovation.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a2d2978162ae433686d0da1f391bf5fc", "input": "claim: Cramming before exams is a bad idea.\n perspective: Long sessions of cramming are totally inefficient", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-6fee74cdc57f438fa6c7e172045121d7", "input": "claim: Cramming before exams is a bad idea.\n perspective: Cramming sessions are ineffective in learning material for exams.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-61c1284d412945a6aec9923715a26071", "input": "claim: Cramming before exams is a bad idea.\n perspective: It is a waste of time to cram for exams.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-dbd83c1364b74d539387efd7ac59b14b", "input": "claim: Cramming before exams is a bad idea.\n perspective: Creates a culture of doing enough to pass exams that actually aquiring knowledge", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-3ec33da40a584139b4786298380ed298", "input": "claim: Compensation should be paid for those who have had their culture appropriated.\n perspective: Compensation has the potential to reverse damaged caused by Cultural Appropriation.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-7c004db2825e46e5ab0211070e65f182", "input": "claim: Compensation should be paid for those who have had their culture appropriated.\n perspective: cultural appropriation damage can potentialy be reversed through compensation", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-bc36c2334065449dae0607e8bd64efa8", "input": "claim: Compensation should be paid for those who have had their culture appropriated.\n perspective: compensation may be able to reverse damage caused by culture appropriation", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d933ba50f3aa4391a148216527b91292", "input": "claim: Compensation should be paid for those who have had their culture appropriated.\n perspective: Compensation is important to give the communities credit they deserve. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f68b02dfb3ea4db29e7b97af67c91851", "input": "claim: Compensation should be paid for those who have had their culture appropriated.\n perspective: it is immportant for the communities to get the credit they deserve through compensation", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-0962ed7385f54a0e9f55d8de5dee6223", "input": "claim: Compensation should be paid for those who have had their culture appropriated.\n perspective: compensation is a way to give the communities the credit they deserve", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ea2944128929400d92bfaf0188946b3f", "input": "claim: Compensation should be paid for those who have had their culture appropriated.\n perspective: Reparations and the use of the term 'cultural appropriation' is a mask for more deep-rooted issues of racism in society. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-7eded81559bf43d09cf6ce7e404000f8", "input": "claim: Compensation should be paid for those who have had their culture appropriated.\n perspective: No feasible system of which grounds of compensation can occur because of the fluidity of culture and cultural identity", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b4351952a7694cc298864bd2c394bcd1", "input": "claim: State funding to universities have to be conditioned upon all academic work being made available to the general public.\n perspective: It reduces the ability of universities to be self-sufficient and to fund other less potentially profitable pursuits", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-87a1fcaccb9945d19939f3f777a8c8e0", "input": "claim: State funding to universities have to be conditioned upon all academic work being made available to the general public.\n perspective: This problem prevents the university from being self-sufficient and funding less profitable projects.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-31204cc0378245ce89790db055688313", "input": "claim: State funding to universities have to be conditioned upon all academic work being made available to the general public.\n perspective: The university is unable to be sustainable and fund other profitable pursuits because of this problem.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-99fbae27e99249f4836c77e37c830b97", "input": "claim: State funding to universities have to be conditioned upon all academic work being made available to the general public.\n perspective: Academic work produced by means of public funds belongs to the public", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c1a3fab40e9740bcb95bc18b6139ef60", "input": "claim: State funding to universities have to be conditioned upon all academic work being made available to the general public.\n perspective: The opening up of information to the public encourages further research and development", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-8e3213ccbc5744a78da0a68518a180c9", "input": "claim: State funding to universities have to be conditioned upon all academic work being made available to the general public.\n perspective: We can futher the research and development of these projects by giving more information to the public.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-3a962fed9d7c42f4872ffb16a6f19b90", "input": "claim: State funding to universities have to be conditioned upon all academic work being made available to the general public.\n perspective: If we are willing to give our customers and consumers more company information, then we are able to persue our development and research on projects.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f99e647db04c4252aff7ef511f5b9932", "input": "claim: State funding to universities have to be conditioned upon all academic work being made available to the general public.\n perspective: A publicly-funded inventor or researcher still deserves to profit from their efforts", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-82f9d4fe37954b6ab542670b559badb2", "input": "claim: Everyone Should Automatically Be Opted into an Organ Donation Scheme.\n perspective: What if a doctor decides to 'let you go' to get an organ?", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-34779f898f3d48149e61e44659bb4c8c", "input": "claim: Everyone Should Automatically Be Opted into an Organ Donation Scheme.\n perspective: Some people will be distressed by the removal of their loved-ones’ organs", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-18280a3ccc9f4f2ca0dd539991aee8f4", "input": "claim: Everyone Should Automatically Be Opted into an Organ Donation Scheme.\n perspective: Most people support organ donation, only a few carry the card", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ab25cc5694d54d28935894853987ae3c", "input": "claim: Everyone Should Automatically Be Opted into an Organ Donation Scheme.\n perspective: What if your loved-one was a recipient?", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-feb31260499f4946800cdd7813811163", "input": "claim: Everyone Should Automatically Be Opted into an Organ Donation Scheme.\n perspective: What use are organs to you when you’re dead?", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-934a2b978608492fbf613f9ef691f942", "input": "claim: Everyone Should Automatically Be Opted into an Organ Donation Scheme.\n perspective: It will be difficult to opt-out", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-dbf811b74eb0419c8670913ba614da6e", "input": "claim: Everyone Should Automatically Be Opted into an Organ Donation Scheme.\n perspective: Other countries that have it have not seen a direct increase in donation.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-bf94bfb20b154b8db32ad53b298e4c53", "input": "claim: Everyone Should Automatically Be Opted into an Organ Donation Scheme.\n perspective: According other countries, it hasn't increased donation.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c47dd34ebaff47129cfbb84cacc28c8c", "input": "claim: Everyone Should Automatically Be Opted into an Organ Donation Scheme.\n perspective: There's no direct correlation with other countries showing an increase in donations.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e66f4a116bc04d0881f13a26a6eca744", "input": "claim: Everyone Should Automatically Be Opted into an Organ Donation Scheme.\n perspective: new ways should be expolred to attract people to be organ donors.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a8b8080c56ce4b1082de5bd5ebbc647c", "input": "claim: Everyone Should Automatically Be Opted into an Organ Donation Scheme.\n perspective: organ donation cannot be made compulsory", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-94b536d08a474ca588518193b9b31da3", "input": "claim: Everyone Should Automatically Be Opted into an Organ Donation Scheme.\n perspective: organ donation is a good thing", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-745d319d08094a6b9cdd02979201a8cc", "input": "claim: It makes sense to drive to an out of town to a shopping centre.\n perspective: Out of town retail developments are bad for the environment", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4bc80d7bda114803b20c4467a1782b1f", "input": "claim: It makes sense to drive to an out of town to a shopping centre.\n perspective: Out of town malls damage town centres", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e4035f18445949b8884a388395e26f45", "input": "claim: It makes sense to drive to an out of town to a shopping centre.\n perspective: Out of town malls can hinder the development of downtown areas.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-9013e9398e42435a9c5b5e58546dc528", "input": "claim: Professional sportsmen must be required to represent their countries at the international level.\n perspective: A moral duty to play for your country", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-faa0e083df2744e4b8f2145c258a08b7", "input": "claim: Professional sportsmen must be required to represent their countries at the international level.\n perspective: A sense of moral obligation to play for your country.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-edf5008f26b34ebb8b294a1f8917b255", "input": "claim: Professional sportsmen must be required to represent their countries at the international level.\n perspective: A civilly moral obligation to play for your country.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-826d44a4e6864e2e9dcf1d23e6cd7905", "input": "claim: Professional sportsmen must be required to represent their countries at the international level.\n perspective: Playing for your country is a mortal duty. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d44bef470252461ba7bc8694db1d3658", "input": "claim: Professional sportsmen must be required to represent their countries at the international level.\n perspective: A mortal duty requires you to play for your country.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-5f37866ce4f24a90a9cb5bec93a341a4", "input": "claim: Professional sportsmen must be required to represent their countries at the international level.\n perspective: Beneficial for the player ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f3ce7a2023004f3dbb93aee115dcc524", "input": "claim: Professional sportsmen must be required to represent their countries at the international level.\n perspective: There is no need for compulsion ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b0dd357dbb244df49f5980d47ae977f0", "input": "claim: Professional sportsmen must be required to represent their countries at the international level.\n perspective: Benefits to the nation", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-2970ddaebcfc4c25882348b166f03a2a", "input": "claim: Hate speech on campus has to censored.\n perspective: Danger to students", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d83e1f4dc59d44aba4967ece43d1e434", "input": "claim: Hate speech on campus has to censored.\n perspective: Universities are bastions of free expression", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-28e7a241885342feb10dfee93e50800b", "input": "claim: Hate speech on campus has to censored.\n perspective: Universities allow for free expression.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-572cbc4896014191a53661bd15f8b0df", "input": "claim: Hate speech on campus has to censored.\n perspective: Free expression is common at universities.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-94708caa2d01420a83f05ed74fca1cb2", "input": "claim: Hate speech on campus has to censored.\n perspective: Freedom of expression is a means to education", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-f38123cfd3f2446384950542fdfcf72a", "input": "claim: Hate speech on campus has to censored.\n perspective: Freedom of expression is a political right", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-031f17855da647cfbb4e5534a136c4f7", "input": "claim: Hate speech on campus has to censored.\n perspective: Free expression is an inalienable right.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-d1358a9a37694ccea976940b6d4fa433", "input": "claim: Hate speech on campus has to censored.\n perspective: Political rights include freedom of expression.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-777bff16d8c843a5b1e90214964e67f5", "input": "claim: Hate speech on campus has to censored.\n perspective: The marketplace of ideas", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c3e84204663d44f0a3726063905edc75", "input": "claim: Healthy eating should be made mandatory.\n perspective: Too hard to enforce", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-287e65efae894194bb21f0e0d4af61ab", "input": "claim: Healthy eating should be made mandatory.\n perspective: It is too difficult to govern.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4f236e187f374451b0411f32ea76b5bf", "input": "claim: Healthy eating should be made mandatory.\n perspective: Enforcement is nearly impossible. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e6a8da0e852a44a1b418071a30a66021", "input": "claim: Healthy eating should be made mandatory.\n perspective: There is no one healthy diet", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-d7af0d00af2043ff83a00d913bc5a3f1", "input": "claim: Healthy eating should be made mandatory.\n perspective: Our economy suffers because of unhealthy eating", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f997b4996d594cc9b023e1b89a152120", "input": "claim: Gender Equality is Treating Men and Women in the Same Way.\n perspective: You have to treat people differently in order to reach equality", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4a103880fb5b40e6a8f48b63a7df505e", "input": "claim: Gender Equality is Treating Men and Women in the Same Way.\n perspective: Positive discrimination towards women should not be allowed", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-5a571e687cce4d17bbdde0673be7e60e", "input": "claim: Gender Equality is Treating Men and Women in the Same Way.\n perspective: Positive discrimination towards women should be allowed", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-11d27f4bd4ba4788a978804330ac4108", "input": "claim: Gender Equality is Treating Men and Women in the Same Way.\n perspective: It is right to treated women differently than men in some cases. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e7406eb0f4b64e01ba1b7796e9e1d65b", "input": "claim: Gender Equality is Treating Men and Women in the Same Way.\n perspective: Due to physical difference between men and women, it's ok to have some positive discrimination towards women. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-208c103c6b9545438e90ddfe34600bcf", "input": "claim: Gender Equality is Treating Men and Women in the Same Way.\n perspective: Positive discrimination for women is discrimination", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-605aa381c99f47e196eb8fcabf7e0b61", "input": "claim: Gender Equality is Treating Men and Women in the Same Way.\n perspective: All-women shortlists or quotas restrict a constituent's freedom of choice", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-189d53e23ca84fea9cb94064f3897c38", "input": "claim: Gender Equality is Treating Men and Women in the Same Way.\n perspective: Positive discrimination takes away voters' freedom of choice by limiting their choices to women", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-b573252141db465faec6027adb79141b", "input": "claim: Catcher in the Rye is a bad book.\n perspective: The book is too long", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-2f9ba7440f9a476696702521c2dead14", "input": "claim: Catcher in the Rye is a bad book.\n perspective: The book is depressing", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-4ccd285c9d194b7d92621013838d70fb", "input": "claim: Wikileaks is not and has never been a non-profit organization.\n perspective: Wikileaks is not registered. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ab6a40afc1614f13afe66cc79bca1f55", "input": "claim: Create an African Criminal Court.\n perspective: ICC treats Africa differently", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-6b77127771df4af68b19a4e587168349", "input": "claim: Create an African Criminal Court.\n perspective: ICC is biased against Africans ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-97d4d1186a414cfbbc28796f346c3995", "input": "claim: Create an African Criminal Court.\n perspective: The ICC is against African ideals.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-5061fcf9f2704a369773bcc7824d18e3", "input": "claim: Create an African Criminal Court.\n perspective: The ICC is in direct opposition of African beliefs. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-aeac7c4998e349bf91de73d57f95f344", "input": "claim: Create an African Criminal Court.\n perspective: The ICC has an anti-African bias", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-20a6b6b7b5cb49d2bb4eee8ce8423435", "input": "claim: Create an African Criminal Court.\n perspective: ACC could deal with pan-African problems that the ICC does not address", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-99c4e06be412495398311282fa408803", "input": "claim: Create an African Criminal Court.\n perspective: Africa has a strong voice in the ICC ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-91d68fb31ecf459d8401f81e163507ec", "input": "claim: Only buildings that are historically important should be preserved.\n perspective: Tastes change over time", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4a994648e44a4c00a9f24f0b1905a1f2", "input": "claim: Mixed Martial Arts (UFC) is a form of human cockfighting.\n perspective: Depending where you are in the world, some of the rules do appear brutal", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-b6453f9649e7461f9fd012f806cf7af3", "input": "claim: Mixed Martial Arts (UFC) is a form of human cockfighting.\n perspective: MMA is Human Cock Fighting", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-3fec70c5bdca4f13b9b84f76eac142e0", "input": "claim: Store nuclear waste underground.\n perspective: Storing nuclear waste underground is necessary - there are no better option available", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a5fca93bfbfe485c87a66fb2ce466ff0", "input": "claim: Store nuclear waste underground.\n perspective: Nuclear waste can be put to beneficial uses", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-1c100f2b1728492d85ca3014fafcff18", "input": "claim: Store nuclear waste underground.\n perspective: Nuclear waste can be used in other forms of power generation", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-2d4f1b88685c4b6392cd012ca95ba04b", "input": "claim: Store nuclear waste underground.\n perspective: Underground nuclear storage is safer than any available alternative", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-640a36b468b14c9f87a347960fd9215f", "input": "claim: Store nuclear waste underground.\n perspective: Storing nuclear waste underground is safer than any other storage method.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-89869496ce5b42f483598521449b4b8d", "input": "claim: Store nuclear waste underground.\n perspective: The best place to store nuclear waste is underground.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-3758d3891ff145ae9ed2bdd7657cf310", "input": "claim: Store nuclear waste underground.\n perspective: Underground nuclear storage is excessively expensive", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-cef4c7a2f00440b5acba638905d1d103", "input": "claim: Store nuclear waste underground.\n perspective: Storing nuclear waste underground is very expensive.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-1768e49369554820afc1d1869431f6e9", "input": "claim: Store nuclear waste underground.\n perspective: It's very costly to store nuclear waste underground.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-6eeed256527749b3afb9e70f15fcf6dc", "input": "claim: We should support universal basic income.\n perspective: Universal Basic Income (UBI) takes money from the poor and gives it to everyone, increasing poverty and depriving the poor of needed targeted support", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-204de9fdd1014e80b93939fbc4874489", "input": "claim: Self-determination of peoples is a human right.\n perspective: Self-determination is necessary to protect minority cultures.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-33668dc4f8574fa2ae7cf825b2c6eaa0", "input": "claim: Self-determination of peoples is a human right.\n perspective: Minority cultures must have self-determination to succeed.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c296eb26efbf4364810228670505f2e1", "input": "claim: Self-determination of peoples is a human right.\n perspective: Without self-determination, minority cultures cannot be protected.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d0d388caedaa4ef4a794937c5dde9d27", "input": "claim: Self-determination of peoples is a human right.\n perspective: What matters are individual democratic rights, not necessarily collective self-determination.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-00fd74095c764f86b2b332876a3b13ea", "input": "claim: Self-determination of peoples is a human right.\n perspective: Individual democratic rights are more important than collective self-determination.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-323c72fce4c94389931e7af603be68c6", "input": "claim: Self-determination of peoples is a human right.\n perspective: The rights of the individual in democracies is more important than collective self-determination.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-d56b86ca606248978afe2e4755f3deb7", "input": "claim: Self-determination of peoples is a human right.\n perspective: Self-determination can destabilise nation states, sometimes with very destructive consequences.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-17cf4a2939e44f43b5605012540d6886", "input": "claim: Self-determination of peoples is a human right.\n perspective: Self-determination embodies the fundamental right of peoples to decide their own futures.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-344b2e2c466641a2a819418380ba94d8", "input": "claim: Self-determination of peoples is a human right.\n perspective: Self-determination is about deciding your own fate.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-becb2d9902724347b77abbb8dfa61efd", "input": "claim: Self-determination of peoples is a human right.\n perspective: All peoples have a fundamental right to determine their own future.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-71f34a19221543a9b4288c57ed6eff99", "input": "claim: Self-determination of peoples is a human right.\n perspective: Self-determination offers a way to resolve otherwise intractable disputes.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f5a6ef5d25384a1cba1f15a24780fbc5", "input": "claim: Self-determination of peoples is a human right.\n perspective: Without self-determination, some disputes are unsolvable.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-7e07c031a74c4f89addfe2e214d5d0a6", "input": "claim: Self-determination of peoples is a human right.\n perspective: Self-determination is how we resolve some intractable issues.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-765a7259f8ee4b169c02201bd891f1ad", "input": "claim: Self-determination of peoples is a human right.\n perspective: Self-determination and independence is recognition of the fact that indigenous peoples were unfairly treated by colonial powers, and their proprietary rights abused.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-699bea455b0f477e981384a11b220825", "input": "claim: Self-determination of peoples is a human right.\n perspective: The rise of universal human rights makes self-determination increasingly irrelevant.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c3970d5cefcf43d58ed45e589fd3e09d", "input": "claim: Self-determination of peoples is a human right.\n perspective: Universal human rights makes self-determination less important.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-2d3a1d44443346a18cda810aa24a2b54", "input": "claim: Self-determination of peoples is a human right.\n perspective: Self-determination is irrelevant in the era of universal human rights.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-f16df15e44f44057a70f865f9aba81e2", "input": "claim: The expenditure of money should be protected as speech.\n perspective: Money is intrinsic to political speech.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-50b22a91173245ac94bb558ac2dd1b0f", "input": "claim: The expenditure of money should be protected as speech.\n perspective: Money stifles, it does not advance debate. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-11530e1945cf4153a013da40257408ec", "input": "claim: Google is the extremely reliable source of information.\n perspective: Google wins as newspapers battle ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-8dc3bc6eda3f4a4e8abce5bda18729c8", "input": "claim: Google is the extremely reliable source of information.\n perspective: Infighting among newspapers has led to a boom for google information.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-541813fd57fa416e9720c71bebbd2fd5", "input": "claim: Google is the extremely reliable source of information.\n perspective: As newspaper battle each other over credibility users turn to google for the news.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-508e3b3ee7464172904a9b23fbd77003", "input": "claim: Google is the extremely reliable source of information.\n perspective: Use google as a way to find multiple sources of agreeing information.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-3839e351fa78411db0e2de7d11d21cbe", "input": "claim: Google is the extremely reliable source of information.\n perspective: Google dependency is risky business", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a37b61f479e3402584ec64ac116ebcfd", "input": "claim: Google is the extremely reliable source of information.\n perspective: Google throttles some information so depending on it is risky.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b7a91d5bc64541f48afbf15ca6ea0cbe", "input": "claim: Google is the extremely reliable source of information.\n perspective: Google promotes what makes it money so dependence on it for reliable information has risks.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-37f2769c4f574ca69719e6e074a1ca5e", "input": "claim: We believe in the right to reply.\n perspective: There is a sense of natural justice that corrections should come in this form rather than a tiny note.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e65fe7289aed4519a4584afafe5d78d8", "input": "claim: We believe in the right to reply.\n perspective: Anyone can respond to critique.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a4ee924ce419489386a1475816696102", "input": "claim: We believe in the right to reply.\n perspective: Protests are a natural form of response.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-49e19ce842024ee6bfb9431347fe3663", "input": "claim: We believe in the right to reply.\n perspective: natural justice should not come by a note", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a2baeb84971043fda0d50b8b9d747d8e", "input": "claim: We believe in the right to reply.\n perspective: justice that is natural should not come in the form of a tiny note", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-bfb27541b8bc496da4aa0f727788ce7b", "input": "claim: We believe in the right to reply.\n perspective: It is only fair where something inaccurate has been said to allow for a correction.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-9fb9a2b887d1404199d65681f3fff799", "input": "claim: We believe in the right to reply.\n perspective: This undermines actual parity by creating a false sense of the right to reply.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-650a2eb129ba4b53adf2c7393e9d14aa", "input": "claim: We believe in the right to reply.\n perspective: Persons should not be dissuaded from response. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-2fd266314e374630b2b35716a295701d", "input": "claim: We believe in the right to reply.\n perspective: This will undermine real parity by making a false sense of the right to reply", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a544d51692e44ce3be221a33e3ef5788", "input": "claim: Drones Should Be Used to Take Out Enemy Combatants.\n perspective: there is nothing illegal in the use of drones", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ea3d776e96ab4c52bbebd40ced2606b9", "input": "claim: Drones Should Be Used to Take Out Enemy Combatants.\n perspective: Drone strikes are legal under international law. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e556a56a1bd54591ae5809565a49a2b9", "input": "claim: Drones Should Be Used to Take Out Enemy Combatants.\n perspective: We should take advantage of the fact that drone strikes are legal ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-0a3d059307a34722800294d79fa1ff04", "input": "claim: Drones Should Be Used to Take Out Enemy Combatants.\n perspective: Drones are acceptable to use under International Law", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c69e3ecf192445c79e3779cd10047a63", "input": "claim: Drones Should Be Used to Take Out Enemy Combatants.\n perspective: Drone Strikes Are Legal under International Law", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-54e4fd7644f842e4bfbbcef8f42786f5", "input": "claim: Drones Should Be Used to Take Out Enemy Combatants.\n perspective: Drone Strikes Are Carried Out with the support of Local Governments and Make Those Countries Safer.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a67f9ba5bc8640dd877225aabd082ff6", "input": "claim: Drones Should Be Used to Take Out Enemy Combatants.\n perspective: Drone strikes are carried out with the collaboration and encouragement of local governments, and make those countries safer. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-6b8f35727e814033b44602d3cfdf24e6", "input": "claim: Drones Should Be Used to Take Out Enemy Combatants.\n perspective: Local governments allow the US to use drones to make their countries safer.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-9abb36c8666f4e80a6821a9fd88a84e0", "input": "claim: Drones Should Be Used to Take Out Enemy Combatants.\n perspective: Drone strikes are allowed by local governments who believe it makes their countries more safe.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f8fc4a845d8f4fb1aa22b09fb0446ed7", "input": "claim: Drones Should Be Used to Take Out Enemy Combatants.\n perspective: Drone strikes can protect foreign countries in collaboration with the local governments.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-b25cdc78c16e425ca768ad56141db8b2", "input": "claim: Drones Should Be Used to Take Out Enemy Combatants.\n perspective: Drone strikes abroad ensures the safety of foreign countries.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-6ab022786469420da1780d2576f5c77e", "input": "claim: Drones Should Be Used to Take Out Enemy Combatants.\n perspective: The Majority of Americans Support Drone Strikes", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-fae94135e9e44ed9a46bd0e69fae7db1", "input": "claim: Drones Should Be Used to Take Out Enemy Combatants.\n perspective: Drone strikes are cheaper than engaging in ground or manned aerial combat. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-48c782e529954ae3be5f2a35bca9f1dd", "input": "claim: Drones Should Be Used to Take Out Enemy Combatants.\n perspective: drones are far more cost effective that whole military units", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-266014ece73c4d7eb3e34adb99e6f8ef", "input": "claim: Drones Should Be Used to Take Out Enemy Combatants.\n perspective: Drones are less costly than fighting with soldiers", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-160cefc12bc34063abaae5d9e9ac26ce", "input": "claim: Drones Should Be Used to Take Out Enemy Combatants.\n perspective: It is cheaper to use drones rather than send soldiers", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-dd8a0859b21040dfbcc5e142e52d615c", "input": "claim: Drones Should Be Used to Take Out Enemy Combatants.\n perspective: Drone Use is Cheaper than Engaging in Ground or Manned Aerial Combat", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-b6fdffffce834ef98c4f9577f1ecb420", "input": "claim: Drones Should Be Used to Take Out Enemy Combatants.\n perspective: The US cannot Risk Lagging Behind the Rest of the World in the Development of These Technologies.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-738aa8dc4b4b4ffbbfdf05d24954dadb", "input": "claim: Drones Should Be Used to Take Out Enemy Combatants.\n perspective: The United States cannot risk falling behind the rest of the world in the development of drone technologies. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-6fa92fa0c6194797aadd5cd156789eb4", "input": "claim: Drones Should Be Used to Take Out Enemy Combatants.\n perspective: Drone Operators Have a Lower Risk for PTSD than Other Military Personnel.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-1f27ed1226b447f6b8e623f40e4981f1", "input": "claim: Drones Should Be Used to Take Out Enemy Combatants.\n perspective: Drones make US military personnel safer. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-09116da20cd7490eb8bd520f13ada835", "input": "claim: Drones Should Be Used to Take Out Enemy Combatants.\n perspective: fewer troops are exposed to dangers when drones are employed", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-3afdfb9910fd41f2b765428784dd5ba9", "input": "claim: Drones Should Be Used to Take Out Enemy Combatants.\n perspective: Drones protect our military from enemies", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-9fe169ee570b43adbb2552949e4ced4c", "input": "claim: Drones Should Be Used to Take Out Enemy Combatants.\n perspective: Drones Keep US Military Personnel Safer", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-9934c58ebdf94c4dac1756aa3cf3fb06", "input": "claim: Drones Should Be Used to Take Out Enemy Combatants.\n perspective: Drone Strikes Are Legal under US Law", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-dcb06686dd8e4395acbfb037d1a3c95d", "input": "claim: Drones Should Be Used to Take Out Enemy Combatants.\n perspective: US law allows for drone strikes.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-9440a51aa4d94b63a7d6a56908cd8f85", "input": "claim: Drones Should Be Used to Take Out Enemy Combatants.\n perspective: There is nothing illegal about drone strikes under US law.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-47e0d239f3a644ea8d7237d126829454", "input": "claim: Drones Should Be Used to Take Out Enemy Combatants.\n perspective: Drone strikes operations are deemed legal by US law.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-90dcd0bcca17497fa5ac5d4aa23c4c8c", "input": "claim: Drones Should Be Used to Take Out Enemy Combatants.\n perspective: United States law endorses drone strikes. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-825a3f72058e4805b905a510525a33d2", "input": "claim: Drones Should Be Used to Take Out Enemy Combatants.\n perspective: Drone strikes are legal under US law. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e7df8a69a0d1437d9c36bd0b2df8187a", "input": "claim: Drones Should Be Used to Take Out Enemy Combatants.\n perspective: Drones kill fewer civilians, as a percentage of total fatalities, than any other military weapon. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ef9e1c4afbc043b2a188b8b090352171", "input": "claim: Drones Should Be Used to Take Out Enemy Combatants.\n perspective: drones are able to be more focused limiting collateral damage", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-64ca0e2b77d448a09c3c440d6cf8bf55", "input": "claim: Drones Should Be Used to Take Out Enemy Combatants.\n perspective: drones can be a more precise weapon", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d156c19b7d1240128680a36160e4ce20", "input": "claim: Drones Should Be Used to Take Out Enemy Combatants.\n perspective: It has been proved that the use of Drone to combat enemy activity has resulted in fewer casualties amongst the civilian population as compared to the usage of other weapons", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-caf15b67cf8d4c18aedfa2a06c9d59bf", "input": "claim: Drones Should Be Used to Take Out Enemy Combatants.\n perspective: The use of Drones to combat enemy actions and terrorism will be an effective method to face enemies and stop terrorism .", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-622014ddc27c45fdaf410be29152bf55", "input": "claim: Drones Should Be Used to Take Out Enemy Combatants.\n perspective: Drones Result in Fewer Civilian Fatalities than Other Weapons.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-b4f55e00105a4ea5ab3bbf33aef307df", "input": "claim: Drones Should Be Used to Take Out Enemy Combatants.\n perspective: Drone Strikes Make the United States Safer by Destroying Terrorist Networks Internationally.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-84897fa4e30640ca9c01b39207cccff9", "input": "claim: Drones Should Be Used to Take Out Enemy Combatants.\n perspective: International Terrorist Networks can be destroyed by having Drone Strikes in the United States. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-232a54051067447bb80d7af8ae83b1b8", "input": "claim: Drones Should Be Used to Take Out Enemy Combatants.\n perspective: Continuing with the Drone Strikes in the United States , would combat any Terrorists Network and plan to attack the country ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-948d07b3dc6a4b98bf733715c8774d2c", "input": "claim: Drones Should Be Used to Take Out Enemy Combatants.\n perspective: Drone strikes are subject to a strict review process and congressional oversight. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-559198c7154b46e3b4638504d699be05", "input": "claim: Drones Should Be Used to Take Out Enemy Combatants.\n perspective: Drone strikes target individuals who may not be terrorists or enemy combatants. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-51c03b2e823d4d208f7951712b547195", "input": "claim: Drones Should Be Used to Take Out Enemy Combatants.\n perspective: Unmanned drone attacks may harm innocent civilians.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-54e36b20f2554b27a62d4d45fbd22297", "input": "claim: Drones Should Be Used to Take Out Enemy Combatants.\n perspective: United States drone strikes include collateral damage.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-52125fab0a80410ab65c6aead122722a", "input": "claim: Drones Should Be Used to Take Out Enemy Combatants.\n perspective: Drone strikes may victimize non-threats.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-3462755b44da474eb8ea73c36000350f", "input": "claim: Drones Should Be Used to Take Out Enemy Combatants.\n perspective: The innocent may be harmed my drone strikes.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-01eaf133ca75462e9c1f712b48fe2db1", "input": "claim: Drones Should Be Used to Take Out Enemy Combatants.\n perspective: Many drone operators have emotional and psychological stress. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ab9fbcc3b2c643f4b08a187cc37aaf20", "input": "claim: Drones Should Be Used to Take Out Enemy Combatants.\n perspective: Operating drones results in a great deal of mental and emotional stress.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b1fb0239e9e44e97afb2c4efdb349589", "input": "claim: Drones Should Be Used to Take Out Enemy Combatants.\n perspective: Drone operators often suffer from psychological and emotional strain.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-6592fab6562648eab2197c3029e0e0aa", "input": "claim: Drones Should Be Used to Take Out Enemy Combatants.\n perspective: Drone strikes create more terrorists than they kill. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-117474588f204c428c990a538fc2906a", "input": "claim: Drones Should Be Used to Take Out Enemy Combatants.\n perspective: Terrorists are created by drone strikes.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4bf55dba76b5435b93425eca996b3506", "input": "claim: Drones Should Be Used to Take Out Enemy Combatants.\n perspective: Drone strikes tend to increase the membership of terrorist organizations.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c3574b3f6f3b4002a9a28f47d9ce890e", "input": "claim: Drones Should Be Used to Take Out Enemy Combatants.\n perspective: Drone strikes can't reduce the number of terrorists. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c83499a8dd924174ae2cce54befeccf0", "input": "claim: Drones Should Be Used to Take Out Enemy Combatants.\n perspective: Drone strikes are secretive, lack sufficient legal oversight, and prevent citizens from holding their leaders accountable. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-21f2a40787574551a6154ccb8b9f52d9", "input": "claim: Drones Should Be Used to Take Out Enemy Combatants.\n perspective: Secrecy prevents accountability for drone strikes.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-2031b1895ed3440fb2e9fd63ea22ca4d", "input": "claim: Drones Should Be Used to Take Out Enemy Combatants.\n perspective: There are many reasons why drones lack sufficient oversight to be of moral value.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-657a8273af6143dc9f5d899ee3b679ac", "input": "claim: Drones Should Be Used to Take Out Enemy Combatants.\n perspective: The use of drones removes accountability from their leaders.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-eec8aae6aa3247db816be121be8979f3", "input": "claim: Drones Should Be Used to Take Out Enemy Combatants.\n perspective: Drone strikes make the United States safer by decimating terrorist networks across the world. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ee327ce5531d4f9eabaabb713759ed64", "input": "claim: Drones Should Be Used to Take Out Enemy Combatants.\n perspective: Drone strikes violate the sovereignty of other countries. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-cc60fb9acca04b10bed66264da4fc81f", "input": "claim: Drones Should Be Used to Take Out Enemy Combatants.\n perspective: Drone strikes infringe upon the rights of other nations.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-08dbacba8df1441bb2191cf5a22b2b46", "input": "claim: Drones Should Be Used to Take Out Enemy Combatants.\n perspective: Drone strikes mostly kill low-value targets who are not significant threats to US safety and security. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-413b1c1e2ed64e1ca49452a6de03cf2d", "input": "claim: Drones Should Be Used to Take Out Enemy Combatants.\n perspective: Those targeted by drone strikes are mostly insignificant to national security.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-5bf191f1dac34ce485056148604e4f27", "input": "claim: Drones Should Be Used to Take Out Enemy Combatants.\n perspective: Drone strikes tend to only kill low value targets.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-5e049566d9dd4ffe9b42635cfeea57ce", "input": "claim: Drones Should Be Used to Take Out Enemy Combatants.\n perspective: Drone strikes violate international law. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-57f7a76f7b034f55b12e0c2db53e9339", "input": "claim: Drones Should Be Used to Take Out Enemy Combatants.\n perspective: The use of unmanned drone attacks is inconsistent with international laws.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ff5504faa568491db13c94692fb14bf5", "input": "claim: Drones Should Be Used to Take Out Enemy Combatants.\n perspective: International laws are violated by drone strikes.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c14500286f4349828d90c0919273155f", "input": "claim: Drones Should Be Used to Take Out Enemy Combatants.\n perspective: International law is violated by drone strikes.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-6e9133ca1ce84a2a88b856d6ef3d98a7", "input": "claim: Drones Should Be Used to Take Out Enemy Combatants.\n perspective: The use of drones conflicts with international law", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-87b5acf73af44cb897543d4b57b8da42", "input": "claim: Drones Should Be Used to Take Out Enemy Combatants.\n perspective: Drone strikes kill large numbers of civilians and traumatize local populations. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c097b2db90b24fd6b5b29558790dfa10", "input": "claim: Drones Should Be Used to Take Out Enemy Combatants.\n perspective: Civilians are traumatized and often killed by United States drone strikes.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-194bd4142d104bd1b5a424a3eb37d6bb", "input": "claim: Drones Should Be Used to Take Out Enemy Combatants.\n perspective: Drone strikes cause a significant amount of localized trauma.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-8949f751912344c18b684ef06ccd77df", "input": "claim: Drones Should Be Used to Take Out Enemy Combatants.\n perspective: Drone strikes are a major threat to individuals, both physically and psychologically.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-873a10715bb6470cb316b7bbf0b8efe4", "input": "claim: Drones Should Be Used to Take Out Enemy Combatants.\n perspective: Drone strikes have done serious harm to civilians, partially through promoting emotional terror.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-2ce6b97abfda4a46925ce88bece0e3f7", "input": "claim: Drones Should Be Used to Take Out Enemy Combatants.\n perspective: The majority of Americans support drone strikes. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-5e618881d042471080013c9e6141b22c", "input": "claim: Drones Should Be Used to Take Out Enemy Combatants.\n perspective: American citizens approve of drone strikes.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-59596a28f9c447df823b02c9aa771427", "input": "claim: Drones Should Be Used to Take Out Enemy Combatants.\n perspective: Most US citizens approve of military drones.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-0665a7c6f1c646a6a95cde5e4d0a7c4f", "input": "claim: Drones Should Be Used to Take Out Enemy Combatants.\n perspective: Most people in the U.S. support the use of drone strikes.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-bfd5654763154b5d9058bf12f76816ef", "input": "claim: Drones Should Be Used to Take Out Enemy Combatants.\n perspective: According to survey, most U.S. citizens support drone strikes.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-b5f309097da94eda929fdc1ed39abc33", "input": "claim: Drones Should Be Used to Take Out Enemy Combatants.\n perspective: Drone pilots have a lower risk for post traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) than pilots of manned aircraft and other battlefield soldiers. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-58dbe4938fcc4566aaf79bb93c086748", "input": "claim: Drones Should Be Used to Take Out Enemy Combatants.\n perspective: PTSD is much less prevalent amonst drone pilots than those who participate in traditional warfare.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-0fafc89d67d748adaa0f7e3880a96c8f", "input": "claim: Drones Should Be Used to Take Out Enemy Combatants.\n perspective: The incidence of PTSD is lower amonst drone pilots than those who pilot manned aircraft or fight on the battlefield.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-dd207f90db4b429280cd432bd081e100", "input": "claim: Drones Should Be Used to Take Out Enemy Combatants.\n perspective: Drone pilots have lesser chance of getting PTSD than other aircraft pilots. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c4037b5aec4649cfb6ff374374ed5178", "input": "claim: Drones Should Be Used to Take Out Enemy Combatants.\n perspective: Using drones can reduce the chance of pilots getting PTSD in operations. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ce7783fff12348e3aa1bbb66544d762e", "input": "claim: Drones Should Be Used to Take Out Enemy Combatants.\n perspective: US drone strikes give cover for other countries to engage in human rights abuses. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-7f387f9fd1104063b6824b412110bb9d", "input": "claim: Drones Should Be Used to Take Out Enemy Combatants.\n perspective: U.S. drone strikes enable other nations to violate human rights.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4c33872610e748a9ab57dbbbd091cbc6", "input": "claim: Drones Should Be Used to Take Out Enemy Combatants.\n perspective: When the U.S. uses drone strikes abroad, it gives those nations permission to participate in human rights infringement.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4ffa42533f424deebaa59dd1275d4207", "input": "claim: Legal empowerment is provided for women through land titling.\n perspective: Land titles do not solve the main issue for women - rental markets. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-cc6d9d44fef741d49e2b766f0f5ee00e", "input": "claim: Legal empowerment is provided for women through land titling.\n perspective: Property has no bearing on women's wealth.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ea07673d464b4d0fa496e20575d99415", "input": "claim: Legal empowerment is provided for women through land titling.\n perspective: Land titles will help end violence against women. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e8d3d8d6f76b49d394f5a840fa54c868", "input": "claim: Legal empowerment is provided for women through land titling.\n perspective: Because of land titles, violence against women would come to an end.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-3093b4f8ecb64dcc8920afae81e53e3c", "input": "claim: Legal empowerment is provided for women through land titling.\n perspective: Land titles would help protect women from violence.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-9b6bd36cee594d29b96fb28630fbc020", "input": "claim: Legal empowerment is provided for women through land titling.\n perspective: Land titles are not affordable to poor women", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-da0f8cf43e014a359aa2472fdeec3c78", "input": "claim: Legal empowerment is provided for women through land titling.\n perspective: Land titles will develop entrepreneurial women. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-503c5106fac54736b8859fe672a7471f", "input": "claim: Legal empowerment is provided for women through land titling.\n perspective: More women would become entrepreneurs because of land titles.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f15adf619665488483e3156982be0f82", "input": "claim: Legal empowerment is provided for women through land titling.\n perspective: Land titles would mean that more women could become entrepreneurs.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-9749abdbb2f247e188341bd2845f137b", "input": "claim: Legal empowerment is provided for women through land titling.\n perspective: Land titles for women today will provide inter-generational equalities for the future.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-725f6042ccf84334aa4ebfaf7a26d623", "input": "claim: Legal empowerment is provided for women through land titling.\n perspective: Giving land titles to women now would lead to an equal playing field in the future.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e906035a0a454d39ad4199b7790ec337", "input": "claim: Legal empowerment is provided for women through land titling.\n perspective: In the future, women would have more equality if they are given land titles today.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-4da6e112d1c4431d9f0cd2f8ba36adcd", "input": "claim: Legal empowerment is provided for women through land titling.\n perspective: Land titling will increase female poverty. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b785ab7d0ef546029cc8d1f53a07f3b5", "input": "claim: Legal empowerment is provided for women through land titling.\n perspective: Owning land will put women in poverty.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-dd94f011419541a7b4352b47acb9a016", "input": "claim: Legal empowerment is provided for women through land titling.\n perspective: Women get poor through land ownership.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b6244886726e4a8b8da6a1c451e3de86", "input": "claim: Legal empowerment is provided for women through land titling.\n perspective: Land titles mean single women can build decent homes.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-46c02dbdebec47199be6330ba28c89c0", "input": "claim: Legal empowerment is provided for women through land titling.\n perspective: Single women could build good homes with land titles.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-1b18584bee7b487a9c35cde831556d85", "input": "claim: Legal empowerment is provided for women through land titling.\n perspective: Women who are not married would be able to get a decent home thanks to land titles.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-406347474c144c1aafbd2cd6676bf059", "input": "claim: Offshoring is a good idea.\n perspective: Offshoring exploits both individual workers and under developed states.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4f46dc171b264cc4a0303ca4c7bcb20a", "input": "claim: Offshoring is a good idea.\n perspective: There are multiple negative effects of offshoring.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-5b6e1ad358a94e2f909af5d6cb9e22a0", "input": "claim: Offshoring is a good idea.\n perspective: Underdeveloped states and workers are harmed by this practice.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-2786577906834020a41afef10ed4b0bf", "input": "claim: Offshoring is a good idea.\n perspective: Offshore outsourcing is consistent with existing labour distribution patterns.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d63c8157e37341ef9cd9fdb26f561310", "input": "claim: Offshoring is a good idea.\n perspective: Outsourcing follows the current labor distribution model.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-3e77c3690fda4431be1dddd0e27dbde5", "input": "claim: Offshoring is a good idea.\n perspective: Offshore outsourcing reduces living standards and limits social mobility.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-491aed95f22a4c13b1ef06a7e25f9704", "input": "claim: Offshoring is a good idea.\n perspective: Social mobility is negatively impacted by offshore outsourcing.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-2a1ae199711d40d6a57cd3c0dd1871a6", "input": "claim: Offshoring is a good idea.\n perspective: Living standards decline and is just one example of the cons of offshore outsourcing.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-bba33a64973b4fadba96e9b8c5af4080", "input": "claim: Evolution has Disproved Creationism.\n perspective: Evolution undermines meaning and morality", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-1edf6a6ddeb34a8188ec838d26fc537f", "input": "claim: Evolution has Disproved Creationism.\n perspective: Evolution has taken away the stories that create morals and meaning to many people.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-51074ed622f74b5da638d62f408866e9", "input": "claim: Evolution has Disproved Creationism.\n perspective: Evolution does not explain morals or guidelines to a way of life.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a72c42a25c7b4ae6a5d3bb10cbab6971", "input": "claim: Evolution has Disproved Creationism.\n perspective: The fossil evidence", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-cf39850b3c294bd39a7bd01d086db39b", "input": "claim: Evolution has Disproved Creationism.\n perspective: Creationism has been dispproved because of the evidence of fossils.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-51792fa6fe274a3da200cfa17d70f05f", "input": "claim: Evolution has Disproved Creationism.\n perspective: Creationism can't explain the fossil record.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-3169252d559a4ea98c0455c7cb446e04", "input": "claim: Evolution has Disproved Creationism.\n perspective: The Bible says God created the world", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-93a19b36f13547479cc9165e02ceadac", "input": "claim: Evolution has Disproved Creationism.\n perspective: Much of the complexity of life cannot be explained by evolution, but is perfectly explained by Creationism.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a862d91b04d347419cfa90091e0260ae", "input": "claim: Evolution has Disproved Creationism.\n perspective: Creationism has theoretical answers to questions evolution can't answer.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-f6fbae2375434075b75ad26b855660a5", "input": "claim: Evolution has Disproved Creationism.\n perspective: Evolution cannot answer irreducible complexity like Creationism can.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-829b7430984344f8823ea9b81502d0f8", "input": "claim: Evolution has Disproved Creationism.\n perspective: There is no empirical evidence supporting Creationism, whereas all evidence supports abiogenesis and evolution.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-9077339170eb4096b154a4cf02d1353c", "input": "claim: Evolution has Disproved Creationism.\n perspective: The scientific community as a whole overwhelmingly rejects Creationism.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-655a75df8a1048498b5be3d06d0b614a", "input": "claim: Evolution has Disproved Creationism.\n perspective: Creationism isn't supported by the scientific community.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-caaa7c02cb0d4ec2a804f0330e3cdb8c", "input": "claim: Tuition Fees Should Be Increased.\n perspective: It is a small price to pay for the quality of education given. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-4089d93fc7a44867851e2fca255be0fb", "input": "claim: Tuition Fees Should Be Increased.\n perspective: For the quality of education given it is a small price to pay.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-01a21f9bf72341b6857b8ddb4a339efb", "input": "claim: Tuition Fees Should Be Increased.\n perspective: You would be paying a small price for the quality of education given.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-bc1e4df0d903438c864e0c0cbea5c67f", "input": "claim: Tuition Fees Should Be Increased.\n perspective: Tuition fees were only increased a few years ago. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b6a2978966a84656bb395fb2c743ab1b", "input": "claim: Tuition Fees Should Be Increased.\n perspective: It will discourage people from getting a higher education.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c2f0d90b76b846099198a8f8a8bf4dea", "input": "claim: Tuition Fees Should Be Increased.\n perspective: People getting a higher education will be discouraged.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c5c28b41746d4730a610e4a1d2dec300", "input": "claim: Tuition Fees Should Be Increased.\n perspective: People will be discouraged and not want to get a higher education.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-158a4b143b2741cb8de4b3d726773464", "input": "claim: Tuition Fees Should Be Increased.\n perspective: It will increase the tension and the gap between rich and poor. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-6f47c390cd2c42eaa22feb3ab3530912", "input": "claim: Tuition Fees Should Be Increased.\n perspective: The tension between rich and poor will be increased.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b524074875cc434aa3a23a681fb94854", "input": "claim: Tuition Fees Should Be Increased.\n perspective: Tensions will rise between the rich and the poor.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-8a6fda7353ef40b7b19380d110a6828a", "input": "claim: Tuition Fees Should Be Increased.\n perspective: The recession is torturing students enough.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ee14b8ef9b3d4163a2a883033ba9fca7", "input": "claim: Tuition Fees Should Be Increased.\n perspective: Students are being tortured enough by the recession.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c29944fa6cc34b848287e94d6dfd84c5", "input": "claim: Tuition Fees Should Be Increased.\n perspective: Enough students have been tortured by the recession.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-9e270d4dd61240fa80e42f9a1c295fbf", "input": "claim: Tuition Fees Should Be Increased.\n perspective: More money will pumped into the economy, helping to overcome the recession. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-cedc9dc5e18342aeb8160e26e5726c9c", "input": "claim: Tuition Fees Should Be Increased.\n perspective: The recession can be overcome by more money in the economy.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-6cf36366c2964d968780fd120e6c5fee", "input": "claim: Tuition Fees Should Be Increased.\n perspective: A way to overcome the recession is by putting more money into the economy.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-2e4500299a224b7a801f85a43c24371f", "input": "claim: African borders must be redefined to reflect ethnic groups.\n perspective: Damages dreams of African unity", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ae3781ec580b47af97fd5b37b8c04ddc", "input": "claim: African borders must be redefined to reflect ethnic groups.\n perspective: The goal of Damages is to create African unity. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-d3bba954de73411eb1a768efa441575c", "input": "claim: African borders must be redefined to reflect ethnic groups.\n perspective: African unity is the hope of Damages.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-62fb24cf244d46b7ba1ace5bae56a84d", "input": "claim: African borders must be redefined to reflect ethnic groups.\n perspective: Ethnic borders erase a wrong of history", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-40f4b4447b724261abd7a4f1d614a22f", "input": "claim: African borders must be redefined to reflect ethnic groups.\n perspective: Ethnic borders return societies to their logical segments and undoes the inequity that was artificially created. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-6c2b488bf313460f9523c12cca74c9f3", "input": "claim: Human Cloning has to be banned.\n perspective: Cloning should be allowed for those who can’t otherwise have a child", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e978ef8383f94f23a4436594171cb7c4", "input": "claim: Human Cloning has to be banned.\n perspective: For those who can't conceive, cloning should be an option.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ec5ee5722fe944e5858c6aadd646cfcd", "input": "claim: Human Cloning has to be banned.\n perspective: Cloning should be acceptable if people cannot have children.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c047b7c6621a447cbb1c40554b30ad48", "input": "claim: Human Cloning has to be banned.\n perspective: Cloning is unsafe", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c252a3eee20b41c385994ae36afd0ee0", "input": "claim: Human Cloning has to be banned.\n perspective: Since it is considered unsafe, human cloning should be banned.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-7d9e8a1a9d4549a3b881a76079ad40cc", "input": "claim: Human Cloning has to be banned.\n perspective: Given the fact that it is currently unsafe, it is in the public's best interest to ban human cloning.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-b0d615d5a60d4c128d02c76d95b81585", "input": "claim: Human Cloning has to be banned.\n perspective: Cloning harms families", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-eff866e45fd942b7b7a2427c0cc284a7", "input": "claim: Human Cloning has to be banned.\n perspective: Families are harmed with cloning", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-822435cfa2f345a9b0c8df73efdf736c", "input": "claim: Human Cloning has to be banned.\n perspective: In order to protect families, human cloning should be banned.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-eba2203a1d594083a5fc283861be44c0", "input": "claim: Human Cloning has to be banned.\n perspective: Banning human cloning would be one way to protect families from harm.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-4b8075e9ffb8403fa5741ab1d6bc0be5", "input": "claim: Human Cloning has to be banned.\n perspective: Cloning violates human dignity", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-aa3570183885487baaa583debc861be0", "input": "claim: Human Cloning has to be banned.\n perspective: Human dignity is definitely violated with Cloning.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f3de6ce352864f919456e2592fa14a09", "input": "claim: Human Cloning has to be banned.\n perspective: Violations to the dignified human occur with cloning.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-838443b909ab492285d986e1e5cca557", "input": "claim: Guinea-Bissau should not let itself be turned in to a front of the US’ \"war on drugs\".\n perspective: Sacrifice of sovereignty ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-6a20b280a8f54f9488782c04672cdc13", "input": "claim: Guinea-Bissau should not let itself be turned in to a front of the US’ \"war on drugs\".\n perspective: War on the poor ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ac1b0d055bba4867a3eaacc9113c3877", "input": "claim: The use of child performers should be banned.\n perspective: It is unethical to expose children to the pressures of performing", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-28f665764f2f4c618e63bb67dec507c1", "input": "claim: The use of child performers should be banned.\n perspective: Imposing pressure on a child performer to perform is unethical.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-94eee2f2633849c784c0fc0b073edad5", "input": "claim: The use of child performers should be banned.\n perspective: Many consider it unethical to expose children to the pressures of performing. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a28a794bb33b40f8b47e0b4e04e0fc26", "input": "claim: The use of child performers should be banned.\n perspective: Children shouldn't be pressured into performing.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-8a13cfdf31984d9ba89c75ee11c119e2", "input": "claim: The use of child performers should be banned.\n perspective: Exposing children to performance pressure is unethical.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-5dfe14e18c0446d1b5c97d388c9e9678", "input": "claim: The use of child performers should be banned.\n perspective: The government has no right to prevent children from doing what they enjoy and are good at", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-29bf894bbf214da18525cb4ac182a1b7", "input": "claim: The use of child performers should be banned.\n perspective: The children should have the final say on whether they want to do it or not.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-1f04942aa201437a834c836058555c29", "input": "claim: The use of child performers should be banned.\n perspective: The government should not interfere in a child's decision.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-639d204076d14f9da969ae0b4da4fa51", "input": "claim: The use of child performers should be banned.\n perspective: the government cannot protect children from entertaining", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-27e29d8ba6974228a1021255479a957d", "input": "claim: The use of child performers should be banned.\n perspective: performers are at risk of exploitation", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-3664685a309a47edb065f9edb10d5de5", "input": "claim: The use of child performers should be banned.\n perspective: There exists the possibility that child performers can be exploited. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-40df2809071f4e8bb1ce3febe0d549bf", "input": "claim: The use of child performers should be banned.\n perspective: Some child performers may be exploited by industry executives.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-bb971602b5eb4f9499971b7c31a3643a", "input": "claim: The use of child performers should be banned.\n perspective: Child performers might be exploited.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-324faab4ceab432e8c0f7fe79588c786", "input": "claim: The use of child performers should be banned.\n perspective: There is a risk that child performers might be exploited.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-2880786d4b814c529969d5d6413a7ef1", "input": "claim: The use of child performers should be banned.\n perspective: Being a performer limits a child’s formal education", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-3d974cd39acb4cba9b96415a5bcf0b36", "input": "claim: The use of child performers should be banned.\n perspective: A child performer's formal education is limited by their work.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-8c8d324eaa484c5589b371dc9053b8d0", "input": "claim: The use of child performers should be banned.\n perspective: Work puts limits on the formal education received by a child performer.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-83b9be84ced449049758cedda701aa71", "input": "claim: The use of child performers should be banned.\n perspective: A child's education is hampered by performing.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-9ebcf4a81d0c405eb9f85045a58b5cc1", "input": "claim: The use of child performers should be banned.\n perspective: When a child works as a performer, their education suffers.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f791f4b1a97443e09f8f3ee7a2762a0b", "input": "claim: The use of child performers should be banned.\n perspective: Allowing children to perform pushes them to grow up too soon", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-132efb1d76ad49fc874d7d44bd78034d", "input": "claim: The use of child performers should be banned.\n perspective: Child performers are often pushed to grow up too soon.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-8b571b18b54b4e8387fdeef28a7e3943", "input": "claim: The use of child performers should be banned.\n perspective: Children that perform are often pushed to grow up too soon.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-926ff851f4bb477ebc04c36659aca368", "input": "claim: The use of child performers should be banned.\n perspective: Children grow up too fast when they're performers.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-b5b929d7e22c4838bb220f37843754c4", "input": "claim: The use of child performers should be banned.\n perspective: Being a performer forces a child to grow up too fast.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-b62f1e3987ac4b9f9eec4d132ccb0161", "input": "claim: The use of child performers should be banned.\n perspective: Child performers are necessary for roles in some films, television shows, etc., and for the survival of some sports", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a2244e026b8841acbc7652dc414b128d", "input": "claim: The use of child performers should be banned.\n perspective: Child performers are the only people who fit some of these roles", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-955cbe54dd7c43099b15989436544a6c", "input": "claim: The use of child performers should be banned.\n perspective: The child actors are the ones who can carry certain shows", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-86b22619fc874930adec8cde440e3e6d", "input": "claim: The use of child performers should be banned.\n perspective: Child performers help films and sports", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-328aa877c2a642cfbfbbf461aef73b1f", "input": "claim: The use of child performers should be banned.\n perspective: child performers are good for movies and shows", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-0f632f6762394cbc8c2bdcad2c650763", "input": "claim: The use of child performers should be banned.\n perspective: If child performers were banned, many children would find a way to perform illegally, now without legal protection.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-66328ee9229e45a5a55ef4d3be0a09c1", "input": "claim: The use of child performers should be banned.\n perspective: Even if banned, child performers would still be hired, although now without protection.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-35f3a103418f488da8e26be571e8f257", "input": "claim: The use of child performers should be banned.\n perspective: if performing children were banned, some would perform illegally ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-7817eb82f2d5465bb34850a8712a13b3", "input": "claim: The use of child performers should be banned.\n perspective: if children were banned from performing, some would do it anyways", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-f4ff8d9cbd434bb28a35e80fbd3400f1", "input": "claim: The use of child performers should be banned.\n perspective: There will always be child actors but by not banning them at least there will be some protection for them", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-73d1ddb0283b40ddb0e73999618daa46", "input": "claim: The use of child performers should be banned.\n perspective: A child becomes physically vulnerable when they become a child performer.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d0e3bd607d9244fb8c537e78d1e47506", "input": "claim: The use of child performers should be banned.\n perspective: It can make a child physically vulnerable to be a child performer.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-9c19fa9cb066432892ec372a0465d3de", "input": "claim: The use of child performers should be banned.\n perspective: Working as a performer can make a child vulnerable.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-aa6d1a4d4c6f4c79a8e1224f96d7fd12", "input": "claim: The use of child performers should be banned.\n perspective: Physical vulnerability might be a factor in being a child performer", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d02457e3276946d2a96d0bc17f52cee6", "input": "claim: The Uhuru Kenyatta indictment was an unwelcome interference by the ICC.\n perspective: Kenya can prosecute these crimes itself", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-60ec7842703b423d88a5b9b1ce52de90", "input": "claim: It should be allowed to patent genes.\n perspective: Genes are intellectual property thus patentable", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-59cd3e847d0a471d8f59bb7f91da8533", "input": "claim: It should be allowed to patent genes.\n perspective: Patenting drives up the cost of therapies and renders them unaffordable to the poor", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-edd0e69b1bc24c41ab4248580e1857fc", "input": "claim: It should be allowed to patent genes.\n perspective: Therapy costs are increased and not affordable to poor people.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-1179ad04fe6a43ba91bb8a9b5a33c600", "input": "claim: It should be allowed to patent genes.\n perspective: This is a disadvantage for poor people as it increases the therapy costs and makes them inaccessible.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-7bcfac752c754200964d09ac14ec778b", "input": "claim: It should be allowed to patent genes.\n perspective: Patenting enables knowledge sharing", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d95606837069424487673810b743f801", "input": "claim: Reality TV shows are an important part of popular culture today.\n perspective: Reality TV shows bring out the worse in people.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-14c5ced3588f4b0292c11d4685ebef9d", "input": "claim: Reality TV shows are an important part of popular culture today.\n perspective: Reality TV shows make celebrities out of talentless individuals.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-bcd49af3289f4ac297b05db9b75374a5", "input": "claim: Reality TV shows are an important part of popular culture today.\n perspective: Reality TV shows allow ordinary individuals a chance of stardom.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-8e4958ccf69a47e8a22b269788fc95c2", "input": "claim: Reality TV shows are an important part of popular culture today.\n perspective: Reality TV shows provide wonderful entertainment.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-8554b9fc7ecb4cc190d5b8c85bd4cd43", "input": "claim: Reality TV shows are an important part of popular culture today.\n perspective: Reality TV can provide you with hours of enjoyment.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-2993ec7a3c3d4abd87cf89230735338c", "input": "claim: Reality TV shows are an important part of popular culture today.\n perspective: Reality TV shows allow us to see the real personalities of celebrities.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e79740b375a344db825a9b0fe94c9b14", "input": "claim: Reality TV shows are an important part of popular culture today.\n perspective: Reality TV shows are just there to make money for their creators.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ceac51efc86545238093d2ddcd29dd7c", "input": "claim: Reality TV shows are an important part of popular culture today.\n perspective: Many reality TV shows are distasteful", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-76e91981240e47cc831b73c5f09da71b", "input": "claim: Reality TV shows are an important part of popular culture today.\n perspective: Lots of the reality TV shows are of poor taste.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-3fa69a643a0f49c38ef17e258045a673", "input": "claim: Reality TV shows are an important part of popular culture today.\n perspective: People have died in connection with reality TV", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-6acbcb54e2d64f2981273727327d29aa", "input": "claim: Reality TV shows are an important part of popular culture today.\n perspective: There have been deaths from the reality TV shows.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-acf1f661b2d94314aae25ec8e019ca67", "input": "claim: Reality TV shows are an important part of popular culture today.\n perspective: Reality TV has had fatal consequences.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-73537c720e5044f796723d1aecbced58", "input": "claim: Football does unify us.\n perspective: Can create improve racial harmony", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-7ed7b1c2f2d3423fa2a1a1badad7f1fb", "input": "claim: Football does unify us.\n perspective: Sports create racial harmony.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-0a6f61b4ddcd4e368b006d1a35921aa8", "input": "claim: Football does unify us.\n perspective: Improving racial harmony is one of the benefits of sports.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ac0cdea82ab14f36a594b85f824a192f", "input": "claim: Football does unify us.\n perspective: Can cause diplomatic crises", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e7625e9ac91649acace0d0aea1fefa56", "input": "claim: Football does unify us.\n perspective: Sports can hurt diplomacy.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-da3a338faf2841eda42e008e176e2f88", "input": "claim: Football does unify us.\n perspective: A diplomatic crisis can happen because of sports.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-45ba74960f9d4bc59f05ec19f5ae3d35", "input": "claim: Football does unify us.\n perspective: Can unite politically divided countries", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-5218084604534ac9af66bd069a111e2f", "input": "claim: Football does unify us.\n perspective: Sports unify divided countries.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f7a9ceb170164893836ffab969bfb878", "input": "claim: Mossad should carry out extrajudicial killings.\n perspective: They damage Israel's foreign relations & reputation", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4c64d018ee444614bd925ded7a50e7b1", "input": "claim: Prescription drugs should be advertised directly to consumers.\n perspective: Direct-to-consumer (DTC) prescription drug ads encourage people to seek medical advice from health professionals. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-8a357c9d7df74c6c9b1d16c9acd2b9fd", "input": "claim: Prescription drugs should be advertised directly to consumers.\n perspective: DTC prescription drug ads help remove the stigma associated with certain diseases and medical conditions.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-09b85fdf656e47a3b4baf7c19a49e448", "input": "claim: Prescription drugs should be advertised directly to consumers.\n perspective: DTC relieves the fear of lack of knowledge about diseases and medical conditions", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-25559dc47f04475abb8c19a3cfde4a95", "input": "claim: Prescription drugs should be advertised directly to consumers.\n perspective: DTC prescription drug ads promote drugs before long-term safety information is known.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ca3671f9c1ec44beaddfa258cec0251c", "input": "claim: Prescription drugs should be advertised directly to consumers.\n perspective: Health care professionals may feel pressured by DTC prescription drug ads to prescribe drugs that may not be in the best interest of the patient.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-9a13e82aede14d9d975d8fe87120beb2", "input": "claim: Prescription drugs should be advertised directly to consumers.\n perspective: When seeing the ads Doctors might feel pressure to give them to patients", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-1e9fa47dcc024e2287e1e7f113da71bc", "input": "claim: Prescription drugs should be advertised directly to consumers.\n perspective: Direct-to-consumer (DTC) drug ads misinform patients.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-2c56663fad87464ca1f6f34387e5c75c", "input": "claim: Prescription drugs should be advertised directly to consumers.\n perspective: DTC prescription drug ads inform patients about diseases/medical conditions and possible treatments.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-4c4cd801d13942e8a25b70fc0d178083", "input": "claim: Prescription drugs should be advertised directly to consumers.\n perspective: Patients receive information from DTC about diseases, medical conditions and treatments.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-0447f61e26d9414d9b968249f3a233ba", "input": "claim: Prescription drugs should be advertised directly to consumers.\n perspective: Information about diseases, medical conditions and treatments come from DTC ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-34579d78eb064f7cae554de762860041", "input": "claim: Prescription drugs should be advertised directly to consumers.\n perspective: DTC prescription drug ads should be allowed as protected free speech.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-23a75a678d4a4230bedaca8d8ca9fdd1", "input": "claim: Prescription drugs should be advertised directly to consumers.\n perspective: stopping DTC ads will take away our free speech", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-1145e73c4a3a4dc3bbd50f696d7a576c", "input": "claim: Prescription drugs should be advertised directly to consumers.\n perspective: DTC prescription drug ads increase health care costs.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e44c17ce0b04455ab8bce25d0dd095e3", "input": "claim: Prescription drugs should be advertised directly to consumers.\n perspective: DTC prescription drug ads encourage over-medication.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-2b8277d706cf4a99a3d8195846de774b", "input": "claim: Prescription drugs should be advertised directly to consumers.\n perspective: The ads make people take too much medicine", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-1609f8393d9d412a940bc975405b16a0", "input": "claim: Prescription drugs should be advertised directly to consumers.\n perspective: Diseases and medical conditions are more likely to be treated when consumers see DTC prescription drug ads.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-3c93866b929a4a0db9c7e5cc6202b4ca", "input": "claim: Prescription drugs should be advertised directly to consumers.\n perspective: Normal conditions and bodily functions are medicalized and stigmatized by DTC prescription drug ads.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-362a9313c02046668997020ad18a4601", "input": "claim: Prescription drugs should be advertised directly to consumers.\n perspective: Seeing the Prescription ads make people believe they have conditions they don't", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-f1169b239df64359b7bf86c403e7631b", "input": "claim: Prescription drugs should be advertised directly to consumers.\n perspective: There will be more people self diagnosing from the Ads", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e931f88e20ed4a69b515f4011f623eea", "input": "claim: Prescription drugs should be advertised directly to consumers.\n perspective: DTC prescription drug ads create revenue for drug companies, which can be used for research & development (R&D) to create new life-changing drugs.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-915975137d6f4474b774f56fcb5096c6", "input": "claim: Prescription drugs should be advertised directly to consumers.\n perspective: DTC prescription drug ads are banned in every country but the United States and New Zealand.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a6522a99a66a4b8fa18ea27ea0b7e8ba", "input": "claim: National service should be re-introduced.\n perspective: The military does not want conscription", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c7177a92a12241bfae5898727a97c279", "input": "claim: National service should be re-introduced.\n perspective: The military feels that conscription is not the right answer. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-fb9767c0c05b4bb2a548be2607c98126", "input": "claim: National service should be re-introduced.\n perspective: Constriction is not something the military is interested in. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-6bf6d6778c8c452b933cceabf3201d37", "input": "claim: National service should be re-introduced.\n perspective: National service would lead to unfair treatment of conscientious objectors", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-70cb074232fb4c019df29f2baa321a2b", "input": "claim: National service should be re-introduced.\n perspective: People who identify as conscientious objectors would be treated unfairly in the national service. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-eec35b01aeb6419dbcb57ab90712a15f", "input": "claim: National service should be re-introduced.\n perspective: Conscientious objectors would, under the national service, not be treated equitably. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e3725d827ed24bdca9f9796d8c88ef50", "input": "claim: National service should be re-introduced.\n perspective: National service would lead to unfair treatment of people with different opinions.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a6cec4b767b642a6a61d6ef217b897c9", "input": "claim: National service should be re-introduced.\n perspective: People who object national service would be treated unjustly. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-3a3aad7fbe0d4bafa89dfe70e30a8b60", "input": "claim: National service should be re-introduced.\n perspective: Society needs a standing army ready to be called to action", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-419d530062414ed79881f27a01fc5c5b", "input": "claim: National service should be re-introduced.\n perspective: Society could really benefit from having the National Sevice again. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f45534eca2e74a708a19d6d0d5d93180", "input": "claim: National service should be re-introduced.\n perspective: Have a standing army that is ready for action could be used in society right now. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-3d420bfa11874aa08ed8f18e9b7474bc", "input": "claim: National service should be re-introduced.\n perspective: It will cost a fortune and be difficult to implement", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-cadb1ff9e5aa41048dc5ecdbebc01df5", "input": "claim: National service should be re-introduced.\n perspective: The costs will be enormous and implementation is arduous. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-74f66067b474429089fb1d54793b1e49", "input": "claim: National service should be re-introduced.\n perspective: The program would be incredibly expensive and very hard to work through. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-8bd0ea2394564168b331260d54b14583", "input": "claim: National service should be re-introduced.\n perspective: National service is expensive and hard to follow through on.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e369c9cf08954deebe7557d704f2f080", "input": "claim: National service should be re-introduced.\n perspective: National services are difficult, and hard to get going.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-fd8d51693255408ebef953e6bbcaf8db", "input": "claim: National service should be re-introduced.\n perspective: National service teaches young people valuable skills", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-1a53c1918b154d749456145275b87455", "input": "claim: National service should be re-introduced.\n perspective: Young people can learn important skills in the national service. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-227d925507474586925eda44b1ee9426", "input": "claim: National service should be re-introduced.\n perspective: Enrolling in national service teaches young people valuable skills.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-5622d28fd47946efac9b9670defbd40d", "input": "claim: National service should be re-introduced.\n perspective: National service could be offset against student loans", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-04abc488078a4f3fa2c4a502e7942bb7", "input": "claim: National service should be re-introduced.\n perspective: National service binds society together", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-cb98cd26efe1451a871c6efad986dc17", "input": "claim: National service should be re-introduced.\n perspective: Society is better connected with national service.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-2ce8b6aa07aa44f49b09dad02f469f6b", "input": "claim: National service should be re-introduced.\n perspective: National service ensures that people and society are more connected to one another. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-401b7b4f5263460fa54793c803505a48", "input": "claim: National service should be re-introduced.\n perspective: National service brings communities together.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-83107dd695174298a2782105ec55a054", "input": "claim: National service should be re-introduced.\n perspective: National services bring people together. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-34f85ef632bb4d44ab566434d96ed974", "input": "claim: National service should be re-introduced.\n perspective: It is unjust for a government to coerce its citizens", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-f5a5c074169946059e17d7332d0afd6a", "input": "claim: 16 year olds should be able to vote at presidental elections.\n perspective: children at 16 have no sense of decesion making", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-88b497e5eccd41769ef44f8a45e97ef0", "input": "claim: 16 year olds should be able to vote at presidental elections.\n perspective: Sixteen is too young to make decisions.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-8a279e1bb6854d43b2dfd7fe51c182ba", "input": "claim: 16 year olds should be able to vote at presidental elections.\n perspective: At sixteen the brain is not developed enough to make decisions.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-f39e68330b3842738ae43b1941626b65", "input": "claim: 16 year olds should be able to vote at presidental elections.\n perspective: 16 year olds are not responsible enough to vote. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-13161fed010c4e69b0b68c209e375924", "input": "claim: 16 year olds should be able to vote at presidental elections.\n perspective: 16 year olds are not wise enough to vote at elections.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-46ec54358c6c4e549544249fc6282ec0", "input": "claim: 16 year olds should be able to vote at presidental elections.\n perspective: Parents are guardians and should be trusted to vote in their children’s interests", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-1bf3768df11c42f9b7ffe8fe430fd488", "input": "claim: 16 year olds should be able to vote at presidental elections.\n perspective: Minor's interests can be appropriately taken into consideration by the votes of their parents.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c649548d36c44fc8abf3b5385a8cbe6b", "input": "claim: 16 year olds should be able to vote at presidental elections.\n perspective: A parent's vote should be counted as a vote in the interest of their child.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e07caf4a930e406591c8971e4d3b1974", "input": "claim: 16 year olds should be able to vote at presidental elections.\n perspective: Voting at a lower age would increase participation", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-21c3a28935a04159a2a4120503886709", "input": "claim: 16 year olds should be able to vote at presidental elections.\n perspective: More citizens would participate if the voting age were lowered.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e5d6a411b5b94230afe7fb75dfa7fb8c", "input": "claim: 16 year olds should be able to vote at presidental elections.\n perspective: A lower voting age would result in an increase in participation.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-88a49d4de4e44c7a8c9ea640d83be51e", "input": "claim: 16 year olds should be able to vote at presidental elections.\n perspective: Young people would be more likely to misuse their vote", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-f6d6bee132614f8bbf3ffce7f11bc1f1", "input": "claim: 16 year olds should be able to vote at presidental elections.\n perspective: Younger people are more likely to not take the impact of their vote seriously.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-73c5b4309ccd4461b83df29d4da9201d", "input": "claim: 16 year olds should be able to vote at presidental elections.\n perspective: Allowing young people to vote would be likely to result in inappropriate votes.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-fba057f44b9a4d13bcfc02c1e91c6563", "input": "claim: 16 year olds should be able to vote at presidental elections.\n perspective: 16 year olds are mature enough to vote", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-701421b9892f46aa84412150e25db364", "input": "claim: 16 year olds should be able to vote at presidental elections.\n perspective: It is appropriate for 16 year olds to have the right to vote.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-7dbb9afe63474f60b0002a287faed8e0", "input": "claim: 16 year olds should be able to vote at presidental elections.\n perspective: At sixteen there is a lack of maturity that is necessary to vote responsibly.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4dc9448134ff410f809b2451538b0f64", "input": "claim: 16 year olds should be able to vote at presidental elections.\n perspective: 16 year olds don't have a high enough level of maturity to vote.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-697709d7600a428fb727710ebb4e46f0", "input": "claim: 16 year olds should be able to vote at presidental elections.\n perspective: 16 years old is too much of an immature age to vote.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e56d3e4ca9b44e459d71e3bf4200c0d9", "input": "claim: 16 year olds should be able to vote at presidental elections.\n perspective: No. too immature.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-5d0babe0e8cb471e8f16408daeffb022", "input": "claim: 16 year olds should be able to vote at presidental elections.\n perspective: Sixteen year olds are too immature to judge the validity of political arguments.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-1e3f0a06b8784a10aa3560fe6168b494", "input": "claim: 16 year olds should be able to vote at presidental elections.\n perspective: It would help distinguish between levels of elections", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a2a5e91bba454ede94e60bfac600357b", "input": "claim: 16 year olds should be able to vote at presidental elections.\n perspective: There should not be different voting ages for different elections", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-541ea834d9ef4490b522fe6e45738159", "input": "claim: 16 year olds should be able to vote at presidental elections.\n perspective: YES, give them the rights they deserve!", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-8b3c0b815f1d481c8d4b397aa81812eb", "input": "claim: 16 year olds should be able to vote at presidental elections.\n perspective: Sixteen years would be a better option in developed countries", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-b31b4024ddee4fe0a9da04f48b6271db", "input": "claim: 16 year olds should be able to vote at presidental elections.\n perspective: I think they should have these rights.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-bfbb35503b50417caf872425af4dcb25", "input": "claim: 16 year olds should be able to vote at presidental elections.\n perspective: I would say give them the rights that they should have.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-bf695e7e94664fda9af56ef7b6571616", "input": "claim: 16 year olds should be able to vote at presidental elections.\n perspective: A slippery slope to forcing all countries to allow the vote at sixteen for all votes", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-7fad562ff659490880ac3f2ceb9c2f25", "input": "claim: 16 year olds should be able to vote at presidental elections.\n perspective: This slippery slope heads towards forcing all countires to lower the voting age to sixteen.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-290167d9a9cc45ce83a8b5f3da1fe161", "input": "claim: 16 year olds should be able to vote at presidental elections.\n perspective: This is a slippery slope that heads towards forcing all countries to allow voting at sixteen for all votes.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-28b830ff68ed454d9264e5b102cbdea1", "input": "claim: 16 year olds should be able to vote at presidental elections.\n perspective: This begins a slippery slope that can have global implications", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-1348750bb2d24e67a886be4e293a3698", "input": "claim: 16 year olds should be able to vote at presidental elections.\n perspective: Doing so may encourage other countries to try something similar", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-39d318aa0b03458a96dd72d54cfa3936", "input": "claim: 16 year olds should be able to vote at presidental elections.\n perspective: Would complicate elections", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c6262c855f184c6180027fad10fe8669", "input": "claim: 16 year olds should be able to vote at presidental elections.\n perspective: This would complicate elections.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-1d8ebc47d93444e1b6beb21ca3296b12", "input": "claim: 16 year olds should be able to vote at presidental elections.\n perspective: Elections would become more complicated.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ce6cb6f10d8b47a0b2c89125d179ffc7", "input": "claim: 16 year olds should be able to vote at presidental elections.\n perspective: Doing so would add more complications to elections", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-38877509889641c4911c4e7edf632e39", "input": "claim: 16 year olds should be able to vote at presidental elections.\n perspective: This would make elections even more confusing", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-40cf1b7f4c0a4408ba1f16dbe2ce7bd8", "input": "claim: 16 year olds should be able to vote at presidental elections.\n perspective: EU elections would put young people off voting", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-17ee94a6f7de497eb1dd500b4d9c98c1", "input": "claim: 16 year olds should be able to vote at presidental elections.\n perspective: EU elections would discourage voting among young people.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4f85070da0454e66ba691c50d6a4129f", "input": "claim: 16 year olds should be able to vote at presidental elections.\n perspective: Voting among youth would be discouraged by EU elections.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-183df33ccdc1498b8c07ddaa229cdcd2", "input": "claim: 16 year olds should be able to vote at presidental elections.\n perspective: It would cause the youth to have less interest in voting", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ee83c0d8be0a41259fcdfb8428f77fd9", "input": "claim: You should never have children.\n perspective: Having children is our duty and responsibility", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-7a73ced6aadc47b099a02673677292e3", "input": "claim: You should never have children.\n perspective: It is our mission to have children", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-37d8902e1a0d4bed8c32df13bdd6fdf5", "input": "claim: You should never have children.\n perspective: The purpose of life is to have children", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-86174a06f5c746bc8f25f74af6d97620", "input": "claim: You should never have children.\n perspective: The act of having children makes people more desirable citizens.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a33e7e02f2e9478bb7d4b30de8deb86f", "input": "claim: You should never have children.\n perspective: Having children makes you a better citizens", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-fb02c80c6716446dab3df21849b27378", "input": "claim: You should never have children.\n perspective: People are better citizens when they have children", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e35b55c575c24e83a200691ab5da5330", "input": "claim: Sexist advertising must be banned.\n perspective: Any changes in advertising should come from businesses themselves rather than through banning.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-55b69bfbfba54632a6088d0122c1e874", "input": "claim: Sexist advertising must be banned.\n perspective: Businesses bear the responsibility of self-policing themselves regarding sexist advertising.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e9670b490fac4c7a9881ea9ecf3168c4", "input": "claim: Sexist advertising must be banned.\n perspective: Sexist advertising is profitable", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-62a6f5ac40e5498db4afadc822629a29", "input": "claim: Sexist advertising must be banned.\n perspective: Policies should be established which ban the promotion of sexist attitudes in advertising.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-32d238a0ca41460698b7d5da10e8e209", "input": "claim: Sexist advertising must be banned.\n perspective: The greater advertising community should come together to decide guidelines for what is and what is not considered sexist advertising that should be banned.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-5f6395e37f674d1ba1ed0c2b216002c3", "input": "claim: Sexist advertising must be banned.\n perspective: Women have a right to be free of stereotyping.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a7e28b7e9c8548b89ceb7698c41b43b8", "input": "claim: Sexist advertising must be banned.\n perspective: Banning advertising that is in poor taste will help both men and women see people as people and not as objects.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c8f6ea1342b842099d468dbce33c9fc1", "input": "claim: Sexist advertising must be banned.\n perspective: Individuals have a choice and right to respond to ads and their meaning.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-590cd296d3fa4dcdaff5a8ede67a4422", "input": "claim: Sexist advertising must be banned.\n perspective: Sexist advertising is harmful to society, especially women.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-41f7a8b9b22e4789a037810c7031faa9", "input": "claim: Sexist advertising must be banned.\n perspective: Viewing women as sex objects in advertising harms the status of women in society.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a9c28227a748430c8cec83a26438c901", "input": "claim: Sexist advertising must be banned.\n perspective: Sexist advertising is just another way of keeping women down.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-431bdfccf40c471a873420bc1d14426d", "input": "claim: Anarchism is a valuable political ideology.\n perspective: Anarchy has nothing to contribute but violence.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c8b40ac251af4c2288f1b0d594cff6bf", "input": "claim: Anarchism is a valuable political ideology.\n perspective: Anarchist Communities have a very poor track record.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e5a8c52542bb44e6aabf25a6611face5", "input": "claim: Anarchism is a valuable political ideology.\n perspective: Even in societies with a state, anarchist groups provide a voice for the oppressed.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d03552f1f395448d8a520515ed51c635", "input": "claim: Anarchism is a valuable political ideology.\n perspective: These groups are the beneficiaries who reap their profits by kindling the deep settled hatred of among the oppressed", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a2f5cf39f4514ccd81134c4174457c8b", "input": "claim: Anarchism is a valuable political ideology.\n perspective: The state has far too often been an instrument for facilitating wars and other acts of violence.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-228ebb99ce1c49939ef205aee311c0d3", "input": "claim: Anarchism is a valuable political ideology.\n perspective: Community action is a more powerful tool than the state for providing goods.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e161082371464e91bddf859f0c82cf8c", "input": "claim: Voting should be compulsory in the UK.\n perspective: If people are forced to vote, they will not have the information needed to vote intelligently.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-9b6dc84f7f074f48884a4ae3df67f23c", "input": "claim: Voting should be compulsory in the UK.\n perspective: A vote cast by someone who does not want to vote is unlikely to be based on careful consideration.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a4391ef605b44f51994818b23d8811a7", "input": "claim: Voting should be compulsory in the UK.\n perspective: It will cause more people to become interested in politics", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d076b49b833c4fbbb09f3e3097210fbd", "input": "claim: Voting should be compulsory in the UK.\n perspective: Cause more people to become interested in politics", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-2afa19db3d1c4d91b6cc95fdc6114969", "input": "claim: Voting should be compulsory in the UK.\n perspective: It's a model that works", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ad6ad7dd7eb244838627ae64e845e614", "input": "claim: Voting should be compulsory in the UK.\n perspective: The right not to vote", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a8ac62c1d93d4ccf8941d01c0ebbbf81", "input": "claim: Voting should be compulsory in the UK.\n perspective: Voting is a civic duty", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-6b1d857dc33a413d87b654dde2d7a155", "input": "claim: Voting should be compulsory in the UK.\n perspective: A true democratic mandate for the government", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-1461a4eab0ce4333bc250780a7313076", "input": "claim: Voting should be compulsory in the UK.\n perspective: Voting is the duty of every individual in a democratic society.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-9ee8ce5bf11f44aa8bb12ddb83a4de4e", "input": "claim: Voting should be compulsory in the UK.\n perspective: It is the duty of every citizen to vote.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-eb17a0ffca934d5aa0171637e53bb6cf", "input": "claim: Voting should be compulsory in the UK.\n perspective: Compulsory Voting Does not enhance democracy", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-eebf260e61154bd79467db1414411afd", "input": "claim: Voting should be compulsory in the UK.\n perspective: Democracy is based on the freedom to vote or not.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-3eb04a460ad84f6c97b4ce23482ccf3f", "input": "claim: Voting should be compulsory in the UK.\n perspective: People can only make free choices if they want to, not because the state makes them", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e1dffa2ba4314650830e5c592f2fdce5", "input": "claim: Voting should be compulsory in the UK.\n perspective: What's the point of voting as politicians don't listen to the public anyways", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-df97bd6de38e43e58250d8bf2febd82d", "input": "claim: Voting should be compulsory in the UK.\n perspective: Why should anyone bother to vote when politicians do whatever they want?", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-eef2b42306d24244ad0e159ef2e5bea2", "input": "claim: Voting should be compulsory in the UK.\n perspective: Once elected, politicians do what they want, so why vote?", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-1842d336c37b4a42966811f15321d6f0", "input": "claim: Voting should be compulsory in the UK.\n perspective: Voting does not make sense as a rewardable/punishable action.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-1d367c0074cf4ee3a80756ff3a894c96", "input": "claim: Voting should be compulsory in the UK.\n perspective: Rewarding or punishing someone for voting is nonsensical.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-841772aaaa3343e180eb34e7c08acc32", "input": "claim: Voting should be compulsory in the UK.\n perspective: Voting should be neither rewarded or punished.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-01e1e9ba0cf64f5086bebec6b8905b48", "input": "claim: Voting should be compulsory in the UK.\n perspective: Weekend voting would be a more sensible solution", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-acbc556a4376408eac8bd5087d544096", "input": "claim: Voting should be compulsory in the UK.\n perspective: Convincing is more effective than forcing.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-0332c4e0c1d24af2a28abec1d3ff5239", "input": "claim: Voting should be compulsory in the UK.\n perspective: You can persuade to vote but you can't force someone to do it.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b9e6f00bbe574c2aa559556ca8110154", "input": "claim: Voting should be compulsory in the UK.\n perspective: People rebel from rules and do what they want anyway", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c7f6ed2dcaed49569388693a7b56f5d1", "input": "claim: Voting should be compulsory in the UK.\n perspective: Policing and financing the system is unmanageable", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a7f0e89e20464596ab947a2e92057243", "input": "claim: Voting should be compulsory in the UK.\n perspective: It would be extremely difficult to police and finance mandatory voting.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4934f76efbfb4c2fb5327bd91cbe76ab", "input": "claim: Voting should be compulsory in the UK.\n perspective: It is unreasonable to expect that compulsory voting could be financed and verified.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-9c655d98ff2547b59561fd205506c4de", "input": "claim: Voting should be compulsory in the UK.\n perspective: There are alternatives that tackle the real causes of voter disengagement", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b9b10976c92b473299feddd3b3d0bdf0", "input": "claim: Voting should be compulsory in the UK.\n perspective: Compulsory voting broadens representation of disadvantaged groups", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-0d7b17619d4e4f4fa5ad50216dcd8158", "input": "claim: Voting should be compulsory in the UK.\n perspective: Disadvantage groups are better represented when voting in mandatory.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-279cc690ebf547239f66c3fbd6c46281", "input": "claim: Voting should be compulsory in the UK.\n perspective: By making voting mandatory, disadvantaged groups improve their representation.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-dd67d82b734147c5a017bd71fe379093", "input": "claim: Voting should be compulsory in the UK.\n perspective: Compulsory voting has been implemented successfully.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-8bb38a1c5ce840cd9ced2a01acb57f2c", "input": "claim: Voting should be compulsory in the UK.\n perspective: Other places have successfully introduced compulsory voting.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-b8f4f175ec26473b8775bb83ddc62917", "input": "claim: Voting should be compulsory in the UK.\n perspective: It will reduce the power of special interest groups", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e0f1500ff5c6426e96c3224ee2a9b172", "input": "claim: The United States’ individual health insurance mandate is unconstitutional.\n perspective: The mandate is constitutional under the commerce clause", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e02afe27adbe48d0b4018e13de7d4035", "input": "claim: The United States’ individual health insurance mandate is unconstitutional.\n perspective: Health insurance's individual mandate is constitutional.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-5c7393a2aa5445898b8db72508e00aa9", "input": "claim: The United States’ individual health insurance mandate is unconstitutional.\n perspective: The United States’ individual health insurance mandate is constitutional because of he commerce clause.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-86df6b65aa5546dfafcaaecd79c8dd95", "input": "claim: The United States’ individual health insurance mandate is unconstitutional.\n perspective: There's nothing wrong with the health insurance mandate according to the constitution.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-7c18f37cb65f4da39b4ce8b3d5d29d92", "input": "claim: The United States’ individual health insurance mandate is unconstitutional.\n perspective: The mandate is not constitutional under the commerce clause ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-eb73917b9a30420fa49c83f069f5a80f", "input": "claim: Women should be allowed to take part in combat.\n perspective: There is a relatively higher female Injury rate", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-37960b3b9d9147a7a6fb0dc4c64cef8f", "input": "claim: Women should be allowed to take part in combat.\n perspective: Women are injured more frequently in combat.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-d1eb3b53619144f2b119001a185d182f", "input": "claim: Women should be allowed to take part in combat.\n perspective: Woman are more susceptible to injury while in combat.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-08e9c94f65c949158e06defbba3ce7d6", "input": "claim: Women should be allowed to take part in combat.\n perspective: Battlefield Rape is a concern", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-7752cf1f873149999be5ea8e14f21cfe", "input": "claim: Women should be allowed to take part in combat.\n perspective: The raping of women in war is a very real concern.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-d50b119153e840a79a2c66a865b71614", "input": "claim: Women should be allowed to take part in combat.\n perspective: Woman may be raped if they are allowed in combat.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-8efd41ae5bea44b0ae7cba0c74920c2c", "input": "claim: Women should be allowed to take part in combat.\n perspective: Allowing women to serve in combat increases the pool for recruits", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-922b05cd961242dea52606683ce1944b", "input": "claim: Women should be allowed to take part in combat.\n perspective: Allowing women in combat strengthens the overall defense.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-964722857d2c4a4da13e53a21dcb32b5", "input": "claim: Women should be allowed to take part in combat.\n perspective: If we do not allow women in combat we are missing out on a whole demographic of potential valuable recruits.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-b39fb224484f4f6094f2f1a98120e516", "input": "claim: Women should be allowed to take part in combat.\n perspective: The less rules there are on recruitment there more soldiers will be available. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-6c8565c6cac2494ab6c1e28761e70f73", "input": "claim: Women should be allowed to take part in combat.\n perspective: There should be equality between men and women. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-56a7c7491695400abc02f09c341f3960", "input": "claim: Women should be allowed to take part in combat.\n perspective: Equality in the sexes is of vital importance.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-09fafd9b2c50446b97dee6991e908397", "input": "claim: Women should be allowed to take part in combat.\n perspective: Male and female equality is vital to society.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-4557dd8743e64652aa02d6aaf73a42b3", "input": "claim: Women should be allowed to take part in combat.\n perspective: Integrating women into male combat units can cause men to behave badly", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-6efd8634b969421d862121509fb7a70a", "input": "claim: Women should be allowed to take part in combat.\n perspective: Men may behave inappropriately if women are in their unit.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-1fc6449b84ac412880aa695791f7221f", "input": "claim: Women should be allowed to take part in combat.\n perspective: Bad behavior may result from men when women join them in combat.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e56eb729947e4235837cf4df7b7869af", "input": "claim: Strict parenting works best.\n perspective: You aren't setting up a good relationship with your child from the start.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-0fa34c5c7d65490c88845e9ffb56fd9d", "input": "claim: Strict parenting works best.\n perspective: Kids with overly strict parents are under a lot of pressure.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-d4919c5abc0a4406b228e16c4d49daff", "input": "claim: Strict parenting works best.\n perspective: Chidren are not their parent's \"property\"", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-cb15b2d1b0804b00b3a1107c1d55c3f9", "input": "claim: Strict parenting works best.\n perspective: parents do not own their children", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ce178476dbc9482dab0902f7edbb4dce", "input": "claim: Strict parenting works best.\n perspective: parents can set boundaries but kids do what they will", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-bc74854ef0d9416bbcd435ce3acc1fcb", "input": "claim: Strict parenting works best.\n perspective: A child needs to play.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-31a082a1c9fd4294b90d7ef05f9b54e7", "input": "claim: Strict parenting works best.\n perspective: children require play and fun", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-342c93f69c984eeda6451b70c624ff3c", "input": "claim: Strict parenting works best.\n perspective: children should play and be innocent ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-0c813c10a37d444cbb521b077b9238f6", "input": "claim: Strict parenting works best.\n perspective: Kids with strict parents are more likely to rebel.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-f993ae4a699a4687a3135f3bbd84e71f", "input": "claim: Strict parenting works best.\n perspective: being too strict causes rebels", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c7ef1c9813d44da6a521ef6045b1d577", "input": "claim: Strict parenting works best.\n perspective: you will cause kids to be sneaky", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c4d6ae6601ff42ba93c71920620b71fe", "input": "claim: Strict parenting works best.\n perspective: It is better for them in the long run", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-bfc89060aa1e414f8e6ee84ec2a32485", "input": "claim: Strict parenting works best.\n perspective: strict parenting has its benefits", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ff30c3da88dd4f0985ef782409337fcd", "input": "claim: Strict parenting works best.\n perspective: in the long run children are better off with rules and restrictions ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-7efbd560046941be81f478c9257c9948", "input": "claim: Public high school students in the United States ought not be required to pass standardized exit exams to graduate.\n perspective: Sets a critical level of knowledge of what a student should know", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-916a25eaa1194785aef9bef5f2873d29", "input": "claim: Public high school students in the United States ought not be required to pass standardized exit exams to graduate.\n perspective: Standardized tests keep schools accountable in making sure their students are prepared for the world.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-2a491160b0ad4558aaa1c2bf930eed09", "input": "claim: Public high school students in the United States ought not be required to pass standardized exit exams to graduate.\n perspective: Students need to know certain things and standardized tests ensure that students are ready to graduate.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e679f7fce4094387ba88fe197329260e", "input": "claim: Public high school students in the United States ought not be required to pass standardized exit exams to graduate.\n perspective: Too much focus on test prepation to the detriment of other skills", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-2ddb74ee59d74992abb6e6b0111deacc", "input": "claim: Public high school students in the United States ought not be required to pass standardized exit exams to graduate.\n perspective: Focusing so much on test preparation takes away from other skills that students could be developing.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-65015e1cac574542b91b3ac30b3c84c9", "input": "claim: Public high school students in the United States ought not be required to pass standardized exit exams to graduate.\n perspective: Students need to be well-rounded and prepared for the world, not just prepared to take tests.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ce0ffa6728784ae096a7157abf86dc83", "input": "claim: Public high school students in the United States ought not be required to pass standardized exit exams to graduate.\n perspective: Standardized tests are arbitrary", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-8470935c5d574c4aaf64190cc2293e2d", "input": "claim: Public high school students in the United States ought not be required to pass standardized exit exams to graduate.\n perspective: Standardized tests exaggerate small differences in performance", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-0ad4621793894ab3bb138fe14532f2d1", "input": "claim: Public high school students in the United States ought not be required to pass standardized exit exams to graduate.\n perspective: Standardized tests discriminate against minorities", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-92a624940eb646ae99a1300c627bc89b", "input": "claim: Public high school students in the United States ought not be required to pass standardized exit exams to graduate.\n perspective: Standardized Tests are skewed in favour of the wealthy", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-fe8bbabe04934708b84bbe3caf876198", "input": "claim: Public high school students in the United States ought not be required to pass standardized exit exams to graduate.\n perspective: Standardized tests result in teachers “teaching the test”", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-1d2e261be9f54859ad8f21e0d36ae92f", "input": "claim: The Schengen Agreement must be dissolved.\n perspective: The Schengen Area eases the free movement of goods and people that the EU strives for", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-294e8f06018a44b9917364469821a890", "input": "claim: The Schengen Agreement must be dissolved.\n perspective: Schengen tightens external borders, creating a ‘wall’ around Europe. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-45cba774764e4a689a3a749a979f38ce", "input": "claim: The Schengen Agreement must be dissolved.\n perspective: Schengen creates an invisible wall around Europe ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c2d1345b2534421fab00c743a514c534", "input": "claim: The Schengen Agreement must be dissolved.\n perspective: As the Schengen area gets bigger, it becomes more difficult to police and this increases the risk of rogue elements being able to move freely between countries", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-7a2a9ae0104e41c4a06a4736483daff9", "input": "claim: The Schengen Agreement must be dissolved.\n perspective: It is difficult to monitor the area as it increases in size", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-5a9fc27ea6644649b32dafcb2a3738b1", "input": "claim: The Schengen Agreement must be dissolved.\n perspective: There is currently too little supervision over the area because of its increase in size", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-2c49d48bfa5240928c2da3f15a007064", "input": "claim: The Schengen Agreement must be dissolved.\n perspective: The Schengen Agreement is both a symbol of and fundamental means of upholding the unity of the European Union", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4928b61cf92a470580b5ed06f6d6a4b3", "input": "claim: The Schengen Agreement must be dissolved.\n perspective: The Agreement helps to promote the stability of the European Union", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b92ebf0dd85d4bbdbbca9a2ffaf9c66a", "input": "claim: The Schengen Agreement must be dissolved.\n perspective: The Agreement helps keep the European Union intact", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-cec80aae7cb04c519e6269517c2ff88a", "input": "claim: The Schengen Agreement must be dissolved.\n perspective: Schengen has allowed cooperation in fighting global crime", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-50960911b4be43ecadfefc48e2ad4b48", "input": "claim: The Schengen Agreement must be dissolved.\n perspective: Schengen helps countries work together to abolish crime", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4d64ad71630a4ed5868f37f1c23b7738", "input": "claim: The Schengen Agreement must be dissolved.\n perspective: Schengen allows countries to aid each other in their quest to abolish crime on a global scale", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-528d42013d2a4cac81efaf0ff8e191d2", "input": "claim: The Schengen Agreement must be dissolved.\n perspective: The Schengen Agreement is an anachronism of a safer age. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-44f13ecf7b00417bab8bdc9682598d4f", "input": "claim: Users of extremist websites should be punished.\n perspective: Criminalisation will not stop radicalisation", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-19564664b7ce4608b47c4beb03fe584d", "input": "claim: Users of extremist websites should be punished.\n perspective: Radicalisation cannot be stopped by criminalisation", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-59bd992b3a2f4be485b3c691e3e1a4bf", "input": "claim: Users of extremist websites should be punished.\n perspective: Limiting communication of extremists can cripple their threatening agendas.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-cfb870bc46584f988230c77f21e57abd", "input": "claim: Users of extremist websites should be punished.\n perspective: Extremist should not be allowed to use internet", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-6b51a57156d742f7b9090f3394e2a93b", "input": "claim: Users of extremist websites should be punished.\n perspective: It makes it more difficult for extremists to organize and spread their message when blocked", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-0558d2e6be1246548e659c4da3c337ed", "input": "claim: Users of extremist websites should be punished.\n perspective: The internet is an echo chamber that will confirm extremists in their views if not stopped", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-9213bf2d18ee4e1483a575aa8dbe1326", "input": "claim: Users of extremist websites should be punished.\n perspective: Criminalisation creates more problems than it solves", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-5b97195c08164a17ac6c93e0c24dd35b", "input": "claim: Users of extremist websites should be punished.\n perspective: Problems are not going to be stopped by criminalisation", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-5d95c09d4e70410abe10906141dde280", "input": "claim: Users of extremist websites should be punished.\n perspective: The freedom of speech can be curtailed when it represents a serious threat to society", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-3282230f4a4b40fc9f3af37283930662", "input": "claim: Users of extremist websites should be punished.\n perspective: In some cases freedom of speech should be limited to protect a nation's security.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-80173d0587a14be5bc20902ff10ac1bb", "input": "claim: Users of extremist websites should be punished.\n perspective: Serious threats to our society sometimes justify restricting a specific person or group's freedom of speech.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ca8a3f1da28047bc9f555ee93725391c", "input": "claim: Users of extremist websites should be punished.\n perspective: Blocking these sites makes it more difficult for extremist groups to coordinate extremist action in the real world", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-90a1d6a6a5e64feeb5cc962a166e3c57", "input": "claim: Users of extremist websites should be punished.\n perspective: Blocking specific sites will disrupt extremist agendas that could threaten the free world.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-4701d3d5401242a3a195745400cc3566", "input": "claim: Users of extremist websites should be punished.\n perspective: Blocking these sites is one of our best preventative measures in combating extremists.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e2eca25c40024d77b2337729399115d1", "input": "claim: Users of extremist websites should be punished.\n perspective: Everyone, even extremists, deserve their freedom of expression protected", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-68a4468a2857453cbf653faeea3ec90d", "input": "claim: Users of extremist websites should be punished.\n perspective: Freedom of expression is a right guaranteed to all, and reducing or eliminating those freedoms is never acceptable.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-dc7a85211d5a4f219ff4743758cec884", "input": "claim: Users of extremist websites should be punished.\n perspective: Freedoms are not earned or deserved they are given to all people equally and no one should determine which agendas are too extreme to receive this protection.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-1b8f92ad45744364a954c6e6468e521f", "input": "claim: We have to teach creationism in schools.\n perspective: There is no empirical evidence supporting Creationism, whereas all evidence supports abiogenesis and evolution.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-f46f368895c3464890b6ef4a4bb706bb", "input": "claim: We have to teach creationism in schools.\n perspective: Schools must teach what is evidence-based, which would mean to teach abiogenesis and not Creationism. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-1b4de3afdd4848abba71c7acc48b7b70", "input": "claim: We have to teach creationism in schools.\n perspective: Faith-based Creationism shouldn't be taught in schools because they must be fact-based, s abiogenesis and evolution are.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a5d441043ae7442096ec9a1655b92421", "input": "claim: We have to teach creationism in schools.\n perspective: There is a very real controversy regarding the origin and development of life, and children deserve to hear both sides.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d0549de7282b49278d338cd0fda56e45", "input": "claim: We have to teach creationism in schools.\n perspective: Children deserve to hear both sides of the argument over the origin of life.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e7a6d9c9fceb431fb41f1818914eb977", "input": "claim: We have to teach creationism in schools.\n perspective: Creationism is as valid a scientific theory as those of evolution and abiogenesis, and should therefore be given equal time in the classroom.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-b7ab2d4c9f884f52b72b3dc6f1a3defc", "input": "claim: We have to teach creationism in schools.\n perspective: Because Creationism is a valid scientific theory, it should be given equal time in teaching.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-04198b97de0e4656b71873aa11f93275", "input": "claim: We have to teach creationism in schools.\n perspective: We must teach Creationism as an alternative theory because it is scientifically valid.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-2520f7c962b943ab8512b447cb2d4db8", "input": "claim: We have to teach creationism in schools.\n perspective: Much of the complexity of life cannot be explained by evolution, but is perfectly explained by Creationism.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-132e40571f484b9c980d7015890bc8a3", "input": "claim: We have to teach creationism in schools.\n perspective: Creationism has theoretical answers to questions evolution can't answer.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e5f95d97ba094236b9f686b48c155d69", "input": "claim: We have to teach creationism in schools.\n perspective: Evolution cannot answer irreducible complexity like Creationism can.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-348e9eadff584460949f179c16bd1203", "input": "claim: We have to teach creationism in schools.\n perspective: The scientific community as a whole overwhelmingly rejects Creationism.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c9559f7f03984defabeb3f7efe101d88", "input": "claim: We have to teach creationism in schools.\n perspective: Creationism isn't supported by the scientific community.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b0d7ed7988d14f1d8b5e9e1a41d065b1", "input": "claim: We have to teach creationism in schools.\n perspective: Communities should have a say in what is taught in schools, and many communities want to teach creationism.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-bc86155e819b4829899e4fbe14d56d8f", "input": "claim: We have to teach creationism in schools.\n perspective: Communities have a right to insist on Creationism when it is popular.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-52b5180152ba46309b29e7bb99191bb2", "input": "claim: We have to teach creationism in schools.\n perspective: Education should be about truth and facts, not dogma and faith.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-5911b9b01a344801992b03add1d54322", "input": "claim: We have to teach creationism in schools.\n perspective: Society should educate based on objective facts, rather than subjective beliefs and opinion.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-31cd8bb5e01a4a02a5b4a31adf84d0ec", "input": "claim: We have to teach creationism in schools.\n perspective: Unproven speculative beliefs have no place in education as it needs to be based on provable facts.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e00dd251b2b54bf1bcb805d3877646be", "input": "claim: We have to teach creationism in schools.\n perspective: Everyone has the right to free speech including teachers. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-8cdc554594964d88a8736f762bc166d4", "input": "claim: We have to teach creationism in schools.\n perspective: Teachers should have freedom to explore ideas just as much as everyone else. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-0da2291bb61f4a53ab76409e7704ee59", "input": "claim: We have to teach creationism in schools.\n perspective: The bill does not exclude evolution just allows room for other theories", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f8c41c73b81c41bd85d2eacee5dcedcd", "input": "claim: We have to teach creationism in schools.\n perspective: Evolution is allowed to be explored along with other theories.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-dc05f353458748c29d55f843990182b9", "input": "claim: We have to teach creationism in schools.\n perspective: This bill allows teachers and students to explore all theories including evolution. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-dca3cdf0dfa64ab787b71e5458d1cae1", "input": "claim: We have to teach creationism in schools.\n perspective: Teaching creationism as well as evolution gives students freedom to choose", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-870b5d50dd804defb98f240ad5564f02", "input": "claim: We have to teach creationism in schools.\n perspective: Creationism and evolution both have merits and it should be up to the children to decide which to believe in.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-5ff650abc7f8415a82cc5c01334c985e", "input": "claim: We have to teach creationism in schools.\n perspective: Teachers should not have freedom to teach whatever they wish as fact", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4d25ed2e707d46a0bce04764f64d6aac", "input": "claim: We have to teach creationism in schools.\n perspective: Teachers should only teach what is agreed to as fact.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-f21865c0f664404a8c99ef1cdfb1aa5b", "input": "claim: We have to teach creationism in schools.\n perspective: Teachers shouldn't teach whatever they want.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-53761abd516f481996e31ff04e44ba9d", "input": "claim: It is sometimes right for the government to restrict freedom of speech.\n perspective: Choosing cultural values are the rights of the people.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-47d36e3c7a8842a2969cb1f7a709c3ac", "input": "claim: It is sometimes right for the government to restrict freedom of speech.\n perspective: People have a right to choose their cultural values", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c6d19a544a334e3080310b83ee80437f", "input": "claim: It is sometimes right for the government to restrict freedom of speech.\n perspective: It may be necessary in the interests of national security", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c957d54aa63d4e0fbf3756cc16043379", "input": "claim: It is sometimes right for the government to restrict freedom of speech.\n perspective: Free speech is bad for national security.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-82dc3ba923404eaa98af20abdac6e8bc", "input": "claim: It is sometimes right for the government to restrict freedom of speech.\n perspective: The nation is at risk if everyone can say anything they want.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-08b0c6e33f5e4366b4d54d4017c46f5e", "input": "claim: It is sometimes right for the government to restrict freedom of speech.\n perspective: Protection of Minors", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-344fdefa3fba4fa493f43b08abd3e080", "input": "claim: It is sometimes right for the government to restrict freedom of speech.\n perspective: Limiting free speech protects youth.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-1e82cdc39ebd400cbcc7d961288b70cd", "input": "claim: It is sometimes right for the government to restrict freedom of speech.\n perspective: Free speech allows challenges to orthodox beliefs", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b7b9dd93de334e348c09a3ec84b9c743", "input": "claim: It is sometimes right for the government to restrict freedom of speech.\n perspective: The freedom of speech can be curtailed when it represents a serious threat to society", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c458747d9bfb49c684104f5b3177019c", "input": "claim: It is sometimes right for the government to restrict freedom of speech.\n perspective: In some cases freedom of speech should be limited to protect a nation's security.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-94457f9911b7405894efd4d1ed6b5ce3", "input": "claim: It is sometimes right for the government to restrict freedom of speech.\n perspective: Serious threats to our society sometimes justify restricting a specific person or group's freedom of speech.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-06bdfa5b30724cac80907a69d5a60ddd", "input": "claim: It is sometimes right for the government to restrict freedom of speech.\n perspective: Everyone should be allowed free speech.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-5eb9dad4a8424b6384d4ad3215444b84", "input": "claim: It is sometimes right for the government to restrict freedom of speech.\n perspective: Everyone, even extremists, deserve their freedom of expression protected", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-64d47db1c25e4f29aaf74ae26ddce370", "input": "claim: It is sometimes right for the government to restrict freedom of speech.\n perspective: Freedom of Speech is a Universal Right", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-9363075ad75e4fb2a3e79a6f5117c64a", "input": "claim: It is sometimes right for the government to restrict freedom of speech.\n perspective: Freedom of expression is a right guaranteed to all, and reducing or eliminating those freedoms is never acceptable.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c9c6015cff2144a2b592330ef013b82c", "input": "claim: Refusing to stand for the National Anthem is an appropriate form of protest.\n perspective: Refusing to stand for the national anthem angers many and sows division in our country.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c8253fdcb5de453e839a33fa3fa04e45", "input": "claim: Refusing to stand for the National Anthem is an appropriate form of protest.\n perspective: When a national figure such as an NFL player refuses to stand for the national anthem, it shocks people into paying attention and generates conversation. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-3e8149a70f254337b3d9ee1a685341a3", "input": "claim: Refusing to stand for the National Anthem is an appropriate form of protest.\n perspective: An NFL player, as a celebrity, can get people to notice and discuss issues by not standing for the anthem.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-384e533c26504df5a3a9a01781d3b2d1", "input": "claim: Refusing to stand for the National Anthem is an appropriate form of protest.\n perspective: When people see a celebrity not standing for the national anthem, it makes people notice and spurs debate.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-1247d706198f4e6b97d0cee72bfbb371", "input": "claim: Refusing to stand for the National Anthem is an appropriate form of protest.\n perspective: Refusing to stand for the national anthem shows disrespect for the flag and members of the armed forces.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-f3f7cc4fdaca421c823a90b534b19dec", "input": "claim: Refusing to stand for the National Anthem is an appropriate form of protest.\n perspective: Although refusing to stand for the national anthem is an appropriate form of protest, it shows disrespect for the flag.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-9d993d18aeac4da2bb5d165f2cd79550", "input": "claim: Refusing to stand for the National Anthem is an appropriate form of protest.\n perspective: Refusing to stand for the national anthem can be viewed as disrespectful", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-00e06fb82d0745b58c6553f010152434", "input": "claim: Refusing to stand for the National Anthem is an appropriate form of protest.\n perspective: Not acknowledging the flag and anthem is perceived as a slight to the military.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-8ef50a7fbe2f4e0c9c2c1f27ccbd1e12", "input": "claim: Refusing to stand for the National Anthem is an appropriate form of protest.\n perspective: A lack of respect and perceived lack of patriotism is brought forth by failing to stand for the national anthem.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-9b4cf3850f154afb8430e4d1c2b3ee1d", "input": "claim: Refusing to stand for the National Anthem is an appropriate form of protest.\n perspective: When one believes the United States is not living up to its ideals of freedom, liberty, and justice for all, refusing to stand for the national anthem is appropriate and justified.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c58a4d911bfe4c3b82f955c909eb4046", "input": "claim: Refusing to stand for the National Anthem is an appropriate form of protest.\n perspective: It is OK to not stand for the national anthem if you think the US is not honoring its ideals.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f9e683545157455fb371d8c9583c0cd9", "input": "claim: Refusing to stand for the National Anthem is an appropriate form of protest.\n perspective: Freedom, liberty, and justice for all are important, and if someone feels the US is not honoring that, they are free to not stand for the anthem.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-1b6b394c8d5e425ea58b585c468ec787", "input": "claim: Refusing to stand for the National Anthem is an appropriate form of protest.\n perspective: Not standing for the national anthem is a legal form of peaceful protest, which is a First Amendment right.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-62af563fd26444b5bc2e3a5dc244e9a9", "input": "claim: Refusing to stand for the National Anthem is an appropriate form of protest.\n perspective: Peaceful protest, like not standing for the anthem, is protected by the First Amendment.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-227d57184086466b84a25c8d1a80f57b", "input": "claim: Refusing to stand for the National Anthem is an appropriate form of protest.\n perspective: Our Constitution allows us to peacefully protest legally, so there's no reason someone should be forced to stand for the anthem.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-318d7bbf62c0438c98e2ae7b53ab94d2", "input": "claim: Refusing to stand for the National Anthem is an appropriate form of protest.\n perspective: Not standing for the national anthem is an ineffective and counterproductive way to promote a cause. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-3c362a16ea684fe898c3ace095677b55", "input": "claim: Refusing to stand for the National Anthem is an appropriate form of protest.\n perspective: Not standing for the anthem doesn't do anything to actually protest injustice.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-629d234a80414542a2202718ff382aa3", "input": "claim: Refusing to stand for the National Anthem is an appropriate form of protest.\n perspective: Not standing for the anthem is counterproductive because it undermines your cause.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-fe586686247d410c9b1c7f3a248afe58", "input": "claim: Alcohol should be banned.\n perspective: Banning alcohol protects third parties (family members) from harm. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-3ac42aa5ad904f77a52301ef5c694ccd", "input": "claim: Alcohol should be banned.\n perspective: We should BAN Alcohol for our families", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-bfab79adc763431bb63855906e314f1c", "input": "claim: Alcohol should be banned.\n perspective: Banning alcohol would lead to healthier individuals. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-1f828503237a43bfa8e83ca960ce0e54", "input": "claim: Alcohol should be banned.\n perspective: Alcohol should be banned so that our individuals would lead healthier lives. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-30b206b4595b4f1790a176156d9c43b0", "input": "claim: Alcohol should be banned.\n perspective: Banning Alcohol will improve health", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c9a5f1aca67747f3b43f2db543620488", "input": "claim: Alcohol should be banned.\n perspective: An alcohol ban would be good for society", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-3a44a91ce3774a2d8b85a01833e111eb", "input": "claim: Alcohol should be banned.\n perspective: Banning alcohol is a quick fix to a wider societal problem. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d220abac1cb94995a5a22a10c030e6c8", "input": "claim: Religion In Itself Is A Purely Positive Force In The World.\n perspective: Religious Doctrine Preaches Altruism", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-66af5a88a2c145bd96bcaf01c717fa62", "input": "claim: Religion In Itself Is A Purely Positive Force In The World.\n perspective: After looking the pros and cons we can conclude religion is a very positive force.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-87506bee742f4744914daa8f6b06620b", "input": "claim: Religion In Itself Is A Purely Positive Force In The World.\n perspective: Religion Does NOT Cause War.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-36f039de90074b4da22f48a70f3a3cfc", "input": "claim: Religion In Itself Is A Purely Positive Force In The World.\n perspective: Religion Does Not Condone Destructive War", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-1ec9b08b263e4da0b264257088d73f4e", "input": "claim: Religion In Itself Is A Purely Positive Force In The World.\n perspective: War does not occur due to religion.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c70ac267c42a4fbab9a7c2b0893b98ab", "input": "claim: Religion In Itself Is A Purely Positive Force In The World.\n perspective: Religion does not promote violence.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-fc9944cdca3041279e68533ee539c7b7", "input": "claim: Religion In Itself Is A Purely Positive Force In The World.\n perspective: Religious organisations are by far the largest providers of charity in the world", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-24a8e00384644ed18b58226ad677815a", "input": "claim: Religion In Itself Is A Purely Positive Force In The World.\n perspective: Religious organisations provide the most charitable giving among anyone else worldwide.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f48b10cec59b49d9afa4b15d9b0d326a", "input": "claim: Religion In Itself Is A Purely Positive Force In The World.\n perspective: No one else gives or does more charitable work in the world than religious organisations.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-84c406d3f158472981c47bf29646817b", "input": "claim: Religion In Itself Is A Purely Positive Force In The World.\n perspective: Religious ceremonies and organisations provide solace and celebration for the great changes in life such as birth, marriage and death, there is democratic support for this around the world", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-5b883c2bec384879a46c7e372bc4aceb", "input": "claim: Religion In Itself Is A Purely Positive Force In The World.\n perspective: Religious events are a good place for people to celebrate various life milestones.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-9b054c27a1b548d1a78121d9ce194439", "input": "claim: Religion In Itself Is A Purely Positive Force In The World.\n perspective: People are able to celebrate various life events at religious gatherings and so there is democratic support for religion.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-1a09cda2733d4730b9afb87cce955c0b", "input": "claim: The U.S. Should Ban The Use of Cluster Bombs.\n perspective: Rejecting the Ban on Cluster Bombs Hurts the international image of the U.S.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-95486ab81c2543648f92520b66dd94e7", "input": "claim: The U.S. Should Ban The Use of Cluster Bombs.\n perspective: Cluster Bombs are too unreliable, so the U.S. should ban them.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-fabfd750cb6441c991f11368993e3aaf", "input": "claim: The U.S. Should Ban The Use of Cluster Bombs.\n perspective: The U.S. should ban Cluster Bombs because they have no place in this world.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-172c10397d524902876887cd18f134c9", "input": "claim: The feminist movement should seek a ban on pornography.\n perspective: Pornography liberates women", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-3790d5fd89a94c1299b64e1e8e6a0393", "input": "claim: The feminist movement should seek a ban on pornography.\n perspective: Porn is inherently dehumanising", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c1e0cfe7da7e430b84f01c99d13174c7", "input": "claim: The feminist movement should seek a ban on pornography.\n perspective: Pornography dehumanizes its subject.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-31b8e9d960c448ee9dca6a9547b10090", "input": "claim: The feminist movement should seek a ban on pornography.\n perspective: Pornography inherently makes a person less human.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-6376429de62641f48bf38b76927d90ea", "input": "claim: The feminist movement should seek a ban on pornography.\n perspective: Pornography eroticises violence", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-39d1c0649b8a4b4181cfc923e84de9f2", "input": "claim: The feminist movement should seek a ban on pornography.\n perspective: Pornography makes violence look sexy.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-3b82b46bec2d43f9973a46038b9cd46b", "input": "claim: The feminist movement should seek a ban on pornography.\n perspective: The feminist movement should not allow women to sell themselves", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-1fe040a48a2541079be5f6828db5ff63", "input": "claim: The feminist movement should seek a ban on pornography.\n perspective: Feminists shouldn't allow women to sell their bodies for porn.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-1a91405104c345c1a04d9f220209de21", "input": "claim: The feminist movement should seek a ban on pornography.\n perspective: Selling one's body for porn is anti-feminist.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-65fddc3a5b21422e8c52958848af7cf0", "input": "claim: The feminist movement should seek a ban on pornography.\n perspective: Attempting to ban it would only cause further problems", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-74e4717e0aa9411fa6672134e3c19732", "input": "claim: The feminist movement should seek a ban on pornography.\n perspective: Only more problems would arise from the prohibition of pornography", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-108bf12e59e345a8a63d826d065d52a7", "input": "claim: The feminist movement should seek a ban on pornography.\n perspective: Pornography fuels unreachable ideals ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-15ec496db4be413ca8c05575e2b40bdc", "input": "claim: The feminist movement should seek a ban on pornography.\n perspective: Pornography causes unreachable standards.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ec91d824aae646e087b19b6fe9d87b3a", "input": "claim: The feminist movement should seek a ban on pornography.\n perspective: Pornography gives people unrealistic ideas.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-b62c755f1d9344368c7edf327213a851", "input": "claim: Africans are worse off due to natural resources.\n perspective: Natural resources create employment", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-51dbfea1af4c4c8b90c520416c1da39a", "input": "claim: Africans are worse off due to natural resources.\n perspective: One positive of natural resources is that it creates jobs.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-5ac29d75748f400faae8a376fd53c461", "input": "claim: Africans are worse off due to natural resources.\n perspective: Natural resources are of huge benefit for many reasons, one being the creation of work for the people. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-99e81bcc9a2642179bdd1a2be35c8a0a", "input": "claim: Africans are worse off due to natural resources.\n perspective: Resources are a source of conflict", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-70b1bb6a2dbf4fd2ad94085d98b3e4c1", "input": "claim: Africans are worse off due to natural resources.\n perspective: The crux of the conflict comes down to the resources.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-0eb594f071164c0291e1dbfbba97ca80", "input": "claim: Africans are worse off due to natural resources.\n perspective: Foreign companies gain most of the profits", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-5bd325a0975647118563df66200177ea", "input": "claim: Africans are worse off due to natural resources.\n perspective: Foreign companies benefit most from the relationship.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-1bb1e3cd84e649628abdd6e93f53c5a6", "input": "claim: Africans are worse off due to natural resources.\n perspective: The arrangement works to the disproportionate advantage of the foreign companies. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-7a3ede3c3bd1405d9bbe454014e0b9c5", "input": "claim: Africans are worse off due to natural resources.\n perspective: Bring Africa out of poverty ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-12cb2e55787b45cb9fa1225ee5868d21", "input": "claim: Africans are worse off due to natural resources.\n perspective: Resource abundance has led to poor governance", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d56752b51e5945cf8fb0274eb7168e46", "input": "claim: Africans are worse off due to natural resources.\n perspective: An influx in resources has led to inefficient leaders", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-1a1a2b4461194e4e86f533dcad8ea504", "input": "claim: Africans are worse off due to natural resources.\n perspective: Richness in resources has caused our leaders to govern poorly", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-af9ad0813c5048c8a8fa28ff620d35ae", "input": "claim: Children should not be allowed to inherit vast wealth as this damages them and society.\n perspective: Inherited wealth can advance rich children in some professions and this can exclude poorer children.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-4c03ed811c8e47d38288bde9463d1311", "input": "claim: Children should not be allowed to inherit vast wealth as this damages them and society.\n perspective: Who decides how much is too much, and on what basis? ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-9d1008f115384d37ad01c8c6e2d1cd30", "input": "claim: Children should not be allowed to inherit vast wealth as this damages them and society.\n perspective: Society can never ensure that all children start on an 'equal footing' and why would it want to?", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-98d6e20d033c47b597c293ddbb953cef", "input": "claim: Children should not be allowed to inherit vast wealth as this damages them and society.\n perspective: Society would be damaged if people could not satisfy the procreative urge by enriching their children, as this would demotivate them.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-6e561912b022446887a0cec8259cc3eb", "input": "claim: Children should not be allowed to inherit vast wealth as this damages them and society.\n perspective: Giving massive wealth to children would demotivate them and make them less productive for society.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-31154074fc9f4b389a7e733bdee72183", "input": "claim: Children should not be allowed to inherit vast wealth as this damages them and society.\n perspective: Children who inherit riches are in a sense demotivated and as a result damaging towards society.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4e27b40530384e26907b6b3899c65e9e", "input": "claim: Children should not be allowed to inherit vast wealth as this damages them and society.\n perspective: An excess of wealth prevents spiritual growth", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-0e6aa5d53da44df6bd555c3b72544fd9", "input": "claim: Children should not be allowed to inherit vast wealth as this damages them and society.\n perspective: The more money you have, the less spiritual you are.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-25e39a9bba264e63a8daa0250bd5e82e", "input": "claim: Children should not be allowed to inherit vast wealth as this damages them and society.\n perspective: Having too much money prevents you from growing spiritually.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-2868c3f834394d578f422de18681a9f4", "input": "claim: Children should not be allowed to inherit vast wealth as this damages them and society.\n perspective: World economics would suffer", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-f0fa813090ef4f89bf48a44e6c5c6160", "input": "claim: The People’s Republic of China should invade North Korea.\n perspective: Is not worth the price", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-db5d1d6161f14315be83e35cfb6835a9", "input": "claim: The People’s Republic of China should invade North Korea.\n perspective: It is far too expensive.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e714ce38772743dc81d6406a89febcad", "input": "claim: The People’s Republic of China should invade North Korea.\n perspective: The costs would be outrageous. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-22e9cc46f86d464eab1ed91d197a3b87", "input": "claim: The People’s Republic of China should invade North Korea.\n perspective: To invade could trigger an Arms Race: the very thing everyone wants to avoid!", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-92ccc10a43f94efc984f71fcfab5c2f7", "input": "claim: The People’s Republic of China should invade North Korea.\n perspective: Everyone wants to avoid an Arms Race, and an invasion could trigger just that outcome. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-50189d0a2ee44c4cb7ab912317b7447b", "input": "claim: The People’s Republic of China should invade North Korea.\n perspective: An Arms race is the one outcome everyone wants to avoid, and an invasion could lead to that. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-58137ea89993421db0357bc877f24e71", "input": "claim: The People’s Republic of China should invade North Korea.\n perspective: North Korea is a threat to China in the future and a nuisance now.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e99db09e9edc41a0aac7fc2080e6a0c6", "input": "claim: The People’s Republic of China should invade North Korea.\n perspective: North Korea is both an annoyance now and a threat in the future to China.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-0f49d99a8cf14f83986b58ac0364edc1", "input": "claim: The People’s Republic of China should invade North Korea.\n perspective: For China, North Korea is a current nuisance and a future threat. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-6778168132e54a129ee004faa89e0ec5", "input": "claim: The UK Should Leave the European Union.\n perspective: Students will have to pay British tuition fees", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-d66157929e3e4708a4e002c75dbf73f8", "input": "claim: The UK Should Leave the European Union.\n perspective: No chance of changing from the Pound to the Euro", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-42fa39063bd347e0ad06cd1c0d4d677f", "input": "claim: The UK Should Leave the European Union.\n perspective: one point that is always not mentioned is the EU is part of the New World Order", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b92aac9f58ec436aaf59e75faf23418e", "input": "claim: The UK Should Leave the European Union.\n perspective: British taxpayers are forced to bail out other European countries rather than receive goods and services", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e2ba271655c94ab996180ba97ce7eb18", "input": "claim: The UK Should Leave the European Union.\n perspective: The UK would have a completely independent foreign policy", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-01e7d54dc8e84ae9a1d45ab8d4fca275", "input": "claim: The UK Should Leave the European Union.\n perspective: The UK can be independed ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e794942f2e264b7ea930ddb0db935bce", "input": "claim: The UK Should Leave the European Union.\n perspective: The UK can have an independet foreign policy", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-8b369ecbfa1d4e7881ed9d5dee0c5018", "input": "claim: The UK Should Leave the European Union.\n perspective: UK will be disentangled from EU affairs", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-0ade1ab365a44c00bde77dabcd92e36c", "input": "claim: The UK Should Leave the European Union.\n perspective: UK will be disentangled", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ce6d9a91f6c849f884c69dd801c0c86e", "input": "claim: The UK Should Leave the European Union.\n perspective: UK will not be entangled", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-2f6b21ef6903475b8518595ca55fd78a", "input": "claim: The UK Should Leave the European Union.\n perspective: Leaving the EU will mean the UK will have less regional influence", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-63ac67e5afdc402791713769717f0de8", "input": "claim: The UK Should Leave the European Union.\n perspective: UK leaving the EU will shift its influences.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4ce5f68f46f04389946aceb0cc75c867", "input": "claim: The UK Should Leave the European Union.\n perspective: By leaving the EU, the UK would have less power in the region", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4844b27269784e2793e13e699fb52fdb", "input": "claim: The UK Should Leave the European Union.\n perspective: The UK would lose their regional influence is they left the EU", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-8f2a200fa0fb4313a3446a2e866ba33f", "input": "claim: The UK Should Leave the European Union.\n perspective: The EU causes instability", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-fbbfb62048674a578b35bcb106261ed9", "input": "claim: The UK Should Leave the European Union.\n perspective: Leaving the EU means leaving the instability that was there", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c857835bd5c64ed994856f9a13f9a448", "input": "claim: The UK Should Leave the European Union.\n perspective: Being involved with the EU causes instability", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-4024b64bdffd420ea1357f041c6bdb14", "input": "claim: The UK Should Leave the European Union.\n perspective: A nation state can only rely on itself for security", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-92d40215431741fab7bf3e77f970392d", "input": "claim: The UK Should Leave the European Union.\n perspective: UK will renew its self-reliance in security.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-4fa8592f79d048cd85de3bfecf8722e1", "input": "claim: The UK Should Leave the European Union.\n perspective: Security changes to arise when UK leaves EU.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-892b1f3690544971a0e3c56cac7f54f8", "input": "claim: The UK Should Leave the European Union.\n perspective: A nation state has only themselves to look out for them", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-54f98a57c80e4388875a1943d548fbf6", "input": "claim: The UK Should Leave the European Union.\n perspective: A nation state can only expect itself to be able to protect the people", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c97acc2648df4f24a2ca3ecd87a5f701", "input": "claim: The UK Should Leave the European Union.\n perspective: Security is better shared", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-bad0ec4552964887bfff102842f4412f", "input": "claim: The UK Should Leave the European Union.\n perspective: UK security strongest when shared with EU.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e8f85bc86c1d4ba9bb62339059a97982", "input": "claim: The UK Should Leave the European Union.\n perspective: Leaving EU would weaken UK security.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-73a4bf10ee93497d884dbc3650f44f5c", "input": "claim: The UK Should Leave the European Union.\n perspective: Security is stronger when there are others involved", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-3faf925fd11c49c48d8d9027ca127e5d", "input": "claim: The UK Should Leave the European Union.\n perspective: It is better protection when others are also sharing some of that responsibility ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-3d9db11c92ff4eb988dc1549ebeca808", "input": "claim: The UK Should Leave the European Union.\n perspective: Leaving the EU would mean leaving their security services too", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e59d6536f049408c9d73c4e82026b1b7", "input": "claim: The UK Should Leave the European Union.\n perspective: By leaving the EU, they would lose the security they had shared", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-8c52cf53b914449890d904847f3e2afb", "input": "claim: The UK Should Leave the European Union.\n perspective: Leaving will mean less communication with other security services", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-0abbe145e81e4d6d9afaa82950a1e89a", "input": "claim: The federal minimum wage should be increased.\n perspective: Increasing the federal minimum wage would disproportionately harm the poorest areas of the United States.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e59a0525c12f414d8c33966c31b38db8", "input": "claim: The federal minimum wage should be increased.\n perspective: Increasing the minimum wage only serves to hurt the unskilled, poor workers.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-0b1a2375b1454e5bb7469342c30da65e", "input": "claim: The federal minimum wage should be increased.\n perspective: By increasing the minimum wage, the poorest section of America is hurt more than any section is helped.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c83162744668424898081832a6c24d53", "input": "claim: The federal minimum wage should be increased.\n perspective: Raising the minimum wage would help reduce the federal deficit.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e8f762e078ab40f68d74a63042f5b8c4", "input": "claim: The federal minimum wage should be increased.\n perspective: Increasing the minimum wage would reduce the federal deficit.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-1a90abf690284ad093dd71b466e8e17d", "input": "claim: The federal minimum wage should be increased.\n perspective: Raising the minimum wage would encourage companies to outsource jobs to countries where costs would be lower. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-41dc4fe44f3543abaf0fc6df75715387", "input": "claim: The federal minimum wage should be increased.\n perspective: Raising the minimum wage would force employers to find lower cost labor", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-977d020262d441efbfa1bea9a529641a", "input": "claim: The federal minimum wage should be increased.\n perspective: Raising the minimum wage would hollow out companies through outsourcing to lower cost labor", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-2c2ef3f384084c32a3ff33c66ebe0462", "input": "claim: The federal minimum wage should be increased.\n perspective: Raising the minimum wage would disadvantage low-skilled workers. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-6871d935be524f208ae365f85d9530e8", "input": "claim: The federal minimum wage should be increased.\n perspective: Less educated workers will be at a disadvantage if the minimum wage is increased.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e64e5cd8300f4d99b0f21640ff410374", "input": "claim: The federal minimum wage should be increased.\n perspective: Raising the minimum wage does not help unskilled workers.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-6f25faf79d8245d0beb70855947f34e8", "input": "claim: The federal minimum wage should be increased.\n perspective: The minimum wage has not kept up with inflation.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a136564c3cca4bd08c0b53fba1b45eff", "input": "claim: The federal minimum wage should be increased.\n perspective: Minimum wage has not kept pace with increases in inflation.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-3aa14ca268e247838ee34e630c930273", "input": "claim: The federal minimum wage should be increased.\n perspective: Inflation has increased at a faster pace than minimum wage.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-de99dc08f3904d86bae83da71935c2af", "input": "claim: The federal minimum wage should be increased.\n perspective: The cost of living has increased but minimum wage has stayed the same. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-1b46d4122e3c459c802794f743eaa966", "input": "claim: The federal minimum wage should be increased.\n perspective: Minimum wage needs to evolved with increasingly more expensive cost of living. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-2cac9cb51cb44076a2a4719900e2e64e", "input": "claim: The federal minimum wage should be increased.\n perspective: Teenagers and young adults may be shut out of the workforce if the minimum wage is increased.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e68a8010b8424848881b21d2289dd409", "input": "claim: The federal minimum wage should be increased.\n perspective: Teenagers and young adults won't be able to find employment, if minimum wage is increased.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-91b067b712754181a1e0602b0f5c4362", "input": "claim: The federal minimum wage should be increased.\n perspective: Inexperienced and new workers will have a hard time finding employment.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-f47b5a8a1c2349a9aa6641eeaf306649", "input": "claim: The federal minimum wage should be increased.\n perspective: Raising minimum wage will increase the cost the living.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-08b7ccfb67634488921ab6913a3a2ce8", "input": "claim: The federal minimum wage should be increased.\n perspective: Housing costs would only go up if the minimum wage is increased. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-daefd98b9ec54aff9b5f364207179d5b", "input": "claim: The federal minimum wage should be increased.\n perspective: If the minimum wage is increased, all Americans will be harmed because housing prices will go up.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-82159eaf15074dd7a9b5f533af20b61f", "input": "claim: The federal minimum wage should be increased.\n perspective: Raising the minimum wage would increase the price of consumer goods.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-475d134f810f48418a1c5d913cba4c29", "input": "claim: The federal minimum wage should be increased.\n perspective: Raising the minimum wage would increase housing costs. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-d6df1cce21174b0db06212a0a55dfcb0", "input": "claim: The federal minimum wage should be increased.\n perspective: Raising the minimum wage would lead to a healthier population and prevent premature deaths.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-2029241255e14875add2cd1f1d469b40", "input": "claim: The federal minimum wage should be increased.\n perspective: An higher minimum wage would lead to healthier people and less premature deaths.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ff87946c8ea94f98bef8200adcba9ef3", "input": "claim: The federal minimum wage should be increased.\n perspective: Increasing the minimum wage would increase the health of the population and prevent premature deaths.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e1d07833d89e44dbb9ad90bfe5936629", "input": "claim: The federal minimum wage should be increased.\n perspective: Raising the minimum wage would increase school attendance and decrease high school drop-out rates.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-3a40e6fecb7c4b26beb3c230b54136e3", "input": "claim: The federal minimum wage should be increased.\n perspective: Raising the minimum wage would lead to less truancy and also lower drop out rates.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f2e183400e66450c9dfe6ec6bc1c9135", "input": "claim: The federal minimum wage should be increased.\n perspective: A higher minimum wage would encourage people to attend school more and lead to lower drop out rates.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-5dae153415c94e26a1972ea1da5b8932", "input": "claim: The federal minimum wage should be increased.\n perspective: Increasing the minimum wage would reduce poverty.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-bfe8c7a853d24258bbb544cfa8656a59", "input": "claim: The federal minimum wage should be increased.\n perspective: An increase in minimum wage would result in a decrease of households living in poverty.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a9640a985b5f4fe098173bb9bdb97315", "input": "claim: The federal minimum wage should be increased.\n perspective: Poverty can be decreased by raising the minimum wage.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-22e284382c054c65ad4143139cb65e14", "input": "claim: The federal minimum wage should be increased.\n perspective: If the minimum wage is increase, more people living in poverty would have more opportunity to attend university or trade school, increasing their chance and their children's chances of getting out of poverty.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-b832c53664504cada8990d6d5a596a2b", "input": "claim: The federal minimum wage should be increased.\n perspective: Raising the minimum wage would decrease high school enrollment rates and increase drop-out rates.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-35ba5d46f89a4b7d98374872663249ad", "input": "claim: The federal minimum wage should be increased.\n perspective: Raising the minimum wage would price teens and other entry-level employees out of a job", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-5b7b3bf64d024f77b9f147b0b5512ee7", "input": "claim: The federal minimum wage should be increased.\n perspective: A higher wage would result in lower benefits", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-6320eb5249494e428132529a0dd9f525", "input": "claim: The federal minimum wage should be increased.\n perspective: Increasing the minimum wage would reduce income inequality.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-9777a785cb184065859cd1c21c0ee5f3", "input": "claim: The federal minimum wage should be increased.\n perspective: A minimum wage increase would help to reduce race and gender inequality.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d4a7e22603e347bba0c533af5c5b41e1", "input": "claim: The federal minimum wage should be increased.\n perspective: Raising the minimum wage would increase economic activity and spur job growth.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-72fd3821c2db4fec80f264ca938bb54f", "input": "claim: The federal minimum wage should be increased.\n perspective: Productivity and economic growth have increased at a faster rate than minimum wage.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ac610694bde94542936ca86e9e375889", "input": "claim: The federal minimum wage should be increased.\n perspective: Minimum wage has not kept pace with improvements in productivity or economic growth.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f7cda899ec9540e2854cfe6af24df0d5", "input": "claim: The federal minimum wage should be increased.\n perspective: The country is growing but minimum wage has not grown with it. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-9401924120c84ff48647c13e08404e06", "input": "claim: The federal minimum wage should be increased.\n perspective: Improvements in productivity and economic growth have outpaced increases in the minimum wage.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-9f6ad62be7244fc2a0447d18b37b5a68", "input": "claim: The federal minimum wage should be increased.\n perspective: Increasing the minimum wage would increase worker productivity and reduce employee turnover. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-1d7f117e3d29495fae95c90744a6416d", "input": "claim: The federal minimum wage should be increased.\n perspective: people won't quit jobs if they are paid enough", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-fb489f368ffb41fc9fb4a6736f1fd5da", "input": "claim: The federal minimum wage should be increased.\n perspective: employers would actually save money by not having to train new workers ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-29e645649cc64082b0b8e1398ab042ed", "input": "claim: The federal minimum wage should be increased.\n perspective: Economica activity and job growth would be positively impacted by an increase in minimum wage.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f58dce4afed1487f8d8a0f35bacd1685", "input": "claim: The federal minimum wage should be increased.\n perspective: Economic activity and job growth would result from raising the minimum wage.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-1b10448be1944be7a329ced99d87019e", "input": "claim: The federal minimum wage should be increased.\n perspective: If minimum wage is increase so would the economy. The more money consumers have, the more consumers buy, thus also increasing the economy. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-67bd6fbda5324a2689cd99e4f7392143", "input": "claim: The federal minimum wage should be increased.\n perspective: Raising the minimum wage would reduce crime.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e1d648a0dbac4970ab2042c40493b56c", "input": "claim: The federal minimum wage should be increased.\n perspective: Increasing the minimum wage would result in less crime.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-7679e601172e495dbfe348f70e895626", "input": "claim: The federal minimum wage should be increased.\n perspective: A higher minimum wage means less crime.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a1f5a7bfa7984778a5928ed1e85cf85c", "input": "claim: The federal minimum wage should be increased.\n perspective: Increasing the minimum wage would have a ripple effect, raising the incomes of people who make slightly above the minimum wage.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f86dd3e564a44d2bb93a2f1bb1448707", "input": "claim: The federal minimum wage should be increased.\n perspective: raising minimum wage raises everyone's pay", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-386e9b03b696453fad55e41f80838e65", "input": "claim: The federal minimum wage should be increased.\n perspective: A minimum wage increase would hurt businesses and force companies to close. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ca42c33eb75e4f00ac28ece9c8cc15d7", "input": "claim: The federal minimum wage should be increased.\n perspective: Businesses and companies won't be able to survive, if minimum wage is increased.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-d2179c52851a424189af5196c0aac54b", "input": "claim: The federal minimum wage should be increased.\n perspective: Increasing minimum wage will have negative effect on the businesses.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a139c2d3cef944b5b3045d56d77c349d", "input": "claim: The federal minimum wage should be increased.\n perspective: The current minimum wage is not high enough to allow people to afford housing.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f7725fbd8c69438aa7c5e15b4b04d9a8", "input": "claim: The federal minimum wage should be increased.\n perspective: The current minimum wage is not high enough to allow people to afford everyday essentials.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a14c2ddc473e455a8a925b29544f6cce", "input": "claim: The federal minimum wage should be increased.\n perspective: people cannot live off of their income", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-9ef1e65edf464c18ada8bf44a09aa3a0", "input": "claim: The federal minimum wage should be increased.\n perspective: People who work for minimum wage cannot afford the things of everyday life.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-0c1cb9b446124090a746216239a7f345", "input": "claim: The federal minimum wage should be increased.\n perspective: The currenit minimum wage is so low, you won't be able to afford everyday needs with it.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ba2352c737254601a449c67da03094ce", "input": "claim: The federal minimum wage should be increased.\n perspective: Increasing the minimum wage would force businesses to lay off employees and raise unemployment levels.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-86fe7ffc7675415c95ac92a3e66ddf3b", "input": "claim: The federal minimum wage should be increased.\n perspective: Raising minimum wage will increase the unemployment level.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-318d2e7ab92a42e3bf5af4cf0cfc1347", "input": "claim: The federal minimum wage should be increased.\n perspective: Businesses will be forced to lay of employees, if minimum wage is raised.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ecbf9c98292740218044581e448ea3fe", "input": "claim: The federal minimum wage should be increased.\n perspective: Raising the minimum wage would decrease employee benefits and increase tax payments.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-3c078d3f0d5d40d1b853565f4f8db847", "input": "claim: The federal minimum wage should be increased.\n perspective: When the minimum wage goes up, employers make up the costs by decreasing employee benefits and increasing general taxes. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-482a247f4f1f4cec926ab767c5cea2d7", "input": "claim: The federal minimum wage should be increased.\n perspective: Even if the minimum wage is increased, Americans will be hurt by a decrease in employee benefits and an increase in tax payments.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-77768b3af9a3428b8cde31c689c239d7", "input": "claim: The federal minimum wage should be increased.\n perspective: Raising the minimum wage would increase poverty.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-6176c3b2598e4ce7a73440d209d6880b", "input": "claim: The federal minimum wage should be increased.\n perspective: Raising minimum wage will increase the poverty rate.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-09a8fa07d5d14857b387b6155d04bfb8", "input": "claim: The federal minimum wage should be increased.\n perspective: If the minimum wage is increased, companies may use more robots and automated processes to replace service employees.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-37abae69c06a4288a69f4906efeb7f1f", "input": "claim: The federal minimum wage should be increased.\n perspective: Increasing the minimum wage will take away jobs from service employees.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-5f16452421124d1084589b2568fabd15", "input": "claim: The federal minimum wage should be increased.\n perspective: More companies will turn to automated robots if the minimum wage is increased.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-5361f60b42164970b0d171bbeeaad97f", "input": "claim: Prioritize eliminating the budget deficit over increasing domestic spending.\n perspective: Paying off national debt via austerity measures would free-up money used for interest payments", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-604e16da67984b96a0d89471906c1144", "input": "claim: Obesity is a disease.\n perspective: Obesity, like other diseases, impairs the normal functioning of the body.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-29e4ff3df150433585452105313792c0", "input": "claim: Obesity is a disease.\n perspective: The body cannot function properly when one is obese.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-88e9916a2e07400dbdf47b89f1f4444f", "input": "claim: Obesity is a disease.\n perspective: Obesity is a disease that results in suboptimal body functioning.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-deec95748abb49ebabd9bea973fa82b2", "input": "claim: Obesity is a disease.\n perspective: Obesity can shut normal body functions. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-5c3b9e38494548c6a92f031ff2468287", "input": "claim: Make sex education mandatory in schools.\n perspective: Sex education damages the education system", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-9d822cb319e64ec1b7f4ba76518e33f2", "input": "claim: Make sex education mandatory in schools.\n perspective: Even religious and conservative communities will benefit from mandatory sex education", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e25ec132b61a47c2893aa77b6de4dd40", "input": "claim: Make sex education mandatory in schools.\n perspective: Sexual development is a process of gradual discovery and cannot be effectively taught in a classroom", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-03f7b3bbf3a443e6a28fc69dd8190771", "input": "claim: Make sex education mandatory in schools.\n perspective: Parents cannot be guaranteed to provide a suitable amount of sex education", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-aaef97a6fd7a49eba2f59f0c86568dc1", "input": "claim: Make sex education mandatory in schools.\n perspective: Sex education provides “Immunization” against sexually transmitted diseases and prevents unwanted pregnancy ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-3d26fb48e6624563b113beeef3b065b5", "input": "claim: Make sex education mandatory in schools.\n perspective: Ignorance about sex is the primary cause of the spread of sexually transmitted diseases (STDs)", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-8b450a15f1434dd8b15a81ca8c434226", "input": "claim: Make sex education mandatory in schools.\n perspective: Sex education leads to experimentation and early intercourse, and indirectly encourages promiscuity", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-9f2fd16f20dd4415927ef859de4de218", "input": "claim: Make sex education mandatory in schools.\n perspective: Restricting information to children is inconsistent with the age of consent", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-41db057b60754e3c87881157f0faffbe", "input": "claim: Make sex education mandatory in schools.\n perspective: The information age makes attempting to hide information on sex impossible", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-01acd82afb16406893b73361517dde5e", "input": "claim: Make sex education mandatory in schools.\n perspective: Sex education for underage children undermines the law", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e1417687e651408c8289d4559dc52b1e", "input": "claim: Performing tests on animals must be banned.\n perspective: Some groups of people have less capacity for suffering than most animals", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-97266bddf58b4c37b939f79d858c9b07", "input": "claim: Performing tests on animals must be banned.\n perspective: Animal research is only used where other research methods are not suitable", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-206e4e05f9794661bc2fa616603294eb", "input": "claim: Performing tests on animals must be banned.\n perspective: Research on animals is a last recourse, but it is still necessary at times.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-5e328834e101460ab4aebb3f4867c4be", "input": "claim: Performing tests on animals must be banned.\n perspective: Would send a positive social message, increasing animal welfare rights more generally in society", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f9b2106f068446b88c77508645e01e08", "input": "claim: Performing tests on animals must be banned.\n perspective: Harming animals is a bad thing.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-8f59260316db42279671aa5b6e97b729", "input": "claim: Performing tests on animals must be banned.\n perspective: Animals shouldn't be put through harmful situations.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f3bd3c40da684c61a86f45e279213fba", "input": "claim: Performing tests on animals must be banned.\n perspective: Animals are severely harmed by research done on them.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-88adf8466ec644b6930270f5e3b45025", "input": "claim: Performing tests on animals must be banned.\n perspective: When research is done on animals, it causes them severe harm.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-249ca5214ae746cab3e46d1adc5f4a7d", "input": "claim: Performing tests on animals must be banned.\n perspective: Animals shouldn’t be harmed", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-248e3855e6e54eec8da1b2c6b2391d39", "input": "claim: Performing tests on animals must be banned.\n perspective: Animal research causes severe harm to the animals involved", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-dfc272ac49524d01800217f85c2cc897", "input": "claim: Performing tests on animals must be banned.\n perspective: Animal research necessitates significant harm to the animals involved", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-236980586c724b8cbd4ce5fc2f33fe8f", "input": "claim: Performing tests on animals must be banned.\n perspective: Animal testing significantly harms the animal used.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ee11aa8f79164119b2212d9fc34d583a", "input": "claim: Performing tests on animals must be banned.\n perspective: Animal research is necessary for the development of truly novel substances", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c639d90897c8420cbaa55124fc30960e", "input": "claim: Performing tests on animals must be banned.\n perspective: Innovation often requires the use of animal research.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-7fd28ba881924c96890b91606136b5ff", "input": "claim: Performing tests on animals must be banned.\n perspective: Science has been progressed through the use of animal research.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-28275f0c22b94683a7f4ea4c5e307d04", "input": "claim: Performing tests on animals must be banned.\n perspective: Animal research ensures greater safety for humans", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-967e5c6c77c84c379d45f159b1e8eacf", "input": "claim: Performing tests on animals must be banned.\n perspective: Animal testing has contributed to many life-saving cures and treatments.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4f420fc000b243f4857f9ad5cbad7ed0", "input": "claim: Performing tests on animals must be banned.\n perspective: Without animal research, we would have fewer products", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-1333097d7da34fb6874ea904d48c366b", "input": "claim: Performing tests on animals must be banned.\n perspective: Animal research has played a vital role in a great many of the major medical advances of the last century", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-5209e1f7b64a4729be32d0a0b6d7c4e1", "input": "claim: Performing tests on animals must be banned.\n perspective: There are no satisfactory alternatives to animal research", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-6d71b3c0846c4f5887a5bfa6a42c3893", "input": "claim: Performing tests on animals must be banned.\n perspective: Animal testing is cruel and inhumane.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-140a0262e18d4336912f733ce48f333a", "input": "claim: Performing tests on animals must be banned.\n perspective: Drugs that pass animal tests are not necessarily safe.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ce4b1096b1e647f2be4ea568e650f533", "input": "claim: Performing tests on animals must be banned.\n perspective: Animals themselves benefit from the results of animal testing.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-dbe5335fa9f64f8a8e31aec74039dc19", "input": "claim: Performing tests on animals must be banned.\n perspective: Most animals that are used in scientific testing have better lives. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-6b98d5eb15204bef974eb1a296dc86c1", "input": "claim: Performing tests on animals must be banned.\n perspective: Religious traditions allow for human dominion over animals.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-0f24e61bf44445c088e100f26ab261d1", "input": "claim: Performing tests on animals must be banned.\n perspective: Alternative testing methods now exist that can replace the need for animals. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d5a11c8fd2aa4636b673bcf2172a9a80", "input": "claim: Performing tests on animals must be banned.\n perspective: Number 2 is a lie, there ARE alternatives to animal testing! Other companies use them, and animal testing doesnt prove anything, because although close, they arent people.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-2491ec31c6354da5bcd00e6add22c254", "input": "claim: Performing tests on animals must be banned.\n perspective: Animal tests may mislead researchers into ignoring potential cures and treatments.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-6772caccbd6140ef8b77ba185e8976d9", "input": "claim: Performing tests on animals must be banned.\n perspective: Animal tests do not reliably predict results in human beings.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-50a6269b3ca94cbeb92e5204ab140f17", "input": "claim: Performing tests on animals must be banned.\n perspective: Animal experiments retard medical progress due to providing misleading results", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-480578928cff47b0b3761b09f22c0d81", "input": "claim: Performing tests on animals must be banned.\n perspective: animal experiments are not always accurate", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-28096fe17b0c491ba1e6a6709f873978", "input": "claim: Performing tests on animals must be banned.\n perspective: many companies get accurate results without testing on animals", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-2978fb921c9c466c9b34bb6a1a5b03de", "input": "claim: Performing tests on animals must be banned.\n perspective: Animal testing dosen't ensure good results", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e6d7a7b76dcc43ed823f1a48eaa92373", "input": "claim: Performing tests on animals must be banned.\n perspective: Animal tests are more expensive than alternative methods and are a waste of government research dollars.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-4d83c31c8ebe407faf8c9a6c240f7032", "input": "claim: Performing tests on animals must be banned.\n perspective: Animals can suffer like humans do, so it is speciesism to experiment on them while we refrain from experimenting on humans.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-75a31be6c634405c9a8e1bbdfa1a529c", "input": "claim: Performing tests on animals must be banned.\n perspective: Religious traditions tell us to be merciful to animals, so we should not cause them suffering by experimenting on them.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-adf289636a694f1ab29618d0b9abfb10", "input": "claim: Performing tests on animals must be banned.\n perspective: People can suffer, but most animals can suffer more. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-374288ca9aa24e26876b9ffa17d24f82", "input": "claim: Performing tests on animals must be banned.\n perspective: While both people and animals both suffer, most animals suffer more than people do.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-de9e78725994466da51e65a80f16de21", "input": "claim: Performing tests on animals must be banned.\n perspective: Most animals can suffer more than some people", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-7625114ead7e4318b6744964c10ccb7e", "input": "claim: Performing tests on animals must be banned.\n perspective: Animals often make better research subjects than human beings because of their shorter life cycles.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-1410c83ee5b94585ad54d6b05def1298", "input": "claim: Performing tests on animals must be banned.\n perspective: Animals are the only choice for testing. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-983a6605a388424385b9ef288f3d33fc", "input": "claim: Performing tests on animals must be banned.\n perspective: Animals are appropriate research subjects because they are similar to human beings in many ways. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a7da7b3af50a4e10a4733fd3797922ed", "input": "claim: Performing tests on animals must be banned.\n perspective: Animals don’t have human rights", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-d6461a5ea9594245b34bd19e1afe8067", "input": "claim: Performing tests on animals must be banned.\n perspective: Animals don't have rights.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-3fdf817106354f8ebf6686a86baf0192", "input": "claim: Performing tests on animals must be banned.\n perspective: Animals do not have rights, therefore it is acceptable to experiment on them.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-efaceb7aa4f145f0a510b28f5d9d70e1", "input": "claim: Performing tests on animals must be banned.\n perspective: Animals' rights are of less moral worth than human rights", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-fe159f33d63a434eb2c8871525e50831", "input": "claim: Performing tests on animals must be banned.\n perspective: Human's rights are a more important consideration than animal rights.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c07447d0fea4489c8392161b2b3f753d", "input": "claim: Performing tests on animals must be banned.\n perspective: When in conflict, the rights of humans must be preferred to the rights of animals.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-2c10a3585417495e836a2cf5f8e2fd34", "input": "claim: Performing tests on animals must be banned.\n perspective: Some cosmetics and health care products must be tested on animals to ensure their safety.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-63fb65ea2b3c4c5eab1744d96f910745", "input": "claim: Performing tests on animals must be banned.\n perspective: Medical breakthroughs involving animal research may still have been made without the use of animals.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-87a11b90a2a1492583eb096a87461162", "input": "claim: Performing tests on animals must be banned.\n perspective: Medical breakthroughs can be achieved without doing any scientific or commercial experiment on animals ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-981f993615694de6b11c15c9353424f4", "input": "claim: Performing tests on animals must be banned.\n perspective: 95% of animals used in experiments are not protected by the Animal Welfare Act.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-3442589b0df54e17899290e6cb9ca9d6", "input": "claim: Performing tests on animals must be banned.\n perspective: Animal researchers treat animals humanely, both for the animals' sake and to ensure reliable test results.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a5773536241b4b8b87b437943f523d00", "input": "claim: Performing tests on animals must be banned.\n perspective: Animals are treated well during animal testing. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-f33625853ebe45ccb5dbc3a56bec42f0", "input": "claim: Performing tests on animals must be banned.\n perspective: Research animals are well treated ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-95f299c3f65f43a1acbc144b310c1641", "input": "claim: Performing tests on animals must be banned.\n perspective: We need to be able to test drugs on animals. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-aee5257aa3114e7ea3acfbe7223e0690", "input": "claim: Performing tests on animals must be banned.\n perspective: We try to only use animal testing when it is needed. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-cd92ea3d1d4741ad85237d8f7dee6b41", "input": "claim: Performing tests on animals must be banned.\n perspective: Sometimes we have no other choices for Animal research, but then to do some animal testing. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-5e89a3dabe8143eb8f8c4961e9b4acb9", "input": "claim: Performing tests on animals must be banned.\n perspective: Animal research is only used when it’s needed", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-61a64bf35979436fa2e49e285c049e5a", "input": "claim: Aid Should Be Tied To Human Rights.\n perspective: Tying aid to human rights puts pressure on countries to act responsibly", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-51f0db30b249449eab8a3cac327dde92", "input": "claim: Aid Should Be Tied To Human Rights.\n perspective: Government and citizens are often not the same entity.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-873b0f8c7a0a431cae3d642fc3d823f1", "input": "claim: Same sex relationships should have the same legal status as heterosexual relationships under EU law.\n perspective: Homosexuals would Change the Institution of Marriage for the Better", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d84e8597a62f4d3fa95bc8aed5e34344", "input": "claim: Same sex relationships should have the same legal status as heterosexual relationships under EU law.\n perspective: Gay marriage would improve all marriages.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-73a07eb1a43e456fa878d52f05635592", "input": "claim: Same sex relationships should have the same legal status as heterosexual relationships under EU law.\n perspective: EU Should Push Forward Equality for All of its Citizens Regardless of Sexuality", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f21e8f2d70554be5a78ab6178b564746", "input": "claim: Same sex relationships should have the same legal status as heterosexual relationships under EU law.\n perspective: The EU should press for full equality regardless of sexuality.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a3c79e0403074cfab3394dd31f0fcfea", "input": "claim: Same sex relationships should have the same legal status as heterosexual relationships under EU law.\n perspective: The EU should remove obstacles to equality in sexual preference.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-4c9675e234164e8d9e475124b0159c8e", "input": "claim: Same sex relationships should have the same legal status as heterosexual relationships under EU law.\n perspective: Two people who want to get married should be able to, no matter their sexuality. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-50bb5ccc77414e079d8b1f16bc88452d", "input": "claim: Same sex relationships should have the same legal status as heterosexual relationships under EU law.\n perspective: Homosexuals should have the same rights as straight people.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-0f03db0f768d47c28d6308a251a1c90b", "input": "claim: Same sex relationships should have the same legal status as heterosexual relationships under EU law.\n perspective: Heterosexuals shouldn't enjoy greater rights than homosexuals.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-fc791e1e99b14ecdb71923c432a520c5", "input": "claim: Same sex relationships should have the same legal status as heterosexual relationships under EU law.\n perspective: Same sex couple should have the same rights as heterosexual couples", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f758338d034d4c3f8b7d59b946e81f4f", "input": "claim: Same sex relationships should have the same legal status as heterosexual relationships under EU law.\n perspective: Marriage is an internationally recognized human right for all people. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ae283250c08645e2a175279643ac6f90", "input": "claim: Same sex relationships should have the same legal status as heterosexual relationships under EU law.\n perspective: Gay people should have the same human rights as Heterosexuals", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-9116e3031ee84746ac31f22f9a055989", "input": "claim: Same sex relationships should have the same legal status as heterosexual relationships under EU law.\n perspective: Who says who can marry and who can't", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e08b2d05a07344ce95c3efd2a710e71a", "input": "claim: Same sex relationships should have the same legal status as heterosexual relationships under EU law.\n perspective: All people have the right to marry.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-39a91e4681554f3b8c954c51b2a7d21c", "input": "claim: Same sex relationships should have the same legal status as heterosexual relationships under EU law.\n perspective: Nature Suggests That Same Sex Marriage is Illogical", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-da217d78db75491bb714ea6ab033c24c", "input": "claim: Same sex relationships should have the same legal status as heterosexual relationships under EU law.\n perspective: From a logical standpoint same sex marriage is illogical.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c35fe8dbb5994670b2226ba82a082bc6", "input": "claim: Same sex relationships should have the same legal status as heterosexual relationships under EU law.\n perspective: Marriage is for procreation and should not be extended to same-sex couples because they cannot produce children together. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4be21800240d4845ba740476bbb883c3", "input": "claim: Same sex relationships should have the same legal status as heterosexual relationships under EU law.\n perspective: Legalizing gay marriage often leads to an end to domestic partnership benefits for gay and straight couples, which disadvantages couples who choose not to get married. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-82829af82d60458dbcc55bff78688bd9", "input": "claim: Same sex relationships should have the same legal status as heterosexual relationships under EU law.\n perspective: If gay couples don't get married it means they lose benefits through the legalization of gay marriage.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-9f8c097373a4400fa09bbbc974542c4a", "input": "claim: Same sex relationships should have the same legal status as heterosexual relationships under EU law.\n perspective: Allowing gay couples to wed could further weaken the institution of marriage. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-f7fba8849c504a59adffee60f57c15dc", "input": "claim: Same sex relationships should have the same legal status as heterosexual relationships under EU law.\n perspective: The institution of marriage has been weakened in recent years and allowing gay marriage will only further damage an already crumbling institution.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-3f96e563cc624a9daf7882e47537e824", "input": "claim: Same sex relationships should have the same legal status as heterosexual relationships under EU law.\n perspective: Gay marriage will not be a positive boost to the institution of marriage.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ac10b88a1fd54f93a9591d89af5eadc1", "input": "claim: Same sex relationships should have the same legal status as heterosexual relationships under EU law.\n perspective: Same-sex marriage is a civil right. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c0edabd5a55a49689fa4bacc1ddc5ce9", "input": "claim: Same sex relationships should have the same legal status as heterosexual relationships under EU law.\n perspective: Our constitution is based on the idea that all people are equal and thus getting married is a civil right. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a590d8888dbd41e9ba43849c4c5c6edf", "input": "claim: Same sex relationships should have the same legal status as heterosexual relationships under EU law.\n perspective: People have fought for civil rights and same sex marriage is a civil right. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e9e7bd7907e7462684392f3aa46e008c", "input": "claim: Same sex relationships should have the same legal status as heterosexual relationships under EU law.\n perspective: State registrars conducting marriage ceremonies could not discriminate between homosexual and heterosexual couples", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e78f38bf883d42c79f8f56c3ac932d29", "input": "claim: Same sex relationships should have the same legal status as heterosexual relationships under EU law.\n perspective: Denying some people the option to marry is discriminatory and creates a second class of citizens. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-eaf082c8be8f4d328f35a8295bc8c143", "input": "claim: Same sex relationships should have the same legal status as heterosexual relationships under EU law.\n perspective: It is discriminatory to refuse gay couples the right to marry", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-703f50183c834fd2b8bb713a5ad3c569", "input": "claim: Same sex relationships should have the same legal status as heterosexual relationships under EU law.\n perspective: gay should not be refused to marry", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-408d337e89f7458e8bf77a7078879ed8", "input": "claim: Same sex relationships should have the same legal status as heterosexual relationships under EU law.\n perspective: Marriage is an outmoded, oppressive institution that should be weakened, not expanded. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-930d924630b44caf93ab401a65b22335", "input": "claim: Same sex relationships should have the same legal status as heterosexual relationships under EU law.\n perspective: Marriage is not something we should encourage or support.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4019e61990554090ab4d245559381056", "input": "claim: Same sex relationships should have the same legal status as heterosexual relationships under EU law.\n perspective: Legalizing gay marriage could lead down a \"slippery slope,\" giving people in polygamous, incestuous, bestial, and other nontraditional relationships the right to marry. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-eebf4053a2634e3ebec078129b2ac34b", "input": "claim: Same sex relationships should have the same legal status as heterosexual relationships under EU law.\n perspective: There are many types of marriage which are innaporpoate and dangerous which may be allowed if gay marriage is legalized. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c6f89b1e704e412aaeb3179dcb2b6494", "input": "claim: Same sex relationships should have the same legal status as heterosexual relationships under EU law.\n perspective: Legalizing gay marriage advances the \"homosexual agenda\" and unfairly paints opponents as bigots. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ff82fad03823411baea7ebf5983163b6", "input": "claim: Same sex relationships should have the same legal status as heterosexual relationships under EU law.\n perspective: Those against gay marriage are called names if gay marriage is legalized.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b0165633504a4e54b42e3e479a9b5b50", "input": "claim: Same sex relationships should have the same legal status as heterosexual relationships under EU law.\n perspective: Legalizing marriage by gays leads to the oppression of those who are against the practice.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-7edc797cc81b4ef28cffe2b73fa7e1b4", "input": "claim: Same sex relationships should have the same legal status as heterosexual relationships under EU law.\n perspective: The concept of \"traditional marriage\" has changed over time, and the definition of marriage as always being between one man and one woman is historically inaccurate. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-b557eac283d348299ae17640696c80e0", "input": "claim: Same sex relationships should have the same legal status as heterosexual relationships under EU law.\n perspective: The idea of a \"traditional marriage\" is a modern convention and has not remained static over the centuries. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-71a6936781de464b83d5b67a7efdb5f3", "input": "claim: Same sex relationships should have the same legal status as heterosexual relationships under EU law.\n perspective: There is no historical basis for believing so called \"traditional marriages\" have been changeless over the centuries. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-94cd2a6ea7fd4486870c55227acbcc28", "input": "claim: Same sex relationships should have the same legal status as heterosexual relationships under EU law.\n perspective: Many religious leaders and churches support gay marriage and say it is consistent with scripture. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-84af71563c4649c9b793aeadf28d5211", "input": "claim: Same sex relationships should have the same legal status as heterosexual relationships under EU law.\n perspective: There is much debate about gay marriage but many religious leaders are in support of it regardless. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-446c3cdf909f445481f009af1ca4d565", "input": "claim: Same sex relationships should have the same legal status as heterosexual relationships under EU law.\n perspective: Even though a vocal group of religious people disagrees with gay marriage, there is a growing number of religious leaders who support it and can back up their opinions with scripture. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-1ecdaf9deda54541a43fa96cc54b21e2", "input": "claim: Same sex relationships should have the same legal status as heterosexual relationships under EU law.\n perspective: Legal marriage is a secular institution that should not be limited by religious objections to same-sex marriage. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e1c7f8cfaa584edcbd8c1d7344e47d48", "input": "claim: Same sex relationships should have the same legal status as heterosexual relationships under EU law.\n perspective: Religion does not have power over marriage and it should not be limited to heterosexual marriage based on that religion. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e4ac9af6201342049a1bfaa32764132b", "input": "claim: Same sex relationships should have the same legal status as heterosexual relationships under EU law.\n perspective: As a secular institution, marriage can not be limited to heterosexuals only based on religious ideals. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d407d5cefcdc45219b77e1a6f96c72f7", "input": "claim: Same sex relationships should have the same legal status as heterosexual relationships under EU law.\n perspective: Marriage provides both physical and psychological health benefits, and banning gay marriage increases rates of psychological disorders. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-9be783cf525b476aa7e23d67a2b751d3", "input": "claim: Same sex relationships should have the same legal status as heterosexual relationships under EU law.\n perspective: If gay marriage is banned, there is likely to be increased rates of psychological disorders. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-1aa439fbc5564d33a48bf9b8d8017cf4", "input": "claim: Same sex relationships should have the same legal status as heterosexual relationships under EU law.\n perspective: We can reduce the prevalence of psychological disorders in the gay community by allowing gay marriage. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-0922394c7c104cdd87489e5c165ef31a", "input": "claim: Same sex relationships should have the same legal status as heterosexual relationships under EU law.\n perspective: Matrimony is a bond between man and woman only.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-abb0783056f84f2ba98a6b5304326145", "input": "claim: Same sex relationships should have the same legal status as heterosexual relationships under EU law.\n perspective: Prominent religious bodies believe that non-heterosexuals seeking to be wed devalue the crucible of the marriage relationship.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-57fa1c14900f4d9aa7fda3ba99e71fc3", "input": "claim: Same sex relationships should have the same legal status as heterosexual relationships under EU law.\n perspective: The institution of marriage has traditionally been defined as being between a man and a woman. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-f429f1c1a89343299decfedecc39f64f", "input": "claim: Same sex relationships should have the same legal status as heterosexual relationships under EU law.\n perspective: Religion does not embraces marriage bonds between same-sex couples.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-84f8b883f4554118b9669086f0000a84", "input": "claim: Same sex relationships should have the same legal status as heterosexual relationships under EU law.\n perspective: God condemns gay marriage in the Bible and it is not supported by a lot of churches. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-8d9c7bbe1e924af4aa36f8e26ed7e4b8", "input": "claim: Same sex relationships should have the same legal status as heterosexual relationships under EU law.\n perspective: Marriage should be between a man and a woman", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-8c993aa4aa8b420db273aedba3439c1a", "input": "claim: Same sex relationships should have the same legal status as heterosexual relationships under EU law.\n perspective: Marriage is a religious institution, and the major world religions frown upon homosexuality", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-99c3842b364146f48667028ce36b31b1", "input": "claim: Same sex relationships should have the same legal status as heterosexual relationships under EU law.\n perspective: It Would Cause controversy in religious countries such as Ireland and Italy", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a82f04a40acf45be820b9619fca48ba8", "input": "claim: Same sex relationships should have the same legal status as heterosexual relationships under EU law.\n perspective: The institution of marriage cannot be harmed by giving more people the freedom to marry and it may become the case that heterosexual marriage is less stable than same-sex marriage. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-fe696f6a05924b0d9cb6b6d1361bcb99", "input": "claim: Same sex relationships should have the same legal status as heterosexual relationships under EU law.\n perspective: Same-sex marriage may have a lower divorce rate than heterosexual marriage proving once and for all that gay marriage is good for the institution of marriage. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-f8447101d3394fa8898cf5ad6888d74c", "input": "claim: Same sex relationships should have the same legal status as heterosexual relationships under EU law.\n perspective: Same-sex couples should have access to the same benefits enjoyed by heterosexual married couples. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-0a2ae2c9d2e34fff9dad5c732a2733ce", "input": "claim: Same sex relationships should have the same legal status as heterosexual relationships under EU law.\n perspective: Same-Sex marriages should have the same legal protections as regular marriages.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-175ca07b9a2a4d26b292cd11f1aa6412", "input": "claim: Same sex relationships should have the same legal status as heterosexual relationships under EU law.\n perspective: gays should be able to use thier rights", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-0dc738b9a81e45f7a68d750841f7e362", "input": "claim: Same sex relationships should have the same legal status as heterosexual relationships under EU law.\n perspective: Gay couples should be able to take advantage of the fiscal and legal benefits of marriage", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a3af15e4f4bd471785d2502f83d9d23b", "input": "claim: Same sex relationships should have the same legal status as heterosexual relationships under EU law.\n perspective: Gay marriages can bring financial gain to federal, state, and local governments and can help boost the economy. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-2fc5927234fb450489da17ae0b81ffef", "input": "claim: Same sex relationships should have the same legal status as heterosexual relationships under EU law.\n perspective: The economy of states can be boosted by allowing same-sex marriages. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-c734c475c95f480e8361b03b1bd77168", "input": "claim: Same sex relationships should have the same legal status as heterosexual relationships under EU law.\n perspective: Gay marriage is good for society", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-477b32d7ab9d42a29a570acfcf3c60cd", "input": "claim: Same sex relationships should have the same legal status as heterosexual relationships under EU law.\n perspective: Marriage is about more than procreation, therefore gay couples should not be denied the right to marry due to their biology.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e72235aaec4c481ea2b245dee81a9311", "input": "claim: Same sex relationships should have the same legal status as heterosexual relationships under EU law.\n perspective: gay people should be able to marry", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-eada34f998be43108ac8ad1145721cca", "input": "claim: Same sex relationships should have the same legal status as heterosexual relationships under EU law.\n perspective: no matter what sexuality all should be able to marry", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-0bcfe02331d84cb1a834b21a7aafacce", "input": "claim: Keep the Sabbath as a Day of Rest.\n perspective: People should be allowed to take their leisure at their own convenience and not on the basis of religious decree ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-99e4d9ba93fb4ba2a47824c9d17fbd8d", "input": "claim: Keep the Sabbath as a Day of Rest.\n perspective: Recreation should be when people want, not when told to by religion", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-f2d956386f6948a681c1057fa4bbdbe2", "input": "claim: Keep the Sabbath as a Day of Rest.\n perspective: Religious decrees infringe on people's freedom of choice", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-7f78b687fdb94e2f960fa6cc48c43ed2", "input": "claim: Keep the Sabbath as a Day of Rest.\n perspective: A shared day when there is no commercial activity encourages family life and recreation ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-96f906c161194e33895fd98d331fb7d8", "input": "claim: Keep the Sabbath as a Day of Rest.\n perspective: Family life will be strengthened during a shared day of Sabbath", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e8f62c7d79694fe9b701c8a681efc934", "input": "claim: Keep the Sabbath as a Day of Rest.\n perspective: Sabbath day puts the emphasis on family and away from commercial activity", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-51139146b0c3463bba19034d6cf2063f", "input": "claim: Civil society should be granted a wider participation in Africa’s political life.\n perspective: Civil society is good for economic development ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-b8d6de25d75b42c0b0d7ff99bd31cde8", "input": "claim: Civil society should be granted a wider participation in Africa’s political life.\n perspective: economic developement can be benefited by civil society", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-edb228512b8a463f8c4bc9992076d18f", "input": "claim: Civil society should be granted a wider participation in Africa’s political life.\n perspective: Western European experiences do not demonstrate that civil society’s involvement in politics would be positive in the African context", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-0e73bee2a1b54312b97b3e32f631b296", "input": "claim: Civil society should be granted a wider participation in Africa’s political life.\n perspective: There is no proof that western European involvement in politics would be beneficial to Africa.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4508fe3415ab47ec92e68014d80bf9a7", "input": "claim: Civil society should be granted a wider participation in Africa’s political life.\n perspective: History has shown that western European involvement would not be beneficial to Africa.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-33ea3027496b4a80bf1c88e689358663", "input": "claim: Sikh school pupils should be allowed to carry ceremonial daggers.\n perspective: Fuelling an atmosphere of religious and cultural tension in Britain.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-886028c201fb4150bce1a0b230bc40a7", "input": "claim: Sikh school pupils should be allowed to carry ceremonial daggers.\n perspective: Respecting the 'rituals' of the school.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-7b54d8fb04624675bd120784070eb0f6", "input": "claim: Sikh school pupils should be allowed to carry ceremonial daggers.\n perspective: fuels discontent between religions ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-8eff292f17fe47c08b21297517f62a55", "input": "claim: Sikh school pupils should be allowed to carry ceremonial daggers.\n perspective: Daggers can be used as weapons. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-eed199c23d144f44abd393e8f5668d53", "input": "claim: Sikh school pupils should be allowed to carry ceremonial daggers.\n perspective: Potentially, daggers carried by Sikh school pupils can be used to harm others. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-765f529a77194ebcacf99fbda312f68d", "input": "claim: Sikh school pupils should be allowed to carry ceremonial daggers.\n perspective: Religious symbols harm no one", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-bc8a93da8c0f4166bbb89b390e43d931", "input": "claim: Sikh school pupils should be allowed to carry ceremonial daggers.\n perspective: symbols for religious benefit bothers no one", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-661c9883265746eb96033ed54b7e8427", "input": "claim: Sikh school pupils should be allowed to carry ceremonial daggers.\n perspective: religious expression should be freely decided", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-66b32b335f8e4075b789f8c56fdae9d8", "input": "claim: Sikh school pupils should be allowed to carry ceremonial daggers.\n perspective: It is a fundamental part of OUR Human Rights", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e135e2ff9a6c41328ce9eb71b913601b", "input": "claim: Sikh school pupils should be allowed to carry ceremonial daggers.\n perspective: It is a fundamental right to practice the religion you wish.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-803045e784ff427ebadb36f79f3fc95b", "input": "claim: Sikh school pupils should be allowed to carry ceremonial daggers.\n perspective: Practicing your religion is a right, not a priveledge. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-55dbdbaa6f3b4439bc8af74ef7a65e81", "input": "claim: Sikh school pupils should be allowed to carry ceremonial daggers.\n perspective: Human rights demand that we are free to express our religion.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-d1ac705b4a4448e8bd896cb9df928987", "input": "claim: Sikh school pupils should be allowed to carry ceremonial daggers.\n perspective: Religious expression needs to be guaranteed for all of us as part of our most fundamental rights!", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-40b63146bb9d43d3a45fa03d1490d5c6", "input": "claim: Israel's 2008-2009 military operations against Gaza were justified.\n perspective: Israel's military operations were disproportionate and harmed too many civilians: ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-cca1864e317c483e8b64b30a26bcf421", "input": "claim: Israel's 2008-2009 military operations against Gaza were justified.\n perspective: A lot of civilians are harmed during the military operations.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-bfa062d2b5d942b7818744256b479fe9", "input": "claim: Israel's 2008-2009 military operations against Gaza were justified.\n perspective: Civilians are hurt during the Israeli military operations. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-8a4684524a2447d89247e2973e992eed", "input": "claim: Israel's 2008-2009 military operations against Gaza were justified.\n perspective: The military operations were legitimate as Israeli self-defense: ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-cc9c579b26c94956a289702ebc84f266", "input": "claim: Israel's 2008-2009 military operations against Gaza were justified.\n perspective: Israel was just self-defending.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ac61cc0f9c114d308374d70a1ee5c70c", "input": "claim: Israel's 2008-2009 military operations against Gaza were justified.\n perspective: The operations are self-defenses, and thus can be justified. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-1414ee47cbb745deb77acb87d1d860d2", "input": "claim: Israel's 2008-2009 military operations against Gaza were justified.\n perspective: The military operations were necessary for long term peace: ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-57878e054942469aa9cc6534b4d9d2dc", "input": "claim: Israel's 2008-2009 military operations against Gaza were justified.\n perspective: Future-wise speaking, the military operations are promoting peace. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-eb8c756284ac42058edc6530d83714ca", "input": "claim: Israel's 2008-2009 military operations against Gaza were justified.\n perspective: The military operations ensures peace in the region in future. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-db233d3407c84fdf91b3b2ed1e5c2d25", "input": "claim: Israel's 2008-2009 military operations against Gaza were justified.\n perspective: Israel's military operations harmed the chances of peace in the long term: ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-17f2d897cd264a5caa409beaec3f615f", "input": "claim: Israel's 2008-2009 military operations against Gaza were justified.\n perspective: Israeli military operations breaks the peace in the region. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c83797e67cab465a843c2a0f3279ce88", "input": "claim: Israel's 2008-2009 military operations against Gaza were justified.\n perspective: The operations eliminate the hope for peace in the future.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-03bad887c98640c49d7c355441dab124", "input": "claim: Israel's 2008-2009 military operations against Gaza were justified.\n perspective: The military operations were proportionate to the threat: ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-72c7240fd3a4491490329a64a23a509c", "input": "claim: Israel's 2008-2009 military operations against Gaza were justified.\n perspective: The operations are just reacting to the tremendous amount of threats. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-eb8c54c5a8fe48e3906bc5eee6e2743e", "input": "claim: Send Yanukovych to The Hague.\n perspective: Yanukovych committed crimes against humanity", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-03f9226a00c445f39e3e865d7f8c862d", "input": "claim: Send Yanukovych to The Hague.\n perspective: Immoral crimes were committed by Yanukovych. ", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-ea5ce0eb793142b7bc25e613b3abc65d", "input": "claim: Send Yanukovych to The Hague.\n perspective: Yanukovych needs to go on trial for crimes against humanity.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-7272cd53cfb0499c8130b6e77153360d", "input": "claim: Send Yanukovych to The Hague.\n perspective: Yanukovych crimes are against humanity.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-706801b5c1764e6195c64f70a0d88981", "input": "claim: Send Yanukovych to The Hague.\n perspective: Would prevent division", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-44b3bba2be374ebba109f5a0dd99295b", "input": "claim: Send Yanukovych to The Hague.\n perspective: Does Yanukovych really qualify for the ICC?", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-57840e71435c4269a63fff785d2a19e4", "input": "claim: Send Yanukovych to The Hague.\n perspective: Do you think Yanukovych qualifies for the ICC?", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-d2b78118a36f48f9a4c23816915f971a", "input": "claim: Send Yanukovych to The Hague.\n perspective: Should Yanukovych be tried at the ICC?", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-7528013ab00849cca0ad3cae0dc7be9a", "input": "claim: Send Yanukovych to The Hague.\n perspective: Could not be tried for all his crimes", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-45a68ecab0714fe491c5325ac1d17900", "input": "claim: Send Yanukovych to The Hague.\n perspective: Should be tried at home", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ffaf76f141044dccad4f4a61358cba17", "input": "claim: Send Yanukovych to The Hague.\n perspective: Yanukovych should be tried at home.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-9e843c2768494da8984adb2d97c165b6", "input": "claim: Send Yanukovych to The Hague.\n perspective: Home is where Yanukovych should be tried.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e7966ddcb2cb4e729921d6a9255e9d9d", "input": "claim: Cultural property residing in museums must be returned to its place of origin.\n perspective: The historical significance of artefacts extends beyond their culture of origin", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-aa6225d3fa3743938fdb58e719a6e367", "input": "claim: Cultural property residing in museums must be returned to its place of origin.\n perspective: Scholars will have better access to artefacts, and more opportunities for study and collaboration, if they are stored in the west", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e7f96aa015594b2abbb3ebba873c9cd8", "input": "claim: Cultural property residing in museums must be returned to its place of origin.\n perspective: Artifacts should be kept where they are safest so that everyone has access to them. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-aee1ed332b1048a18ae57506bed6e097", "input": "claim: Cultural property residing in museums must be returned to its place of origin.\n perspective: Many countries do not have the means to protect precious artifacts so they should remain in the West where they are safe. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-efd449b2a26d4a3aa822629945b55905", "input": "claim: Cultural property residing in museums must be returned to its place of origin.\n perspective: Artefacts should be made accessible to the largest possible number of visitors", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4c84a87792164763be74aa4a07884f0c", "input": "claim: Cultural property residing in museums must be returned to its place of origin.\n perspective: In many cases, returning an artefact may prove to be unreasonably expensive", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-745dd61448c34ddd9a7b32a9ed8f0e0a", "input": "claim: Cultural property residing in museums must be returned to its place of origin.\n perspective: The West should not have to spend enormous sums of money to return artifacts to their original locations.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-2e7ff76bc8cd4adaaea9848e021d6e9c", "input": "claim: Cultural property residing in museums must be returned to its place of origin.\n perspective: Artefacts are enriched by being viewed in their place of origin", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-1b98957f66ba4028a8c1ee9564e76a9f", "input": "claim: Cultural property residing in museums must be returned to its place of origin.\n perspective: Artifacts are best viewed where they came from.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-cb0cdf1a4db54a2b96424ea73c18933b", "input": "claim: Cultural property residing in museums must be returned to its place of origin.\n perspective: Viewing an artifact in its native area is beneficial to its perception.", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-fb8f2247bd3345fe9892dc577dffb522", "input": "claim: Cultural property residing in museums must be returned to its place of origin.\n perspective: Having artefacts in different locations encourages us to think of our common origins", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4190e87bc06b4bc087e20626da465998", "input": "claim: Cultural property residing in museums must be returned to its place of origin.\n perspective: Artefacts should be repatriated....including the people which were stolen and scattered world wide!", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-e0945cdbf3a54603b95627af498f8599", "input": "claim: Cultural property residing in museums must be returned to its place of origin.\n perspective: These artefacts should bring revenue to the counties of origin", "output": [ "support" ] }, { "id": "task738-a90a85e98ae24663bf8460ed18f8a2d1", "input": "claim: Hosting the Olympic Games is beneficial.\n perspective: The Olympics displace and burden residents of the host country and city. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-19a8437972ad4747ae890ce52eb7b873", "input": "claim: Hosting the Olympic Games is beneficial.\n perspective: The Olympics place a strain on the residents of the host city and country.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-6417f72372b74c199a410150c8c90e71", "input": "claim: Hosting the Olympic Games is beneficial.\n perspective: Hosting the Olympics can be more trouble than it's worth for those who live there.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-35313b148bd14600be8a9e7ea4026167", "input": "claim: Hosting the Olympic Games is beneficial.\n perspective: It sanctions and encourages 'Islamophobic' panics and promotes the excessive 'securitisation' of the globe", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-0294ce76aaf4408fb8e5c214e791fe39", "input": "claim: Hosting the Olympic Games is beneficial.\n perspective: This would result in Islamophobic panics and knee jerk reactions across the world.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-2c0cb73295034488a32c2930faa977fe", "input": "claim: Hosting the Olympic Games is beneficial.\n perspective: Islamophobic panic and excessive security would be sanctioned by this action.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-9a13f854ff984b0486ddc949cbef3349", "input": "claim: Stop sending development aid to India.\n perspective: Development aid still makes a difference", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ad1c882c85c1417f86044a05a51bdea4", "input": "claim: Stop sending development aid to India.\n perspective: A difference is made with development aid.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-233cf0ea86ec44c88159240c845de95e", "input": "claim: Quebec should secede from Canada.\n perspective: This is not the will of the people of Quebec. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-119667a1c6c24eeba10602dfd23ac3da", "input": "claim: The United States was correct in going to war against North Korea in support of their territory of South Korea.\n perspective: To invade could trigger an Arms Race: the very thing everyone wants to avoid!", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-5afacc952dae459a844b30197c7dd340", "input": "claim: The United States was correct in going to war against North Korea in support of their territory of South Korea.\n perspective: Everyone wants to avoid an Arms Race, and an invasion could trigger just that outcome. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-397f7040f3b046e49647bf7749e58eda", "input": "claim: The United States was correct in going to war against North Korea in support of their territory of South Korea.\n perspective: An Arms race is the one outcome everyone wants to avoid, and an invasion could lead to that. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-8323dbcdbea34705822b80f4c3f432fc", "input": "claim: It should be allowed to have military recruitment in schools.\n perspective: Military recruitment in schools is less education than propaganda", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b5878d656c1e4148a6686d8bc7691b49", "input": "claim: It should be allowed to have military recruitment in schools.\n perspective: Military recruitment in schools is more propaganda than education. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-54fdb6e2bbcb42ae8a2b0f773954f5bb", "input": "claim: It should be allowed to have military recruitment in schools.\n perspective: Military recruitment in schools provides more propaganda than it does education.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e1f7f4550d6e46f48246fb5a29f78b64", "input": "claim: It should be allowed to have military recruitment in schools.\n perspective: Military recruiters downplay the risks of a military career, tempting schoolchildren into a career they would not have chosen with honest information.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-0abae500618242ffbf55a881b9372139", "input": "claim: It should be allowed to have military recruitment in schools.\n perspective: Military recruiters decieve children about the risks of a military career, tempting them into a career they would not choose with honest information.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a9614a1ccc784f2d8cc4dbb61ceb9823", "input": "claim: It should be allowed to have military recruitment in schools.\n perspective: Since schoolchildren would not chose a military career with honest information, military recruiters downplay the risks of a military career to tempt them.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-721eddbd46174c63a69fa91489cb0c9d", "input": "claim: It should be allowed to have military recruitment in schools.\n perspective: School children are too young to target for military service", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-0db9816b85dd4881b5fa5dbdc80596be", "input": "claim: It should be allowed to have military recruitment in schools.\n perspective: School children are too young to be targeted for military service.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-0dbf78a22cac47318841c93ef3a143d9", "input": "claim: It should be allowed to have military recruitment in schools.\n perspective: The military should not target children for service as they are too young.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-cd842fc920e646e5b0e090c37c49aac7", "input": "claim: Corporations are a threat to Democracy and society.\n perspective: Corporations support our living standards and ensure democracy and human rights are STRONGER, not WEAKER!", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-088717bb59ba47acb16419c3878d3843", "input": "claim: Corporations are a threat to Democracy and society.\n perspective: Corporations give citizens a better way of life.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-feadff308db14dc9bf452bc280771662", "input": "claim: Corporations are a threat to Democracy and society.\n perspective: Corporations makes the country stronger by providing a better way of life.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b879f47a893e4b01b296d9dd9f678fe8", "input": "claim: Smokers should be denied access to state healthcare.\n perspective: Denying access to healthcare for smokers will hurt the economy", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-45631f020d594089b59aa78dbad0c1e1", "input": "claim: Smokers should be denied access to state healthcare.\n perspective: Denying access to healthcare for smokers will lead to thousands of people being turned away and potentially dying from preventable illnesses", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4f95c1252a394534a9482079206a2180", "input": "claim: Smokers should be denied access to state healthcare.\n perspective: Denying healthcare to smokers is a restriction on people's liberties", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-34a745bc597141ee89b015676b529c23", "input": "claim: Smokers should be denied access to state healthcare.\n perspective: Denying healthcare to smokers alone is victimization", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-fad1fa1c6a3e460f89cbfe56fc4abd77", "input": "claim: Smokers should be denied access to state healthcare.\n perspective: Denying healthcare to smokers is impractical", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-377c79fc5cca420983847e35aac08de6", "input": "claim: You should join Facebook.\n perspective: Facebook has some dangerous consequences", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c45da88e44db406eb291499e0eed244f", "input": "claim: You should join Facebook.\n perspective: The internet can be a dangerous place and Facebook is no different.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-31c4222922a94582954e73c594fca55e", "input": "claim: You should join Facebook.\n perspective: We must always be careful what we post on Facebook or there could be negative consequences.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ee94c959f4f54d529925cab868990d2f", "input": "claim: You should join Facebook.\n perspective: Facebook has a negative impact on learning", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-7691d0e51e7344288dfdba50d7ff435e", "input": "claim: You should join Facebook.\n perspective: People would learn more without a connection to Facebook.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-7de197201b654c69b32176d1c6d5db7a", "input": "claim: You should join Facebook.\n perspective: Facebook hurts people's ability to learn and retain new information.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-efd28c7e2a624924a0e8b98c7645e296", "input": "claim: Deregulation and tax cuts should be embraced to lead the world out of economic crisis.\n perspective: Deregulation Fuels Corporations to Behave Unethically, Devastating Human Rights and the Environment", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-be496563465a491e8debedfa114bdbcd", "input": "claim: Deregulation and tax cuts should be embraced to lead the world out of economic crisis.\n perspective: Corporations have only one goal, profit, human rights and environmental concerns be damned.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-02b22a84b9c24ed29434a339ee5eb9a9", "input": "claim: Deregulation and tax cuts should be embraced to lead the world out of economic crisis.\n perspective: Tax Cuts Harm Social Programs for Citizens", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-0a26ec108ff4486b97a1660f5e7cbff4", "input": "claim: Deregulation and tax cuts should be embraced to lead the world out of economic crisis.\n perspective: Regulation is Necessary for the Stabilization of Markets and Employment", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-be016f4a59a74d6d96ec04806217796b", "input": "claim: Parents should be allowed to genetically screen foetuses for heritable diseases.\n perspective: Genetic screening may lead the marginalisation of those living with genetic disorders", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-39651f0efc8a4337b1dace5b5764ac25", "input": "claim: Parents should be allowed to genetically screen foetuses for heritable diseases.\n perspective: People with genetic disorders will be marginalized by genetic screening.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-3bce11c1c2ed483d80353e286174ab80", "input": "claim: Parents should be allowed to genetically screen foetuses for heritable diseases.\n perspective: A screening culture may lead to the value of human life becoming distorted", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-dcf643baa4614fecac73ce7f11b189f8", "input": "claim: Taking food thrown out by supermarkets should not be illegal.\n perspective: Scavengers cause problems for the shop and make the atmosphere unpleasant.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-0313af870d9b463db992a3aba489cd47", "input": "claim: Taking food thrown out by supermarkets should not be illegal.\n perspective: The supermarket could get into legal trouble.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-bf6f136f73e346aeb54c37a008b7bd1b", "input": "claim: Taking food thrown out by supermarkets should not be illegal.\n perspective: Supermarkets can be held legally responsible if someone gets sick from food they have thrown out.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-1f67e309ea8a4fb28a3bf227c6768a3f", "input": "claim: Taking food thrown out by supermarkets should not be illegal.\n perspective: Even though someone took food thrown out by a supermarket, they could sue the supermarket if they get sick.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-085658049e0a4f05b7fdb7282cc89e26", "input": "claim: Teachers should be armed.\n perspective: Children would be caught in the crossfire", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-d8da4bd0948d48be834f018f0bd4f4bd", "input": "claim: Teachers should be armed.\n perspective: It would be difficult to prevent the unintentional shooting of children in the crossfire.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-cce7024c8ce54e08b3f5bb285648d5df", "input": "claim: Teachers should be armed.\n perspective: If teachers shoot a gun children will be killed", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-cc29d44c63d649eba4b79c690c015938", "input": "claim: Teachers should be armed.\n perspective: Guns in schools might be used in circumstances other than defense.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4037663b1a284b8890d5e0e032313873", "input": "claim: Teachers should be armed.\n perspective: There are risks involved with allowing guns in schools.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-138fdcaf0c0741319a3a7b3dffacafe4", "input": "claim: Teachers should be armed.\n perspective: Allowing guns in schools might contribute to school violence if they are not used only for defense.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-56f1296c2f114e598fff2feab9ff8c4d", "input": "claim: Abolish the monarchy.\n perspective: The head of state should be a position that is separate and distinct from politics", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-d8bc21a4c74d47b189fa4e31b7b1153c", "input": "claim: Abolish the monarchy.\n perspective: Politics should not include the head of the state as in a monarchy.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-f3c4c5d9fa5149e9959b8cf61d5223ae", "input": "claim: Abolish the monarchy.\n perspective: There should be a separation from the head of state and politics.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-f263fb77cc754d1b9fe8b97bb96edc91", "input": "claim: Cut aid to African states that criminalise homosexuality.\n perspective: The reduction of aid will cause innocent people to suffer", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-315112a32f004078957c6ce59a4d5be0", "input": "claim: Ghana’s ban on smoking in public places is a model for Africa.\n perspective: Pack labelling or taxation a better alternative", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ec81ae43703044619b65a8d909c1ea4a", "input": "claim: Ghana’s ban on smoking in public places is a model for Africa.\n perspective: Ban would harm the wider economy", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-40ca316980a849ce912d2611e361a1d8", "input": "claim: Ghana’s ban on smoking in public places is a model for Africa.\n perspective: A smoking ban in public places is harmful to the economy", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b5f88dc5bc324827ac1d61dc67cddd3f", "input": "claim: Ghana’s ban on smoking in public places is a model for Africa.\n perspective: Economic hardship would follow a public place smoking ban", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-2071ae3dff5849e88a30b3304f30d2a3", "input": "claim: Ghana’s ban on smoking in public places is a model for Africa.\n perspective: Unenforceable", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-311a9d9c1dac467287c8fdefb89d4117", "input": "claim: Ghana’s ban on smoking in public places is a model for Africa.\n perspective: people have the right to smoke ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-36bfc88a2fb74842b9ea728aaabe09cb", "input": "claim: Ghana’s ban on smoking in public places is a model for Africa.\n perspective: You should be able to smoke in public.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-be6052837ae74dcca2c360da6daf5f34", "input": "claim: Ghana’s ban on smoking in public places is a model for Africa.\n perspective: Smoking is a personal choice, and should not be restricted.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-d57514863f8f4043b893ad75d73501b8", "input": "claim: Ghana’s ban on smoking in public places is a model for Africa.\n perspective: The decision to smoke is a human right.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-1c608d3720b04fc8bf6139f3a978d262", "input": "claim: Ghana’s ban on smoking in public places is a model for Africa.\n perspective: Smoking is a human right.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b2df19d523f741cc9353e8d27dfe3843", "input": "claim: Ghana’s ban on smoking in public places is a model for Africa.\n perspective: WHAT HAPPEN TO A FREE CANADA. WE ARE GOING BACK TO THE TIME WERE SLAVES HAD NO RIGHT, NOW IT IS SMOKERS HAVE NO RIGHT", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-36846863263f4333a5d4159abde56ec6", "input": "claim: Ghana’s ban on smoking in public places is a model for Africa.\n perspective: Taking away a smoker's rights to smoke in public is akin to the time of slavery!", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-5bccbaf345a246cf89e03fed77f48410", "input": "claim: Ghana’s ban on smoking in public places is a model for Africa.\n perspective: How can this be a free Canada, if our right to smoke in public is taken away?", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e6465dd149fe4861ab7ee09e224f9f5f", "input": "claim: Ghana’s ban on smoking in public places is a model for Africa.\n perspective: Canada is a free country, so we should be free to be able to smoke.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-12c318704af14298808a3b062409a96c", "input": "claim: Ghana’s ban on smoking in public places is a model for Africa.\n perspective: Being free to smoke is a basic right that someone in a free country should have.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-2d4d1bc8ca25452494857907c7d97245", "input": "claim: Ghana’s ban on smoking in public places is a model for Africa.\n perspective: No - it should not be banned in places people CHOOSE to go ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-018213c88c6342a4841d7cccb74a3b32", "input": "claim: Ghana’s ban on smoking in public places is a model for Africa.\n perspective: A smoker should be allowed to smoke in any place that they have a choice to go to.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-2a2757cc6263492ca8e0aaea405c6d69", "input": "claim: Ghana’s ban on smoking in public places is a model for Africa.\n perspective: If I choose to go somewhere, I should be allowed to smoke there.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c13f6cbe9be34def917356b3a0b64b59", "input": "claim: Ghana’s ban on smoking in public places is a model for Africa.\n perspective: Since people are choosing whether to go to places, smoking shouldn't be banned there,", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-75ecd48a393f4205b3530bae4e39ff0a", "input": "claim: Ghana’s ban on smoking in public places is a model for Africa.\n perspective: Smoking shouldn't be banned in places where people choose to be.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-87b9b199064f4b51ad1a008c3b0a343a", "input": "claim: Ghana’s ban on smoking in public places is a model for Africa.\n perspective: Banning smoking isn't necessary.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-3e0e7f7d131a4024bc3830186c23edcc", "input": "claim: Ghana’s ban on smoking in public places is a model for Africa.\n perspective: smoking don't necessarily have to be banned", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-5b197bf0c05d4a9cbb6421e0a036628f", "input": "claim: Ghana’s ban on smoking in public places is a model for Africa.\n perspective: It's not necessary to ban smoking.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-df8037d63183401b9e2f19602daa16cf", "input": "claim: Ghana’s ban on smoking in public places is a model for Africa.\n perspective: Banning smoking is not something that's necessary.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-11abfb6e18d741d0806cd0860f01206f", "input": "claim: Ghana’s ban on smoking in public places is a model for Africa.\n perspective: Banning smoking in public places is not right.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ca1c09f574b94fbab3da6dec416b3c1f", "input": "claim: Ghana’s ban on smoking in public places is a model for Africa.\n perspective: It is not right to ban smoking.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-9f2e64b218b94041b82e4b073eb1368d", "input": "claim: Ghana’s ban on smoking in public places is a model for Africa.\n perspective: Banning smoking is a bad idea.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-3db2067dfc70466c839443afcef850b9", "input": "claim: Ghana’s ban on smoking in public places is a model for Africa.\n perspective: It's a bad idea to ban smoking.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-d864f6aee21b4f2a9c7a9be5e13f80a8", "input": "claim: Ghana’s ban on smoking in public places is a model for Africa.\n perspective: Smoking shouldnt be banned", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a20718a3d30b4795ac096a0dd4a5490d", "input": "claim: Deny Organs to Non-Donors.\n perspective: What if your loved-one was a recipient?", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a5c7e6955fd043b5bf2225b859a3d6f9", "input": "claim: Space Exploration Is a Waste of Money.\n perspective: The cost isn't actually very high", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-91c0e84c08dd45a7897397443d62dfc8", "input": "claim: Space Exploration Is a Waste of Money.\n perspective: The resources and efforts focused on space exploration could better humanity.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-6e0ae09eb3494e97971779c85e958c8a", "input": "claim: Space Exploration Is a Waste of Money.\n perspective: It is in man's nature to explore his environment.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-997bad28639645a5890720d9c8987c60", "input": "claim: The UK would be better off economically outside the European Union.\n perspective: Economic growth comes with closer integration with your neighbours", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a948c912fb7449609b1e816af002c82f", "input": "claim: The UK would be better off economically outside the European Union.\n perspective: Leaving will cause a shock to the British economy", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-5ca226e1055145178f1f4de6fec4c1f8", "input": "claim: The UK would be better off economically outside the European Union.\n perspective: british economy will take a hit", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-576525e469cf48c2838ef7d70e11b71f", "input": "claim: The UK would be better off economically outside the European Union.\n perspective: Leaving will give a shock to the British economy ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-6588db920d3e464bb24c24068e3bef69", "input": "claim: The UK would be better off economically outside the European Union.\n perspective: Leaving may increase British unemployment", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c8ee00ad1de2438f9c8e51d0e0dd09c3", "input": "claim: The UK would be better off economically outside the European Union.\n perspective: Students will have to pay British tuition fees", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-226a1cceef954178bc5afcff0372d79e", "input": "claim: Domestic intelligence agencies have a legitimate role to play in democracy.\n perspective: Intelligence agencies inflate threats.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-199c5b1361f3415a97fbe652dcf10568", "input": "claim: Domestic intelligence agencies have a legitimate role to play in democracy.\n perspective: Intelligence agencies exaggerate the nature of threats.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-d89921c3cd6d424797e705cbd706762b", "input": "claim: Domestic intelligence agencies have a legitimate role to play in democracy.\n perspective: Intelligence agencies use hyperbole when describing threats.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b6a67c5b67154183a5d086d4da11df1c", "input": "claim: Domestic intelligence agencies have a legitimate role to play in democracy.\n perspective: Threats are exaggerrated by intelligence agencies.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-791e189ae0ec4229a55ddad3f2495d1b", "input": "claim: Domestic intelligence agencies have a legitimate role to play in democracy.\n perspective: It can be self-serving for intelligence agencies to over exaggerate threats.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-82df6c664b42485e8c1c0b5849e71c23", "input": "claim: Domestic intelligence agencies have a legitimate role to play in democracy.\n perspective: Domestic intelligence agencies cannot be controlled", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-0b966d0e55ff43389becae6b09e8fc54", "input": "claim: Domestic intelligence agencies have a legitimate role to play in democracy.\n perspective: It is too difficult to control domestic intelligence services.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-f405a108255a49829258dc875871d403", "input": "claim: Domestic intelligence agencies have a legitimate role to play in democracy.\n perspective: Domestic intelligence services lack the oversight to be controlled.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c3165d3d1c8949de9aa1653e1c43cd45", "input": "claim: Domestic intelligence agencies have a legitimate role to play in democracy.\n perspective: There is an inability to control domestic intelligence agencies.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4e44b72d6b894e3ea0eae5b25d92a160", "input": "claim: Domestic intelligence agencies have a legitimate role to play in democracy.\n perspective: Intelligence agencies operating domestically are unable to be controlled.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e8ef7288388f43968b3bad28324f14af", "input": "claim: Domestic intelligence agencies have a legitimate role to play in democracy.\n perspective: The government has no right to spy on citizens.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-7cf5a4324487442c90ac1be41908c925", "input": "claim: Domestic intelligence agencies have a legitimate role to play in democracy.\n perspective: Citizens have a right to privacy against the government.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a358c1d6c5104f36b2b59d21f115de32", "input": "claim: Domestic intelligence agencies have a legitimate role to play in democracy.\n perspective: Government sponsored domestic intelligence cannot be allowed to spy on citizens.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-30ef7b2a66cb4e21934f40c451b4887c", "input": "claim: Domestic intelligence agencies have a legitimate role to play in democracy.\n perspective: Citizens have the right to expect privacy and not be spied on by domestic intelligence agencies.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-bcecea8f2f0c45a493ca2c3f8f4e68f9", "input": "claim: Affirmative Action in South Africa does more harm than good.\n perspective: AA does more good than harm", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c952ab22e13849a0a317d305031b6098", "input": "claim: Affirmative Action in South Africa does more harm than good.\n perspective: Affirmative Action is necessary to combat racism.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-5b9d36a909f142cda6136ae0a15b5e79", "input": "claim: Affirmative Action in South Africa does more harm than good.\n perspective: There is a moral obligation to provide affirmative action programs", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-1eed0bec52704c64863edbe19f7036c0", "input": "claim: Affirmative Action in South Africa does more harm than good.\n perspective: We are obligated to promote racial equality and provide affirmative action programs.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ac661a9ed05a496fabd108993ff252a8", "input": "claim: Affirmative Action in South Africa does more harm than good.\n perspective: We have a moral obligation to stop discrimination with affirmative action.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-f21dc2c0e9b04a86b809250d13dd0e3b", "input": "claim: Affirmative Action in South Africa does more harm than good.\n perspective: Affirmative action removes the cyclical disadvantages of discrimination", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-acd744563bee4d9183982082823d8592", "input": "claim: Affirmative Action in South Africa does more harm than good.\n perspective: Discrimination can be helped by affirmative action.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-dc2fa76b00564e7db7dbcc51b6a66384", "input": "claim: Affirmative Action in South Africa does more harm than good.\n perspective: The cycle of racial discrimination can be broken through affirmative action programs.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-d2a82a8aa38f4ea887d6e153796bdfe5", "input": "claim: Affirmative Action in South Africa does more harm than good.\n perspective: Affirmative action reduces social prejudice", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-db82e948e0a54460a498a79922189a6b", "input": "claim: Affirmative Action in South Africa does more harm than good.\n perspective: Affirmative action is needed to combat racial and gender prejudice.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-cdcd12b301754903a0cd8a483c4cb46d", "input": "claim: Affirmative Action in South Africa does more harm than good.\n perspective: We can help decrease social prejudice with affirmative action programs.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-63b69a26a7d7467cba6534c3d002a326", "input": "claim: Prosecutions help the healing process.\n perspective: Peace more important than Justice ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-72c00648e2f6450f92448949792ffb7e", "input": "claim: Prosecutions help the healing process.\n perspective: Fear of prosecutions cause leaders to do more damage", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a473da3cb72c418ca5fc7373dcc306c2", "input": "claim: Prosecutions help the healing process.\n perspective: Prosecutions don't get to the real truth", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-0287d826052f4dabbaf9bcec4c00c620", "input": "claim: New prisons need to be built to ease overcrowding.\n perspective: The new prisons will just fill up as well.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-6a2dcd45d3364e0b8d667ae7db31dcc1", "input": "claim: New prisons need to be built to ease overcrowding.\n perspective: Too many prisons.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-815dd2e362fc475abdcd25b8f52ca575", "input": "claim: New prisons need to be built to ease overcrowding.\n perspective: Rehabilitation is the answer not extra prison spaces.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-0471df6a29584edd890dfb2ef4337b67", "input": "claim: New prisons need to be built to ease overcrowding.\n perspective: Prisoners should be rehabilitated, not imprisoned.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-af9ecc1551b746d99ea54a9732b2458f", "input": "claim: New prisons need to be built to ease overcrowding.\n perspective: Rather than create more spaces in prison, we should rehabilitate and release prisoners.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e6fb0ae228ca431caa593c2581b97728", "input": "claim: New prisons need to be built to ease overcrowding.\n perspective: It is better to rehabiliate people instead of buidling prisons.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-6b3727eefda1410f8d7d235ba8b136cd", "input": "claim: New prisons need to be built to ease overcrowding.\n perspective: If rehabilitation were an option, there would be less need for prisons.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-2b0b9026a0f3414fb322ea7a4d2171ed", "input": "claim: New prisons need to be built to ease overcrowding.\n perspective: Communities nearby the prisons will suffer.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e95c84c9fe624d90a4f8786485957270", "input": "claim: New prisons need to be built to ease overcrowding.\n perspective: Building more prisons will just negatively affect the surrounding communities.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a2523ddc77d04ebdbff1abf301567c8c", "input": "claim: New prisons need to be built to ease overcrowding.\n perspective: More prisons means more negative impacts on surrounding communities.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4120cdaf3c4e47179aacf3b637710c7b", "input": "claim: New prisons need to be built to ease overcrowding.\n perspective: Community value will plummet with the building of new prisons.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ecde43d4e910460eada9d95fc77c0643", "input": "claim: New prisons need to be built to ease overcrowding.\n perspective: New prisons will harm nearby communities.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-0e3a7c20c66f4aef99776cecf88ce27c", "input": "claim: Parents or other adults should be able to ban books from schools and libraries.\n perspective: Many frequently challenged books help people get a better idea of the world and their place in it", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-da884a77198e4d9fb8279afcecdb8784", "input": "claim: Parents or other adults should be able to ban books from schools and libraries.\n perspective: Keeping books with inappropriate content out of libraries protects kids, but doesn't stop people from reading those books or prevent authors from writing them.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-32c865744c514cbaadc3d9a2a97d22a8", "input": "claim: Parents or other adults should be able to ban books from schools and libraries.\n perspective: Parents may control what their own children read, but don't have a right to restrict what books are available to other people.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b3cf4eab35274c4da5f4566507bf4f0c", "input": "claim: Parents or other adults should be able to ban books from schools and libraries.\n perspective: Parents can restrict the reading of their children, but don't have a right to control what books other people read.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-451f04de7e414629a8daabb1cfe8baa1", "input": "claim: Parents or other adults should be able to ban books from schools and libraries.\n perspective: Parents have a say about what their children read, but don't have a right to control what books are available to others. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-1c9c3303b780449c94103e9fe5ec4041", "input": "claim: Parents or other adults should be able to ban books from schools and libraries.\n perspective: Books are a portal to different life experiences and reading encourages empathy and social-emotional development", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-d4d2d6ccf29b43fb8635a2405259ca27", "input": "claim: Parents or other adults should be able to ban books from schools and libraries.\n perspective: Reading encourages empathy and social-emotional development, and books are a portal to different life experiences.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-de71c0c09900413aaeaa537006bd06ae", "input": "claim: Parents or other adults should be able to ban books from schools and libraries.\n perspective: Books are an open door to different life experiences and reading encourages social-emotional development and empathy.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-5c7d5113a9e1446384b1e40a3e1f2897", "input": "claim: That Zero Tolerance Policing is a Good Tactic for Fighting Crime.\n perspective: There is no concrete proof that a zero tolerance approach to crime exists0", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-d64042b266a54a00bf5105912593f345", "input": "claim: That Zero Tolerance Policing is a Good Tactic for Fighting Crime.\n perspective: Zero tolerance policing is enormously expensive", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-1bdfbcb337f34d1f8ff23e0731d34f0e", "input": "claim: That Zero Tolerance Policing is a Good Tactic for Fighting Crime.\n perspective: Tolerance has a negative correlation with costs", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-2e0897b6567a4dd0801cb2fd197d1c97", "input": "claim: That Zero Tolerance Policing is a Good Tactic for Fighting Crime.\n perspective: It can be more difficult to afford a lesser tolerance policing setup", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c3f74d37d98f4e2ab5424a5e714cd1b6", "input": "claim: Prisoners Should Be Used For Medical Experiments Without Consent.\n perspective: Against morality and medical ethics", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-01d4fdfda6d44592b72ec28f6a86c420", "input": "claim: Prisoners Should Be Used For Medical Experiments Without Consent.\n perspective: Against the Principle of Criminal Justice ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-1a3adadfe58c41c1b4bf449cc61cfd3b", "input": "claim: Prisoners Should Be Used For Medical Experiments Without Consent.\n perspective: No Cruel and Unusual Punishment", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-93e4e7b886df4b6d84103575d646cd6f", "input": "claim: Prisoners Should Be Used For Medical Experiments Without Consent.\n perspective: Protection of prisoner's rights", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-dc29ccd9e8e546b59959710017610715", "input": "claim: Labels on food must be mandated to encourage people to eat better.\n perspective: Food labeling allows companies to deceive consumers", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-2bb8294616b74aa19c2bc10df0c2cab9", "input": "claim: Labels on food must be mandated to encourage people to eat better.\n perspective: By labeling their foods, companies are able to convince consumers of falsehoods. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-23b976271df3441fa7d0a58740755b75", "input": "claim: Labels on food must be mandated to encourage people to eat better.\n perspective: Consumers can be fed lies by companies via food labels.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-fc730e8e62da4b1588af7e4ba96213ed", "input": "claim: Labels on food must be mandated to encourage people to eat better.\n perspective: Food labeling does not change consumer behavior", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-27be9a44dcad490283a5bf4df9ce37c7", "input": "claim: Labels on food must be mandated to encourage people to eat better.\n perspective: Consumers do not change their buying habits based on the absence or presence of labels.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-aa128f58539f4ad5a6f6efcb0b48078b", "input": "claim: Labels on food must be mandated to encourage people to eat better.\n perspective: Food labeling introduces unfair prejudice against certain products", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-8eb35c68e2204b359922b85d32c22b6d", "input": "claim: Labels on food must be mandated to encourage people to eat better.\n perspective: Food labels encourage bias against certain types of products.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a24978658db24e5994632ae0349bc70a", "input": "claim: Labels on food must be mandated to encourage people to eat better.\n perspective: Nutrition labeling on packages can encourage consumers to buy certain types of foods over others.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-f8b89f5bb5c845d0bfa40813c7a8dbb5", "input": "claim: Force has to be used to protect human rights abroad.\n perspective: This is an illegitimate violation of national sovereignty.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-2756754040f847f9b61914ff420f6ae6", "input": "claim: Force has to be used to protect human rights abroad.\n perspective: The use of force violates our sovereignty, instead of protecting human rights.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4266312bb7ec401091c847e4f9fb18f0", "input": "claim: Force has to be used to protect human rights abroad.\n perspective: Force does more harm than good.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ca9d94948af842e08fabb414d278b8a3", "input": "claim: Force has to be used to protect human rights abroad.\n perspective: Using force to protect human rights can be detrimental.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-259173cfe35f43baa525a6d75554509b", "input": "claim: Long term cooperation between Russia and the United States is possible.\n perspective: Missile defence shows Russia is still suspicious of U.S. motives.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a0493f0448154908b422ee6f5e653936", "input": "claim: Long term cooperation between Russia and the United States is possible.\n perspective: Missile defense is an area where Russia is suspicious of the United States.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-444e58fa274e4bea9fe6934a02239311", "input": "claim: Long term cooperation between Russia and the United States is possible.\n perspective: The countries must account for the competing economic interests in addition to finding the ways to cooperate.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e0122f771b4643808e85e922fa6af75b", "input": "claim: Long term cooperation between Russia and the United States is possible.\n perspective: Conflicts in the economic interests of the countries make the long term cooperation more difficult to accomplish.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-f72674e3a82248c49ea19adc51f5923c", "input": "claim: Long term cooperation between Russia and the United States is possible.\n perspective: Russian and US economic interests conflict", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-622fc51191704baba29f9a7304b703c8", "input": "claim: Long term cooperation between Russia and the United States is possible.\n perspective: Russian and US strategic interests conflict", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-d2ec9dddce1347c492d14a57c6464a5f", "input": "claim: Long term cooperation between Russia and the United States is possible.\n perspective: The conflicts between US and Russian strategic interest make this difficult.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-9479e1e5c6204a0eb87c36c6fd9f2c15", "input": "claim: Long term cooperation between Russia and the United States is possible.\n perspective: This is more challenging because of the conflicts between Russian and US strategic interests.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-2123d9da1bb54473b8a652ee94ae4950", "input": "claim: Long term cooperation between Russia and the United States is possible.\n perspective: The conflicts between the economic interests of the two countries are an obstacle to long term cooperation between the two countries.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-6f14c6f35a8442b4b459898a0690a457", "input": "claim: Macs are better than PCs.\n perspective: Macs are plagued with hardware issues", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-485f1b6b512e4b1ca767fd3e2cda6833", "input": "claim: Macs are better than PCs.\n perspective: Despite sometimes numerous hardware issues, Macs continue are better than PCs for many reasons", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-26b63936f17f4123994607bd7a18a5fb", "input": "claim: Competition in the long run is healthy rather than harmful for the community: GRE issue.\n perspective: for having a fair competition many bright students have to suffer: reservation", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-856ee5d22e3a4d1cb4d1122b17226160", "input": "claim: Competition in the long run is healthy rather than harmful for the community: GRE issue.\n perspective: Reservation is having a fair competition that man students have to suffer.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-6f70c67859c245a08c3af1ec4a428bd8", "input": "claim: Adding artificial happy endings to a story completely ruins it.\n perspective: Hopeful endings are important for morale", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-f21b46a69e5b43b7854fe0891d7f9f12", "input": "claim: Adding artificial happy endings to a story completely ruins it.\n perspective: A good ending is good for morale.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c878740b96ea4fdca115e6d01fad3c8e", "input": "claim: Adding artificial happy endings to a story completely ruins it.\n perspective: If there is hope at the end, it boost morale.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4224f278830b4602b6c1aeb4ac58f366", "input": "claim: Adding artificial happy endings to a story completely ruins it.\n perspective: Truly faithful versions of fairy tales would be unsuitable for young children.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a49af72296b74a519f914a440e56df82", "input": "claim: Hosting the world cup is beneficial.\n perspective: Scarce public resources.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-7ce2985e8914416b85c957601f7f5c16", "input": "claim: Hosting the world cup is beneficial.\n perspective: Financially costly for the hosts", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-57b51f434ecd410ab6f25f06cda6e3fa", "input": "claim: Hosting the world cup is beneficial.\n perspective: too much money for the hosts", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-1b25c04017e549088e7d38417392ce6e", "input": "claim: Hosting the world cup is beneficial.\n perspective: costly for the hosts in a financial sense", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-5fa3186e528a4465ad014f93b7684cb0", "input": "claim: Men are the key to family planning in Uganda.\n perspective: Family planning is wrong: controlling sexuality", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-775eff5792ee4eb19a227b3a57b6dae0", "input": "claim: Men are the key to family planning in Uganda.\n perspective: Controlling sexuality in family planning is wrong", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-83fe3b115e8f4a22befc2e0dea6e86ec", "input": "claim: Men are the key to family planning in Uganda.\n perspective: Sexuality and family planning don't mix", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-cf3f616c4ed7481bacd5e3470002a50a", "input": "claim: German unification has been a success.\n perspective: People from East Germany feel disgruntled and this is reflected in who they vote for", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-5ba167d627444c40b233dcbc56f66db5", "input": "claim: German unification has been a success.\n perspective: East Germans don't necessarily believe unification to be a success no matter who they vote for.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-723b162e671b465ea202c31070a1beb0", "input": "claim: Prostitution has to be legalised.\n perspective: Markets in sex would corrupt non-market sexual relations, turning women and girls into commodities ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-7307a1cc88d44babbfef0b24ef2bbe9b", "input": "claim: Prostitution has to be legalised.\n perspective: Markets in sexual services undermine the values of commitment and loyalty ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-0ce1ae46d68547b6aa395894da75abfa", "input": "claim: Prostitution has to be legalised.\n perspective: Sex markets undermine the institution of marriage.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-dd0e95c5378a484382136b9dff913de7", "input": "claim: Prostitution has to be legalised.\n perspective: Sex markets are bad for society.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-58a6a51b72514e1f9ebf4de35b3a9d1f", "input": "claim: Prostitution has to be legalised.\n perspective: No, can you imagine the ADS on TV?", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-7fb25ff726f4477a9bce9fe3d41677ab", "input": "claim: Prostitution has to be legalised.\n perspective: Legalizing prostitution will result pornographic advertisements. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-07afd164c65e4255b337935e9a1bd2e7", "input": "claim: Prostitution has to be legalised.\n perspective: The advertising for prostitution would be against public decency.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b5e090e694c846cc995d48645cdd89f8", "input": "claim: Prostitution has to be legalised.\n perspective: Legalised prostitution still victimises the vulnerable.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-55380a6cfa174026ae0ac13f84fe0166", "input": "claim: Prostitution has to be legalised.\n perspective: Prostitution hurts vulnerable women. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-300b7838874d4ff3b7b72eedd10226cb", "input": "claim: Prostitution has to be legalised.\n perspective: Prostitution takes advantage of women, turning them into victims.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e3b4bf3190a749adbd48f7118df413f4", "input": "claim: Prostitution has to be legalised.\n perspective: Would lead to similar policy towards drugs", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-bf8b720a4f15442da6c260a4b742eb5d", "input": "claim: Prostitution has to be legalised.\n perspective: We should declare the war on prostitution", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-d7375921a9cb4da38c329a9c38694b29", "input": "claim: Prostitution has to be legalised.\n perspective: The law should not condone illicit behaviour", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-d13c05930a1f4daf92e0673853c051b0", "input": "claim: Prostitution has to be legalised.\n perspective: It would not solve the violence of prostitution.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-0ae5393276b8413e8bb31efe3784888d", "input": "claim: Prostitution has to be legalised.\n perspective: Proposal will exacerbate the HIV problem", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-0d4457a5e9cf45119ca24899606de6fc", "input": "claim: Prostitution has to be legalised.\n perspective: Legalizing prostitution would exacerbate the HIV problem.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-8b33d97db81841dab8ddde57bc3f0972", "input": "claim: Prostitution has to be legalised.\n perspective: Detrimental to womens rights", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-0e9fdb6c4dfd400b8eb5c9229befb230", "input": "claim: Prostitution has to be legalised.\n perspective: Legalizing prostitution opposes women's rights.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-824a1bba606d4811bba3293d42661dad", "input": "claim: Children should be banned from watching shows that contain violence and other adult contents.\n perspective: Any legislation would be impossible to enforce", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-89d5511607404b0e8ae160d4696e0793", "input": "claim: Children should be banned from watching shows that contain violence and other adult contents.\n perspective: Laws on this matter can not be enforced.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e7f02ee67f6d4a36a0b127933e146f71", "input": "claim: Children should be banned from watching shows that contain violence and other adult contents.\n perspective: The government can not control these matters.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-12f0e25a4129496ea4c3cc6dcc7ba284", "input": "claim: Children should be banned from watching shows that contain violence and other adult contents.\n perspective: People would not follow new laws about restricting kid's tv ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-1190df6e930344e993d6ce9ecaa69263", "input": "claim: Children should be banned from watching shows that contain violence and other adult contents.\n perspective: There is no one to enforce the new tv rules", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-63532144ed66426980306538f819ffa5", "input": "claim: Children should be banned from watching shows that contain violence and other adult contents.\n perspective: banning wouldn't stop people viewing them", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e245dafd109e41a2b2de03d398750351", "input": "claim: Children should be banned from watching shows that contain violence and other adult contents.\n perspective: Banning would just encourage undergound use.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ff7047feb8ad4af0a68e2c79e9fdbde4", "input": "claim: Children should be banned from watching shows that contain violence and other adult contents.\n perspective: Illegal viewing would still occur with a ban.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e119ed59902b42efb14c513bc663e297", "input": "claim: Children should be banned from watching shows that contain violence and other adult contents.\n perspective: People do not follow rules", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-7f07ef13ed7d4f92bc843eccd759a913", "input": "claim: Children should be banned from watching shows that contain violence and other adult contents.\n perspective: People do not like being told what to do", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-befafc94dbc74aa38f6efd547ec0acd3", "input": "claim: The UN should recognize a Palestinian state.\n perspective: Even a successful move for statehood would place the United States in a challenging position, and alienate American opinion which the Palestinians are dependent on", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e0d4efcd6fb54c39b89c5d9bbe112222", "input": "claim: The UN should recognize a Palestinian state.\n perspective: An attempt to build up international support reinforces Israeli fears of a Palestinian state being used as a platform for attacks against them", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-02c6b3f088f0489c915e8334bd202aec", "input": "claim: The Tibet should be an independent state.\n perspective: Tibet could never be a viable independent state and would either become a Chinese puppet or a launching pad for American and Indian power against China.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-bfeeb3e869814c9cb7c56a6710bb0756", "input": "claim: The Tibet should be an independent state.\n perspective: Tibet is too small of a nation to hold its own and not become a pawn of larger superpowers.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-933dc91e935f4390bdb694b04ba26f62", "input": "claim: The Tibet should be an independent state.\n perspective: Before Tibet can be an independent nation, it needs to demonstrate that it can act apart from the pressures from China, India or the U.S.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e8f10370a8e641b1973107ec1d56f739", "input": "claim: The Tibet should be an independent state.\n perspective: Tibet is almost 50% Han Chinese and they dominate the economy. Expelling them would be catastrophic", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ca5e6fab7299419885d07f69ca5ace7a", "input": "claim: Governments be allowed to disrupt Internet service on grounds of national security.\n perspective: Disrupting internet service is a form of repression. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-67bdca56e50a478fa6234c67daa5f5f2", "input": "claim: Governments be allowed to disrupt Internet service on grounds of national security.\n perspective: Governments that disrupt internet service are repressing their people.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ce78ce691a624ae1b29d634d3b417e8f", "input": "claim: Governments be allowed to disrupt Internet service on grounds of national security.\n perspective: Government control of internet is repression.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-2f2810ae53834d1db5b8045d06a4cc85", "input": "claim: The media’s selective coverage of certain issues works to worsen problems in society and create problems.\n perspective: The media has a duty to report any news it feels the public needs to hear about", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-5f49b6b345e34690a24b71cb7d0551be", "input": "claim: The media’s selective coverage of certain issues works to worsen problems in society and create problems.\n perspective: The media owes the public the right to hear all news and not selective coverage.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-68c43ec7bc534e759460604be43784b8", "input": "claim: All Americans should have the right (be entitled) to health care.\n perspective: Providing a right to health care could raise taxes. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-510fb8a12a474cdc888d33d2d6bfeee3", "input": "claim: All Americans should have the right (be entitled) to health care.\n perspective: Taxes might have to be raised to pay for all Americans to have health care.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-027c38f7b106403da85ed8c294c965c5", "input": "claim: All Americans should have the right (be entitled) to health care.\n perspective: A right to health care could increase the wait time for medical services. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-3352d8fa22aa46cc8fe6ead41b4dcd69", "input": "claim: All Americans should have the right (be entitled) to health care.\n perspective: It might take longer get medical care with a right to healthcare.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ffb6af6093e24a0eb965f17d8761fa95", "input": "claim: All Americans should have the right (be entitled) to health care.\n perspective: Medical services may be delayed with a right to health care.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a600755e3f1f410eb0baad0dd6e4d2a5", "input": "claim: All Americans should have the right (be entitled) to health care.\n perspective: Providing a right to health care could create a doctor shortage. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a71fff0e4e464244b687b918e00a9c88", "input": "claim: All Americans should have the right (be entitled) to health care.\n perspective: There aren't enough doctors to provide health care for all Americans.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-511186b7e2e3483c9e65d7d3cb53b960", "input": "claim: All Americans should have the right (be entitled) to health care.\n perspective: Implementing a right to health care could lead the United States towards socialism. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-5725c59bfbc94f839afb25ffdaf393a5", "input": "claim: All Americans should have the right (be entitled) to health care.\n perspective: A right to health care could lower the quality and availability of disease screening and treatment. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-5d0121b80c5e45cabc7be48796620053", "input": "claim: All Americans should have the right (be entitled) to health care.\n perspective: If all Americans are guaranteed health care, the overall quality of disease detection and management might be lower.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a590a4ef5bcd495cab61abdbcc570f15", "input": "claim: All Americans should have the right (be entitled) to health care.\n perspective: Disease testing and therapy might be worse if everyone has a right to health care.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c875b4de01e9400b9a5f358a71faad30", "input": "claim: All Americans should have the right (be entitled) to health care.\n perspective: The founding documents of the United States do not provide support for a right to health care. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-409781f11276482c88d9f9fbc191b35d", "input": "claim: All Americans should have the right (be entitled) to health care.\n perspective: There is no support for a right to healthcare in the United States founding documents.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b9a98bd6abed42f99beb3282a5b3a5db", "input": "claim: All Americans should have the right (be entitled) to health care.\n perspective: A right to health care is not predicated in our United States founding documents. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-8c4a64c1f3a44300882f515f555d0a70", "input": "claim: All Americans should have the right (be entitled) to health care.\n perspective: A right to health care could lower doctors' earnings. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-fbbbd86a52c64c2d83628db640350544", "input": "claim: All Americans should have the right (be entitled) to health care.\n perspective: A right to health care could cause people to overuse health care resources. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-dc12fd31846c498f8a240f0371f28c8f", "input": "claim: All Americans should have the right (be entitled) to health care.\n perspective: If all Americans have health care, people might burden hospitals by going to much.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c79edadbe14540ecad04a321609f400b", "input": "claim: All Americans should have the right (be entitled) to health care.\n perspective: If there is a right to health care, people might overwhelm the medical system by using it too much.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-9c38573ff9d949dd8c8dac87f2d0b974", "input": "claim: All Americans should have the right (be entitled) to health care.\n perspective: People should pay for their own health care, not have it given to them by the government. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-6d5f8f6f5d3c426889ccd30a5b8620ba", "input": "claim: All Americans should have the right (be entitled) to health care.\n perspective: The government shouldn't pay for everyone's health care.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e2d8624c5a5549879159bcf0a5003164", "input": "claim: All Americans should have the right (be entitled) to health care.\n perspective: People need to be responsible for their own health care costs, not the government.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-fcc16b996a3b42e9a389767252ca23ed", "input": "claim: Cyberbullies must be punished with prison even if under 18.\n perspective: There are other options besides jail", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c849860ca00943758ef2b722115f3d44", "input": "claim: Cyberbullies must be punished with prison even if under 18.\n perspective: There are alternatives to jail.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-7083f367dd5140ec8210c5814c9a5ea6", "input": "claim: Cyberbullies must be punished with prison even if under 18.\n perspective: There are choices other than jail.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-59df2a88fb2b405a95d3ec5d0a86883e", "input": "claim: Cyberbullies must be punished with prison even if under 18.\n perspective: Should not damage a normal childhood with jail", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a86e2027e1c946d399bc9f8db8d36883", "input": "claim: Cyberbullies must be punished with prison even if under 18.\n perspective: Jail time would damage a childhood.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-7e81dd78bd034ca3a8d8ff6b57e29624", "input": "claim: Cyberbullies must be punished with prison even if under 18.\n perspective: It hurts children to imprison them.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-3621ec462e774c1592f782106659a6dc", "input": "claim: Cyberbullies must be punished with prison even if under 18.\n perspective: Children should not be sent to jail", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e2eb9ad9be26422494cf7937babaf7ae", "input": "claim: Cyberbullies must be punished with prison even if under 18.\n perspective: We should not imprison children.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-806eed4a717e4dbb85d1815da933f971", "input": "claim: Cyberbullies must be punished with prison even if under 18.\n perspective: Imprisoning children is wrong.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-d15f95957b9b4727a129570fa6c52e52", "input": "claim: Protect braille out of respect for free speech.\n perspective: If the information is accessible in another format, it is wrong to claim that this is an issue of free speech. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-7421d0bc4d1a43f5b039fea677a756b1", "input": "claim: Protect braille out of respect for free speech.\n perspective: no matter the format, it is still free speech", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-2f9aae85a1df4d5f9b828ab9dbe42ff0", "input": "claim: Protect braille out of respect for free speech.\n perspective: Readers of all kinds are adapting to books being produced in new formats, publishers need to respond to this decline.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-cef45d875b384b0ca45b06c7ecebddda", "input": "claim: We must negotiate with terrorists.\n perspective: Even if negotiation with one group is successful others will take their place", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-25262729a8594f6e84d9aad20382203f", "input": "claim: We must negotiate with terrorists.\n perspective: Negotiation with a terrorist group is a futile action that will only lead to another terrorist group emerging at the forefront.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-1b1aa0d9f78a46b4942e531c8d4e3f26", "input": "claim: We must negotiate with terrorists.\n perspective: Negotiation with a terrorist group is not a productive long-term strategy, as other groups will be ready to ascend to the top of the threat matrix.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-2e391a7c5b3b4b9d8aa6729c0797fe94", "input": "claim: We must negotiate with terrorists.\n perspective: Negotiation provides more resources to terrorists", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-8c1ceda1d2774280a5f9119859f3d09e", "input": "claim: We must negotiate with terrorists.\n perspective: Excersizing the option of negotiation avails more resources for the terrorist to make their stand.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ad7a7ff919fd45e68dc06768592f0331", "input": "claim: We must negotiate with terrorists.\n perspective: Negotiation buttresses the position of the terrorist by provides additional resources.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-3f277d32b665404c9195106706b35c64", "input": "claim: We must negotiate with terrorists.\n perspective: Negotiation encourages more terrorism", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4a9ff466361b41e0886f26dc05cc55d5", "input": "claim: We must negotiate with terrorists.\n perspective: Negotiations lead to more destruction. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b182de99fe9e4d0db2ad799875525bc2", "input": "claim: We must negotiate with terrorists.\n perspective: Terrorism intensifies when negotiations take place. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b0f42daa64b447bf9b37a92d7df34fd1", "input": "claim: We must negotiate with terrorists.\n perspective: Terrorists can’t be trusted – better to crush them", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b1428b00825247afa9eca9d8c2620bd0", "input": "claim: We must negotiate with terrorists.\n perspective: Terrorists must be put down because placing trust in untrustworthy people is a losing strategy.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-d641b85ab0154756828dc77d6013bd9e", "input": "claim: We must negotiate with terrorists.\n perspective: Vanquishing the terrorists is the best option because terrorists are not worthy of trust.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-41e3fbdb3c634436a0a50f6382e62318", "input": "claim: We must negotiate with terrorists.\n perspective: One cannot negotiate while innocent people are in danger. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-226d234f1ab94ed0927ccd27aa6098e3", "input": "claim: We must negotiate with terrorists.\n perspective: When innocent people are threatened, negotiations should not take place. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b98441bd7b444735ad77cb098e6eccff", "input": "claim: Recreational marijuana should be legal.\n perspective: Legalizing marijuana increases use by teens, with harmful results.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-444328fa7a3249a3bdf24e12263006e0", "input": "claim: Recreational marijuana should be legal.\n perspective: Legalization of marijuana would cause teens to smoke more pot and would be harmful.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-eb24afe8762b42a9bc4b12fceed356db", "input": "claim: Recreational marijuana should be legal.\n perspective: Growing marijuana harms the environment. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b16ea2e6088a4e728a3716370dac057d", "input": "claim: Recreational marijuana should be legal.\n perspective: The black market and organized crime benefit from marijuana legalization.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-05fff78c7734431e8de2b5c6ac624b4d", "input": "claim: Recreational marijuana should be legal.\n perspective: The legalization of marijuana benefits both the black market and organized crime.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-166f192f4f454d5ea517e41ffd592b6a", "input": "claim: Recreational marijuana should be legal.\n perspective: Legalized marijuana creates steep costs for society and taxpayers that far outweigh its tax revenues.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-793983cc14984f9bb941e10ea4a5ed0c", "input": "claim: Recreational marijuana should be legal.\n perspective: One needs to consider the costs for society and taxpayers that would outweigh the tax benefits should marijuana be legalized.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b0d2d1a92fdc447ca758796c2f30dd75", "input": "claim: Recreational marijuana should be legal.\n perspective: Legalizing marijuana would create costs for both society and taxpayers that would offset the tax revenues that are generated.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-67c10431d635480393ca08fdbf311674", "input": "claim: Recreational marijuana should be legal.\n perspective: There are significant costs to taxpayers and society that that legal marijuana produced that are greater than the tax benefits. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e1e05f7d1926498686aa2dac1f859cf0", "input": "claim: Recreational marijuana should be legal.\n perspective: The benefits of taxation does not outweigh the cost of legalized marijuana to society and taxpayers. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-bec12ce5ca144774884ce93e943a99e9", "input": "claim: The Spread of Nuclear Weapons: More may be better.\n perspective: Humanitarian intervention becomes impossible in states that possess nuclear weapons", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-d2484f0df7e14b3390898fcd057975c0", "input": "claim: The Spread of Nuclear Weapons: More may be better.\n perspective: Humanitarian missions would not be possible in states that have nuclear weapons.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-9aed21fdf7dd47698a7d23770f20f3e2", "input": "claim: The Spread of Nuclear Weapons: More may be better.\n perspective: It is very difficult to intercede in humanitarian crises in states wherein nuclear weapons are present.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a41c14855cc7434cbb6ae2623071253e", "input": "claim: The Spread of Nuclear Weapons: More may be better.\n perspective: The threat of a state developing nuclear weapons could instigate pre-emptive strikes from its neighbours and rivals to prevent the acquisition of such weapons", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-5b2e748261ed45caa19dd08893bdc223", "input": "claim: The Spread of Nuclear Weapons: More may be better.\n perspective: Other countries could strike against those developing nuclear weapons to protect themselves.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-06342d6a88694056bfe0d34aa5604e73", "input": "claim: The Spread of Nuclear Weapons: More may be better.\n perspective: To keep other countries from obtaining a nuclear arsenal, other nations may pre-emptively strike.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-271e478e101240969b51537409211f64", "input": "claim: The Spread of Nuclear Weapons: More may be better.\n perspective: The intention of a state to develop nuclear weapons may incite military attacks by enemies and by other supporting countries.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-48a743dfd20445dc9a6e942d0f944127", "input": "claim: The Spread of Nuclear Weapons: More may be better.\n perspective: Possessing nuclear weapons will be counter to the peaceful interests of states", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-126605053f2047269ccc32d671b39c0a", "input": "claim: The Spread of Nuclear Weapons: More may be better.\n perspective: The United States has an obligation to protect international stability due to its unique military strength.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-92894d1c62d044a4886dc18a59918538", "input": "claim: The Spread of Nuclear Weapons: More may be better.\n perspective: The US must protect the international community.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-915fde2bcb134f99b66dc87e2538bddf", "input": "claim: The Spread of Nuclear Weapons: More may be better.\n perspective: The US military is needed to ensure peace.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-f6c79fc4153e418cb7618cc6cfb428fb", "input": "claim: The Spread of Nuclear Weapons: More may be better.\n perspective: [Iran specific] Others, particularly Israel, would act if the United States did not", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-05ea306f97904a21902920ab81cdce84", "input": "claim: The Spread of Nuclear Weapons: More may be better.\n perspective: If the US does not act on Iran, Israel will", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-fe4c123e6d654652836ecb9965ccb962", "input": "claim: The Spread of Nuclear Weapons: More may be better.\n perspective: Nuclear waste disposal is rarely safe/efficient; it is too much to expect a sqeaky clean disposal/disarmament of nuclear weapons ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-897461205f6c453da0b8e4cb6a23f404", "input": "claim: The Spread of Nuclear Weapons: More may be better.\n perspective: Proliferation of nuclear weapons increases the chances of nuclear accidents", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b827201a0502414fa462183712be71c0", "input": "claim: The Spread of Nuclear Weapons: More may be better.\n perspective: Nuclear weapons can fall into the wrong hands.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-703c390285f446a9992865b2d594ffea", "input": "claim: The Spread of Nuclear Weapons: More may be better.\n perspective: States will give terrorists nuclear weapons", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c4d92663539d44d28a0fdb3c2e16a151", "input": "claim: The Spread of Nuclear Weapons: More may be better.\n perspective: Terrorists will steal nuclear weapons from poorly guarded arsenals", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4387a382cb0b438a90a59f15d1fd4cc3", "input": "claim: The Spread of Nuclear Weapons: More may be better.\n perspective: The nukes can end up being used against us.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-7480216cb8454ec6ada0ca6e21d0fa71", "input": "claim: The Spread of Nuclear Weapons: More may be better.\n perspective: It's conceivable that the wrong people will have the weapons.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-5b00d03c704c43f08cbf354fe328fb61", "input": "claim: The Spread of Nuclear Weapons: More may be better.\n perspective: Irrational leaders make the possession of nuclear weapons dangerous", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-6c53c9c599d64bbaabf7fe781c768753", "input": "claim: The Spread of Nuclear Weapons: More may be better.\n perspective: It is immoral to use the threat of nuclear annihilation in order to achieve foreign policy aims", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-531f673878894b10aa41b018d08274da", "input": "claim: It is a good idea to build the Keystone XL pipeline.\n perspective: Environmental risks", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e84911182dc14bba950282c40aaa8b58", "input": "claim: It is a good idea to build the Keystone XL pipeline.\n perspective: America should not become more dependent on oil", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e8e75f1e1bf44eaeaf585877f37d8b08", "input": "claim: It is a good idea to build the Keystone XL pipeline.\n perspective: Dependence on oil needs to be reduced to ensure we do not end up slaves to others.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b99ea44fef2245c090b46705e00603aa", "input": "claim: It is a good idea to build the Keystone XL pipeline.\n perspective: We need to be free of the shackles of oil dependence and develop alternative fuels.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-0a2e6b091b3a4dfdb6bcb39cbf1783d5", "input": "claim: Do not allow companies to collect/sell the personal data of their clients.\n perspective: The storing and sale of personal data aids companies by making marketing more efficient and allows niche markets to thrive", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-5883db01add345a3b870b7ad52d3fcfa", "input": "claim: Do not allow companies to collect/sell the personal data of their clients.\n perspective: The sort of information being kept and sold is legitimate for firms to utilize in this fashion", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-9898e218e884442785a4c64321573f9f", "input": "claim: Invest in Renewable Technologies rather than Nuclear Power.\n perspective: The nuclear industry is constantly judged on criteria that do not take its externalities into account ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-d751808e3e744578b967878089506955", "input": "claim: Invest in Renewable Technologies rather than Nuclear Power.\n perspective: There is no instance in which renewable energy has been able to provide a major share in the energy market ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a224eb7e74704ef6917cd6d10549397d", "input": "claim: Invest in Renewable Technologies rather than Nuclear Power.\n perspective: Nuclear power has a proven track record in France, Canada and Russia and an increasing role in new energy markets", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-485ef1165ded4073aa01398e4299d853", "input": "claim: Invest in Renewable Technologies rather than Nuclear Power.\n perspective: Renewables are mostly unproven, experimental technologies being developed on a small-scale basis that is not ready to take up the gap to move away from fossil fuels under climate change agreements", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-deeb642f574c4d98ac96c51e0232f9cd", "input": "claim: Invest in Renewable Technologies rather than Nuclear Power.\n perspective: Mostly unproven, experimental technologies being developed on a small-scale basis that are not ready to take up the gap to move away from fossil fuels under climate change agreements are known as renewables.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ac6d1669ea5842f8a0ad78d82d891e90", "input": "claim: Invest in Renewable Technologies rather than Nuclear Power.\n perspective: Mostly unproven, experimental technologies being developed on a small-scale basis that are known as renewables are not ready to take up the gap the move away from fossil fuels under climate change agreements would create.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-29c4b452446d4a97935257576ae83fe9", "input": "claim: Homework is beneficial.\n perspective: Homework disadvantages low-income students", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-1795d842a2eb4e528392289b89dd8efe", "input": "claim: Homework is beneficial.\n perspective: Low-income students are at a disadvantage when it comes to homework.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ed29e512f99b44a69d2a1900944358e8", "input": "claim: Homework is beneficial.\n perspective: Homework doesn't help low-income students succeed.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-1f17bc2736604450a5a49d4d4b8129c7", "input": "claim: Homework is beneficial.\n perspective: There is no evidence that homework makes a difference for young children.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4dbad81ad2b142e3803a18cb5df81bdc", "input": "claim: Homework is beneficial.\n perspective: Homework has little educational worth, and therefore is a waste of students' time", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-10ef6279a96743b5b7e2078e069999bd", "input": "claim: Homework is beneficial.\n perspective: There is a lack of evidence that homework helps younger children", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-babf7a86a83343a08ac93ed09f1d0fb7", "input": "claim: Homework is beneficial.\n perspective: Small children are not helped by having homework.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-21651199026447e6bbabcf2dbda9e485", "input": "claim: Homework is beneficial.\n perspective: Too much homework can be harmful", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-527ea668da744498ae922e6691bff757", "input": "claim: Homework is beneficial.\n perspective: Yes Homework Should Have A Limit", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-9e3f53fe0fc8454986a0846d44520d7f", "input": "claim: Homework is beneficial.\n perspective: Yes, it should.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-95bf95d98b174513b2fb7946a7fb48d1", "input": "claim: Homework is beneficial.\n perspective: Assigning large amounts of homework isn't good for students.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-f807bc86fbe949819e974aec18612f03", "input": "claim: Homework is beneficial.\n perspective: Too much homework is detrimental.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-9a856e99714d4485942d423fc67af041", "input": "claim: Homework is beneficial.\n perspective: Yes, kids need to balance out mental and physical exercise.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-7fc786251a57453bbfba33c19bcecd5a", "input": "claim: Homework is beneficial.\n perspective: Kids need time to do many different kinds of activities. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-98b772b0424b4e5782d2c8cf26019e9d", "input": "claim: Homework is beneficial.\n perspective: There needs to be a balance for kids between mental and physical stimulation.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-1aca82747cb04eb89df2c6b7a05359c9", "input": "claim: Homework is beneficial.\n perspective: Mental stimulation and physical exercise need to have the proper balance in children.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c1d40229334e4f0eaf04030a950f8e8f", "input": "claim: Homework is beneficial.\n perspective: Homework puts students off learning", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-77be85f4697641e089d02f3ca4960843", "input": "claim: Financial Assistance for the Poor Should Be the Responsibility of Charities, Not Government.\n perspective: 4. Gov is better suited than charities.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-1b9833579f384ac19205b576e250f3a6", "input": "claim: Financial Assistance for the Poor Should Be the Responsibility of Charities, Not Government.\n perspective: The government is better equipped than charities", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-e4ba56e0b6dc46b1baa3525d9c110f1f", "input": "claim: Financial Assistance for the Poor Should Be the Responsibility of Charities, Not Government.\n perspective: The government can handle things better than charities", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-020c6b1311e54b92b411ca10c64996e2", "input": "claim: Financial Assistance for the Poor Should Be the Responsibility of Charities, Not Government.\n perspective: Government's duty to remedy a social problem", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-d884075b136f4a7da2ba9d6b83de9444", "input": "claim: Financial Assistance for the Poor Should Be the Responsibility of Charities, Not Government.\n perspective: [Response to rebuttal] Suitability: Government has essential macro-view(scale&scope), and IS better organized, better funded.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c1e6ce04b3b84d0babef2784db241d9a", "input": "claim: Financial Assistance for the Poor Should Be the Responsibility of Charities, Not Government.\n perspective: Government is better organized", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-0850098db5714f80af8f762a732b134f", "input": "claim: Financial Assistance for the Poor Should Be the Responsibility of Charities, Not Government.\n perspective: Government has more resources", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a42cf87b0c2b4d97b81ef5c1dcc938ee", "input": "claim: Corporal Punishment Should Be Reintroduced.\n perspective: Allowing children to be hit sends the message that it is OK to treat children in this way.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-69a445576164415ebdf0798876faa5ee", "input": "claim: Corporal Punishment Should Be Reintroduced.\n perspective: Corporal punishment creates an unsafe and violent school environment.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-425444d2d31a419cb8f8556233e97b8c", "input": "claim: Corporal Punishment Should Be Reintroduced.\n perspective: an unsafe and violent school environment is the affect of corporal punishment", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-ddbae51917cb4a668ea9027e1d97d3b2", "input": "claim: Corporal Punishment Should Be Reintroduced.\n perspective: corporal punishment will negatively affect the school experience for chiildren", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-50ca588e94044885963efdc9f0a795a8", "input": "claim: Corporal Punishment Should Be Reintroduced.\n perspective: Corporal punishment is an inappropriate punishment that harms the education of children.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b8be9532a2cb4d95ac2e993364ea03dc", "input": "claim: Corporal Punishment Should Be Reintroduced.\n perspective: the education of children will be hindered by corporal punishment", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-cbf5a90f96c64971abf5eb1899cac1d8", "input": "claim: Corporal Punishment Should Be Reintroduced.\n perspective: it is inappropriate to use corporal punishment on children as it can affect their education", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-221eaceac1d5443c920e828d7c1ea50e", "input": "claim: Corporal Punishment Should Be Reintroduced.\n perspective: Corporal punishment can inflict long-lasting physical and mental harm on students.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-6a7d51f2f0af462ba8c942ed19b03a23", "input": "claim: Corporal Punishment Should Be Reintroduced.\n perspective: long lasting physical and mental harm can be caused by corporal punishment", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-5e315ca0fb84489792c08df9f77cd368", "input": "claim: Corporal Punishment Should Be Reintroduced.\n perspective: by using corporal punishment you can cause serious mental and physical damage", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4b7fc00eff3040fc85d6a5a42fba4a21", "input": "claim: Nuclear technology must be adopted.\n perspective: Nuclear power is very expensive", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-1b1a953c3c6c42fe9ee3d11a1ef74ac8", "input": "claim: Nuclear technology must be adopted.\n perspective: Nuclear power is not cheap.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-fab32c93e0b0460da577094c2bf83d26", "input": "claim: Nuclear technology must be adopted.\n perspective: Nuclear power has many benefits, but cost is not one.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-48fd362534144d8fb6c740a910bd4c8d", "input": "claim: Aid is killing Africa.\n perspective: Aid serves a purpose and should not be discouraged", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c60e1f1c2f7d4f2383a189f476e216b9", "input": "claim: There must be a progressive tax rate.\n perspective: Progressive taxes place an unfair and disproportionate burden on the wealthy", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a80265e1cf58449796bd6b781c0210fa", "input": "claim: There must be a progressive tax rate.\n perspective: The wealthy bear a disproportionate burden of a progressive tax rate,", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-2da97a75a13e4184a29135c578b396bb", "input": "claim: There must be a progressive tax rate.\n perspective: Progressive tax rates are unfair to the wealthy.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-34f5bf86f9974a99ae88db501e6e362a", "input": "claim: There must be a progressive tax rate.\n perspective: The ability to orchestrate a progressive taxation regime gives undue and dangerous power to the state", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-650d69bd35e149e39fc7c6a543444423", "input": "claim: There must be a progressive tax rate.\n perspective: A progressive tax rate will cause the state to have undue powers.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-6d26b564da684685bcf76773d42b2b1d", "input": "claim: There must be a progressive tax rate.\n perspective: It is dangerous to give the state the power of a progressive tax rate.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-44de490e42b04ffd9a0cf98b2fd5282f", "input": "claim: There must be a progressive tax rate.\n perspective: The aim of taxation should be to provide equality of opportunity, not of outcom", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-36aa9a21ea244284ac2474794b57bc7b", "input": "claim: There must be a progressive tax rate.\n perspective: Progressive systems are invariably highly complex and inefficient in implementation, breeding the knock-on inefficiencies of evasion and avoidance", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-538fe830e76f4ae3b1492137a1ec8873", "input": "claim: There must be a progressive tax rate.\n perspective: Individuals’ property and income are an index of deserving achievement, and of value contributed in the market place to society ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-3f3890fe6a8a4ae087e4b5ff23b07b0e", "input": "claim: Degrees in the creative arts are luxuries society can no longer afford.\n perspective: The notion that money is the best way of judging value is far more damaging to society than the Arts", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-680304e4621c4b559db281584f6fcc8d", "input": "claim: Degrees in the creative arts are luxuries society can no longer afford.\n perspective: The Arts provide huge benefits to society; easily comparable to humanities or theoretical science", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c4567156cd884262bda1786795993cb0", "input": "claim: Degrees in the creative arts are luxuries society can no longer afford.\n perspective: The Arts pay their way in film, heritage and design industries", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-37318dffc13b4adeb766c8f07a4d156c", "input": "claim: Smoking should further be restricted.\n perspective: Democratic systems should educate on smoking rather than restrict it", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-b83f182018c74d82a4b9b3aaa306d0ce", "input": "claim: Smoking should further be restricted.\n perspective: Education is a better tactic in the war on smoking.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-8a0daf88edad49c78854867bd8e35585", "input": "claim: Universities should make all academic work they produce, including scholarly articles, course handbooks and recorded lectures, available to the general public.\n perspective: Less incentive to study at university", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-148c85e43a91426bb7604171fda8d2f0", "input": "claim: Universities should make all academic work they produce, including scholarly articles, course handbooks and recorded lectures, available to the general public.\n perspective: Making everything free to access will damage universities ability to tap private funding", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-9df511cd6750471ab75f1886eb5c70f0", "input": "claim: Universities should make all academic work they produce, including scholarly articles, course handbooks and recorded lectures, available to the general public.\n perspective: Universities will struggle with private funding if all provided resources become free", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-2ba8c030aaff4b85b615c8ebbbb3ae64", "input": "claim: Universities should make all academic work they produce, including scholarly articles, course handbooks and recorded lectures, available to the general public.\n perspective: Opening up resources to free access can be damaging to universities", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-0820c2675d354247951737530eec89fb", "input": "claim: Universities should make all academic work they produce, including scholarly articles, course handbooks and recorded lectures, available to the general public.\n perspective: Universities deserve to profit from their work", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a0c59e1a8561415bb7fc05915ae9467d", "input": "claim: Universities should make all academic work they produce, including scholarly articles, course handbooks and recorded lectures, available to the general public.\n perspective: Universities should be directly profiting from their services", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-d0f9caa18bea43c381782d9c4c6c5f16", "input": "claim: Universities should make all academic work they produce, including scholarly articles, course handbooks and recorded lectures, available to the general public.\n perspective: Universities deserve to add costs to their resources instead of leaving them open to the public, restricting profits", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a1e18d5759e748b6b3dc3a3704bacc7b", "input": "claim: Universities should make all academic work they produce, including scholarly articles, course handbooks and recorded lectures, available to the general public.\n perspective: Considering the amount of data governments produce, compelling them to publish all of it would be counterproductive as citizens would be swamped. ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-3c0f74eebab94d75a7a37f0725da57b3", "input": "claim: Universities should make all academic work they produce, including scholarly articles, course handbooks and recorded lectures, available to the general public.\n perspective: The government produces too much data to make it all available to the public.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c7ab7cb75d87409884496837a759f868", "input": "claim: Universities should make all academic work they produce, including scholarly articles, course handbooks and recorded lectures, available to the general public.\n perspective: It would take citizens too long to go through all of the government data so they only produce what is necessary for understanding.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-80c4aad26e754db097ec3ebfdc68af38", "input": "claim: We have to offer amnesty to bloggers currently prosecuted by their native states.\n perspective: The offer of amnesty allows home governments to discredit bloggers and paint them as foreign agents of disruption", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c317b31ee3bf48499703fe7ebe4db6c0", "input": "claim: We have to offer amnesty to bloggers currently prosecuted by their native states.\n perspective: An amnesty policy will serve only to alienate regimes, shutting down the possibility of discourse or reform", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-729a8919e1ab4513adc557e994317c08", "input": "claim: The ICC is not an effective deterrent.\n perspective: The ICC’s investigations have already deterred potential crimes.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-32b41b1d183a477ba28028a1ad0eb2c7", "input": "claim: The ICC is not an effective deterrent.\n perspective: Investigations alone by the ICC deter crimes.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-53bd69dcbccd4d8e93cbb402be65f393", "input": "claim: The ICC is not an effective deterrent.\n perspective: Investigations by the ICC deter potential criminals.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-75c840607bf84941822820c03052b8d7", "input": "claim: The ICC is not an effective deterrent.\n perspective: The ICC’s widely endorsed authority extends its deterrent effects.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-dcf7a1ef8c704be2b3c507df0896bd8d", "input": "claim: The ICC is not an effective deterrent.\n perspective: The ICC's deterent effect is as wide as its authority is endorsed.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a1ea12d26bb44303ae9f84481ab621fa", "input": "claim: The ICC is not an effective deterrent.\n perspective: Potential prosecution by the ICC encourages local authorities to improve their own judicial systems.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-41900b6124d046dfb26157d1aaf496e8", "input": "claim: Homework should have a limit.\n perspective: Homework is an essential part of education, allowing students to learn information beyond that which they are taught at school.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-eed50fb42ead453d8d72b125ce16575c", "input": "claim: Homework should have a limit.\n perspective: Homework is crucial to a well rounded education as it is the means by which students are encouraged to learn beyond the school curriculum.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-4810b44264e340aab885e40e80cd2e6b", "input": "claim: Homework should have a limit.\n perspective: Homework allows students to explore and learn beyond the instruction they are given in the classroom.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-6cbeabb43ebd43d6a5c91b537743f150", "input": "claim: Homework should have a limit.\n perspective: Homework ensures that students practise what they are taught at school", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-a5ee78b5e6e1460b9eace5db1f2d904c", "input": "claim: Homework should have a limit.\n perspective: Homework provides a link between child, school and the home", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-485d391b4dd8425f9922792b5c8024a1", "input": "claim: Homework should have a limit.\n perspective: Homework allows parents to be involved with their child's learning", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-1a4dde7082cd45a59eaef0fe457ab3c9", "input": "claim: Homework should have a limit.\n perspective: Homework is beneficial because of parent/child involvement", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-78da5b9bbe0f43458b728abc45edcde3", "input": "claim: Homework should have a limit.\n perspective: Homework helps parents understand what their children are learning.", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-c1cb1e0edace4dedb027378fb44ca66a", "input": "claim: Homework should have a limit.\n perspective: Homework can get parents involved", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-57f3e8842ab440118fc12134116af5c4", "input": "claim: Homework should have a limit.\n perspective: Homework helps involve parents ", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-7a0fea0ca95b484a8262df751889fae0", "input": "claim: Homework should have a limit.\n perspective: Homework improves student achievement", "output": [ "undermine" ] }, { "id": "task738-5a40e4f21aeb4a3e984f1c177f5d60ff", "input": "claim: Homework should have a limit.\n perspective: Assigning homework to students improves their level of achievement", "output": [ "undermine" ] } ], "Instance License": [ "CC BY-SA" ] }